(G)I-DLE - Allergy | Line Distribution

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 дек 2024
  • What do you think about the video?
    The bars are inspired from honey!
    Please don't copy my videos, thumbnails or layouts!
    If you like my content, feel free to subscribe it would help allot~
    If you want to comment anything make sure it is in english otherwise i won't understand it /:
    I do NOT own anything! All rights are reserved
    FAQ:
    Q : What editing platforms do you use for editing your videos?
    A : I use Adobe Photoshop, Adobe After Effects & Vegas Pro
    Q : From where did you learn how to make line distribution videos:
    A : I learned form @C H O G I W A & @GL-KPOP they have great tutorials!
    Q : Are you a boy or a girl?
    A : I am a boy and my pronounces are he/him
    Q : What is your favorite kpop group?
    A : My favourite is BLACKPINK
    Q : Who is your ultimate bias of all time?
    A : My ultimate bias is rosie~
    Q : From where are you?
    A : I am from israel
    Tags:
    #linedistribution
    #여자아이들 #GIDLE #I_feel

Комментарии •

  • @KVNP_
    @KVNP_ Год назад +852

    I thought Miyeon would get the most lines with this cute concept, because I knew Miyeon would really suit the cute and girly concept.But apparently Miyeon got the last line

    • @bnuy772
      @bnuy772 Год назад +96

      She shines so much on the choruses💕💕

    • @Fabi_lumina
      @Fabi_lumina Год назад +95

      She had two choruses so it's fair

    • @KVNP_
      @KVNP_ Год назад +6

      @@bnuy772 FRR

    • @KVNP_
      @KVNP_ Год назад +63

      @@Fabi_lumina I didn't said it's not fair,but isn't it from the era before allergy miyeon never got the most lines?, and as a main vocal is that fair?i think is not

    • @aquatic_shadow2123
      @aquatic_shadow2123 Год назад +42

      ​@@Fabi_lumina in other words a line she just repeated 2 times lol

  • @jamesheng1878
    @jamesheng1878 Год назад +434

    Miyeon has her hosting gig, she is on a variety show as a fixed member, she got a solo. You people can’t see the bigger picture. It’s clearly a rock oriented song, so Yuqi will get prominent roles. We haven’t even heard the main song, let alone the rest of the album. Chill

    • @turnupthekpop
      @turnupthekpop Год назад +16

      But yet it seems that Cube doesn't want to promote her as a Main Vocalist. She doesn't even get to be on Lee Mujin's show. She doesn't have a cover on their channel

    • @turnupthekpop
      @turnupthekpop Год назад +2

      Good thing she has a solo.

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +21

      @@turnupthekpop cube or soyeon? lol. she said she prefer minnie's voice than miyeon's voice a lot of times... she divided the parts and... you know.

    • @jim_kc_8301
      @jim_kc_8301 Год назад +8

      @@amorfatee they pick their own parts then decide if it fits their voice.

    • @ivanparbo1673
      @ivanparbo1673 Год назад +7

      it's giving kitsch vibe:
      *main vocalists getting the least lines and not enough screen time
      *pre-release track
      *

  • @no_one.43
    @no_one.43 Год назад +289

    Miyeon has been last in all title tracks since 'TOMBOY'. Allergy is a song which suited her but also she got only one line which she had to repeat 2 times.

    • @cesarwalker6654
      @cesarwalker6654 Год назад +27

      You mean, since Uh-oh, DD was just an exception

    • @tbeee3375
      @tbeee3375 Год назад +57

      this isn’t a title track, she also sang the catchiest part of the song which suited her voice great? least lines doesn’t mean she didn’t get many lines which she did btw.

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +13

      Wow those 2 times were poor for her and totally discredit her as a main vocalist. Soyeon and producers give her incoherent lines like “Lalalala” to compensate 14 seconds that made her a sub-vocalist.

    • @Whos_4n4
      @Whos_4n4 Год назад +16

      Y’all know that in idle the members are the ones that decide their lines right? STOP COMPLAINING ABOUT LINE DISTRIBUTION WHEN IT COMES TO (G)I-IDLE PLEASE! if she has this amount of lines is because SHE wants that amount of lines!!!

    • @anuabraham5823
      @anuabraham5823 Год назад +7

      She shined throughout the m/v though. Plus her part is the best part of the entire song.

  • @Cryforme-
    @Cryforme- Год назад +458

    They could have gave Miyeon atleast one more vocal part or ablibs during Lalala part 😭

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +83

      if they gave miyeon parts miyeon would be shine more than them fr so... soyeon chose minnie as her main vocalist like she said this a few times. miyeon is treated like a sub vocal and we are getting used to it sadly. and no one gives a shit about it. when shuhua sang less everyone spoke up about it but when it is main vocalist miyeon, they say "she doesn't suit the concept" ahahaha

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +24

      Oh yeah producers have nothing to do. They just sit there and count how many seconds every member sing 😂 sorry guys, but this is a job meant for petty stans like u

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +1

      ​​@@gimlisonofgloin4083 this is not one song you dmbass it happens everytime. People just say what happens and it doesn't mean they are solo stan. You can't get away with saying this shit Got it?

