GUYS!!! Asrar Rashid uploaded this same video BUT its shorter than ours which means they have CUT the video up, they GOT US TO MAKE A PROMISE we would release it unedited! From what i have seen so far the last 10 minutes are gone and in these last 10 minutes they tried to get us to turn of the camera, and Ustadh Abdul Rahman called him our for the debate there and then and he quickly got out of it and left... alhamdulillah we left the video unedited, go and watch that last part now on 02.00.53
I like the mutual respect between the two. Even tho im ahlul hadeeth , i like Br. Asrar manners. He was poised the whole time. And may Allah preserve Ust. AbdulRahman
19:43 Asrar: "U promised to get back too me after april, is that not the case? So why did you delay so long until I had to press u for a debate? " Ustadh: "Because I was traveling, I have commitments, I have other things to do, my wife gave birth to a kid, you want more details?" Asrar: "No, thats sufficient" hahahahahahah what a answer :))
You can clearly see a big difference in knowledge between the two. Especially when it comes to Usool ul Fiqh, Qawaa'id Fiqhiyyah and Mustalah ul Hadeeth. Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan schools him when they start arguing. You can also see how the Qur'aan constantly is on the tongue of Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan, while Asrar only have memorized lots of shubuhaat connected to Tawassul and Istighaathah. May Allaah let the truth become manifest through this debate.
when Asrar Rashid asked "why did it take u so long to get to back to me in April" and ustadh Abdul Rahman replied "my wife gave birth to a kid, do u want more details?" I burst out laughing 😂😩 his reaction 😂😂😂
For the most interesting parts of the discussion, refer to the information section above, parts like when Asrar Rashid belittled Ahmed Raza Berelvi... I wonder how the Berelvi's will be towards him now?
The body language says it all, Abdul Rahman Hassan looks calm, collected, and confident. The scrambled paper Asrar Rashid has, makes me scared for him, makes him look like fluffy lamb about to be sacrificed as a deterrent for those on the same ideology (my first impression). May Allah make both parties benefit from this discussion and what follows with only love between.
+Mohammed Ahmed wAllah body language is key, in fact experts say it communicates way more than our words, 57% of what we are trying to say in fact is down to our body language... I really noticed it as well
You see that the argument Asrar used about musa (as) benefitting the ummah is wrongly used. Because you will never find a person who seeks istighata travel up to the heavens to get benefitted. They all go to the graves and therefore the statement brother AbdulRahman made about that the person in the grave cant benefit or hurt anyone is true. If the prophet Muhammed saw would have went to the grave of Musa (as) he could never have benefitted Muhammed in the same way he did when they met in the 6th heaven. Like so everybody can see this point.
Masha'Allah I had a feeling there must me a logical answer to that, wish if it was coming from Shaykh Abdul Rahman but nevertheless May Allah grant you goodness...
Wooohoo Ustadh Abdul Rahman fantastic,full of knowledge and patience, this bugged me so much when sheikh Asrar wouldn't let Ustadh Abdul Rahman talk how rude!!! He needs to learn some manners!!
Good job imam Asim backed off from the mawlid debate a couple of months back.. The Somalian imam would of wiped the floor with him... And I am not being biased... Asrar has 100X more Knowledge than imam Asim.. And he's still struggling against the Somalian imam.
41:20 I am very happy that Ustadh Abdul Rahman refused to have barelwia replaced with Sunnis. This would be a big mistake and misunderstanding when addressing them during the debate.
The debating tricks of the brelwis in summary 1) Invite someone to a debate (preferably based on loose rules so they could go in circles) 2) Come to the debate with half the books in the british library to hoax their blind followers into buying into their intellectual prowess (even though there isn't enough time in the debate to use all books) 3) Veer off the topic of the debate by nit picking every minutiae of information driving you crazy by going in circles constantly opening/reopening tiny debates in things both parties already agree on . 4) Recording the video of debate to capture the person losing their cool and then editing it online 5) If all of the above doesn't work they pretend to not speak English and call it a day
Ustaad Abdirahman may Allah bless you those suffis problems always used to be warshipping Allah alone by asking graves and slaughtering for awliyaa committing major shirk yet arguing that it is permissible may Allah guide them
he wants to argue to death over something that has a win - lose consequence. if it was halal( which it's not ) there is minimal benefit and because it's haram and bidah the punishment is leaving Islam. because he's not 100% sure it's allowed he's playing with a small act of worship on one side and being a disbeliever on the other
My question to Asrar is did any of the prophets celebrate thier birthday or the people at that time celebrate thier birthday did the prophet celebrate his birthday as we supposed to follow the prophet no ? Second question is when Surat Fatiha says ask god alone for help then why do u need to pray to a prophet to get to god
sheikh asrar is a knowledgable person but boy is he on the back foot sheikh hassan is more decisive in his answers i hope things can be clear to all...
