WATCH LIVE: Johnny Depp v Amber Heard Defamation Trial Day 20
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 май 2022
- LIVE COVERAGE: Johnny Depp v Amber Heard Defamation Trial
Actor Johnny Depp is suing ex-wife Amber Heard for $50 million for defamation in connection with Heard’s 2018 Washington Post op-ed, in which she spoke out about being the victim of domestic violence. Heard’s article did not specifically name Depp as her alleged abuser, but according to Depp’s lawsuit, it relied “on the central premise that Ms. Heard was a domestic abuse victim and that Mr. Depp perpetrated domestic violence against her.” Amber Heard is counter-suing Depp for $100 million.
The defamation trial began Monday in Fairfax County Circuit Court in Virginia, with jury selection completing on the same day. There is a possibility of celebrity witnesses testifying, including James Franco and Elon Musk. Tune in to the Law&Crime Network for daily coverage of this high-profile trial.
#JohnnyDepp #AmberHeard
Listen to Court Junkie Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3NMVnpx
Spotify: spoti.fi/3Pv7lpc
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Written Coverage & Analysis of Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial:
lawandcrime.com/?s=Johnny+Depp
lawandcrime.com/?s=Amber+Heard
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter! bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Watch Law&Crime Network NOW on RUclipsTV!
tv.ruclips.net/user/welcome?...
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH LAW&CRIME NETWORK IN YOUR AREA:
lawandcrime.com/where-to-watch/
READ MORE GREAT ARTICLES FROM LAW&CRIME NETWORK HERE:
lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK RUclips CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Channel B: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel C: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel D / @lawandcrimebodycam 
Развлечения
Imagine going to Dr. Spiegel for psychiatric help, and then realizing he needs it more than you do.
Yeah I’m glad he’s not my psychiatrist
😂
Little people like yourself love to make fun of people to make themselves feel better about their own insecurities. You poor thing.
haha and drug and alcohol treatment, definitely on something 😅
🤣🤣
It wasn't Waldman's statements that made Heard unpopular. I'd never even heard of him until last week. It was the public who 'blew it up on social media' the public hate her, that's down to HER, not Waldman. She's on audio saying she hit her husband, let's not forget that.
More than that people are capable of making their own decisions without being swayed by negative comments on social media… She has been caught out lying and being ugly and that’s why it’s happening.
Am I the only one who kinda despised her from the moment he started dating her?
Before Johnny Depp she was making movies that no one watched. She was nobody
Who is Waldman?
@@tanvirkabir4960 One should never poop in a bed PERIOD. LOL.
No one even knew who she was till she made these accusations. Let’s not pretend this woman is a talented actress 🤦🏻♀️
Who? Her lawyer is a better lawyer than she is an actor
🤣 you know it took me days to realize it was Seth Rogan’s highschool gf 🤦🏽♀️
@@Amy_Stanmore 😂
@James Bell your comment 👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
She is not a good actress on screen but a master of manipulation in her everyday life.
I love how while explaining what a narcissist is, he’s describing Amber and HER actions during the trial 😂
Good thing he testified after we saw her reactions and attitude
Dr. Spiegel is a mental patient himself and engages in sophistry to hide his own mental issues. The way Dr. Spiegel responds to questions clearly indicates problems with his cognitive ability.
My god I know! Im rewatching and the shrink just literally described her totally. Uncanny.
As an ER nurse for over 25 years that hand surgeon is clueless about mechanisms of injury. He’s not taking a lot of things into account. He is assuming the injury affected the whole fingertip. Depending on angle the hand at the time of injury and weather or not the finger was completely supported on the palmer side at the moment of contact are both variables. After more than 25 years in the ER, there isn’t much I haven’t seen. I have seen fingers slammed in a door which resulted in a clean wound that resembled a laceration with a knife to the nail bed and the nail remained intact. I’ve also seen a finger that had been hit with a sledgehammer with no visible injury to the site of the hammer impact and the opposite side completely avulsed. Hand surgeons go off nurses notes and usually don’t see the injury until it rolls into the OR!
I suppose he's just saying what he's told to say by the people paying him $1,000 an hour was it? All of them are just doing what they're told. It's disgusting.
I had a hand and finger injury that required surgery and 117 stitches. When the EMTs arrived at my house they saw the glass and my position and still found it hard to believe how my wound happened. The Dr at the ER asked more than once what "really" happened 😂 So this fool acting like he could say for sure it didnt happen the way Johnny was saying is asinine.
FYI I was watering plants with a cut glass pitcher and tripped over the cat and fell on the pitcher. 😂 severed veins, arteries and tendons in my wrist and the palm of my hand and almost cut off my pinky finger with lasting nerve damage.
An accurate account. ER nurses see it all. I have a relative who accidentally sawed off two of his fingers while building a house. He knew enough to tell his partner to get the fingers and some ice before they drove to the ER. An excellent surgeon attached both fingers. One didn't take, but the index one did. That was 50 years ago, and he just retired from his job as a doctor. He saved his finger and the career he was studying to have.
Yeah the surgeon was just working off of a preordained narrative and tried to build a case around that narrative, hyper fixating on factors that literally are not static.
More preoccupied with how glass didnt stick in the wound rather than the fact people arent static objects that dont move and bottles only ever impact a finger directly head on
Thak you for clearing that up. To bad you aren't up there.
Dr Spiegel absolutely loves the sound of his own voice. Listening to him was absolute torture, that poor jury
yeah sure, you would say about anything at this point , you and yours. You hivemind rat ! he sounds like george c scott and thats pretty cool, he is the kind of professor the people admire what are you?
Someone should’ve told him his hair was messed up… I bet he was mortified when he looked in the mirror after being on the stand all cocky all that time 🤣🤣.
SO!!
It was SO distracting that he kept peppering his language with SO SO SO.
Such an ego on that guy.
He was such an obnoxious, arrogant human being. I pity his poor wife if he's been able to keep one.
The fact that Mr. Depp is willing to subject himself to this public display of his most intimate moments and the financial magnitude this trial will cost, tells me how important it is to him that the world know without a doubt, he is not an abuser of women. He may be a man with a substance addiction and a very sad childhood, but his morals will be shown intact after this!!!
He showed what an actual narcissist he really is. By filing this lawsuit. Disgusting.
That's exactly why he filed so you would think that. An entitled narcissist thinks like that however, it's much more then he wanted to see of himself ..he hurt her and himself. He doesn't fool me
@@sunsdup You have the estrogen blinders on. He's not your ex husband or a boyfriend that did you wrong. You're willing to disregard every clear piece of evidence that proves Amber is abusive because you hate men.
“Johnny Depp” and “morality” should not be used in the same sentence.
@@sunsdup she hurt him more than he ever hurt her. Amber heard is a liar
That witness at 2:03:14 whispers that he's gonna lie and if there's something he shouldn't lie about, WTF, HOW IS THIS NOT BLOWING UP?????????
Yo what!!!!
