You both got the most bizarre boxes this month. Either products that I've never seen before or in anybody else's boxes this month, or products that were sent out months and months and months ago. The big news update is that they're announcing something at 7 a.m. PST tomorrow morning. It has something to do with Ipsy and boxycharm doing something together. Katrina, there are websites you can go on to check the expiration dates for your products. I had it on my old phone but it didn't get transferred to this one somehow. I would just Google skincare expiration look up and see what comes up for you. You just put in the lot number at the bottom and it brings up the expiry date or the date of production. Hope that helps.
I really appreciate your ladies honesty. I'm still thankful I canceled all 3 tiers of boxycharm. They went so downhill the minute ipsy took over. It's unfortunate. Great video ladies. 💓
The boxes were just a random hodgepodge this month. Like a bunch of throwaway items. I happened to get a decent box with my foundation choice, but I saw a lot of very random products in other’s boxes.
I got the ciate compact too. I am light skinned and was scared but it goes on a lot lighter than in the pan. The pink actually makes a really nice blush. I’m also 44 and looking for a youthful dewy look now anyway. That was the best thing I got I think.
I agree that it was a bad boxy month. And even if you did pick the rare beauty foundation, you probably wouldn’t have received it and been given a $6 credit for it. My box came with 2 lips products, one is hot pink and glittery and I have no idea when I would ever wear it, the other is a balm. I got a neutral tarte eyeshadow palette (which I have so many neutrals already), eyebrow conditioner (like wtf) and a primer which I will use. I would give my box a 2/5
They were a let down for sure. I do like the FAB cleanser. I use it a bunch. I don't get Boxycharm anymore. I agree with you both. Have a great week ❌️ ⭕️
Boxycharm and Ipsy are going to be on one site. Not merging but both will be available on one website instead of separate ones. And personally I’ve been liking Ipsy better than boxy the last year or so. It use to be the other way around. “Shadow Moon” reminded me of American Gods. 😂 I love that name !!! 😉
I found the FAB cleanser at TJMaxx quite some time ago, maybe a year? I notice that TJMaxx gets discontinued products, so maybe it's pretty old. Look for a website you can input the lot number into, and that'll tell you when it was produced or expires.
It was Rare beauty foundation. I was able to make it my choice then I got an email saying it was out of stock. My box was poopy! I got the mascara liquid eye shadow, lip liner, lip gloss and a primer. I have gotten 3 of the products before. Great video ladies! Much love sent from Ontario Canada 🇨🇦
Good evening Rachel and Katrina!!! Out of both boxes I like Rachel's the best. My favorite out each box would be the mascara. Thank you so much for sharing with us, and I hope you both have a Blessed night!!!
They just announced it they are becoming one !! It’s a lot better for boxy subscribers as you will get add ons and you get to choose 3 products and see your box ahead of time just like Ipsy so that’s great !
I haven't gotten my box yet. I hope I get the Iconic highlighter pallette in my box. I have identical twin daughters who turn 23 yrs old next month and they love the cream highlighters, contours, and blushes the most.
Just got an email...Ipsy and Boxycharm are merging. That's their big announcement. Glam bag is same, Glam Bag Plus is now Boxycharm, and Glam Bag X is now Iconic Box.
I got my base box today and premium Saturday. My base box was fantastic. My premium was lackluster. None of my products were the same as any of yours. None were put in my: Give it to my nieces pile. I would not have been happy with any of your products except Rachel’s eyeshadow palate. Great for everyday. Wow! Who knows how they select who gets what!
Looks like this month everyone got hodgepodge boxes comprised of crap they couldn’t get rid of in their sales. I got the standard apology for once again not getting my choice of the foundation, in spite or picking it at 10:30 am on choice day, and getting confirmation of my choice. Boxy is still advertising to new subs that they will get the foundation if they sign up. WTH?? They can’t stay in business with the rate of us old subs canceling, and the new subs won’t stay if they promise them things and don’t deliver. Boxy has become the standard example of promising one thing and delivering nothing.
