this is live. i was there and she asked the audience what song you want me to sing ....and we said this one and she said this wasn't in her set but she will grant us our wish...i love you Mariah!
One of her most underrated songs in my opinion. I don´t care if she lip-synced the song as it´s a hard song to sing live, as most of her songs are. So if she lip-syncs some of her songs that´s fine with me. She has proved herself as one of the best female singers in the industry a long time ago.
I was there.. and this song was not on the bill... but she asked us what song would she like us the fans for her to sing.. and we said this One! I love her!
Mariah is sooo funny ...one of the few who i like to listen to when she speaks,other than when she sings,cause she's got that ironic way to tell stories which alwasy makes me laugh...good hearted person she must be....and this song is a masterpiece!!
actually it is live she just sang the whole thing in falsetto because in the real song she changes from her head voice to her chest voice she stays in her head voice in this performance I love her!!!!!!
I don't care if she lipped 1 or two, or even all of her songs. The show I saw in Phoenix was amazing, and it will remain one of my favorite. Whatever she did, she made me a fan that night.
at 3:41 she got out of breath.. why would she fake be out of breath.. I'm pretty sure its not that serious that she would do all that in the studio just make a bunch of haters think its real.. she could care less what you say because at the end of the day she's still making hits..
HOLY CRAP YOU PEOPLE!! This is NOT lipped! Just listen to the whistle and compare it to the one on Today. the one on today is a lot weaker. this one is different and plus at some parts she sounded kind of strained. She's an amazing singer no matter what! Mimi fan 4ever
@mikeyb110 I agree with you 100% i was at the show in dc and ppl tryed tosay the same thing, if u wasnt there u have no clue, yes these videos make u feel like u where there and the quailty is good. but being there is sooooo different then any video u will ever see. and i was up close she sangggg every song and sound amazing. you better work MCC
that was totally live if you go back to the record you will see that some of the notes particularly the high ones were hit differently from the record. she's beautiful and she rocks
@thats0hboy It's just the way Mariah does things these days. On tour, especially with her voice, you need to conserve it. she lips bits and pieces here and there. Most of the whistle notes, and certain lines of songs alternate from being sung to lipped. With her vocal chords and nodules, her voice changes every day. She might be able to handle a note one-day, but on another day, it might be hard. It's just used as a safety net.
ii was actually at this concert in oakland...........wasnt lipped.....even if it was...WHO CARES!!!!!!! LOVE MARIAH :) ii was just happy she actually did this song cuz it wasnt on the set list....
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
I think its horrible that we always have to debate with Mariah's new performances whether they are lipped or live. Search up a video from 1990 and see if you have the same doubts. SMH.
@JamieCleaton1 wow.. well even if she did lip it.. Everyone does it.. Beyonce even did it! Maybe she was sick or voice giving out that day. I think that she can still do live performances.. I've seen some that are really good
F. Simms the best thing about night sleep tonight at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs nah cards are a great many people who were not going to be talking about night sleep well and I think the best way home from work at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs nah cards are a great many things in order to do is not going anywhere else best thing about night sleep tonight at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs to do is to be expected from work at all times when you
@tomlow123 Just so you know. Singing in a concert after you have warmed up alot, been singing for a while and fans are screaming your name is NOT the same as just going to a tv studio and sing maybe at a time when you feel tired, not properly warmd up and nervous because of the cameras.
@MCdahBEST yes but its not different to the prerecorded version she uses in almost every live performance of this song....its still lipped, just not from the recorded version, well that part is anyway...
sounds live to me, I guess thats just my opinion tho, cause everyone says she lips all the time, which i dont think is true. I know she has lipped before, but is it impossible for MC to sing great live? I think not.
After 20 years I think you deeserve to be able to lip-synch. Her voice is only going to get more strained after her pregnancy. Something about the hormones do something to your voice. I think I'd be more upset if I went to a Mariah concert and she sounded bad than her lipsynching.
why is mariah Carey so often lypisinching? i cannot figure it out, she had one of the most beautiful voices on Earth...what really happened,that forces her to constantly use a base track?
MMM I didn't remember that performance... I just saw it but the video is out of sync...but yeah it sounds live... Here it's not live and yeah i agree all her performance of HATEU on her tour were lipped... unfortunetly... see you my friend
Do you really think some one can really sing every day during 4 hours (rehearsals and stuff) every day during a tour? Of course there are lipsynched parts... I dont get ppl highlighting that sh.. all the time
this is live. i was there and she asked the audience what song you want me to sing ....and we said this one and she said this wasn't in her set but she will grant us our wish...i love you Mariah!
