I was hoping it was gonna be the story of Buddha since Siddartha was his original name. But this is a really enlightening story and analysis. Spirituality is beautiful
Yeah it's interesting to me because Govinda = a name of Krishna/Vishnu, one of the most worshiped and important gods of Hinduism (in some sects considered to be the supreme God), and Siddharta = the name the Buddha had before he became enlightened. Both of them seem to struggle with living up to those names, but in a way, they both end up representing the struggles within modern-day Hinduism and Buddhism. Buddhism goes off and becomes more worldly and Westernized, but that causes it to conflict with its spiritual roots. Hinduism in some ways is too guru-focused and stuck in tradition to see that true wisdom has to come from individual experience, not collective ritual or guru-disciple teaching.
but who is being talked about? who is enlightened? all just words. there is no buddha, self, enlightenment, meaning, or anything. all exists within itself yet does not exist. its all manifestation of self, god, the god within all, even though god is not praised, it is reconised within all life, all being, and in a way that is the praise. a simple node to one another. nothing to find or seek. its all in front of us. it is us weather we realize or not. :)
Or religion as a tool, and that is ALL what religion really is,l must evolve as human beings evolve. I see nothing wrong with "Westernizing" and even Hinduism is getting away from too much guru lead understanding. The age of the guru is past but a little refresher now and then helps the evolution of thought and body to continue. You might try studying some Fourth Way teachings to get a better idea.
I read this book three times. the first just to understand, the second to underline all of the color themes throughout dudes life, and the third to circle all of the references to water. it's amazing how well and detailed and connected this book is. Herman Hesse is a bomb ass author!!!!
Isn't this book an allegory for the Buddha's Four Noble Truths and Eightfold Path? From memory, I always thought the novel was split into two parts because the story's twelve chapters are segregated into four chapters for part one and eight chapters for part two, which symbolizes the Four Noble Truths and the eight trainings of the Eightfold Path. Each of the chapters isn't meant to show the truths and trainings in a literal sense, but in a subtextual sense where the realization of the truths and the acquisition of the trainings are the backbone for Siddhartha's character arc, much like (for example) how one could use the Monomyth as a lens to examine the character arc of a typical Western hero. Can someone clarify me on this?
Jenifer Joseph He doesn't disagree with the Buddha's teachings, only with the notion that teaching them will help a person achieve Enlightenment. Remember, this novel's angle is that you can't rely on a teacher to help you become Enlightened, but that you have to go out and find Enlightenment on your own. So it would be fitting if Siddhartha experienced the Noble Truths and Eightfold Path himself rather than be taught it by the Buddha.
+Jenifer Joseph He does not disagree with Buddha. He says the very thing Buddha said. Have faith in yourself, not in the teachers. That is what John Lennon reworded in his song the God.
This fella is so wonderful! I appreciate his insightful comments, especially in a simplistic “lay-mans terms” manner shedding the fancy words for truer meaning, a true scholar and blessing!
It took me 23 years of my life to figure out that 3:56 on my own... Like this Siddhartha character, I was raised in a religious family (Buddhist), but like any other Asian families, you're not supposed to question your parents, you are only to obey. But unlike any other Asian kids, I asked "why?". Like any other Asian parents, their responses are rage & violence. It's ironic when you think about it... But it can be said they did told me about these kind of things, but I never understand any of them, now I realize my parents don't understand it much either, they are merely citing what they have been told by their parents & their parents before them. If I ever have children, I will let them go than to bind them with tradition. Because I know they will not understand, all I can do is tell them my experiences...
i love your work... and i live in a town full of kids who would love to hear literature in this voice... i will do everything i can to spread your channel in my town... thank you thank you thank you!!
What's more laudable than the videos is the fact that you can leave out important things about the novel (like the eightfold path and the eight chapters and junk) and still make a damn good analysis.
9 лет назад+1
This is such a great channel, and from personal experience, I would have to say what Siddhartha has to say about wisdom and enlightenment is true.
look man I have to do a Pecha Kucha on this book and this really helped, I wish I could give something in return but all I can say is God bless you. keep doing your thing you were a blessing to me from him and I'm sure you'll continue to be a blessing to others; if we never meet again, stay safe and stay blessed. keep it up
Thanks for the rundown. I have to admit, I really enjoy your take on these as you're able to link to many other books and form interesting connections. Thanks, man!
