Kirsten jakobsen Although my former partner is still alive we are no longer a couple and at first hearing Lou Reed and some other albums we'd grooved to was heart- breaking ,over time it got better and now I have to smile remembering the great times we had, some still make me cry but Lou can do that to me and it's always been the case. I hope you are/will be at the stage where the joy you remember heavily outweighs the sorrow. jules
the Berlin album is amazing. It's one album that can make me smile one day, yet depress the hell out of me the next. Only great music can do that. Lou was incredible.
+Tom Maynard -- No kidding. I had listened to this album about 20 times, until one night I sat outside, with a bottle of bourbon, and listened through the whole album. By the end, I was having a nervous breakdown, bawling my head off, waking the family and neighbors. I almost went to a psych ward that night, but I didn't, and I was fine the next day. I can only wonder what making this album did to Lou Reed and producer Bob Ezrin. It sounds so complicated, stressful, and expensive.
This album cures me, as most of my depression consists on hiding from hard realities and not dealing with them, I walk without me and this album makes me a whole being, who I am, the same way that Sarabande by Ingmar Bergman does, based on Sarabande by Bach.
From Transformer to Berlin is the best one two punch in anyone's career. To think Lou was using alot of chemicals...the work still shines through...still the same man
Berlin is lou reeds masterpiece,the fact it tells such a disastrous story so beautifully is unbelievable. As Martin Scorsese said, lou reed spoke the language of people with nothing. He will be remembered for a long time
The Berlin album is such a masterpiece. It helds me captive from start to finish. To me it always felt like a film and this particular track would be the one over which the credits would roll IF it was a film. The whole album builds up so much tension which is then released with this song. This is how I personally always experienced it.
😅j'ai decouvert ce disque en 1973, alors que je vivais dans une petite chambre de bonne à Paris. Cette oeuvre magistrale me plongeait dans une forme d'extase et de melancolie. Je l'écoute toujours avec le même ravissement.
Staring at my picture book She looks like Mary, Queen of Scots She seemed very regal to me Just goes to show how wrong you can be I'm gonna stop wastin' my time Somebody else would have broken both of her arms Sad song, Sad song, Sad song, Sad song My castle, kids and home I thought she was Mary, Queen of Scots I tried so very hard Shows just how wrong you can be I'm gonna stop wasting time Somebody else would have broken both of her arms Sad song, Sad song, Sad song, Sad song
Bob Ezrin produced this and you can hear in the arpeggios the influence it had on his later work Pink Floyd's The Wall, particularly the track 'Comfortably Numb'
You can also hear the 'Bob Ezrin' effect on his work with Alice Cooper and Kiss' Destroyer here on this Lou Reed record. Of course Wagner and Hunter joined Cooper's band for Welcome to My Nightmare.
+Peter -- Of course, you're right. The string arpeggios are just different enough to avoid any plagarism case, but most likely, Bob Ezrin was merely plagarizing himself. Roger Waters and David Gilmour get the songwriting credits, and Michael Kamen is credited with the orchestral arrangements, but this is one case in which Bob Ezrin clearly had a hand in. From what I've read, Ezrin works as hard as the artists he produces, and he's a very "hands-on" producer, who expects to be treated as equal to the artist. (He claims he "re-wrote" _The Wall_ overnight. Hmm.) You don't hire a guy like Ezrin just to add a lick and a polish. Funny thing is, after Ezrin imitated "Sad Song" for "Comfortably Numb", Roger Waters and Michael Kamen imitated "Comfortably Numb" for the song "The Final Cut".
this shit makes me tear up late at night in my room just like it did when i was in fucking highschool, beautiful music is timeless. rest in peace Lou Reed he lives on through his music, like all great artists who have died
Sgt. Pepper ni si quiera se acerca en concepto, musica y estilo a Berlín. El primero es una pomposidad, el segundo, la desnudez del alma frente al infierno.
