Who would have thought that Paul would end up solving his own murder. What a heartbreaking video taken just moments before 2 people's life ended in a brutal manner.
I mean this what sealed it. Saying you weren’t there and then only admitting you were once a video is released showing you were there is too damning to overcome
This is confusing. Does the video actually show him there? Or just his voice on the video? Yes, he admitted at trial that he was there. But I want to know if the video shows his face.
@@sarahnewcomb738 I know he admitted being at the kennels at the trial. I said that in my post. I am curious if the video shows him. Or his shadow. How close was he from being captured on video. Would be interesting to know where he was standing in relation to Paul and Maggie. And it is also strange that he would not notice Paul filming the dogs.
@@Better_Call_Raul his voice is heard. Due to how the laws of physics work, he has to be within earshot. Cellphone camera microphones are not that sensitive, therefore even if his voice comes up as “quiet” on the recording, he still had to have been loud enough i.e. close enough to have the camera pick up his voice. He was likely within 30-50 ft of the Kennels by my guessing.
@@Better_Call_Raul if he was minutes away from taking their lives, I think it's safe to presume he was more focused on his cover up and not really what the mom and son were doing... Only what he needed to do to pull off his crime. Also, the phone was pointed down, not exactly up and on display. Phones are our 11th appendage these days. I'm sure you and myself are in many videos and we never saw the phone either. It's just sad.
What is amazing is that the dog caught and brought them the chicken. If he was just standing there, Alex would have probably not said anything in that short video. It's like nature made sure that such an evil man's plan to get away with it failed.
Yes God had a hand in that. There was no way he’d ever get away with it. Our phones track us, they knew his steps from the phone he had too!! For someone supposedly so smart, he was stupid!
@@Corgi4pack Narcissists/sociopaths/psychopaths have no self-awareness.....they all think they are the smartest person around and have gotten away with no consequences for YEARS.....they are so proud it's easy for them to think they are smarter than cops/human behavior is so predictable. Alex is right where he belongs......no empathy, controlling, selfish, scheming....attributes of a Narcissist......and when they progress down the scale....they become dangerous....Jesus said "Satan was a Liar, Thief, Murderer from the very beginning.......Alex's progress: Liar, Thief, and Murderer......more to be revealed in the future......I think he was a gambler and possibly into trafficking women also.
This is so creepy, is almost unbelievable that someone who seemed to be in good standing with his son will go and just killed him, just like that, without remorse. That was his son. But then again, I remember Christopher Watts and all the other cases and it happens.
Paul kept finding his pill stash and telling Maggie. The boat death didn’t help either. The wrongful death lawsuit is what cracked open his finance books and exposed the theft
@@Paintmerosered I think he didn’t kill Buster because he liked him more OR because he knew he could handle himself during and after the impending implosion of their life OR because he simply wasn’t there at the time.
Alex, in the car during questioning, is focusing on keeping his story straight. He isn't displaying shock, grief, disbelief or any emotions that normal people would show upon discovering his wife and son shot dead. His voice is steady, his eyes move about like he is keeping track of his rehearsed story. I've never seen such a lack of emotion in a person, given the absolute MESS he is in. He had just blown the brains out of his own son and his wife, yet is lacking feeling.
he is a cold blooded killer. He is a drug addict, a money swindler, a schemer for insurance money, he killed his long time house help and defrauded the insurance company of her money..... that man has no morals and no conscience. he probably killed wife and son for insurance money too.
Pretty sure he killed them buf, where were the two weapons he was holding? Surely, the son would’ve said something seeing him with two guns in his hand just before he shoots him. And how would he not see Paul was recording if he shot him up close?
Sociopaths who also happen to be psychopaths are among us. Don't know how he can deceive his family like that, laughing, playing with dogs, and then just killing them. And then taking off to get rid of the guns, probably in some unknown body of water. It leaves a cold feeling in your heart.
My ex was/is a psychopath, in my opinion. I know how they do it, because I watched him. He practices deception. I mean, he literally practices lying to people, then scrutinizes their faces to see if they believe him. Deception and manipulation are skills they develop, like a musician practicing scales. At the time, I thought he was just annoying. I did not understand the seriousness of what I was seeing. That's the danger of psychopaths -- we don't know what they are, therefore, we can be deceived. By the time we figure it out, if we ever do, it's too late. Also, people are things to them. Accessories. Props that they use, like actors, to play a role. To play the role of a family man, you need a family. Do they mean anything to you? No. Just supply or fuel, as to a narcissist; or tools to paint an image of themselves...so they can get close enough to deceive more people.
THANKS FOR THIS VIDEO. SO SAD HIS OWN SON AND WIFE COULDN'T SENSE HE WAS SO DANGEROUS. WELL, MAYBE MAGGIES DOG BUBBA 🐕 SENSED THINGS WERE GOING TO GET VIOLENT. SEEMED LIKE MAGGIES DOG MAY HAVE BEEN TRYING TO DISTRACT ALEX FROM BREAKING BAD ON HIS WIFE AND SON. YET, AT LEAST BUBBA WAS ABLE TO GET ALEX TO YELL AT HIM. AND GOT ALEX TALKIN' ON THE VIDEO TAPE....THANK GOD FOR THAT. ❤ DEAR LORD HELP ALL INVOLED...ESPECAILLY THE VICTIMS. GOD BLESS ❤ AND PLEASE HELP 🙏 THEM ALL LORD GOD...BRING THEM PEACE AND JUSTICE PLEASE....❤PRAYING FOR YOU GOD TO COMFORT THESE VICTIMS LOVED ONES TOO. IN CHRIST JESUS HOLY NAME AND PERFECT BLOOD SACRIFICE AMEN 🙏❤.
It would appear he thought he had it all covered...EXCEPT...it never occurred to him to think of Paul making a recording. This video just sunk reasonable doubt. This man is going to prison
Yep I love these of cases. Also the Jodi Arias case where she accidently took pictures while she was killing Travis and prosecutor Martinez had a perry Mason moment with the 2 gas cans ordeal.
