of course they are, they are trained to be vocalists although different people have different techniques, tones, and skills. However, somehow I can feel their sadness from their eyes, feeling that the performance is incomplete without Wendy :(, or maybe I am just being sentimental
@@btsismyoxyjin6577 someone who didnt have any predebut exposure. She was the only one in Red Velvet who was never revealed to the public until her debut. She was the only one who was never added to SMRookies. She was known to be the hidden trainee predebut.
아는사람들은 모두 인정하는 기적의 합동공연. 이건 불가능한 무대다. 원래 무대에 오를사람이 병원에 실려가서 나머지 멤버들이 남은 그 짧은 시간동안 무대를 준비해서 이렇게 훌륭하게 빈자리를 메꿔준다고? 너무나 노래하고싶던 웬디의 간절함을 생각하는 마음과 레드벨벳을 끝까지 믿고 무대를 꾸며준 MBC와 성시경에 대한 감사함, 그리고 마음만 가지고는 할수 없는걸 뒷받침해주는 탄탄한 실력과 시간적 장애를 극복하기 위한 노력까지 곱씹을수록 레드벨벳을 칭찬하게되는 무대다
I was thinking the same but to me Seulgy did the highest normally Wendy does. Seulgy is really good (singer) in her own way, she just need more confidence in herself.
From my opinion, Yeri and Joy fit this song the most. Yerim's harmonization never disappoint me, I swear. But all of them did superly great. I feel like crying because I'm missing them too much and this is my fav song from IU. Let's give round of applause to all of them for covering Wendy's absence, they need more love and strength at these times, luvies. I can see they are struggling much to keep it up with their emotion and nervousness especially that they're collaborating with one of the experienced and best vocalists in this industry. I feel so worried because their voices somehow tremble, but really, good work, red velvet! You've worked hard! Thank you for being with us till the end of 2019. Let's be together again in 2020!
Secret BxT yeri’s voice always compliments well with others. She harmonies so well with the guy’s high tone by singing the low range with her sweet angelic voice 🥺 She’s the best for collabs and ost. Also big shout out to Joy with her voice full of emotions also good for osts.
rv choosing to do a vocal stage for the special stage just shows how much confidence they have in their vocals and even with missing their main vocal (get well soon wendy) they still put on a great performance. let's hope 2020 is a good year for red velvet
Yohane Descends I agree, but it’s not like they had much of a choice. They can’t change the set and song choice last minute, especially with all their practice. Red Velvet will always pull through, even if they don’t a have a member. Get well soon, Wendy. ❤️
Seeing so many comment about Joy’s vocals makes me so happy her vocals are so underrated and she rarely get the chance to show off See SM she deserves more singing activities!!!
selena azalea I’m a Reveluv so I know she gets much likes I’m not taking about the amount of lines but the hype she gets for it most people y’all about her visuals etc not her vocals
JOY - Main Vocalist our tone fairy - To tier Visual - Such a graceful dancer - Variety show queen - Such a good actress - Sexy - Perfect body proportion - Fashionista - It girl Damn STANNING JOY is the best thing happened to me
Damn, Joy's voice is giving me serious goosebumps! She should really consider releasing a duet with Sung Si Kyung someday because that's how good they sound together. Although Joy's singing is so underrated, I feel like she's already better than the lead vocalists of many girl groups.
Видеоклипы![데이식스 영케이(Young K) & 치즈(CHEEZE) ‘그대네요'(It’s You) │아이유(IU), 성시경을 잇는 감동 콜라보!! [it's KPOP LIVE 잇츠라이브]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2oLYp1SvKZQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![데이식스 영케이(Young K) & 치즈(CHEEZE) ‘그대네요'(It’s You) │아이유(IU), 성시경을 잇는 감동 콜라보!! [it's KPOP LIVE 잇츠라이브]](/img/tr.png)
![[HOT] OH MY GIRL X ASTRO - The red shoes ,2019 MBC 가요대제전 : The Chemistry 20191231](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AvFQxC5FFWc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[띵곡플레이어] 조이가 Joy했다♡(feat.옥구슬🔮메들리♬) ㅣ KBS방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/B-9c-osZ1jc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Eminem - The Death of Slim Shady [Graveyard Album Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vOJD-6vQpXU/mqdefault.jpg)
The feels when you know Red Velvet are still the superior vocalists without their main vocalist Queen Wendy
Damn ur right🔥🔥
Vocal Queen indeed💚
of course they are, they are trained to be vocalists although different people have different techniques, tones, and skills. However, somehow I can feel their sadness from their eyes, feeling that the performance is incomplete without Wendy :(, or maybe I am just being sentimental
@@tangon2202 my thoughts actually,,, i'm crying
@@tangon2202 my thoughts as well. 😔
Joy's voice oh my gosh ㅠㅠ
We deserve more ballad song from her
She made me cry..i don’t even understand lyrics..
she made me cry literally
The harmonization at 2:40 ㅠㅠ
Joy really does have an ability to convey the full emotion of the song even when you don't know the lyrics. One of my favorite voices ever.