No.
bestie who u tryna fool-
@@jacefreeney1387 💀
Lol I've seen Mariah live before....and this ain't it. I love Mariah to death, but this is all lip synced.
youre so dumb, she lipped this on every date
her whistles in this song are so beautiful omg this is like my favorite song by her
Facts!
One of her most underrated songs in my opinion. I don´t care if she lip-synced the song as it´s a hard song to sing live, as most of her songs are. So if she lip-syncs some of her songs that´s fine with me. She has proved herself as one of the best female singers in the industry a long time ago.
One of her most beautiful songs and sadly one of the most underrated ones.
Sara23RM yep, its amazing how she captures that bitter feeling
in angels advocate tour, she got her best voice again...
+95
I'm jealous Oakland got so many songs!! This was awesome of Mariah to do. She loves her fans.
I was there.. and this song was not on the bill... but she asked us what song would she like us the fans for her to sing.. and we said this One! I love her!
peepallgame I was there too!!! The lambs on the floor were screaming they wanted HATEU and she did it for us!!!
Yes I really like this. Song I play it all the time it makes felll like singing every time I hear it I just fell in love with this bless you to.
Mariah is sooo funny ...one of the few who i like to listen to when she speaks,other than when she sings,cause she's got that ironic way to tell stories which alwasy makes me laugh...good hearted person she must be....and this song is a masterpiece!!
i keep comin bcd to watch cuz of the whistle
still watching on 2023.. September ❤
Honestly this concert is one of the best without a doubt! This should be recorded in a high quality! 🥺
This is not singing. This is art. ❤
💖 yes is art.
actually it is live she just sang the whole thing in falsetto because in the real song she changes from her head voice to her chest voice she stays in her head voice in this performance I love her!!!!!!
justiceforHATEU
wow! she looks so gorgess in that dress and with that jewelry! totes fab!
Love the how the last verse goes -
I loved her whistle notes
I don't care if she lipped 1 or two, or even all of her songs. The show I saw in Phoenix was amazing, and it will remain one of my favorite. Whatever she did, she made me a fan that night.
Absolutly FLAWLESS !!! ...LYM Mimi ♥
100% live (L)!!!! I love you Mimi
Helo?
at 3:41 she got out of breath.. why would she fake be out of breath.. I'm pretty sure its not that serious that she would do all that in the studio just make a bunch of haters think its real.. she could care less what you say because at the end of the day she's still making hits..
HOLY CRAP YOU PEOPLE!! This is NOT lipped! Just listen to the whistle and compare it to the one on Today. the one on today is a lot weaker. this one is different and plus at some parts she sounded kind of strained. She's an amazing singer no matter what!
Mimi fan 4ever
Live performance! this is what it is..:) Love u MC!
Love this hair color!❤❤
i love this song... soooooo much.. thank u mariah... :))
love the ensemble
She looks amazing, + that voice 😍❤.
i love this song!a legend
i love this song!a legend in the haus
@mikeyb110 I agree with you 100% i was at the show in dc and ppl tryed tosay the same thing, if u wasnt there u have no clue, yes these videos make u feel like u where there and the quailty is good. but being there is sooooo different then any video u will ever see. and i was up close she sangggg every song and sound amazing. you better work MCC
correct is right i concur
She is not lipping this. You can hear it in the texture of her voice.
2020 cuarentena ❤️
@dannymakeithappen - She's singing to a backing track because this is a layered song. Any music professional knows this.
Wow!!!!
the backing track is layered to her voice to blend in and make harmony.
Impecável 👋👋👋
2024❤
2018
that was totally live if you go back to the record you will see that some of the notes particularly the high ones were hit differently from the record. she's beautiful and she rocks
@thats0hboy It's just the way Mariah does things these days. On tour, especially with her voice, you need to conserve it. she lips bits and pieces here and there. Most of the whistle notes, and certain lines of songs alternate from being sung to lipped. With her vocal chords and nodules, her voice changes every day. She might be able to handle a note one-day, but on another day, it might be hard.
It's just used as a safety net.
i don't care she lipped or not! i love her so much!
yeah I agree... almost the complete performance was lipped but some parts are live... 4:05 definitly sounds live
ii was actually at this concert in oakland...........wasnt lipped.....even if it was...WHO CARES!!!!!!! LOVE MARIAH :) ii was just happy she actually did this song cuz it wasnt on the set list....
