I've been a big Midweek Rub fan all year. As much as I enjoy Duck's banter and energy, the new dynamic with host (ex-player and one of the better minds in footy), ex-player, ex-coach, and journalist is better and I'm enjoying it.
Its a thousand times better. I always though Duck was the weak link, and his banter too often missed the mark for me. I also think he secretly hates Damian Barrett, his interactions with him are always super weird, and filled with disrespect. I'd love if Lyon was on this long term, its great.
Yep exactly. Those who tip Sydney have forgotten that Jordan DeGoey was a late out, and Jack Ginnivan was subbed out early, and several players were reported to be ill during the week, but those who tip Collingwood seem to remember that.
Atkins could go back, Parfitt into the midfield, O'Connor on Neale, Bews on McCarthy. Cats to win, and the Pies Sydney game will be a cracker. I think the Swans will win, but I won't be surprised if the Pies get up.
Suggesting the Dees weren’t great last year and we’re maybe lucky to win the grand final is laughable. They won by 74 points and had an extremely dominant finals series with an average winning margin of 10 goals!
The Pies have been great but they just hold absolutely no fear for the Swans. In fact, the Pies play a game that is really quite similar to the Swans but they are just not as good at it: 1) defensively the Swans are better at pressuring, tackling and much stronger at protecting scoring chains from the Opp i50 2) the Swans are a better scoring side by a lot, particularly with our weapons i50 3) the Swans have many more skilled players across the board and probably more A-graders (De Gooey; Pendles; both Daicos'; Moore; maybe Crisp vs Heeney, Papley, Mills; Buddy; Warner; Buddy on his day; McCartin) 4) the Swans are just as young and dynamic and have a stronger crop of U24s (Florent, Gulden, Stephenson, Rowbottom, Warner, Blakey, MacDonald
@@dilanabey In could make a case as well.. and your case accurately reflects the home and away season.. but if you think the Swans handles Melb or will handle Geel better than Coll you are dreaming.. this is 50:50 with the Swans having a home advantage.. I pray the Swans players feel the same as you
Typical of Damian Barrett to refer to the Fremantle's win at Geelong in the 2013 Qualifying Final as the "famous Shane McGuinness game". He is such a flog. Never mind it was the first final ever played in Geelong; or that Michael Barlow was BOG with 32 disposals and 3 goals, or that Stephen Hill snuck off the interchange to gather the ball unopposed, take 5 bounces, run 90 metres and kick the winning goal. The most important take away from that afternoon was Ross Lyon getting pissed off at some two-bit journo trying to goad him in the press conference and create a headline about the skirmishes behind play. The media always put themselves and their meaningless little stories ahead of the actual game itself. Damo is one of the worst offenders. The guy thinks he is a rock star. Pathetic.
Did they seriously say that Buddy Franklin kicked 3 goals against Melbourne in the qualifying final? He was 0.0 on the scoreboard. Understand he sucked May in and created a goal or two for his teammates, but god the media suck up to the ‘star’ players. Franklin on the whole looked horrible against May
One of the show's producers would've fed them a note that "Buddy kicked 3 last time against them" (meaning against Collingwood in Round 22.) Daisy being the genius that he is, misread it and said that he kicked 3 against Melbourne.
@@alexanderwarby-cooper3549 That's right. That's only one of five goalless games in Buddy's career. I wouldn't bet on him having another one. But even if he did, the Swans are so even around the ground that someone else will pick up the slack. Go you Bloods!
@@alexanderwarby-cooper3549 Scored my ticket on Monday. Got butterflies every time I think about it. Whatever happens, I'm so proud of the boys. They're way ahead of where they should be and next year we'll have Sheldrick, Gould, Amartey and McLean (amongst others) putting competitive pressure on the team which only helps get us better. Exciting times.
Lyon coached his team into the Grand Final in 2009, 2010 and 2013 for 3 narrow losses against much better opponents than Melbourne. He will go down in history as the one of the unluckiest coaches ever (and possibly the greatest coach never to win a flag.) It will be interesting to see if Goodwin can get his team back into another Grand Final. None of my Dees mates ever rated him prior to 2020 and he seemed to coach poorly again this year, especially given the cattle he has at his disposal. Maybe he just got a bit lucky with his timing last year. Did his best work in the year that Geelong players got gastro before Prelim, and Tigers & Pies both had off years. The competition seems a lot tougher this year and Melbourne's opponents seem to have worked them out. Has Goody (or Choco Williams) got any more tricks up their sleeves?
Eagles got 100000 members, Poachers beware, You will pay the price, Eagles have brought back plenty of ordinary homesick kids in the past, Makes a man cranky when the Media say we ain't family club 😆
Stop bashing losing teams, such a shit culture saying things like it’s a waste of a year. Melbourne just won the premiership last year, celebrate that instead and say better luck next year. At the end of the day not every team can win someone has to lose so talk about why teams win and celebrate that instead. These teams put their heart body and soul into the sport and just because they come up short because another team performed better doesn’t mean they deserve a bashing! Change the narrative improve the culture!