Hi girls. This month they send to us the old stuff. Not happy with boxycharm and if you live in Canada do not waist your money until you see something that you really want. xox
In my base box this month i got the Iconic London Highlighter, the Benefit mascara, the Mischo liquid eyeshadow, the Evio lip serum, and a nail poilish from Orosa. I was initially disappointed in my box, i would’ve given it a 2.5 ⭐️ but after trying everything i really liked these products. It’s a 4 ⭐️ box for me now!
I Feel the same way as you I will be so surprised if it is them merging but somebody else I follow pretty much said it was confirmed it wouldn't make any sense that would be a last ditch effort instead of claiming bankruptcy and going out of business I mean if you think about it if they are getting 4 payments a month from me between the boxes and they combine they are only going to be getting 2 payments that's what they started out with and how would that be exciting to anybody who wants to receive a bunch of different packages?? Oh girl don't kick yourself in the butt over the foundation choice if you check their social media 80% of people who chose foundation received an email saying they would not be getting their choice instead they ended up getting mascara which affects your entire variation. I don't know what happened there only certain people that chose certain shades got it and I know that I chose a light shade for my daughter and I did not get it. Oh my gosh the shadow moon is such a joke I do not know anybody who is happy receiving that I would much rather receive like cut crease stickers or little stickers to do a wing how are you going to get them even when you have to hold it?
Thats a shame they put older products in the Box you pay enough for it 🤔 😂😂”old room. Scent Brilliant Great video Katrina & Rachel. Have a Good weekend 🥰
I honestly think that they are using these couple of months to just get rid of old stock. So there will not be a card with info and a numbered variation. Like so so so many people are not happy at all this month. I seen one base box that had the mascara two brow products and two lip products. I get it in a business sense they have to get rid of this stock but there is definitely better ways of doing it. So sorry ladies! But you both are hilarious with your analogies of smells 😂😂😂! Thanks for sharing ❤
I think they will merge cause they sent out that email survey about it few months ago and they both have the exact same message about something coming so I feel like it has to include both Ipsy and Boxy …if you go in your boxy account and go to where it says the box then click on the current box it will tell you about every item that ppl would get so if you ever can’t find a product go there and you will find it …the boxes was ok this month I wanted the rare beauty foundation but they didn’t have my color
I liked Katrina’s box better. Sadly, the lip oil smelled bad. Rachel’s was good except the eyeshadow shield. I agree not a good month for either of u. Not good products. Still love to watch u guys especially when u guys describe scents! U have me hysterical! 😂! See u on the next one! ❤
I thought I would like cream blush because I thought I had dry skin but I find myself using more powders in my old age. I always had straight hair now I have all these waves both boxes are about the same as far as who's is the best
There’s no method to their madness this month. Random throw togethers. Not small variations. I got one product that I can’t review for charms cause it’s not listed. True & Luscious plumping lip and eye serum. Then evioskin lip serum (rare is my preference for lip stuff and I got 2 last month, reds not neutral preference lol). Micho liquid shadow that’s not impressive. (Dries to a different color and fades away) Not my choice item of benefits magnet mascara, cause they ran out of my shade of foundation. But pleasantly happy with iconic London dewy glow highlighter in 3 shades. Ipsy is also saying that have a huge announcement apparently. Merge may be on the horizon. If the announcement is tomorrow it will help me decide how I’m changing my subscriptions
Odacite brand I've tried samples of & was never a fan of any of them. The ones I sampled smelled horrible...so butthole is an honest opinion Rachel 😆 I feel like Beauty Bakery would be a good brand geared towards teens who are just getting into makeup. Neither one of these boxes were exciting to me. I have been curious about that mascara so keep us posted if u like it. There are sooo many mascaras & brands to choose from...it makes being a beauty junkie hard😄
Wow! Usually I get at least one thing or another that you or Rachel got, but this time I didn't get anything you two got. I got TWO eye palettes(woo hoo!), one from Persona and one from Tarte. Both palettes are so pretty. I received BDB brow conditioner, which I use every night. I received Toy Factory's hyaluronic and collagen face primer(can't wait to try it), and Give Them Lala liquid lipstick in Take it Off, a very pretty, neutral caramel color. I am even whiter than you, Katrina, if ghats possible, lol! I don't know about you, but I have almost no pigment jn my lips at all, so I have to be cautious about the shade of my lipstick. The liquid lipstick I got this month works quite nicely with my complexion. Sounds as though I made out better on my Boxycharm than you and Rachel did! I rated my box at 4.5.(only because I need to try the primer to see how it works) Well...lucky me, lol!
