I’m so glad there’s finally a MAP about Reedshine! She’s so underrated, and usually when she’s in MAPs it’s only for a few seconds in Mapleshade’s MAPs only to be seen as “Appledusk’s second mate”. When she’s more than that! But anyways everyone did amazing on their parts!
Honestly, when I first read Mapleshade’s novella, I hated Reedshine, not for anything she did to Maple but more so how she came across way too “teehee my husband can’t do anything wrong!” But when you see it from her perspective, Appledusk, the cat she loved, had just lost three children in front of his eyes, had just confessed as much to the entire clan, and was about to be driven out altogether while she likely knew she was pregnant. She ended up defending the cat she loved after seeing him suffer for his actions more than any other cat, and honestly, I can’t blame her for snapping at Mapleshade with the whole “you’ve caused enough trouble here tonight” line, since she likely genuinely believed she was responsible for the kits’ deaths, too. She was honestly just put into a horrible situation of no fault of her own, and did her best to approach it with grace, and it came back to bite her in the butt. I guess I just wish we got to see better writing for her in general, maybe have a scene that shows her talking it out with Appledusk in StarClan, or showing at least any kind of hurt or anger towards how she’d been wronged outside of just being the unknowing affair partner.
To be honest, Appledusk was always not responsible for his actions. And Reed did a terrible thing, kicking out the cat, who was speechless with horror, in order to preserve her authority and place in the tribe for her cheating husband.
Yessss! So glad this map explored Appledusk and Reedshine’s feelings and portrayed Apple as actually grieving for his kits because he actually was shown to love them. I don’t condone his cheating but I love reedshine and she deserves so much better :( good work!
I've never seen a map show Appledusk actually filled with regret for what he did to Burchface. I honestly wouldn't mind if we got a novel for him , just to see how he felt about Mapleshade and his whole situation, and how he fell in love with Reedshine.
anyone else remember that youtube video to this song of a blonde girl and brunette boy who meet as kids and fall in love and it was super sad with the dog and everything 😭
Reedshine and Appledusk my beloved, ahhhhhh I love them so much. I also love how clearly distrust Apple is over a Birches death, reading about it, with how it’s described as Flower and Birches head coming out of the water, screaming in terror or just a second before being put dragged back under. I can imagine being their or causing it. And the way Maple treated OMG, Birch was her clan mate and she treats it like an inconvenience “If only you hadn’t killed Birchface” she doesn’t treat it like a tragedy,sifee see isiusheh that annoys me so much, Maple he died, he wasn’t some inconvenience he was a clan mate, and how she doesn’t even care who freaking upset Apple is, I love this MAP.
yo guys there's now another completed map I hosted similiar to this one but about Heathertail, go check it out! ruclips.net/video/w6IgWSgJBLo/видео.htmlfeature=shared
Appledusk and Reedshine are two of my favorite characters in Warriors, and, alot of Maple stans attack me for that, and also simply because I dislike Mapleshade. This map holds a dear place in my heart, as it represents Reedshine and Appledusk MORE than just ‘side characters that Mapleshade can wreak revenge on because she's an insufferable asshole.’ Gorgeous map.
Out of curiousity, why do you dislike Mapleshade and why are Appledusk and Reedshine your favs? Dw I'm not gonna attack you for your opinions, I'm not one of those Mapleshade stans.
@@evelutioncor I am a Crookedstar kinnie, Mapleshade groomed him and multiple other apprentices and kits after death to do what she wanted, and also objectified Appledusk and mentally abused him. I like Appledusk because he's morally grey, he's neither good nor bad. Sure he cheated on Mapleshade, but he loved Reedshine and every one of his kits, even the ones he had with Mapleshade. He gave his life for Reedshine. Hope this covers it ^_^
@@ccowpokeHOWEVER, this freak acted like a redneck. He didn't deserve either Reedshine or Mapleshade. He's an abuser and a redflag, and that was even said. He abandoned a cat that must have been bursting with pain. Just to warm the sides of the tribe. A stump who has no right to be called Maple's ex, and who has no right to be called the father of her kittens. HER kittens! Only her, and no one else. She loved them so much that she was ready to give her life for them, and also literally became a sadist to take revenge for them. She is a miracle woman-mother, keep it up.