Kind of disheartening when people read this book and mistake it as a biographical account of the historical Buddha's life. Anyway, this is the kind of book where a translation either makes or breaks it. I recommend the Penguin Classics Deluxe Edition.
This is a hilarious review for a book that is surprisingly funny at times. I love this book and it helped me turn a major corner in my spirituality, cant recommend it enough for people who are looking for answers.
I've been spreading the word about Thug Notes ever since I watched your video on Oedipus Rex! My classmates love your show and this video made us actually like Siddhartha! Thanks man! Keep up the fantastic work!
Great work on your channel! I appreciate what you do to support the reading of these seemingly complicated books for students. Many blessings to you! 🙏
When I first started getting into different theistic and philosophical studies, this was one first books was recommended to me. I really enjoyed it. I found it to be a sort of parallel of of Siddhārtha Gautama's own path to enlightenment. Biggest difference was Gautama was born a sheltered Prince and lived like one till about the age of 30. There are others but that was the biggest one. It would be great if you did The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho.
One of my fave Hesse novels. I know your analysis is supposed to be spare and quick but there is much more to this story. It's based on the beginnings of Buddhism - actual started from some of the other local Eastern religions such as Hinduism (hence Brahma) Zoroaster - the Ascetics and the Taoism - practical Buddhism which Zen Buddhism is based on. Siddhartha found each avenue too "easy" for him and couldn't keep them together or their main tenants without any actual experience and he would forget them but somehow realize that he had known them all along - "I can wait, I can fast and I can pray/meditate..." Patience, Fortitude and Deep Realization or Self Knowledge based on self observation. Similarly is the Zen Koan "If you meet the Buddha on the road you must kill him."
I just finished reading it myself. And it’s everything you said it would be. I’m glad I gave it a read at long last! (Maybe I’ll read Where The Red Fern Grows next. I’ll probably cry even harder reading that!)
Love your show !! The topic of India came eventually up, because hesses father was a missionary in India and Buddhism has its roots in india. Just a short note. Please do "In a grove" by Ryunoskue Akutagawa next, please :-) (He was really into Buddhism too ;-) )
You guys at wisecrack must be following my phone or something, first you put on some alien interpreting spring breakers after I set some hot pic from that movie as my wallpaper, and now that I'm reading this book in school, we get sparky sweets to roll on it? Keep doin what you're doing
Could you do 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?' sometime soon? You could also take a look at 'Blade Runner' on Earthling Cinema, looking at the different versions which put the main character in a serious identity crisis
I was hoping it was gonna be the story of Buddha since Siddartha was his original name. But this is a really enlightening story and analysis. Spirituality is beautiful
you might like Thich Nhat Hanh's book, Old Path White Clouds.
It's a play on the story of Buddha. Told almost in reverse.
Thanks for reminding me. I might need to read this. I have seen a documentary about Buddhism itself.
***** Most biographies about spiritual personalities tend to be like that. Most famous example "Autobiography of a Yogi"
Yeah it's interesting to me because Govinda = a name of Krishna/Vishnu, one of the most worshiped and important gods of Hinduism (in some sects considered to be the supreme God), and Siddharta = the name the Buddha had before he became enlightened. Both of them seem to struggle with living up to those names, but in a way, they both end up representing the struggles within modern-day Hinduism and Buddhism. Buddhism goes off and becomes more worldly and Westernized, but that causes it to conflict with its spiritual roots. Hinduism in some ways is too guru-focused and stuck in tradition to see that true wisdom has to come from individual experience, not collective ritual or guru-disciple teaching.
hey, i'm from india, your knowledge about this subject is just mindblowin playa, naw mean?
but who is being talked about? who is enlightened? all just words. there is no buddha, self, enlightenment, meaning, or anything. all exists within itself yet does not exist. its all manifestation of self, god, the god within all, even though god is not praised, it is reconised within all life, all being, and in a way that is the praise. a simple node to one another. nothing to find or seek. its all in front of us. it is us weather we realize or not. :)
hahaha, dont listen! find, be yourself!
