Gustave Flaubert’ Madame Bovary - Why Married Women Get Bored?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 янв 2025

Комментарии • 116

  • @Fiction_Beast
    @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +5

    NEW Video on Gustave Flaubert's Life and Style of Writing: ruclips.net/video/66Vf-y-k3ZU/видео.html

    • @j0nnyism
      @j0nnyism 2 года назад +1

      Please do a video on Waverley it’s my favourite political historical romance novel. In my heart I’m a Jacobite high Tory but in my head I’m a Whig

  • @Nia-yz4ft
    @Nia-yz4ft 2 года назад +94

    Everyone pities Madame Bovary. No one talks about wretched Charles. He had been the subject of torment from beginning , domineering parents , unpleasant first marriage...and as he found the woman he worshipped more than love , she decieves him and lets herself and her passions adrift. Her beauty being the snare for all others and her doom. Poor Charles , he did nothing to deserve this.

    • @mayankbajpai170
      @mayankbajpai170 2 года назад

      यू आर राइट सर आई हैव नो सिंपैथी फॉर एमा

    • @AtifShafiinheritance
      @AtifShafiinheritance 2 года назад +3

      Seems not only me saw that

    • @tushitushi9919
      @tushitushi9919 Год назад +5

      Poor Charles!!! His first wife literally died because of him........ imagine yourself in her shoes. What if your wife or husband do this to you?

    • @SaadiaKaamalahD
      @SaadiaKaamalahD Год назад +4

      NYRB has a book called "Charles Bovary, Country Doctor: Portrait of a Simple Man." I have yet to read it, but it's on my list!

    • @brileyvandyke5792
      @brileyvandyke5792 9 месяцев назад +2

      Absolutely correct. Charles was a sympathetic character. Madame was a selfish, ugly personality.

  • @Nia-yz4ft
    @Nia-yz4ft 2 года назад +17

    Just finished reading Madame Bovary. You've summarised it aptly , meticulously pointing creat and troughs of the Flaubert's work. One can relate to her , her sorrows and hollowness that pervades her heart screams aloud , we all have that appetite , Madame slaked it ferociously without thinking of the consequences.

  • @davet2625
    @davet2625 Год назад +3

    Just finished reading Madame Bovary. Have read Anna Karenina twice. First time seeing any of your videos. New subscriber - I appreciate all the insights.

  • @채정훈-w6u
    @채정훈-w6u 2 года назад +13

    What a wonderful and impressive analysis of the materpiece novel "Madam Bovary". Beautiful novel and brilliant summary! Thanks a lot!

  • @KuR58
    @KuR58 Год назад +6

    Although it's easy to find Emma very irritating. Thinking things like: woman, you're ruining a perfectly fine life and bringing ruin to you and everyone around you. For example I felt horrible for little Berthe since her mother never really loved her, sometimes she wanted to pay her some attention as if she were a cute doll for a while and as soon as she started crying she forgot that she had a daughter again. Or how she grew to hate and mistreat Charles even when he didn't do anything "wrong" althought I think it can be argued that he was so happily ignorant of her pain that I can't help but feel like he was a bit emotionally neglectful. I felt for Emma a lot, specially at the beginning. She talks a lot about how she craves for freedom and excitement in life and I don't necessarily feel that's a bad thing to wish for, but the novel sometimes feels as if it's trying to chastize women about it "don't wish for too much". Okay Emma has unreasonable and unreal expectations on life and that will bring forth her downfall but some of her anguish and pain is very relatable. She wished she was a man so she could travel the world, meet all sorts of people, have relationships and experience love, and have an exciting life. All things that were forbidden for a woman at the time. When she went on about how she felt as if she was watching life through the windows of her house without really living in it or how she was always hoping something new or different would happen to her but never did and suddenly she realized her life would be a neverending loop of living the same day over and over, an eternity of boredom and then death, I can't help but really feel for her. I feel it's a very valid fear and pain. She even wished her baby would be born a man, so that at least she could have lived a happier, more free life.

  • @Socratez7
    @Socratez7 2 года назад +8

    Amazing commentary and analysis - as always! Bravo!

