Bon came across more authentic because he was singing in his natural voice. He didn't have to push himself to get a "rock and roll voice", it was just there, seemingly without effort. He also had a swagger and charm that was unequalled. He made Mick Jagger look like an introvert, if such a thing is possible.
Nailed it an when Brain came he had more of a fast tuff guy routine an had to sing song written for another singer but when the wrote songs for Brian he nailed it
I saw Axl/DC in 2016 or thereabouts. I thought his singing was more than good enough and what he did do was stay out of the way. He sang and let the band carry the show which as an AC/DC fan I really appreciated. I wasn’t there to see Axl. As a performer he seemed to get that
The one really cool thing about this band is they’ve never relied on an image, hype or being pretty… They get so much respect just because of the pure soul of the music… I could just listen to Philip Rudd and Cliff Williams play rhythm tracks all day… And I miss Malcolm Young quite dearly.
I seen them in 16 as well, i’m not about Axl Rose myself but I have no disrespect towards the guy, he did do a good job but I think he should definitely be praised for what he did stepping up when Angus needed help, but I’m actually happy Brian is back.
I honestly loved Axl in AC/DC I thought his voice on the back in black tracks in particular was awesome. Frankly I would have loved an axl/dc album but I love the new AC/DC album. Through the mists of time.
i think Bon Scott was just a better front man , and his voice matched their style better. Anyways i like ACDC with both singers , but will always prefer Bon over Brian
Just a pity he couldn’t make different lifestyle choices and thereby render this analysis moot. He sadly left us just as the band was about to go mega. But could he have done what Brian has done since? We will never know.
@@davidgeisler9885 Brian was the one that made the band go huge. If Bon didn't die we wouldn't have ACDC as one of the top bands today. Bon started it but Brian took the band to the stars. I do think Bon was a better front man though. Brian is definitely a better singer.
Although the point and intention of this series is about replacement singer comparisons, there is a whole extra dynamic beyond the vocals when throwing in Axl's contribution. Axl said in an interview that he wasn't so sure that AC/DC would even want him, but almost felt a calling to help AC/DC out of the real crisis that they were in, if they weren't going to be able to finish the full tour commitment. The word was that it could have cost them about $20 million and caused irreparable damage to the band's relationships with the record company, promoters, etc. It was an extreme crisis for the band. Meanwhile, GnR was newly, finally, reunited, and had also just started out with new commitments themselves and about to start their Not in This Lifetime tour. Fortunately, the rest of GnR were supportive of what Axl wanted to do for AC/DC. But then to add on top of that, Axl breaks his foot in GnR's first reunion show. So now, Axl successfully manages to juggles both the AC/DC and GnR show commitments, despite having to do it with a broken leg, yet was on time for every show, ready to go and giving his best effort, almost humbly. Angus had spoken out that Axl was actually very professional, respectful, always on time and prepared for the shows. **That's a Whole Lotta Good Job Put Together!!** Axl has also obviously grown a lot since those early days, and is much more professional in GnR since the reunion and beyond, as well. He works very hard to do his best, and deserves so much more recognition, and much less focusing on the diminishing vocals and weight issues. He's so much more than than any of that. He's incredibly talented, rather a musical genius, very intelligent, actually a nice, funny guy, and too often misunderstood. Having an extremely horrible childhood, then adding the probable bipolar issues would mess with anyone, but imagine having the repercussions of having it highlighted constantly to the international masses, as part of the cost of fame. Yeah, he really deserves a break from the flack, and validation and credit where it's really due.
I saw GnR last September. Axl was on point. He nailed it. He looked genuinely happy and appreciative of the fans that turned out for the show. He may not have the range he once had, but he made up for it with putting on a great show. He had to have walked 5 miles during their set. He was all over the stage.
Someone once asked me to best describe the spirt of Rock and Roll in a couple words, I simply said Bonn Scott. For me he is simply one of the greatest front men of all time.
I really liked what Axl did filling in here, I like the angry trademark Axl sound and I thought it fit in really well and I was pleasantly surprised. But then I am no vocal expert but personally I liked it
Brian Johnson is the ultimate replacement singer. Love them both, but ultimately prefer Brian’s voice. Although my favorite record overall is Highway to Hell.
Bon did it better because it's easier to hear his words, Brian is all power and hard to understand, Axl was just filling in and did great. If Axl was around 30 and not 55 Axl would've dominated
I agree...Brian gets words wrong too..it makes me cringe..take highway to hell? Bon sings.."Livin easy..lovin free..? Brian says Livin both times...and when bon says.."goin Down..party time? Brian says... for the time lol!
@@isotopia7681 Bon was the best no doubt..but yeah..he was a drunk..but a functioning alcoholic...and yes..he'd been drinking all day before the show..everytime..and during live shows...check out ac/dc live on countdown..and rock goes to college at colchester.. on another note..Malcolm was very fussy and choosey bout his band... and auditioned many..but when bon came along..he simply asked..'you wanna join? Lol! anyone who couldn't perform through drink or drugs was gone...but with bon? He tolerated it..
Bon and Brian are both great in there own styles. Their voices portray power. Axel....did not match the power of AC/DC songs. He screams...and try but not good.
I’d love a whole episode on Axl’s singing method, he sounds different in pretty much every tour. 2010 was phenomenal, then 2011 onwards totally different.
He’s gained a lot more control instead of pushing scream notes the whole show and getting voice fatigue. Of course his singing is a lot less gutsy it used to be, but it’s great that he can do it.
He really does sound different. His tone and style say in 87 is utterly different to 93, which was different again to say 2010 and different again to 2016.
5 years ago today we crossed the pond for the final Ac/Dc gig in Philadelphia . Axl Rose was on lead vocals. - he was amazing and absolutely spot on! Ac/Dc songs suited him so well and he had the vocal range to sing both Bon and Brian’s songs effortlessly whereas I feel Brian’s voice doesn’t naturally suit the classic Bon songs . . Love Axl/GnR and love Ac /Dc and so it was the perfect combo for me and one of my favourite concerts ever!
My brothers favorite band is AC/DC. Mine is GnR. So to see them somewhat in the same band was awesome. IDC what flak axl gets now. But the dude really stepped up and helped them out and did a great job.
Bon is my personal favorite, I favor their more bluesy sound from early AC/DC. Really enjoy the first few albums Brian was on as well. As for Axl, I love when he’s all distorted, it’s so him and his unique persona. Wish he’d do it more often when he plays with GNR.
For me Bon Scott is the best! Very different sounding voice and had alot of charisma when performing. I often wonder how Back in Black would have sounded with Bon on lead vocals. But i do think Brian Johnson was an awesome replacement!
I've seen a lot of Bon Scott footage where he sang much better live than the videos shown here. That being said they are all great singers, but I think Bon just had the most charisma and showmanship. He gets my vote, even though their best album is probably Back in Black. Highway to Hell and Powerage are my other favorites. Great Band!
The Whole Lotta Rosie video chosen here was terrible. Plus, throwing in a snippet of Long Way to the Top, which Brian Johnson refuses to perform (he has said that is a Bon's song) - get out. Clearly, the video maker didn't study enough to know that is the ONE song they don't touch.
To be honest. Axl did a good job, kinda out of his comfort zone. It takes guts to step on stage and sing something you don't usually sing on a Tour Basis. But to compare all three, I think they all provided a good sense of style for the times they played with AC/DC. It was interesting to listen for the difference in sound within each vocalists. Good Stuff, Good Stuff.
The only thing I did not approve of Axl Rose being in AC/DC is because of his lack of professionalism. I knew he had the potential to do a good show because his vocal range and style is very similar to the sound of the band. But because AC/DC is a very professional minded band I feared that Axl was going to screw it up because of his antics. Stopping songs to call out members of the audience, showing up hours late before the designated time of the concert or not even showing up at all.
@@kgunitkeese17 Even though Malcolm wasn't there - his spirit is always there and no one fucked over Malcolm Young or Angus and Axl would know that and he showed the respect that was due.
@@kgunitkeese17 Angus had spoken out that Axl was actually very professional, respectful, always on time and ready to give his all. Axl stepping up to this helped save AC/DC from some terrible repercussions that would have happened, financially and otherwise, if they would not have been able to finish that tour commitment. Axl wanted to be able to help, never tried to upstage the band, and did a damm good job in this last minute challenge. Axl has also grown a lot since those days, and is much more professional in GnR since the reunion, as well.