asrar is talking not for the sake of truth..it is purely a DEBATE to defend ego. Asrar should not begin by insisting on who challenged first. Waste a lot of time.
ok seriously this is not rocket science , Mawlid is haram, I don't know why people are still debating about this. the prophet didn't celebrate his birth day .
is anyone else surprised asrar rashid didn't want to debate the mawlid issue? something is telling me Asrar rashid told imam asim to back of when he made that dangerous move!!
He doesn't answer any question clearly, keeps crossing over to other points, and answers depending on the context of the situation. You can't compare the prophets asking for help and people asking the graves for help. What Allah has said is set in stone and can not be changed for one person and be different for another. I think his main problem was that brother Imran went public with it. He kept mentioning him and going back towards him in the beginning and the end. He had a good sense of humor whenever he realized he was wrong. And at the end, when they're talking about him saying he is willing to debate here and now, he won't even accept the fact that he was wrong in saying that. He won't debate here and now, yet he won't take his statement back. Regardless of whether they have books or not. I don't trust him on his word to be honest. Otherwise, Allah knows best and I pray that He guides you guys to victory for standing firm on the Haqq.
LOL Ustaadh AbdurRahman keeps calling Asrar's evidences "shubuhaat" and Asrar doesn't even even flinch. SubhanAllah. Almost as if Asrar is in agreement that his own evidences are nothing but doubts he will throw at people.
Vice, in vice-debator comes from the Latin Vice which means in place of, however, it does also mean a sin or blameworthy attribute which is its common usages. Vice is generally used for roles in business and presidency.
Ustadh didn't ask 6 questions nor did he or Imran prolong it as much or little as Asrar (it ran on for 13 minutes ) so he has nothing to claim in regards to what is and isn't petty.
So is asrar rashid point is its permissible to ask the prophet Muhammad SAW for help while he has passed away?? And the other br is sayin its not permissible and we shud only ask Allah swt for help which i agree on....
Asrar is just someone who likes to intimidate whoever he can. Goes around with his gang challenging people & then doesn't give his opponents a word or chance to answer or especially question his true aqeedah which I believe to be of barelvis but this is all just an act he puts on, I mean look at the way he behaves in this video. Why doesn't he go round giving dawah to the Kuffar? No because obviously he follows a flawed deviant sect.
10 mins in the beginning is so awkward and even though ustad kept telling him that that he ddnt call him to challenge nor debate by name but a lot of the times he doesn't answer ustad's questions
Asrar said to Ustad that he could ask 5 questions at the end, every spin off question that the Ustad asked, he denied to answer, however he asked many spin off questions in his own 5 questions? Am I wrong ?
i commented on the mahamadiya page of the youtube account, where theyre all saying abdurahman got schooled? my comment has been removed, but i was al listening with affiliation from neither side and i have to agree, the sufi chap got schooled
These barehlvis will never answer a question straight forwardly. They will never be logical, i do not c the point of all this, it is futile and a waste of time, abdurahman use ur time and energy on other deen stuff that will benefit you. This israr character hasnt a leg to stand on.
Asrar rashid is shook and wallah he is rude an he said the word wtf in the clip 2:00:20 subhanallah and towards the end of the video he said do pray behind me sheikh conducting in this manner feel sorry for him may allah guide inshallah
dawah Name Bro there is no bias in Imran's words. It's all on video 😂😂 I've watched nearly half an hour now and it's so clearly evident how worried Asrar Rashid is behaving.