Or religion as a tool, and that is ALL what religion really is,l must evolve as human beings evolve. I see nothing wrong with "Westernizing" and even Hinduism is getting away from too much guru lead understanding. The age of the guru is past but a little refresher now and then helps the evolution of thought and body to continue. You might try studying some Fourth Way teachings to get a better idea.
Its believed that Siddhartha is the eighth avatar of Vishnu himself, thus he is both Krishna and the Buddha.
I read this book three times. the first just to understand, the second to underline all of the color themes throughout dudes life, and the third to circle all of the references to water. it's amazing how well and detailed and connected this book is. Herman Hesse is a bomb ass author!!!!
MATTA FACT
I loved ithat part lol
I am now glad I am subscribed to Lotus Prince.
-Cinos
+TrioInTheTree Thank you very much!
+Lotus Prince Been subbed since Killer 7. Just love the style you bring to the LP game.
+TrioInTheTree Thanks again! The comic review was long overdue, but I'm glad that I finally got it online. :-D
one of the best of thug notes... love your show guys, keep it up :)
I wish they did
I love this channel.
May Dantas this channel loves you
Wisecrack kudos
May Dantas I love Hesse, and most of all, I love Siddhartha!!!! :)
+Cosminen Steppenwolf is fucking epic too, as is the Glass Bead game. So much wisdom in that guy.
+Cosminen my favorite is Demian
the irony of these videos is that the establishment might not like this style but he's bang on the money accurate and details every time :) 10/10
I love this series. PLEASE BRING THIS SERIES BACK ITS SO NEEDED NOW ESPECIALLY BECAUSE OF THE PANDEMIC
I think this book is about individuality and how everyone must take their own path.
This is surprisingly close to my inner monologue when I review for history exams, he just does it waaay better
Isn't this book an allegory for the Buddha's Four Noble Truths and Eightfold Path? From memory, I always thought the novel was split into two parts because the story's twelve chapters are segregated into four chapters for part one and eight chapters for part two, which symbolizes the Four Noble Truths and the eight trainings of the Eightfold Path. Each of the chapters isn't meant to show the truths and trainings in a literal sense, but in a subtextual sense where the realization of the truths and the acquisition of the trainings are the backbone for Siddhartha's character arc, much like (for example) how one could use the Monomyth as a lens to examine the character arc of a typical Western hero.
Can someone clarify me on this?
Well, I don't think so, because the main character of Siddhartha disagrees with the Buddha about how to teach Enlightenment.
Jenifer Joseph He doesn't disagree with the Buddha's teachings, only with the notion that teaching them will help a person achieve Enlightenment. Remember, this novel's angle is that you can't rely on a teacher to help you become Enlightened, but that you have to go out and find Enlightenment on your own. So it would be fitting if Siddhartha experienced the Noble Truths and Eightfold Path himself rather than be taught it by the Buddha.
+Jenifer Joseph He does not disagree with Buddha. He says the very thing Buddha said. Have faith in yourself, not in the teachers. That is what John Lennon reworded in his song the God.
My mother gave me this book when I was 14 and so far I've read it countless times.
The scientific method has given me a form enlightenment in a way that materialism or spirituality could never do for me.
This fella is so wonderful! I appreciate his insightful comments, especially in a simplistic “lay-mans terms” manner shedding the fancy words for truer meaning, a true scholar and blessing!
It took me 23 years of my life to figure out that 3:56 on my own...
Like this Siddhartha character, I was raised in a religious family (Buddhist), but like any other Asian families, you're not supposed to question your parents, you are only to obey. But unlike any other Asian kids, I asked "why?". Like any other Asian parents, their responses are rage & violence. It's ironic when you think about it...
But it can be said they did told me about these kind of things, but I never understand any of them, now I realize my parents don't understand it much either, they are merely citing what they have been told by their parents & their parents before them.
If I ever have children, I will let them go than to bind them with tradition. Because I know they will not understand, all I can do is tell them my experiences...
beautiful story friend. I can relate to your story too, as I have similar parents
You’re going to be a good parent. Beautiful story.