It's safe to say Axl's short membership was simply a business arrangement to complete the tour dates when Brian was suddenly and affectionately fired because of his health issues. I doubt Angus had any genuine visions of making sweet music with Axl. Axl was simply chosen because of his fame to give the live shows something to buy on.
I agree and can't think of anyone else anywhere near his status that could have pulled it off. OK at the end of the day it was Guns n Roes sings Ac/DC but on the other hand it was Guns and Roses sings AC /DC, how unique is that!
Ken I just wanted to say thank you for being such a clean channel to watch. We can watch your channel and never worry about vulgar language or any nasty content.
Axl killed it ! They did songs they didn't played in a long time. Touch too much / Live Wire / If You want blood / Problem Child. Come on give the man some credit
Bon Scott was a comedic genius, he was seductive and dirty and enjoyed it, and a show man and a great lyrist. And it was a different group back then with different rhythms. When I was younger I prefer Brian Johnson now I like bon Scott and the sound of ACDC with bon Scott
Great video! I have to disagree with your initial assessment though - Bon Scott wasn't ducking notes and actually went higher than the studio version on the 'AAAAAAAAAALL!'. I've always found that Bon manages these sounds effortlessly, while Brian pinches and strains too much. He tenses his neck so much that his chin ends up resting on it, especially in more recent years.
In his prime, Axl was definitely the most accomplished of the three with his unbelievable range, different styles and vibratos. Bon Scott I agree is the trademark sound of ACDC. We all heard him first and he created the attitude of the band. I just simply love the sound of Brian Johnson's voice. It's like a '70s muscle car with a racing cam in it. If it idles down too far it stalls out, but when it's cranking it's nasty. The guy was born to sing rock. IMHO
I have a lot of respect for Brian how he helped carry the band on which would have taken a lot of bravery. However You can not get over the charisma and charm Bon brought to the stage. It's Bon for me. Also in 1974 Bon was in a motorcycle accident which lead to him being in a coma, when he came out his voice became a lot more raspier, if you look on his neck there is a scar which I am assuming was from the accident.
I'm a Scott fan hands down. I think he brought something to music that you can only be born with. ..... love your break downs and everything I learn from every video.
Also, like you said, Brian was always doing his interpretation of what Bon used to do and it was wrong. Bon didn't used to scream, this was the way his voice naturally sounded, Brian had to scream to even approach what Bon did naturally
I think its cool to see each singers different little styles and takes during their performances, they each have their own unique thing going on. I for one think Axl Rose did a phenomenal job filling in for Brian Johnson, It puts a smile on my face to see him up there with AC/DC knowing he is enjoying it yet being respectful with his stage presence not to make it all about himself. Some people don't like Axl Rose with AC/DC but I just think it's so cool! It's like one of my top all time singers mixed together with one of my favorite bands. I can only imagine the intensity attending one of those live shows with Axl Rose singing with AC/DC
Brian Johnson has somethig Bon and Axl are missing. It's the swing. When he sings it makes you wanna dance. Stiff Upper Lip is the best example of that
That is a really great record, and it shows the R&B blues and jazz roots of the band in the sound… There’s almost none of the early, snotty rebellious sound, it’s a different band. It’s like Led Zeppelin’s album Presents… Lots of groove.
Bon scott have the swag , better than Brian The big difference , As steven tyler with The 2 others , you forget . Is Bon did not only doo woop stuff , or Prog stuff ( Fraternity ) , as singer , he was a drummer and Snare champion ... And beign a drummer who sings advantage a lot of things in the way you place yourself , the impulsion and percussive of words . And the groove .
It’s like comparing Moët champagne with Newcastle Ale… Champagne is fantastic stuff, but sometimes you just want to sup a working man’s pint. Brian is like Newcastle with steak and kidney pie…
All three are great, but the sound of Brian Johnson have always been the perfect fit for AC/DC for me. Raised laryngeal position might inhibit the range, but man, what a great, unique sound he achieved with that. That's the tone I couldn't confuse with anybody else.
I think Brian Johnson did it best. That's why I own more Brian Johnson albums than Bon Scott albums. Axl Rose did a heck of a job filling in for Brian Johnson though.
I’ll go out on a controversial limb and suggest Bon didn’t not have the vocal power to rock the stadiums like Brian has so successfully done for 40 years since. I also prefer Brian’s sound but admit that could be because when I was getting into music Brian was in the driver’s seat. I think Bon’s bigger recording sound was more driven by studio techniques than Brian’s has been. Not that Brian wasn’t helped in the studio but he seems better able to replicate the records live.
@@davidgeisler9885 ..I think that may be partly why I much prefer Brian myself..I just discovered AC/DC when Back In Black came out..so it was Brian from the get-go on AC/DC for me..I remember back then, hearing some of their earlier work, and thinking:"something sounds odd about the vocals on those songs" to myself..I didn't even realize it was a different singer at first..similar enough for me to assume it was the same guy, but different enough for me to realize something was "off" or "different"..and even though I liked some of the songs, I must be honest and say I didn't like the sound of Bon's voice as much..later, I was discussing this with some guys, and they then told me:"oh, no..that's not Brian..that's Bon Scott..the original singer..he tragically passed away and Brian took his place"..then, I saw some pictures and a couple video clips of Bon singing with AC/DC..and I remember thinking he looked a bit odd/out of place with them, I think Brian's look fits in more with Angus and the other guys as well..not dissing Bon at all..he was the first with AC/DC, and nothing can take that away from him..although, Brian has been with them for a MUCH, MUCH longer time..now, had I known about/been an AC/DC fan from the very beginning, my opinion may have been very different..who knows..but, a person's personal place when being really into a band or singer, or any music in general, has much influence on his/her personal opinions and feelings about said band/singers/music....
I disagree because Bond was getting better and better with each album and the albums were selling better and better highway to hell was the bestselling album of bon Scott if he wouldn't have passed away tragically he would have took them to new heights too especially with his lyrics he always had the best lyrics a lot of his lyrics were funnier than s***the Jack whole Lotta Rosie can I sit next to you
Or his previous band Geordie. He sang with a lot of soul in some of their songs. A perfect example of that would have to be their rendition of house of the rising sun.
Axl for sure the strongest vocalist live out of all of them. I like Bon Scott’s tone a lot tbh. It’s tough to beat the original lead singers who set the precedent. Brian is a good compromise of the two.
One of my favorite clips of AC/DC is one of the early promo videos of a very young AC/DC band on a float going down a city street in Australia performing It's a Long way to the Top with Bon and the bagpipes. That video set the stage for what I expected from AC/DC from that point on, rocking and having fun and enjoying what they were doing. Axle made his Hay in the early days with the original GNR lineup. I saw them live in a fairly small indoor arena and his vocals were so very powerful. That was the time frame axle really was one of the best, but to me that was where he should remain!
@billwiley.... very interesting. IALWTTT was prob my intro to Acdc. Loved that song. I am actually wondering if they ever sang that song live on tour, even in the early days, and if there is even any audio bootlegs proving it. I have a few myself so must check that out. Perhaps the inclusion of the bagpipes was a reason for it not being a staple song. One things for sure, Brian would struggle delivering that song with kudos the way Bon did. Bons delivery was effortless and his raising the volume to his vocals without a struggle is why Bon will always be regarded as the ultimate ACDC singer
As a singer Brian is my favorite by a slight margin. The way his voice has changed over the years is very fascinating to me. Some say he just screams, but just compare him to anyone trying to imitate him in an AC/DC cover band. They lack the soul and bluesiness that's the basis of his high, distorted notes. Like this video shows, Brian is not really screaming even if it sounds powerful. He sings without ego or macho and is able to deliver even the worst AC/DC lyrics with soul. You just gotta love the guy. His enthousiasm compensates somewhat for his lack of lyrics. I don't even know how much he actually wrote; a lot of the lyrics since Back in Black seem to be from Angus. But Brian's dedication goes together with Angus' sober attitude, which is "we keep rocking no matter what", which is why Back in Black was such a monster album and why Brian has been in the band ever since. Bon was by far the greatest lyricst of course. His songs were fueled by pain and loneliness but they were also fun, being the template for later songs although they rarely got close. He gave AC/DC a darker edge that made the band deeper, which went well with the raw 70s production. His vocals and lyrics were uncompromised and honest. Axl is one of my favorite singers and frontmen but AC/DC doesn't cover his range, even if the man himself loves the band. Bon's material suited him better than Brian's, on which he went all out with distortion, which sounded way too angry compared to Brian's soul, but he did impress me with hitting all the high notes. Damn did he shred his voice during those AC/DC gigs. He probably wouldn't be able to do it again. But he was there when AC/DC needed it, giving the band fresh energy during a rough period. It was definitely a legendary crossover.