That’s what I’m sayin. I heard it too. 🤦🏽♀️
yeah this should be a much bigger deal
Omg you are right it's sounds like he's asking her if there something he's gotta lie about
I went back to rewatch and he sure does. It's hard to hear unless you know it's there
I’ve Never Seen A Psychiatrist Lose His Temper & Get Childish, Leave It To Amber & Her Team To Find One!! Quack For A Quack!!
Exactly!!!
He was a joke all day. Someone commented to me that he has a neurological disorder. I wrote back so what he is still an angry person and needs to control himself.
He's definitely what I understand a quack to mean ..😂😂
Always is academic people’s fault right?🙄.
THIS!! 💯
Every single one of Ambers witnesses have just embarrassed themselves. This woman claims she’s an expert but didn’t know half the things he was talking about when cross examining.
She didn't even know Patrick Wilson ... the horror movie legend of this generation and the main Antagonist in Aquaman 1.
@@bobk2649 I was just about to write the exact point lol 😂 she didn’t know Patrick Wilson 😂
I hope the jury sees right through it 😅
Only lawyer in the whole world that can get AH out of this mess either by hook or by crook is Saul Goodman.
@@rakibulislam1112 I love this comment😂
As a primary care and psychiatric NP, I am appalled by this psychiatrist's testimony. There is obvious bias. He is basing his assumptions and evaluations on hearsay. He is difficult on the stand, defensive, and uncooperative. Much of his testimony appears unethical and unprofessional. He could learn a lot from previous expert witness testimony from earlier psychologists. It seems that he is testifying to purely meet the defense's narrative.
I was about to say the same thing.
💯 correct!
You can literally hear him around 2 hours 3 minutes asking if he’s allowed to lie about it 😂😂😂
2:03:15 "I will lie in my testimony"
Well of course there's bias when the "expert" witnesses are being paid 5 THOUSAND dollars a day to testify, or a THOUSAND dollars an HOUR to give depositions. Money talk, I guess.
Have you ever seen Johnny Depp in interviews as a man in his 20's, 30's and 40's? He is exactly the same as he is now. He demonstrates the same manner and speed at which he processes and delivers his ideas, anecdotes, humor and conversation.
100% he's soft and humble, he thinks before speaking I envy and admire him for that it's truly rare and special. Does not make him delayed makes him smarter in my opinion because I always wish I would shutup and think before I speak....
Exactly xx
Denial doesn't help, drugs, alcohol has fried his brain!
@@gailcerreta7807 is that appropriate to say? My partner has slow processing at times when talking and might stutter. Who are you to judge and presume it's from drugs.
It's ridiculous how they are letting these Doctors testify to things in the case as if they are facts.
They are expert opinions
@@zachbraxton1997 Exactly, "opinions." Not facts as they pertain to the case.
It's the psychiatrist for me. He literally just gave a diagnosis, and didn't quite get that he literally did.
@@m.c.3640 and it’s very clear that Johnny depp does not have npd. His “traits” are far more consistent with ADD.
And they are quite literally paid off for their opinions. Several hundred/thousand per hour.
This psychiatrist straddles a fine line between being scary and being funny.
And to think...he's teaching others! Ms Heard wasted her money on these so called experts.
he's a cross between Trevor from GTA V and Jim Carrey as Mr. Scrooge in Christmas Carrol.
But at the same time far from professional or credible 💩
He seriously gave me vibes of Jordan Peterson from Wish lmao.
He looks like Jack Nicholason would have done if he survived cuckoos nest all these years😆
Ben Chew has such great energy. Upbeat & a pal to Johnny throughout. He's a rock!
Judge arrives just after 1:08:50
Testimony begins
1:11:11 Dr Richard Moore - Expert Witness (Orthopaedic Surgeon)
2:04:03 Dr Spiegel - Expert Witness (Psychiatrist Physician)
3:09:54 End of morning break
Continuing with Dr Spiegel
6:03:53 End of lunch break
Continuing with Dr Spiegel
6:33:11 Katherine Arnold - Expert Witness
8:09:38 End of afternoon break
Continuing with Katherine Arnold
Did anyone else hear Dr Spiegal say to Elane who apparently is having mic issues, "I'm gonna lie in my testimony. Is there anything I shouldn't lie about?" And Elane responds "no". It’s at around 2:03:16
@@hannah6339 yes I heard him say “is there anything I shouldn’t talk about?”
Thank you!
@@meba444 you're welcome!
2:03:15 "I will lie in my testimony"
Didn’t this woman say that she can’t judge how much Johnny lost because Pirates 6 didn’t come out yet she’s guessing how much Amber lost when none of those endorsements or movies happened either??
Im surprised I didn't see this comment higher. I was thinking the exact same thing. Claims pirates 6 isn't out so you can't use it as an example. Says Amber lost money on aquaman 3 despite not being out also. Then when the lawyer mentioned aquaman 3 again she said something like "Aquaman 2 isn't even out yet". Pick a lane woman. Either say she lost money on aquaman 3 and in direct correlation so did johnny on pirates 6, or just don't use aquaman 3 as an example.
I mean I get it. She's there on behalf of Amber so she's going to try to stand up for her. Just feels like she has little consistency with her points.
Amber's lot don't know how to play fair.
Just so you understand it, JD was not contracted for pirates 6 so that point is moot.
AH is contracted for AM3 at $4m however what the witness is saying is that she has “lost” the potential to renegotiate that to a higher rate because of the negative press apparently as a result of the Waldman statement.
However this is in contradiction to the Warner Bros head of DC Universe who was deposed as saying that the actors were just being paid as per the contract. Therefore any potential to renegotiate is just speculation. Which council pointed out.
Council also did a great job so sewing the seed of doubt for AH’s actual ability to land a big role (other than the AM franchise which she already had) by bringing up that for 15 odd months following the release of AM1 she failed to land much else in a significant role until finally the timeline of the Waldman statement when it “apparently” then declined further.
AH’s case for the counter IS the Waldman statement. If they can’t prove that statement directly caused; not correlates, to her losing roles, then she has no case.
@@at802 Thank you for the further explanation. I completely understand.
My comment was about the comparison between her alleged “losses” as they relate to further endorsements like the “water, makeup, beauty, health, etc.” and the future roles in other films.
The witness claims she lost those opportunities (that could have potentially grown her career similar to the other actors and actresses).
With her reasoning, she cannot claim Johnny’s losses because Pirates had not happened yet. So, how can she claim those losses if they hadn’t happened yet for Amber?
Her argument is not sound all around. If she wanted to make a sound argument, she would have argued that Johnny lost the opportunity to be in Pirates 6 which could have made ___ amount of money compared to the previous box office sales. However, Miss Heard suffered a much greater loss due to x,y,z.
👍
Lets not forget how lucky we are to be able to skip parts of this video or even to click off. The poor jury had to sit through this whole thing and listen to his crazy babbling. I hope they get therapy after this cause I know I’d need it.
I've been watching all of this at the 1.5 speed. You can see they are all paid by the hour, because I've never heard any American speak so sloooooowly. When sped up it's more dynamic and you don't waste precious time.