    • @sopeintheaugustworld7457
      @sopeintheaugustworld7457 Год назад +39

      @@amorfatee ​ Miyeon always gets the catchiest line to sing. Be honest which line or tune comes to your mind when u want to try singing allergy. For me the chorus which is Miyeon’s part. I think u haven’t watched knowing bro’s where clearly she states what part is given to each member & why. This shows that members agree upon her decision. Miyeon being the eldest she can always question but yet she trusts Soyeon becoz for a reason she is a leader & let’s not come to an conclusion since this is just a pre-release or bside, the main cb is yet to be released.

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +8

      ​@@sopeintheaugustworld7457 tomboy and nxde were title songs too. im waiting for the title song but if it is the same with others fr then that's fucked up

  • @Eric-ck7gs
    @Eric-ck7gs Год назад +37

    This is the 3rd time Miyeon is last omg 😭😭

    • @elevatorkid4814
      @elevatorkid4814 4 месяца назад

      miyeon is 2nd to last not last minnie is last in this song 2:14 to 2:36 is just shuhua not both shuhua and minnie

  • @geeseshat9770
    @geeseshat9770 Год назад +162

    this is the only one i’ve seen so far that count the lalala as minnie and shuhua harmonizing, and i agree, great video!

  • @sahi304
    @sahi304 Год назад +216

    A perfect concept for miyeon. And yet... I don't think concept is the issue anymore

    • @rarisapwarii916
      @rarisapwarii916 Год назад +3

      @@KIMATOKOREA My @S$

    • @muhammadhafizfadillah5695
      @muhammadhafizfadillah5695 Год назад +1

      ​@@KIMATOKOREA in your dream

    • @sqdg3
      @sqdg3 Год назад

      ​@@KIMATOKOREA W

    • @sqdg3
      @sqdg3 Год назад

      ​@@rarisapwarii916 yea ur dead as$ brain??

    • @doclinny
      @doclinny Год назад +1

      @@rarisapwarii916 you obviously dont stan the group lol

  • @Ellp0x1
    @Ellp0x1 Год назад +37

    I understand people find it unfair, but each song has its own main character, this was Soyeons song and Yuqi and Shuhua played a big roll in it. I'm sure Miyeon will get more lines in the other songs 💗

  • @니이모를찾아서-u4h
    @니이모를찾아서-u4h Год назад +20

    Miyeon always has the least part, even though she's the main vocalist

  • @jayseu0044
    @jayseu0044 Год назад +21

    Miyeon's chorus was the best! Really love how she starts it❤

  • @firedragonbri547
    @firedragonbri547 Год назад +5

    Y’all are upset that Miyeon is last when half of Shuhua and Minnie’s lines are literally just them repeating “lalalalalala” over and over. At least Miyeon got actual lines, even if she’s last XD

    • @krewbiess
      @krewbiess Месяц назад

      well at least Shuhua and Minnie ACTUALLY GOT LINES. like they couldn't have gave miyeon a repeating prechorus over the lalalalas or like a high note?

  • @pablo3679
    @pablo3679 Год назад +15

    poor miyeon, again is last

  • @SunFlower-hw2wy
    @SunFlower-hw2wy Год назад +16

    Miyeon...

  • @marcx..lirissss3198
    @marcx..lirissss3198 Год назад +47

    Why Miyeon being main vocalist always gets the least lines?

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +1

      Least lines she got in the last 2 title tracks, but gidle has more than that.

  • @kuanyshrakhmetov8934
    @kuanyshrakhmetov8934 Год назад +161

    It is always funny for me how those who always complain about the line distribution are not Neverland. Real (G)I-DLE fans and the girls themselves understand which part suits them more. Soyeon is professional and she knows how to highlight girls vocals. Miyeon is my bias and she sounds incredible in the chorus, which is the main part of the song. Her voice and the lyrics in that part is the most important in that song. If you don't know (G)I-DLE, please don't write anything about fairness. We are here for music and art, not to count who said "la-la-la" more. Love and peace

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +18

      Miyeon suits all the parts but you still say excuses to cover it. They give chorus only to her because miyeon is the girl who never be loved in the mv. She says "im not pretty im not lovely etc" if she was not they would never give this part.
      your bias can't be miyeon since you ignore all of those times which miyeon only has 2 prechorus total 14 seconds.😂 i hope you don't try to ignore this fact anymore