You know why Joy is a hidden trainee? THIS.
What is hidden trainee??
@@btsismyoxyjin6577 someone who didnt have any predebut exposure. She was the only one in Red Velvet who was never revealed to the public until her debut. She was the only one who was never added to SMRookies. She was known to be the hidden trainee predebut.
@@jenskie16 Oo....ok . Thanks for replying
@@jenskie16 high ihihigig
She is diamonds in SM.. 👏👏👏👏
Everyone talking about Joy and I understand why
I love their vocals, but to be honest, Joy's vocal really match with him pls smstation for them....
Red velvet's Irene Intro made my 2019 complete
아는사람들은 모두 인정하는 기적의 합동공연. 이건 불가능한 무대다. 원래 무대에 오를사람이 병원에 실려가서 나머지 멤버들이 남은 그 짧은 시간동안 무대를 준비해서 이렇게 훌륭하게 빈자리를 메꿔준다고? 너무나 노래하고싶던 웬디의 간절함을 생각하는 마음과 레드벨벳을 끝까지 믿고 무대를 꾸며준 MBC와 성시경에 대한 감사함, 그리고 마음만 가지고는 할수 없는걸 뒷받침해주는 탄탄한 실력과 시간적 장애를 극복하기 위한 노력까지 곱씹을수록 레드벨벳을 칭찬하게되는 무대다
헐 아 원래 성시경하고 웬디만 하는 듀엣이였어요?
@@user-mq7yn7pf6y 성시경 님이랑 레드벨벳 멤버 5명이 꾸며야할 무대였어요! 아무래도 웬디가 메인보컬이니까 파트도 많았을텐데 그 짧은 시간에 파트분배도 다시하고 했을거에요 멤버들.. ㅠㅠ
옆동네 s로 시작하는 곳과는 다르게 잘해주었죠 ㅠㅠ
왜 이 댓글 눈물 나지,,,
아...그 때의 무대였구나 왜 웬디는 없나 했네요...
슬기가 가장 안정적이게 잘 부르는데 성시경과 목소리 합이 잘 안맞는것 같고 조이는 역시 음색이 너무 좋은데 성시경과 목소리합까지 잘맞아서 제일 확 눈이 가는듯
rla alsdud 그러게요. 슬기가 초반에 부르다가 너무 높고 튄다고 느끼는지 바로 음역 수정해서 부르네요.
@@user-gn6hp2si3o 저만그런거 느낀 게아니얐군요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 저는 슬기가 실수한줄....
새벽 원곡에서도 높았다가 음 낮아져요 원래!! 슬기가 수정한게 아니라
@@Eliana_96 그러킨한데 이유랑높게부른거랑 슬기기높게부른게 슬기기좀더튀는듯한느뀜?
이녕 네 그게 음이 다른게 아니라 슬기 목소리가 튀는거라는 말이에요! 음은 같고
Imagine being an SM group and you have to fill in the space of your main vocal. Red Velvet did *that.*
Joy's honey vocals 😭😭😭
JOY REALLY NEEDS A SOLO!!
근데 아무리 봐도 성시경이 돌아가면서 듀엣 맞추는 거 너무 웃긴 기획임ㅋㅋ 회전초밥도 아니구..근데 역시 성시경 진짜 노래 잘한다
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
성시경 ㅈㄴ여유로움 ㄹㅇ 처진눈이라 더그런가 자기집안방에서 부르듯 편안..
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-hp6uf5zl7p ㅅㅂㅋㅋ
Joy's voice is really suitable to this song
Guess joy and seulgi shared Wendy’s part they are so great 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I do think the same too ....seulgi n joy got many lines..
Wendy must be proud ...since she watching it live too at hospt !!
Feels like half of them are main vocals and the rest are lead vocal
Yaaas, our queens consists of all vocals ❤️💛💚💙💜
I was thinking the same but to me Seulgy did the highest normally Wendy does. Seulgy is really good (singer) in her own way, she just need more confidence in herself.