Willie Rioli (Junior), with him leaving after WC supported him after breaking the law multiple times, and paying and playing him, and then him leaving is of poor taste. It shows this show lacks gumption. If he was a white fella....
Don't talk shlt. It's got nothing to do with his skin colour. Rioli's father died and he's going to Adelaide so he can support his mother better. Rioli has been away from his entire family through a traumatic time for them all and he has tried to find solutions to the problem but it hasn't worked. This has happened DOZENS of times over the years but nobody else gets this bullshit. The Eagles had a choice to make and they made it. Support him or don't support him. But you don't support someone and then hold it over their head when circumstances like this occur. Racist w@anker.
Jesus, his dad has recently died and he wants to go home to family. It's a job not a knighthood. And your pathetic racist snipe shows you wouldn't want him there anyway. Hope he keeps the West Coke Eagles at the bottom of the ladder next year, just so you can cry some more salty tears.
I've been a big Midweek Rub fan all year. As much as I enjoy Duck's banter and energy, the new dynamic with host (ex-player and one of the better minds in footy), ex-player, ex-coach, and journalist is better and I'm enjoying it.
Its a thousand times better.
I always though Duck was the weak link, and his banter too often missed the mark for me. I also think he secretly hates Damian Barrett, his interactions with him are always super weird, and filled with disrespect.
I'd love if Lyon was on this long term, its great.
Not to kick a man while he's down, but unfortunately for Carey, Ross offers a much more in-depth answers to the serious questions.
In saying that, Carey brings great banter and energises the room.
@@AG-lu3ew If you like football analysis, Ross is the pick. If you like banter and domestic violence, go with Carey.
Carey kicks women when they're down so...
@@felixcd3799 Didn't ask! If its such a big issue to you then why did it take you 10 years to bring up. Fkn peanut
@@user-fg5lq2dg4h Love Ross the Boss' insight into matches.
Great show. Easily my favourite footy podcast. Please keep Ross the boss.
Everyone forgets 7 players were sick , no de goey and ginnivan subbed off first quarter. Pies have gone another level last couple weeks also .
Yep exactly. Those who tip Sydney have forgotten that Jordan DeGoey was a late out, and Jack Ginnivan was subbed out early, and several players were reported to be ill during the week, but those who tip Collingwood seem to remember that.
Colliwobbles
Atkins could go back, Parfitt into the midfield, O'Connor on Neale, Bews on McCarthy.
Cats to win, and the Pies Sydney game will be a cracker. I think the Swans will win, but I won't be surprised if the Pies get up.
Its fun to watch Ross talk over all of his co hosts
Unironically is
Good call
Suggesting the Dees weren’t great last year and we’re maybe lucky to win the grand final is laughable. They won by 74 points and had an extremely dominant finals series with an average winning margin of 10 goals!
There’s still a Daisy Duck dive
The Pies have been great but they just hold absolutely no fear for the Swans. In fact, the Pies play a game that is really quite similar to the Swans but they are just not as good at it:
1) defensively the Swans are better at pressuring, tackling and much stronger at protecting scoring chains from the Opp i50
2) the Swans are a better scoring side by a lot, particularly with our weapons i50
3) the Swans have many more skilled players across the board and probably more A-graders (De Gooey; Pendles; both Daicos'; Moore; maybe Crisp vs Heeney, Papley, Mills; Buddy; Warner; Buddy on his day; McCartin)
4) the Swans are just as young and dynamic and have a stronger crop of U24s (Florent, Gulden, Stephenson, Rowbottom, Warner, Blakey, MacDonald
Agree with everything you said except I don’t think Mccartin is an A grader
You said “our” .. objectivity gone
@@user-dj2xn Yeah I can see that too - I think he *will* become one next year as the intercepting marker
@@Zed137 Yeah true *but* I still haven't seen any convincing data/arguments that oppose those pieces of evidence
@@dilanabey In could make a case as well.. and your case accurately reflects the home and away season.. but if you think the Swans handles Melb or will handle Geel better than Coll you are dreaming.. this is 50:50 with the Swans having a home advantage.. I pray the Swans players feel the same as you
Typical of Damian Barrett to refer to the Fremantle's win at Geelong in the 2013 Qualifying Final as the "famous Shane McGuinness game". He is such a flog. Never mind it was the first final ever played in Geelong; or that Michael Barlow was BOG with 32 disposals and 3 goals, or that Stephen Hill snuck off the interchange to gather the ball unopposed, take 5 bounces, run 90 metres and kick the winning goal. The most important take away from that afternoon was Ross Lyon getting pissed off at some two-bit journo trying to goad him in the press conference and create a headline about the skirmishes behind play. The media always put themselves and their meaningless little stories ahead of the actual game itself. Damo is one of the worst offenders. The guy thinks he is a rock star. Pathetic.
Maybe if we don't mention his name no one will notice that Carey has been sacked🤔
good 0ne 😁👍
They mentioned it last week
when did learnings replace lessons. i didn't get the memo.
Ross for Carey is a dub
Lyon understands how badly coached the Dee’s where this year in the second half of the year! Goodwin out!!
