What's wrong with Simon lately? He's usually a good mentor but he's been fucking up quite a lot recently. Emily did so bad this time around. I can honestly see Emily and Sam in the bottom 2 after the Live Shows this week.
Completely agree. Wrong song choices for both Sam and Emily. Their voices are so unique, they really need good mentoring in order to find the right songs. Simon is usually good, but at the moment I don't know what he's doing.
Emily has a special and unique voice. This is what this show should be about, finding recording ARTIST and she is one of them (Just listening to this song on Spotify. It was really amazing). This may not be her stronger week, but props to her for still giving a haunting and beautiful performance despite being SICK.
indeed, I mean what the heck...judging from this performance it really should have been her who should have been dropped...oh well atleast she was in bottom-3
For once, I agree w Louis, which is REALLY rare, but Simon honestly played it safe w such songs for Emily, and Sam. But then again, X FACTOR SHOULD GET RID OF THE LAME THEMES
2:57 that tone was amazing.. so I was like: finally she will blow me away... and than this... she sings without any surprises, but her tone isn't as exciting to listen to after 30 seconds.. so this was bad..
Ya but I'm also not from UK, I think that's the problem Brits are voting only for their own not really base on talent you can see this bec. Honey G is still there, DUH!??? The rest of us just likes the real singer to win.
tbh, I was expecting that Emily will out of her comfort zone and upbeat tempo song and dance on the disco week. what a disappointing for me. I hope she's not getting eliminated because she can do it more than this 😞
I am not even a fan of Ryan but how on earth is this better than his performance this week?! He embraces the theme. He dances and sing all on point and he hit all his notes. LOL Let's be fair here.
Emily is much better than this. Fright Night week was her best performance by far - that is the sound that distinguishes Emily. This is not working for her.
and now for points 1st) matt terry-100 2nd) sam lavery-98 3rd) ryan lawrie-97 4th)saara Aalto-65 5th)5 after midnight-55 6th)honey G-35 7th)-emily middlemas-20
hello hello i judge before the performance u judge only after the performance so dont act cool and i m not judging about who is out who i like this and that is about whose performance i felt the best that week u just rate saara first bcoz she was your favourite but for me i m different evenmatt terry was my favourite but go and see every week i dont always give him the number 1 so dont act cool with me here ok i already said is not about who is going to the finals or whatsoever or who is eliminated is about the performance !!!!!!your rank is just about favourites but not about the performance !!!!!!! and u knew the 2 was in the bottom 2 already thats why u put them last 2 and u just put how the top 5 favourites are ok???i m judging the singing performance not about favourites
honestly, this has to be one of the worst performances on the x factor history. and I don't blame Simon. what voice is that? how is this girl on the top 10????
I don't know about the other performances but this is unacceptable for a finalist. Flat vocals, no stage presence whatsoever... I'm sure they had better singers/performers to be there...
Okay you are wondering why she is on the top ten?!? Are you kidding? Honey G is still in the competition. I'm scared for her though. Hopefully she makes it next week.
I don't recall saying honey g was good, did I? She's just a joke act, and people complaining about her is exactly what Simon wants. Wonder why she's still on the competition? Now, Emily was supposed to be taken seriously... which I just can't do anymore.
I'm really sorry but I have to say this, her performance this time is worse than Ryan and Honey G. I guess it's the song choice but I need to admit that her performance is getting really boring. From live show week 1, she just standing there or just sitting on the stage (that was her best performance so far) and she do the same thing AGAIN! I'm so sorry and I love you, Em...
