Elections 2024 I What Do Voters Want? I Is Unemployment a Bigger Issue or Hindutva? I Barkha Dutt
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 апр 2024
- #Elections2024 #Modi #RahulGandhi
A new pre-poll survey by Lokniti CSDS identifies the key issues that matter to voters in Elections 2024. Unemployment is identified as the key issue that matters most to people. There are several other findings as well that might appear paradoxical- a majority of people identify their lives having improved but at the same time say corruption has increased and that it has become more difficult for development to reach all classes. To understand and decode the political meaning of this survey Barkha Dutt speaks to Sanjay Kumar of CSDS.
All left leaning people are making videos and having debates on same subject at the same time. It's a new narrative by the ecosystem. People trust Modi to solve problems of unemployment and inflation even if they r current Problems
Bro this seems to be issue in youth in rural places who are completely dependent on Government jobs
Yes there is no leader who can solve it other than Modi
I hope in Modi 3.0 modi solves this & encourage youths to not go behind govt jobs
Bull shit. Bjp is uncaring, in ompetany corrupt and communsl . This pollster is lying through their teeth. They continue to suck the evil modi.
@@ab20037 yes we hope he will solve it. But all the people of India CANNOT get government jobs. That's an impossible task
@@CRuS4D3R88 but all are preparing for that especially in rural places
There must be shift in mindset
Modi has failed played with communal harmony and is hell bent in breaking the constitution
Congress wants to go back to their good old "freebies" promises. There are some people who still believe in this (Delhi, Punjab and Karnatka) but once they get it they will soon realise that it just gives temporary relief. Teaching people how to fish (which is tougher initially) is better than giving one fish a day as a freebie.
BJP had 10 years to teach them how to fish but they were busy giving free ration to 81 crore people.
And the same years congress was busy abusing Hindus and our army so its good for us to get rid of congress permanently
Looks like you only watch Godi media channels. Since you do not know about BJPs freebies, Rs. 5K rashan to everyone, that’s not freebie?
In delhi, electricity is only free to a certain level. If you consume more than that, you pay the entire bill. It encourages people to use energy carefully. These are not freebies.
Congress has communis t manifesto. Check history of it, guarantee to finis up people and country, I writing this in all my senses.
Even if u do not align with BJP, for yourself, family and India vote BJP.
@@vishakhabharti1443 no that’s no freebies.
Congress has directly lifted from communis ts. Look at example of Venezuela. Congress said they will print money, which is bad when there is no events like pandemic.
BJP didn’t print money even during pandemic which helped India to control inflation otherwise entire world is facing inflation.
Besides communism is bad and it has only finish the people and country
People say they don't get job as per their liking .. it's not unemployment
Job at an IT cell is not a liked employment.
Yes, everyone wants to go to America 😂
@@pichumanisankar2617or everyone wants to become Ambani overnight😊
@@ish1979utube yes.. Nd that's why you're frustrated
So if you do engineering and sell chai, that’s not unemployment?!?!
common people thinks opposition has been raising their issues not common people's issue..
Unemployment. We don't get plumber or electrician
exactly....plus they charge heavily even if we get one
Because of abject poverty, people believe any education and degree is better than a skill. Indians and other developing countries look down on people like plumbers (B is silent when pronunciation) or electricians or road sweepers bin collectors as somehow sub-human. Fact is everyone must be treated with respect as the bin men and road sweepers keep out streets clean and make our lives better. Yet many Indians in the UK work in security or on building sites not something they would do in India. Attitude and mindset are the biggest problems
Is the opposition ready to listen to the people’s voices who do not seem to bother about ‘democracy in danger’ cry.😂
The voters will decide what you promised and delivered. What are your goals in 100 days after winning the election? Focus on skill development, not solely acquiring degrees.