@@0.721xdude. She lost everything because she was looking for love... it turns out that Reedshine also deserved a terrible life because she fell in love
IM VERY LATE HOLY MOLY- 😭 But anyway, I'm here to say that the map is very good! The 2000s vibe is really searing in this and I LOVE IT 🤭 It was great to participate in this! I'm honored :D
I have to say i found nice the way how she changed a bit her opinion about appledusk after she had know that he got pregnant a cat from another clan and then left her for dont break the warrior code even if i will always keep be sad for appleshade she was the best mother? Not really because she have caused accidentally the kits death in the river after they have told her to dont cross and she was too focused on her anger instead of care for the safety of her kits but if the things would be ended different i belive she would be a better cat and a lovely mother and a good partner but sadly the things did turn bad for her and reedshine looks like the only one who have understood this point of view even if she couldn't nothing for fix her fury and is ended to see the cat she loved after everything is happened between he and mapleshade die in front of her with their kits with his last memory
If you read the book she honestly kinds just brought it upon herself what happened (not Apple cheating, but everything else) she felt like everything she did was right even when it was clearly not, she continued to encourage the lie that Birchface was the father, and just straight up told Ravenwing when he found her 💀 And it was a very dumb decision to go across a flash flooded river too, especially when she was told countless time it wasn't safe, even by her kit. I mean, her life sucked, but she kinda made it suck from all the silly decisions she made imo
@5re0r gonna disagree a bit here, she doesn't directly tell raven that appledusk was the father but he already knew cause the omen + the way he interacted with the kits and how they played in the river. I also don't think she deserved to have her kits thrown out of the clan, oakstar was a complete ass by banishing innocent children cause they don't have 'pure' blood (in my opinion, nobody is innocent expect myler, the kits, perchpaw and nettlepaw and possibly reedshine since she didn't know he was cheating (though she was a bit rude, I don't think that makes her awful); the rest have done something "bad" at least once in the book.)
@@blueberry7400 Oh yeah that's my mistake, and yeah I agree those kits definitely didn't deserve anything that happened! All I'm saying is Mapleshade kind of just didn't care much. She thought StarClan was allowing her to do what she did, and her being exiled n shit kinda just happened due to her ignorance really - But yeah no one by any means was innocent
@@masoch1st1c she’s a pick me /hj it’s probably because I love Mapleshade and as Reedshine stole Appledusk from Maple I just don’t like her for that reason as well.
@@MentallyBrokenKitty yeah i get that, but no need to demonize characters who r pretty much interesting. You can dislike reedshine but please do not mischaracterize her Appledusks sucks tho
i really wish reedshine had defended mapleshade instead of appledusk. yeah appledusk was probably sad about his kits but reedshine didn’t even care that he was cheating on both her and mapleshade with each other, and just acted like he did absolutely nothing wrong and helped him cast out the GRIEVING MOTHER. in my universe, reedshine would leave appledusk and bond with mapleshade instead over the similarities in what happened to them both
Appledusk left Mapleshade because he believed that she was to blame for their kits drowning as not at all long before her exile, Appledusk, and two of his clanmates warned Mapleshade that the kits could've drowned in the river. (Keep in mind that two of Mapleshade's clanmates drowned in that exact river). So, it makes sense as to why Appledusk blamed Mapleshade for what happened to the kits. Before he and Mapleshade broke up, he truly loved Mapleshade and their kits. Even after they broke up, he couldn't bring himself to fight Mapleshade, showing he still cared for her, just not romantically, despite the fact that Mapleshade was trying to harm not only Appledusk, but his new mate and his apprentice. Stepping away from his relationship with Mapleshade, he loved his new mate, Reedshine, just as much as he loved his former mate, Mapleshade. In fact, he loved and cared for Reedshine enough to sacrifice his life to save her, as Mapleshade was initially aiming for Reedshine, not Appledusk.