@@juiceyblend what do you mean by "DC", please? (Sorry, I'm French :) )
@@juiceyblend thank you 🤗
@@helenebouyerbregeon3171 District of Columbia is DC, as in Washington DC, our country's capitol.
You are so right I click off then later listen to Emily for the low down. Lol
Who ever said to listen in 1.5 speed! You're a genius!
I've listened to so much at 1.5x normal speed sounds bizarre now😂
Im at 1.75 lol
The "expert witness" for damage on both their careers claims she's been a witness in many cases, yet gets an objection come up for hearsay, she then fumbles and says, "I'm sorry, I'm just trying to understand this world." Shouldn't you already know you can't testify to what other people have said if you've done this multiple other times?
Nervousness & trying not to lose train of thought I would assume.
I’ve heard that this particular judge is extraordinarily strict with hearsay to the point other judges have criticized her. Not taking sides at all but just wondered if some of these expert witnesses weren’t used to these constraints while testifying
Exactly! (To original comment, not replies)
I think she needs glasses, Jason Moamoa and Satan's daughter didn't have chemistry. She can't act, why would they pay for more? She is difficult to work with the industry has stated that.
@@elvirafeher4254 They had zero chemistry, I agree with you. That movie would have been a hit no matter who played the female lead.
I think dr Doofenshmirtz is really a patient and decided to pose as a doctor for the day to shake things up. Lmao
I think Judge Perry perfectly saw through his charade.
If Dr .Spiegel is not a narcissist himself, then I have learned nothing about personality desorders in the past years!
Yup! I do wonder if he has autism though.
What this Dr was describing sounds like untreated ADHD to me, (being adhd & having similar symptoms, AND never!! Have tried or used heroine or any type of drugs)
He doesn't even know about his own medications he uses to treat his patients .
Is it shame starting at 4:29:20? Dissociation? The lack of humor? This whole persona and situation is maximum insane. His name "Spiegel" is the german translation for "mirror"!
I had to skim through his part because it was making my head spin and I was feeling a lot of second hand embarrassment.
That male attorney of Johnny's who was cross examining the psychiatrist was awesome! He was like Camille. Great questioning!!!
Honestly there is no way he could've anticipated some of those responses. Dude knew how to think on his feet, react to what was in front of him, and play to the psychiatrist's personality. He successfully made that psychiatrist create talking points that supported the side he was supposed to be testifying against.
@@bennitori4 yea hard!
Very true.. Finally someone commented about the male attorney
Never trust a doctor who would testify that he absolutely knows how an injury like this could not have happened.
Well, and his review of the video where Johnny described what happened... he is wrong! Johnny didn't say, or demonstrate, that his hand was resting flat. He showed his hand hanging loose over the edge of the bar, with his elbow and forearm resting on the bar
ignorant not to trust what this MD is saying may have happened, you can clearly see a chunk of skin and tissue was pinched off. MD is brilliant and if you have any sense you would think he made a lot of sense!
@@gailcerreta7807 I am accountable only for the words I release, not for the voices in your head.
@@gailcerreta7807 medically, yes he does make sense. however, he clearly failed physics class. a thrown bottle will not stop midair then drop straight down. it arcs, so there was downward and lateral movement at the same time
This Judge seems like such a genuine, good souled person.
Hopefully that is the case and she instructs the jury properly. As far as if the jury complies is to be seen.
But will there be a surprise twist?? 😲what of judge is childhood neighbor or amber
A truly fair judge, very impartial and hence, very professional :)
Please upload video
I agree a lot but sadly she does not act like that.Psychologist Hughes should not have been permitted to present accusations as fact, she was here to present a psychological analysis .
She should have been stopped she is not a detective , she is a shrink. And there is more too
15 months of marriage has cost Johnny 7 years of his life because AH loves to play victim sadly.
AH gold is gold digger
Don’t say “victim” too loudly, apparently it’s triggering to her 😂😂😂
@@eclipsesnarl4079 and how she loves it!
This is why most guys are afraid to pull the trigger on marriage 😂
Wow, her psychiatrist literally described Amber when he "thought" he was describing Johnny. Smh...listen to the 5 hr tape of crazy talk she put johnny through. Going in circles, putting him down, wanting control, admitting she starts the physical fights.
Where Can I Find This Tape At ?
Even Know I Have Heard Some Of It In Court.
@@Strawberries0000 just search Johnny Depp audio and they will appeal😊
Appear
I googled the tape omg, she loses her cool several times
I've come to the conclusion that I don't want my doctors board-certified
I agree 😄
@@IngaLeo4
🤣😂🤣🤣😄😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂
So true!!!!!! 😂
1:11:12 direct examination of Dr. Richard Moore begins
1:38:41 direct examination of Dr. Richard Moore ends
1:38:55 cross examination of Dr. Richard Moore begins
1:54:16 cross examination of Dr. Richard Moore ends
1:54:21 redirect of Dr. Richard Moore begins
1:58:23 redirect of Dr. Richard Moore ends
2:04:06 direct examination of Dr. David Spiegel begins
2:18:27 Plaintiff challenges Dr. David Spiegel's qualifications as an expert witness
2:26:30 direct examination of Dr. David Spiegel resumes
2:50:21 morning recess
3:09:55 direct examination of Dr. David Spiegel resumes
4:04:55 direct examination of Dr. David Spiegel ends
4:05:06 cross examination of Dr. David Spiegel begins
4:59:00 cross examination of Dr. David Speigel ends
4:59:12 lunch recess
6:03:55 redirect of Dr. David Spiegel begins
6:32:33 redirect of Dr. David Spiegel ends
6:33:16 direct examination of Kathryn Arnold begins
7:51:58 direct examination of Kathryn Arnold ends
7:52:05 afternoon recess
8:09:40 cross examination of Kathryn Arnold begins
9:27:02 cross examination of Kathryn Arnold ends
9:27:12 redirect of Kathryn Arnold begins
9:37:57 redirect of Kathryn Arnold ends
Thanks
thanks
Useless Duh 😒
The witness from 2:04:06 to 6:32:33 is a piece of work. I wonder if he has a lot of patients. And will he still have patients after this?
Dr. Heinz Doofenshmirtz cameo on today's trial was crazy.
IM DED
🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣 omg that is a great way to describe him
Oh my god!! Perfect statement!!!!
Ben Chew's facial expressions during Dr. Spiegel's testimony is gold!!
What’s the time stamp ?
That psychiatrist Dr. Siegel is a narcissist attempting to protect another narcissist. Worse-he's trying to gaslight us into believing a kind empathic soul is supposedly a narcissist. It's sickening. I was glad when he fell apart on the stand.
It makes me so mad that Elaine argues every time Depps team objects. The judge should stop Elaine.
Same. The way she whines makes my skin crawl. Like shut up, move on with the questions
She has the right to argue her point, but thankfully the judge sustains their objections (Depp's lawyers) most of the time.