MAD TO THINK if this had happened just 10 years prior before the explosion in popularity of mobile video sharing, this murder could have well gone unsolved!
He believes he is above the law like the whole family has been for years. I don’t think he will get away with this ending the family history of cover ups
This!!! They have been covering it up for a long time & they have had the means and assets to financially cover it up. Attorneys are big on being close & having each other’s backs he even had law enforcement involved. These aren’t normal citizens we are talking about people of power. He’s used to getting a slap on the wrist but not this time.
U can tell by every single face in the room that they have got away with so much but it’s over for him this time. I wish he would step forward and just confess already, something tragic happened that day but they are good at cover ups u can tell he didn’t think this one thru he’s a personal injury attorney so he’s used to hearing tragic stuff all the time. That’s one reason he comes off cold or numb, but not enough to be believable this was his own child and wife I noticed he only cries when it comes to the thought of him being guilty for it….
Just because a family friend can't think of a reason that Alex would murder his son and wife...that doesn't mean anything. Spouses murder spouses all the time and usually their closest friends don't know of the problems. Murderers don't generally tell other people that they are going to murder their family members. And that family friend has absolutely nothing to gain by testifying. He probably feels bad, but he knows he has to. I for one have no doubt that Alex is a cold blooded murderer and he was so rich and powerful at one point that it all went to his head and he thought he was smarter than the cops. He needs to go to prison for the rest of his life. I hope his remaining son sees the lesson of all of this.
Innocent until PROVEN GUILTY. The presumption is always innocence. The prosecution has to PROVE guilt. Unfortunately, while he's probably guilty, he's not been proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt by any means. Missing evidence, while may be evidence in itself, is not proof.
Even if he deleted it it would still be there unopened on Paul's friends Snapchat feed, right? And of course beyond that LE could get it back in other ways.
@@astridvvv9662 people have testified that the service at the kennels was really crappy and alot of the times videos and call constantly didn't go thru
Paul And Maggie were killed most likely as REVENGE KILLINGS in association with the Boating accident. Those who fuelled the hatred that caused Paul and Maggie thier lives also have thier hands stained with thier blood! The murder scene has every fingerprint of REVENGE KILLINGS!! Those killers are still at Large!
I shudder at the thought of the absolute devastation Paul and Maggie mustve felt when they processed what was happening😔 How surreal it must've been. It's enough to bring tears to my eyes. It's heartbreaking.
@timpickels7900 we are to believe some vigilante showed up to the Murdaugh property UNARMED, found 2 loaded guns and was able to gun down Maggie and Paul in the 10-15 mins time after Alex walked off, then placed the dogs in their Kennels, and wrapped up the hose for them! Look at the evidence. Alex had the means, he had the motive and and and most of all he had the oppurtunity. The vigilante theory for a boating accident is so astronomically UNLIKELY. Alex lied about being there, he asked Ms sherry to lie about how long he was at his mom's. He tried convincing someone else of what he was wearing that day, he wasn't at all concerned for his or busters safety! He tried to have himself killed and lied about that! These aren't the actions of an innocent man. They're the actions of a desperate man, losing all control and willing to sacrifice anything and anyone to save himself.
Alex hunted them. First was the disabling shot and then the kill shot. Maggie was still moving after that first shot so he continued shooting disabling shots until the kill shot. That predatory hunting style was a worse kind of cold-hearted which should have had charges of Aggravated added.
The voice on the video just prior to the murder, combined with the wife's text about Alex acting "suspicious" just prior to the murder are pretty compelling evidence. Then there's the interview in the police car, where he doesn't seem devastated by the bad news which is pretty damning.
@@zakrios7389 it’s his voice. I can tell just from listening to his voice during the trial and listening to that video. The defense even admits- does this sound like a happy family “ so they are admitting he’s there at the crime scene
Seeing Alex Murdaugh in the squad car with no tears, shock, just keeping his made up story straight is disturbing. The Snapchat video basically sealed the deal and gave him that life sentence. Maggie and Paul got their justice because of that key piece of evidence.
Could this be a reason Alex said in the first police interview that he messed with his sons cell phone when he found him dead? Mabey was gonna delete the video but didn't know the password
I don’t think he knew Paul was recording. I think he wanted to see if Rogan had texted Paul or tried to call Paul. That’s why he kept calling Rogan, to make sure his son had not revealed that his Dad was there
C'mon. Make it make sense. This dude is at the dog kennels 4 minutes before his wife and child are shot? and he lies about it. The man would probably have gotten away with it if that snap video was never recorded.
With his obvious sociopathic personality he would have been convicted anyways. Obvious liar. It’s east to lie to others when you’re explaining to them something they know nothing about. It’s very hard to get away with a lie with body language.
@@timsmith2279 If you watch the police video cam Alex Murdock said his son‘s phone fell when he tried to roll him over and he was going to take it but decided to leave it there. A.M. must’ve had no idea that his son had videoed the scene minutes prior.
@@Seek-God-First The phone reference is a deliberate distraction, seems Buster did the actual shooting, Alex did the planning. Buster looked very nervous and shaky during his cross-examination, he should be investigated further by an outside police force, he definitely knows a lot more then he’s letting on. Surprised the prosecution were soft on him, may be there was a grubby deal to let him go as long as Alex got convicted.
Paul was under question for what he did as well. Let’s not forget about the house keeper that fell down the steps and died. Also, Stephen who was possibly plowed down by Buster.
Had this video been at 8pm there could have still been reasonable doubt, but being literally 5 minutes before both their phones were never active again makes this insurmountable to defend
Yes. You know I wonder…did AM just not realize that his son was filming or did he just not understand that a video, which I believe was a Snapchat video, could be stored? I know AM said he checked his son’s phone and then placed/laid it back on the outside of his son’s pocket, which was an odd thing to do. I would be focused on my son’s body, not his phone.