Just the she cat who stole apple disks feeling for maple shade. I believe he truly loved maple shade but reedshine was so pushy he eventually found it easier to be with her but like a cruel Tom he feel for reedshide only to abandon mapleshade. He should have defended her. His betrayal is part of what made her go crazy. Makes me wonder how he would have acted if larch/patch& petalkit had lived
She didn't "steal" him. We don't know enough about her or anything abt Appledusk and her relationship to just start making silly headcanons like this 💀 From the book, he was most likely just friends with her and since he couldn't talk to Mapleshade when Darkstar put out more patrols, him and Reedshine probably just gained feelings like that. That's the most likely canon option honestly LOL Also Reedshine was never pushy whatsoever
@@5re0r literally Appledusk was not really showing interest in her but reedshine tried everything to spend every minute with Apple dusk, even though I never really saw Apple dust being that interested her until after Maple Shade’s kits were born. The scene where she tells Apple desk, that there’s a funny story about an elder, choking on a frog I literally always just saw that as an excuse to get him to come hang out with her there’s no way a story like that can be that funny the way she tells him about it she literally acts like it’s the funniest thing on earth when really, it’s just mildly amusing
@@Luna_moon_1127 okay?? So what? 😭 that doesn't me she was trying to STEAL him. she was literally just interested in talking to her clanmate bro, you need better reading comprehension
@@Kotop-o4pshe had nowhere to go... plus hunger, cold, tired, wounded and kittens at her side. Panic! A hopeless situation! Any way means the death of the kittens! The enemy is behind you, watching you, you need to act quickly! Oops..
@@Kotop-o4poh no! You go to the bridge, and... you slip, fall into the river! And there is no guarantee that there was one at all. We are going into the territory of two-legged... oops... the kittens got sick because of the rain, they got sick green cough! Death of kittens! Death of kittens!
mapleshade hated reedshine and her children cause they were of appledusk's kin (and appledusk cheated on her with reed) mapleshade directly tries to kill Reed in the book but appledusk gets in the way and is killed instead.
Reedshine isn't bad. She defended Appledusk when Mapleshade came in because she didn't know about him cheating on Maple at first, and she defended him because he was the father of her kits and she needed him most.
There are like two things that could have been the case. We don't know that he cheated. It was Mapleshade's assumption, similar to how she assumed Frecklewish wanted the kits dead and how she assumed Ravenwing had malicious intent. Appledusk could have been mates with Reedshine before becoming mates with Mapleshade. Appledusk could have already been friends with Reedshine, and when he broke up with Mapleshade, he may have just become mates with Reedshine. (Keep in mind that the only time Reedshine is pregnant is at the end of the book).
@@_The_Lizard_King I like to think the 2nd one, since Reed actively spoke with Apple like during the gathering in the first chapter. Maple was also very obsessive and possessive of Appledusk too, so it may have made sense that he would break it off with her It'd be nice if we had other books like a Super Edition to fill in lil holes, or just author statements abt things like that in MV honestly 🙏
@@Nakazivuishi I have taken care of numerous pregnant cats. I'm literally a foster for the stray cats in my neighborhood. I've done plenty of research on cat pregnancy. They don't start showing the first few days. And guess what; Reedshine was never showing in the books. 🤯 There were no romantic interactions between Appledusk and Reedshine until *after* he left Mapleshade. The first time we see him reciprocate Reedshine's affection was when he broke up with Mapleshade. "Oh, but Reedshine was pregnant," you claim. But Reedshine was only pregnant multiple days after Appledusk and Mapleshade broke up. Mind you, Reedshine wasn't even showing at the end of the book. The only reason Mapleshade knew Reedshine was pregnant was because Appledusk, the cat that got her pregnant, said she was pregnant.