I think academia is failing students in finished skills in a big way
I think NEP would solve this in long term
The opposition is not able to asure people that these issues will be solved by them
Rahul Gandhi is talking about caste census Asset redistribution & full freebies
In Karnataka election Congress state unit raised important issues & put up a credible face who can solve it & has experience
Now in Karnataka with freebies it is complete mess of Economy & mismanagement
People are not believing in Congress or Opposition they feel Modi is better
One points need to be confirmed, that the people who indicated unemployment as the main issue for the election,
How many of those are employed and how many of those were unemployed?
The reason I am asking this is, may be, this is because of the noise being created by the opposition
Fair question but it is not just noise. Two million Indians revoked citizenship last year, Agents/ people traffickers duping people going to Russia and Israel. GOI has a deal with Israel to employ Indians to replace the Palestinians. One million Indians illegal in US and same number crossing the Mexican border. Europe has more Indians than Africans. Indians are the highest number of migrants in the world according to IOM. Sadly this is Not Noise.
In whch election was unemployment and price rise not an issue? Modi's make in India, infra-push, bullet trains, new trains makes people believe that Modi can solve it and is working on it. On the other hand, Congress'a election manifesto indicates these issues will become more pronounced if they come to power.
26:20 When 60% of the electorate says they are happy with the incumbent, it is blamed on the ‘culture of fatalism’. Essentially implying it is terrible that Hindus are culturally a happy people. These very consultants blow the trumpet when India is ranked amongst ‘saddest nations in the world’ by global surveys.
Totally agree.
As Indian born and educated but chose to live in the West I liked your comment. Pleased you picked up the "culture of fatalism" as I did which is pervasive as parents brainwash their children with mumbo jumbo tradition and cultural norms. All based on Religion and ancient practises being unchallenged.
Well said Sanjay is a leftie
Unemployment is number one issue of the survey agreed and government should take necessary measures to address the issue but one thing to remember population of India is 1.4billion and it keep on growing so unemployment issue will reduce drastically that is not going happen so government needs yo come up with solution on how to control the population rise
Absolutely true but wait for all the "Hate" trolls who will argue black is white. Hope you have broad shoulders!
I am usually a critic of Barkha Dutt and I dont like how she portrays one side of problems only but this coverage is really good. So credit where its due👏🏻👏🏻
In all elections unemployment and price rises were issues. But the fact is who the people consider could tackle these issues is a factor. After pandering while several countries suffer economically India manages to survey better.
U r absolutely right...people know solution of these two problems can be solved by modiji or bjp..belv me I am congress voter but still I know on ground what's happening...🙏🙏🙏
bhakth sootted
@@ravi-it3vj bhakths are better than sevants or chamchas of family or family party.
Is that the reason why people are paying agents or traffickers for jobs in war zones?
@@MukeshKamlani-jt1zk you 2 rupee coolie cannot be a congress voter.
What about the duty of state govts to control inflation and generate employment? Even state govts have to make efforts. For example the Karnataka govt is not bothered about controlling inflation and is only interested in getting rice for its guarantee scheme.
25:13 Because in India Job means "Govt. job", "White collar job", But a supermarket cashier or pharma MR Or Salesman is not an Job.. But people are earning more nowadays..
Unemployment issue INDIA allince couldnot put into their highest priorties becuase the regional parties had performed similar or worse than the central govt. They have no answer to their own regional people. No one see the Allience is going to bring any hope rather people will vote against their regional party which are all almost going with INDIA alliance. Take an example of West Bengal.
Congress and its supporters have pouring scorn on Make In India and want it to fail. Manufacturing push is seen as job creating. Sops are seen as good old poverty sustaining schemes.
A simple thing which you intelligent people are not getting is, even if people understand that there is a major unemployment issue in the country yet they also know that opposition has no solution for this issue. They also know that Congress had no idea about generating employment then or they have any idea now. Therefore considering all the others aspects of the matter people have understood that bjp is still the best option remains.
Unemployment should have been a lot more than 27%, it shows people are likely happy receiving free rashan and don’t mind sitting unemployed
In India in every election unemployment and inflation is an issue no matter which party is in power.