Check out Axl doing Whole Lotta Rosie back in the mid-80s too. He was a huge Bon Scott fan and his contribution to the band came from the heart, not just karaoke.
I'm definitely a fan of the bon era, I do like the first couple Brian records but not much after that. I will say that axl killed those bon Scott songs, absolutely incredible imo. The set list was a dream for early ac/dc fans like myself. A touch to much! Bon was a great lyricists for sure.
Imho it's impossible to compare Brian Johnson and Bon Scott. Johnson is a great rock n roll singer but Scott has a unique sound that goes beyond being a rock singer. Scott, performance included but not solely, oozes sex, without being obnoxious (like a certain replacement singer with Queen). I would've loved to heard Bon Scott sing Back in Black.
Cool series! I’d put what Axl did up against any current or former singer and bet they couldn’t do better than what he did for ACDC, from the saving them money on a tour contracts, to the performance, he was incredible and didn’t take the role for granted
I have to call it a draw between Bon and Brian, am a huge fan of both. Shout out to Axl, he had some big shoes to fill. Also, am a fan of Axl Rose, cannot forget he wrote and sang "Sweet Child of Mine" It's a masterpiece!
When I saw Axl on the Appetite for Destruction tour he crushed all the songs. I know that’s not the question, but when he was in his prime the concerts were phenomenal.
I would have liked to see you add Marc Storace and Udo Dirkscheinder to this one as both have been compared to Bon and Brian over the years and it would be cool to hear how they'd stack up.
I’m a massive Bon Scott fan cos I heard highway to Hell when I was 3 and it stuck in ma heed. Also, he was so charming and lovely. Bloody shame to leave him in that car.
You hit the nail on the head with the difference between Bon and Brian. Both awesome singers IMO. I do prefer Bon's voice for the songs he sang with the band. Bon definitely had the bar room voice, which I do prefer. However, Brian's voice is special too. Truly my favorite band. I'm 47 born in 1975. I should have been in high school in 75 😂😂
Bon Scott by a mile and says a hell of alot because AC/DC did alot of badass songs after his death but Bon Scott man justmour of this world/ Amcouple,of washed out jeans and some boots Haha no fancy / But untouchable as a frontman 🏅🥇🏅🥇♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Bon Scott's voice is the embodiment of rock and roll; raw, unpolished, emotional, rebellious, and sexual. Brian's voice is rock and roll intensity. I enjoy his live versions of Bon's stuff. Axl pleasantly surprised me. I salute him. If I were to hire a singer for my rock and roll band it would be Ronnie James Dio. Very close second would be Bon Scott. Ronnie and Bon sound like rock and roll to me. Great video.
To be honest, all the complaints about Axl, that's what I hear with Brian Johnson's voice. Not a slight on either of them. I just think that Axl was a perfect fit for the vocal style and I don't hear much difference between. Other than Axl's voice is Axl's voice. I just feel it was the right fit as GnR was a very similar kind of rock band to begin with. Though possibly inferior technically I favour Bon's voice as it comes across as less screechy.
I think the reason why most fans disapprove of Axl Rose because of his lack of professionalism tendencies. I personally wouldn’t want him in my band because of the fear of him showing up hours late before a concert. That to me is the worst level of professionalism you could ever receive.
@@kgunitkeese17 fortunately, he never showed any of it. Everything went off without a hitch, even as much as Axl probably should've gone into a bipolar panic.
Wish we have Axl sing for AC/DC when he's in his prime. The moment he fills the place of Brian was 20 +years vs Bon Scott or Brian, so 1996 Axl seems interesting to me.
Here we have 2 great singers and front men in Bon and Brian in my opinion I feel that if Bon was still around I could still see this band still being on top now as for Axle well he could fill in so many bands and pull it off no doubt but I think it would be hard to replace him in G&R
Bon is the winner. AC/DC has carried on, but all the magic was created with Bon. Bon was there for the grind and the rise. Ac/Dc's peak was Highway to Hell & Back and Black both masterpieces written by Bon. After the rise to the top Brian has done a great job keeping the spirit of the band alive and delivering great live concerts. 50 years later they still have the momentum that Bon created
Acdc are my favourite band of all time. I own every album, a stupid amount of memorabilia and have them tattooed on me. Bon Scott is lyrically leagues above Brian, he's a street poet, he's been around the block a million times. He's easier to imitate with his nasal tone, but unique in his front man presence, rivals Freddie Mercury but in a completely different way. He's one of my heroes, but the other hero of mine, Brian Johnson, has an insane range (look at House of the rising sun covered in his Geordie days). The vocal ability and range of Brian Johnson is vastly underestimated, he's able to transcend the limits of blues rock. The power of Brian is absolutely insane, I often find he gets ridiculed (when I go to see tribute acts) despite his unrivalled ability. There seems to be Bon Scott purists in the acdc community and it's very disappointing, because Brian took them to a completely different level, his actual singing is superior to Bons in my opinion. Whether you like the albums after back in black or not, there's no denying it's their best effort, it sent them into the stratosphere. If you're a true acdc fan, you have to take them hand in hand. They're just as perfect as each other, but somehow match each other in their importance and brilliance for the band. If the general Malcolm had Brian in the band for longer than Bon was alive, then there's a reason for it, because he was a true perfectionist. Fucking love em, appreciate them both 🤘
This is so illuminating, Ken. Thank you! To my ear, Brian sounded very different from 1995 onwards, in that he changed his technique to be more head voice than forced chest. My guess is that he had singing lessons around 1995. Do you think that you would be able to teach him now to extract more from his voice or would he be too set in his ways by this stage of his career?
Bon was effortless and little bit bluesy, brian is energetic, axl always with his special raspy voices (very good for brian's replacement). Behind these differences, there was a same thing that always appeared. That was angus' duckwalk😂
Bon - best Rock frontman of all time, you don't have to scream, it's all in the soul..like Paul Rodgers, Phil Lynott, Jim Morrison, Phil Mogg...it all comes from the blues, it's a feeling.
Ken, after you conclude this series, would you consider doing the flip-side of this, namely, analyzing vocal harmonies/shared vocals in bands? (Going from "Vs". to "working together", and how combined voices make a sum greater than the parts.) I'm thinking of examples like the harmonies in bands where the combined voices have a unique recognizable quality. Examples: Crosby, Stills, and Nash, The Beach Boys, Yes (Squire, Howe, and Anderson, or Squire, Anderson, Rabin), Simon and Garfunkle, Van Halen, etc. And how vocalists shared leads, like Waters/Gilmour/Wright of Pink Floyd, and how they complement each other by contrast ("Comfortably Numb", for example, Water's sinister spoken-word style vs. Gilmour's gentle, reassuring voice), examples like that. Alice In Chains comes to mind, as well (Staley and Cantrell). Or, an example like the Cars, where sometimes it's Ocasek on vocals, and sometimes Benjamin Orr. And as always, thanks for all you do!
(Oh, just thougt of another angle: Duets. Ozzy and Lita, Phil Collins and Phillip Bailey, Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush...Chris Cornell and Eddie Vedder... Stevie Nicks with Tom Petty or Don Henley...and Fleetwood Mac in general, of course...Buckingham/Nicks/McVie had some great harmonies...oh, and how could I forget Aerosmith's harmonies? Certainly unique and iconic.)
And I have to mention Queen in this regards; talk about vocal harmonies! And we all know that Freddy was great, but Roger Taylor was a vocal force in his own right! And together...well, "a kind of magic."
@@metalguru5226 Aren't they that boy band from the 60's? Of course, I've heard of them. ;) But I didn't mention them for the same reason I didn't mention the Eagles; notorious for blocking these kinds of videos on RUclips, sadly.
Scott was great but Brian Johnson was epic af. He took AC/DC into a new era and never soiled the old sound of Bonn’s but brought his own too. And Axl just kicks ass. Sorry but I think he was amazing running the group. What a front man. AC/DC was sooo lucky to have three A-plus vocalists in a row.