after watching the whole show i will give the position 1st-matt terry 2nd-sam lavery 3rd-ryan lawrie 4th-saara Aalto 5th-5 after midnight 6th-honey g 7th-emily middlemas 1st)-matt terry-beautiful singing performance that was awesome sounded so beautiful good dancing performance as well u nailed it this week 2nd)-sam lavery-that is her most beautiful performance ever the vocals were so good when it sounded on the headphone i really love this strong vocals of performance tonight and very good song choice 3rd)-ryan lawrie-very beautiful music performance this week he is so on fire the choreography and the whole entire performance was absolutely beautiful 4th)-saara Aalto-i wasnt so mad with the singing bcoz i felt it was only average but i love the choreography and her dancing performance with star swagger 5th)-5 after midnight-to be honest for that performance i just feel that the choreography and the dancing was great for the singing i didnt like the beginning of the singing and after that the lyrics behind that were sang was only average 6th)-honey g-to be honest i felt like this week rapping performance was not going really well the rapping voice was actually like sinking and is too like a reapeated version of it when she rap her name but one thing i love about it is the choreography and how she dance bcoz the dancing was sensational and amazing she is a very good performer 7th)-emily middliemas-i just love the choreography this week didnt like the singing performance it was not very nice this week
Emily did well, considering she was ill this week. I wonder if she could've done big vocals with sore throat. I just wonder if people know these old songs enough to appreciate her performance as it should. Besides, there's a slow song in every disco night, so this was it!
I have to agree with everyone but Simon. I love Emily and think she has a chance of winning but because this song was mostly falsetto it did kind of swallow her voice in the production.
People find Emily boring but honest she has a great voice I see next mariah carey or Celine Dion.just because emily sings different type off music don't make her less talented people vote 4 her coz they see the talent in her ,I know most teenagers can't relate with such song don't blame them
elaizel fajardo it's about matt since from the start evrything has been setting up they eliminate all contestant that can possibly defeat matt and choose the rest which are just ok,they also change some mechanic of this show just to give way to matt remember the 6chair challenge well this is just my personal opinion,base on what i have seen
dheyo lobaton good guess, it's about Matt. 5am is my personal favourite but I don't think they will win over Matt, they're voices are not that strong. And saara is the real threat voice wise. I hope she will be in the final 3 atleast. They have to put a good competition to Matt atleast if they want him to really win.
Daniel Lee wow, you pulled the “there still better than u” card, girl, we are allowed to have opinions, just because we aren’t singers doesn’t mean we can’t judge. After all we are the consumers.
This song brings me back to Tamera Foster's performance. It was dope. This pales so much in comparison to that.....which is so disappointing. Where is the UMPH! 0 Conviction!
Oh this one was a bit lacklustre for the theme. I find it interesting how the initial front runners are having worse performances than usual. I do think that she was going to eventually going to mess up(especially since the theme is disco).
Again a pretty voice. To much makeup for just standing there and not moving around. Disco was the error of time when the songs made you really move and dance your ass off! Emily & Sam song choices from Simon were totally wrong for Disco night. Again the only one I seen doing the Disco theme excellent was Sarra! Amazing how Sarra sings, dances and moves around that entire stage and puts on a big show compared to these boring shows Simon's giving his girls. Again for me in my opinion this was bad song choice for Emily.
What happened to her voice it felt like she is trying too hard to hit falsetto after her last 2 performances I was actually rooting for her! the song choice was sooo bad!! I kept comparing it the version of all the x factor contestants in 2011 (little mix and etc) that was great this no no no. This is not her I blame Simon too!! :((
Don't judge her. Do you all not feel sympathy or try to understand her? She is in sick condition and she is just 18. This perf still look good for me bcoz of she cond and she age maturity. You just gay ass jerk. You must see Fatin Shidqia from indonesia. She has been judged as not deserve to be winner bcoz her technique isn't good as the runner up. But as far as now, she (and the 4th position) is the most selling contestant from XFi. so the the conclusion, i wanna tell you sometime the good one is not the most selling. Emily still young, so her chance to shine is si big, and what i try to tell is to persuade you to vote the commercial one. Not only the technician or the fun one. Maybe emily's live showis boring 4 you, but you must remember her audition era is so different and commercial one
She can't sing! ! !! help . I don't get it !? It's a singing competition ans she's got no power her voice is so fragile the track is louder than her even with a microphone! !