To consider that AB drove around the farm with Paul, while he waits for Maggie to arrive is evil. He was keeping Paul at the scene, making small talk with his boy; while he was planning their execution!! Such a chilling thought !!
I think he realizes he's caught. This is clearly Alex voice. It's unfortunate that $ Gets in the way, if you love your family this should never happen. Very sad
Aside from just asking people's opinion if that is Alex's voice, do they have voice analysis technology that can say for sure that it is Alex? I do not want Alex to get away with murder.
@@susanfisher4944 Let's not forget the data from his vehicle, which also demonstrates he lied about the events and his whereabouts. There was no way he check Paul and then Maggie in 10 seconds when Paul was laying about 32 feet away from his vehicle... Also, if he tried to find a pulse of Paul or Maggie, there is no way he - his hands or shoes - and/or clothing would be clean.
So are we to believe that the murderers were lurking the bushes while the snapchat was taken waiting for Alex to leave so they could gun down the rest of his family. Without Alex hearing a thing? COME ON. had it not been for the video Alex would've Never revealed his being there.
The young man was found on a lonely highway in the dark, just thrown from a vehicle like trash. He did have a secret history with a Murdaugh son.Hmm.Mur -der.
The young man maybe but not the housekeeper, all he did to her was steal her families money.... well at least try, ended up paying them a lot more in the end. He didn't kill her but he sure as heII exploited her death for money.
When Alex was saying “come here Bubba” I can’t help but to think he was probably calling him over so he wouldn’t be in the line of fire for what was about to happen. 😢
If it wasn't for the kennel video, Murdaugh would have gotten away with it. Either he would have been acquitted or it would have been a hung jury, and there never would have been a conviction. Of course he would have gone away for decades for the financial crimes, but not for murder. Cell phones can be troublesome, problematic things.
The GPS on star evidence was pretty telling too. Showed everything he did that night, how fast he was driving & that he even slowed down where he ditched Maggie’s phone. Paul’s video was the icing on the cake
Wow. I’ve been following this story with Mandy Matney. If it isn’t Alex then what kind of murderer calls someone else’s animals like that and banters with the soon to be dead Maggie? He obviously didn’t know Paul was filming. Wow.
I’m from the South and lived a few years in South Carolina and I don’t understand how all these people sound like they are in a Tennessee Williams play.
I would think that anyone planning on murdering their family would maintain a “good look” in front of friends and other family members. To do otherwise would look suspicious.
It really makes you wonder the timeline. If he's actually placed here right before the death he clearly lured them to dog the kennel... I wonder if Paul was known for running random videos on snap all the time? Or was he also suspicious of his dad too. Edit: just learning about the vid being for a friend
the video was taken because the dog was hurt and Paul told his friend who is the owner minutes before, he would make a video to show him the injury, it came up in the trial.
Amazing. AM probably did not even realize his voice was on that video until much, much later. And now, like the dog in the cage, AM will spend the rest of his life in a cage.
His cell phone did track him so it’s not much of a fight. I wonder if Paul accidentally shot his mother and then the dad snapped or if buster was in on it too. A lot of things coming to light. I don’t think he will ever admit to this.
@@MeneTekelUpharsin it means the prosecution's argument that it had to be used by the killer and that's why it wasn't wound up the same way the caretaker left it, could be wrong because you can see that it was obviously used by Paul and Maggie while they were still alive
@@cookied456 Maggie was involved in the death of their housekeeper (at the very least was callous) and Paul was involved in a drunk boating accident where he was the driver and tried pinning it on his friend.
Sad to think that these are the last moments of their lives. Not only will beloved friends and family miss Maggie and Paul, but their dogs as well. Labrador’s are so devoted to their humans. That’s why they are companion and medical assistance animals. Now NONE of the humans that THEY love will be coming out to feed, pet, walk, run, hunt, get loved on etc. I hope that they are being cared for by other people that they love and trust. Perhaps even the gentleman who’d come up twice per day to feed/water them. I know that I would take them in a heartbeat. I’ve had labradors, no less than 2 at a time for just over 40 years. Murderers rarely think of the pets left behind.
Paul isn’t saying “ catch” he’s saying, “Cash.” Which is the name of his friend’s dog for whom he was making the recording to show his friend Cash’s tail that there was some concern over. Their 2 Labrador’s Bubba ( Yellow lab) and Grady.( Black Lab) were there in the Kennel, perhaps viewing the whole tragic murder. Poor dogs. :-(
@@OOceaneyess bubba definitely saw the shooting.....theres police video of the crime scene and in one part you can see bubba and he's lying on his side in the kennel and he looks so sad (traumatised ).
A BIG OVERLOOKED FACT: AM did not put Bubba in a cage after he took away the chicken, so if Maggie and Paul were murdered within minutes, Bubba should be free around the corpses when AM arrived on the scene. The alleged murderers would not bother to leash Bubba after a double murder.... and also, the dogs barked with an alarming, angry voice during the 911 call (recognizing AM not as their owner but as someone who hurt Maggie and Paul).
The deep voiced male says what sounds to me like "tie him up" it was strategically done so dogs were put up first. I would disregard anything Alex Says on the stand honestly ...
So why wouldn't Maggie or Alex put Bubba in before the murders? It takes seconds to do this. There were other dogs there and would bark when Alex returned to the scene of his crime. BTW, why lie about being there just moments before his family was killed?
You can delete most info off of your phone but there is still a record with the phone company. The prosecution demonstrated this and presented the recovered phone logs.
And someone is using the hose. It's wet everywhere, you hear the sound, or was it raining strongly at that time??? Alex said it was hot .... And nobody was using the hose when he was there on his golf cart with a hight oh approximately 5'4 .........
I would not be surprised if Buster, the other son, was in on this too. I definitely think theres more to this. Maybe Alex did do it... maybe he didnt...? Maybe he knew or seen. But maybe hes taking the fall for his son also? Only God knows. And may God rest their souls.