I think what they are merging is the boxy base and glam bag plus. On instagram they are hinting two full size boxes both from Ipsy and boxy. I’m thinking they are getting rid of glam bag plugs and the trial size. I’m not sure about premium, glam x, or luxe. I can be wrong but just following the clues. Supposedly we will find out the details tomorrow
The base and premium boxes for everyone had 1 or 2 current products and then the other 3-4 products were old stock lying around the old Boxycharm warehouse. So they will be end of line old stock or products no longer sold and can only be found on Ebay or TK Maxx. It’s just dodgy business practice. They put the prices up of the Boxycharm boxes and give us pure old stock. Just wish they’d hurry up and merge the boxes and give us new exciting products from known brands. And stop all the cheap private label brands and old stock
I am REALLY annoyed that my Feb box still shows "Shipping" on the Boxy website. I'm seriously considering just cancelling bc I am not as excited about the boxes Ive been receiving for prob the last 6 mo
@Cate Harding I just got mine today 2/25, and get this... I have never in over 5 years of BoxyCharm gotten not just one, not just TWO, but THREE FREAKING MASCARAS in one box. 😳 Yeah I can use mascara but wtaf??? This is totally like they are clearing out the stock at the BoxyCharm offices. I'm kinda pissed. I didn't get my choice item, I got 3 mascaras and then the lip serum one of the girls got, and the dewy bronzer that Katrina got.
@@msdraeneichick I strangely got 6 items. 2 primers, 2 lip colors - 1 being almost black, an eyebrow conditioner/primer, and a beautiful tarte eyeshadow pallet. I lov e the pallette...
I also chose to rare beauty complexion product and got an email that they would not be able to send almost a month after choice and confirmation email. Still haven’t received February box. Did anyone get the foundation???
I love the beauty bakery eyeshadow, but the rest of your box stuff sucks.. I hate that mascara it’s doesn’t work that great… and the lip oil 😮sucks I got that tooo
I find you are whining about a lot of things lately, 😞 you are normally not this bad. Did you ever consider you're getting tired of boxes? I'm not being negative I'm just pointing out what I see. You are the one that purchased, you are the one that accepted the pr. Try to show a little gratitude instead of so much negativity...
I love videos of you and your sister together. “Old room” scent ~ you crack me up.
Rachel's scent descriptions are always hilarious
You both got the most bizarre boxes this month. Either products that I've never seen before or in anybody else's boxes this month, or products that were sent out months and months and months ago. The big news update is that they're announcing something at 7 a.m. PST tomorrow morning. It has something to do with Ipsy and boxycharm doing something together.
Katrina, there are websites you can go on to check the expiration dates for your products. I had it on my old phone but it didn't get transferred to this one somehow. I would just Google skincare expiration look up and see what comes up for you. You just put in the lot number at the bottom and it brings up the expiry date or the date of production.
Hope that helps.
I really appreciate your ladies honesty. I'm still thankful I canceled all 3 tiers of boxycharm. They went so downhill the minute ipsy took over. It's unfortunate. Great video ladies. 💓
Great job I will do the same.
I love that Rachel is wanting to experiment more with eye products!
Thanks for the awesome haul. Both of you are looking good!!! Ipsy and BoxyCharm are getting together, should be great!!!!
The boxes were just a random hodgepodge this month. Like a bunch of throwaway items. I happened to get a decent box with my foundation choice, but I saw a lot of very random products in other’s boxes.
I love First Aid Beauty
I got the ciate compact too. I am light skinned and was scared but it goes on a lot lighter than in the pan. The pink actually makes a really nice blush. I’m also 44 and looking for a youthful dewy look now anyway. That was the best thing I got I think.
Sister sister throw down!! Bunch in a row nice. 💖💖💖
You didn’t miss much with choice, a lot of us that picked the foundation didn’t get it.