@@reverendayglow Perfectly correct, if slightly archaic, English. "Credit" as in "believe". (See "incredulous" and the translation of "believe" in at least Italian and French. See also Mark E Smith's lyrics to Glitter Freeze)
Berlin's 50th birthday is coming up and I would love to redo it with my take, but I would never know where to begin. It almost seems like it would be sacrilegious. There's only about 10 pieces of musical art that Goosebump me ... This is definitely at the top, I can barely get through the first 5 minutes watching the performance in New York without tearing up immediately. Lou's been along with me all my life and will be missed as well as so many other brilliant artists. Sad song.....
Not fair to hear it out of context is such a great remark. I came to these comments to hear people's perspectives on this tune in particular, but we need perspective of the album as a whole to appreciate how we got to this tone. Good man Lou
I can't listen to Lou Reed without thinking about my dad anymore. Born in the same month and passed in the same year. RIP to both my dad and Lou Reed. 2/14 marks four years since my dad's passing. I may just listen to Lou Reed that day. Fuck. Sorry. :(
Shakey Greene sorry for your loss. I think of my dad when I hear Lou Reed too. my dad passed away at 47 when I was 16 in jan '05. my dad loved Lou Reed. we got to see Lou put his hands into cement down in Hollywood for the hall of fame and watched him perform that day. I remember because I ended up with a bad headache through the concert but enjoyed the concert and didn't tell my dad about the headache because I knew he loved his music too much. on new year 2000 my dad decided we'd all play our favorite songs to celebrate new years and his #1 was egg cream! haha. my aunt left me with his cds so I have a bunch I haven't even listened to yet.
I had to listen to the original again after watching the stream of the 2006 live version at St Ann's Warehouse that Julian Schnabel made into a movie - streaming live on RUclips until November 29th. The original is a masterpiece, harrowing and wonderful at the same time. I'd go so far as to say that Berlin will be remembered as opera, it's like a classical Greek tragedy, complete with chorus - Sad Song is monumental. I think Berlin is in the top 3 of all time great albums.
2 years later, I bet it still hurts. Recent anniversary of my dad, 2020, from 26 years ago. It still hurts. Just occasionally & briefly nowadays.. Love to your mom. Love to you. I wish that ending could go on for hours. Sad Song. He said it. Hope you have found happiness, Landy.x
Sorry, Dark in most places. As is Berlin. Dark, disturbing and unsettling. A place where Communism was removed and Socialism is present. But nobody knows as all living there have been robbed of initiative and don't know how to work. True story. So the LP does fit in.
Bed was so damn sad. I'm glad this song made up and ended on there's hope in the end kind of song to end the Berlin Album. Lou is a genius songwriter. Unbelievable talent he had. A song about a couple he either knew or heard about. This song was a true story. Absolutely sad. Love this beautiful hope kind of song.
It's not hopeful, though. Not to me, anyways. It's mocking that. Listen to the lyrics. I think it's very sardonic. He's mocking the idea of people "just getting over stuff" like the abusive husband. Put on a happy face! Sad song!
This is the album I've had to buy the most. Had people borrow it and never got it back. Buy again. Preach to someone else. Borrow. Not get it back, rinse and repeat. Although annoying it's also admirable as they blatantly either lie about not being able to find it or just vanish from your life with a treasured possession. One guy was extolling the virtues of Roger Waters concept albums, it's like a story... I knew if he borrowed it I wouldn't get it back but fuck it I thought... a story... This is a film for the ears... and it's Fucked up and beautiful... put your Roger Waters in the bin you ain't gonna need them no more and you will see what story albums truly are. Don't know what you will garner from reading this? Either don't lend Berlin out or lend it out and save a soul for the price of it or jesus why have I read this bloody comment? Fin
It's as capable of changing someones life as listening to Beethoven or standing in front of a Matisse or a Rothko - art from the soul that enters the soul. Berlin manages to be raw without being rough - it really is a modern version of a classical tragedy. When you gift a work like this to someone, it will change them if they are open to it. I introduced Berlin to a good friend, and he ended up changing his surname to Alaska!