Where’s the rest of the video like what I saw last night? It has Paul crouched down behind Cash, looking up scared.This was one I saw online last night
He had a motive to kill his wife but why the son?! I just watched the Netflix documentary, everyone was saying bad things about them, except for Anthony Cook who presented another side of Paul Murdaugh. Anthony was a real friend and he seemed to be affected by everything that happened. This is a tragedy …
Yup!!!! Why is he not being interrogated but instead protected and I'm really interested in knowing if that was Eddie? They are saying Free Eddie but I'm saying wait a dang minute here ..... Are we sure cause supposedly Alex and Buster were not there as well we know because of this video that they were there. So the whole Eddie having an alibi I'd like to see proof.
Who would have thought that Paul would end up solving his own murder. What a heartbreaking video taken just moments before 2 people's life ended in a brutal manner.
Still doesn't forgive him for killing that young girl on the boat....
I mean this what sealed it. Saying you weren’t there and then only admitting you were once a video is released showing you were there is too damning to overcome
This is confusing. Does the video actually show him there? Or just his voice on the video?
Yes, he admitted at trial that he was there. But I want to know if the video shows his face.
Video doesn't have to show him...He admitted he was there...
@@sarahnewcomb738 I know he admitted being at the kennels at the trial. I said that in my post.
I am curious if the video shows him. Or his shadow. How close was he from being captured on video. Would be interesting to know where he was standing in relation to Paul and Maggie. And it is also strange that he would not notice Paul filming the dogs.
@@Better_Call_Raul his voice is heard. Due to how the laws of physics work, he has to be within earshot. Cellphone camera microphones are not that sensitive, therefore even if his voice comes up as “quiet” on the recording, he still had to have been loud enough i.e. close enough to have the camera pick up his voice. He was likely within 30-50 ft of the Kennels by my guessing.
@@Better_Call_Raul if he was minutes away from taking their lives, I think it's safe to presume he was more focused on his cover up and not really what the mom and son were doing... Only what he needed to do to pull off his crime. Also, the phone was pointed down, not exactly up and on display. Phones are our 11th appendage these days. I'm sure you and myself are in many videos and we never saw the phone either. It's just sad.
Paul solved his own murder.
It's impossible to solve your own murder and realise it
😆
@@drewhyland9574 so true
@@drewhyland9574 Mr.Literal over here
"The Little Detective's" last case.
What is amazing is that the dog caught and brought them the chicken. If he was just standing there, Alex would have probably not said anything in that short video. It's like nature made sure that such an evil man's plan to get away with it failed.
Yes God had a hand in that. There was no way he’d ever get away with it. Our phones track us, they knew his steps from the phone he had too!! For someone supposedly so smart, he was stupid!
@@Corgi4pack Narcissists/sociopaths/psychopaths have no self-awareness.....they all think they are the smartest person around and have gotten away with no consequences for YEARS.....they are so proud it's easy for them to think they are smarter than cops/human behavior is so predictable. Alex is right where he belongs......no empathy, controlling, selfish, scheming....attributes of a Narcissist......and when they progress down the scale....they become dangerous....Jesus said "Satan was a Liar, Thief, Murderer from the very beginning.......Alex's progress: Liar, Thief, and Murderer......more to be revealed in the future......I think he was a gambler and possibly into trafficking women also.
Ran a-fowl.
talking about the kennel video i really think i hear someone utter Buster at the 22-23 seconds mark
@@curtisenglish1520 i wonder if Law enforcement established where Buster was that night?
This is so creepy, is almost unbelievable that someone who seemed to be in good standing with his son will go and just killed him, just like that, without remorse.
That was his son. But then again, I remember Christopher Watts and all the other cases and it happens.
Chris Watts family pictures were featured constantly as if no one would suspect such loving husband be a cheater and murder.
Think that's why these cases become so well known, it's so hard to imagine such a seemingly loving father could do that.
Paul kept finding his pill stash and telling Maggie. The boat death didn’t help either. The wrongful death lawsuit is what cracked open his finance books and exposed the theft
@@ericajenkins2416but why leave the other son I think he saw him self in that son….i can’t wrap my head around it
@@Paintmerosered I think he didn’t kill Buster because he liked him more OR because he knew he could handle himself during and after the impending implosion of their life OR because he simply wasn’t there at the time.
Alex, in the car during questioning, is focusing on keeping his story straight. He isn't displaying shock, grief, disbelief or any emotions that normal people would show upon discovering his wife and son shot dead. His voice is steady, his eyes move about like he is keeping track of his rehearsed story. I've never seen such a lack of emotion in a person, given the absolute MESS he is in. He had just blown the brains out of his own son and his wife, yet is lacking feeling.
He's guilty
he is a cold blooded killer. He is a drug addict, a money swindler, a schemer for insurance money, he killed his long time house help and defrauded the insurance company of her money..... that man has no morals and no conscience. he probably killed wife and son for insurance money too.
Ikr I h8 that guy.
Pretty sure he killed them buf, where were the two weapons he was holding? Surely, the son would’ve said something seeing him with two guns in his hand just before he shoots him.
And how would he not see Paul was recording if he shot him up close?
That's called trauma reaction.
That's the most damning evidence right there, proves he was there when they are murdered either by him or saw who did it
exactly within minutes after that video they were dead. So what happened during those few minutes God knows.
@@wk8000 yep that is what it sounds like. Poor Paul and Maggie ..... what this monster did to them.
@@brettcantrell8650 I think he said "come here Bubba" because it had a chicken in its mouth.
Yes, and we now know that that's exactly what the jury thought as well since his sentencing.
That's definitely the dad's voice
Yup
Paul pointed the finger of guilty from his grave at his evil, monstrous father.
If that isn’t poetic justice, I don’t know what is.
Sociopaths who also happen to be psychopaths are among us. Don't know how he can deceive his family like that, laughing, playing with dogs, and then just killing them. And then taking off to get rid of the guns, probably in some unknown body of water. It leaves a cold feeling in your heart.