You mean like when she’d argue the objection to the judge by saying; “I think he has the right to use here say.” 😱 Did I miss something…when is it ok to speak here say in court?
Every single time she either says “they’re just explaining” or “they’re just answering the question” OR “I THINK it’s ok for them to say that”
Her voice haunts me 😂
Maybe because she no longer knows how to structure her questions to get the answer she wants the jury to hear 😁
The term , “lets someone talk for long enough, and they will hang themselves with their own words”, springs to mind.
100%
That is my favorite hobby. People ask how I do to spot liars so easily. Its always nothing... You listen attentively/actively, show no reactions and let them panic and talk more than they should because they can't read you.
U see how ambers attorneys try to cut the answers short? They understand they have nothing to work on so they can’t let Johnnys witnesses talk to long. But ambers witness get the entire floor.
The look on this doctor's face when there is an objection... 🤣 It's like he just cannot believe that someone interrupted him during his display of brilliance! 🗣🗣🗣🧐
RIght! He looked at them like, "How dare you interupt my lecture!" 🤣
The crazy 🤪 looking one. He reminds me of someone but I can't figure out who. It is driving me nuts
@@garfield2439 He reminds me of Dr Emmet brown from Back To The Future.
😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😫🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️😆😆👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽💯💯💯👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
@@raeman7042
🤣😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂🤣🤣😂👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽💯💯💯👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
So ironic that Amber's team obsesses over a "yes or no" answer, but Dr. Siegel said everything he wanted to except a simple "yes or no"....shows the maturity level of Johnny's team and also how the "witnesses" are wasting time
What’s the most annoying thing about AH’s lawyer: 1) Starting almost all questions with “What if any…?” 2) Constantly arguing with the judge on her decision to sustain an objection from JD’s lawyers with an attitude 3) Never turning on her microphone 4) Overall disorganization, disorientation and ability to formulate questions after the judge’s sustaining of objections? 🤔
Yes!! It drives me nuts that the judge doesn’t ever give her a warning for challenging her time and time again minute after minute 🤦🏼♀️
…You ask questions that way to *avoid* objections. Are you being serious about this? Because these two notions contradict each other.
An attorney is *supposed* to argue objection motions. The biggest problem with defense is that they’re arguing objections *poorly.*
@@brandimartinez1444 Christ.
She’s a lawyer. She’s supposed to argue rulings in her client’s favor. You’re not being paid to back a party here, right? Because it’s weird that you’re this worked up about a lawyer doing their job.
Well it is to be expected cause that is the way they try to not get objected to.
@@christianc.christian5025 On a different court day when Camille was nonstop objecting to all of Elaine’s leading and calls for speculation questions, the judge had to point out to Elaine that her question starting with “what if any” isn’t the “cure all” and Elaine ended up stumped and said “I have no more further questions” LOL
My ex girlfriend was narcissistic, controlling, spread lies about me, cheated and in the end stalked me. It's been 5 years and I still can't say her name and still have trust issues. If I had to face her in court and listen to her spew more lies about me I'd probably break down crying in all honesty. I cannot imagine how hard this has all been for Johnny. He puts on a brave face because he has to and disguises his pain with humor but he can't even say her name or look at her. I know he's hurting from all this so thank god he's got a good team who care about him.
I really want this trial on NETFLIX as documentary because I also want to know what the Jury and Judge was thinking everyday of this trail, please 🙏
Amber ruined her career for absolutely no reason! she was upset that johnny was still jhonny after they broke up and her endless cash flow had dried up..
All my love and solidarity to you x
So sorry you experienced that. I've been thru it myself, with a couple ex boyfriends. I hope johnny gets justice. If she wins this, it's like all abusers win. I know that's not how it really is, but it feels like it. Nothing more painful than being the victim and being manipulated and gaslit and drug thru all of this. And for him, in front of the whole world. My heart breaks for him.
I wish you the best tho! 🙏🏼
First love your first name!! Second, so sorry you went through such a horrendous experience 😔 I couldn't even imagine the terror of being stalked😱 Glad you survived! One day at time.....thank you for sharing ♥️ May you find your peace. Absolutely agree with a Netflix doc 👍
more strength to you . sorry that you had such a terrible experience .
It is being made into a show. They have started already but details aren't clear yet. We just know it's happening
It's crazy how this psychiatrist is so brilliant that he can diagnose and predict if a man is violent by looking at a picture of him sleeping...
Literally got a cold sweat when Johnny’s lawyer cross questions the psychiatrist 😅😅 when they are discussing the ethics 😅😅😅 holy smokes that got crazy. If you want to question his ethics, question why he was asking what he can lie about at 2 hours 3 mins.
❤️Thanks for uncounted love and support you have consistently been showing me. I really appreciate the unconditional love I’ve gotten from you, which has inspired me to give more sensational entertainment. I’m forever grateful. What country are you watching from?
This agent met Amber for the first time today. She’s talking as if she were her agent for the previous 10 years
Yes and also some of her testimony was based on what Amber told her regarding her career which she stated as fact.
Right? The agent with ZERO CLIENTS.
No way...
I called her the unemployed agent . She admitted she wasn’t working at the moment. Obviously another paid witness 🤦🏻♀️
The people she compared with were way advanced: Chris Pine, Jason and Gal were all lead characters in their movies.
That doctor who talked about the the bottle hitting the finger had to have been paid something. Absolutely disgusting how you can sit there and straight up lie, knowing it makes no sense. Shoutout to Camille for applying pressure!
$5,000 per day + & they mentioned he had previously testified twice for 2 of Amber's other law firms.
And you know this because you’re a Doctor?
@@jared3235anyone watching the case in it’s entirety knows he lying because he lied about the hand placement and angle. Which was corrected. Why do people need to be doctors to know that
@@jared3235 um no we know this because the dr himself testified to it
@@jared3235 he knows it because the doctor was not there when it happened. Let's wait for the actual doctor who did the surgery to Johnny. I believe he's included in JD's witnesses and will testify either on Wed or Thu
Interesting how Amber was not wearing any makeup and doing her hair very conservatively or leaving it deliberately disheveled, up until the point that she was testifying and playing the "survivor not victim" card and as soon as it's done, she's back in full-glam mode. This woman is terrifying in how far she's willing to go to get her way.
Johnny’s team is obviously really loyal to him, not just legally but are now emotionally invested for justice for Johnny! Love Ben Chew & of course Camille!
The last witness said JD cannot claim loss of earning because Pirates 6 doesn't exist. So with that in mind, how can she say AH would lose up to $50m in the future for projects that do not exist today?
Correct!
She basically said that JD did it to himself by defending himself in a court of law. I would say that if AH didn't make it public that he was allegedly an abuser then he wouldn't have had to defend himself.
Exactly and she thinks she is worth $100M, in what world would she have lost more than Depp.
@@Kayla-ed2rp yes exactly. He has more credits to his name than she has had hot breakfast.
This "expert" is so one sided. And who does she think she is? Speaking on behalf of Disney?