  • @yeyuravi3859
    @yeyuravi3859 2 года назад +28

    Ah good old French literature! I'd suggest you to do a video on Victor Hugo's Les Miserables soon.. Anyway awesome content! ❤️

  • @harikaimal
    @harikaimal 11 месяцев назад +3

    Remarkable
    The observation that Capitalism is to blame...is remarkable

  • @Sachie465
    @Sachie465 Год назад +3

    I had assumed that I was going to dislike the novel. You inspired me to read it and it was unexpectedly absorbing. The way Emma slowly goes mad like an addict. The impressive agricultural fair when the door to doom opens. The ghastliness of the final scenes…I’ll read again to fully appreciate the writing, but next, I'm thinking of reading Maupassant's One Life, another story of an unhappy marriage in 19th century France.

  • @zakcole2229
    @zakcole2229 2 года назад +5

    Another awesome, thought provoking video. Thank you!

  • @roshananoor3066
    @roshananoor3066 2 года назад +3

    You've done it brilliantly as always.
    Grateful.......

  • @kasiakwiatkowska5816
    @kasiakwiatkowska5816 2 года назад +4

    This is incredible!! Listened to this video several times to capture as much as possible! Love this summary and analysis. It actually m,add me reach out for my NY Public Library Edition and started reading today! Thank You 🙏

  • @jamesboulger8705
    @jamesboulger8705 2 года назад +4

    Thank you for the review. Unfortunately, I do not read French, but I have read on Gustave, and I can completely emphasize with his writing ethic. It is incredibly tempting to make cliche', ham-fisted writing. He did not produce a lot, but from what I have read on him, what he did produce was worth 10 books by other authors.

  • @andrewdunbar828
    @andrewdunbar828 2 года назад +7

    I seem to recall that Flaubert believed writing was about the crafting of the language and that the story was of no importance and he specifically chose this story from the tabloid press because to prove his point he wanted a story "about nothing". I read this book twenty years ago while backpacking in Guatemala so I'm not sure how accurate my memory is.

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +2

      You're right, he wanted to turn base metal into gold. that's Madame Bovary.

    • @andrewdunbar828
      @andrewdunbar828 2 года назад

      ​@@Fiction_Beast Yes I see you covered this aspect in more detail in your latest video.

  • @tolanishuilleabhain6708
    @tolanishuilleabhain6708 7 месяцев назад

    fantastic stuff, I love your style of explaining, top notch humor too!

  • @thevagabond9228
    @thevagabond9228 2 года назад +2

    great summary. easy to understand. funny. great analysis. thank you so much.

  • @zicokahuroa3660
    @zicokahuroa3660 2 года назад +2

    “Doctors alleviate your pain and lawyers empty your pockets so both are equally as useful”
    Lmao

  • @sitapurbari
    @sitapurbari Месяц назад

    Great presentation, in-depth copy and good VO,❤

  • @Reza090
    @Reza090 2 года назад +2

    Thank you:) Would love to see more great books like this.

  • @nefwaenre
    @nefwaenre 2 года назад +18

    i have zero sympathies for Emma. She deserved the misery she got. But i absolutely felt for Charles. Clearly the poor guy and the innocent daughter deserved much, much better. Guys like Charles are mild mannered, nice and so it was a perfect catch. There's no competition. But no.. there needs to young men, attractive men. All just shallow and vain. This is an excellent case for that saying that beautiful people are never satisfied by one lover.

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +3

      Charles did everything right except he was boring. His biggest mistake.

    • @pseudonamed
      @pseudonamed Год назад

      It's tragic, because he was a simple man who could have been happy with a simple wife, and vice versa. But marriage at that time didn't involve really getting to know your future spouse, it had little to do with your personalities being compatible, you could end up with totally the wrong match.. as these characters did.

    • @andyg35311
      @andyg35311 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@Fiction_Beastgot it, you shouldn't be boring. I'm guessing you should also be charming and funny too? Oh and handsome, gotta make sure that I'm handsome. Rich too of course, can't be poor and satisfy a woman! Romantic too, gotta make sure she is the centre of attention. And agreeable, happy wife happy life, can't go letting her go wanting for anything.
      Did I miss anything?
      No matter, she will leave anyway because of her personality.
      Moral of the story- don't change yourself to please another, find one that likes you as you are 😊

  • @nadaroshan4022
    @nadaroshan4022 2 года назад +2

    your analysis for novels and those who have written them is wonderful
    it remembers me the way of choline Wilson the outsider
    keep going ,I got one of your discipline