Please Please Please have a duet with Celine Dion, Mariah the Queen❤❤❤
Good idea
She's the fucking best!!!
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
Queen Mariah she is fucking Glowing of Lust
she only performed this song live on letterman show... I don't know if it's live here it sounds lipped I'm confussed
@gmm369 it was live. I didn't feel cheated. are you a lamb? sit yo ass down.
@gmm369 she is
I think its horrible that we always have to debate with Mariah's new performances whether they are lipped or live. Search up a video from 1990 and see if you have the same doubts. SMH.
3:34 !
@JamieCleaton1 wow.. well even if she did lip it.. Everyone does it.. Beyonce even did it! Maybe she was sick or voice giving out that day. I think that she can still do live performances.. I've seen some that are really good
F. Simms the best thing about night sleep tonight at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs nah cards are a great many people who were not going to be talking about night sleep well and I think the best way home from work at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs nah cards are a great many things in order to do is not going anywhere else best thing about night sleep tonight at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs to do is to be expected from work at all times when you
Normally se doesn't lipped in a Tour! the true fans knows that......
@tomlow123 Just so you know. Singing in a concert after you have warmed up alot, been singing for a while and fans are screaming your name is NOT the same as just going to a tv studio and sing maybe at a time when you feel tired, not properly warmd up and nervous because of the cameras.
@dannymakeithappen how the hell can you prove it?
ABSOLUTELY NOT LIPPED. STOP IT YA'LL
She could’ve at least prerecorded the studio vocals 🙄
Exactly. 🙄
@MCdahBEST yes but its not different to the prerecorded version she uses in almost every live performance of this song....its still lipped, just not from the recorded version, well that part is anyway...
It is a little.
@irvinmaraj not all
she's not lipping. Its not that hard of a song for her to sing... helllooo!
Helo boy
Lol I see there was a live not live debate here. I think she sang to track in the chorus only. The rest was live
This is very different with Stripped and Today Show version... stop accusing start appreciating
@gmm369 Are you really a Lamb???
@dannymakeithappen ...Yes can u legitimately prove this to us tho ??
Can MC create a powerfull song again ?
Why don't you just be the mature person and don't argue back...I make certain observations too but I don't let the term "Hater" phase me =)
sounds live to me, I guess thats just my opinion tho, cause everyone says she lips all the time, which i dont think is true. I know she has lipped before, but is it impossible for MC to sing great live? I think not.
@dannymakeithappen emotions whistles are lipped
her face will tell us if she lip,
but whatever lambs dont care if she lip.
i think she lip some parts, not the whole of this.
Definitely not lipped. xD
After 20 years I think you deeserve to be able to lip-synch. Her voice is only going to get more strained after her pregnancy. Something about the hormones do something to your voice. I think I'd be more upset if I went to a Mariah concert and she sounded bad than her lipsynching.
why is mariah Carey so often lypisinching? i cannot figure it out, she had one of the most beautiful voices on Earth...what really happened,that forces her to constantly use a base track?
Because i listento her ,since her beginnings... and i notice thibgs,which make me doubt, she is actually singing live,that s it
andrea cecchi she has nodules thats why she cant sing properly sometimes so she needs to lip sync.
@jochiluis 80% of the whistles and belts were lipped lol
Yea but the truth isn't the truth if it's being exaggerated...Also you are obviously trying to piss big fans off if u put certain things in CAPS! =)
MMM I didn't remember that performance... I just saw it but the video is out of sync...but yeah it sounds live... Here it's not live and yeah i agree all her performance of HATEU on her tour were lipped... unfortunetly... see you my friend
Do you really think some one can really sing every day during 4 hours (rehearsals and stuff) every day during a tour? Of course there are lipsynched parts... I dont get ppl highlighting that sh.. all the time
Mariah is a beast on the mic; sing honey.
@tomlow123 And even there she lipped all the whistles except for one. She even got out of breath so bad that she almost missed the one in the middle.
i love this song!a legend in the hause
that is in live i love this song !!!
@2009fas check out the today show performance, the 'out of breath' part is EXACTLY the same on that performance
This isn’t fully lip synch. A lot of it is live, some are lip synched but whatever.
been in the game a long time, and to still hang with all thats come out over the years has got to take its toll on any human. she is very talented
love that she sang it live its believable ..love it ...i dont care if she ran out of breath its still live and that special.
Great falsetto from the legend
@MsEutz dont forget about us ending is lipped, and emotions whistles are lipped and this whole song is lipped :/