Finally a book that I've read
Sparkie seems like such a cool dude in the off-stage recordings :)
i love your work... and i live in a town full of kids who would love to hear literature in this voice... i will do everything i can to spread your channel in my town... thank you thank you thank you!!
What's more laudable than the videos is the fact that you can leave out important things about the novel (like the eightfold path and the eight chapters and junk) and still make a damn good analysis.
This is such a great channel, and from personal experience, I would have to say what Siddhartha has to say about wisdom and enlightenment is true.
You're one smart man
You used the word "you're" correctly. You are also a smart man. :P
***** hi
look man I have to do a Pecha Kucha on this book and this really helped, I wish I could give something in return but all I can say is God bless you. keep doing your thing you were a blessing to me from him and I'm sure you'll continue to be a blessing to others; if we never meet again, stay safe and stay blessed. keep it up
Thanks for the knowledge, Doc. Guess I'm off to get myself some wisdom. :P
Just remember booty comes first (^_^
"Find yoself 'fore you wreck yoself!"
This channel is the one true source of legit wisdom!
+Daniel Gospodinov Scratch wisdom and write knowledge or else you won't be taking nothing from the video.
Thanks for the rundown. I have to admit, I really enjoy your take on these as you're able to link to many other books and form interesting connections. Thanks, man!
I just read that book not that long ago. This. Was. PERFECT!
Keep spreading that wisdom, Sparky Sweets.
Kind of disheartening when people read this book and mistake it as a biographical account of the historical Buddha's life. Anyway, this is the kind of book where a translation either makes or breaks it. I recommend the Penguin Classics Deluxe Edition.
I read Siddhartha, amazing book, I recommend it to everyone
I am starting this book right now.
This was the best review of any kind I’ve ever seen.
This is a hilarious review for a book that is surprisingly funny at times. I love this book and it helped me turn a major corner in my spirituality, cant recommend it enough for people who are looking for answers.
Man, you're awesome for making these! Mad props.
Clicked just cause the thumbnail had my name on it
Such an awesome name!
@@silentspace.. Thanks, lol
@@siddarth_vader my pleasure! I hope you the best in all, stay safe🖤.
You are Siddharth not Siddhartha
@@Kevin-cy2dr both names are totally beautiful!
I've been spreading the word about Thug Notes ever since I watched your video on Oedipus Rex! My classmates love your show and this video made us actually like Siddhartha! Thanks man! Keep up the fantastic work!
I stumbled upon this gem by accident. So much offered that I am a fan extraordinaire.
by far, one of the best channels out there.
Probably the best thing I've watched all day before taking my English final over Siddhartha and other books. Thanks man!
The thug makes me wanna read. Job well done sir.
I don't even have these stories in my courses and I still love to watch your videos! Here's some love from India :)
I love these, they're so good
Nice! Thanks for another great review Sparky-sensei.
I've learned more from thug notes than actually going to English class, keep up the videos bloooood!
Great work on your channel! I appreciate what you do to support the reading of these seemingly complicated books for students. Many blessings to you! 🙏
Please do Mansfield Park by Jane Austen- I love how it freaks people out that the heroine is passively virtuous rather than aggressively righteous.
When I first started getting into different theistic and philosophical studies, this was one first books was recommended to me. I really enjoyed it. I found it to be a sort of parallel of of Siddhārtha Gautama's own path to enlightenment. Biggest difference was Gautama was born a sheltered Prince and lived like one till about the age of 30. There are others but that was the biggest one.
It would be great if you did The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho.
One of my fave Hesse novels. I know your analysis is supposed to be spare and quick but there is much more to this story. It's based on the beginnings of Buddhism - actual started from some of the other local Eastern religions such as Hinduism (hence Brahma) Zoroaster - the Ascetics and the Taoism - practical Buddhism which Zen Buddhism is based on. Siddhartha found each avenue too "easy" for him and couldn't keep them together or their main tenants without any actual experience and he would forget them but somehow realize that he had known them all along - "I can wait, I can fast and I can pray/meditate..." Patience, Fortitude and Deep Realization or Self Knowledge based on self observation. Similarly is the Zen Koan "If you meet the Buddha on the road you must kill him."
