Always a treat to hear Geri sing. She’s sometimes criticised for her vocals but I think she has a lovely tone to her voice. Can easily imagine her singing Jazz in a club!
Aww Geri was so nervous. But she got confident at the end. Sometimes these girls forget how amazing they are and get all nervous about their voices. They actually sound really good when they believe in themselves.
@@antonioeliasfirminoferreir3559 no, the album version is "Once again if we endevour Love will bring us back together Take it or leave it, take it or leave it" Victoria sang the same like you wrote
@@noecases5940 yeah it did. "once again if we endeavor, boys and girls feel good together" on the album to "any deal that we endeavor, love will bring us back together" on the single and video
Mel C’s voice is amazing as always, she owned the performance. Wow it took Melanie to make Geri sing her original verse from 2 Become 1 for the very first time.
@@pencilmaxstar I saw that geri wasn't comfortable in the key that part is in so they changed it to Victoria when it came time to do the video and tour
Geri only sang her parts but it would have been nice if they sang the song together..like Geri taking Mel B's part in the first verse, singing solo in the chorus and singing Emma's bridge
It would have sound better if it had been rehearsed, but it was improvised since they bumped into each other unexpectedly and just tried to do it in that moment.
It was clearly Emma and Melanie C who made the song sweet. Geri didn't really have part. Geri is amazing in Lady Is A Vamp, Say You'll Be There and other hits too.
@@sakuraitonen9513 This song was written about her and her relationship with a boy... SO.. this conveys most emotions from her in the song and i can feel it ;) Spice girls songs are almost all starting from a Geri's note or story or point of view XD
#teamsporty even when Melanie C can sing the whole song she always share it splendid. Geri OMG Geri I love her so much she is the Spice Girls soul she can do whatever she wants. I love when Geri do the "talk" at the scenario she has a great voice but she gets shy with Mel...unbelievable.😢😢 I love them so much ❤❤
2 Become 1 Album versión con la parte de Geri Halliwell original. Será un agrado ver este 2019 cantar en vivo en la Gira UK a Geri con las Spice Girls como Cuarteto, y ella cubriendo las partes de Victoria.
De eso nada, en la versión original de estudio, no dice nada de chicos y chicas, hace referencia al amor en general y sin distinguir condiciones sexuales
@@noecases5940 Geri finalmente mezclo sus lineas originales con las de Victoria en su parte en solitario de 2 become 1. Además hace el tono en alto: ruclips.net/video/dO4d7cqlVro/видео.html
Its strange that she has the biggest personality but when it cones to singing live she struggles with confidence. I happen to love the sultry yet innocent tone of her voice. She sounds like a nun with a naughty past
I'm so happy that they did the album version of the song; I really like that verse, even though it doesn't exactly fit the song. I remember getting the album and being so confused by the "new" verse, haha.
Geri wrote that verse thinking about her relationship, but they later re-recorded it, when it was chosen as a single, to give the song a wider appeal and not to exclude gay community, which was a BEAUTIFUL idea. And in 1996 was even more important:)
Demetris Georgiou exactly! Finally, Geri was allowed to sing her verse the same way as on my 1996 tape! :-) she usually does well in this song, including the chorus. To my ears she sang in 2 become1 well on SpiceWorld Tour
That's not really fair. I don't think this performance was planned for Geri, it was a spur of the moment thing. That's why she seemed nervous. If you were thrown on stage and expected to be perfect, I'm sure you would disappoint.
I listened to the album so much when I was younger the ‘boys and girls’ line always seemed to be the original to me, the other always just seemed wrong
So the story goes that Victoria replaced Geri for the single version of 2 Become 1 because Geri wasn't comfortable with the key of the song (notice that she takes the last line down rather than up like Mel B and Victoria did on the verses). The lyric change from 'boys and girls feel good together' to 'love will bring us back together' was made so as to not alienate their gay following. If you listen to the demo the first verse is sung by Mel C and Victoria and the second by Mel C and Geri (link below). ruclips.net/video/FQmPDSYxLzs/видео.html
And it was good that Geri gave Victoria to sing her lines for a change, since Victoria herself had no solo line in WANNABE. I remember how Melanie C, Melanie B, Emma and Victoria had to sing her lines in Spiceworld tour 1998 when she left them and I'd like to see how Geri and the others would sing Victoria's lines on this upcoming tour.