Never underestimate these lions
they'll get up
Did they seriously say that Buddy Franklin kicked 3 goals against Melbourne in the qualifying final? He was 0.0 on the scoreboard. Understand he sucked May in and created a goal or two for his teammates, but god the media suck up to the ‘star’ players. Franklin on the whole looked horrible against May
One of the show's producers would've fed them a note that "Buddy kicked 3 last time against them" (meaning against Collingwood in Round 22.) Daisy being the genius that he is, misread it and said that he kicked 3 against Melbourne.
Franklin was goaless against the Dees fellas
Listening to them you’d think he tore the game apart lmao
And the Swans Still Won 🏆 😎
@@alexanderwarby-cooper3549 That's right. That's only one of five goalless games in Buddy's career. I wouldn't bet on him having another one. But even if he did, the Swans are so even around the ground that someone else will pick up the slack.
Go you Bloods!
@@jaredburgess8381 Let's Go Swans 😍🔴⚪
@@alexanderwarby-cooper3549 Scored my ticket on Monday. Got butterflies every time I think about it.
Whatever happens, I'm so proud of the boys. They're way ahead of where they should be and next year we'll have Sheldrick, Gould, Amartey and McLean (amongst others) putting competitive pressure on the team which only helps get us better. Exciting times.
Goodwin out!! Ross Lyon in!!!
Tigers next year WOW
Can we get the audio and visual fixed up please? Looks like a Kung fu movie lol 😆
Yes Collingwoods midfield was good last game but De Goey didn't play that game
Buddy will go mad in the game. Watch out Pies.
Fuck buddy lol
An AFLW podcast won "Best podcast"? I wonder what the requirements for winning are
It ticks a box!
@@cjames21 that's an amazing way to phrase it
Be a woman
Swans will overcompensate to set up to move it to the outside and there was no JDG last game around
Bring back Duck….or is he still trying to get that swelling under control?
So much better without the Duck.
sacked for casino white powder incident
:( will mis duck not the same
May kept Buddy goalless and was clear BOG. Yet these guys get paid to say Buddy kicked 3 lol
The criticism of Melbourne was absolutely embarrassing to watch
Educate us about attempting a back to back, Ross... 😂😂
Facts are, Dee's botched this year. They have the talent to back it up with a flag tilt next year, but this year was a fail
Lyon coached his team into the Grand Final in 2009, 2010 and 2013 for 3 narrow losses against much better opponents than Melbourne. He will go down in history as the one of the unluckiest coaches ever (and possibly the greatest coach never to win a flag.) It will be interesting to see if Goodwin can get his team back into another Grand Final. None of my Dees mates ever rated him prior to 2020 and he seemed to coach poorly again this year, especially given the cattle he has at his disposal. Maybe he just got a bit lucky with his timing last year. Did his best work in the year that Geelong players got gastro before Prelim, and Tigers & Pies both had off years. The competition seems a lot tougher this year and Melbourne's opponents seem to have worked them out. Has Goody (or Choco Williams) got any more tricks up their sleeves?
Eagles got 100000 members, Poachers beware, You will pay the price, Eagles have brought back plenty of ordinary homesick kids in the past, Makes a man cranky when the Media say we ain't family club 😆
If Joe daniher gets going on the G lookout!
I back GEELONG, however if Joe kicks 5 they win
The last time Daniher kicked five was 2017. The Cats should be fine.
Where is duck?
whaaa haaa haa, good call 😁👍
He's OUT, he is too much of a cokehead
Its not the same without Carey
Yeah its better.
@@David-lq8cx worse
Agreed it seemed better this ep, less personality and more footy analysis
Stop bashing losing teams, such a shit culture saying things like it’s a waste of a year. Melbourne just won the premiership last year, celebrate that instead and say better luck next year. At the end of the day not every team can win someone has to lose so talk about why teams win and celebrate that instead. These teams put their heart body and soul into the sport and just because they come up short because another team performed better doesn’t mean they deserve a bashing! Change the narrative improve the culture!
Willie Rioli (Junior), with him leaving after WC supported him after breaking the law multiple times, and paying and playing him, and then him leaving is of poor taste. It shows this show lacks gumption. If he was a white fella....
Racism unnecessary
@@samanthagollan8592 it works both ways sweety
Don't talk shlt. It's got nothing to do with his skin colour. Rioli's father died and he's going to Adelaide so he can support his mother better. Rioli has been away from his entire family through a traumatic time for them all and he has tried to find solutions to the problem but it hasn't worked. This has happened DOZENS of times over the years but nobody else gets this bullshit. The Eagles had a choice to make and they made it. Support him or don't support him. But you don't support someone and then hold it over their head when circumstances like this occur.
Racist w@anker.
@@my2cents198 nah it doesn't dh
Jesus, his dad has recently died and he wants to go home to family. It's a job not a knighthood. And your pathetic racist snipe shows you wouldn't want him there anyway. Hope he keeps the West Coke Eagles at the bottom of the ladder next year, just so you can cry some more salty tears.