I'm not bashing on the time given to Moonbyul. I know she is listed as a rapper, but even in the live performances during the last chorus of Mr. Ambiguous, she is singing alongside Wheein. She does sing more than what people can detect because she can blend well. Even in the part switch of Um Oh Ah Yea, when she sings Wheein's original part, it's hard to distinguish without trying to hear the difference. She and Wheein, when singing, sound almost identical. So, theoretically speaking, she has more lines than what many distribution videos assign. If she only rapped, then yes this is fair esp. since it was a debut. But she does sing, just not easily detectable. Either way, I love this song and how MAMAMOO is a great band with fantastic vocals, astounding beauty, and great concepts that have a nostalgic twist. For a Debut, it stands out because they held nothing back and continued to adapt, grow, and assemble a loving fanbase. :)
Chanbae if the mv came out 6 years ago and hwasa is 24 currently how would she be 20, and for Wheein if you do the math for the exact date the mv came out, Wheein was 19
guys, stop trying to defend the line distribution, it's objectively bad. moonbyul even said that in the early days of mamamoo it made her sad to be on stage and just stand there for the majority of a song
It’s always almost equal when it comes to Wheein and Hwasa’s lines. Then there is solar and moonbyul sharing a half. Really what there to complain. I think this fair.
Tống Ngọc Nguyên She is responsible for high notes and she always sing most among vocalist in other titled songs like “you are the best”. It depends on song, hwasa has most part in “yes I am” since she do both rap and sing
I'm not bashing on the time given to Moonbyul. I know she is listed as a rapper, but even in the live performances during the last chorus of Mr. Ambiguous, she is singing alongside Wheein. She does sing more than what people can detect because she can blend well. Even in the part switch of Um Oh Ah Yea, when she sings Wheein's original part, it's hard to distinguish without trying to hear the difference. She and Wheein, when singing, sound almost identical. So, theoretically speaking, she has more lines than what many distribution videos assign. If she only rapped, then yes this is fair esp. since it was a debut. But she does sing, just not easily detectable.
Either way, I love this song and how MAMAMOO is a great band with fantastic vocals, astounding beauty, and great concepts that have a nostalgic twist. For a Debut, it stands out because they held nothing back and continued to adapt, grow, and assemble a loving fanbase. :)
She was just lipsyncing on those parts
when you realize that here whasa was 18 yo 😮
So is Wheein then
Autumn Moon wheein wouldve been 19
Also Wheein
She's actually 20
Chanbae if the mv came out 6 years ago and hwasa is 24 currently how would she be 20, and for Wheein if you do the math for the exact date the mv came out, Wheein was 19
Even though their voice is 'chipmunked', this is still eargasm! any, thanks
wheein is a master at singing the chorus lol
she is the main vocal afterall ^^
Alex Black yup I also find her vocal color imo one of the best in the kpop industry :)
nur cinar i agree, shes one of the strongest ones out there
nur cinar Wheein, Solar, and Hwasa could all be main vocals in other groups
They are all such amazing singers!!
Liam Taylor yass
guys, stop trying to defend the line distribution, it's objectively bad. moonbyul even said that in the early days of mamamoo it made her sad to be on stage and just stand there for the majority of a song
WHEEIN MY QUEEN ♥
Remember when Moonbyul and Solar had rounder jaws... ah foetuses
Istg they looked like actual babies
I deadass thought this was a newer song before I found it it was actually their debut song like oh my gods
i love mamamoo
This is a fair distribution. Moonbyul is a rapper not a vocal. Why do you commenting about this is not a fair.
Randolph Kim Jigger Baya Moonbyul from Paint Me doesn't agree.
Moonbyul is a very good singer, sadly all 4 are good, and the others are outstanding...
moonbyul! my bias~ i hope u get more lines😶😶😶😶
gaby muten shez the rapper and she did have all rap parts, what do you want more , highnotes or adlibs?
You read the lyrics? Moonbyul sings fast
she gets a lot in bsides
Can you make more Mamamoo videos? I'd really appreciate it.
OMG! Thank you for this one :)
Me: full song waiting for Moonbyuls famous rap part
Me at 2:30 : ooohhh there it goesss!! 😂
Wheein🥰🥰🥰🥰
mamamoo :)
moonbyul: welp ok, im an rapper afterall
It’s always almost equal when it comes to Wheein and Hwasa’s lines. Then there is solar and moonbyul sharing a half. Really what there to complain. I think this fair.
thanks so much for making this😘😘😘😘😘♥🐰
QWheein👑🔥
Damn the views back then is so small, and now it’s like 10M views or more
Moonbyul :(
moon byul :(
It was fair. She did some harmonies with them all and her part is way faster than the others
any 2020 corona may? just me? oh ok;-;
This ma shit, yo!!
Solar is Lead Vocalist right ?
main
Mori Morie why Solar sing little ?
Tống Ngọc Nguyên She is responsible for high notes and she always sing most among vocalist in other titled songs like “you are the best”. It depends on song, hwasa has most part in “yes I am” since she do both rap and sing
All of them experienced being rank 1 in their songs except Moonbyul
In Mamamoo doesn't exist "Main" or "Lead" vocal
Weein is best
piano man plsss
นึกว่า wheein ร้องอยู่คนเดียว
Poor Moonbyulie :(
I can think of some ways you could make this look a bit cleaner, it's a bit crowded.
Посему у репершы так мало текста😡😡😡
Moonbyul gets fair lines cause she is a rapper and she chooses not to sing most of the time so please stop fussing about it in the comments
She never "chooses" not to sing, the company FORCED her to become a rapper, remember sweetie? There's a reason if in her solo songs she mostly sings.
WHEEIN MY QUEEN ♥