Once again if we endevour love was bring us back together take or live it take or live it...❤️!!! Sorry I love Victoria but also Geri is good... I love Mel C❤️!!!
Posh always could sing! it was Geri the talentless one in the group but nobody cares about it because she's a flop. They always attack Posh because she's the queen
@@SailorSpears little do you know is that Geri had a lot to do with writing their material. She may not be the best vocally and shes even aware of that but shes a huge part to why the spice girls were the way they were, especially when it comes to their music. Dont be nasty, Geri is a good vocal, nothing amazing but keep in mind she hasnt sang in over 10 years... shes nervous as well.
she was nervous because she doesn't sing live anymore her last tour was like 10 years ago. if she practices her voice more and gets more comfortable performing she will be back to being the amazing singer we all know she is
It sounds way better, actually. Some surgeries, ageing, kids, lots of vocal training... and there it is! Not perfect, but light years apart from her beginings.
@@noecases5940 no, they're not. In the Spice album, Geri sings "any deal that we endeavour, boys and girls feel good together". in the singles and Greatest Hits, Victoria jumps in and sings "once again if we endeavour, love will brings us back together".
Geri has totally lost her confidence as a singer, watching her in 2012 belting It's Raining Men 100% love... to this. I can't help but think Melanie could've been a little more supportive but she's always been a back door mean girl in my opinion.
geri was the worst singer in the band. even vicky could sing better. you can see here that she is nervous singing with the best singer of the band mel c.
Listen to this: ruclips.net/video/Zx4c1IzBYaM/видео.html Geri's rendition of 'Wannabe' is just awesome! A true vocalist voice! In the performance above, she only sings her parts.
Geri has good solo live performances. Spanish: It is the only one of the Spice that has released songs in Spanish like: Mi Chico Latino, the Spanish rap of If U Can`t Dance, Get involved and its part of Seremos 1 los 2. ruclips.net/video/YH0YIzoBbDM/видео.html ruclips.net/video/BYMkg-LdKcQ/видео.html
Who are you to say that Melanie C can't sing.. She's one of the greatest female vocalists of all time and has a huge range and very beautiful, strong and unique voice. The only British female artist who holds the rocord for having most number one singles in Britain with 11. She has won many awards and many other singers say that it's her talent and her persona that is the reason they see themselves in the industry too. MØ, Little Mix, Saara Aalto and many others. 😎
Singing is not natural for everyone, particularly Geri, even if you are good. Some people need more rehearsal time, and warming up to be able to sing properly. Notice how after she got going, it was much better. Of course, Melanie C can sing most things perfectly at the drop of a hat, so I would be intimidated without the other 3 girls between us ahaha.
Very rare to see just the 2 of them together. It’s always Mel C & Emma or Geri & Mel B. Or Mel B & Emma. Or Geri & Emma. Or Victoria & Emma or Mel C & Victoria..
Geri was the main writer for this song. She also contributed a lot in Wannabe, Viva Forever, and STOP. I think she contributed by not just her distinct sound, but the lyrics to some of their major hits.
![DDG & G Herbo - Nosey [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I9Ra0Zc2NlQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Always a treat to hear Geri sing. She’s sometimes criticised for her vocals but I think she has a lovely tone to her voice. Can easily imagine her singing Jazz in a club!
Nah, Victoria is worst
Geri is the worst but she has something make u love her voice , its like kinda funny and she is so beautiful , it helps a lot !
Geri is the lest talented vocalist by far. Victoria can harmonise at least.
@@alexanio81 Victoria could’ve even been a wonderful r&b artist with her harmonising ability.
@@noecases5940 Victoria is a far better singer than Geri. Trained aswell.