guys if you're interested i opened a new map call! ruclips.net/video/QrDc3EhvR64/видео.htmlfeature=shared
THIS IS SO 2010s CORE I LOVE IT
Wait its you- i see you everywhere
Frrr
I’m so glad there’s finally a MAP about Reedshine! She’s so underrated, and usually when she’s in MAPs it’s only for a few seconds in Mapleshade’s MAPs only to be seen as “Appledusk’s second mate”. When she’s more than that! But anyways everyone did amazing on their parts!
Honestly, when I first read Mapleshade’s novella, I hated Reedshine, not for anything she did to Maple but more so how she came across way too “teehee my husband can’t do anything wrong!” But when you see it from her perspective, Appledusk, the cat she loved, had just lost three children in front of his eyes, had just confessed as much to the entire clan, and was about to be driven out altogether while she likely knew she was pregnant. She ended up defending the cat she loved after seeing him suffer for his actions more than any other cat, and honestly, I can’t blame her for snapping at Mapleshade with the whole “you’ve caused enough trouble here tonight” line, since she likely genuinely believed she was responsible for the kits’ deaths, too. She was honestly just put into a horrible situation of no fault of her own, and did her best to approach it with grace, and it came back to bite her in the butt. I guess I just wish we got to see better writing for her in general, maybe have a scene that shows her talking it out with Appledusk in StarClan, or showing at least any kind of hurt or anger towards how she’d been wronged outside of just being the unknowing affair partner.
someone had the books memorized
To be honest, Appledusk was always not responsible for his actions. And Reed did a terrible thing, kicking out the cat, who was speechless with horror, in order to preserve her authority and place in the tribe for her cheating husband.
Yessss! So glad this map explored Appledusk and Reedshine’s feelings and portrayed Apple as actually grieving for his kits because he actually was shown to love them. I don’t condone his cheating but I love reedshine and she deserves so much better :( good work!
This is so cool!
tysm!!
I never thought I'd find my childhood favourite channel without searching on RUclips
Same!! It's so wild seeing one of my fav childhood creators like something I participated in haha
WHOA WHAT I’m amazed that they commented
BRO LOVE YOUR VIDEOS LOL
A Reedshine MAP that does not demonize neither her or Appledusk!!
Well done everyone!
But despite this, Appledusk is terrible
@@Nakazivuishi
Terrible for cheating, yeah.
But aside from that, he’s just a morally grey guy.
I've never seen a map show Appledusk actually filled with regret for what he did to Burchface.
I honestly wouldn't mind if we got a novel for him , just to see how he felt about Mapleshade and his whole situation, and how he fell in love with Reedshine.
AppleReed are so cute, but so underrated! Thanks for this MAP, I missed content on these two
I absolutely love Appledusk and Reedshine. This MAP is so adorable 😭🙏 Amazing song choice too frfr
The artist even sounds like her 😢
Why love Apple...
Apple is stupid
anyone else remember that youtube video to this song of a blonde girl and brunette boy who meet as kids and fall in love and it was super sad with the dog and everything 😭
OMG, YESS! I cried like a baby when I watched that:')
I- No-
😭
Reedshine and Appledusk my beloved, ahhhhhh I love them so much.
I also love how clearly distrust Apple is over a Birches death, reading about it, with how it’s described as Flower and Birches head coming out of the water, screaming in terror or just a second before being put dragged back under. I can imagine being their or causing it.
And the way Maple treated OMG, Birch was her clan mate and she treats it like an inconvenience
“If only you hadn’t killed Birchface” she doesn’t treat it like a tragedy,sifee see isiusheh that annoys me so much, Maple he died, he wasn’t some inconvenience he was a clan mate, and how she doesn’t even care who freaking upset Apple is, I love this MAP.