    • @kuanyshrakhmetov8934
      @kuanyshrakhmetov8934 Год назад +43

      @@amorfatee haha, you are so funny. I am happy for my bias because she is in the self-producing group. I am happy because the producer highlights her vocals and knows how to do it. Stupid people like you think that main vocal have to sing more, but it is not true. Main vocal have to sing the hardest parts, and she is doing a great job in the group. I was waiting for her solo the most, and her album was literally on repeat for me last year. Don't tell me who is my bias. I love Miyeon, but I love the whole group too. That's the reason why Neverland is the best fandom. We don't have SOLO stans like some other groups, who are ready to fight for some 5 secs. I am with the group for 3+ years and I know that "la-la-la" part sounds way better by Minnie and Shu, than Miyeon. Each of them have different charms and they know how to use it. i hope you don't try to ignore this fact anymore

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +2

      @@kuanyshrakhmetov8934 your points are meaningless asf. i am following them since may 2 2018 which the day debuted i can recognize their voices better than you don't dare to give me a lecture. you say hardest parts bla bla and they also don't give her hardest parts so what? you still try to ignore the fact miyeon is treated like a sub vocalist. and saying what she deserves is not being a solo stan. you are saying the same shits over and over again come to me with better arguments.

    • @sukmadp1602
      @sukmadp1602 Год назад +8

      The amount of trust we nevies has on soyeon still nothing compared to the girls.
      Trust everything on SY.

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +4

      @@amorfatee well if she suited every party why she didn’t go to solo and released this track? Oh, right… she is in the group😂 so calm down over these 14 seconds

  • @KevinLopez-sg7se
    @KevinLopez-sg7se Год назад +57

    Miyeon last in another comeback? What a surprise

    • @igot7-lu
      @igot7-lu Год назад +9

      Actually shes 3rd since I wouldn't count "lalalas" as actual lines lol but if u go by ranking then yes. But I'd rather have proper lines than las

    • @Ra1xYii
      @Ra1xYii Год назад +9

      Pray for miyeon to get first in the actual album cuz this is just the pre-release😭😭

    • @akonori4071
      @akonori4071 Год назад +2

      lets hope she gets more in the title track

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +4

      im so surprised like how can it be? ahaha

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +1

      Yeah, 14 seconds less than other wow Whatta pity for her main vocalist position

  • @yohanedescends4683
    @yohanedescends4683 Год назад +302

    yall keep saying its fair when a main vocalist is at the bottom and the only one who didn't get more than 30 seconds...

    • @avrilynicolas3247
      @avrilynicolas3247 Год назад +27

      Kitsch = Allergy
      BESTIES ❤ 😅

    • @victjsofjsmdngor
      @victjsofjsmdngor Год назад +84

      @@avrilynicolas3247 i mean technically minnie and shuhua got less actual lines than miyeon. In a performances i don’t think those two would be highlighted during the whole time during the “lalala” part, that’s the only thing putting them ahead

    • @ryanostone22
      @ryanostone22 Год назад +38

      Yah but Shuhua and Minnie didn’t get actual lines. Miyeon did.

    • @ding4567
      @ding4567 Год назад +28

      @@avrilynicolas3247 get over it y'all act like letting someone other than the main vocal sing is a crime. Liz literally has the second most lines out of all the songs yet you token stand are still hung up on kitsch. If you don't like it, don't listen to it simple as that leave Ive alone.

    • @m.a2345
      @m.a2345 Год назад +23

      ​@@avrilynicolas3247 Miyeon still has more lines than Minnie and Shuhua since that "Lalala" shouldn't even be considered as a line, but if you want to consider it... what changes? The group has TWO Main Vocalists (and one had many "lines" if you want to consider the "Lalala") and ive only one, not the same case!

  • @truccc
    @truccc Год назад +89

    YuQi's voice is so good ❤❤

    • @inawairuz87
      @inawairuz87 Год назад +2

      Ikr??? Queen Yuqi slays💕💕💕

  • @lexichan5047
    @lexichan5047 Год назад +23

    Miyeon? Main vocalist? I don’t see it….. #plsgivemorelinestomiyeon

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +2

      14 seconds less than others and she is a sub-vocalist, Whatta pour soul. Nowadays people loose their skills and main vocalist position over those 14 seconds😢

  • @fontamillasjay1007
    @fontamillasjay1007 Год назад +13

    Maybe I want miyeon got comeback a soloist again. That would be amazing.

  • @wishing_moon
    @wishing_moon Год назад +253

    this is actually fair!! shuhua got to shine so much, i'm glad cube is starting to realize that she has an amazing voice

    • @ncteno
      @ncteno Год назад +46

      soyeon is the one that produces and distributes their songs. additionally, shuhua didn't sing a lot before because she stated to the fans she was not confident in her korean.