masha'Allah abdur Rehman give evidence from Qur'an but mushrik israr not let to him finish his answer or when he read ayat from Qur'an , but please abdur Rehman read this ayat for mushrik israr rashid ( KHATAMALLAHU ALA QULUBIHIM,WA ALA SAM'IHIM WA ALA ABSARIHIM RISYAWAH WALAHUM AZABBUN ALIM.)sufi mushrik israr will die but he never accept ayat Qur'an because his grandfather name is ahmed raza khan bralwi
![DEBATE: Can You Make Du'a To The Prophet ﷺ After His Death? [PART 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oG7ZYk5_RhE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
May Allah reward Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan for his patience, سبحان الله
GUYS!!! Asrar Rashid uploaded this same video BUT its shorter than ours which means they have CUT the video up, they GOT US TO MAKE A PROMISE we would release it unedited! From what i have seen so far the last 10 minutes are gone and in these last 10 minutes they tried to get us to turn of the camera, and Ustadh Abdul Rahman called him our for the debate there and then and he quickly got out of it and left... alhamdulillah we left the video unedited, go and watch that last part now on 02.00.53
I like the mutual respect between the two. Even tho im ahlul hadeeth , i like Br. Asrar manners. He was poised the whole time. And may Allah preserve Ust. AbdulRahman
19:43
Asrar: "U promised to get back too me after april, is that not the case? So why did you delay so long until I had to press u for a debate? "
Ustadh: "Because I was traveling, I have commitments, I have other things to do, my wife gave birth to a kid, you want more details?"
Asrar: "No, thats sufficient"
hahahahahahah what a answer :))
You can clearly see a big difference in knowledge between the two. Especially when it comes to Usool ul Fiqh, Qawaa'id Fiqhiyyah and Mustalah ul Hadeeth. Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan schools him when they start arguing. You can also see how the Qur'aan constantly is on the tongue of Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan, while Asrar only have memorized lots of shubuhaat connected to Tawassul and Istighaathah. May Allaah let the truth become manifest through this debate.
when Asrar Rashid asked "why did it take u so long to get to back to me in April" and ustadh Abdul Rahman replied "my wife gave birth to a kid, do u want more details?" I burst out laughing 😂😩 his reaction 😂😂😂
Most Polite and Respected Debate i ever saw. This type of we look forward to see in the future. When the debate will take place?
10minuts about who called who out, some will be irritated about it, but i enjoy this chess game.
For the most interesting parts of the discussion, refer to the information section above, parts like when Asrar Rashid belittled Ahmed Raza Berelvi... I wonder how the Berelvi's will be towards him now?
wallahi the ustadh got patience. I would have a headache if I was in his position
The body language says it all, Abdul Rahman Hassan looks calm, collected, and confident. The scrambled paper Asrar Rashid has, makes me scared for him, makes him look like fluffy lamb about to be sacrificed as a deterrent for those on the same ideology (my first impression). May Allah make both parties benefit from this discussion and what follows with only love between.
+Mohammed Ahmed wAllah body language is key, in fact experts say it communicates way more than our words, 57% of what we are trying to say in fact is down to our body language... I really noticed it as well
You see that the argument Asrar used about musa (as) benefitting the ummah is wrongly used. Because you will never find a person who seeks istighata travel up to the heavens to get benefitted. They all go to the graves and therefore the statement brother AbdulRahman made about that the person in the grave cant benefit or hurt anyone is true. If the prophet Muhammed saw would have went to the grave of Musa (as) he could never have benefitted Muhammed in the same way he did when they met in the 6th heaven. Like so everybody can see this point.
Masha'Allah I had a feeling there must me a logical answer to that, wish if it was coming from Shaykh Abdul Rahman but nevertheless May Allah grant you goodness...
How is that ?
Mashallah the Somali brother has patients debating this guy
I would go mad speaking to him
Wooohoo Ustadh Abdul Rahman fantastic,full of knowledge and patience, this bugged me so much when sheikh Asrar wouldn't let Ustadh Abdul Rahman talk how rude!!! He needs to learn some manners!!
Was very entertaining Barak Allahu feekum :) Excited to watch the debate, inshaAllah
May Allah make the truth clear to all
Ameen
Good job imam Asim backed off from the mawlid debate a couple of months back.. The Somalian imam would of wiped the floor with him... And I am not being biased... Asrar has 100X more Knowledge than imam Asim.. And he's still struggling against the Somalian imam.
i love how Ustadh Abdul rahman jokes and keeping it calm 😂 #SmileItSunnah. Maa shaa Allah!
