Tamil Nadu: Debate On 'Secularism' Erupts After Governor's Remarks Spark Storm| India Upfront

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 173

  • @Bobamant
    @Bobamant Месяц назад +58

    Remove Secular from constitution asap....

    • @subramanianramanathan5854
      @subramanianramanathan5854 Месяц назад

      What was the peculiar situation prevailed in 1976? Why anchor did not ask DMK panelist?​@@ASMandya

    • @rangavesa2016
      @rangavesa2016 Месяц назад +2

      @@ASMandya Temples built by kings are public properties. It should be with the govt only throught the India. Due to agitation by people in view private irregularities in temples the govts formed relegious boards for administration.

    • @SarathiSanjayVK-u8g
      @SarathiSanjayVK-u8g Месяц назад

      ​@@rangavesa2016you are true but somebody never understand this

    • @NTIS-DHARMIK
      @NTIS-DHARMIK Месяц назад

      Dumbo India is not secular we should be secular

    • @AST7117
      @AST7117 Месяц назад

      Wah.. what wisdom and become pakistan immediately... Cow belt

  • @rajalakshmikarthikeyan1242
    @rajalakshmikarthikeyan1242 Месяц назад +14

    Yes. Totally agreed with hon. Governor.

  • @Virtues128
    @Virtues128 Месяц назад +21

    Hindus make India secular in all its real sense

  • @chandanaparimala5498
    @chandanaparimala5498 Месяц назад +16

    the guy from dmk cannot even pronounce santana properly…and he is commenting on it…what nonsense…

  • @RKVS-04
    @RKVS-04 Месяц назад +31

    Plz all Hindus in India plz wake up wake up wake up sounds for Hinduism

  • @SusantaHazra-dc9xw
    @SusantaHazra-dc9xw Месяц назад +5

    It was never a secular country 🇮🇳🕉️☝️👑

  • @RKVS-04
    @RKVS-04 Месяц назад +13

    BJP government RSS should declare India as Hindu county

    • @IrshadMalik-n3t
      @IrshadMalik-n3t Месяц назад

      Korona

    • @pundarikalucky4059
      @pundarikalucky4059 Месяц назад

      But u must elect indi alliance & congress for freebies & demand bjp to declare hindu rastra

  • @Virtues128
    @Virtues128 Месяц назад +11

    No need of these notorious DMK fellow to misguide and educated wrongly the well -educated public

  • @RKVS-04
    @RKVS-04 Месяц назад +20

    Tamil Nadu Hindus plz don't vote for DMK alliance

    • @aishwaryashanmugam6256
      @aishwaryashanmugam6256 Месяц назад +1

      Bro no matter what these TN PPL will never think ...they only want money and alcohol datsit

    • @rangavesa2016
      @rangavesa2016 Месяц назад

      South India will not vote for parties doing relegious politics.

    • @aishwaryashanmugam6256
      @aishwaryashanmugam6256 Месяц назад

      @@rangavesa2016 ya u guys will only vote for religious parties supporting Christian and muslims ....known fact 😂😂

    • @aishwaryashanmugam6256
      @aishwaryashanmugam6256 Месяц назад

      @@rangavesa2016 yeah they will only vote for parties supporting Christians and muslims cos these are not religions 😂😂😂

    • @gmresports2414
      @gmresports2414 Месяц назад

      ​@@rangavesa2016 south Indian telugu here we gave bjp mandate so u can go to sleep don't count kannadigas and telugus with u dummeel pundas it's an insult. We are not dravidian. We gave bjp 12 and ka gave 25 seats to bjp so don't teach us. U mallu and tamil will sell your mothers to Muslim save your culture from Islam first u people act like weakling

  • @yess10
    @yess10 Месяц назад +2

    One of the best spokespersons in BJP.

  • @RKVS-04
    @RKVS-04 Месяц назад +19

    India should be declare as Hindu country

    • @pundarikalucky4059
      @pundarikalucky4059 Месяц назад

      Yes to achieve hindu raastra, hindu must give vote to indi alliance & congress

    • @AST7117
      @AST7117 Месяц назад

      Sathasivan.. sootha mudikittu poda punda..