@@heyylemo ahh really?? I thought it was live ...
Joy perfect.
Joy 💚
i love how joy became confident in singing
Me too 😭😭💚 loyalty stanning her for 4 years I have no regrets 😢❤️
Lol your username 😂
Me too, i love her so much
Red Velvet = Real Vocal = Real Visual
Periodt
RV=RV
joy becomes prettier each time, she sings even better each time.
True...
💯💯
I love Joy voice. She needs a solo. Please SM we need a solo for Joy
I👏🏻NEED👏🏻JOY👏🏻TO👏🏻DROP👏🏻ANOTHER👏🏻BALLAD👏🏻SONG👏🏻
JOY VOCAL GUYS. OMG I SAID JOY VOCAAAAL
The audience want joy solo
2:50 이 부분 보러 온다고 해도 될 만큼 진짜 조이 음색이 너무 예쁨 ㅜㅜ 개인적으로 제일 좋아하는 부분
Yeri Low note😭
Irene Sweet Voice
Joy Honey Voice
Seulgi Highnote
And Sikyung too, they are amazing😭😭. Their emotion make me cry
Joy's voice give out such a deep emotion she really suits this song
So true
mina is bae her voice giving me chills
That voice is so precious 💚
Listen it trhough earphone. Like damn seriously. I feel so emotional
Her voice is so emotionally filled.
JOY😭💚
Joy's voice and visual is out of this world.
I love her 💚💙
Me too
So true 😍
how can joy have that much emotions in her voice
even when i see her expression it makes me sad somehow
Bec. She sings from her heart that is. 🤗🥰
Joy's honey voice. Im inlove 😍
이마리 a monbebe and reveluv?! We stan!!
@@ashanab.7105 YES! 😍
Joy's singing skill is not joke.
because i love joy she is biaswrecker
조이 음색 너무 좋다..아니 다 좋네..근데 진짜 조이 너무 좋다 저런 목소리가 조금이라도 잘못 부르면 바로 삑사리 타기 쉬워서 보통 가성으로 넘겨버리는데 조이는 다 진성이야ㅠㅜㅜ이때 웬디도 불렀다면 참 좋았을텐데 그래도 다시 완전체 복귀했으니 됐다됐어 ㅠㅜㅠㅜ
Joy is honey voice and now Joy is tone fairy 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
JOY can always bring her emotions
she is known as tone fairy for a reason
She made me cry
Yes .. 🥰🥰🥰
You forget she’s an actress
@@ultlalisam476 even so.. She sings from her heart. It's not an act.
Joy the tone fairy 😍
joy here is looking like snow white 😍
From my opinion, Yeri and Joy fit this song the most. Yerim's harmonization never disappoint me, I swear. But all of them did superly great. I feel like crying because I'm missing them too much and this is my fav song from IU.
Let's give round of applause to all of them for covering Wendy's absence, they need more love and strength at these times, luvies. I can see they are struggling much to keep it up with their emotion and nervousness especially that they're collaborating with one of the experienced and best vocalists in this industry. I feel so worried because their voices somehow tremble, but really, good work, red velvet! You've worked hard! Thank you for being with us till the end of 2019. Let's be together again in 2020!
Secret BxT yeri’s voice always compliments well with others. She harmonies so well with the guy’s high tone by singing the low range with her sweet angelic voice 🥺 She’s the best for collabs and ost. Also big shout out to Joy with her voice full of emotions also good for osts.
yeah...Yeri is the best for harmonizing with other and well she great at low voice
yess
Yeri's low voice is really something
Gosh .. I wanna cry because your comment >,<
Thanks for appreciate yeri >,< ♡♡♡
Joy's voice sounds perfectly suit on the Sung sikyung's voice
JOY THE WEAPON OF SM
Joy's vocal visual is next level
Joy just stole my heart💚
Same dear😍
When your name is Joy and you just scrolling through these comments like 😊😂
stanning joy was my best choice , she never disappoints
period. she is my bias. I stanned the right one 😌
Yeahh
아니조이음색진짜
사르르 녹는중인 눈같음..
겨울이긴한데.. 아련하게 녹아가는 겨울
Seulgi and joy’s high notes omg...😭💞💞💞
Joy hitting the high note plus her pretty face💚💚💚
Joy's voice is the best
We need a joy solooo😭💚
Joy voice match with Si Kyung voice😍
Joy is so cute with this hairstyle😍
Joy 💚💚💚💚😍
Joy has a good voice and a high note
Red Velvet out here flexing vocals without their main vocalist
Seulgi carrying the torch.