    • @wishing_moon
      @wishing_moon Год назад +3

      @@ncteno oh i just remembered, ty for correcting me

    • @tuhilam7651
      @tuhilam7651 Год назад +9

      ​@@wishing_moonsaid that Shuhua can't sing, Soyeon also said that Shuhua pronounces the word "la" very well so it makes sense to sing that part

    • @paulovictorfreitasgadziski6634
      @paulovictorfreitasgadziski6634 Год назад +1

      Actually she has a great amount tho, the others only got more lines because of adlibs

    • @pablo3679
      @pablo3679 Год назад +12

      its not, miyeon is last

  • @josephineswordshop
    @josephineswordshop Год назад +42

    I hope Miyeon can stand at the third or the second of line distribution in the title QUEENCARD. It's just a little bit wish.
    I've been waiting for her next best era since "Dumdi Dumdi" was released, she's so stunning with the vivid vibe and girly concept.
    Honestly in this "Allergy", although she had the least line at all, she still had an iconic line, can say a killing part that make every non-fans put it on air.
    Love you girl, Miyeonnn❤

  • @saika_saikawa
    @saika_saikawa Год назад +21

    I know all member's voice fit this concept but i still dont know why MY usually has the least line though she is main vocal

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +3

      I would get if she sang 4 second like Liz. But dude she is has 14 second less than the other members. Why are you discrediting her main vocalist position over those 14 seconds 🤦‍♀️

    • @tbeee3375
      @tbeee3375 Год назад +3

      @@gimlisonofgloin4083 EXACTLY like she still had a good amount of lines despite being last in the distribution, people see last place and instantly assume they don’t have lines

  • @closed3000
    @closed3000 Год назад +13

    I hope Miyeon will get more lines in TT

  • @freedomdive1881
    @freedomdive1881 Год назад +10

    Oh, a very fair line distribution. Everyone gets more than 20 secs of singing exposure.

  • @nicdoesntexistt
    @nicdoesntexistt Год назад +4

    I dont get why people are mad here, Miyeon shinned alot in the two chorus that she was given which is fair since main vocalist Mainly get given the chorus anyways. And The gap between minnie and miyeon isnt bad since minnie just repeated lalala over and over again which isnt much of a line which got her more seconds in the song, and soyeon got her rap lines since shes a rapper, so i think its fair

  • @VintageGyu
    @VintageGyu Год назад +96

    Miyeon slaying the new sub vocalist position 💅💅💅

    • @Jakubeq8617
      @Jakubeq8617 Год назад +7

      That's so sad

    • @hannapapp4667
      @hannapapp4667 Год назад +18

      And she's the best (G)i-dle vocal...

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +10

      She is the best vocalist among All

    • @closed3000
      @closed3000 Год назад +10

      And yet she outsing all of members

    • @Salma04445
      @Salma04445 Год назад +6

      Girl they choose there own line go make this kind of comment under groups who don’t participate in anything in there comeback

  • @hulwanadalili
    @hulwanadalili Год назад +27

    despite of how you guys saying it's unfair for miyeon, i really like this line distribution because each member suits their parts.
    ps: i dont have bias in gidle nor a hater of any member

  • @hungtran5056
    @hungtran5056 Год назад +27

    YuQi's voice is really good she's so shining❤

  • @anuabraham5823
    @anuabraham5823 Год назад +3

    People, please stop complaining about Miyeon not getting more parts. In the m/v she shines a lot and her part is actually the best part of the whole song. They already said that they consider the member's opinions when it comes to line distribution. Don't hate on Soyeon for this too. Girl's already been hated on a lot. And most of the time, it's not even nevies who are disappointed but other fandoms.

  • @tosomnia.BONVOYAGE
    @tosomnia.BONVOYAGE Год назад +4

    actually we all should be happy for miyeon lines BEcause main vocals always get the chorus and i understand.. She just got 2 chorus here but it's better than one single line repeated multiple times and she must have chosen her proper line! Miyeon shined a lot in these eras, she's beautiful and her voice made up her more elegant and it seems to like her lines! that's a reason to love her and (G)-idle. They treat themselves equally and nobody is excluded so thanks soyeon and miyeon for owning this song❤

  • @sagirin777
    @sagirin777 Год назад +24

    Wow Yuqi era ❤❤❤ i love Miyeon’s chorus so much.

  • @albarebollarcompte1380
    @albarebollarcompte1380 Год назад +3

    miyeon might have the least lines but they're the catchiest💋

  • @avrilynicolas3247
    @avrilynicolas3247 Год назад +6

    The mirror: WHAT WAS THE REASON!!!??? 😠

  • @Anna-fl7ho
    @Anna-fl7ho Год назад +2

    I need some of you to understand that Miyeon is a grown woman and would tell Soyeon if SHE had a problem with the line distribution.

  • @igot7-lu
    @igot7-lu Год назад +36

    Yuqis era! Finally she gets alot of lines and shines here

  • @felt8397
    @felt8397 Год назад +3

    Even in the 'Allergy' music video, Miyeon had the fewest costume changes, just like in 'Nxde.'
    KEEP TREATING MIYEON BADLY.