I agree that it was a bad boxy month. And even if you did pick the rare beauty foundation, you probably wouldn’t have received it and been given a $6 credit for it. My box came with 2 lips products, one is hot pink and glittery and I have no idea when I would ever wear it, the other is a balm. I got a neutral tarte eyeshadow palette (which I have so many neutrals already), eyebrow conditioner (like wtf) and a primer which I will use. I would give my box a 2/5
They were a let down for sure. I do like the FAB cleanser. I use it a bunch. I don't get Boxycharm anymore. I agree with you both. Have a great week ❌️ ⭕️
I’m loving Rachel’s hair down, looks great 🌺
Hey 👋🏼 Katrina and Rachel I’m excited to see who got the best box 📦. I like Rachel’s the most because of the Palette.
Hi Girls I love Sister vs Sister so fun!
Boxycharm and Ipsy are going to be on one site. Not merging but both will be available on one website instead of separate ones.
And personally I’ve been liking Ipsy better than boxy the last year or so. It use to be the other way around.
“Shadow Moon” reminded me of American Gods. 😂 I love that name !!! 😉
Thanks ladies
So many people got repeats/old products this month, BoxyCharm is cleaning out.
Hi. I was happy with my premium boxycharm for February. Tfs. Sorry you both were displeased. ❤
I found the FAB cleanser at TJMaxx quite some time ago, maybe a year? I notice that TJMaxx gets discontinued products, so maybe it's pretty old. Look for a website you can input the lot number into, and that'll tell you when it was produced or expires.
It was Rare beauty foundation. I was able to make it my choice then I got an email saying it was out of stock. My box was poopy! I got the mascara liquid eye shadow, lip liner, lip gloss and a primer. I have gotten 3 of the products before. Great video ladies! Much love sent from Ontario Canada 🇨🇦
the same here girl, they did that to me 2 times, well why you let me select if you will not send it to me
Did you reach out to get a refund or credit? That happened to me in December and I did end up getting a refund
I love watching you guys! ❤️ You both got some weird stuff in your boxes...lol. You two stay healthy and stay safe!
I love my shadow moon!!!
Lol 🤣😆😆 Rachel cracks me up,. I gotta get that lip gloss she has on ..from Ipsy bag it looks like.
Hi Katrina and Rachel, I love how you describe the products lol
Good evening Rachel and Katrina!!! Out of both boxes I like Rachel's the best. My favorite out each box would be the mascara. Thank you so much for sharing with us, and I hope you both have a Blessed night!!!
They just announced it they are becoming one !! It’s a lot better for boxy subscribers as you will get add ons and you get to choose 3 products and see your box ahead of time just like Ipsy so that’s great !
I haven't gotten my box yet. I hope I get the Iconic highlighter pallette in my box. I have identical twin daughters who turn 23 yrs old next month and they love the cream highlighters, contours, and blushes the most.
Just got an email...Ipsy and Boxycharm are merging. That's their big announcement. Glam bag is same, Glam Bag Plus is now Boxycharm, and Glam Bag X is now Iconic Box.
I got my base box today and premium Saturday. My base box was fantastic. My premium was lackluster. None of my products were the same as any of yours. None were put in my: Give it to my nieces pile. I would not have been happy with any of your products except Rachel’s eyeshadow palate. Great for everyday. Wow! Who knows how they select who gets what!
Looks like this month everyone got hodgepodge boxes comprised of crap they couldn’t get rid of in their sales. I got the standard apology for once again not getting my choice of the foundation, in spite or picking it at 10:30 am on choice day, and getting confirmation of my choice.
Boxy is still advertising to new subs that they will get the foundation if they sign up. WTH?? They can’t stay in business with the rate of us old subs canceling, and the new subs won’t stay if they promise them things and don’t deliver. Boxy has become the standard example of promising one thing and delivering nothing.
Yes my favorite videos of all the time ❤
I got 4 eyeshadow palettes this month.. two in each box. One of the ones in premium expires today… terrible boxes.