Aww Geri was so nervous. But she got confident at the end. Sometimes these girls forget how amazing they are and get all nervous about their voices. They actually sound really good when they believe in themselves.
TheMadPillow 👍🏻 what a shiny comment!!!
All these years later! And Geri still sounds Like when she first recorded her verse 💋Ginger💋
Geri has such a distinct voice i love it
YES!!!! Album version live for the first time ever!!!
No, the album version didn't say boys and girls
@@noecases5940 yes, it did. "Any deal that we endeavour / Boys and girls feel good together / Take it or leave it, take it or leave it"
@@antonioeliasfirminoferreir3559 no, the album version is
"Once again if we endevour
Love will bring us back together
Take it or leave it, take it or leave it"
Victoria sang the same like you wrote
@@noecases5940 yeah it did. "once again if we endeavor, boys and girls feel good together" on the album to "any deal that we endeavor, love will bring us back together" on the single and video
I like this song. Geri is and always been my favourite Spice Girl. Good seeing her and Mel C sing the song together again.
Mel C’s voice is amazing as always, she owned the performance. Wow it took Melanie to make Geri sing her original verse from 2 Become 1 for the very first time.
I hope Geri will sing her part again in 2 become 1 on this upcoming june for the reunion
Love this. But i think that Mel c and Emma are the best voices!
Which is why they’re my 2 favorite Spice Girls
Geri's voice is actually very prominent in the studio version of this she sings the chorus with Emma.
BucklandsP3 I agree her voice is all over the chorus and it sounds lovely....especially with the video and how gorgeous she looks.
Woow memorable and sweet this Spice moment!!!❤❤
amazing Melanie C
Geri did very well, I like her harmony
GERALDINE 😍😍😍
It's nice that Mel C taking the other girls to sing with her
mel c is justing singing so much and doing much of music. she is a complete pro.
Being able to hear Geri sing her original "boys and girls" verse made this performance.
smck 2016 We’ve Bren waiting for this for ages!!!
I thought that was posh's part?
PencilMaxStar No Victoria re recorded it for the video and single release. Geri recorded her part first for the album.
@@pencilmaxstar I saw that geri wasn't comfortable in the key that part is in so they changed it to Victoria when it came time to do the video and tour
@@rayoflight6505 why changed in the video and tours?
Geri, minha preferida♡
❤❤❤❤ela é maravilhosa. Saiu muito cedo da banda
Geri only sang her parts but it would have been nice if they sang the song together..like Geri taking Mel B's part in the first verse, singing solo in the chorus and singing Emma's bridge
It would have sound better if it had been rehearsed, but it was improvised since they bumped into each other unexpectedly and just tried to do it in that moment.
Boys and girls FELL Good together....dont Change your lyrics ,geri ! Keep it !
the combination of the various spice girls voices fits so perfectly togetherx
I love them both! GIRL POWER
LEGENDS.
I'm maybe the only one, but to me is Geri's voice that made the song sound SO SWEET. Love her so much ♥♥
It was clearly Emma and Melanie C who made the song sweet. Geri didn't really have part. Geri is amazing in Lady Is A Vamp, Say You'll Be There and other hits too.
@@sakuraitonen9513 This song was written about her and her relationship with a boy... SO.. this conveys most emotions from her in the song and i can feel it ;) Spice girls songs are almost all starting from a Geri's note or story or point of view XD
God Bless Them lovely girls!
Aww, Geri was nervous, but she did a good job, I love these two Queens 💕
Obrigada, vc trouxe um pouquinho de alegria ao meu coração!
Geri and Mel C sound good together! What a nice blend! Now to hear Victoria sing after all of these years!
#teamsporty even when Melanie C can sing the whole song she always share it splendid. Geri OMG Geri I love her so much she is the Spice Girls soul she can do whatever she wants. I love when Geri do the "talk" at the scenario she has a great voice but she gets shy with Mel...unbelievable.😢😢 I love them so much ❤❤
sporty spice.😘
2 Become 1 Album versión con la parte de Geri Halliwell original. Será un agrado ver este 2019 cantar en vivo en la Gira UK a Geri con las Spice Girls como Cuarteto, y ella cubriendo las partes de Victoria.