After first discovering Lou and the Velvets I was left with solo Lou to pursue in the early mid-Seventies. This was the one album of his I played over and over, and it still sounds superb all these decades later. I have never found it depressing in spite of its content, for me it's just too rich for that.
Mon album préféré de Lou Reed, celui de l'époque où on était à Berlin... Quelle époque !! Et quel bonheur... Que tous les jeunes l'écoutent, et se le disent... Moi je ne serai plus là...
What drove her to suicide, I mean. Like I have very little faith this dude is going to be better going forward. I still think the song is incredible and powerful.
I've always found this song throw away and complex. Lou Reed is so conversational I find. Like having an intimate chat with a stranger at a bar. Was he influenced by Chuck Berry I always wonder? Berry had much the same technique..."Meanwhile I was thinking...". I listened to this song endlessly when I split up with my wife. He sets you up "I'm gonna stop wasting my time". And then "Somebody else would have broken both of her arms" is so grimly true and funny.
He's subverting that sort of farty 'optimistic' brass band musical trope. I agree that this subversion is very amusing. It's also amusing how so many people take the 'happy' tone here at face value and think this thing is a 'hopeful' refuting of the previous tracks.
maybe the best reed solo song,is an epic progression and arrangements the shape of the loop is awesome.i said to lou that i heard this song 200 times in a row(in gran rex theatre-argentina)
I do love the fact that he thinks anyone else would have broken BOTH of her arms. Probably my favourite song about domestic violence. From an album with a couple of contenders..
It’s SO dark. From the POV of an abuser both wistfully remembering and making excuses for himself at the same time, delivery that becomes more and more emotionless and backed by almost triumphant music. It’s one of a kind.
Lou ironically name checking Mary Queen Of Scots. I wonder if he knew the parallels with his Berlin to her own in this dramatic story? Guess so. Genius.
Sorry, Dark in most places and not beautiful. Dark, disturbing and unsettling. A place where Communism was removed and Socialism is present. But nobody knows as all living there have been robbed of initiative and don't know how to work. Public transportation is a mess. You wait for an hour for a menu at a restaurant while the waitresses smoke cigarettes and look uninterested. Citizens are non-responsive until you give them something extra...True story. So the LP does fit in.
As much as I appreciate the live version there has to be acknowlegement for technical stuff and, even so, no harm done to this or even the whole of it. It is, as said elsewhere, brilliant and, in old words, who can and does write and use words as in this story nowadays, 2019?????? I can not let this LP go!!!!
To be honest, and as a kid in the 1970s I’d give anything a listen - Maybe one of the weirdest albums. I mean, I’m just responding to the comment one of the best albums. I did come around to enjoying it - still very weird.
Ho passato,i migliori anni della mia esistenza,assieme; alla soavità, della musica di Lou..ma anke Berlin è un capolavoro ..luigi.b ❤️ R.i.p. grande Lou!!!
La pieza se llama "Canción Triste" pero de principio a fin suena como alegre, optimista, casi como si de una moderna composición alegro de Beethoven se tratase. ¡Qué extraño...! ¿Verdad? Jim parece sentir nostalgia mirando esas fotos, pero ante todo siente alegría, libertad, insensibilidad ("voy a dejar de perder el tiempo (mortificándome), alguien más también le hubiera roto sus brazos"), en vez de una agonizante tristeza por el suicidio de su supuestamente "amada" Caroline. Sabes que esta es una de las canciones más "siniestras" compuestas por Lou Reed cuando la entiendes, aunque ante todo, una declaración sincera y sumamente pesimista (en la muerte se suele hacer un antes y un después para olvidar y uno seguir viviendo "mejor", aunque esto a veces no es más que una excusa egoísta para enterrar a alguien y pasar página). El desinterés de Reed a lo largo de la pieza ("Sad Song... Sad Song..."), ese compás tan fino y calmado, como si de un hallazgo de vida se tratase, le dan un toque final muy simbólico y oscuro. Es genial que consiga ese efecto. A simple vista, uno puede fácilmente creer que en efecto es una canción triste, pero en realidad resulta ser un juego de palabras. Un gran cierre para Berlín, un álbum que llega a sentirse como una adaptación de alguna historia de William Burroughs. Es algo complicado de digerir, pero si te dejas llevar lo disfrutas mejor.