  • @akatsongcastronaga7992
    @akatsongcastronaga7992 Месяц назад +2

    Majority rules in democracy, so Hindus have full power and eligible to declare India as Hindustan or Hindu Nation

  • @Das1984P
    @Das1984P Месяц назад +2

    Ya we Hindu Dont want any secularism due to these secularism status other religions r doing whatever they want they r doing

  • @pvseshadri8174
    @pvseshadri8174 Месяц назад +8

    Governor is absolutely correct.The word securialism introduced by Indira Gandhi. originally there was no mention of securialsm in the constitution.Even India as a nation secular that is Sanatan Dharma.The people are misguided by the power hungry politician for their interest

    • @devaeprasad8886
      @devaeprasad8886 Месяц назад

      The constitution defines what is secularism not the fanatics. Dont get disturbed when some one says something. For power people can stoop to any dirtiest level.

  • @rangavesa2016
    @rangavesa2016 Месяц назад +3

    Even without that world the constitution for secularism only. Read the constitution.

  • @-AkhilTej-
    @-AkhilTej- Месяц назад +2

    🎯💎🏆 Great insightful Debate 🏆💎🎯
    लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु
    ( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )

  • @rasamanimsv5416
    @rasamanimsv5416 Месяц назад +2

    Saravanan has his begg bowl in hand and mind. He rants rubbish. An anti.indian advocate.

  • @conectwel1
    @conectwel1 Месяц назад +4

    SARAVANAN proved himself to be a "FOOL".

  • @RKVS-04
    @RKVS-04 Месяц назад +5

    Hindus must be be UNITE & surport BJP Hindu government

  • @ganeshshenoy9636
    @ganeshshenoy9636 Месяц назад +4

    Saravanan is a joker 🤣

  • @narendramarkale7908
    @narendramarkale7908 Месяц назад +6

    Sarvanand is joker par excellence. DMK has many one among them 😅😊

    • @AST7117
      @AST7117 Месяц назад

      India is secular.. and psychologically low self esteemed RSS and BJP cannot change that.

    • @narendramarkale7908
      @narendramarkale7908 Месяц назад

      @@AST7117 those feku left liberals don't understand the meaning of secularism & DMK has many such fools & hypocrites.

  • @NannaBharatha28
    @NannaBharatha28 Месяц назад +3

    What a co incident....?
    I have a carpenter in my new house construction work who is Sarvanan by name.
    Believe me he also behaves, speaks mindlessly and doesn't listen like the above person😂😂😂😂

  • @Sath70
    @Sath70 Месяц назад +3

    Whatever be the nature of sanatana dharma isn’t it “ secular “ to accept it as it is . Why is he not talking about reforms in other religions then .

  • @christinedianebarretto2163
    @christinedianebarretto2163 Месяц назад

    Finally the right questions are being asked .

  • @TST-INDIA651
    @TST-INDIA651 Месяц назад +1

    India and pakistan were born with a single ajends
    Hindu vs muslim
    So we must live with it
    Jai Sri Ram

  • @maheshkumarrao-ji5wb
    @maheshkumarrao-ji5wb Месяц назад +2

    Secular the word only to please one particular community for a vote bank politics.

  • @PP-zr3ih
    @PP-zr3ih Месяц назад +1

    Please implement ucc

  • @sudhashrikhanth4250
    @sudhashrikhanth4250 Месяц назад

    Yes bring the Dr.Ambedkar Constitution. All will accept

  • @dr.venkataramana9607
    @dr.venkataramana9607 Месяц назад +2

    “Secularism “ vital vote bank for pseudosecular parties of Bharat ,who doesn’t have equitable perception/observance/application when it applicable to Hindu communities.🇮🇳🙏🏻✍️

  • @rajafernando2787
    @rajafernando2787 Месяц назад

    Even "Governor" is the British Concept.... and Problematic for decades..... Empowerment of the States and their Parties should rule INDIA, THE UNION OF STATES....

  • @arunkk004
    @arunkk004 Месяц назад

    Amazing to hear this from a person of this level. He himself mentioned secularism arised in the west to separate chrush from the state. That is exactly what is needed in India aswell..
    Laddu, ram mandir can win elections in India.. not supporting any religion. Law should be one and the religion should be kept in door that is the only way for growth and peace in our country.. and that is sucularism. Without that India will be one more Pakistan or afganistan where religion starts dictating the rules

  • @MosesDkhar-cl7og
    @MosesDkhar-cl7og Месяц назад +1

    I just want to know the boundary of india before the British rule,

  • @vijaybalraj6913
    @vijaybalraj6913 Месяц назад

    True...

  • @tseringjurmey1165
    @tseringjurmey1165 Месяц назад

    Secularism removed and now i m treated as shit. No opportunity is given to me because i m son of a driver and i m expected to do the same .