This trial doesn't follow logic or rational thought. But a good observation on your part.
Omg Spiegel is so condescending and arrogant. His patients surely leave his office worse than when they walked in
There's an article online about how us "toxic" Depp fans who must have narcissistic personality traits have gone on a review attack of Dr. Speigal..🤣 It states that after his testimony in court today Depps toxic fans who clearly have narcissistic traits went on an attack bombarding Dr. Speigal with negative reviews online.
I find it absolutely despicable that because Johnny Depps fans have stood behind him & not called him a liar at a time like this that means we are ALL "TOXIC" & "NARCISSISTIC" simply because we are supporting a victim of DV who isn't a women..? Absolute obserd! 🙄🤦♀️ Yet they want to claim amber is the victim here...but Johnny's fans even go under attack for supporting him...so his career has been f***ed, his kids have been made fun of & now his fans are under attack too....hmmmm🥴
He needs his licence revoked he describes his client's as victim's!! Discusting attitude and he's clearly taking his own meds!
Yea, that man should see a doctor. When a normal person goes out and sees a person like this, you'll keep your distance because you have an instinct that says something is not ok with him. The way he talks and acts is what tells us this. And this is an instinct. A very basic instinct that keeps us away from something that could be dangerous. So, yea. He is totally not ok! He could be smart, it's not about that, but mentally he is just f. up. If you ask me it's like asking a blind person if he/she saw anything..
I think he is the one who need medical treatment...
Oh god…🥺I pray that anyone who was seeing this so called psychiatrist “dr spiegel run..and run fast and far as you can!!!!! Go find a real psychiatrist that’s not on drugs like spiegel and who is not an arrogant cocky @$$hold
This guy was one of the rare times Johnny stopped looking down drawing/writing and just had to watch what was going on. 😂 Can’t help but wonder if he’ll inspire a future character. He’s definitely a character…
I agree Johnny seemed amused and found him an interesting character, he was entertaining for sure and I can tell he is very intelligent, that peaked Johnny's attention.
oh JD looked up for a while and directly at Amber's sister. rare times certainly for these two individuals.
@@estelvga8499 I also noticed he looked up at the hand Dr. when he was trying to show how Johnny's hand was laying flat
He basically is channeling Dr Emmett Brown from Back to the Future. Minus the likability and minus the genius.
JD's legal team should be paid their weight in gold! The amount of a thorough research they have to conduct for each and every witness is aspirational for junior lawyers like myself. Bravo!
no way. his team seemed completey desperate to make sure none of the most important evidence was presented to the jury. they play semantics and the power of being the "popular" team. they too are affected by johnny's power.
@@laurenmace5835 I don't know what trial you've been watching. However, to entertain your comment above, attorney Crawford when questioning the wack job of a psychiatrist hired by Amber's team on the witness/testimony stand (a character you can only meet in Looney Tunes) Attorney Crawford has taken off his lawyer hat and wore his professional psychiatrist one, putting the actual pychotrist into shame.
The amount of research himself and his team had to conduct in order to refute a "bonified doc" was uncanny.
It seems the psychiatrist is the one that has the most narcissistic personality traits in the courtroom.
yes, he's unnecessarily complicated and likes to beat around the bush,.. you never know what he'll say next. Very reactive
I would say he got into the profession because he was nuts to begin with and wanted to get into other people’s heads to figure out his own
Yeah, that was awkward, where do they find those people?
@@mutzicat he makes me think of Trevor from GTA lmao
no he is only the second, AH is indeed the first of all
Comparing Amber Heard to Jason Momoa, Zendaya, Chris Pine, and Gal Gadot isn’t even comparing apples to oranges. It’s more like comparing apples to a cardboard pizza box. Amber Heard isn’t even another FRUIT!
She’s a potato
Not even a potato
I did not even know who she was till Rum Diaries which she got the role because of Johnny.
She's bananas
She got aquaman because of Johnny. She said "I auditioned and got it". Well who got you the audition? Depp did. She is no Zendaya. Zendaya is on the cover of every chick magazine. Gadot was main character. Heard would've never been billed as thee top actor or actress. Not a #1.
Don't remember her name but the industry expert "I've testified around 1 hundred times". Later objection for hearsay "I'm sorry I'm just trying to get used to this world".
About as full of BS as Amber.
Speaking directly to the judge multiple times as well. An expert witness who’s testified around 100 times has never been instructed to only answer questions asked by the questioning attorney and to not directly address the judge? That stuck out to me along with what you mentioned 😬
The outpour of support for Johnny has been unbelievable and awesome to watch unfold.
Johnny Depp has won regardless of whatever the outcome of the trial is. He's gained his reputation back in front of the public, period.
Yes he has. Win or lose, he has already WON 🏅!
hahaha! Are u kidding. What trial are you watchin?
@cuinheaven apparently the one you are NOT watching because it has been clear since the first week the public is behind JD . It's a landslide in the public opinion AH is at the bottom of the barrel where she belongs
@@littledaisies6856 Time will tell honey 😌🙌🏻 Have some patience !!
And amber lost hers.
This might sound weird, but I would have loved for Camille to do the cross-examination of Dr. Spiegel.
I like how Johnny just sits and looks at Dr. Moore like "yeah, buddy, tell me about how I did or didn't sustain an injury to my finger". :D
"Please just answer the question" lmao the judge was just as annoyed by this guy as everyone else
I also find it funny how he cuts Depp's attorney off implying that the question has already been answered and then goes on to ramble about other questions instead of answering them straight. What a quack.
Kate Moss is being called as a rebuttal witness to testify against Amber’s allegations on Wednesday! (Via video)
Really? Kewl. The sphinx will talk then?
Really, where you saw that!?
I just saw that! I’m really looking forward to it.
Jennifer Howell is set to testify too and she has some very interesting things to say that goes against what Ambers sister testified to 🤔
@@Areniapixie who is Jennifer Howell?
So excited for this!!
This “psychiatrist” makes me question, who can be a board member or a psychiatrist to begin with .. this guy can’t even answer a question.. he’s literally insane. What an awful redirect too, cross got its point across and then some to discredit him completely. Who advertises their book on the witness stand?! This guy is something else.
Sam the Eagle from The Muppets meets Doc from Back to the Future.🤣
Yes!!!! He is completely gone off the deep end…right on the stand. Anger management issues, arrogant, narcissistic personality, the legal team they ALL have the SAME personality issues as AH. Crazy
You just called a man who you literally have seen talk for a small portion of his life literally insane.
Think thats entirely why he was on the stand to plug his book. As he said, "Thanks for plugging my book"
Says all I need to know about him.
@@charitygeisler1356 did we not watch the same testimony? Because it was very telling.
Listen closely at 2:03:16. He asks Heards lawyer ‘I’m going to lie in my testimony, is there anything I shouldn’t lie about?’ And she replies ‘no’
i think i says „is there something i’m not allowed to talk about“
@@pannabelle. he does say "allowed" and not "shouldn't" - but I think he says "lie about" and not "talk about". Even though "allowed to lie about" sounds weird (since you're technically not allowed to lie about anything), I think that's what he says.