after i have listened to lou reed's songs i feel and see how bad of music these days. He knew what music is and singers and musicians must learn form his works
+Daniel -- Or so the story goes. Lou Reed said he hated Dolby units, and click tracks. He said "I like leakage" (one loud track "bleeding" onto another), and "I don't like Lou Reed albums. I like Velvet Underground albums." But our dearly-departed Lou did like to lie to journalists, A LOT. You can tell this album was made with utmost care for sound quality.
Saw Lou perform for 5 hours straight -- no break -- in 1979, SF. Best concert ever!
In my opinion this is Lou Reed's masterpiece. Absolutely.
❤
There is many masterpieces of Lou Reed
❤
Yr opinion is gold
Absolutely, with Waves of Fear following
Great album, sadly my husband of 40 years is't here anymore. We have more than 20 albums of lou and not a single one is bad. RIP ❤️Lasse and RIP ❤️Lou
Kirsten jakobsen Although my former partner is still alive we are no longer a couple and at first hearing Lou Reed and some other albums we'd grooved to was heart- breaking ,over time it got better and now I have to smile remembering the great times we had, some still make me cry but Lou can do that to me and it's always been the case. I hope you are/will be at the stage where the joy you remember heavily outweighs the sorrow. jules
I send you my love 💖
the Berlin album is amazing. It's one album that can make me smile one day, yet depress the hell out of me the next. Only great music can do that. Lou was incredible.
+Tom Maynard -- No kidding. I had listened to this album about 20 times, until one night I sat outside, with a bottle of bourbon, and listened through the whole album. By the end, I was having a nervous breakdown, bawling my head off, waking the family and neighbors. I almost went to a psych ward that night, but I didn't, and I was fine the next day. I can only wonder what making this album did to Lou Reed and producer Bob Ezrin. It sounds so complicated, stressful, and expensive.
check out Trout Mask Replica by Beefheart for a similar experience. But hide the razors first. Let me know.
try Smile
#moodstabilizers
This album cures me, as most of my depression consists on hiding from hard realities and not dealing with them, I walk without me and this album makes me a whole being, who I am, the same way that Sarabande by Ingmar Bergman does, based on Sarabande by Bach.
There is beauty in Melancholy
Didn't Joni Mitchell sing something like that?
the best lou reed album
I'm inclined to agree, certainly his best non commercial en devour.
Undecided between Berlin and Magic and Loss.
Soooo good
@@sanborns Endeavor not en devour.
Transformer ranks pretty high as well in my humble opinion:)
One day this song will be remembered by the children of the future as one of the greatest of all time
From Transformer to Berlin is the best one two punch in anyone's career. To think Lou was using alot of chemicals...the work still shines through...still the same man
Berlin is lou reeds masterpiece,the fact it tells such a disastrous story so beautifully is unbelievable.
As Martin Scorsese said, lou reed spoke the language of people with nothing.
He will be remembered for a long time
He will be remembered forever.
Berlin is a beautiful great album Lou Reed is vero great writing the word and the music of this concept album. He is the best n.1❤
The Berlin album is such a masterpiece. It helds me captive from start to finish. To me it always felt like a film and this particular track would be the one over which the credits would roll IF it was a film. The whole album builds up so much tension which is then released with this song. This is how I personally always experienced it.
you nailed it @ThreeWishesFairy
BERLIN! Easily one of the best records of the 70s
The best
Jings, it's one of the best albums of all time.
@@privatetartanarmy It is! Lou's magnum-opus! ♥
How did I just discover this one when I had all his other stuff? Amazing. Berlin is what I’d like to have listened to a while ago!💯🤙
No one like Lou. So spiritual, high and low, like looking back at life in a picture book. Good night.