1977-1979, Bon Scott was at his peak. Listen to Powerage. His voice on that album is phenomenal. Brian Johnson was at his peak from 1980-1983. Listen to the album For Those About To Rock. He hits notes that hardly anyone can do. Right up there with Rob Halford. Axle Rose?? Perfect for Guns. Not so much for AC/DC. He sucked. But Angus needed a huge name to pull the rest of the tour off and continue. Personally, I think he should have offered it to the Krokus lead singer or the singer from Jackyl...
reminder, axl is a dedicated vocalist, on and off stage. duff said some thing about starting to warm up like an hour before a show. he had tardy tendencies, but brian never took care of his voice, and bon never lived long enough to damage his, save that bike crash, which was in a drunken rage after getting the boot from his last band. and that was pretty well bad luck, and one bad desicion. Brian? still smoking.
Angus said axl was showing up earlier than they were, ready to go before they even got to rehersals. He was always looking to Angus and the guys for approval, and axl himself said he liked having Angus as his boss. On stage, axl was going places Brian could ever only reach in the studio. Bon's voice was staring to show signs of breakdown on that last tour, and although Brian still has his voice, it would have been nice if he had preserved it a little better. Brian is the man, and his sound is irreplaceable, but axl did a stand up job
Strangely as a kid I had no idea AC/DC had different singers because to me they sounded alike... but now as an adult they sound totally different. Both very talented obviously, but have two different styles. As for Axl, again, it would be completely dull to ignore how talented he is as well but still his own distinctive sound and style to it that still fit well.
Heya Ken. So. I’ve been thinking about this for a while since you said it. Listen to Brian Johnson in Geordie. He was singing in a regular voice. Then, he gets the opportunity to audition for AC/DC and what does he do? He does his interpretation/impression of how he thinks Bon Scott sings….which in turn winds up giving him a unique voice…..But still puts him in that top end high register that you pointed out! I NEVER put that together until you pointed that out. Quite the ‘ah ha’ moment! Great connection Ken!
Bon Scott has a better tone and I think has better songs. Brian has great songs but not as good a tone. Axl Rose I love his AC/DC singing coz axl is my favourite singer
Too bad Axl ruined Guns n Roses... they could have been as good as ACDC but back then Axl was the biggest jerk in rock but now he's turned into a nice guy.
I think that "blues bar singer" sound of Bon is not a coincidence since a lot of the early songs had a lot of blues elements or where actually blues. He just sounded cool and nasty but with that "I know what I'm doing!" attitude. Pure rock'n'roll. With Brian ACDC got a cleaner sound which I think is not bad at all. When Axl stepped in I was really surprised when I heard a recording of him singing Highway to Hell. No matter who you are, it needs a lot of guts singing THE rock song of the century as a replacement. And he pulled it off like his life was depending on it. By the way I recommend to watch the performance from 1989 MTV Awards when he sang Free Fallin together with Tom Petty. It felt like Axl killed Toms confidence in his voice that night. :D
I love Bon and Brian, Bon’s cheekiness and song writing is what tips the scales for me personally🇦🇺. Top points to Axle for fronting AC/DC, turning up on time! He did a good job. It helps that I’m a huge GnR fan
YES, I agree with YOU!! And I wanted to write what I felt. Was able to go see & HEAR that very last RARE AC/Axl/DC show in PhilaHellphia, A MAZING SHOW! And I was lucky (enormously) to meet Axl & Angus after that (better than nothing) gig, I told Axl, YOU DID A GOOD JOB!! 👍 *seen AC/DC 34 times in 34 years. Helps that I'm a huge AC/DC fan, & do love GnR too! My birth/day/year was only 2 days before Axl Rose. *same age*
Bon is hard rock's Elvis. Period. His witty song writing, toilet poetry, stage persona and genius double entendre lyrics cannot be equaled. There's a lot more to the "sound-tone of the voice" when it comes to rock. That Brian guy has sounded the SAME for over 40 years. He just happened to be at the right place when AC/DC was in a business bind.
The main difference between Brian and Bon is of course that Brian is a better singer technically. Don't get me wrong, Bon could belt with the best of them, but his strength lay in the intimacy of his voice. When Bon sang it was like he sat just opposite of you and told you a story and he could make the fans feel that whether they were 200 or 20000. Brian brought, as you say, more muscle to the band and raised the bar, almost making the band more disciplined in his quest to not be the next Bon, but rather make his bones as his own man. He's done a wonderful job of it I'd say. Axl, being a huge fan of AC/DC, made a great impression as lead singer as Brian was forced to step back, but he does feel a tad light next to a behemoth such as Brian. Cool video man👍.
I just started recently watching your videos and I got to say with your musical talent and how you train your students and how they can sing is remarkable you are definitely the real deal and I don’t know if I can sing but I do love music and it would be an honor to be trained by you if I ever had the chance.
Imagine, you're AC/DC and Brian Johnson has to cancel for your tour that just started. If you cancel the tour, you lose a lot of money. What singer has the vocal range, experience on big stages and has the credibility to fill that empty spot. There are not that many candidates. Axl did at he had to do.
This analysis was very cool. Ken I have a suggestion which I would like to see; tour review and analysis of Survivor singers Dave Bickler, Jimi Jamison and Robin McAuley. Thoughts?
Bon came across more authentic because he was singing in his natural voice. He didn't have to push himself to get a "rock and roll voice", it was just there, seemingly without effort. He also had a swagger and charm that was unequalled. He made Mick Jagger look like an introvert, if such a thing is possible.
Nailed it an when Brain came he had more of a fast tuff guy routine an had to sing song written for another singer but when the wrote songs for Brian he nailed it
Quite right, though I think Axl when singing always has that kind of voice.
Ride on
I saw Axl/DC in 2016 or thereabouts. I thought his singing was more than good enough and what he did do was stay out of the way. He sang and let the band carry the show which as an AC/DC fan I really appreciated. I wasn’t there to see Axl. As a performer he seemed to get that
Axl/DC lol
The one really cool thing about this band is they’ve never relied on an image, hype or being pretty… They get so much respect just because of the pure soul of the music… I could just listen to Philip Rudd and Cliff Williams play rhythm tracks all day… And I miss Malcolm Young quite dearly.
I seen them in 16 as well, i’m not about Axl Rose myself but I have no disrespect towards the guy, he did do a good job but I think he should definitely be praised for what he did stepping up when Angus needed help, but I’m actually happy Brian is back.
i felt okay about acdc and gnr but axl/dc man…thats my kinda perfection😂
I honestly loved Axl in AC/DC I thought his voice on the back in black tracks in particular was awesome. Frankly I would have loved an axl/dc album but I love the new AC/DC album. Through the mists of time.
I was totally shocked, the summer I seen Axl Rose singing for AC DC. He did so well.
i think Bon Scott was just a better front man , and his voice matched their style better. Anyways i like ACDC with both singers , but will always prefer Bon over Brian
Just a pity he couldn’t make different lifestyle choices and thereby render this analysis moot. He sadly left us just as the band was about to go mega. But could he have done what Brian has done since? We will never know.
Check out my video of Marc Storace singing "Ride On"
@@davidgeisler9885 Brian was the one that made the band go huge. If Bon didn't die we wouldn't have ACDC as one of the top bands today. Bon started it but Brian took the band to the stars. I do think Bon was a better front man though. Brian is definitely a better singer.
@@racoon6299 100% agree my brother
@@racoon6299 I doubt that.
Although the point and intention of this series is about replacement singer comparisons, there is a whole extra dynamic beyond the vocals when throwing in Axl's contribution. Axl said in an interview that he wasn't so sure that AC/DC would even want him, but almost felt a calling to help AC/DC out of the real crisis that they were in, if they weren't going to be able to finish the full tour commitment. The word was that it could have cost them about $20 million and caused irreparable damage to the band's relationships with the record company, promoters, etc. It was an extreme crisis for the band. Meanwhile, GnR was newly, finally, reunited, and had also just started out with new commitments themselves and about to start their Not in This Lifetime tour. Fortunately, the rest of GnR were supportive of what Axl wanted to do for AC/DC. But then to add on top of that, Axl breaks his foot in GnR's first reunion show. So now, Axl successfully manages to juggles both the AC/DC and GnR show commitments, despite having to do it with a broken leg, yet was on time for every show, ready to go and giving his best effort, almost humbly. Angus had spoken out that Axl was actually very professional, respectful, always on time and prepared for the shows. **That's a Whole Lotta Good Job Put Together!!** Axl has also obviously grown a lot since those early days, and is much more professional in GnR since the reunion and beyond, as well. He works very hard to do his best, and deserves so much more recognition, and much less focusing on the diminishing vocals and weight issues. He's so much more than than any of that. He's incredibly talented, rather a musical genius, very intelligent, actually a nice, funny guy, and too often misunderstood. Having an extremely horrible childhood, then adding the probable bipolar issues would mess with anyone, but imagine having the repercussions of having it highlighted constantly to the international masses, as part of the cost of fame. Yeah, he really deserves a break from the flack, and validation and credit where it's really due.