  • @xlrpj123playz6
    @xlrpj123playz6 2 года назад +1

    thank you for making this

  • @moshefabrikant1
    @moshefabrikant1 2 года назад +4

    9:40
    Woman want a real man, its in anna karinana and madame bovary
    11:00
    We only realize we are getting older because how others see us
    15:00
    Don't read too much romances when you are young
    21:00
    Jordan Peterson
    might argue that women are chaos. Without chaos in their lives, they search to find
    one somewhere else. If they can’t, they create chaos themselves. These two novels
    seem to suggest that both Anna and Emma married boring men, reliable but not exciting. So
    they searched for some excitement somewhere else. Today that message has been instilled
    in every one of us. Don’t wait for happiness, chase it. Don’t be content with what you
    have. Always shoot for the best. So I don’t blame Emma. I am much like her. On a subconscious
    level we all chase chaos. We’re programmed to deal with adversities, chaos and thrills.

    • @yohann2217
      @yohann2217 Год назад

      I think there's a difference betwern chaos and to be stimulated. Charles was objectively boring. To seek other man it's not to seek chaos in this case. I think Emma and Léon was a good couple.

  • @cappy2282
    @cappy2282 2 года назад +5

    Flaubert was extremely good and many consider Madame Bovary one of the best. My favorite book of his is "A sentimental education" 👍

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +3

      I love Sentimental but everyone knows Bovary. Thanks for watching.

    • @cappy2282
      @cappy2282 2 года назад +2

      @@Fiction_Beast Ya Bovary is his masterpiece forsure. I would like to re-read it. (I forget most of it lol)

  • @katlynklassen809
    @katlynklassen809 2 года назад +4

    She got what she thought love was. The problem is she never knew what it is that would get you.

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад

      i think she had fun but it was tough for others around her.

  • @shivanitiwari2382
    @shivanitiwari2382 9 месяцев назад

    Literally I must salute your explanation🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉you justify the novel Thanking you so much

  • @madinaurinova751
    @madinaurinova751 Год назад

    Thanks for the best explanation)

  • @sharontheodore8216
    @sharontheodore8216 2 года назад +5

    A novel with a powerfully lasting effect. Emma was the product and the victim of the new romantic era in literature and art where true love meant certain experience without which it is not love.
    Flaubert was the teacher of Guy de Maupassant, another leading French writer and who is the father of the French short stories. If you get a chance, read his story ‘The Necklace’ or ‘La Parure’ which kind of resonates with Madame Bovary.
    Thank you so much for your amazing analysis.

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад

      I read the necklace a while back. It’s a great short story. Thanks so much as always.

  • @kasialeparska2480
    @kasialeparska2480 2 года назад

    Excellent review, thank you! 🌹

  • @carakathleen
    @carakathleen 2 года назад

    Really, really incredible!

  • @j0nnyism
    @j0nnyism 2 года назад +1

    When I read this in my 20s I detested Emma and sympathised with Charles but reading it again in my 40s I reversed my opinion on them. Strange how age and life experiences change the way you react to character

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +1

      Proust’s novel in search of lost time is mainly about how time changes us.

  • @Tolstoy111
    @Tolstoy111 2 года назад +2

    Madame Bovary inspired Anna Karenina. Just as War and Peace was inspired by Les Miserables.

  • @4imee198
    @4imee198 Год назад +1

    In my opinion his warning was against Monopolies, because one his competition is gone (free market) he's able to do as he please.
    I love to realize all the authors I grew up admiring like Leo Tolstoy weren't fans of modernity as myself. Things just go so damn fast I just want a break and a simpler life, happiness or no I want peace, quietness, stability :/
    #minimalism?

  • @Barnabas94
    @Barnabas94 2 года назад +4

    Just finished reading Madame Bovary. Loved your analysis of the book like how I love all of your videos but I did not love this book. Idk if it was bc I read the Eleanor Marx translation or the plot just wasn’t for me. The descriptive language was beautiful as is to be expected of Flaubert, the social commentary is interesting but others do it better, I couldn’t get into the characters and didn’t care or like Emma. Just a narcissistic girl who takes others for granted and wastes everything for selfish gain. I also have another Flaubert on the shelf with “Bouvard and Pecuchet”, but I’m going back home to Russia for awhile before I give Flaubert another chance. 2/5

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +3

      I think Madame Bovary's plot has dated a lot since we live in a very different world with female liberation but at that time it was a huge scandal. Flaubert delibrately chose a somewhat ordinary story he read in a newspaper and chanllenegd himself to turn it into piece of great literary work. For me Flaubert's language is magical an dI agree the story is pretty ordinary.