Nowhere was it shown that Maple didn't care about Birchface... rather, Apple did. "It was just an accident," he snapped gloomily.
I still blame Appledusk but feel sorry for the kits
Anyway, good work animators
I also hate Appledusk but I feel sorry for Reedshine.....she deserved so much better
Womp wom
When I heard the music all I was imaging was the “me pulling out my wallet as fast as I can to give to the officer”
This is such a lovely MAP! I love both Appledusk and Reedshine, so it’s nice to see a project that doesn’t demonize either of them!!
However, Appledusk is terrible.
love a map that doesnt demonise my son appledusk. my all time favourite character, amazing job!
Terrible...it's terrible! If this Appledusk is good to some extent, then I can assume that Darkstripe is too!
Imagine hanging out with ur bf and seeing his ex gf stalking at you two from a bush
That can happen quite often to people💀
Not his ex, though. The girl he cheated on with Reed, ahaha
Aww this is an absolutely adorable and heartbreaking map I love reedshine sm
This is to emotional for me
Everytime I hear this song always those tiktok vids reminded.
Omg I can't believe this only has 107 views and 27 likes? This M.A.P is so amazing and underrated, everyone did great! I'm subscribing now 😎✨✨
I LOVE REEDSHINE!!!!!!!!!!!! she deserved better
🍁🍂🍂🍂🍁🍁🍁❤️❤️❤️❤️
OHHH this turned out so sweet!!! love reedshine sm, she deserved so much better😭
ty for letting me work on this project!!! it turned out beautiful :D
yo guys there's now another completed map I hosted similiar to this one but about Heathertail, go check it out! ruclips.net/video/w6IgWSgJBLo/видео.htmlfeature=shared
This is such a sweet, heartwarming map! Everyone did incredibly well, I'm so glad I found this!
OMG I used to hear all the time on the radio! Love that it’s in a map and a map about one of my favorite books in the series!❤
I like the idea that reedshine does feel some empathy for mapleshade
Appledusk and Reedshine are two of my favorite characters in Warriors, and, alot of Maple stans attack me for that, and also simply because I dislike Mapleshade. This map holds a dear place in my heart, as it represents Reedshine and Appledusk MORE than just ‘side characters that Mapleshade can wreak revenge on because she's an insufferable asshole.’ Gorgeous map.
Realest comment
Omg YESSS I agree so much!
Out of curiousity, why do you dislike Mapleshade and why are Appledusk and Reedshine your favs? Dw I'm not gonna attack you for your opinions, I'm not one of those Mapleshade stans.
@@evelutioncor I am a Crookedstar kinnie, Mapleshade groomed him and multiple other apprentices and kits after death to do what she wanted, and also objectified Appledusk and mentally abused him. I like Appledusk because he's morally grey, he's neither good nor bad. Sure he cheated on Mapleshade, but he loved Reedshine and every one of his kits, even the ones he had with Mapleshade. He gave his life for Reedshine. Hope this covers it ^_^
@@ccowpokeHOWEVER, this freak acted like a redneck. He didn't deserve either Reedshine or Mapleshade. He's an abuser and a redflag, and that was even said. He abandoned a cat that must have been bursting with pain. Just to warm the sides of the tribe. A stump who has no right to be called Maple's ex, and who has no right to be called the father of her kittens. HER kittens! Only her, and no one else. She loved them so much that she was ready to give her life for them, and also literally became a sadist to take revenge for them. She is a miracle woman-mother, keep it up.
I love this sm !!!! I don’t even have the words for it
Everyone did so well!!
petition for more reedshine maps
👇
AHHH ITS DONE!!! TYSM FOR HAVING ME EVERYONE DID AN OUTSTANDING JOB ON THEIR PARTS!!
I LOVE THIS, OMG, EVERYONE DID GREAT!!!
OMG ITS FINISHED IT TURNED OUT SO AWESOME
I LOVE THIS?????? I PROUD OF U GUYS
Ty again for having me Kora! It was a lot of fun!