It's not in india it's world over phenomena unemployment and inflation . You cannot do anything . For eg if someone is fired from the job let say and if that person say because of modi I lost my job is it sensible to think
Analysis of the survey results does not provide any great insights into the minds of the voter.
How can the corruption on the ground in a village be attributed to the central government’? Will a CM like Mamta let Modi fix their state’s corruption?
Barkhajee, what would an qualified, unemployed youth do with the Hindutva Nara? Barakhajee, it's a question of SURVIVAL for many Indian youth in 2024, not of faith
She is an outstanding female journalists , i respect her very much ,
Lagta hai Pappu sabko collector bana dega
Real citizens want is a transparent secular government which will allow people from all walks of life to lead a harmonious life ....our economy is intertwined among all the stake holders (diff,caste, religion, geography ) which makes this a sub continent politically ...we are very sad of the ongoing government initiatives......after seeing this people will stamp me anti indian , anti Hindu.....i am a true blue hindu only but doesnt mean that we can accept all the non sense going around to my fellow brothers
yes we want equal right for hindus. we want sam elaw same right for every one. revoke personal laws, revoke reservation.
Then let’s push for uniform civil code
what is the criteria for defining Poor, Lower, Middle, Upper? surprised to know that Poor are not using the Roads, Trains, Hospitals and Schools!!! I think they want everything free to consider it as developments!!
The issue is not that the Modi Govt. has not been able to solve issues but can opposition can do a better job. Clearly not.
1. People believe that BJP and Narendra Modi are best to handle the problems including unemployment and price rise.
2. Barkha, please do not confuse viewers simply because you cannot interpret data accurately.
3. People's opinion on development being biased towards the "Pro rich" is not capitalized by opposition because it has no credibility.
4. Interestingly. corruption as perceived by common people stays as very high (70+ %) in spite of the digital governance that has greatly impacted the citizen government interface. This question should be further investigated to identify the services for which they had to pay bribes or use an influencer, or they simply saw corruption? Will CSDS do something? My guess and suggestion are to take a look at corruption in real estate related offices and RTO offices primarily.
5." There is no alternative" is bigger than you think. In my view 10% or even more people vote for BJP because TINA.
That's the problem with people like Barkha - they view the world in binaries - why is it so hard to get through that it can be BOTH: economic growth + Hindu rights awakening
whoever comes to power must ban proselytization and must be declared against the law. This will prevent interference of external forces who are desperate to change demography of India. This will makes the people peacefully practice their faith and focus on things that matter. Also provide benefits only to families that have less than 3 children. Also all public sector jobs , 100%, are only for those who are poor and are unemployed. 50% should be exclusively for women.
Modi is India’s Deng Xiaoping and has the unique capacity, conviction & the vision to reform the nation at speed & scale. He deserves a big mandate in the 3rd term for all her has done.
2024 election
Dismantling of islamisation of bharat
That was such an underwhelming discussion. When numbers can't be explained speak in generalizations rather than explaining the numbers in a more thorough manner. What was the point of the survey if that's completely ignored in the discussion. Or maybe we do not have slides for the follow up questions. That's why Yashwant's survey, and the discussion, is so much better than this.
Totally agree. Just hand wringing!
Unemployment and price rise was, is and will remain an issue in this country for foreseeable future. Let's be real. Given our extra large population, there is no quick fix to these issues. The question is, is the government action giving enough confidence that are working towards it? For the current government - YES. Does the Congress 'manifesto' gives that confidence - NO.
Opposition were weak in the phases where BJP had bad times after 2014,opposition only coming in the scene one or two years before election
Where is success of Indian foreign policy issues, 5th economy, highest GDP growth, increasing FDI to India , success of make in India, making defence equipment, arms and income from exporting them, increased soft power to the world, 4th largest defence country, Kashmir issues, success of space research sector, export of agriculture products or to aid for poor countries??? Where is infrastructure development issues!!! These are the most important issues which are in favour of government as success. Ram mandir and hindutva is not a big issues but researchers avoid these important issues which are more important in this digital era. People are aware of the success of government in these fields. Price is not much higher . In ten years price hike is normal. Unemployment can't solve any government in any day. We have a great knowledge of last 75 yrs in this field, so how opposition's can solve it if they elected!!! Have they any specific strategy or commitment to the people! Nothing. It's not possible,. Employment character is changing now a days. But people's imagination as previous, a government job will not be available for every body, it's only for genius. So taking the scope of developed infrastructure and be a successful in life is the future. No government can provide job for unskilled. BJP will win with absolute majority.