I miss you, thug notes
This episode is definitely one of the tip-tops. Good for you and big gratitude!
p.s. I dig what you did there with the chakras.
Analysis of The Little Prince, please....
I love this channel, because I explains the parts of lit that I don't understand.
I just finished this book and just stumbled on your channel. Loved this episode and became a subscriber. Looking forward to more vids!
I just finished reading it myself. And it’s everything you said it would be. I’m glad I gave it a read at long last! (Maybe I’ll read Where The Red Fern Grows next. I’ll probably cry even harder reading that!)
plz NEVER STOP DOING THIS MAN! U ALSOME
Game changer , on so many levels.
this is destined to be one of my new favorites. Thank you Dr. Sweets.
"BAM! Instant enlightenment." lol... best description of that I've ever heard.
Never saw a thug notes before! this is good stuff!
This book changed my life
King in Yellow next maybe?
I would advise against reading past the first act.
Please do "The Jungle" by Upton Sinclair.
Bring back thug notes pls we miss you
Impressively competent host.
Also this book was amazing
a wise man may act a fool, but a fool cannot act wise. good channel.
Love your show !!
The topic of India came eventually up, because hesses father was a missionary in India and Buddhism has its roots in india. Just a short note.
Please do "In a grove" by Ryunoskue Akutagawa next, please :-)
(He was really into Buddhism too ;-) )
do Candide by Voltaire
I can show you the path but you have to learn how to walk the path yourself. Then you will being to truly know it. Experience is the best teacher.
Thanks for enlightening us about this epic story!
How about Roadside Picnic?
I'd love to see that.
Need. More. Thug. Notes. PLEASE.
I loved this! Thank you brotha
I love these so much, I swear idk if it's funnier than it is useful or the other way around but either way keep up the good work
You should do Nausea by Jean-Paul Sartre
OUR CLASS LITERALLY WAS IN NEED OF THIS
Yo....Sparks.....You gotta do A Hero of Our Time by Mikhail Lermontov.
THANK GOD you upload this before my spring break. It's a life saver. =D
I really connected with what you said. I never have thought of this story in that fashion. Thanks brah. :)
Hahahhaha this summary is Gold! Loved it and loved the book. I feel both Sid and hesse would have approved!
I just finished reading this and though I'd see some videos on it. This is brilliant!
just discovered your channel, funniest thing in a long time :D
That bit about enlightenment has to be through experience is true, I found that out after I joined the army.
BAAM! Instant enlightenment man...!!!
I always loved this book!
Do Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy please!!!
I have been waiting for this episode amd I was not disappointed! Keep up the great work Sparky. :)
You guys need to get do a series on art and sociology.
I would love to see an episode on House of Leaves.
+Ian McIvor Oh that would be so heavy!
Ahahah that was brilliant. Greetings from Italy. Keep it up
Great video!
got to wrap it up, broda!!!!! BEST LINE.
I do not think I could have found a better way to start off a Monday morning (even at 1am)
Why did I even bother reading the book when I could've just watched this video? 🤣🤣 This is from 2015?! Absolutely hilarious.
excellent analysis! I loved this book back in the day!
I LOVE this so much. You're so awesome
Straight up enlightened yo ❤
just awesome! love your video, thank you!
Just read this book. FUCKING AMAZING. Quick read too, go read it, everyone go reeead it!
For such complex metaphysical concepts, I have to say is well written. Even if it is the translated version.
Wow. This is.....freakin awesome. Subscribing post haste, and will promote this series to the best of my ability.
You guys at wisecrack must be following my phone or something, first you put on some alien interpreting spring breakers after I set some hot pic from that movie as my wallpaper, and now that I'm reading this book in school, we get sparky sweets to roll on it? Keep doin what you're doing
Do "Gravity's Rainbow" by Thomas Pynchon please
Could you do 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?' sometime soon?
You could also take a look at 'Blade Runner' on Earthling Cinema, looking at the different versions which put the main character in a serious identity crisis