  • @veerakumar8033
    @veerakumar8033 Месяц назад

    Why only single family is ruling TN will others ever get a chance or is it only family of Karunanidhi is entitled to rule .

  • @AST7117
    @AST7117 Месяц назад +1

    Gov Ravi is holding a position which is also foreign... If he is so self righteous.. he should first resign... He is nothing but an RSS stuge

  • @shravansp4408
    @shravansp4408 Месяц назад +1

    what is the meaning of secularism please let me know as per definition of secularism no intervention of state in any religious practice where as all hindu temples are under govt hands what a dumb of this country if you want practice full secularism all churches and masjids also undertaken by govt .

  • @RKVS-04
    @RKVS-04 Месяц назад +1

    DMK S Sarawanan is DMK para anti sanathanam Darman. A Sarawanan can Tamil Nadu don accept Sanathanam Darman but Hindus in Tamil Nadu strictly follow sanathanam Darman & anti DMK

  • @ayurjani1185
    @ayurjani1185 Месяц назад

    Saravanan, VP name is Mr Dhankar. Please pronounce properly

  • @minimilisttothecore6856
    @minimilisttothecore6856 Месяц назад

    Inders gandhi added the word of secular in the constitution.

  • @indranichandra9669
    @indranichandra9669 Месяц назад

    Even these bunch of "secularism fanatics" know Bharatbarsa is a true sarbadharmasamanay place. But for selfish reason they argue.

  • @pmm7268
    @pmm7268 Месяц назад

    Secularism is an idea rejected by the constitution assembly but intriduced by Indira Gadhi. Indira was Rahul 's grandmother. She was not more intelligent than this man. She was a fool. She introduced 'secularism' for her selfish reason. That woman hardly understood what secularism was. Secularism is anti dogmatism, anti sectarisnism. Impose it with definition closer to that of the West. It means rejection of theocentric thoughts & theology, dogma, god centered dictrines and endorsement of openness, human institutions of Dharma. It is rejection of the authority of Bible, Quran, Prophet etc. It is rejection of religious conversions, religious politics, sectarian voting, ... It is a call for openness. Hindutva in that sense secular. The politicians made it to be anti-hindu. So defend secularism. Let us have secular civil laws. Secularism is good for hindutva, endorse the true form of secularism.

  • @hemapatil4859
    @hemapatil4859 Месяц назад

    When the DMK spokesperson says for DMK Sanatan means hierarchy, is that not exactly what they r following in Tamilnadu. first Mr. Karunanidhi ,then Mr. Stalin as CM and no sooner there may be his son taking over who knows.

  • @sklux6147
    @sklux6147 Месяц назад

    To the West, the word Secular remains same then and now. It is the others like in India who altered the definition.
    It is a fact that West realised the impracticality and detriment of the interplay of the religion and statecraft. They had the wisdom to isolate the two for the purpose of common good. Religion may still be allowed in politics to some extent but not in government. They reaped the benefits of being objective rather than being subjective and avoided being conflicted in running the affairs of the government and in delivering good governance to the citizens. For most part Democracy flourished and progressed under the practice of Secular Ideals. That is, without denying the religion unlike in communist governments where religion is barred.
    Therefore for any democracy, particularly for those which are diverse in faith and in traditions, culture etc, the original definition of being Secular is valuable. When the term Secular was incorporated in the preamble of the constitution, in the spirit of above definition, it is valid.
    Secularism; used elsewhere to mean the equality of all religions in terms of rights and freedom becomes a redundant concept because it is embedded in the constitution under the Right to Religion and Equality. Interpreting and understanding Secularism as Equality Of Religion is therefore quite different from the original notion and intent while the term Secular was incorporated in the preamble of the Constitution.
    So be it. They are two similar sounding words and are quite different from eachother in the sense of the meaning derived from them.
    Therefore it is quite logical that the term Secular, as meant in the West, is indeed quite valuable and appropriate in a Democracy.
    Let noble thoughts come from all sides.
    Satyameva Jayate ✌️
    Jai Hind 🫡

  • @dr.rajadurairajadurai1484
    @dr.rajadurairajadurai1484 Месяц назад

    Governor view the amount to contempt for the supreme court?

  • @dsrinath1965
    @dsrinath1965 Месяц назад

    enough...