  • @baepinkobsession
    @baepinkobsession Год назад +21

    "This is fair omg"
    Well ig nobody cares about Miyeon since day 1

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +4

      if this was shuhua they would scream

  • @cesarwalker6654
    @cesarwalker6654 Год назад +7

    Miyeon being last position in the song that suit her voice the most... I can't imagine how the other darker songs will be... At this point she is the subvocal

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +3

      Oh yeah 14 seconds less than other immediately make her a sub-vocalist. Soyeon and producers give her incoherent lalalala to compensate to return her position

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +2

      ​@@gimlisonofgloin4083 still you are just talking about "this song". Atp i think you have never listened other Idle songs check ot Nxde and Tomboy i recommend.

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +2

      @@amorfatee If u don’t know, gidle has other songs not only nxde and tomboy. listen to them and her solo, instead of degrading her to sub-vocalist position.

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +2

      ​@@gimlisonofgloin4083 the one who talks about this song and say "you are degrading her with 14 seconds" repeatedly like there is no tomorrow is not me. It's you. So You better listen other songs of Idle and make comments after then.

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад

      @@amorfatee I don’t complain how u come after every comment to whine over Miyeon. Give me reasonable response why her getting less lines totally erase her main vocalist skills, and I will leave.

  • @Rocket_finds
    @Rocket_finds Год назад +21

    I was expecting for miyeon.... Literally she is the main vocalist if in the title track she got less line ill stop listening them

    • @Rocket_finds
      @Rocket_finds Год назад +1

      @Minnah Lifestyle I hope so and I'm a boy not a girl....

    • @imeaniguessbutkindaeh
      @imeaniguessbutkindaeh Год назад +1

      ​@Minnah Lifestyle she literally been given the last place in the majority of songs in their last comebacks.... it's pretty obvious she won't get many lines unless it's some ballad where she would end up on the 2nd/3d place.... it's pretty logical to be upset about it LMAO

  • @skyef9891
    @skyef9891 Год назад +4

    Idc if miyeon got the least amount of lines, this was her era

  • @neodxlso
    @neodxlso Год назад +2

    the way y’all are talking in these comments… you’d think miyeon got like 5 secs but she has 22? she’s the main vocalist and sang both choruses this is extremely fair the only reason minnie and shuhua got more lines then her is because the lalalala

  • @lieselorevangheluwe6371
    @lieselorevangheluwe6371 Год назад +3

    Everyone is saying it isn't fair, but I actually feel like every member got the lines that suited them the most. Altough MY got the least lines, she also had the most important lines. I think to make it more fair, they could give MY some adlibs with highnotes. Also if SH and MN didn't got the lalala they would have been last.
    Btw for those who keep saying SY doesn't makes good line distributions. She asks the members which lines they want. And if she got the most lines that's bc she's the center, leader and the only announced rapper (ik YQ is a rapper too, but that's not official)

  • @san88zz
    @san88zz Год назад +1

    0:13 This line sounds more like Shuhua
    1:48 Clearly this is yuqi's voice

  • @kuvroblox_ontop
    @kuvroblox_ontop Год назад +9

    This is actual one of the best gidle line distributions I saw

  • @aweirdgirlinthisweirdworld6159
    @aweirdgirlinthisweirdworld6159 Год назад +1

    I love how they gave shushu more scenes in the mv ❤

  • @rahulsahu4.3.3.7
    @rahulsahu4.3.3.7 Год назад +2

    Wait Miyeon is least , it's doesn't seem like that when you hear cause she shines so much during the chorus

  • @ikhwanizat1386
    @ikhwanizat1386 Год назад +11

    Idk, miyeon same line singing for is not fair. For me, i think give minnie 2nd chorus, minyeon take the 2nd part minnie verse and 1st chorus. That show versitility of main vocalist.

  • @chiedzawith2ds
    @chiedzawith2ds Год назад +1

    Shuhua actually sang the bridge alone (according to official Genuis lyrics) so she had the most lines.

  • @bloomingmami
    @bloomingmami Год назад +1

    Miyeon may main vocal in Quuen card in this 15 may

  • @efae
    @efae Год назад +3

    Miyeon has the least lines but it's my favorite

  • @toddpacker867
    @toddpacker867 Год назад +3

    1:49 the “oh my oh my” is Yuqi

    • @amitkpoplds
      @amitkpoplds  Год назад +6

      You can hear it is soyeon

    • @toddpacker867
      @toddpacker867 Год назад

      @@amitkpoplds no the adlibs before were Soyeon. The “oh my oh my” was yuqi. Compare it to the one in the first pre-chorus that was Soyeon

  • @kpopbroughtmehere
    @kpopbroughtmehere Год назад +47

    literally 4 lines perfectly fitting each other and then there's miyeon... AS USUAL. and when she fitted perfectly for the concept.
    anyway, thank you for your videos, nowadays your channel is on top of the channel i trusts with line distributions

    • @drigoykz
      @drigoykz Год назад +13

      I really can't with people saying this is fair tbh. It wouldn't be a problem at all if this wasn't recurring, it's the 3rd comeback in a row Miyeon gets the least lines, and especially on this one where her vibe fits the song so much
      Also she's a visual, but I barely noticed her in the MV?