My box was lame too and I also was meh on the highlight palette thing
Hi girls. This month they send to us the old stuff. Not happy with boxycharm and if you live in Canada do not waist your money until you see something that you really want. xox
In my base box this month i got the Iconic London Highlighter, the Benefit mascara, the Mischo liquid eyeshadow, the Evio lip serum, and a nail poilish from Orosa. I was initially disappointed in my box, i would’ve given it a 2.5 ⭐️ but after trying everything i really liked these products. It’s a 4 ⭐️ box for me now!
Hi! I agree with both of you Ladies, this month isn’t a good one for Boxycharm😣😳😜😃Maybe next month will be better🤷♀️💁🏼♀️🙋🏼♀️🇨🇦😘😘♥️♥️🌹🌹
I Feel the same way as you I will be so surprised if it is them merging but somebody else I follow pretty much said it was confirmed it wouldn't make any sense that would be a last ditch effort instead of claiming bankruptcy and going out of business I mean if you think about it if they are getting 4 payments a month from me between the boxes and they combine they are only going to be getting 2 payments that's what they started out with and how would that be exciting to anybody who wants to receive a bunch of different packages?? Oh girl don't kick yourself in the butt over the foundation choice if you check their social media 80% of people who chose foundation received an email saying they would not be getting their choice instead they ended up getting mascara which affects your entire variation. I don't know what happened there only certain people that chose certain shades got it and I know that I chose a light shade for my daughter and I did not get it. Oh my gosh the shadow moon is such a joke I do not know anybody who is happy receiving that I would much rather receive like cut crease stickers or little stickers to do a wing how are you going to get them even when you have to hold it?
Thats a shame they put older products in the Box you pay enough for it 🤔
😂😂”old room. Scent Brilliant Great video Katrina & Rachel.
Have a Good weekend 🥰
Rachel, if you don't mind, what mascara do you have on in this video?
I honestly think that they are using these couple of months to just get rid of old stock. So there will not be a card with info and a numbered variation. Like so so so many people are not happy at all this month. I seen one base box that had the mascara two brow products and two lip products. I get it in a business sense they have to get rid of this stock but there is definitely better ways of doing it. So sorry ladies! But you both are hilarious with your analogies of smells 😂😂😂! Thanks for sharing ❤
I think they will merge cause they sent out that email survey about it few months ago and they both have the exact same message about something coming so I feel like it has to include both Ipsy and Boxy …if you go in your boxy account and go to where it says the box then click on the current box it will tell you about every item that ppl would get so if you ever can’t find a product go there and you will find it …the boxes was ok this month I wanted the rare beauty foundation but they didn’t have my color
Rachel you look so cute today love your hair
I’ve been hearing bad things about people’s boxy charm boxes lately….
I liked Katrina’s box better. Sadly, the lip oil smelled bad. Rachel’s was good except the eyeshadow shield. I agree not a good month for either of u. Not good products. Still love to watch u guys especially when u guys describe scents! U have me hysterical! 😂! See u on the next one! ❤
I thought I would like cream blush because I thought I had dry skin but I find myself using more powders in my old age. I always had straight hair now I have all these waves both boxes are about the same as far as who's is the best
hope I get the Iconic palette
Mean was bad too this month I got a tarte eyeshadow palette that's about it was really bad. 🤔🤔🙄🙄🙄
There’s no method to their madness this month. Random throw togethers. Not small variations. I got one product that I can’t review for charms cause it’s not listed. True & Luscious plumping lip and eye serum. Then evioskin lip serum (rare is my preference for lip stuff and I got 2 last month, reds not neutral preference lol). Micho liquid shadow that’s not impressive. (Dries to a different color and fades away) Not my choice item of benefits magnet mascara, cause they ran out of my shade of foundation. But pleasantly happy with iconic London dewy glow highlighter in 3 shades. Ipsy is also saying that have a huge announcement apparently. Merge may be on the horizon. If the announcement is tomorrow it will help me decide how I’m changing my subscriptions
I just re-subscribed ... bad timing .... but I think it's going to get good again
Odacite brand I've tried samples of & was never a fan of any of them. The ones I sampled smelled horrible...so butthole is an honest opinion Rachel 😆 I feel like Beauty Bakery would be a good brand geared towards teens who are just getting into makeup. Neither one of these boxes were exciting to me. I have been curious about that mascara so keep us posted if u like it. There are sooo many mascaras & brands to choose from...it makes being a beauty junkie hard😄
Wow! Usually I get at least one thing or another that you or Rachel got, but this time I didn't get anything you two got. I got TWO eye palettes(woo hoo!), one from Persona and one from Tarte. Both palettes are so pretty. I received BDB brow conditioner, which I use every night. I received Toy Factory's hyaluronic and collagen face primer(can't wait to try it), and Give Them Lala liquid lipstick in Take it Off, a very pretty, neutral caramel color. I am even whiter than you, Katrina, if ghats possible, lol! I don't know about you, but I have almost no pigment jn my lips at all, so I have to be cautious about the shade of my lipstick. The liquid lipstick I got this month works quite nicely with my complexion.