Whoa
I heard it multiple times and every time I heard “I’m gonna lie in the testimony… is there something I’m not allowed to lie about?”
Im a very empathic person and the way speaks gives me the sensation he’s a smug person even the way he talked to the lawyers either side
Listening to this was just 🤯
@@JazminJHC I heard the same thing you did there.
Camille, I love you for being available to be there for Johnny! You are spot on, and you know and do your job impeccably! Mr. Chew has a great team with each and every one of you. Camille definitely deserves a raise. This team is a VERY WELL OILED MACHINE. You can all work competently with your eyes closed! Congratulations 🎊🎈🎉!
Aaqaaàaàaaà
When the judge asked “How long is it gonna take?” I was like “With all due respect, your Honor, you’re allowing a neurotic psychiatrist to put up his own personal show, for which he’s being well compensated! Therefore, expect a very long display of meaningless nonsense on Ms. Heard’s behalf!”
As far as I’m concerned, that nut job actually helped Depp and his legal team!
Righhhht he had me trippin out
💀
When he was explaining what narcissism is, all he said checks out Amber. Lmao.
And the gaslighting, Amber literally gaslights everyone around her including us. “That’s not what I said.” “I disagree with your characterization.” are examples.
@@whitexangelic Exactly this! I don't think her legal team realizes they should steer clear of any questioning regarding narcissism. Before the cross, I thought the Doctor was actually presenting decently well, but he fell apart in cross and their questioning about narcissism was almost tailored to hurt their client.
@@whitexangelic “I disagree with that characterisation” is almost akin to gaslighting “that didn’t happen, you’re remembering it wrong. What I say happened, is what happened.”
Ben Chew and Johnny Depp's faces when Dr Spiegel went crazy with the face contortions was comedy gold.
It actually makes them look bad because a lot of people stick out their tongues when they’re thinking or trying to concentrate as that is actually very normal. However, he could have TD or something like it and that would mean that JD and his team were making fun of him which is very messed up in my opinion.
Time stamp?
@@codyandjessisalazar3429 I honestly think they were just caught off guard like a lot of us watching
Do i have to answer that 🤔 🤣🤣🤣 what a cockwomble!
@@codyandjessisalazar3429 Amber?
To anyone who is a lawyer: Can Elaine argue immediately after the objection? She always says, "I think that.... he can say this. or "it's not leading" or "it's not hearsay." Does she have to wait for the judge? And if so, why hasn't she been warned? This judge is really the real MVP. She's seems so amazingly patient and also firm and fair.
Not a lawyer but I’m in law school, and I’ve done Mock Trials. Sometimes after an objection the Judge will ask the party who is being objected to how do they respond. Generally though, the Judge will just implicitly wait for the other side to make their make point if they want to fight to get in.
Judges are human and they sometimes do make errors on objections, especially hearsay. It is the lawyers job to keep them on their toes. Stating your response also helps if you want to appeal a case.
@@patrickisidore7640 Interesting, thanks for answering.
The fact that she argues with the judges decisions is SO gross unprofessional. Arguing your point is one thing, but the way Elaine does it is toddler-like. I'm surprised she hasn't gone down to the floor kicking her legs in a tantrum yet.
I believe they’re not supposed to argue the objection, that’s when they have to approach. At one point Camille cuts her off and asks to approach calling it ‘inappropriate’ that Elaine kept arguing her objections in redirect. But by the looks of it, it’s not a big bad rule. So they will ask to approach so things aren’t said in front of the jury but Elaine’s very quick to defend her questions. You can kinda tell the judge isn’t a fan of her.
Depends on the judge as well. Some would NEVER tolerate her behavior!
How come no one has done a comparison on the writing on the mirrors to amber’s writing in the love journal? How do ambers lawyers get away with being so rude to the judge?
Thank you! I've been saying the same thing.. And what about when he punches her he's right handed if she's facing him he's gonna punch her on the left cheek, and her facial injuries are always on the right
Because it is so far off. She could have forged it though
Because itd prove its johnnys writing
That’s what some lawyers were saying Camille was getting at by showing some of the “love notes”, but without actually saying it.
@@sheleanesteele5025 I made the same observation. This is but one of her many screw ups. It’s all in the details
Every single person on Amber’s team-from lawyer to witness, has a horrendous attitude problem, just like Amber.
Big time mate!!!! That Dr forced his speech after sustained was spoken what a bi++h
Probably from having to deal with Amber
Today was the first time i seen them enter all smiling and friendly toward everyone and each other.
All mental crazies like her
Birds of a feather.
The whole Willie wonka moment was just one of the most odd and entertaining moments of this whole shabang I've seen. Dr incoherent licking his face, JD and his lawyer leaning forward in awe.... I mean why did AH lawyers think this was a good idea?
lol licking his face.. what was that??
Jajaja I never saw something like that in real life jajaj.
he's a victim himself 😄😄😄
Yes! I couldn't stop laughing. He's quite the oddball.
The face licking and asking the judge if he had to answer...surreal.
Why are all of Heard’s witnesses snarky and rude af to Depp’s lawyers?!? They think they are being cute but it makes them look unprofessional and ignorant.
I think they’re now trying (albeit late) to mimick the dynamics of the Depp Team and witnesses.
Thank you Dr. Spiegel for lending some comedic relief to this trial. Oh boy! Did I have some laughs during that testimony. He is super smart, but obviously was paid to testify for the wrong side lol and had to stick to that! But I thoroughly enjoyed the back & forth banter between him and Johnny's attorney
Wait I don’t get it … so dr curry “CAN’T”Diagnose amber after a 2- hours session but amber’s witness “ CAN “ diagnose johnny just by watching him in pirates of the Caribbean???? 🤔😵💫
Dr Curry spent pretty much a full weekend with Amber though, it was much more than 2 hours
I’m pretty sure she said it was 12 hours over 2 days
DA........ everyone who worked on the film said the same, extremely late, drunk and couldn't remember a single line, you are clearly not paying attention to the facts!
12 hours*
I’m sorry I said 2 hours but it’s actually 12 hours !! (It’s even worse) but Thank you for rectifying me 😁
Are they sure that guy is Dr. Spiegel? He looks like the escaped patient who locked Dr. Spiegel in a trunk. Frickin creepy.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣D.Y.I.N.G 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Reminds me of Jim Carrey's character in Lemony Snicketts A Series of Unfortunate Events.
SKIP TO 2:03:15! WAIT until Elaine approaches the Dr out of view at first and they both come into view. One of their mics were on and it sounded like the Dr said; “I will lie in my testimony.” “Is there something I’m not allowed to lie about?” Elaine than responds; “No” and taps him on his arm.
ALL ALLEGEDLY.
But if someone can amplify this piece of audio that was picked up, PLEASE do so and contact Johnny’s Atts ASAP.