I would like to know of a time when unemployment wasn't an issue in India, along with high prices. We are a poor and overpopulated country, what else did you expect to find? Especially when employment is a problem across the world.
Opposition is bunch of fools and the leader of them is Pappu. Opposition need to remove RG from the equation if they want to come back.
I think trade work like plumbing electrician etc will come in high demand. So doing a degree throough the route of Polytechnics is a great option rather.
Price rise and employment has been problems from time memorial !
Just like lack of Birth Control measures which were scrapped after Sanjay Gandhi's measures. I sometimes wonder whether all the vociferous noises around those measures was scaremongering as Indians have overtaken the Chinese with their one child policy. Fake noise
I really wish there be a frank discussion about how jobs are created in any economy. Sure Modi can do better and let people who have ideas share with him but around the world it is the most difficult thing to create. It takes years of building a compelling case for a country and Modi is working hard in that direction. The opposition has no sensible plan. India will be looted down to the last penny if the current rag tag of the opposition comes to power as they may think it is their last chance
Wave of taunnami is there of modi specialy
Unemployment 27%
Democracy 0%
Secularism 0%
Minority Rights 0%
Media freedom 0%
Dictatorship 0%
😂😂😂😂
He fails to mention about the foreign policy of Bharat under modi ji. All the major Islamic nation like UAE and Saudi have very strong relationship with Bharat. A temple has come up in UAE Abu Dhabi under Modi era.
Stature of Bharat has grown Multifold in the world. G20 summit success under Modi..there are so many positives which outweigh few negatives as per my analysis.
What is the answer opposition has for unemployment issue??
9:15 is the point which proves why #Sanjay Kumar ji can never become #Yashwant Deshmukhji or #Pradeep Guptaji.. because he is too shy mention points like Infrastructure (Road, Rail, Bridge ect), Last mile Delivery, PM house, Rashan are Modi's positive points... 😀😀
Look bjp has not released their manifesto because people should have not time think while voting
It is funny to see a person making a perception and calling it a data and facts which is collected through 10000 people of country of a size of 142 crore.
📍23:19
Who knows better than barkha to manipulate... Yesterday she was interviewing nitin gadhkari sir... And trying to manipulate..
And today... Trying to destroy the image of our prime minister modiji... By starting with some good stupid survey and trying to manipulate again..
Orchastated
interview... I am from Manipur... I should be hating modi and bjp like anything...but will vote for bjp.
Reason being..
Decades of Congress rule..
No peace, bomblast and killing daily... I ended staying and staying my life away from home and family. But in the last 6-7 years i could go home and do anything i want. Thats the difference... Coz before modi.
my parents would rather travel to delhi or Bangalore where i was studying..coz they find it unsafe back home..
FYI: 4.30 pm was the dead line for us before bjp. Fact... Do google and check.
Yes the problem is uncertain... But the development in the last 6-7 years.. has been more than all those time combined by Congress since independence.
Yes I am tat bit unhappy with Modi sir.. but I still count on him than that stupid Rahul who came to pour fuel on the fire.
Jobs are there every time but not Govt. Jobs. However unemployment refers to lack of Govt. Jobs as we find that there are no carpenters, plumbers, potters, and many self employment in many places and how do you explain this
Maturity is when u realize voter mudde ke sath ye bhi dekh ta hai kon trust full hai ????? ... abhi keliye chahe jo mudde ho . Modi ji jeetege becoz of 2 reason hope to modi and no opposition
This goes to show how out of touch the opposition is with the people at the ground level.