  • @ReligionOfSacrifice
    @ReligionOfSacrifice 2 года назад +1

    What is the story where the wife returns and the husband does not remember her?

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад

      The man who forgot his wife?

    • @ReligionOfSacrifice
      @ReligionOfSacrifice 2 года назад

      ​@@Fiction_Beast, yes, as you described this book to me, I wondered if it wasn't the book my mother wants me to read, where the wife returns only to find she can't return for the man does not even know who she is (dementia).
      I can still remember picking up a book my mother was reading where a man was wondering where all the churches in Russia had gone. That book was "In the First Circle" and I wasn't a teenager. She always had a book around her that was usually big and so I'd pick it up and read one chapter around where she was and then go back to Sci-Fi.
      As I got older, I fell in love with the Russian writers she had read by reading the whole book and now I ask for book ideas, but that book she told me about has been the only illusive book I can't find.
      She leaves her husband and then finds she can't go back. It isn't "Jude the Obscure" as mom calls that one the book where the wife jumps out of the window, but does go back and the husband takes her back.

    • @ReligionOfSacrifice
      @ReligionOfSacrifice 2 года назад

      @@Fiction_Beast, oh, that is the title. Mom didn't know.

    • @ReligionOfSacrifice
      @ReligionOfSacrifice 2 года назад +1

      @@Fiction_Beast, no, that is not it. Or at least I don't believe it is.
      The book I want has the wife returning to him. Not they are divorcing. Rather she is used poorly by other men and returns to the man who she knows loves her, only her husband can't even remember her.
      This would be a book before 1995 let's say.

  • @CinemaSatsang
    @CinemaSatsang 2 года назад +2

    your videos are very educative! Thank you! I didn't like the live action images (the black & white one) in India this story could still be taboo!

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад

      Thank you! You mean women leaving their husbands?

    • @CinemaSatsang
      @CinemaSatsang 2 года назад

      @@Fiction_Beast yes!

  • @custer264
    @custer264 11 месяцев назад

    Women get bored because they are meant to be taken for a ride and cannot find satisfaction in work, whereas a man can become obsessed with some hobby or profession.

  • @MrExtraordinaire16
    @MrExtraordinaire16 2 года назад +1

    As a big fan of your video i am curious at the end you stated that you thought jordan peterson whould think woman's are chaos is that what you believe he would say or did he actually say that I am quite curious.

    • @gracefitzgerald2227
      @gracefitzgerald2227 2 года назад +3

      I’ve read Both of JPs books and he says woman are the Yin to the man’s Yang. The dark to the light. The chaos to the order. No pussyfooting, that’s what’s literally in his books. Funny thing is, I still love his books.

    • @MrExtraordinaire16
      @MrExtraordinaire16 2 года назад

      @@gracefitzgerald2227 really! What page is that for the most part I more often than not watch his lectures because i love them a lot except the one on communism which he himself has stated to not having read any other communist text other than marx. So yeah! But as much as many say they don't like jordan Peterson I truly adore his works, probably because of my conservative values but then again I did hear that a lot of moderate liberals say that they like his work .

    • @gracefitzgerald2227
      @gracefitzgerald2227 2 года назад

      @@MrExtraordinaire16 rule 2 treat yourself like someone you are trying to help. That’s where he mostly talks about the yin and the Yang and the book of Genesis. The message is spread apart in both of his Order books ( I’ve never read Maps on Meaning). I lean towards the liberal side, and I’m seeing him in 2 weeks. I’m praying he sticks to the books. 😊

    • @MrExtraordinaire16
      @MrExtraordinaire16 2 года назад +1

      @@gracefitzgerald2227 really!wow that's awesome hopefully the reunion will go well between you two,I really appreciate that you took the time to explain the page thank you very much and seems like my hunch on certain liberals liking him is true.😊

    • @gracefitzgerald2227
      @gracefitzgerald2227 2 года назад +1

      @@MrExtraordinaire16 you’re correct. He’ll be in Providence so I’m hoping it’ll be mostly peaceful New England folks. It’s scary that some people are showing up to his lectures with banners about him being hateful. I don’t agree with everything he says but I also don’t like the far leaning left. You sound nice Imran, I hope you read his books and get the best from them.