😅j'ai decouvert ce disque en 1973, alors que je vivais dans une petite chambre de bonne à Paris. Cette oeuvre magistrale me plongeait dans une forme d'extase et de melancolie. Je l'écoute toujours avec le même ravissement.
Goosebumps and tears. Every time.
Staring at my picture book
She looks like Mary, Queen of Scots
She seemed very regal to me
Just goes to show how wrong you can be
I'm gonna stop wastin' my time
Somebody else would have broken both of her arms
Sad song, Sad song, Sad song, Sad song
My castle, kids and home
I thought she was Mary, Queen of Scots
I tried so very hard
Shows just how wrong you can be
I'm gonna stop wasting time
Somebody else would have broken both of her arms
Sad song, Sad song, Sad song, Sad song
O
majestic. reed's masterpiece album.
This is beautiful... How can you not like this..awesme !! RIP Lou ... Love You
Bob Ezrin produced this and you can hear in the arpeggios the influence it had on his later work Pink Floyd's The Wall, particularly the track 'Comfortably Numb'
You can also hear the 'Bob Ezrin' effect on his work with Alice Cooper and Kiss' Destroyer here on this Lou Reed record.
Of course Wagner and Hunter joined Cooper's band for Welcome to My Nightmare.
+Peter -- Of course, you're right. The string arpeggios are just different enough to avoid any plagarism case, but most likely, Bob Ezrin was merely plagarizing himself. Roger Waters and David Gilmour get the songwriting credits, and Michael Kamen is credited with the orchestral arrangements, but this is one case in which Bob Ezrin clearly had a hand in.
From what I've read, Ezrin works as hard as the artists he produces, and he's a very "hands-on" producer, who expects to be treated as equal to the artist. (He claims he "re-wrote" _The Wall_ overnight. Hmm.) You don't hire a guy like Ezrin just to add a lick and a polish.
Funny thing is, after Ezrin imitated "Sad Song" for "Comfortably Numb", Roger Waters and Michael Kamen imitated "Comfortably Numb" for the song "The Final Cut".
The orchestration on Alice Cooper's "Only women bleed" definitely came from this. Especially the guitar fills at the end.
@@kostasxrysogelos yes!
Absolutely and one of the greatest producers of all time if not the greatest
this shit makes me tear up late at night in my room just like it did when i was in fucking highschool, beautiful music is timeless. rest in peace Lou Reed he lives on through his music, like all great artists who have died
Masterpiece
Amen brother
Lou Reed was a great singer and Yes I loved his music..."I´m waiting for my man", "Nobody but you" ....❤❤❤ ...
lou reed the complete artist
Complete A*****e !!
The Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band of depression.
Sgt. Pepper ni si quiera se acerca en concepto, musica y estilo a Berlín.
El primero es una pomposidad, el segundo, la desnudez del alma frente al infierno.
@@noctourniquet_ that’s why Simon Jager said it was the Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band “OF DEPRESSION”.
I belly laughed when I read your comment. I love Lou and this song, but I also loved your comment here.
Not a Beatles fan anymore. But I love Lou more every time I play an album, especially this one.
I will never listen to that horrible Beatles album again but I'll listen to sweet Lou's "Berlin" for the rest of my life
I can't get enough of this song
The twin guitars go so well with the orchestra on the crescendos. Lou’s greatest album, for my money.
Amazing song. I'm always so disappointed when it ends! Why can't it go on a little bit longer!!
I love Lou.
great song for a "Sad Song"
I remember a quote from Lou about this album...'one day it will find it's place in the Sun'
An absolute masterpiece! You may not credit this, but my late Mom - march 1929/february 2016 - loved listening to Lou Reed!
credit this?
@@reverendayglow
Perfectly correct, if slightly archaic, English.
"Credit" as in "believe". (See "incredulous" and the translation of "believe" in at least Italian and French. See also Mark E Smith's lyrics to Glitter Freeze)
Berlin's 50th birthday is coming up and I would love to redo it with my take, but I would never know where to begin. It almost seems like it would be sacrilegious. There's only about 10 pieces of musical art that Goosebump me ... This is definitely at the top, I can barely get through the first 5 minutes watching the performance in New York without tearing up immediately. Lou's been along with me all my life and will be missed as well as so many other brilliant artists. Sad song.....