    • @illegaluser69
      @illegaluser69 Год назад +1

      ​@@drigoykz it's just a pre-release. Who knows? Maybe she still get lines in Queencard. Let's hope

    • @toamszkozak8822
      @toamszkozak8822 Год назад

      ​@@drigoykzomg why are you so selfish, Miyeon is happy with what she have so stop trying to create a problem

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад

      Wow guys you are so dramatic over those 14 seconds 😂 calm down already

  • @Omgits7ito
    @Omgits7ito Год назад

    I love it ♥️.

  • @wildchicken6324
    @wildchicken6324 Год назад

    Im so glad yuqi and shuhua got lots of lines!! As for miyeon she got a lot in other concepts so i think its fine, it brings back the balance

  • @VKarina929
    @VKarina929 Год назад +1

    1:48 Oh my oh my is Yuqi

  • @thitmyatlin3280
    @thitmyatlin3280 Год назад +35

    miyeon deserves more she is the main vocalist

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +3

      Deserves to get this incoherent lalala part, it will def prove her main vocalist position

  • @myaaurora
    @myaaurora Год назад +14

    at this point miyeon is a sub vocalist

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +6

      Sub vocalist gets 30 seconds so she is a backup dancer

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +4

      14 seconds less than others and BOOM you are a sub-vocalist, nowadays this is how idols loose their positions and skills 😢

  • @liar9950
    @liar9950 Год назад +39

    It would have been fairer if at the end there was a vocal part where they gave miyeon and minnie a high note instead of a "lalala" ☠️
    and I understand that they give the chorus to miyeon but is it so difficult to give her a verse? 😭

    • @jacklast
      @jacklast Год назад +7

      Or they can do miyeon's highnote along with the Lalala i can imagine it sounds amazing

    • @Cryforme-
      @Cryforme- Год назад +1

      @@jacklast Excatly!

  • @Swarup_8382
    @Swarup_8382 Год назад +3

    Yuqi's era🫶🏼

  • @erioldesaulniers3032
    @erioldesaulniers3032 Год назад +5

    Is Miyeon really the main vocalist? Maybe once or twice she's got the least line, but it's not good to continue like that.

    • @closed3000
      @closed3000 Год назад +1

      There are two main vocals-Minnie and Miyeon.
      But Miyeon is a better vocalist.
      She is a sub vocal at this point

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +1

      Right, 14 seconds less than others and you are a sub-vocalist. This is how people loose their skills. Producers give her lalalala part and adlibs to return main voc position

  • @marckyhaze9049
    @marckyhaze9049 Год назад +1

    I'm honestly not complaining if Miyeon got the least line, the important thing is she shine just like the rest of them. i didn't even realized Miyeon got the least line because her part may be short but it's honestly the best and impactful part for me. Her part is my favorite and most awaited. It's not important who's first to know if the song is fair. Not all of them need to be first just to be fair, SY know what she's doing and it's the best decision of her to give Miyeon pre/chorus part. It suits her so much.

  • @Kizz_meh
    @Kizz_meh Год назад

    I just wait for their live!!

  • @dojacatagorahills
    @dojacatagorahills Год назад +8

    (g) i-dle Line distribution Allergy
    Shuhua - 35.9
    Minnie - 35.1
    Soyeon - 35.1
    Yuqi - 34.6
    Miyeon - 21.8
    Soojin - 0.0
    Its so fair but i really miss Soojin 😢 if shes here she will slay this concept too

    • @hellobye4984
      @hellobye4984 Год назад +1

      The main vocal being the only one who doesn’t get 30s is fair lol

  • @choiminjun9986
    @choiminjun9986 Год назад +6

    Kitsch : 20-5
    Allergy : 35-22
    Liz🤝Miyeon

    • @farelg4948
      @farelg4948 Год назад +5

      but liz gets the most parts in other songs. bro this is just one song 💀 just wait, miyeon will get more parts in other songs

    • @closed3000
      @closed3000 Год назад +6

      @@farelg4948 well,if you check Idle previous album,Miyeon is like 4th place in album distribution.
      Fact-Miyeon actually never got 1st place in album distribution
      So it is kind of hopeless for her to get lines like Liz in album🧐

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад

      @@closed3000 One previous album totally indicates that Miyeon will be 4th forever. Yeah, sure 😂

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад

      ​@@gimlisonofgloin4083 it is just not one album and you know this very well.

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +1

      @@amorfatee oh yes? Name me every album where she is 4th, 5th and 6th. I’m pretty sure it won’t be enough To discredit her main vocalist position

  • @yamyam3111
    @yamyam3111 Год назад +1

    It’s actually fine, Minnie and shuhua basically just keep singing lalaala

  • @rahrety
    @rahrety Год назад +1

    yuqi's voice is this music style

  • @DeeDeeDeeeee
    @DeeDeeDeeeee Год назад +26

    Y’all acting like it isn’t fair when if it weren’t for the lalala’s which is barely a line and probably won’t be highlighted in performances, Miyeon would be third and got chorus lines. It’s also very obvi based on the mv this song was meant to highlight Soyeon and Yuqi, that’s why they all got their characters and track spoilers designated to them. Plus this isn’t even the title track and isn’t gonna be promoted until the album comes out, it’s not even on streaming yet. I agree that the past two eras Miyeon’s potential has been wasted but y’all are acting like her lines were terrible.