De eso nada, en la versión original de estudio, no dice nada de chicos y chicas, hace referencia al amor en general y sin distinguir condiciones sexuales
@@noecases5940 Geri finalmente mezclo sus lineas originales con las de Victoria en su parte en solitario de 2 become 1. Además hace el tono en alto:
ruclips.net/video/dO4d7cqlVro/видео.html
Geri sang the album version!
Time for a full reunion!!!
Just did it
@@noecases5940 4/5 isn't full.
@@retrofun1479 better without pose
@@noecases5940 I agree
Its my imagination or Geri seems so nervous? Love It!
Jose Armando she's always nervous when going live. She constantly counts the tempo and seems to stop breathing at times.
and probably because Mel C Id stronger singer, she's a bit nervy.
Its strange that she has the biggest personality but when it cones to singing live she struggles with confidence. I happen to love the sultry yet innocent tone of her voice. She sounds like a nun with a naughty past
@@tarync6539 🤣🤣🤣 my fave description of her voice EVER!! And I love her voice too lol
yep, because I think Mel C is technical and all
They are so cute together
💕😍 as good as new.
Mel C 💙 Best Spice Girl
Love them!
Gorgeous😍
I'm so happy that they did the album version of the song; I really like that verse, even though it doesn't exactly fit the song. I remember getting the album and being so confused by the "new" verse, haha.
DegrassiInstantStar me too. Posh's verse is off putting
Geri wrote that verse thinking about her relationship, but they later re-recorded it, when it was chosen as a single, to give the song a wider appeal and not to exclude gay community, which was a BEAUTIFUL idea. And in 1996 was even more important:)
@@andreasemenzato7263 gay community? In this song?
One of a kind song
I Never want to hear anybody say that Geri can’t sing again. She’s so good in the lower notes.
SHE CAN'T SING PERIOD. Just loud. Monotone af
Angels among us!!!!
Mel C always sings this song, Geri probably hasn’t sang it since the tour in 07. But she should be able to sing her groups song 😒
Probably with another spice girl since 2008 but not in solo
Spice girls forever ✌️✌🏻✌🏾
40tena curtindo minhas divas 😍😍
💓💓👏👏👏
😍 ✌🏼❤️⚽️
Geri and her original version 💐
Beaaauuutiful
love it
Geri sang the original lyrics 💕
Looking forward for Spice Girls Tour
The shade
Mel C (the tomboy) is really in touch with her femininity.
MELANIE C feat. Geri Halliwell - 2 Become 1 -album version- hahahahahahaahhaa
that's what came to mind immediately after THAT verse!
Demetris Georgiou exactly! Finally, Geri was allowed to sing her verse the same way as on my 1996 tape! :-) she usually does well in this song, including the chorus. To my ears she sang in 2 become1 well on SpiceWorld Tour
Omg lucky audience
Melanie C saved the performance and ist's obviously that Geri was very nervous. But Melanie is amazing!😍
So? She didn't do badly
That's not really fair. I don't think this performance was planned for Geri, it was a spur of the moment thing. That's why she seemed nervous. If you were thrown on stage and expected to be perfect, I'm sure you would disappoint.
Love it ✌️
Ginger estava nervosa porque a Mel B tem uma voz poderosa
I listened to the album so much when I was younger the ‘boys and girls’ line always seemed to be the original to me, the other always just seemed wrong
So the story goes that Victoria replaced Geri for the single version of 2 Become 1 because Geri wasn't comfortable with the key of the song (notice that she takes the last line down rather than up like Mel B and Victoria did on the verses). The lyric change from 'boys and girls feel good together' to 'love will bring us back together' was made so as to not alienate their gay following.
