Not in the MWATGG fandom but agreed on the critique, these designs sorta feel like the ppg reboot and mlp G5, as in, way too bland and sorta, round?. Also, don't beat yerself up about your voice, my friend is also 13 and sounds way deeper than that, while people sometimes mistake me for a 12 yr old when in uniform :P
im going to be honest i dont really like this video, but i cant fully explain why I dont like a lot of the redesigns that much either but the way they were 'critisized' in the video feels kind of immature and not very thought out, like its more biased opinions & (admittedly kind of unfunny) memes rather than actual thought out criticism based on character design knowledge no ill will intended though, i just figured genuine feedback would be more wanted/helpful than anything else and hey maybe im wrong and its just for a different demographic than me 🤷
Make sure to like, comment, and subscribe! ----------------------------------- Here is the full video on my thoughts about the redesigns! I am aware that “Syllv” already did one and I address that in the video. This video took a very long time to make and so I hope you like it a lot, despite the basic editing. Here’s time stamps for all the sections in case if you really like one: Intro: 0:00 Milky Way: 1:02 Venus: 2:21 (the background was taken from a youtuber apology video lmao) Mars: 3:20 Jupiter: 4:33 Pluto: 5:42 Mercury: 6:38 Neptune: 7:27 Uranus: 8:09 The Moon: 9:01 Artstyle: 9:58 Reason why the artstyle is bad 1: 10:52 Reason why the artstyle is bad 2: 11:45 Overall thoughts: 12:46 Outro: 13:43 Fun fact: you can actually see my editing and visual style evolve as the video goes on! Also I hope my voice doesn’t bother you at all, I never liked how deep it sounded (im 13) so I hope you can look past that This video was a lot of fun to make :)
I really really really loathe the Milky Way and the galaxy girls characters’s redesigns it looks ultimate creepy but I prefer the original design MWGG characters!
For me there are aspects of the new designs that I like, but there are a lot of aspects of them that I don't like. There's something that I've noticed about newer designs compared to Old designs in any type of media, is that the new designs are usually worse than the older designs rather than being better. Which makes me sad. For me I would much rather having the new designs be better than the old ones rather than worse, which is the intention of redesigns in the first place, but most of the time they make them worse or not as good as the older ones. Sorry if I repeated myself. I just want to share my input
Well those 200 different colors matched her upbeat personality better in my opinion. Because her original bio said “A true space cadet, Mars is from another planet!! Green skin and hair, a pair of antennae and quite an….uh……INTERESTING….fashion sense. This Martian sees the universe in a different light than every one else, and expresses her unusual, eclectic thoughts through her art. Painting, sculpture, collage, you name it!! And you’ve never seen anything like it before, and certainly never will again! Mars may be be the weirdest girl in the galaxy, but she is by far the most creative.” And her personality was described as “kooky, quirky, silly, slightly ditzy, giggly” i think that the clashing colors were intentional to help a viewer better understand what her personality was by just looking at her, by making her fashion sense feel more “out of this world” but thats just my own opinion.
Saturns redesign was good however her rings are gone now and I was pretty upset about it.
it doesnt look like my little pony at all. it looks like a mixture of dc super hero girls and power puff girls
Not in the MWATGG fandom but agreed on the critique, these designs sorta feel like the ppg reboot and mlp G5, as in, way too bland and sorta, round?. Also, don't beat yerself up about your voice, my friend is also 13 and sounds way deeper than that, while people sometimes mistake me for a 12 yr old when in uniform :P
HAHAHAHAHAAH
THIS VIDEO'S A TOTAL BANGER BRO
im going to be honest i dont really like this video, but i cant fully explain why
I dont like a lot of the redesigns that much either but the way they were 'critisized' in the video feels kind of immature and not very thought out, like its more biased opinions & (admittedly kind of unfunny) memes rather than actual thought out criticism based on character design knowledge
no ill will intended though, i just figured genuine feedback would be more wanted/helpful than anything else
and hey maybe im wrong and its just for a different demographic than me 🤷
let’s agree to disagree.
@DennisFinch-gj7be HAHAHAHAHA
@@scribblecloud also bro im 13 of course its gonna be immature you expect too much smh
the sun was the only one that looked better 😭
Yes thats why I didnt make fun of her
Make sure to like, comment, and subscribe!
-----------------------------------
Here is the full video on my thoughts about the redesigns!
I am aware that “Syllv” already did one and I address that in the video.
This video took a very long time to make and so I hope you like it a lot, despite the basic editing.
Here’s time stamps for all the sections in case if you really like one:
Intro: 0:00
Milky Way: 1:02
Venus: 2:21 (the background was taken from a youtuber apology video lmao)
Mars: 3:20
Jupiter: 4:33
Pluto: 5:42
Mercury: 6:38
Neptune: 7:27
Uranus: 8:09
The Moon: 9:01
Artstyle: 9:58
Reason why the artstyle is bad 1: 10:52
Reason why the artstyle is bad 2: 11:45
Overall thoughts: 12:46
Outro: 13:43
Fun fact: you can actually see my editing and visual style evolve as the video goes on!
Also I hope my voice doesn’t bother you at all, I never liked how deep it sounded (im 13) so I hope you can look past that
This video was a lot of fun to make :)
Can you talk about my MWGG OC character, Blood Moon?
@@antoniolopez-leonproductio9032 no i dont even know who that is
Very well made video!
I really really really loathe the Milky Way and the galaxy girls characters’s redesigns it looks ultimate creepy but I prefer the original design MWGG characters!
why are all your videos age restricted
YOOOO THIS IS SO PEAK THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR GIVIJG ME A CHSNCE 😎😎😎😎😎
And to everyone THIS VIDEO IS VERY VERY GOOD. watch it
Very nice video! :)
@@Natalie_Milana7 thank you
This video is so entertaining
Keep up my boy
Do you guys actually like this video or is it bad and a waste of time
For me there are aspects of the new designs that I like, but there are a lot of aspects of them that I don't like.
There's something that I've noticed about newer designs compared to Old designs in any type of media, is that the new designs are usually worse than the older designs rather than being better. Which makes me sad.
For me I would much rather having the new designs be better than the old ones rather than worse, which is the intention of redesigns in the first place, but most of the time they make them worse or not as good as the older ones.
Sorry if I repeated myself. I just want to share my input
BANGER VID O YA
Ta bueno we/Good video man
LMAO this is so funny holy peak /gen
@@greenphony thank you
3:45 I think I prefer a boring outfit than 200 different, incompatible, intense colors
Well those 200 different colors matched her upbeat personality better in my opinion. Because her original bio said “A true space cadet, Mars is from another planet!! Green skin and hair, a pair of antennae and quite an….uh……INTERESTING….fashion sense. This Martian sees the universe in a different light than every one else, and expresses her unusual, eclectic thoughts through her art. Painting, sculpture, collage, you name it!! And you’ve never seen anything like it before, and certainly never will again! Mars may be be the weirdest girl in the galaxy, but she is by far the most creative.” And her personality was described as “kooky, quirky, silly, slightly ditzy, giggly” i think that the clashing colors were intentional to help a viewer better understand what her personality was by just looking at her, by making her fashion sense feel more “out of this world” but thats just my own opinion.
@@GoGoRocket23 I must admit that this logic makes sense, I am probably prejudiced because I prefer more minimalist designs...
@@unowakot3303 design racism