People are crazy! Most evil things on this planet…
My ex was/is a psychopath, in my opinion. I know how they do it, because I watched him. He practices deception. I mean, he literally practices lying to people, then scrutinizes their faces to see if they believe him. Deception and manipulation are skills they develop, like a musician practicing scales.
At the time, I thought he was just annoying. I did not understand the seriousness of what I was seeing. That's the danger of psychopaths -- we don't know what they are, therefore, we can be deceived. By the time we figure it out, if we ever do, it's too late.
Also, people are things to them. Accessories. Props that they use, like actors, to play a role. To play the role of a family man, you need a family. Do they mean anything to you? No. Just supply or fuel, as to a narcissist; or tools to paint an image of themselves...so they can get close enough to deceive more people.
By all accounts, his son Paul was also supposed to be a sociopath... the whole family has left behind a trail of bodies
Lies again? Bus Driver Black Dog
THANKS FOR THIS VIDEO. SO SAD HIS OWN SON AND WIFE COULDN'T SENSE HE WAS SO DANGEROUS. WELL, MAYBE MAGGIES DOG BUBBA 🐕 SENSED THINGS WERE GOING TO GET VIOLENT. SEEMED LIKE MAGGIES DOG MAY HAVE BEEN TRYING TO DISTRACT ALEX FROM BREAKING BAD ON HIS WIFE AND SON. YET, AT LEAST BUBBA WAS ABLE TO GET ALEX TO YELL AT HIM. AND GOT ALEX TALKIN' ON THE VIDEO TAPE....THANK GOD FOR THAT. ❤ DEAR LORD HELP ALL INVOLED...ESPECAILLY THE VICTIMS. GOD BLESS ❤ AND PLEASE HELP 🙏 THEM ALL LORD GOD...BRING THEM PEACE AND JUSTICE PLEASE....❤PRAYING FOR YOU GOD TO COMFORT THESE VICTIMS LOVED ONES TOO. IN CHRIST JESUS HOLY NAME AND PERFECT BLOOD SACRIFICE AMEN 🙏❤.
It would appear he thought he had it all covered...EXCEPT...it never occurred to him to think of Paul making a recording. This video just sunk reasonable doubt. This man is going to prison
This is one of those Perry Mason moments that catches the killer in a lie...lol
Yep I love these of cases. Also the Jodi Arias case where she accidently took pictures while she was killing Travis and prosecutor Martinez had a perry Mason moment with the 2 gas cans ordeal.
MAD TO THINK if this had happened just 10 years prior before the explosion in popularity of mobile video sharing, this murder could have well gone unsolved!
I thought the same thing
Or if AM got a hold of Paul's phone
@@RCsFinest
Don't you know he's kicking himself for not grabbing that phone!?!?!?
@@paxmule It's a sick way of thinking but yeah I'm sure he was pissed when that evidence was brought up 😄
Exactly. Alex was banking on “boomer lies.”
He believes he is above the law like the whole family has been for years. I don’t think he will get away with this ending the family history of cover ups
This!!! They have been covering it up for a long time & they have had the means and assets to financially cover it up. Attorneys are big on being close & having each other’s backs he even had law enforcement involved. These aren’t normal citizens we are talking about people of power. He’s used to getting a slap on the wrist but not this time.
U can tell by every single face in the room that they have got away with so much but it’s over for him this time. I wish he would step forward and just confess already, something tragic happened that day but they are good at cover ups u can tell he didn’t think this one thru he’s a personal injury attorney so he’s used to hearing tragic stuff all the time. That’s one reason he comes off cold or numb, but not enough to be believable this was his own child and wife I noticed he only cries when it comes to the thought of him being guilty for it….
Just because a family friend can't think of a reason that Alex would murder his son and wife...that doesn't mean anything. Spouses murder spouses all the time and usually their closest friends don't know of the problems. Murderers don't generally tell other people that they are going to murder their family members. And that family friend has absolutely nothing to gain by testifying. He probably feels bad, but he knows he has to. I for one have no doubt that Alex is a cold blooded murderer and he was so rich and powerful at one point that it all went to his head and he thought he was smarter than the cops. He needs to go to prison for the rest of his life. I hope his remaining son sees the lesson of all of this.
With this guy the only motive would have been MONEY.
Innocent until PROVEN GUILTY. The presumption is always innocence. The prosecution has to PROVE guilt. Unfortunately, while he's probably guilty, he's not been proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt by any means. Missing evidence, while may be evidence in itself, is not proof.
How did he murder them with both weapons?
I hope he didn’t inherit his irrepressible ego but it appears he may have.
@@crzyautochic4807 One at a time I would guess ?
I’ll take cellphone evidence for 400$ Alex
Basically
I think that might be a daily double.
That's why he handled Paul's phone - he tried deleting the video, but the phone was LOCKED!!
Even if he deleted it it would still be there unopened on Paul's friends Snapchat feed, right? And of course beyond that LE could get it back in other ways.
@@astridvvv9662 No, he tried Snapchat, but it wouldn't work, so he filmed it and intended to send it, but didn't have time.
@@astridvvv9662 people have testified that the service at the kennels was really crappy and alot of the times videos and call constantly didn't go thru
Paul was smart to put a lock on his phone & not tell his dad the PW
You almost wonder why he didn't just take the phone and dispose of it
It’s sad that the passing of a young women happened but I feel like it brought all of this to light. It’s like the ultimate justice for Mallory Beach.
Well said
RIP Mallory ❤ that’s the young lady that got killed in the boating accident right?
@@dntwachmewachtv4644 yes, and the lawsuit by her parents against the murdered son and mother was the motive for Alex to kill them.
Well Spoken
Paul And Maggie were killed most likely as REVENGE KILLINGS in association with the Boating accident. Those who fuelled the hatred that caused Paul and Maggie thier lives also have thier hands stained with thier blood! The murder scene has every fingerprint of REVENGE KILLINGS!! Those killers are still at Large!
You know he's so pissed at Paul for recording that
He probably blames most of his downfall on his wife and son. If it wasn't for them he could've kept the lies going.