If you listen to the demo the first verse is sung by Mel C and Victoria and the second by Mel C and Geri (link below).
ruclips.net/video/FQmPDSYxLzs/видео.html
And it was good that Geri gave Victoria to sing her lines for a change, since Victoria herself had no solo line in WANNABE. I remember how Melanie C, Melanie B, Emma and Victoria had to sing her lines in Spiceworld tour 1998 when she left them and I'd like to see how Geri and the others would sing Victoria's lines on this upcoming tour.
Not available
@@mcairolyakup Geri got to cover most of Victoria's lines in the 2019 tour and I feel she did a superior job.
Melanie did all the singing
She had no choice but to carry the tunes like she always did in the group
Geri was nervous like didn’t want to overshadow Melanie, anyway I lover her
Once again if we endevour love was bring us back together take or live it take or live it...❤️!!! Sorry I love Victoria but also Geri is good... I love Mel C❤️!!!
Jesus 😳
👍
Geri is so uncomfortable and just sang her few spice girls lines . Bless her. We love ya ginger xxx
And we all thought posh couldn't sing. Now there's geri.
stringer 2295 how you know she can't sing?
Posh always could sing! it was Geri the talentless one in the group but nobody cares about it because she's a flop. They always attack Posh because she's the queen
@@SailorSpears Melanie C is the queen when it comes down to singing. Or a goddess or an empress. 😎
@@SailorSpears little do you know is that Geri had a lot to do with writing their material. She may not be the best vocally and shes even aware of that but shes a huge part to why the spice girls were the way they were, especially when it comes to their music. Dont be nasty, Geri is a good vocal, nothing amazing but keep in mind she hasnt sang in over 10 years... shes nervous as well.
Geri almost looks worried to sing
because she can't
she was nervous because she doesn't sing live anymore her last tour was like 10 years ago. if she practices her voice more and gets more comfortable performing she will be back to being the amazing singer we all know she is
@@shayleelove220 you're wrong. She made a new song in 2013 and also did it in live...
@@noecases5940 Shaylee was talking about a wehole tour, not some random performances...
Emma Bunton ?where is Emma Bunton ? This is her song !!!
This is a Spice Girls song. If u want only Emma search elsewhere.
I heard only Melanie singing tbh
What happened with Geri's voice ?? :(
is featuring
Children and the aging process maybe...?
It sounds amazing, that's what happened.
It sounds way better, actually. Some surgeries, ageing, kids, lots of vocal training... and there it is! Not perfect, but light years apart from her beginings.
It actually has gotten better
Geri sang Victoria’s lyrics ;)
Sebastian Paul Dora' nope, Geri's sung Geri's lyrics. It's the album version, Victoria didn't sing in it.
She sang her lines. In the album version Geri had a solo part, Victoria replaced Geri with slightly different lyrics for the single edit.
Antonio Elias Firmino Ferreira Victoria sang
Victoria sang them better ;)
it was originally Geri's lyrics for the album but Victoria replaced her for the single because geri wasn't comfortable performing it
in spice girl only mel c can sing...
Geri's not the best in terms of vocal techniques but I looooooooove her voice!
Nice to hear this version, but I like the lyrics Victoria sings better!
Are not the same? I thought they were
@@noecases5940 no, they're not. In the Spice album, Geri sings "any deal that we endeavour, boys and girls feel good together". in the singles and Greatest Hits, Victoria jumps in and sings "once again if we endeavour, love will brings us back together".
@@antonioeliasfirminoferreir3559 now I now is not the same
Se a Mel tivesse deixado a Geri cantar teria ficado ainda melhor.😤
Camila Brenner A Mel fez foi ajudar ela. A Geri demonstrou insegurança demais ao cantar. Perdeu o timbre.
Parecia ate que a Gery não conhecia a música.
Geri has totally lost her confidence as a singer, watching her in 2012 belting It's Raining Men 100% love... to this. I can't help but think Melanie could've been a little more supportive but she's always been a back door mean girl in my opinion.
Geri seems really why these days, like she lost her confidence to a certain extent. Feel a bit sorry for her of that is the case
Lovelyyy... I'm crying.. But mel should've not monopolize the verses. Geri voice was so much more genuine.