Joy unique tone fit this song the best, she sounded amazing💚💚
If you see this, don't forget to note the 31st of May for the FIRST SOLO JOY DEBUT
아이린도 도입부 짱이고 목소리 매력있고 난 특히 예리의 얇지만 탄탄한 뭔가 살랑이는 음색도 좋더라ㅠㅠ 레드벨벳은 음색도 다 다르고 각자 다른 5명의 매력들이 한 팀에 모여서 잘 어우러졌어. 레드벨벳 오래가길
맞아요..예리짱 파트좀 늘려주면 좋겠어염
JOY 💚💚💚💚
Yeri's harmonization. Joy fits the song very well. As expected from Red Velvet.
I comeback again here because of Joy's beautiful voice
me too
Yep me too
Same here
I love how most of the comments here are for Joy.
Joy looks so confident. I’m a proud mom T.T
Joy's voice fits the song 😍
Joy’s voice make me comeback here💚
조이 목소리 정말 쨍하니 맑고 이뿌다. 10대 20대때의 S.E.S 의 바다, 아이즈원의 채연 등이 이런 쨍하니 정오의 여름햇살같이 만년설이 녹아 흐르는 물같이 맑고 깨끗한 목소리를 갖고 있음. 조이 남기키에 맞춰서 고음을 아끼는 저 배려심.
채연이 아니라 채원이 아닌가요,,???
@@user-iw1lw8qd7r 채연도 있어요ㅎㅎ
채원이가 아무래도 음색이 맑고 깨끗해서 윗윗 댓분이 그렇게 생각하신 게 아닐까요...?? 채원이 음색이 유명해서
채연이 음색..?
원곡에서도 원래 고음안지르는 부분아님..?
rv choosing to do a vocal stage for the special stage just shows how much confidence they have in their vocals and even with missing their main vocal (get well soon wendy) they still put on a great performance.
let's hope 2020 is a good year for red velvet
Are they going to sing more?
I love my vocals queens
Yohane Descends I agree, but it’s not like they had much of a choice. They can’t change the set and song choice last minute, especially with all their practice. Red Velvet will always pull through, even if they don’t a have a member. Get well soon, Wendy. ❤️
Yves’ Apple even if wendy was there, they still chose to do a vocal-heavy song while their peers did a lot of idol covers
Catarina Ferreira they have an event on the 4th but that will be the end of the psycho era unless sm suddenly announce something else
Joy looking like barbie😩
Wendy unnie, get well soon. We will wait for you patiently.
Joy is a Queen👑
조이 너무 노래 잘한다 감성적인 노래에 정말 잘어울려 ㅠㅠ 그리고 아이유 목소리 팍 꽂히는 인트로가 중요한 노랜데 아이린이 나름 잘 소화했다고 생각함 음색 잘어울려 ~~
인트로는 슬기가 했어야댐 딱바도 얼굴땜에 아이린을 첫빠따로 세운거구만
웬디님도 목소리 좋으신데 스브스 sbs끼들이...
맞아요 아이린 음색 진짜 좋은데 사람들이 몰라ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@user-mo5nd8qv7e 배주현도 존나 잘하는데요 ..
@@user-mo5nd8qv7e 니 레드벨벳한테 악감정있냐ㅋㅋ 열등감에 찌들어선 그딴말을 처뱉고다녀
Joy's voice like super super soft😭. So unique, you don’t need to watch to know it was her🥰
joy really went from lead rapper to lead vocals and I'm nothing but proud of her development, both in vocals and confidence 💚
왜 성시경 칭찬은 없지ㅠㅠㅠ후배들 맞춰주면서 부르는데 너무 감미롭게 잘불렀는데ㅠㅠ
메시 축구 잘한다고 얘기하는 꼴이라..ㅋㅋ
그냥 레전설이지 성발라는 너무 당연함
Joy can do acting, singing, variety, even musical or CF in the future.
I support JOY 💓
Joy's voice always makes me cry 😭😭😭 hope she will get a duet song again
*Joy really improved she’s way more relaxed on her mixed register.*
Yes i agree. She's more confident in singing now, i hope she will keep training her vocal technique because she already has a sweet tone.
Joy Unnie... You can just kill me.. I'll die happily💚💚💚
@greenfairy_ joy Though couldn't monetarily, I did stream her.. She is amazing💚💚
Joy's voice is lovely as her look...she has a dynamic looks...