He ambushed his wife and son.Sickening.
I shudder at the thought of the absolute devastation Paul and Maggie mustve felt when they processed what was happening😔 How surreal it must've been. It's enough to bring tears to my eyes. It's heartbreaking.
@timpickels7900 we are to believe some vigilante showed up to the Murdaugh property UNARMED, found 2 loaded guns and was able to gun down Maggie and Paul in the 10-15 mins time after Alex walked off, then placed the dogs in their Kennels, and wrapped up the hose for them! Look at the evidence. Alex had the means, he had the motive and and and most of all he had the oppurtunity. The vigilante theory for a boating accident is so astronomically UNLIKELY. Alex lied about being there, he asked Ms sherry to lie about how long he was at his mom's. He tried convincing someone else of what he was wearing that day, he wasn't at all concerned for his or busters safety! He tried to have himself killed and lied about that! These aren't the actions of an innocent man. They're the actions of a desperate man, losing all control and willing to sacrifice anything and anyone to save himself.
@@queenlegitimate5015 Yes, they must have been terrified and frightened. So sad.
@@ErrorMoose because. By saying he wasn't there meant that he was somewhere else. Duh
Alex hunted them. First was the disabling shot and then the kill shot. Maggie was still moving after that first shot so he continued shooting disabling shots until the kill shot. That predatory hunting style was a worse kind of cold-hearted which should have had charges of Aggravated added.
The voice on the video just prior to the murder, combined with the wife's text about Alex acting "suspicious" just prior to the murder are pretty compelling evidence. Then there's the interview in the police car, where he doesn't seem devastated by the bad news which is pretty damning.
Exactly.
Do they know 100% that’s his voice? Clearly not 100% if it was that would mean guilty lol
@@zakrios7389 it’s his voice. I can tell just from listening to his voice during the trial and listening to that video. The defense even admits- does this sound like a happy family “ so they are admitting he’s there at the crime scene
What did her text say??
@@erick6102 exactly.
Aww, the doggy was so happy to see him!! Poor thing had to witness the murders 😢😢😢
I'm so glad the dog wasn't harmed. At least we can appreciate Alex for that
@@astridvvv9662 Yea cuz killing 2 people isn't worse.
@@EastSide_LBRight. You know people love dogs more than other people. 😩 Smh
@@EastSide_LB with how people are today I'd put my love and trust in a dog over most humans anyday
yep if only the dog could talk.
Seeing Alex Murdaugh in the squad car with no tears, shock, just keeping his made up story straight is disturbing. The Snapchat video basically sealed the deal and gave him that life sentence. Maggie and Paul got their justice because of that key piece of evidence.
I think Buster was there…
Could this be a reason Alex said in the first police interview that he messed with his sons cell phone when he found him dead? Mabey was gonna delete the video but didn't know the password
Alex most likely didn’t know Paul made that video. If he had known, he would’ve probably changed his lies.
right!
@@cberry6751 correct you can see him clenching his teeth in court after seeing that video.
Wasn't it a snapchat video? Those videos are saved on servers so even if Alex could delete a copy in the phone it's still in the cloud.
I don’t think he knew Paul was recording. I think he wanted to see if Rogan had texted Paul or tried to call Paul. That’s why he kept calling Rogan, to make sure his son had not revealed that his Dad was there
C'mon. Make it make sense. This dude is at the dog kennels 4 minutes before his wife and child are shot? and he lies about it. The man would probably have gotten away with it if that snap video was never recorded.
With his obvious sociopathic personality he would have been convicted anyways. Obvious liar. It’s east to lie to others when you’re explaining to them something they know nothing about. It’s very hard to get away with a lie with body language.
Who found this video, Alex would have got away without it ?
You obviously watch 10 to life
@@timsmith2279 If you watch the police video cam Alex Murdock said his son‘s phone fell when he tried to roll him over and he was going to take it but decided to leave it there.
A.M. must’ve had no idea that his son had videoed the scene minutes prior.
@@Seek-God-First The phone reference is a deliberate distraction, seems Buster did the actual shooting, Alex did the planning. Buster looked very nervous and shaky during his cross-examination, he should be investigated further by an outside police force, he definitely knows a lot more then he’s letting on.
Surprised the prosecution were soft on him, may be there was a grubby deal to let him go as long as Alex got convicted.
He definitely did it…his story was all bs to go along w/his crocodile tears during questioning. Guilty!
The "little detective" speaking from the grave, "You'll never get away with it dad, never..." RIP Paul & Maggie.... rot in jail Alec Murdaugh!
Paul was under question for what he did as well. Let’s not forget about the house keeper that fell down the steps and died. Also, Stephen who was possibly plowed down by Buster.
Had this video been at 8pm there could have still been reasonable doubt, but being literally 5 minutes before both their phones were never active again makes this insurmountable to defend
Yes. You know I wonder…did AM just not realize that his son was filming or did he just not understand that a video, which I believe was a Snapchat video, could be stored? I know AM said he checked his son’s phone and then placed/laid it back on the outside of his son’s pocket, which was an odd thing to do. I would be focused on my son’s body, not his phone.
To consider that AB drove around the farm with Paul, while he waits for Maggie to arrive is evil. He was keeping Paul at the scene, making small talk with his boy; while he was planning their execution!! Such a chilling thought !!
The Bible says ...the LOVE of money is the ROOT of all evil.
@susan ..... Amen 🙏 !!!!!
I think he realizes he's caught. This is clearly Alex voice. It's unfortunate that $
Gets in the way, if you love your family this should never happen. Very sad
Aside from just asking people's opinion if that is Alex's voice, do they have voice analysis technology that can say for sure that it is Alex? I do not want Alex to get away with murder.
@@susanfisher4944 Let's not forget the data from his vehicle, which also demonstrates he lied about the events and his whereabouts. There was no way he check Paul and then Maggie in 10 seconds when Paul was laying about 32 feet away from his vehicle... Also, if he tried to find a pulse of Paul or Maggie, there is no way he - his hands or shoes - and/or clothing would be clean.