Dang it I can't hear it🤨😕. I listened again with the volume up. I heard lie and testimony WTH
I thought he was saying "I'll rely on my testimony" I wish my earbuds were louder!!
I turned earphones up and I thought I heard the same
The trial starts at 1:11:12 with first witness being Dr. Richard Moore
The second witness, Dr. David R Spiegel at 2:04:06
The trial takes a break at 2:50:14
It comes back at 3:09:51
The trial takes a break at 4:59:04
The recap of the trial starts at 5:07:26 until 6:02:57
The trial comes back at 6:03:57
The testimony of the third witness, Kathryn Arnold begins at 6:33:16
The trial takes a break at 7:51:58
It comes back at 8:09:36 with the Cross-Examination
Thank you!
Bless you
You’re my hero!
Thanks
Thank you!!!
Did anybody notice Catherine Arnold said Johnny Depp did not lose anything because pirates six had not been made yet? She later went on to say that Amber Hurd lost $4 million for Aquaman three… Which has not been made yet.! This woman is clearly biased.
So true 💯 Percent
Aquaman 3 has not been made yet but it is already contracted! There is no contract whatsoever for pirates 6!! Big difference! That is you not listening and only hearing what you wanna hear to twist it around!! Pay attention Or don’t watch it all if you cannot understand anything completely.
Aquaman was contracted. Big difference you're purposely trying to ignore
@@codyandjessisalazar3429 she also mentions a few other movies and shows that amber was being “considered” for as a loss when there was no contract.
@@codyandjessisalazar3429 well apparently I wasn’t that wrong.
What’s weird is when he was talking about narcissism he was describing Amber 🤣 I hope the jury noticed that
As well as when he was talking about it building up and the victim receding.. did Johnny not always try to get away? I feel like he’s not helping amber’s side at all
I think this psychiatrist is a narcissist! Lol
@@julesp7596 I thought the same thing lol. He can’t even let someone finish their question and talks over them. He talks like a narcissist
Literally rolling with laughter at the nutty therapist. Your honor I object, argumentative, foundation. He actually proved the plaintiff case by describing Ms.Heard diagnosis. 😁
And yet, the person with a medical degree says that you’re wrong.
In fact, even Depp’s psychologist says that you’re wrong. Shannon Curry said that Heard has BPD and HPD. Those *are not the same thing as narcissism.*
You just don’t know what ‘narcissism’ is. That’s why you may not get it.
@@christianc.christian5025 the so called expert, never spoke to Mr Depp directly so how on earth can he give any expert opinion? It was only his thoughts based on what that woman said.
@@christianc.christian5025 I know… I (heard) lol, her full testimony. What r you talking about??
“I’m sorry I’m just trying to understand this world” After stating in her first sentence that she was a professional expert witness 🙄
My thoughts exactly!!
Good note!
Exactly what I thought .
I think she meant understanding the world of the courtroom. because she got cut off and corrected after objections
Yep, she said she has done several testimonials, but after getting objected she said I'm still new to this.
This psychiatrist is scary. I would be terrified to be seen by him. He reminds me of Mr. Burns from the Simpsons.
Compared to that guy Mr. Burns seems lovely.
😂😂😂😂
Loool
😂😂😂😂
At the end of his testimony he is clearly muttering away to himself.
There's literally audio recording of Amber saying "I didn't do it on purpose", Dr. kipper saying "she threw the bottle at him first" and Dr. Kipper asking the nurse how she got cocaine in the house while Amber says, "I'm only doing Xanax, Adderall, hallucinogens" (and something else, I can't remember). And no one knew the recording was on. It's an absolute shame they couldn't use it in court and it's an absolute shame this doctor is straight out denying a bottle could do this when the audio recording proves that's exactly what happened.
Why couldn't they use it in court?
@@jellyflower32 I keep hearing the lawyers taking about how the audio recording can only have Johnny or Amber's voices. They can't play any audio that has anyone else in it. I honestly have no idea why, though.
Ok, so I tried to look it up and it just made me more confused because all I found was that most audio recordings are not admissible in court, especially if one party did not know they were being recorded. So, idk. 🤷
@@whatsmyname9977 it’s probably both bc they have mentioned that you can’t play it if there’s other people in it
Ecstacy
The witness said he will lie in his testimony and if there was something he’s not allowed to lie about. 2:03:15. Nice and clear
Wow
Yep I heard that 😅
L
that is absurd
So basically what this Catherine entertainment industry expert person is saying is that Johnny's career started tanking when Amber Heard was part of his life. She is largely responsible for any problems in Australia with the Pirates 5 shoot. It makes sense to me that a victim of domestic violence would start having trouble at work. And that's what Johnny was.
My thoughts exactly!
THANK YOU!!! I have said this before myself on another trial day. DV victims become a shell of theirselves. Hollywood didn't cancel JD because of drugs, alcohol or being late. They knew he's done drugs since at least the 90's. River Phoenix died in his arms from OD'ing in front of the Viper Room, that didn't even affect his career. AH's false accusations of DV by JD is directly responsible for his career downturn. AH can only blame her lies for this whole mess.
💯💯
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I couldn't agree more or said it better!!💯👍🏾
Amber is responsible for her own demise. Those vile and evil recordings have sunk her with the public. Her real personality shined through and people hate her because of it. If she hadn't falsely filed that restraining order, nobody would have listened to her own voice mocking her husband and acting like a vile witch.
That psychiatrist was told _it was vomit_
How many other lies was this expert told?
And which audios or parts of audios has this expert been shown ?
And we know who Johnny is after seeing all the texts he’s sent to his friends slagging off the mother of his kids and his wife.
Theyre both responsible for their own demise.
That is correct; she asked for it
She drugged her own grave.
@@Manuel_Bache Look at the table in the lower corner of the Ice Cream Passed out pic. There is a theatre makeup bruise kit sitting there, For Making bruises, not covering them. OMG
Why do Heard’s witnesses insist on describing her character through Johnny? It’s amusing yet disturbing
Yes this is exactly what I said before xx
Had to rewatch Katherine Arnold's testimony after Walter Hamada testified (the next day). She said AH could renegotiate her salary for Aquaman 2 - false. She also said (AH told her) a second script was released - reducing AH's role and screen time - also false. Hamada testified that the one and only script was written in 2018 and not altered. He also said that due to lack of chemistry between JM & AH - recasting for Mera was discussed. Hamada also said that Aquaman 2 was known ahead of time to move Mera out of the spotlight. Also, all actors agreed before Aquaman 2 to salaries - there was no option to negotiate. There were no damages or losses from anything anyone said in regards to AH's Aquaman role. Arnold is not a reliable witness, nor an "expert".
Her character in Aquaman was NOT what made it popular. Period. She could be replaced and nobody care. Jason Momoa cannot!
I wonder Momoa's reaction if he hears this🙃
These people are on my Last Nerve. There is a HUGE DIFFERENCE between an ADDICTION & and being an ABUSER. Their only hope is to make one and the same.