    • @mizore922
      @mizore922 Год назад +2

      This is the B-side. They never give a chance for Miyeon tittle. The songs that Miyeon got good line time on so far were b-sides. Now she's completely sub vocal.

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад

      @@mizore922 they don't understand bro they don't understand...

    • @mizore922
      @mizore922 Год назад +1

      @@amorfatee No, they understand. They just ignore it...

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад

      @@mizore922 this is more frustrating

    • @DeeDeeDeeeee
      @DeeDeeDeeeee Год назад

      @@amorfatee y’all are corny

  • @marygl3853
    @marygl3853 Год назад +11

    Shuhua finally has many lines, I'm so glad for her!

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +2

      She had many lines since lion that's not new

    • @marvel3734
      @marvel3734 Год назад +2

      Yeah
      A disaster

  • @turkburg7816
    @turkburg7816 Год назад +39

    IMHO "Equal line distribution" isn't always "fair", but every member getting a part to shine is.
    it's already known that Miyeon usually sings choruses or prechoruses in songs and she seems very happy about it. she even said that she literally had a say in picking the parts she did in Nxde, implying that members in general decide their parts in collaboration with Soyeon and then the company.
    Miyeon shines in the chorus, her voice fits it super well, she's gonna do great with it on stage too, I'm sure, and I love her a lot

    • @sychoi5597
      @sychoi5597 Год назад +2

      I think the producers team have already tried to equally distribute the lines if you compared to their older songs (hann,hwaa,etc...) at least no one getting lines less than 10 seconds

  • @felt8397
    @felt8397 Год назад +112

    Everyone always made excuses that the reason for the lack of lines for Miyeon in songs was because she didn't fit the concept, but did you see it? Miyeon always sings only half of the pre-chorus or chorus.(If she sings the pre-chorus, then there is no chorus) The concept is not the problem. Soyeon just always tries to use Miyeon in only the predetermined parts. So, half of the pre-chorus or chorus is always the entirety of her part.

    • @carolsoares3501
      @carolsoares3501 Год назад +7

      but it's the girls who choose their parts so if she wanted to sing only that part it was because she wanted to

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +26

      ​@@carolsoares3501 no soyeon decides they said this in a variety program.

    • @ellalloyd17
      @ellalloyd17 Год назад +25

      Soyeon gives the parts to the members who suit it most,also remember that if they were unhappy with their lines in a song they would discuss it

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +33

      Soyeon always a villain. Shuhua has the least lines. It is SY’s fault. Yuqi has the least. Again SY’s fault. Miyeon also has the least lines. We will blame Soyeon one more again.
      Uk someone will eventually have the least lines, right? Stop making her a scapegoat, Not everything can be divided with the ruler and this how adult life works.

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +8

      @@gimlisonofgloin4083 shuhua can has least lines yuqi too because they are sub vocalist. this case is not the same.

  • @eygxo
    @eygxo Год назад +1

    I love it but I def feel bad for miyeon

  • @sakurai5819
    @sakurai5819 Год назад +1

    Im sure that ppl that claim miyeon’s lines are fair did not buy miyeon’s jewel album :)) and you ppl don’t deserve to comment on miyeon’s lines

  • @NhuNguyen-sy1bn
    @NhuNguyen-sy1bn Год назад +1

    Isn’t this song an example that line distribution is somewhat a silly concept? Miyeon might be last in terms of the length of her part, but it’s literally the chorus and most addicting part of the song. Everyone is praising her vocal. And seriously, shuhua or minnie get more time in the song, only because of the lalala part and that their lines are slower paced.

  • @naefertiri
    @naefertiri Год назад +8

    this should never be considered fair.

  • @GummyKpopMumy
    @GummyKpopMumy Год назад +5

    It's so fair omg😭❤

    • @amitkpoplds
      @amitkpoplds  Год назад +18

      But miyeon😭😭

    • @pablo3679
      @pablo3679 Год назад +9

      WTF????? IT'S NOT, MIYEON IS LAST

    • @paulovictorfreitasgadziski6634
      @paulovictorfreitasgadziski6634 Год назад +2

      @@pablo3679 yo, without minnie and shuhua's adlibs in the end she would be third

    • @snowy5812
      @snowy5812 Год назад +6

      @@paulovictorfreitasgadziski6634 That doesn't matter, she's being last since Lion

  • @nadia_vfx1386
    @nadia_vfx1386 Год назад +6

    This is actually a really good distribution but Miyeon deserves more lines

  • @PoppyYolk
    @PoppyYolk Год назад +3

    atp better change miyeon's position to lead vocal and i'll shut up. cuz this happen since senorita (i think except for dumdi dumdi) :/

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад

      Same just change miyeon's position and we will say nothing.