I've seen a few of her performances now, and she coughs a lot when she finishes singing. She may want to get checked out. Given the time between shows, I don't think its as simple as a sore or dry throat. But, i'm not a doctor, so...
What is she still doing here? Her voice is nice, yeah, but it's powerless, weak, lacks originality and bores me to death. Anyone can sing lullabies! She's predictable and sounds the same every week - Why. Is. She. Still. Here???
do u know the mean of disco, disco is doesn't mean upbeat but a rhtymic song i think she sing this song on rhtym people must be stupid to think disco is upbeat song.
She killed all the fun
wahahaha true
She should just sing a Smith's/Morrisey song & be down with it. >>>
She is no where good enough for this song either. It showed a lot of weakness in her voice.
What's wrong with Simon lately? He's usually a good mentor but he's been fucking up quite a lot recently. Emily did so bad this time around. I can honestly see Emily and Sam in the bottom 2 after the Live Shows this week.
Completely agree. Wrong song choices for both Sam and Emily. Their voices are so unique, they really need good mentoring in order to find the right songs. Simon is usually good, but at the moment I don't know what he's doing.
Saara Alto won this round hands down #NoContest
Yes!!!
Lizzie M She is soo good :) Btw neat profile pic :O
Danny Steeler Thanks
Lizzie M ur welcome *hug*
Emily has a special and unique voice. This is what this show should be about, finding recording ARTIST and she is one of them (Just listening to this song on Spotify. It was really amazing). This may not be her stronger week, but props to her for still giving a haunting and beautiful performance despite being SICK.
after gifty left it feels like Simon just doesn't care anymore
this song is so soothing!!!
Oh my this can cause Emily her spot on the competition. hey Simon!!! What did you do to the two girls? Tsk tsk
Actually, I think he already lost his strongest one...
Elia Ilano u guys are sickkkkk
Maybe because she is not versatile. Disco is not her thing.
it's just not their theme of music....
yes, he lost gifty :(
Don't mean to be rude but this performance is quite dreadful.
indeed, I mean what the heck...judging from this performance it really should have been her who should have been dropped...oh well atleast she was in bottom-3
Pollux Chung no it wasn't well she was really out of tune only coz she was sick so shut up
+Naomi Bick thank you for defending her.. :)
VOTE FOR EMILY‼️
For once, I agree w Louis, which is REALLY rare, but Simon honestly played it safe w such songs for Emily, and Sam. But then again, X FACTOR SHOULD GET RID OF THE LAME THEMES
Her and her friend's accent is real omg haha
You must be getting tired of us saying it, but THANKS, Anthony! 👍👍
She just sing. Saara is much better, so Please Vote Saara.
2:57 that tone was amazing.. so I was like: finally she will blow me away... and than this... she sings without any surprises, but her tone isn't as exciting to listen to after 30 seconds.. so this was bad..
Saara is like million times better, then Sam and Emily combined. But emily is little bit more likeable.
anthony ying what would we do without you thanks a million for the uploads
Oh. Emily was so good last week. I'm worry she will leave the show after tonight
Yeah, I don't like this one either! I am still rooting for Saara!
Nichole Pantley Me too, Saara was the best!!!!
Saraaa it is!!!!! YES!
#TeamSaaraAlto...Please vote you guys..I dont qualify to vote because i am all the way in Jamaia!I love the Fairy Princess from Finland!
Ya but I'm also not from UK, I think that's the problem Brits are voting only for their own not really base on talent you can see this bec. Honey G is still there, DUH!??? The rest of us just likes the real singer to win.
true......Saara fan base building!
tbh, I was expecting that Emily will out of her comfort zone and upbeat tempo song and dance on the disco week. what a disappointing for me. I hope she's not getting eliminated because she can do it more than this 😞
Simon truly screwed up.
+Stephen Green Yes indeed. Both girls had bad non-disco song choices.