Masterpiece.
this just blows me away as it did at the time it came out, not fair to hear it out of context but. Lou always believed in this album, so did I
Not fair to hear it out of context is such a great remark. I came to these comments to hear people's perspectives on this tune in particular, but we need perspective of the album as a whole to appreciate how we got to this tone. Good man Lou
I can't listen to Lou Reed without thinking about my dad anymore. Born in the same month and passed in the same year. RIP to both my dad and Lou Reed. 2/14 marks four years since my dad's passing. I may just listen to Lou Reed that day. Fuck. Sorry. :(
Shakey Greene sorry for your loss. I think of my dad when I hear Lou Reed too. my dad passed away at 47 when I was 16 in jan '05. my dad loved Lou Reed. we got to see Lou put his hands into cement down in Hollywood for the hall of fame and watched him perform that day. I remember because I ended up with a bad headache through the concert but enjoyed the concert and didn't tell my dad about the headache because I knew he loved his music too much. on new year 2000 my dad decided we'd all play our favorite songs to celebrate new years and his #1 was egg cream! haha. my aunt left me with his cds so I have a bunch I haven't even listened to yet.
i love you, i hope things will be okay for you, hang in there please
Take care. Im sure smwer hes smilin and proud seeing u listenin to lou
It’s ok
what an epic "Sad song" chorus
I had to listen to the original again after watching the stream of the 2006 live version at St Ann's Warehouse that Julian Schnabel made into a movie - streaming live on RUclips until November 29th.
The original is a masterpiece, harrowing and wonderful at the same time.
I'd go so far as to say that Berlin will be remembered as opera, it's like a classical Greek tragedy, complete with chorus - Sad Song is monumental.
I think Berlin is in the top 3 of all time great albums.
call it as it is .. is always a relief
An Incredible song
Thx Lou Reed been going thru it sense my mom passed 9 months ago much love to anyone feeling like there not worth it you are u are we are
2 years later, I bet it still hurts. Recent anniversary of my dad, 2020, from 26 years ago. It still hurts. Just occasionally & briefly nowadays.. Love to your mom. Love to you. I wish that ending could go on for hours. Sad Song. He said it. Hope you have found happiness, Landy.x
Beautiful.
The most important concept album ever made.make a work so pretentious and with this perfect result is something to admire.Reed was a genius artist
Having been often in Berlin in the 80’s….this album has the exact atmosphere from how it once was over there, very special……
Lou Reed has always been one of my favotites. And here we go again, great music. - jon fisher
Beautiful song the whole record is beautiful yet dark in places 💙👌🏻
Sorry, Dark in most places. As is Berlin. Dark, disturbing and unsettling. A place where Communism was removed and Socialism is present. But nobody knows as all living there
have been robbed of initiative and don't know how to work. True story. So the LP does fit in.
this gracious song makes me really sad! wonderful song!
Berlin is a masterpiece!
great song, great album
Bed was so damn sad. I'm glad this song made up and ended on there's hope in the end kind of song to end the Berlin Album. Lou is a genius songwriter. Unbelievable talent he had.
A song about a couple he either knew or heard about. This song was a true story. Absolutely sad. Love this beautiful hope kind of song.
It's not hopeful, though. Not to me, anyways. It's mocking that. Listen to the lyrics. I think it's very sardonic. He's mocking the idea of people "just getting over stuff" like the abusive husband.
Put on a happy face! Sad song!
Great album.
Such beautiful music on this and so easilly, it seems, well written. Can't let it go and respect to all involved in the production. Regards L.R.