I didn't know Islam was so so technical.
Mashallah knowledge of Usool Ul Fiqh Really helped to understand
41:20 I am very happy that Ustadh Abdul Rahman refused to have barelwia replaced with Sunnis. This would be a big mistake and misunderstanding when addressing them during the debate.
The debating tricks of the brelwis in summary
1) Invite someone to a debate (preferably based on loose rules so they could go in circles)
2) Come to the debate with half the books in the british library to hoax their blind followers into buying into their intellectual prowess (even though there isn't enough time in the debate to use all books)
3) Veer off the topic of the debate by nit picking every minutiae of information driving you crazy by going in circles constantly opening/reopening tiny debates in things both parties already agree on .
4) Recording the video of debate to capture the person losing their cool and then editing it online
5) If all of the above doesn't work they pretend to not speak English and call it a day
The ending 'do you guys pray behind us'😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 mash'allah Ustadh got it 👌🏻
Ustaad Abdirahman may Allah bless you those suffis problems always used to be warshipping Allah alone by asking graves and slaughtering for awliyaa committing major shirk yet arguing that it is permissible may Allah guide them
he wants to argue to death over something that has a win - lose consequence. if it was halal( which it's not ) there is minimal benefit and because it's haram and bidah the punishment is leaving Islam. because he's not 100% sure it's allowed he's playing with a small act of worship on one side and being a disbeliever on the other
would be great if I had popcorn tbh.
My question to Asrar is did any of the prophets celebrate thier birthday or the people at that time celebrate thier birthday did the prophet celebrate his birthday as we supposed to follow the prophet no ? Second question is when Surat Fatiha says ask god alone for help then why do u need to pray to a prophet to get to god
I am sure the brother Asrar clearly saw Abdurahman is much stronger than him, he is even benefiting from Abdurahman. Baraka Allah fihi
sheikh asrar is a knowledgable person but boy is he on the back foot sheikh hassan is more decisive in his answers i hope things can be clear to all...
As long a Muslim don’t commit shirk he is a Muslim May Allah make us amongst ones who follow the Quran and Sunnah
asrar is talking not for the sake of truth..it is purely a DEBATE to defend ego. Asrar should not begin by insisting on who challenged first. Waste a lot of time.
ok seriously this is not rocket science , Mawlid is haram, I don't know why people are still debating about this. the prophet didn't celebrate his birth day .
can't wait for the debate, when will it be out in sha ALLAH
is anyone else surprised asrar rashid didn't want to debate the mawlid issue? something is telling me Asrar rashid told imam asim to back of when he made that dangerous move!!
Why does it even matter who called who out! The first ten mins are a waste
He doesn't answer any question clearly, keeps crossing over to other points, and answers depending on the context of the situation. You can't compare the prophets asking for help and people asking the graves for help. What Allah has said is set in stone and can not be changed for one person and be different for another. I think his main problem was that brother Imran went public with it. He kept mentioning him and going back towards him in the beginning and the end. He had a good sense of humor whenever he realized he was wrong. And at the end, when they're talking about him saying he is willing to debate here and now, he won't even accept the fact that he was wrong in saying that. He won't debate here and now, yet he won't take his statement back. Regardless of whether they have books or not. I don't trust him on his word to be honest. Otherwise, Allah knows best and I pray that He guides you guys to victory for standing firm on the Haqq.
LOL Ustaadh AbdurRahman keeps calling Asrar's evidences "shubuhaat" and Asrar doesn't even even flinch. SubhanAllah. Almost as if Asrar is in agreement that his own evidences are nothing but doubts he will throw at people.
Asrar is not debating but illogic argument
Asrar stop interrupting man, I cannot focus
This was at times uncomfortable to watch
Vice, in vice-debator comes from the Latin Vice which means in place of, however, it does also mean a sin or blameworthy attribute which is its common usages. Vice is generally used for roles in business and presidency.
Ustadh didn't ask 6 questions nor did he or Imran prolong it as much or little as Asrar (it ran on for 13 minutes ) so he has nothing to claim in regards to what is and isn't petty.
This was so annoying to watch. Asrar kept repeating the same questions over and over!
So is asrar rashid point is its permissible to ask the prophet Muhammad SAW for help while he has passed away?? And the other br is sayin its not permissible and we shud only ask Allah swt for help which i agree on....