Seulgi's cool voice. You really can feel seulgi when she sings
Joy's voice matches sung si kyung's so well. Smstation please 🙏🙏
Let's give this comment more likesssss
Yes please
Yes
YES PLEASE .
Joy voice soooo beautiful....
Damn joy voice is so blend with that man voice.
Yes that is soo true
Mr Seong Si Gyeong, he is a great ballad singer.
I strongly agree...that's what I noticed, too. Joy's voice easily matches with any male or any deep voice. A real angelic, honey voice!🥰
The confidence of Red Velvet to showcase their vocals with a top singer. Wished Wendy was here as well, but everyone did exceptionally well.
Seeing so many comment about Joy’s vocals makes me so happy her vocals are so underrated and she rarely get the chance to show off
See SM she deserves more singing activities!!!
She get much lines in bsides track. Try to listen it.
selena azalea I’m a Reveluv so I know she gets much likes I’m not taking about the amount of lines but the hype she gets for it most people y’all about her visuals etc not her vocals
Your profile pic though
Hope Joy debut Solo 🙏
Joy's voice always makes me peaceful
JOY
- Main Vocalist our tone fairy
- To tier Visual
- Such a graceful dancer
- Variety show queen
- Such a good actress
- Sexy
- Perfect body proportion
- Fashionista
- It girl
Damn STANNING JOY is the best thing happened to me
Anna luna 💚💚💚
Same
Who run the world.? Joy
@@pinkapple8862 yess
Joy bringing joy to the world!!
OMG JOY IS LOVE!
RV IS REAL VOCAL!
😭
성시경 x 조이 제발 ㅠㅜ 듀엣곡 하나만 ㅠㅠ
Joy SOOOO PRETTYYYY!!!!
조이 음색..진짜 조이가 부르면 뭔가 더 슬프고 애틋해지는 거 같음.
1:13
wise people 원래 음색이 그래요 데뷔때 부터 청아한 음색+저렇게 떨리는?목소리 오히려 그래서 저 음색을 좋아하는 1인..
wise people 아ㅋㅋㅋㅋ제가 말을 좀 헷갈리게 했네요 청아한 음색에 떨리는 목소리가 합쳐져서 오히려 저는 그걸 좋아한단거지 불안한 음정이 음색이라고 빼액거리는건 아녔어요ㅠㅠ
그만좀 빨아라 ㅋㅋ 아닌건아니다 조이보단 슬기다
@@gjdoskendnxjd 응 갠팬
Damn, Joy's voice is giving me serious goosebumps! She should really consider releasing a duet with Sung Si Kyung someday because that's how good they sound together. Although Joy's singing is so underrated, I feel like she's already better than the lead vocalists of many girl groups.
조이는 처음에 보컬 멤이 아니었는데
점차 발전해서 발라드, r&b도 되고
댄스도 됨 ㄹㅇ 솔로 앨범 빨리 나왔으면
조이 원래 보컬멤이긴 했음 음색담당
조이는 처음부터 보컬 멤인데 에스엠의 곡에 꼭 끼어넣는.. 그런 랩을 종종 맡은 것뿐입니닿..
?보컬멤이었고 오디션도 보컬로 들어옴
@@user-tm6tn3xs2y 데뷔초에는 서브래퍼였음
성시경이랑 조이 같이 보니까 계절을 모르겠네..... 겨울이야??? 왜 겨울에 저런 옷을 입혀.....??
근데 진짜 레전드 무대다 너무 좋아 ㅠㅠ
Real Vocals, Real Visuals, Real Versatility, Red Velvet to end the year perfectly
Periodt
1000% true😊
What title song ? Please tell me
@@dewiriananana1221 it's you - iu & sung shi kyung
joy voice is so unique i love it
들을수록 조이 파트가 진짜 킬링파트다. 천상의 목소리를 가졌다. 조이.
Joy vocals is so angelic and sweet.
Now we can talk about how talented Red Velvet members
They kill us with their vocal and visual
JOY’s vocals and emotions on point as always💚💚she really has unique and soothing voice
symkrks her voice is like a lullaby it just calms me
😍😍
Her voice is highly emotive.. That's why she is loved by SK so much for her vocal color.. And she is a disney princess too💚💚
Joy's fashion here had a vibe like Jugyeong in True beauty.
Her voice is like honey💚
Joy❤️❤️❤️