What's wrong with Simon... like wtf, fisrt Sam and now this...
gifty didn't deserve that
Angel V they are all awesome
You're The Best Anthony TYSM ! *[2-Thumbs-Up]*
What a voice, truly magnificent !!
Emily is my favourite💗
If europe can vote, then Saara totally win
I think Europe has had more than enough say in Britain’s affairs in recent years.
Just like with Sam, she can have a weak week and still be better than Ryan and Honey G.
I am not even a fan of Ryan but how on earth is this better than his performance this week?! He embraces the theme. He dances and sing all on point and he hit all his notes. LOL Let's be fair here.
mae_ash I'm not saying off these performances. I mean that she can have a bad week and still overall be better than Ryan and more deserving to stay.
Simon always says bad things to the contestans, but when the other judges say something bad about their contestans he gets mad, lol
Emily is much better than this. Fright Night week was her best performance by far - that is the sound that distinguishes Emily. This is not working for her.
and now for points
1st) matt terry-100
2nd) sam lavery-98
3rd) ryan lawrie-97
4th)saara Aalto-65
5th)5 after midnight-55
6th)honey G-35
7th)-emily middlemas-20
my rank
1. Saara
2. Emily
3. 5AM
4. Matt
5. Honey G
6. Ryan
7. Sam, she is already eliminated
hello hello i judge before the performance u judge only after the performance so dont act cool and i m not judging about who is out who i like this and that is about whose performance i felt the best that week u just rate saara first bcoz she was your favourite but for me i m different evenmatt terry was my favourite but go and see every week i dont always give him the number 1 so dont act cool with me here ok i already said is not about who is going to the finals or whatsoever or who is eliminated is about the performance !!!!!!your rank is just about favourites but not about the performance !!!!!!! and u knew the 2 was in the bottom 2 already thats why u put them last 2 and u just put how the top 5 favourites are ok???i m judging the singing performance not about favourites
This was weak... Kind of scared for her
I hope she 's not eliminated because she's still not the worst. Ryan is much worse. At least she does have that star quality
LOL remember the theme "disco"? Good times..... what is this?
It is very flat, not versatile. Lacks strength of his personality and voice.
Thaks Anthony ;)
honestly, this has to be one of the worst performances on the x factor history. and I don't blame Simon. what voice is that? how is this girl on the top 10????
I don't know about the other performances but this is unacceptable for a finalist. Flat vocals, no stage presence whatsoever... I'm sure they had better singers/performers to be there...
she did well for the first parts of the shows but i gotta agree its just getting more & more boring
Yeah, but blaming Simon doesn't take away the fact that her vocals in here were awful... her stage presence worse. Not a top 10 worthy performance.
Okay you are wondering why she is on the top ten?!? Are you kidding? Honey G is still in the competition.
I'm scared for her though. Hopefully she makes it next week.
I don't recall saying honey g was good, did I? She's just a joke act, and people complaining about her is exactly what Simon wants. Wonder why she's still on the competition? Now, Emily was supposed to be taken seriously... which I just can't do anymore.
I'm really sorry but I have to say this, her performance this time is worse than Ryan and Honey G. I guess it's the song choice but I need to admit that her performance is getting really boring. From live show week 1, she just standing there or just sitting on the stage (that was her best performance so far) and she do the same thing AGAIN! I'm so sorry and I love you, Em...
sounds like a backup singer tbh... nothing out of this world
I really hope Saara win!
But people, don't dislike the video! It's not Anthony's fault...he's just helping us by putting these videos here...dislike the X Factor's videos!
She bored me to death! I just can't watch her whole audition!
imagine Ryan and Emily having to do a sing off
Queen Riley I imagine it and it could possibly happen in week 7 ( this week )
Saara Alto the best on this show!Let the best come to the top
That was not Disco! And she didn't move on the rhythm of the song....