  • @gracefitzgerald2227
    @gracefitzgerald2227 2 года назад +4

    I’m so happy I listened to this. I always thought Madame Bovary was when the wife has an affair with a farmhand because her husband is disabled . What am I thinking of? As usual your explanation was thoughtful, and fun. This one was sadder than the others.

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +4

      Thanks a heap! I think you're talking about Lady Chatterley’s Lover by DH Lawrence. the husbnad tells the wife to cheat so there is no betrayal i suppose.

    • @gracefitzgerald2227
      @gracefitzgerald2227 2 года назад

      @@Fiction_Beast yes! I think I might have sneaked some peaks on Skin-a-max back in the 80s when my parents went to bed. Ha ha😝

  • @burke9497
    @burke9497 2 года назад

    FB, which English translation of Madame Bovary do you recommend? Thanks!

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +2

      I read the penguin classics version. It’s beautifully done.

    • @gurashishsingh7813
      @gurashishsingh7813 2 года назад +2

      Lydia Davis's translation is absolutely stunning!

  • @encantarebelde
    @encantarebelde 2 года назад +1

    Sick burn on the lawyers

  • @ericuttamkumar1672
    @ericuttamkumar1672 2 года назад +1

    Very very very true this is going on in this society, just like a fictional dreamy world imagination fairytale of fantasy romantic perfect love friendships attachments connections fantasy obsessions all are one day becomes as a bulshit rubbish ruins the precious valuable life's of the person (person) even the families it is all going on in the societies of the people and in the world very very bad it's all happening in the practically.

  • @weile4u
    @weile4u 2 года назад

    Madame Bovary was NOT Flaubert's first novel!

  • @2msvalkyrie529
    @2msvalkyrie529 2 года назад +1

    Strindberg understood women better than Flaubert. It's blindingly obvious that Emma is sexually unfulfilled . ( to
    everyone except the author apparently .). She would like Charles to beat her..? Hmmm.....?

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +5

      Here’s the irony though. Strindberg was heavily attacked by women for his views while Flaubert’s Emma has become the symbol of liberated woman.

  • @YoYo-gt5iq
    @YoYo-gt5iq 2 года назад +2

    I love the jokes, like when you say that all of France celebrated. Just kidding. It's a provincial wedding.

  • @hrprtgill
    @hrprtgill 8 месяцев назад

    Why married men get bored?

  • @Stopcolonizinglebanon
    @Stopcolonizinglebanon Год назад

    It's amazing and awful to have had almost the same partner. I should have known better. Blaming this on capitalism is foolish. Nonetheless an excellent precis.

  • @custer264
    @custer264 11 месяцев назад

    Oh yeah. And just like junk food ruins your body junk information ruins the mind.

  • @nycgweed
    @nycgweed 2 года назад +3

    Worse are the novelas on tv! Every Latina I’ve dated thinks life is like a novela where everyone is screwing everybody lol

  • @robmurrah3224
    @robmurrah3224 2 года назад

    The widow was so humiliated she DIED? That's pretty weak writing.

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад

      it's on me. Hard to convey his writing in a short video.

  • @sammoe1292
    @sammoe1292 10 месяцев назад

    Society is now full of Emma’s… and how terrifying it is that they think their neuroticism and capriciousness is empowering.

  • @humanfirst11
    @humanfirst11 2 года назад

    When you say "Bovary" it always sounds to me that you are saying "Bolvary", or it's just me!

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад

      I still dont know the correct french pron

  • @mayankbajpai170
    @mayankbajpai170 2 года назад +1

    I have no sympathy for Emma

  • @AC-ob7ke
    @AC-ob7ke 2 года назад

    She's a Brenda.

  • @oksanatulpa7984
    @oksanatulpa7984 2 года назад +1

    Ufortunately never read and don't like romantic novel. Better myths of German . Legend of Nibellungs for example )

    • @Fiction_Beast
      @Fiction_Beast  2 года назад +2

      It’s not really a true romance. More a social and psychological commentary on chasing happiness.

  • @reeset2198
    @reeset2198 Год назад

    Millions of people today, mostly women, are in Credit card debt because their shopping habits? What on earth are you talking about?? What a completely weird thing to say.

  • @mayankbajpai170
    @mayankbajpai170 2 года назад

    सॉरी फॉर हेर डॉटर हर हस्बैंड