  • @RNIIVIIIXVIIIV
    @RNIIVIIIXVIIIV Месяц назад

    Secularism is important and good, right? 🇮🇳

  • @kavitakumbhakar7220
    @kavitakumbhakar7220 Месяц назад +2

    It was added by Indira through 42nd constitutional amendment act 1976, it should be repealed .

  • @devaeprasad8886
    @devaeprasad8886 Месяц назад

    India is going to doom by these fanatics, cannot issues be solved by amicable solutions and agreements if found hurting each others. With great sacrifice we got independence and are struggling for unity.

  • @ampandit9473
    @ampandit9473 Месяц назад

    DMK spokes person : "....Let me finish this , let me finish this ....."
    *Does
    not finish his point uptill 12 minutes !!!😅

  • @vtr756
    @vtr756 Месяц назад

    The governor is a stupid fellow, having failed repeatedly in all his attempts to destabilse TN, he is now taking one weapon or another as per the diktats of delhi bosses.
    He is becoming more of a joker in TN.

  • @balajik6381
    @balajik6381 Месяц назад +4

    He must be booked for violating constitutional breach immediately

    • @TST-INDIA651
      @TST-INDIA651 Месяц назад

      Who Mr sudalai 😅 ask him to pronounce the word secular

  • @shanthadevi2687
    @shanthadevi2687 Месяц назад

    Fool governor in tn.

  • @umashankarh.u6904
    @umashankarh.u6904 Месяц назад

    Sir leave this basturd DMK Man

  • @ZenmaiZamurai-r3l
    @ZenmaiZamurai-r3l Месяц назад +2

    How about getting rid of casteism first?

  • @ganeshnb-s5g
    @ganeshnb-s5g Месяц назад

    What is this man talking ?

  • @PD20244
    @PD20244 Месяц назад +1

    Real indian will not utter such words. May be he was born and brought up in Pakistan.

  • @Pradeep11159
    @Pradeep11159 Месяц назад

    godi media bo 1

  • @rajasathyanarayanan6648
    @rajasathyanarayanan6648 Месяц назад

    First remove this anchor

  • @ImranKhan-ce9ef
    @ImranKhan-ce9ef Месяц назад

    🗽

  • @Pradeep11159
    @Pradeep11159 Месяц назад +1

    godi media no 1

  • @ganeshnb-s5g
    @ganeshnb-s5g Месяц назад

    😂😂😂😂😂

  • @seenusvasu4408
    @seenusvasu4408 Месяц назад

    Talk about gainful employment MSP for farmers reduction in petrol diesel lpg price, preindependance mogal period mohanjodara harappa things you throw now.ECI will not ECI allways.also talk about hasina BD ranil SL to learn lesson by appropriate persons.

  • @AST7117
    @AST7117 Месяц назад +1

    Pranesh Roy keeps on ranting about "before Nehru before Nehru"... Come to the present day you fool !!! Today the constitution has the word Secular... If you feel threatened... Pass an amendment and remove it if you have the guts !!!

    • @venkatraman7396
      @venkatraman7396 Месяц назад

      So Saravanan's rants soulnd music to your ears? There is no one word of reason in Saranvana's ad hominem attack.

    • @AST7117
      @AST7117 Месяц назад

      @@venkatraman7396 Yes Mr. Venkat... It is music to my ears. India is secular.. and psychologically in secular RSS and BJP cannot change that.

  • @panneerselvaml7662
    @panneerselvaml7662 Месяц назад +1

    RN.Ravi , an IPS officer and now Governor forgets the history shamefully that before 1947 , there's NO India!!!

    • @ravikumarbs7298
      @ravikumarbs7298 Месяц назад +1

      BJP bootlicker RN Ravi is a Bihari from patna - he is employed by his political bosses to make TN into UP and Bihar...............

  • @MohammedJaweed-jw3xv
    @MohammedJaweed-jw3xv Месяц назад

    These sanghis often misquote and often misguide.

    • @Npushpal
      @Npushpal Месяц назад

      Pakistani barking

    • @nellorecharan3587
      @nellorecharan3587 Месяц назад +2

      Do you have any proof to say or simply showcasing your commenting skills.

    • @yess10
      @yess10 Месяц назад +1

      DMK was notorious in misquoting.

  • @AST7117
    @AST7117 Месяц назад

    Times Now ... Along with cow urine do you eat cow dung also ??

    • @shushmithabai
      @shushmithabai Месяц назад

      Just like you eat sheep d Ung and sheep Ur! Ne like Jesus??😂😂