He didn't know his son was making that video
How fortunate his friend insisted on the video!
probably because he never paid much attention to that son of his
yep he probably killed him to stop him from making that video right?
So are we to believe that the murderers were lurking the bushes while the snapchat was taken waiting for Alex to leave so they could gun down the rest of his family. Without Alex hearing a thing? COME ON. had it not been for the video Alex would've Never revealed his being there.
He also killed his housekeeper and his sons romantic boyfriend
No he absolutely did not you imbecile….. some of you people are unbelievable..
@@TeeTV22 You don't know he absolutely did not just like Daniel doesn't know he did, so you both are unbelievable. Time will tell...
The young man was found on a lonely highway in the dark, just thrown from a vehicle like trash. He did have a secret history with a Murdaugh son.Hmm.Mur -der.
"Romantic boyfriend"
The young man maybe but not the housekeeper, all he did to her was steal her families money.... well at least try, ended up paying them a lot more in the end. He didn't kill her but he sure as heII exploited her death for money.
When Alex was saying “come here Bubba” I can’t help but to think he was probably calling him over so he wouldn’t be in the line of fire for what was about to happen. 😢
Bubba is one of there dogs name
So true
yep or maybe he did not want the dog to protect the mother and son.
Bubba had a bird in his mouth, in this moment he was trying to get it out
Bubba had a chicken in its mouth. But I'm sure the blasting started happening right after that
This case has just rocked my world! I can not fathom why he would do this to his baby 😔 and wife
Alex is clearly guilty and deserves to rot in prison but his wife and son were evil mfers too
If it wasn't for the kennel video, Murdaugh would have gotten away with it. Either he would have been acquitted or it would have been a hung jury, and there never would have been a conviction. Of course he would have gone away for decades for the financial crimes, but not for murder. Cell phones can be troublesome, problematic things.
The GPS on star evidence was pretty telling too. Showed everything he did that night, how fast he was driving & that he even slowed down where he ditched Maggie’s phone. Paul’s video was the icing on the cake
@@MZHARDBODYENT The convenience of technology comes at a price.......even for those of us who aren't murderers. ☹
@2:12 WHOA - Look at that sudden stare of complete attention from Alex! (He even stopped chewing!)
Wow. I’ve been following this story with Mandy Matney. If it isn’t Alex then what kind of murderer calls someone else’s animals like that and banters with the soon to be dead Maggie? He obviously didn’t know Paul was filming. Wow.
Im so glad Paul made this video. That boy suffered a lot because of his parents 😢 RIP
He wasn’t innocent he did kill the girl on the boat accident
@@CrunchyMom70 She got thrown from the boat when the boat crashed. Paul & Connor were both drunk & at the wheel
He crave his parents love and his parents love his brother more..that why he's a drinker...Alex is a drug addict
@@azura9034I don't understand how anyone cannot love a doll like Paul.
He didn't seem to be upset while sitting in the cop truck interviewing minutes after finding his wife and son
What a sad life all those dogs had/have. Locked in concrete pens all alone.
All that land ,, they could fence in and let them run. And they throw them in a 3 x 5 cage. Payback now Alex in a 5 x 7. Karma? 👍
@@fted4734 don't worry, in his next life he's gonna be a locked up animal.
I’m from the South and lived a few years in South Carolina and I don’t understand how all these people sound like they are in a Tennessee Williams play.
What part? Because they sound like everyone I’ve ever interacted with around here.
@@snausages43 Columbia. Most of the people I interacted with were transplants so that might explain it.
People from the Lowcountry speak differently from Columbia folks. It's the Charleston "geechie" influence.
Only the dogs knows the truth😢
Man if only dogs could talk…
If the dog could only talk!!
yep I said the same thing.
Woof woof
DONT worry he have taken dog out also if that were the case..
Poor dog
Paul left his dad a nice little gift for killing him.
I would think that anyone planning on murdering their family would maintain a “good look” in front of friends and other family members. To do otherwise would look suspicious.
Evidence from their graves.
May they now rest in peace 🙏
You can hear in the long range video on 0.14 Alex asked Paul "what's the matter Paul?" Paul said "it's alright dad"
Where can l find this
It really makes you wonder the timeline.
If he's actually placed here right before the death he clearly lured them to dog the kennel... I wonder if Paul was known for running random videos on snap all the time? Or was he also suspicious of his dad too.
Edit: just learning about the vid being for a friend
yep, he might have had that bad gut feeling and took the video.
the video was taken because the dog was hurt and Paul told his friend who is the owner minutes before, he would make a video to show him the injury, it came up in the trial.
@@ailidh-Bcn but he never got the video. He uploaded it to Snapchat. I wonder how they retrieved it since Snapchat deletes after 24hours
Is she saying EDDIE, he’s got a bird in his mouth?
She said heyyy
Yes
Eddie
Amazing. AM probably did not even realize his voice was on that video until much, much later. And now, like the dog in the cage, AM will spend the rest of his life in a cage.
He is Guilty
The only thing defense has to hold on here is to dispute time of death.
Also seems like his hands were clean & there were no murder weapon retrieved or his clothing from that night. They have that to fight as well.
His cell phone did track him so it’s not much of a fight. I wonder if Paul accidentally shot his mother and then the dad snapped or if buster was in on it too. A lot of things coming to light. I don’t think he will ever admit to this.
I thought experts were able to retrieve deleted calls and messages. Hmmm...
This is awesome Paul getting justice from the grave for his mother and himself
you sir ... are busted.
Anybody else notice that the hose is on the ground in the kennel video?
What does that mean?
@@MeneTekelUpharsin it means the prosecution's argument that it had to be used by the killer and that's why it wasn't wound up the same way the caretaker left it, could be wrong because you can see that it was obviously used by Paul and Maggie while they were still alive
Alex the killer is using it in the background
Oh c’mon defense attorney…Chris Watts was loving in all his videos too!! 🙄 what’s your point?! 🙄
Paul’s feet didn’t look swollen in this video 🤔
Maggie killed Gloria. Paul killed Mallory.