Sounds as though I made out better on my Boxycharm than you and Rachel did! I rated my box at 4.5.(only because I need to try the primer to see how it works) Well...lucky me, lol!
RACHEL!!!!!!
I got the same box as Rachel and I’m not trill about it, not the best month…
I think what they are merging is the boxy base and glam bag plus. On instagram they are hinting two full size boxes both from Ipsy and boxy. I’m thinking they are getting rid of glam bag plugs and the trial size. I’m not sure about premium, glam x, or luxe. I can be wrong but just following the clues. Supposedly we will find out the details tomorrow
The base and premium boxes for everyone had 1 or 2 current products and then the other 3-4 products were old stock lying around the old Boxycharm warehouse. So they will be end of line old stock or products no longer sold and can only be found on Ebay or TK Maxx.
It’s just dodgy business practice.
They put the prices up of the Boxycharm boxes and give us pure old stock.
Just wish they’d hurry up and merge the boxes and give us new exciting products from known brands. And stop all the cheap private label brands and old stock
My Boxy for both Jan and Feb felt like they were left overs. None of my were anything like I’ve seen in reviews.
Nice absolutely amazing so beautifull
I really think they are just throwing all their old crap into boxes to get rid of them I didn’t like either base or premium this month.
wow... bessst video
I am REALLY annoyed that my Feb box still shows "Shipping" on the Boxy website. I'm seriously considering just cancelling bc I am not as excited about the boxes Ive been receiving for prob the last 6 mo
Mine has been in that status too! I'm like "hello people, less than a week left in the month!"
@@msdraeneichickand until they charge our card!
Update- its 2/24 and I got my base box yesterday. The boxycharm website still has the status as "shipping"
@Cate Harding I just got mine today 2/25, and get this... I have never in over 5 years of BoxyCharm gotten not just one, not just TWO, but THREE FREAKING MASCARAS in one box. 😳 Yeah I can use mascara but wtaf??? This is totally like they are clearing out the stock at the BoxyCharm offices. I'm kinda pissed. I didn't get my choice item, I got 3 mascaras and then the lip serum one of the girls got, and the dewy bronzer that Katrina got.
@@msdraeneichick I strangely got 6 items. 2 primers, 2 lip colors - 1 being almost black, an eyebrow conditioner/primer, and a beautiful tarte eyeshadow pallet. I lov e the pallette...
I also chose to rare beauty complexion product and got an email that they would not be able to send almost a month after choice and confirmation email. Still haven’t received February box. Did anyone get the foundation???
Mascara was the only good thing.
Hi sweeties ❤❤
hey Rachel - aloha
I love the beauty bakery eyeshadow, but the rest of your box stuff sucks.. I hate that mascara it’s doesn’t work that great… and the lip oil 😮sucks I got that tooo
I had Rachel's box. Garbage. But all planned by Ipsy right?
I find you are whining about a lot of things lately, 😞 you are normally not this bad. Did you ever consider you're getting tired of boxes? I'm not being negative I'm just pointing out what I see. You are the one that purchased, you are the one that accepted the pr. Try to show a little gratitude instead of so much negativity...
You girls are so fun to watch. But ugh...... I feel like you guys are getting ripped off. Are they just sending you old or even returned 😱 products?