As regards to employment most important is ‘employability’ of man power. Very few efforts were made so far for cultivating human capital through skill development & education programs. So lot of youth just doesn’t possess skill. This is not the present government’s doing. But they can’t talk about it openly.
The un employment & inflation is not becoming the issue coz it varies from region to region. Down south here young not getting a high paid first job is considered as un employment and inflation never had a big issue . But self skilled states like Maharastra Gujarath, Rajasthan and north east where people have family involved in businesses where inflation can be a issue but un employment is not a issue. Affluent states like Punjab, Haryana and Kerla never had these issues.
Everyone want govt job, how is it possible?
Disbelief in Opposition to work better than BJP to solve the issues except giving some free things. People see development and foresee a better picture in the years ahead though present is not hanky dory.
BJP does not care about the people they are only interested in filling their coffers and owning the country not governing the country ..:.:: whom do you want to vote BJP has failed to fight price rise and Provide jobs in the last 10 yrs
Cbds lok Nitin has got that bjp will not cross 200 now they changing the survey and after 1 month look what they will say after one month
There are issues and problems but people are aware that if opposition comes to power the matter would be worse due to caste and religion appeasement, increased corruption, anti hindu and anti India ideology leading to riot and bad foreign policies
Why he did not ask who can solve this problem Rahul or Modi ?
Modi
unemployment is only for ppl who dont have any skills and for ppl who are only waiting for years to get govt job.......i have met many ppl who have bbeen waiting for years for govt vacancies and are not ready for hard work and do private jobs....otherwise jobs are available.....yes you can say that salaries are not that good
There is nothing new in this survey though... It's exactly same copy of #Yashwant Deshmukh Ji's survey.. 🤔🤔
Democracy is considered
IAC-2014, Pulwama-2019, Ramnavami live telecast-2024.
IAC 2014 plz elaborate
I didnt understand that ram mandir issue . What is issue in this . Means it can be 2 sides . Ram mandir . Kyon banaya ye issue hain ki achhha ho gaya ram mandir banaya . So i dodnt understand that
Barkha, Sanjay ji didn't understand Prasad Davvuri's question and he went on a tangent. You could have asked that to him in Hindi.
How many jobs is Congress promising.. ? I could not get any number from manifesto other than saying they will fill up 30 lakh sarkari jobs.
Opposition rightly highlights problems of Unemployment ,Inequality Price Rise etc. It is however difficult for people to believe the opposition has any concrete schemes to address these issues within a time frame. It is important to go for a well planned job oriented education system making people skilled enough to get jobs . People should become job providers and not necessarily job seekers People seem to be having confidence ,rightly or wrongly, that NDA is capable of addressing these issues by having short term and long turn vision ( even upto 2047 ! )
It is better to have milestones for achievements even they are slipped.
People also look for a strong country commanding world wise honour and respect .
Those who belittle the Country, its culture and heritage have no chance.
Those who purposefully undermine the pride of this nation in terms of its age - old rich multi region , multi-religion, multiculltture heritage and its time immemorial
all -inclusive nature of this great Nation have no chance.
Issue of 2024 is inspite of issues whether bjp under Modiji will get 370 seats r not.
As a father of an international journalist daughter my question to barkha y in the guise of journalism u are peddling an antibjp and pro India alliance. As an Indian I hope all these antimodi media analyst of both lutyens and regional don't commit suicide when bjp under Modiji wins 2024.
So who will solve the problem sir
No one, even if Congress win the price rise will be an issue and unemployment will be an issue. Corruption will be an issue.
For heaven's sake pls someone tell these two after covid n Russia war whole world is experiencing high inflation,india is better compared to many big economies..just look at inflation data today in usa it has short up.. commodities prices r very high..
I am not understand one thing why barkha is asking a poor cds survey head guy that what you have done if your govt , or opposition . His job is to do survey that it . This is too much and funny also
Mr know all should be told that the voters want the moon!!!
Great Insights!!