Holy shit! That's the best comment I've ever read!
I saw GnR last September. Axl was on point. He nailed it. He looked genuinely happy and appreciative of the fans that turned out for the show. He may not have the range he once had, but he made up for it with putting on a great show. He had to have walked 5 miles during their set. He was all over the stage.
When Axl starts his high pitched wails you know it's about to be good
I can appreciate Axl's work ethic. It's always Bon for me. ❤️ It would be boring if we all liked the same.
Sorry bro I ain’t tryin to read a book rn
Someone once asked me to best describe the spirt of Rock and Roll in a couple words, I simply said Bonn Scott. For me he is simply one of the greatest front men of all time.
100% agree. He’s up there with Roth, Plant and Mercury for stage presence for me.
The very greatest in my opinion
Agree
Brian Johnson was actually famous before he joined AC/DC. He was the lead singer of the English band Geordie
Bon Scott was phenomenal. The Aussies will always rate Bon number 1
I really liked what Axl did filling in here, I like the angry trademark Axl sound and I thought it fit in really well and I was pleasantly surprised. But then I am no vocal expert but personally I liked it
i actually prefer Brian Johnson he sounded great in his prime, more throaty
Brian Johnson is the ultimate replacement singer. Love them both, but ultimately prefer Brian’s voice. Although my favorite record overall is Highway to Hell.
It's Bon singing on Highway to Hell.
thats why he said "although"@@andrewj4190
Bon did it better because it's easier to hear his words, Brian is all power and hard to understand, Axl was just filling in and did great.
If Axl was around 30 and not 55 Axl would've dominated
I actually think it's harder to understand Bon because he drunkenly stumbles over words a lot (imo)
@@JAce94007 and that's fine if we have different views.
I agree...Brian gets words wrong too..it makes me cringe..take highway to hell? Bon sings.."Livin easy..lovin free..? Brian says Livin both times...and when bon says.."goin Down..party time? Brian says... for the time lol!
@@isotopia7681 Bon was the best no doubt..but yeah..he was a drunk..but a functioning alcoholic...and yes..he'd been drinking all day before the show..everytime..and during live shows...check out ac/dc live on countdown..and rock goes to college at colchester.. on another note..Malcolm was very fussy and choosey bout his band... and auditioned many..but when bon came along..he simply asked..'you wanna join? Lol! anyone who couldn't perform through drink or drugs was gone...but with bon? He tolerated it..
@@isotopia7681In their 2001 documentary Angus says their first concert I guess Bon was loaded. And not just on booze.
I personally like Studio Bon Scott over studio Brian Johnson I think Axel did a great job filling in for Brian.
Bon Scott , there is no question 🎸
Bon and Brian are both great in there own styles. Their voices portray power. Axel....did not match the power of AC/DC songs. He screams...and try but not good.
I’d love a whole episode on Axl’s singing method, he sounds different in pretty much every tour. 2010 was phenomenal, then 2011 onwards totally different.
I would love to have Ken do a series too on Axl's voice changes through the years.
He’s gained a lot more control instead of pushing scream notes the whole show and getting voice fatigue.
Of course his singing is a lot less gutsy it used to be, but it’s great that he can do it.
He really does sound different. His tone and style say in 87 is utterly different to 93, which was different again to say 2010 and different again to 2016.
I thought Axle did a nice job, and...he showed up on time! 😆 🤣 😂 😹 😆
@@j_freed He can't.
Axl respect!!!
In fairness to Axl that audio was coming off a cell phone
5 years ago today we crossed the pond for the final Ac/Dc gig in Philadelphia . Axl Rose was on lead vocals. - he was amazing and absolutely spot on! Ac/Dc songs suited him so well and he had the vocal range to sing both Bon and Brian’s songs effortlessly whereas I feel Brian’s voice doesn’t naturally suit the classic Bon songs . . Love Axl/GnR and love Ac /Dc and so it was the perfect combo for me and one of my favourite concerts ever!
My brothers favorite band is AC/DC. Mine is GnR. So to see them somewhat in the same band was awesome. IDC what flak axl gets now. But the dude really stepped up and helped them out and did a great job.
Bon is my personal favorite, I favor their more bluesy sound from early AC/DC. Really enjoy the first few albums Brian was on as well. As for Axl, I love when he’s all distorted, it’s so him and his unique persona. Wish he’d do it more often when he plays with GNR.
For me Bon Scott is the best! Very different sounding voice and had alot of charisma when performing. I often wonder how Back in Black would have sounded with Bon on lead vocals. But i do think Brian Johnson was an awesome replacement!
I've seen a lot of Bon Scott footage where he sang much better live than the videos shown here. That being said they are all great singers, but I think Bon just had the most charisma and showmanship. He gets my vote, even though their best album is probably Back in Black. Highway to Hell and Powerage are my other favorites. Great Band!
The Whole Lotta Rosie video chosen here was terrible. Plus, throwing in a snippet of Long Way to the Top, which Brian Johnson refuses to perform (he has said that is a Bon's song) - get out. Clearly, the video maker didn't study enough to know that is the ONE song they don't touch.
Bon Scott up there as one of the BEST frontmen ever ❤️ He just had the X factor 👍✨
💯💯
To be honest. Axl did a good job, kinda out of his comfort zone. It takes guts to step on stage and sing something you don't usually sing on a Tour Basis. But to compare all three, I think they all provided a good sense of style for the times they played with AC/DC. It was interesting to listen for the difference in sound within each vocalists. Good Stuff, Good Stuff.
I just don't think he was the right choice for the band though.
The only thing I did not approve of Axl Rose being in AC/DC is because of his lack of professionalism. I knew he had the potential to do a good show because his vocal range and style is very similar to the sound of the band. But because AC/DC is a very professional minded band I feared that Axl was going to screw it up because of his antics. Stopping songs to call out members of the audience, showing up hours late before the designated time of the concert or not even showing up at all.
@@kgunitkeese17 Even though Malcolm wasn't there - his spirit is always there and no one fucked over Malcolm Young or Angus and Axl would know that and he showed the respect that was due.
@@kgunitkeese17 Angus had spoken out that Axl was actually very professional, respectful, always on time and ready to give his all. Axl stepping up to this helped save AC/DC from some terrible repercussions that would have happened, financially and otherwise, if they would not have been able to finish that tour commitment. Axl wanted to be able to help, never tried to upstage the band, and did a damm good job in this last minute challenge. Axl has also grown a lot since those days, and is much more professional in GnR since the reunion, as well.
It's safe to say Axl's short membership was simply a business arrangement to complete the tour dates when Brian was suddenly and affectionately fired because of his health issues. I doubt Angus had any genuine visions of making sweet music with Axl. Axl was simply chosen because of his fame to give the live shows something to buy on.
I think Axl did a amazing job. Thunderstruck suits him fine as wel. I think he actually did a better job with acdc then the gnr reunion tour
Yes he did ! Acdc tour blew out his voice. We can all thank acdc for that !
Amazing video ! Axls performance with AC/DC was proof he could still perform like he used to and he was an amazing replacement singer
I agree and can't think of anyone else anywhere near his status that could have pulled it off. OK at the end of the day it was Guns n Roes sings Ac/DC but on the other hand it was Guns and Roses sings AC /DC, how unique is that!
Ken I just wanted to say thank you for being such a clean channel to watch. We can watch your channel and never worry about vulgar language or any nasty content.
Thanks for including Axl. I also think he did a much better job than people gave him credit for considering.
Axl killed it ! They did songs they didn't played in a long time. Touch too much / Live Wire / If You want blood / Problem Child. Come on give the man some credit
Bon Scott was a comedic genius, he was seductive and dirty and enjoyed it, and a show man and a great lyrist. And it was a different group back then with different rhythms. When I was younger I prefer Brian Johnson now I like bon Scott and the sound of ACDC with bon Scott
Great video! I have to disagree with your initial assessment though - Bon Scott wasn't ducking notes and actually went higher than the studio version on the 'AAAAAAAAAALL!'. I've always found that Bon manages these sounds effortlessly, while Brian pinches and strains too much. He tenses his neck so much that his chin ends up resting on it, especially in more recent years.