I love the way this turned out!! So happy to have been able to participate :D
i hate appeldusk so much but love mappleshade and reedshine they deserved better
Yeah no Mapleshade definitely deserved her fate. Reedshine is the only victim here
@@0.721xdude. She lost everything because she was looking for love... it turns out that Reedshine also deserved a terrible life because she fell in love
HOLY MOLY A MAP FROM 4 DAYS AGO??? THIS IS SO GOOD
Such a lovely map!
Beautiful map!
this came out awesome!!!
THATS SO GORGEOUS AND UNDERRATED!! >:0
This is so cute!
IM VERY LATE HOLY MOLY- 😭
But anyway, I'm here to say that the map is very good! The 2000s vibe is really searing in this and I LOVE IT 🤭 It was great to participate in this! I'm honored :D
YES PLSSSS MORE BG CHARACTERRRRRS
Great job!!! Everyone did great!!+
This is so cute
Wooooo! This is so cute and sad! :
This is amazing! (Also 700th sub!^^)
I need a map where instead of staying with appledusk reddshine goes with mapleshade
Proshipper moment
@@0.721x Touch grass
Maple literally attempted to kill her and her unborn kits, that would never happen lol
@@sarahblack9333proshippers mad lolll
@@0.721x babies what
I have to say i found nice the way how she changed a bit her opinion about appledusk after she had know that he got pregnant a cat from another clan and then left her for dont break the warrior code even if i will always keep be sad for appleshade she was the best mother? Not really because she have caused accidentally the kits death in the river after they have told her to dont cross and she was too focused on her anger instead of care for the safety of her kits but if the things would be ended different i belive she would be a better cat and a lovely mother and a good partner but sadly the things did turn bad for her and reedshine looks like the only one who have understood this point of view even if she couldn't nothing for fix her fury and is ended to see the cat she loved after everything is happened between he and mapleshade die in front of her with their kits with his last memory
I love Reedshine
Ngl i wanna see a map where Maple nd reed end up sort of teaming up.
This is soooo good but i hate Reedshine XD
Reedshine didn't do anything wrong but okay 😭🙏
I loved this so much. But ngl I dislike how the books do some of the cats so dirty. Like Maple’s life was trash. 💀
If you read the book she honestly kinds just brought it upon herself what happened (not Apple cheating, but everything else) she felt like everything she did was right even when it was clearly not, she continued to encourage the lie that Birchface was the father, and just straight up told Ravenwing when he found her 💀 And it was a very dumb decision to go across a flash flooded river too, especially when she was told countless time it wasn't safe, even by her kit.
I mean, her life sucked, but she kinda made it suck from all the silly decisions she made imo
@5re0r gonna disagree a bit here, she doesn't directly tell raven that appledusk was the father but he already knew cause the omen + the way he interacted with the kits and how they played in the river. I also don't think she deserved to have her kits thrown out of the clan, oakstar was a complete ass by banishing innocent children cause they don't have 'pure' blood (in my opinion, nobody is innocent expect myler, the kits, perchpaw and nettlepaw and possibly reedshine since she didn't know he was cheating (though she was a bit rude, I don't think that makes her awful); the rest have done something "bad" at least once in the book.)
@@blueberry7400 Oh yeah that's my mistake, and yeah I agree those kits definitely didn't deserve anything that happened! All I'm saying is Mapleshade kind of just didn't care much. She thought StarClan was allowing her to do what she did, and her being exiled n shit kinda just happened due to her ignorance really - But yeah no one by any means was innocent
@@5re0rshe didn’t lie to anyone about her father... what nonsense. Come on, bro, Riedshine was definitely sick with Down syndrome, believe me
Okay, I don’t like Reedshine or Appledusk, but I NEVER see MAPS of them and I love this. Actually- good job.
I get not liking appledusk, but how come you dislike reed? /Gen /nm!