Such surveys - results should be taken with a pinch of salt. The sequence of questions also bias the survey. Has anyone take that into account? More important question should be - current state of unemployment/inflation, who do you think can solve/address this issue best? Guess what the answer would be.
I agree with issues raised by lokniti which bother the common citizen. But unfortunately for the anti Modi and pro Rahul lutyens media like barkha channel the citizen of this country are happy with Modi. It's unfortunate barkha a paid agent of India alliance is silent on the corruption of kujriwal.
Opposition Is concerned about their own ilk, which translates into the Save Democracy narrative. Jobs are a primary issue, but it is so big that it cannot be resolved in a generation. Why generation? There are three essentials for full employment. We need infrastructure, which is in progress, but it will take another decade to catch up to China's scale.
Similarly, the Manufacturing shift from China to India and from other places required the stability of the Modi government and its policies. Few companies came, and much more to come.
The third essential element is employability, which means having a degree doesn't mean you are employable. You need to have skills and experience to compete.
Overall, all these have been in working because of Modi governance; the opposition is offering completely opposite communist nightmare policies which will destroy whatever we have.
My question to Sanjay how he will advise the opps to create jobs.
Was there ever any time when unemployment was not the issue in India? We have always been breeding faster than jobs created by job-creators. On top, as a society, we do not respect Job creators.
So true. Am Indian born and educated but chose to live in the West. Yes the breeding factories in the UP with a population the size of Pakistan and other states must be prioritised by stricter Birth control measures. The landmass has shrunk and its resources depleted. It is not rocket science 2+children = poverty lack of jobs houses sanitation food etc.
Don't worry mam, Modiji is coming again & again
What were the main issues in Elections in 2004, 2009, 2014, 2019
for me - defeating the pandavas and taking back Kuru kingdom.
As usual Sanjay has spoken about the reality about in spite of issues people are prepared to vote for Modi which antimodi and pro Sonia Gandhi family funded barkha finds disgusting.
There is anger which the govt cant overcome with Hindutva and muslim league. Unemployed youth all around and price rise has crossed tollerance.
Going from social media any anger is not translated into action as far as unemployment goes. People will pay agents or traffickers to work in war zones but not riot or protest in India . Corruption is almost natural default so look for illegal routes to the West
The youths of this country will boot out the most wickedest, most cruelest most stupid pm.
They already did that in 2014😂😂
bygod if they dont get big factory jobs in the next term...be ready for RG premiership in 2029
It all depends on the raw data, the methodology used to arrive for the conclusion. If there are open ended questions without any context, obviously you will get different results set which you can skew to your political lenses/biases. If you ask questions about unemployability to people who are not educated, or rather did not skill develop, then in this competitive environment, you will be unemployed forever. Also, he might not have asked or looked for Entrepreneurship data meaning many people now a days are their own boss, they work for themselves... he might not have looked into it. India w/140 crores population, taking a sample size of 10K and extrapolating across nation is purely a BS Survey. These folks including bdutt desperately want some issues to corner BJP/MODI -
PR work of BJP is excellent ,giving people more than vote
Also my dear barkha.... You didnt come there to report the situation or problem in Manipur...you came there for views... And to help congress right before... Bharat toro anyaay yatra 😁
Mr sanjay kumar is BJP unbeatable😅
I see 2 rupee coolie are commenting here. I saw a decline in their comments. maybe want of ekectotal bond has dried uo their payments.
People see modi as the problem solver !!! For 10 years he has been a spectacular problem creator. He brought us into this hell hole ! What you are saying doesn't make any sense!!!
super
In 2009 election.
1. We had seen Mumbai Attack
2. Worst ever recession
3. Financial crisis
4. lots of corporate corruption
Still BJP did poorly in election and Congress improved its seat tally.
History teaches lots of lessons.
चलो चलता है और पहेलेसे अच्छे है ये समान नही है. कितनी निगेटिव्हिटी चला रहे हो.
Godi Journo like Barkha will have tough to digest
Vai barkha sabse bada modi critic hai😂😂, aaj bhi hai bas utna nehi dikhata hai
barkha putt