In his prime, Axl was definitely the most accomplished of the three with his unbelievable range, different styles and vibratos. Bon Scott I agree is the trademark sound of ACDC. We all heard him first and he created the attitude of the band. I just simply love the sound of Brian Johnson's voice. It's like a '70s muscle car with a racing cam in it. If it idles down too far it stalls out, but when it's cranking it's nasty. The guy was born to sing rock. IMHO
You nailed it on all counts
Its like do you like Chocolate , Vanilla or Pistachio ice cream , they're all different
Been waiting for this one. Thanks for including Axl, I thought he rocked it!
I have a lot of respect for Brian how he helped carry the band on which would have taken a lot of bravery. However You can not get over the charisma and charm Bon brought to the stage. It's Bon for me. Also in 1974 Bon was in a motorcycle accident which lead to him being in a coma, when he came out his voice became a lot more raspier, if you look on his neck there is a scar which I am assuming was from the accident.
I'm a Scott fan hands down. I think he brought something to music that you can only be born with. .....
love your break downs and everything I learn from every video.
Also, like you said, Brian was always doing his interpretation of what Bon used to do and it was wrong. Bon didn't used to scream, this was the way his voice naturally sounded, Brian had to scream to even approach what Bon did naturally
I think its cool to see each singers different little styles and takes during their performances, they each have their own unique thing going on. I for one think Axl Rose did a phenomenal job filling in for Brian Johnson, It puts a smile on my face to see him up there with AC/DC knowing he is enjoying it yet being respectful with his stage presence not to make it all about himself. Some people don't like Axl Rose with AC/DC but I just think it's so cool! It's like one of my top all time singers mixed together with one of my favorite bands. I can only imagine the intensity attending one of those live shows with Axl Rose singing with AC/DC
Saw them twice and it was the best Rock N' Roll Show/Party ever! Düsseldorf 2016 best Show of my life, was bloody awesome!
Brian Johnson has somethig Bon and Axl are missing. It's the swing. When he sings it makes you wanna dance. Stiff Upper Lip is the best example of that
I agree completely. Hard rock is not dance music. But dangit if I don't want to get up and dance to ACDC. It's so weird.
That is a really great record, and it shows the R&B blues and jazz roots of the band in the sound… There’s almost none of the early, snotty rebellious sound, it’s a different band. It’s like Led Zeppelin’s album Presents… Lots of groove.
Bon scott have the swag , better than Brian
The big difference , As steven tyler with The 2 others , you forget .
Is Bon did not only doo woop stuff , or Prog stuff ( Fraternity ) , as singer , he was a drummer and Snare champion ...
And beign a drummer who sings advantage a lot of things in the way you place yourself , the impulsion and percussive of words .
And the groove .
Brian Johnsons iconic voice is great, Axl has way more power. Can‘t decide what I like more. Kinda do prefer Axl I guess.
It’s like comparing Moët champagne with Newcastle Ale… Champagne is fantastic stuff, but sometimes you just want to sup a working man’s pint. Brian is like Newcastle with steak and kidney pie…
Axl is the better singer in general but Johnson works better for the AC/DC stuff.
All three are great, but the sound of Brian Johnson have always been the perfect fit for AC/DC for me. Raised laryngeal position might inhibit the range, but man, what a great, unique sound he achieved with that. That's the tone I couldn't confuse with anybody else.
Bon was amazing, but play Brian Johnson guarantee you 100% of people will know exactly who it is.
No way Bon Scott all the way dead are alive Bon Was the man
Hellyeah Ken, I think that was a great analysis!👍💯
Appreciate it!
I think Brian Johnson did it best. That's why I own more Brian Johnson albums than Bon Scott albums. Axl Rose did a heck of a job filling in for Brian Johnson though.
Brian had a great voice in is prime.... power up is a great album how much longer will these guys keep playing lol
I just love Brian Johnson's entire vibe (and power, obviously). Bon's sound never did much for me personally.
I’ll go out on a controversial limb and suggest Bon didn’t not have the vocal power to rock the stadiums like Brian has so successfully done for 40 years since.
I also prefer Brian’s sound but admit that could be because when I was getting into music Brian was in the driver’s seat.
I think Bon’s bigger recording sound was more driven by studio techniques than Brian’s has been. Not that Brian wasn’t helped in the studio but he seems better able to replicate the records live.
@@davidgeisler9885 ..I think that may be partly why I much prefer Brian myself..I just discovered AC/DC when Back In Black came out..so it was Brian from the get-go on AC/DC for me..I remember back then, hearing some of their earlier work, and thinking:"something sounds odd about the vocals on those songs" to myself..I didn't even realize it was a different singer at first..similar enough for me to assume it was the same guy, but different enough for me to realize something was "off" or "different"..and even though I liked some of the songs, I must be honest and say I didn't like the sound of Bon's voice as much..later, I was discussing this with some guys, and they then told me:"oh, no..that's not Brian..that's Bon Scott..the original singer..he tragically passed away and Brian took his place"..then, I saw some pictures and a couple video clips of Bon singing with AC/DC..and I remember thinking he looked a bit odd/out of place with them, I think Brian's look fits in more with Angus and the other guys as well..not dissing Bon at all..he was the first with AC/DC, and nothing can take that away from him..although, Brian has been with them for a MUCH, MUCH longer time..now, had I known about/been an AC/DC fan from the very beginning, my opinion may have been very different..who knows..but, a person's personal place when being really into a band or singer, or any music in general, has much influence on his/her personal opinions and feelings about said band/singers/music....
Totally agree, I don't reckon acdc would've been as huge with bon up front.
I disagree because Bond was getting better and better with each album and the albums were selling better and better highway to hell was the bestselling album of bon Scott if he wouldn't have passed away tragically he would have took them to new heights too especially with his lyrics he always had the best lyrics a lot of his lyrics were funnier than s***the Jack whole Lotta Rosie can I sit next to you
If you want to hear Brian Johnsons's natural voice, listen to "Sky Hooks and Tartan Paint" from Sting's album "The Last Ship".
Good call, Chris! I'd never heard this one. It's a lot of fun!
Thanks for the tip, that's awesome
Or his previous band Geordie. He sang with a lot of soul in some of their songs. A perfect example of that would have to be their rendition of house of the rising sun.
@Bad Boys Boogie best cover of the animals
all because of you?
Axl for sure the strongest vocalist live out of all of them. I like Bon Scott’s tone a lot tbh. It’s tough to beat the original lead singers who set the precedent. Brian is a good compromise of the two.
Bon had it all, had the dirty lyrics dirty voice all suits for dirty rock n roll we all love 👍💪
I know it's not the most popular opinion, but for me it's Brian...how many generations have discovered back in black and become rock and ac dc fans ?
One of my favorite clips of AC/DC is one of the early promo videos of a very young AC/DC band on a float going down a city street in Australia performing It's a Long way to the Top with Bon and the bagpipes.
That video set the stage for what I expected from AC/DC from that point on, rocking and having fun and enjoying what they were doing.
Axle made his Hay in the early days with the original GNR lineup. I saw them live in a fairly small indoor arena and his vocals were so very powerful. That was the time frame axle really was one of the best, but to me that was where he should remain!
@billwiley.... very interesting. IALWTTT was prob my intro to Acdc. Loved that song. I am actually wondering if they ever sang that song live on tour, even in the early days, and if there is even any audio bootlegs proving it. I have a few myself so must check that out. Perhaps the inclusion of the bagpipes was a reason for it not being a staple song. One things for sure, Brian would struggle delivering that song with kudos the way Bon did. Bons delivery was effortless and his raising the volume to his vocals without a struggle is why Bon will always be regarded as the ultimate ACDC singer
As a singer Brian is my favorite by a slight margin. The way his voice has changed over the years is very fascinating to me. Some say he just screams, but just compare him to anyone trying to imitate him in an AC/DC cover band. They lack the soul and bluesiness that's the basis of his high, distorted notes. Like this video shows, Brian is not really screaming even if it sounds powerful. He sings without ego or macho and is able to deliver even the worst AC/DC lyrics with soul. You just gotta love the guy. His enthousiasm compensates somewhat for his lack of lyrics. I don't even know how much he actually wrote; a lot of the lyrics since Back in Black seem to be from Angus. But Brian's dedication goes together with Angus' sober attitude, which is "we keep rocking no matter what", which is why Back in Black was such a monster album and why Brian has been in the band ever since.