Oh I think it’s been regarded lol
@Alexandru lol
What does Depp call you crazy fans again? The other word for Sucker fish....? Hahaha. It's the only thing I'll agree with him on.
Depp ruined Depp's career. And his life. And kids. And everything else he touches. Depp brought everything upon himself, but he's too pickled to see that.
@Alexandru
Good analogy.
When the doc said he noticed Johnny had a significant delay in processing speed he himself said it super slow which made me smile. But also, if you watch a video if Johnny from 30 years ago, he talks the same.
Oh my God. Attorney: "Correlation does not imply causation, does it?" Witness: " I'm not an expert in semantics.". Wow. I know she isn't qualified as a statistician, but essentially she's working with statistics, wherein being mindful of causation and correlation is essential. Who t f is this woman?! She is even visually constructing a CHART with her hands while she talks, mentioning a decline in popularity, or whatever, correlating with certain statements. She's obviously looking at data and most likely inputting the data to make a chart. The statement "correlation does not imply causation" should NOT be mistaken for semantics by someone doing work like she is doing. As much as I hate to use this phrase, having heard it used by at least 2 idiots during day 20, it is 'part and parcel'!
Very well stated, Mary. 👍👍
I’ve lost count the number of times this lawyer says “what if any” before her questions as if that negates her being leading or using hearsay.
Its my LEAST FAVORITE freaking line right now. She makes my blood boil
We need “What, if any?” merch 😆
…But it usually *does.* Are you sure that you understand why objections actually happen?
And why they’re sustained or overruled? There are so many exceptions to hearsay that they essentially swallow the rule.
Leading is also only restricted on direct. Plaintiff isn’t objecting to questions because they think that they’re going to win the motion, they’re doing so to throw off the rhythm.
Occasionally, they have a valid point.
The judge told her it's not a "cure-all" during cross, to which she later replied that it is.
Hahahaha...totally...and when the objection comes, she says:"but I said, what if any..."
It's killing me!
58:40 the recording inside the court room starts
1:01:19 Amber Heard arrives
1:04:40 Johnny Depp arrives
1:08:58 Judge arrive and the trial starts
1:10:36 Trial starts
1:10:43 Witness Dr. Richard rise to the stand
2:04:10 Witness Dr. David rise to the stand
2:50:18 Morning recess
3:07:55 Trial continues
4:59:07 lunch break
5:07:27 Recap and Live Q&A
6:03:50 Trial continues
6:33:10 Witness Catherine rise to the stand
7:52:37 court on a break
8:08:37 Trial continues
9:38:05 Witness questioning ends
9:40:17 The judge leaves and the trial end
9:41:00 Recap
Thanks so much ❤️
Thank you, that's very helpful.
🙏🙏
Pin this.
This needs to be pinned.
Amazing how she has all these hypotheses on earning potential for all of these things that don't exist yet; but on the other side she said she couldn't even estimate for Pirates 6 because it doesn't exist for JD. If he's does several movies, you could estimate how much he might have made had he been in the next movie. Her opinion is completely biased.
Anyone else hear him say he will lie during his testimony and then asked if there's something he isn't allowed to lie about? You can hear it around 02:03:15 mark
Yep that’s exactly what he says
Yes!!
Would he actually risk saying that possibly loud enough to be heard by the audience behind him, what if the other attorneys happened to hear!?? Or picked up by this recording...it could come back on them and the case could be thrown out!
Wait what 😮
@@jenniferhudson3498 old people whisper loudly. They think they are being quiet because they can barely hear themselves. Also, the static noise gets louder when it detects sound so that it’s picked up easier on the microphones.
The reason why I am invested in this case is not because I am a "fan" of Johnny. I have watched a few of his films, but I cannot qualify myself as a fan. What I wanted to see was how justice is going to be served to a man who was defamed and framed by a woman.
Agreed same here I don’t normally follow celebrity stories etc. but there’s just so much more going on here and it is one of a kind and made public. Really curious to see where this goes..
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Well said 👌
@@christinagkritzali4779 same here 👏
That’s beautiful
The egos of all those witnesses were just awful. Trying to be somebody they are absolutely not
Agree
How would u know
True
Oh the first “ finger doctor 👨⚕️ “ get paid $5000 / day for court appearance and $1000/ hour for evaluation answer his “ opinion “; none of these two doctors 🥼 it’s the finger exam doctor 👨⚕️ which it’s happened in Australian years back.Why call that doctor 👨⚕️ or zoom him instead call those” second opinion doctor “?
Fitting for their client
Dr. Spiegle is completely nutty! I don’t think he’s in a position to be analysing anybody. He’s all over the place verbally and physically. He comes across as one of the very people he is describing.
What’s also strange is that at points in his ramblings he comes across as if he is positioning himself for a job with Johnny. His performance is unbelievable. He has absolutely no idea what is going on around him.
I work at Norfolk General where he does and nobody has positive things to say about him as professional acquaintances. Not a single person.
@@mamatee907 He clearly believes his importance is greater than those around him. I feel sorry for these deluded types.
Camille did a great job with the surgeon. He is very well qualified, but she brought into question that he could be mistaken.
Amber literally started all this by going to the courthouse with TMZ with a “bruise” on her cheek. She ruined her own career
@Holly Evans yes you are right. No one would do so unless they are actually suffering.
@@KavitaKumari-ot1ls or unless they’re a fraud that likes to punish ppl for wanting to divorce them
100%. And she practically admitted to leaking their divorce to TMZ in her witness testimony video for the UK trial.
@@KavitaKumari-ot1ls if she was really wanting protected from him after a violent assault she would have gotten the PTO when she filed for the divorce. She waited because she was trying to extort money from him she knew he didn’t have. So yes, there’s a really good reason for her to fake bruising. Especially bruising that is not at all consistent with her “recollections”.
@Nicole Patterson, Yes, you are right. This is also a strong possibility which can not be denied.
I think the psychology doctor really needs to see a psychiatrist.
Seems some people enter the psychiatric field for personal reasons. That guy's issues were on full display. It was sad to watch.
I second that!!!!😩
💯 what I thought! Talking about narcissistic traits... uhmm
🤣
He’s nuts 😜
Amber Heard was in Aquaman????? I just know I watched it for Jason Momoa!!!! 😂
Court starts at 1:10:38
Court takes first break at 2:51:30
Court returns at 3:09:00
Court takes second break at 4:59:50
Court returns at 6:03:33
Court takes third break at 7:52:27
Court returns at 8:08:31
This needs to be higher up in the thread lol
Thank you!!
2:03:15 "I will lie in my testimony"
I believe Mr Depp, a DV survivor, and his truth. I don't think he is a perfect man but a good man. I admire his courage and perseverance to reveal the truth even at the cost of his privacy. I've heard the tapes and seen the evidence. I choose to stand by him.
me too!!
Justice for Johnny!!!
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏same here.
I feel exactly the same. Justice for Johnny! 🤍🤍🤍🤍
She antagonized and taunted him to the point where a sane sober person would slap the ship out of her. She was terrible.