The melody announces the future
This is the album I've had to buy the most. Had people borrow it and never got it back. Buy again. Preach to someone else. Borrow. Not get it back, rinse and repeat. Although annoying it's also admirable as they blatantly either lie about not being able to find it or just vanish from your life with a treasured possession. One guy was extolling the virtues of Roger Waters concept albums, it's like a story... I knew if he borrowed it I wouldn't get it back but fuck it I thought... a story... This is a film for the ears... and it's Fucked up and beautiful... put your Roger Waters in the bin you ain't gonna need them no more and you will see what story albums truly are. Don't know what you will garner from reading this? Either don't lend Berlin out or lend it out and save a soul for the price of it or jesus why have I read this bloody comment? Fin
It's as capable of changing someones life as listening to Beethoven or standing in front of a Matisse or a Rothko - art from the soul that enters the soul. Berlin manages to be raw without being rough - it really is a modern version of a classical tragedy.
When you gift a work like this to someone, it will change them if they are open to it. I introduced Berlin to a good friend, and he ended up changing his surname to Alaska!
Happy 2020 everyone! Life goes on.
REED deserves an epiphone signature guitar
,perhaps transformer-berlin are the two most iconic photos with an epi guitar on the album cover
Sad Song mi fa venire la pelle d d'oca, Fantastica
Awesome..best ever song IMO
Sad song is a Great song. Made by Lou Reed. He was a madter too. Very important for mr. ❤ Yesh, I loved his music. - jon fisher
After first discovering Lou and the Velvets I was left with solo Lou to pursue in the early mid-Seventies. This was the one album of his I played over and over, and it still sounds superb all these decades later. I have never found it depressing in spite of its content, for me it's just too rich for that.
It always cheers me up tbh. I guess it's the catharsis and black humor as well as the gorgeous music.
Sad (best) song.
lou reed spoke the language of people with nothing. so true !
Mon album préféré de Lou Reed, celui de l'époque où on était à Berlin... Quelle époque !! Et quel bonheur... Que tous les jeunes l'écoutent, et se le disent... Moi je ne serai plus là...
the best lou ever! rip my love
Lou Reed had never been to Berlin when he did this album.
Lou Reed didn't come to Berlin.
Berlin came to Lou Reed.
This album changed my life-
Beautiful and magnificent x
Lou Reed RULES!!!!
a very rare album ! so great !
It's Art.
Absolutely magnificent x
It is a wonderful experience.
so dark it is bright
too right
Yep
There is life affirmation in tragedy.
Brian • man I always took it the opposite way. Like, this is denial and refusing to acknowledge the narrators role in Caroline’s suicide.
What drove her to suicide, I mean. Like I have very little faith this dude is going to be better going forward. I still think the song is incredible and powerful.
I've always found this song throw away and complex. Lou Reed is so conversational I find. Like having an intimate chat with a stranger at a bar. Was he influenced by Chuck Berry I always wonder? Berry had much the same technique..."Meanwhile I was thinking...". I listened to this song endlessly when I split up with my wife. He sets you up "I'm gonna stop wasting my time". And then "Somebody else would have broken both of her arms" is so grimly true and funny.
So very true. The conversational intimacy is the mark of a great writer.
? omg, whatever you're on cut the dose.
He's subverting that sort of farty 'optimistic' brass band musical trope. I agree that this subversion is very amusing. It's also amusing how so many people take the 'happy' tone here at face value and think this thing is a 'hopeful' refuting of the previous tracks.
we miss you lou.
O what beautiful
What a sad song
maybe the best reed solo song,is an epic progression and arrangements the shape of the loop is awesome.i said to lou that i heard this song 200 times in a row(in gran rex theatre-argentina)
I do love the fact that he thinks anyone else would have broken BOTH of her arms.
Probably my favourite song about domestic violence. From an album with a couple of contenders..
It’s SO dark. From the POV of an abuser both wistfully remembering and making excuses for himself at the same time, delivery that becomes more and more emotionless and backed by almost triumphant music. It’s one of a kind.
Masterpiece!
Lou ironically name checking Mary Queen Of Scots. I wonder if he knew the parallels with his Berlin to her own in this dramatic story? Guess so. Genius.