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +2

      Yeah let’s totally forget her skills and degrade her position over those 14 seconds. She must have sing those incoherent adlibs and lalalala part to return her vocalist supremacy

  • @nichaxxx_
    @nichaxxx_ Год назад +1

    finallyy the right line because people said shuhua only sang the lalala part

  • @MarinaRibeiro-ku2hm
    @MarinaRibeiro-ku2hm Год назад +1

    🤎🩷🩷🩷🩷
    🩷🤎🩷🩷🩷

  • @braincabbage
    @braincabbage Год назад +6

    this song fits Yuqi's voice so well! And I think for this song it's good that there's no real rap part

  • @onlylyah_
    @onlylyah_ Год назад

    Thank you❤

  • @WAFFLE747
    @WAFFLE747 Год назад

    I think the line distribution is quite fair but because Shuhua doesn’t sing the “Lalalala” part she would get last. Miyeon gets second last but Minnie and Miyeon are both Main vocalists so if Miyeon gets a lot of lines then the other members won’t get many lines. She maybe could of taken a verse from Yuqi or even Minnie but it’s still pretty fair

  • @danhhuy4952
    @danhhuy4952 Год назад

    The second "oh my oh my " is Yuqi😊

  • @danielnising
    @danielnising Год назад +1

    Imagine being a Main Vocal and getting the least amount of lines 💀

  • @sofiaaaa28
    @sofiaaaa28 Год назад

    thanks❤

  • @kpop_drama250
    @kpop_drama250 Год назад +1

    I don't why but it kinda sound like winx club song

  • @_Yana
    @_Yana Год назад +13

    I’m also tired of seeing Miyeon at the bottom of the line distributions, but I don’t think we can count Shuhua & Minnie’s “lalala” as actual lines. I’m not saying this video is inaccurate, I’m just saying that we should be glad Miyeon got actual lines bc she and Yuqi sound amazing on the chorus 💕

  • @mrblueberry599
    @mrblueberry599 Год назад +7

    Some of you wont be satisfied with anything and keep saying its not fair for blah blah blah. Only thing you guys want is all member sing 20% equally i guess. Im just so tired of this

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +3

      no we don't want that but we are tired of miyeon being last everytime. we want her not being the last and treated like a main vocalist.

  • @cherrysquad2000
    @cherrysquad2000 Год назад

    Minnie and shuha be like let just sing lala with full force or else we have. Nothing

  • @muhammadsyarkowi2449
    @muhammadsyarkowi2449 Год назад +1

    Lalala part only shuhua sing

  • @Ra1xYii
    @Ra1xYii Год назад

    Minnie and shuhua in yuqi “senorita” era y’all🤠🤌🏻

  • @tuafarelpandiangan9482
    @tuafarelpandiangan9482 Год назад

    this is just right

  • @caelloum1374
    @caelloum1374 Год назад +9

    LMAO the main vocalist barely sung

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +1

      Yeah 14 second less than other is called barely singing. Yeah, this is how people loose main vocalist position😢 she should have sung this incoherent lalala part to show her talent.

  • @yeeun3901
    @yeeun3901 Год назад +2

    yall miyeon got to sing the first chorus twice. IMMA NEED YALL TO UNDERSTAND THAT IT'S A FUCKING CHORUS AND NOT FILLER LINE STOP SCREAMING MISTREATMENT. ty

    • @hellobye4984
      @hellobye4984 Год назад

      Lol they literally do this to her EVERY CB we’re tired of the same old shit. She’s the only member who gets treated like this- nothing special for her part all she does is share a part with the lead or sub vocal. Last 3 cbs she’s gotten the least lines

  • @Silverqueen833
    @Silverqueen833 Год назад +12

    Miyeon is the main vocalist right? :(

    • @amorfatee
      @amorfatee Год назад +9

      she is being treated like a sub vocalist since dumdi dumdi and most people even don't know she is a main vocalist.

    • @gimlisonofgloin4083
      @gimlisonofgloin4083 Год назад +2

      Yeah having 14 seconds in title track less than others immediately make u lose ur position as main vocalist😂 Whatta crazy world we live

    • @hellobye4984
      @hellobye4984 Год назад

      @@gimlisonofgloin4083 having the least lines three title tracks in a row and the same amount of lines/bottom tier with the lead and sub vocals for like 2 years is NOT how a main vocalist is treated pls stfu

  • @hoangphita8143
    @hoangphita8143 Месяц назад

    1:48 is Yuqi

  • @misteon_builds
    @misteon_builds Год назад +1

    first

  • @marcypanin
    @marcypanin Год назад

    Very not bad🥰

  • @jinn8339
    @jinn8339 Год назад +4

    YES SHUHUA GET THOSE LINES