Bon was by far the greatest lyricst of course. His songs were fueled by pain and loneliness but they were also fun, being the template for later songs although they rarely got close. He gave AC/DC a darker edge that made the band deeper, which went well with the raw 70s production. His vocals and lyrics were uncompromised and honest.
Axl is one of my favorite singers and frontmen but AC/DC doesn't cover his range, even if the man himself loves the band. Bon's material suited him better than Brian's, on which he went all out with distortion, which sounded way too angry compared to Brian's soul, but he did impress me with hitting all the high notes. Damn did he shred his voice during those AC/DC gigs. He probably wouldn't be able to do it again. But he was there when AC/DC needed it, giving the band fresh energy during a rough period. It was definitely a legendary crossover.
Check out Axl doing Whole Lotta Rosie back in the mid-80s too. He was a huge Bon Scott fan and his contribution to the band came from the heart, not just karaoke.
X sure better than Brian.. he cannot sing Bon's song..!
I'm definitely a fan of the bon era, I do like the first couple Brian records but not much after that. I will say that axl killed those bon Scott songs, absolutely incredible imo. The set list was a dream for early ac/dc fans like myself. A touch to much! Bon was a great lyricists for sure.
Imho it's impossible to compare Brian Johnson and Bon Scott. Johnson is a great rock n roll singer but Scott has a unique sound that goes beyond being a rock singer. Scott, performance included but not solely, oozes sex, without being obnoxious (like a certain replacement singer with Queen). I would've loved to heard Bon Scott sing Back in Black.
Cool series! I’d put what Axl did up against any current or former singer and bet they couldn’t do better than what he did for ACDC, from the saving them money on a tour contracts, to the performance, he was incredible and didn’t take the role for granted
I have to call it a draw between Bon and Brian, am a huge fan of both.
Shout out to Axl, he had some big shoes to fill. Also, am a fan of Axl Rose, cannot forget he wrote and sang "Sweet Child of Mine" It's a masterpiece!
When I saw Axl on the Appetite for Destruction tour he crushed all the songs. I know that’s not the question, but when he was in his prime the concerts were phenomenal.
I'm going to comment before I even watch it. Although I love ac/dc with Brian. Bon will always be it for me. Axl=no.
I'm not a vocalist but this was a really fun video to watch. Great analysis
I would have liked to see you add Marc Storace and Udo Dirkscheinder to this one as both have been compared to Bon and Brian over the years and it would be cool to hear how they'd stack up.
I can't choose between Bon and Brian. Both are great imo. My daughter, whos 10, prefers Brian but likes both.
Only love for AC/DC,can’t even vote for anyone.Axl nailed it though !
I’m a massive Bon Scott fan cos I heard highway to Hell when I was 3 and it stuck in ma heed. Also, he was so charming and lovely. Bloody shame to leave him in that car.
You hit the nail on the head with the difference between Bon and Brian. Both awesome singers IMO. I do prefer Bon's voice for the songs he sang with the band. Bon definitely had the bar room voice, which I do prefer. However, Brian's voice is special too. Truly my favorite band. I'm 47 born in 1975. I should have been in high school in 75 😂😂
Bon Scott by a mile and says a hell of alot because AC/DC did alot of badass songs after his death but Bon Scott man justmour of this world/
Amcouple,of washed out jeans and some boots Haha no fancy /
But untouchable as a frontman 🏅🥇🏅🥇♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Bon Scott's voice is the embodiment of rock and roll; raw, unpolished, emotional, rebellious, and sexual. Brian's voice is rock and roll intensity. I enjoy his live versions of Bon's stuff. Axl pleasantly surprised me. I salute him. If I were to hire a singer for my rock and roll band it would be Ronnie James Dio. Very close second would be Bon Scott. Ronnie and Bon sound like rock and roll to me. Great video.
To be honest, all the complaints about Axl, that's what I hear with Brian Johnson's voice. Not a slight on either of them. I just think that Axl was a perfect fit for the vocal style and I don't hear much difference between. Other than Axl's voice is Axl's voice. I just feel it was the right fit as GnR was a very similar kind of rock band to begin with.
Though possibly inferior technically I favour Bon's voice as it comes across as less screechy.
Axl hit more of the notes than Brian's done in the last few decades so I found him more melodic. AC/DC in general has less range than GNR songs.
I think the reason why most fans disapprove of Axl Rose because of his lack of professionalism tendencies. I personally wouldn’t want him in my band because of the fear of him showing up hours late before a concert. That to me is the worst level of professionalism you could ever receive.
@@kgunitkeese17 fortunately, he never showed any of it. Everything went off without a hitch, even as much as Axl probably should've gone into a bipolar panic.
Bon had it natural! Didn't need to push anything and just had fun! Rock n Roll!!
Thanks for posting this and the science of singing and learning how each singer approaches the song.
the biggest thing for me is bonns lyrics and the way they were delivered a true poet of rock n roll.
The Very Best AC⚡DC Ever Was Bon period but
Thank you Brian for Doing your Very best
Wish we have Axl sing for AC/DC when he's in his prime. The moment he fills the place of Brian was 20 +years vs Bon Scott or Brian, so 1996 Axl seems interesting to me.
Check out covers Axl did back in the '80s! I love his Whole Lotta Rosie
I love Bon and Brian they're both awesome singers, I personally like Brian more but man it's a hard decision
I think axl did amazing job there, plus this is a mobile recording which i think cannot capture the real sound the audience is hearing live.
The awesome shirts are back! Axl is the man. Rock royalty and understood his role in the band.
Here we have 2 great singers and front men in Bon and Brian in my opinion I feel that if Bon was still around I could still see this band still being on top now as for Axle well he could fill in so many bands and pull it off no doubt but I think it would be hard to replace him in G&R
Great video. Don't forget Alice in Chains, Anthrax and Iced Earth.. 👍👍👍and here, I like Brian and Bonn, but Bonn Scott I preferre more..
Bon is the winner. AC/DC has carried on, but all the magic was created with Bon.
Bon was there for the grind and the rise.
Ac/Dc's peak was Highway to Hell & Back and Black both masterpieces written by Bon.
After the rise to the top Brian has done a great job keeping the spirit of the band alive and delivering great live concerts.
50 years later they still have the momentum that Bon created
Bon didn't write anything on Back in Black. That was all Brian, Angus and Malcolm who did the writing.
Acdc are my favourite band of all time. I own every album, a stupid amount of memorabilia and have them tattooed on me. Bon Scott is lyrically leagues above Brian, he's a street poet, he's been around the block a million times. He's easier to imitate with his nasal tone, but unique in his front man presence, rivals Freddie Mercury but in a completely different way. He's one of my heroes, but the other hero of mine, Brian Johnson, has an insane range (look at House of the rising sun covered in his Geordie days). The vocal ability and range of Brian Johnson is vastly underestimated, he's able to transcend the limits of blues rock. The power of Brian is absolutely insane, I often find he gets ridiculed (when I go to see tribute acts) despite his unrivalled ability. There seems to be Bon Scott purists in the acdc community and it's very disappointing, because Brian took them to a completely different level, his actual singing is superior to Bons in my opinion. Whether you like the albums after back in black or not, there's no denying it's their best effort, it sent them into the stratosphere. If you're a true acdc fan, you have to take them hand in hand. They're just as perfect as each other, but somehow match each other in their importance and brilliance for the band. If the general Malcolm had Brian in the band for longer than Bon was alive, then there's a reason for it, because he was a true perfectionist. Fucking love em, appreciate them both 🤘
This is so illuminating, Ken. Thank you! To my ear, Brian sounded very different from 1995 onwards, in that he changed his technique to be more head voice than forced chest. My guess is that he had singing lessons around 1995. Do you think that you would be able to teach him now to extract more from his voice or would he be too set in his ways by this stage of his career?
I'd be interested in that too. I'd like to know about Don Dokken too.
Bon was effortless and little bit bluesy, brian is energetic, axl always with his special raspy voices (very good for brian's replacement). Behind these differences, there was a same thing that always appeared. That was angus' duckwalk😂
Bon - best Rock frontman of all time, you don't have to scream, it's all in the soul..like Paul Rodgers, Phil Lynott, Jim Morrison, Phil Mogg...it all comes from the blues, it's a feeling.