She was one of my favourites at bootcamp but WTF is she doing?
after watching the whole show i will give the position 1st-matt terry 2nd-sam lavery 3rd-ryan lawrie 4th-saara Aalto 5th-5 after midnight 6th-honey g 7th-emily middlemas
1st)-matt terry-beautiful singing performance that was awesome sounded so beautiful good dancing performance as well u nailed it this week
2nd)-sam lavery-that is her most beautiful performance ever the vocals were so good when it sounded on the headphone i really love this strong vocals of performance tonight and very good song choice
3rd)-ryan lawrie-very beautiful music performance this week he is so on fire the choreography and the whole entire performance was absolutely beautiful
4th)-saara Aalto-i wasnt so mad with the singing bcoz i felt it was only average but i love the choreography and her dancing performance with star swagger
5th)-5 after midnight-to be honest for that performance i just feel that the choreography and the dancing was great for the singing i didnt like the beginning of the singing and after that the lyrics behind that were sang was only average
6th)-honey g-to be honest i felt like this week rapping performance was not going really well the rapping voice was actually like sinking and is too like a reapeated version of it when she rap her name but one thing i love about it is the choreography and how she dance bcoz the dancing was sensational and amazing she is a very good performer
7th)-emily middliemas-i just love the choreography this week didnt like the singing performance it was not very nice this week
She's so much better than this. Hope
She comes with a better song next week
Really like her but this is her worst performance. Won't be surprised if she's not in bottom 2.
Ofcourse it's another slow song for Emily.. What's new
Thank God she has a big fan club because this was a bit boring. I'm 100% confident though she's gonna bring it again next week.
flaaaaaaaaaat
Emily did well, considering she was ill this week. I wonder if she could've done big vocals with sore throat. I just wonder if people know these old songs enough to appreciate her performance as it should. Besides, there's a slow song in every disco night, so this was it!
I have to agree with everyone but Simon. I love Emily and think she has a chance of winning but because this song was mostly falsetto it did kind of swallow her voice in the production.
I want to see her on the bottom with Lawrie.
Simon so ANGRY With Emily
She needs to be in the bottom, I'm not enjoying her performances at all. Acts like Saara deserve the stage so much more
People find Emily boring but honest she has a great voice I see next mariah carey or Celine Dion.just because emily sings different type off music don't make her less talented people vote 4 her coz they see the talent in her ,I know most teenagers can't relate with such song don't blame them
Faith Shizoh i dont think she has the vocal range for celine dion or mariah carey songs.
I'm really wondering how come Simon had chosen Emily and Sam. they are too plain and simple.
elaizel fajardo it's about matt since from the start evrything has been setting up they eliminate all contestant that can possibly defeat matt and choose the rest which are just ok,they also change some mechanic of this show just to give way to matt remember the 6chair challenge well this is just my personal opinion,base on what i have seen
elaizel fajardo they better watchout for 5'AM that group is the biggest treat
dheyo lobaton good guess, it's about Matt. 5am is my personal favourite but I don't think they will win over Matt, they're voices are not that strong. And saara is the real threat voice wise. I hope she will be in the final 3 atleast. They have to put a good competition to Matt atleast if they want him to really win.
she didnt do well
I like Emily very much, but this performance was the worst of the night by far :/
this season is disaster ...we are wasting our time watchin this average singers
***** I'm not a singer , I'm nusic producer
Daniel Lee buuuuuuuurn! 😀✌🔥
Daniel Lee wow, you pulled the “there still better than u” card, girl, we are allowed to have opinions, just because we aren’t singers doesn’t mean we can’t judge. After all we are the consumers.
Emily is one of the better singers.
It felt flat, and it fell short of disco..
This song brings me back to Tamera Foster's performance. It was dope. This pales so much in comparison to that.....which is so disappointing.
Where is the UMPH! 0 Conviction!
Oh this one was a bit lacklustre for the theme. I find it interesting how the initial front runners are having worse performances than usual. I do think that she was going to eventually going to mess up(especially since the theme is disco).