@@masoch1st1c she’s a pick me /hj it’s probably because I love Mapleshade and as Reedshine stole Appledusk from Maple I just don’t like her for that reason as well.
@@MentallyBrokenKitty reed stole nobody from no one? She had no idea about mapleshade and neither did she control appledusks actions 😭
@@masoch1st1c might just be because I love Mapleshade lol-
@@MentallyBrokenKitty yeah i get that, but no need to demonize characters who r pretty much interesting. You can dislike reedshine but please do not mischaracterize her
Appledusks sucks tho
i really wish reedshine had defended mapleshade instead of appledusk. yeah appledusk was probably sad about his kits but reedshine didn’t even care that he was cheating on both her and mapleshade with each other, and just acted like he did absolutely nothing wrong and helped him cast out the GRIEVING MOTHER. in my universe, reedshine would leave appledusk and bond with mapleshade instead over the similarities in what happened to them both
Appledusk left Mapleshade because he believed that she was to blame for their kits drowning as not at all long before her exile, Appledusk, and two of his clanmates warned Mapleshade that the kits could've drowned in the river. (Keep in mind that two of Mapleshade's clanmates drowned in that exact river). So, it makes sense as to why Appledusk blamed Mapleshade for what happened to the kits.
Before he and Mapleshade broke up, he truly loved Mapleshade and their kits. Even after they broke up, he couldn't bring himself to fight Mapleshade, showing he still cared for her, just not romantically, despite the fact that Mapleshade was trying to harm not only Appledusk, but his new mate and his apprentice.
Stepping away from his relationship with Mapleshade, he loved his new mate, Reedshine, just as much as he loved his former mate, Mapleshade. In fact, he loved and cared for Reedshine enough to sacrifice his life to save her, as Mapleshade was initially aiming for Reedshine, not Appledusk.
Just the she cat who stole apple disks feeling for maple shade. I believe he truly loved maple shade but reedshine was so pushy he eventually found it easier to be with her but like a cruel Tom he feel for reedshide only to abandon mapleshade. He should have defended her. His betrayal is part of what made her go crazy. Makes me wonder how he would have acted if larch/patch& petalkit had lived
She didn't "steal" him. We don't know enough about her or anything abt Appledusk and her relationship to just start making silly headcanons like this 💀 From the book, he was most likely just friends with her and since he couldn't talk to Mapleshade when Darkstar put out more patrols, him and Reedshine probably just gained feelings like that. That's the most likely canon option honestly LOL
Also Reedshine was never pushy whatsoever
@@5re0r literally Appledusk was not really showing interest in her but reedshine tried everything to spend every minute with Apple dusk, even though I never really saw Apple dust being that interested her until after Maple Shade’s kits were born. The scene where she tells Apple desk, that there’s a funny story about an elder, choking on a frog I literally always just saw that as an excuse to get him to come hang out with her there’s no way a story like that can be that funny the way she tells him about it she literally acts like it’s the funniest thing on earth when really, it’s just mildly amusing
@@Luna_moon_1127 okay?? So what? 😭 that doesn't me she was trying to STEAL him. she was literally just interested in talking to her clanmate bro, you need better reading comprehension
Appledusk design is so 2009-2014
yep I did that on purpose! old warrior cats designs were so fun, I want them back lol
Come on ReedShine, MapleShade had AppleDusk first. Don't fall in love with him right in front of her!
For real thats why i hate she
Womp womp. Try reading the book. :3
All Reedshine really did was insist Appledusk hears a funny story, nothin’ too deep.
Everybody says that Mapleshade was sooo evil, but who can blame her? She was betrayed!
Yeah but Mapleshade didn’t have to kill those cats, even if her exile was unfair, the death of her kits was completely her fault.
@@Kotop-o4pshe had nowhere to go... plus hunger, cold, tired, wounded and kittens at her side. Panic! A hopeless situation! Any way means the death of the kittens! The enemy is behind you, watching you, you need to act quickly! Oops..