Ken, after you conclude this series, would you consider doing the flip-side of this, namely, analyzing vocal harmonies/shared vocals in bands? (Going from "Vs". to "working together", and how combined voices make a sum greater than the parts.) I'm thinking of examples like the harmonies in bands where the combined voices have a unique recognizable quality. Examples: Crosby, Stills, and Nash, The Beach Boys, Yes (Squire, Howe, and Anderson, or Squire, Anderson, Rabin), Simon and Garfunkle, Van Halen, etc. And how vocalists shared leads, like Waters/Gilmour/Wright of Pink Floyd, and how they complement each other by contrast ("Comfortably Numb", for example, Water's sinister spoken-word style vs. Gilmour's gentle, reassuring voice), examples like that. Alice In Chains comes to mind, as well (Staley and Cantrell). Or, an example like the Cars, where sometimes it's Ocasek on vocals, and sometimes Benjamin Orr.
And as always, thanks for all you do!
(Oh, just thougt of another angle: Duets. Ozzy and Lita, Phil Collins and Phillip Bailey, Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush...Chris Cornell and Eddie Vedder... Stevie Nicks with Tom Petty or Don Henley...and Fleetwood Mac in general, of course...Buckingham/Nicks/McVie had some great harmonies...oh, and how could I forget Aerosmith's harmonies? Certainly unique and iconic.)
And I have to mention Queen in this regards; talk about vocal harmonies! And we all know that Freddy was great, but Roger Taylor was a vocal force in his own right! And together...well, "a kind of magic."
@@joemaurone7923 Ever heard of the Beatles?
@@metalguru5226 Aren't they that boy band from the 60's?
Of course, I've heard of them. ;) But I didn't mention them for the same reason I didn't mention the Eagles; notorious for blocking these kinds of videos on RUclips, sadly.
Absolutely killing it Ken, love you my man. Keep on rocking in the free world
Love these videos. You do a very good job pointing out the differences. I love your voice as well. You have great tone and range.
Scott was great but Brian Johnson was epic af. He took AC/DC into a new era and never soiled the old sound of Bonn’s but brought his own too. And Axl just kicks ass. Sorry but I think he was amazing running the group. What a front man. AC/DC was sooo lucky to have three
A-plus vocalists in a row.
Great chat. Thank you. Music is also memories. And so for a middle Aussie like me it's always Bon Scott. He is the soundtrack of my life.
1977-1979, Bon Scott was at his peak. Listen to Powerage. His voice on that album is phenomenal. Brian Johnson was at his peak from 1980-1983. Listen to the album For Those About To Rock. He hits notes that hardly anyone can do. Right up there with Rob Halford. Axle Rose?? Perfect for Guns. Not so much for AC/DC. He sucked. But Angus needed a huge name to pull the rest of the tour off and continue. Personally, I think he should have offered it to the Krokus lead singer or the singer from Jackyl...
reminder, axl is a dedicated vocalist, on and off stage. duff said some thing about starting to warm up like an hour before a show. he had tardy tendencies, but brian never took care of his voice, and bon never lived long enough to damage his, save that bike crash, which was in a drunken rage after getting the boot from his last band. and that was pretty well bad luck, and one bad desicion. Brian? still smoking.
Angus said axl was showing up earlier than they were, ready to go before they even got to rehersals. He was always looking to Angus and the guys for approval, and axl himself said he liked having Angus as his boss. On stage, axl was going places Brian could ever only reach in the studio.
Bon's voice was staring to show signs of breakdown on that last tour, and although Brian still has his voice, it would have been nice if he had preserved it a little better.
Brian is the man, and his sound is irreplaceable, but axl did a stand up job
Hey, you could do an episode about Nightwish, not a big fan, but it could be really interesting!
I did. ruclips.net/video/-GqhifV06Ew/видео.html and ruclips.net/video/1ZlmZeMXzKA/видео.html and ruclips.net/video/S6q9w7tx9Dw/видео.html
Strangely as a kid I had no idea AC/DC had different singers because to me they sounded alike... but now as an adult they sound totally different. Both very talented obviously, but have two different styles. As for Axl, again, it would be completely dull to ignore how talented he is as well but still his own distinctive sound and style to it that still fit well.
Heya Ken. So. I’ve been thinking about this for a while since you said it. Listen to Brian Johnson in Geordie. He was singing in a regular voice. Then, he gets the opportunity to audition for AC/DC and what does he do? He does his interpretation/impression of how he thinks Bon Scott sings….which in turn winds up giving him a unique voice…..But still puts him in that top end high register that you pointed out! I NEVER put that together until you pointed that out. Quite the ‘ah ha’ moment! Great connection Ken!
Bon is the man.
Wow! Always interesting watching these videos! Really love the way you tackle everything that makes a singer great!! Have a great day Ken!
Bon Scott has a better tone and I think has better songs. Brian has great songs but not as good a tone. Axl Rose I love his AC/DC singing coz axl is my favourite singer
Too bad Axl ruined Guns n Roses... they could have been as good as ACDC but back then Axl was the biggest jerk in rock but now he's turned into a nice guy.
@@leadnsteel1428 he didn’t ruin gnr he’s not the one that left
I think that "blues bar singer" sound of Bon is not a coincidence since a lot of the early songs had a lot of blues elements or where actually blues. He just sounded cool and nasty but with that "I know what I'm doing!" attitude. Pure rock'n'roll. With Brian ACDC got a cleaner sound which I think is not bad at all. When Axl stepped in I was really surprised when I heard a recording of him singing Highway to Hell. No matter who you are, it needs a lot of guts singing THE rock song of the century as a replacement. And he pulled it off like his life was depending on it. By the way I recommend to watch the performance from 1989 MTV Awards when he sang Free Fallin together with Tom Petty. It felt like Axl killed Toms confidence in his voice that night. :D
I love Bon and Brian, Bon’s cheekiness and song writing is what tips the scales for me personally🇦🇺. Top points to Axle for fronting AC/DC, turning up on time! He did a good job. It helps that I’m a huge GnR fan
YES, I agree with YOU!! And I wanted to write what I felt. Was able to go see & HEAR that very last RARE AC/Axl/DC show in PhilaHellphia, A MAZING SHOW! And I was lucky (enormously) to meet Axl & Angus after that (better than nothing) gig, I told Axl, YOU DID A GOOD JOB!! 👍 *seen AC/DC 34 times in 34 years. Helps that I'm a huge AC/DC fan, & do love GnR too! My birth/day/year was only 2 days before Axl Rose. *same age*
WITHOUT Bon lyrics and singing we would not even be talking about AcDC I firmly believe that
Bon is hard rock's Elvis.
Period.
His witty song writing, toilet poetry, stage persona and genius double entendre lyrics cannot be equaled. There's a lot more to the "sound-tone of the voice" when it comes to rock.
That Brian guy has sounded the SAME for over 40 years. He just happened to be at the right place when AC/DC was in a business bind.
Absolutely agree Buddy
So true, Bon was the man!
Exactly. Rock is not about technical ability. Rock is fucking attitude. Bon Scott had it in Aces. Brian Johnson is a toad and Axl is a turd.
As usual good job...I have another unusual isolated vocals recommendations. You haven't used any yet 😉but how about going over Suzuka Nakamoto?
The main difference between Brian and Bon is of course that Brian is a better singer technically. Don't get me wrong, Bon could belt with the best of them, but his strength lay in the intimacy of his voice. When Bon sang it was like he sat just opposite of you and told you a story and he could make the fans feel that whether they were 200 or 20000. Brian brought, as you say, more muscle to the band and raised the bar, almost making the band more disciplined in his quest to not be the next Bon, but rather make his bones as his own man. He's done a wonderful job of it I'd say. Axl, being a huge fan of AC/DC, made a great impression as lead singer as Brian was forced to step back, but he does feel a tad light next to a behemoth such as Brian. Cool video man👍.
I just started recently watching your videos and I got to say with your musical talent and how you train your students and how they can sing is remarkable you are definitely the real deal and I don’t know if I can sing but I do love music and it would be an honor to be trained by you if I ever had the chance.
Imagine, you're AC/DC and Brian Johnson has to cancel for your tour that just started. If you cancel the tour, you lose a lot of money. What singer has the vocal range, experience on big stages and has the credibility to fill that empty spot. There are not that many candidates. Axl did at he had to do.
This analysis was very cool. Ken I have a suggestion which I would like to see; tour review and analysis of Survivor singers Dave Bickler, Jimi Jamison and Robin McAuley. Thoughts?