Asrar is just someone who likes to intimidate whoever he can. Goes around with his gang challenging people & then doesn't give his opponents a word or chance to answer or especially question his true aqeedah which I believe to be of barelvis but this is all just an act he puts on, I mean look at the way he behaves in this video. Why doesn't he go round giving dawah to the Kuffar? No because obviously he follows a flawed deviant sect.
Hahahahaha he called him petty subh'Allah. You can clearly see that ustadh abdirahman was calm and collected while the other guy was nervous
10 mins in the beginning is so awkward and even though ustad kept telling him that that he ddnt call him to challenge nor debate by name but a lot of the times he doesn't answer ustad's questions
can some1 explain what was his reason for not debating Mawlid? i didnt understand half of the arabic terms used
1.55.26 looooooool awww Ma sha Allah
Good to see a meet up!
Asrar said to Ustad that he could ask 5 questions at the end, every spin off question that the Ustad asked, he denied to answer, however he asked many spin off questions in his own 5 questions? Am I wrong ?
I think I no why the barelvi lost the debate he didnt hv his green hat on lol
Al hamdulilah Salafi sunni
i swear sheikh asrar sounds like sheikh hassans student...
why does asrar constantly interrupt ? he is very experienced in debate it seems
i commented on the mahamadiya page of the youtube account, where theyre all saying abdurahman got schooled? my comment has been removed, but i was al listening with affiliation from neither side and i have to agree, the sufi chap got schooled
These barehlvis will never answer a question straight forwardly. They will never be logical, i do not c the point of all this, it is futile and a waste of time, abdurahman use ur time and energy on other deen stuff that will benefit you. This israr character hasnt a leg to stand on.
why's asrar turned up with a walking stick
Asrar Rashid was DESPERATE TO GO👀
I hope sincerely asrar rashid don't bring the same crew he sent down to murtza Khan debate. Appalling behaviour
😂 Allahuma baarik, ustadh Abdurrahman destroyed that guy while sipping his tea all chilled out lol
asrar rashid need to learn arabic language from ustadh abdur Rehman first .
Asrar rashid is shook and wallah he is rude an he said the word wtf in the clip 2:00:20 subhanallah and towards the end of the video he said do pray behind me sheikh conducting in this manner feel sorry for him may allah guide inshallah
Abdurrahman cooked Allahumma barik
at 1hr.20. he said they dont chant the naareh.. i recall when they went in to murtaza khan talk chanting all sorts. lol. playin in circles here
Barelvi are brothers of Shia. Both worship graves.
This is interesting
Can't he just answer all the questions or he just hiding lol
18:45 LOOOL Asrar Rashid backed down yo. 😂😂😂😂
+Dan Mush Akhee.. he did that throughout the ENTIREEEEEE 2 hour discussion... he kept backing out of EVERY point... watch and see for yourself!
+Naseeha Sessions dont be byest, come on thats a form of blindness i just analyse these brothers in an objective way khalas.
dawah Name Bro there is no bias in Imran's words. It's all on video 😂😂 I've watched nearly half an hour now and it's so clearly evident how worried Asrar Rashid is behaving.
How can Abdul Rahman be right? He only calls to Allan and not to allays creation?
According to my small mind profet musa help profet Mohammad not in this world,
Mohammad s.w helped his ummat in this
Asrar said I'm not Barelwi twice - so what is he then? Deobandi?! Wahhabi?! Shia?!
I want to be taught by him too imran
Plz teach me too
This asrar rashid needs to stop being ignorant and arrogant
masha'Allah abdur Rehman give evidence from Qur'an but mushrik israr not let to him finish his answer or when he read ayat from Qur'an , but please abdur Rehman read this ayat for mushrik israr rashid ( KHATAMALLAHU ALA QULUBIHIM,WA ALA SAM'IHIM WA ALA ABSARIHIM RISYAWAH WALAHUM AZABBUN ALIM.)sufi mushrik israr will die but he never accept ayat Qur'an because his grandfather name is ahmed raza khan bralwi
is it me or is ustadhs beard less than a fist length
+The time is near Slow hair growth like most somalis?
I just want to ask one thing were are my barelviooon bredrin at lol
Dang deep
المبتدع لا حرمةَ له
LOOOOOOOL