@@Nakazivuishi She could’ve gone to the bridge or the twoleg place(Oakstar only raids it once in Pinestar’s choice)
@@Kotop-o4poh no! You go to the bridge, and... you slip, fall into the river! And there is no guarantee that there was one at all. We are going into the territory of two-legged... oops... the kittens got sick because of the rain, they got sick green cough! Death of kittens! Death of kittens!
@@Nakazivuishi The bridge was wide, no way they could just slip and fall. You can’t get greencough from the rain.
Nice map, but Reed really should’ve dipped CANT think of a bigger red flag than having a side chick with dead kids
I still think mapleshade deserved better instead of reedshine
But otherwise this is amazing!
Yes! Mapleshade was looking for love, but she got...
Mapleshade Her Kits Death Sad Mother Cat
Appledusk x Reedshie Poor Mapleshade :(
Womp womp
Wait I’m confused- did Reedshine hate Mapleshade and her kits or?
Other way around
@@catweedcocaine so she was sorry for their fate? (I’m so sorry- I never got to read the books much-)
mapleshade hated reedshine and her children cause they were of appledusk's kin (and appledusk cheated on her with reed) mapleshade directly tries to kill Reed in the book but appledusk gets in the way and is killed instead.
Appldusk should've saw that coming
@blueberry7400 lol have you even read?? Appledusk moved on. I mean, wouldn't you leave someone who got ur kids killed??
Ok Reedshine and Appledusk are fr the worst cats i ever seen (my opinion) but i need to say...good map
Reedshine isn't bad. She defended Appledusk when Mapleshade came in because she didn't know about him cheating on Maple at first, and she defended him because he was the father of her kits and she needed him most.
а кто родился у рогозницы?
Reedshine and Appledusk are actually a good couple….but then Appledusk cheated-
There are like two things that could have been the case. We don't know that he cheated. It was Mapleshade's assumption, similar to how she assumed Frecklewish wanted the kits dead and how she assumed Ravenwing had malicious intent.
Appledusk could have been mates with Reedshine before becoming mates with Mapleshade.
Appledusk could have already been friends with Reedshine, and when he broke up with Mapleshade, he may have just become mates with Reedshine.
(Keep in mind that the only time Reedshine is pregnant is at the end of the book).
@@_The_Lizard_King I like to think the 2nd one, since Reed actively spoke with Apple like during the gathering in the first chapter. Maple was also very obsessive and possessive of Appledusk too, so it may have made sense that he would break it off with her
It'd be nice if we had other books like a Super Edition to fill in lil holes, or just author statements abt things like that in MV honestly 🙏
no...Ridshine was pregnant 3 days later?SERIOUSLY?Dude, read biology about cats@@_The_Lizard_King
@@Nakazivuishi I have taken care of numerous pregnant cats. I'm literally a foster for the stray cats in my neighborhood. I've done plenty of research on cat pregnancy.
They don't start showing the first few days. And guess what; Reedshine was never showing in the books. 🤯
There were no romantic interactions between Appledusk and Reedshine until *after* he left Mapleshade. The first time we see him reciprocate Reedshine's affection was when he broke up with Mapleshade. "Oh, but Reedshine was pregnant," you claim. But Reedshine was only pregnant multiple days after Appledusk and Mapleshade broke up. Mind you, Reedshine wasn't even showing at the end of the book. The only reason Mapleshade knew Reedshine was pregnant was because Appledusk, the cat that got her pregnant, said she was pregnant.
boo, reedshine sucks!! but nice map :)
What did reedshine ever do?
She's a victim
Mapledhade is a horrible cat who deserves that faith.
Reedshine didn't do anything wrong.
@@Urfavv_livvy1MAPLESHADE IS THE BEST
@@IxL3nn0xIReedshine better.
@@Urfavv_livvy1um... duh???