This album feels like a methamphetamine comedown. Beautiful album
Canção belíssima (de um álbum extraordinário). Expressa o ponto exato em que tristeza e alegria se fundem.
an all time favorite. i take pleasure in knowing that one day people will discover the beauty in Berlin
Sorry, Dark in most places and not beautiful. Dark, disturbing and unsettling. A place where Communism was removed and Socialism is present. But nobody knows as all living there
have been robbed of initiative and don't know how to work. Public transportation is a mess. You wait for an hour for a menu at a restaurant while the waitresses smoke cigarettes and look uninterested. Citizens are non-responsive until you give them something extra...True story. So the LP does fit in.
Those drums...
None of his solo albums come even close to this....none.
Man up. I was lucky enough to see it in live. In Tallinn, Berlin Tour, Linnahall (Tenet place).
Just brilliance x
As much as I appreciate the live version there has to be acknowlegement for technical stuff and, even so, no harm done to this or even the whole of it. It is, as said elsewhere, brilliant and, in old words, who can and does write and use words as in this story nowadays, 2019?????? I can not let this LP go!!!!
2022!
To be honest, and as a kid in the 1970s I’d give anything a listen -
Maybe one of the weirdest albums.
I mean, I’m just responding to the comment one of the best albums.
I did come around to enjoying it - still very weird.
Lou, You're still with us et Berlin est bien le meilleur album
Emotional album what make me in deep
LOVE
The most ELO-sounding Lou's music got.
Ho passato,i migliori anni della mia esistenza,assieme; alla soavità, della musica di Lou..ma anke Berlin è un capolavoro
..luigi.b
❤️ R.i.p. grande Lou!!!
I'm having a collapse of self and identity. Lou aligns
"I'm gonna stop wasting my time
Somebody else would have broken both of her arms.."
Lou somehow makes this into a poignant love song
Very Beautiful album, the best of Lou Reed.
La pieza se llama "Canción Triste" pero de principio a fin suena como alegre, optimista, casi como si de una moderna composición alegro de Beethoven se tratase. ¡Qué extraño...! ¿Verdad? Jim parece sentir nostalgia mirando esas fotos, pero ante todo siente alegría, libertad, insensibilidad ("voy a dejar de perder el tiempo (mortificándome), alguien más también le hubiera roto sus brazos"), en vez de una agonizante tristeza por el suicidio de su supuestamente "amada" Caroline.
Sabes que esta es una de las canciones más "siniestras" compuestas por Lou Reed cuando la entiendes, aunque ante todo, una declaración sincera y sumamente pesimista (en la muerte se suele hacer un antes y un después para olvidar y uno seguir viviendo "mejor", aunque esto a veces no es más que una excusa egoísta para enterrar a alguien y pasar página). El desinterés de Reed a lo largo de la pieza ("Sad Song... Sad Song..."), ese compás tan fino y calmado, como si de un hallazgo de vida se tratase, le dan un toque final muy simbólico y oscuro.
Es genial que consiga ese efecto. A simple vista, uno puede fácilmente creer que en efecto es una canción triste, pero en realidad resulta ser un juego de palabras. Un gran cierre para Berlín, un álbum que llega a sentirse como una adaptación de alguna historia de William Burroughs. Es algo complicado de digerir, pero si te dejas llevar lo disfrutas mejor.
bellissima
after i have listened to lou reed's songs i feel and see how bad of music these days.
He knew what music is and singers and musicians must learn form his works
+Charlies Politanont you know he used to get into fights with the studio recording techs because they would try and change how he sounded.
+Daniel Stuurop-Wiffen that's cool lol
+Daniel -- Or so the story goes. Lou Reed said he hated Dolby units, and click tracks. He said "I like leakage" (one loud track "bleeding" onto another), and "I don't like Lou Reed albums. I like Velvet Underground albums."
But our dearly-departed Lou did like to lie to journalists, A LOT. You can tell this album was made with utmost care for sound quality.
I started making music on my channel, check it out and tell me what you think.
What a simple statement! Nowadays there are thousands of amazing and innovative bands that can be perfectly compared to lou!
It's a sad song indeed.
"Somebody else would have broken both her arms"