She shd try fast number on disco week
Again a pretty voice. To much makeup for just standing there and not moving around. Disco was the error of time when the songs made you really move and dance your ass off! Emily & Sam song choices from Simon were totally wrong for Disco night. Again the only one I seen doing the Disco theme excellent was Sarra! Amazing how Sarra sings, dances and moves around that entire stage and puts on a big show compared to these boring shows Simon's giving his girls. Again for me in my opinion this was bad song choice for Emily.
Emily should have been sent home.. Sam was better
She is wearing same outfit than Saara did before. It was better on Saara and this song would have been better on Saara too.
What happened to her voice it felt like she is trying too hard to hit falsetto after her last 2 performances I was actually rooting for her! the song choice was sooo bad!! I kept comparing it the version of all the x factor contestants in 2011 (little mix and etc) that was great this no no no. This is not her I blame Simon too!! :((
and i thought sam was bad this week
mm dont like her voice nah
Top 3 songs of the week Emily and Sam are always my favourites and why the heck did Sam leave at least there's still Emily Sara and 5 after midnight
Too slow
Struggling to understand why he sings only slow songs week in week out. Wasn't it supposed to be DiscoWeek this time???
What a boring song! Its disco Emily!!!!!!
It's Simon.. not her
It's not a boring song. It's just she didn't move.
Always the same, it's starting to get bored
They are right. She coughing on the smoke lol.
however these girls are 17 years old not 40 geesh
Poor for her. This is not pure disco. She should worry this week.
She probably be at the Bottom 3. Unless she gets the votes
Dont put Saara first if you dont want others acts look like shit :D
Don't judge her. Do you all not feel sympathy or try to understand her? She is in sick condition and she is just 18. This perf still look good for me bcoz of she cond and she age maturity. You just gay ass jerk. You must see Fatin Shidqia from indonesia. She has been judged as not deserve to be winner bcoz her technique isn't good as the runner up. But as far as now, she (and the 4th position) is the most selling contestant from XFi. so the the conclusion, i wanna tell you sometime the good one is not the most selling. Emily still young, so her chance to shine is si big, and what i try to tell is to persuade you to vote the commercial one. Not only the technician or the fun one. Maybe emily's live showis boring 4 you, but you must remember her audition era is so different and commercial one
I though she was sick....where is her voice?.
She is still my winner and I going to delete this performance from my mind.
it was boring!
nice!
This performance kinda killed the disco mood...
She can't sing! ! !! help . I don't get it !? It's a singing competition ans she's got no power her voice is so fragile the track is louder than her even with a microphone! !
i love emily, really, but what the hell was that? she's so better than that...
boring boring boring so boring as always just go home!
I've seen a few of her performances now, and she coughs a lot when she finishes singing. She may want to get checked out. Given the time between shows, I don't think its as simple as a sore or dry throat. But, i'm not a doctor, so...
The music overpowered her voice. I could barely hear her!
i just love the choreography this week didnt like the singing performance it was not very nice this week
What is she still doing here? Her voice is nice, yeah, but it's powerless, weak, lacks originality and bores me to death. Anyone can sing lullabies! She's predictable and sounds the same every week - Why. Is. She. Still. Here???
This was bad
She is so Good but i blame it to simon
Disco?? Wouldn't overtly disagree with Simon though...
Good voice but the judges are right, she needs to move!
Honey G is king of the scene comparing to this. Simon is senile a bit,,,it was disco week Simon!!!! DISCO!!!!!
She spent the whole song on a really shy falsetto...it was so boring :(
This is was a clear deramp by the producers she was becoming too much of a threat
do u know the mean of disco, disco is doesn't mean upbeat but a rhtymic song i think she sing this song on rhtym people must be stupid to think disco is upbeat song.
No feeling at all. lord what louisa would have done with this song!!!! Honey G will win this.
Pauline Zammit Honey G.. will never win this...