Muhammad Aulia ahahahaa idiot
Geri cant sing at all
Muhammad nice joke 😂😂😂😂😂
geri was the worst singer in the band. even vicky could sing better. you can see here that she is nervous singing with the best singer of the band mel c.
Listen to this: ruclips.net/video/Zx4c1IzBYaM/видео.html
Geri's rendition of 'Wannabe' is just awesome! A true vocalist voice! In the performance above, she only sings her parts.
RockVeteran that's horrible! ahahahah what's wrong wit U geri fans? ahahah
SailorSpears Nah what's wrong with you 😊?
Vegnis Tengan Nah
Geri has good solo live performances. Spanish: It is the only one of the Spice that has released songs in Spanish like: Mi Chico Latino, the Spanish rap of If U Can`t Dance, Get involved and its part of Seremos 1 los 2.
ruclips.net/video/YH0YIzoBbDM/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BYMkg-LdKcQ/видео.html
Not being funny should of took in turns to sing it. Was kinda pointless getting her up.
Wish Geri had more confidence in her voice it had a real sultry tone like a nun with a past
Geri before she started wearing all white and acting like royalty.
And before you start acting like a total jerk instead of respecting her and never speak of her this way (if you don't like her anymore)
@@gharbimedali5793 I still like her. I'm not disrespecting her, just stating an opinion.
The worst voice of the SG is Geris. Grear personality but voice is a big let down.
Mel cs voice horrible too put on
Bloody terrible.neither of them can sing n did Gerry sing at all.my cat makes a better racket. GOODBYE!!
Pearl Ford go ahead and hop the fuck off this video if you hate SG!😠😠
Mel C can sing Geri can't sing
Who are you to say that Melanie C can't sing.. She's one of the greatest female vocalists of all time and has a huge range and very beautiful, strong and unique voice. The only British female artist who holds the rocord for having most number one singles in Britain with 11. She has won many awards and many other singers say that it's her talent and her persona that is the reason they see themselves in the industry too. MØ, Little Mix, Saara Aalto and many others. 😎
Sorry but Mel c can sing pretty dang well actually.
Still better than the singers we have nowadays.. That’s how bad the music industry is now.. Lol
I love Geri's solo
My favorite part honestly!
Melaniec is great as always
Singing is not natural for everyone, particularly Geri, even if you are good. Some people need more rehearsal time, and warming up to be able to sing properly. Notice how after she got going, it was much better. Of course, Melanie C can sing most things perfectly at the drop of a hat, so I would be intimidated without the other 3 girls between us ahaha.
Very rare to see just the 2 of them together. It’s always Mel C & Emma or Geri & Mel B. Or Mel B & Emma. Or Geri & Emma. Or Victoria & Emma or Mel C & Victoria..
Now is different and also nice
They were actually very close
Melanie was extremely complimentary about Geri in her new autobiography. She barely spoke about any of the others.
Come on Geri ! You have a wonderful voice !
Geri can sing good in live show. But i love her vocal. So uniqe. if her sang or talk. Peopel know voice who? "Geri is mean"
I heard that this song is about a relationship with Geri and some guy I don't remember who but Geri doesn't have any solo in that song.
Not every Spice Girls song is about Geri
Geri was the main writer for this song. She also contributed a lot in Wannabe, Viva Forever, and STOP. I think she contributed by not just her distinct sound, but the lyrics to some of their major hits.
She wrote all their hits.
@@jollyfighter7319ALL the Spice Girls plus some other guys are credited writers in all their songs
Now, we just need the other three.
Damn i miss them so much
Beautiful I love it
why is geri acting braindead for last year or two????? has anything happened? I'm concerned cause she seems scared all the tme
Rafael Henrique like Alzheimer’s or something I agree
@@musicislyfe1672 Maybe something else happened that debilitated her... I don't see the girls forcing her on tour in case she actually had alzheimer.
Rafael Henrique maybe it’s in its very early stages u know?
What kind of sick people here calling Geri debilitated and suffering from Alzheimer disease here??? This is such a vile statement... 😠😠😠😠😠