Paul and Maggie speaking from the grave and seeking justice.
yep we should make sure they get justice and this monster is behind bars or death sentence. We want him off the streets for sure.
@CookieD456 yup just 2 dead proven scumbag murderers seeking justice...it's called karma, none of them deserve to take another breath
Both Paul and Maggie are horrible people. Justice has been served all around.
I have seen the documentary, I hear what you're saying, BUT they did not deserve to be murdered.
@@cookied456 Maggie was involved in the death of their housekeeper (at the very least was callous) and Paul was involved in a drunk boating accident where he was the driver and tried pinning it on his friend.
Alex's eyes are GUILTY. They should pin the murders to him just by the look on his eyes. Guilty, dark, with a lack of emotion.
No , no Alex wasn't not there , he thought his voice 😂
Sad to think that these are the last moments of their lives. Not only will beloved friends and family miss Maggie and Paul, but their dogs as well. Labrador’s are so devoted to their humans. That’s why they are companion and medical assistance animals. Now NONE of the humans that THEY love will be coming out to feed, pet, walk, run, hunt, get loved on etc. I hope that they are being cared for by other people that they love and trust. Perhaps even the gentleman who’d come up twice per day to feed/water them. I know that I would take them in a heartbeat. I’ve had labradors, no less than 2 at a time for just over 40 years. Murderers rarely think of the pets left behind.
Paul isn’t saying “ catch” he’s saying, “Cash.” Which is the name of his friend’s dog for whom he was making the recording to show his friend Cash’s tail that there was some concern over. Their 2 Labrador’s Bubba ( Yellow lab) and Grady.( Black Lab) were there in the Kennel, perhaps viewing the whole tragic murder. Poor dogs. :-(
I love your comment about the dogs...so true!
@@OOceaneyess bubba definitely saw the shooting.....theres police video of the crime scene and in one part you can see bubba and he's lying on his side in the kennel and he looks so sad (traumatised ).
@@josienic361 yes. I saw that after I watched it again. So sad. :-(
@@tamarakorb Thank you.
Holding your dogs like this is a crime in and of itself
A BIG OVERLOOKED FACT: AM did not put Bubba in a cage after he took away the chicken, so if Maggie and Paul were murdered within minutes, Bubba should be free around the corpses when AM arrived on the scene. The alleged murderers would not bother to leash Bubba after a double murder.... and also, the dogs barked with an alarming, angry voice during the 911 call (recognizing AM not as their owner but as someone who hurt Maggie and Paul).
The deep voiced male says what sounds to me like "tie him up" it was strategically done so dogs were put up first. I would disregard anything Alex Says on the stand honestly ...
So why wouldn't Maggie or Alex put Bubba in before the murders? It takes seconds to do this. There were other dogs there and would bark when Alex returned to the scene of his crime. BTW, why lie about being there just moments before his family was killed?
How do you delete your call logs? I thought the cell phone companies have that in their servers
You can delete most info off of your phone but there is still a record with the phone company. The prosecution demonstrated this and presented the recovered phone logs.
Do we know when he was first made aware of this video? Is there video of that? Would love to see the look on his face
Yes!!!!! I would love to see that also!!!!
Did Snap Chat stock go up after this video surfaced?
Every DOG has his day....
His son somehow left an evidence to lock his wicked father…..
that in itself seems like evidence enough to me.
Thank God that Paul was recording AND that Alex lied about being there...
You can clearly here his father at 14 seconds asking Paul a question!
This is so chilling.
You can hear Paul say sorry dad!!
When?
Time stamp please?
Clickbait!!! He got you guys!
Yes!
Omg you can here 3 different voices
This wasn’t a snap chat video, this was the one on his cell phone
Snapchat videos are saved in your snapchat memory log or in your album on phone
one snap chat solved a murder.......
Well he said he wasn't there..but he was
Crabby kennel( to have so much money). Would not put my dog in it😳
Is it a Snapchat video or a video sent to his friend that is on the stand here?
And someone is using the hose. It's wet everywhere, you hear the sound, or was it raining strongly at that time??? Alex said it was hot .... And nobody was using the hose when he was there on his golf cart with a hight oh approximately 5'4 .........
I would not be surprised if Buster, the other son, was in on this too. I definitely think theres more to this. Maybe Alex did do it... maybe he didnt...? Maybe he knew or seen. But maybe hes taking the fall for his son also? Only God knows. And may God rest their souls.
Thank God for Bubba and that chicken!!!
Underuts?
That sounded like Alex voice to me.
Where’s the rest of the video like what I saw last night? It has Paul crouched down behind Cash, looking up scared.This was one I saw online last night
He had a motive to kill his wife but why the son?! I just watched the Netflix documentary, everyone was saying bad things about them, except for Anthony Cook who presented another side of Paul Murdaugh. Anthony was a real friend and he seemed to be affected by everything that happened. This is a tragedy …
Anthony seems like a really good solid guy
Hey, Alec, how's Bubba treatment?Open the big house wapa wapa wapa😅
Proofread before posting, ABC7 Chicago. What is "underuts" ?????
I hear 3 men’s voices and one female. I believe Buster was there. He’s the one with the lower tone and says, “hey and Buster”
Yup!!!! Why is he not being interrogated but instead protected and I'm really interested in knowing if that was Eddie? They are saying Free Eddie but I'm saying wait a dang minute here ..... Are we sure cause supposedly Alex and Buster were not there as well we know because of this video that they were there. So the whole Eddie having an alibi I'd like to see proof.
why was it even recorded?
The time lines are off
When you delete something its sus, 100% sus
I don't get it. What happened between the video and when they were shot? They sounded normal here.
Bubba got a chicken and Alex. If he didn't get the chicken we never would have known he was there. Good boy, Bubba. Blanca has a treat for you.