I went trough the comment section and there are actually quite a few people who would want a bass cover. Perhaps if we upvote those and maybe write Rob a message he'll eventually do it :)
One is one of the best modern songs. It's a masterpiece. Compare it to Mozart, etc. In a few hundred years it will be studied as classical music. I'm saying this, and I'm really not that much of a Metallica fan.
Actually he's only playing Bass Instruments and he has a drum set in the background no biggie, Hardly a Musical Wizard he might be a really good Bassist, i'm not putting the guy down, Im just saying what he did here doesn't constitute wizardary or playing EVERY SINGLE instrument
IcyblueGaming oh...?? i thought you asked because you perceived this guy to be someone who could pick up anything from a guitar to a sax to a piano to an oboe to a violin to a harmonica to a harp or a theramin for that matter and just play anything.
1) Bassened 2) And Justice For Bass 3) Eye of the Bassholder 4) Bass 5) The Shortest Bass 6) Harvester of Bass 7) The Bass Ends of Sanity 8) To Live is to Bass 9) Dyers Bass
In an alternative universe this was the version that was released and a huge endless controversy still rages amongst fans about the lack of rhythm guitars and solos. However, no one is complaining about the lack of drums.
Rob Scallon Hey Rob, thank you for doing this and the Anesthesia upright bass cover. It's really inspiring to see how unbelievably creative your approach to bass is (especially solo), and I really hope to see more of you playing bass in the future. I think "One" was particularly well done, and it could be cool to see a full bass cover of that. Thanks again man, I look forward to see what's next for you.
Rob Scallon Unrelated question, do you still skate around? Haven't seen much blading stuff from your recently, and you are miles ahead of me, so it's fun to watch your sessions. Oh and great work on this vid, the Bass guitar is definitely an unappreciated instrument! :P
I was thinking the same thing and I was gonna put a comment like that But I have good bass ears so doesn't matter in my case So I can hear the bass in and justice for all anyway
Yes, the reason why i love so much Frayed is for the main riff, and is not that simple achieve that fat sound playing it! Just like Unforgiven 2, not that easy but sounds great!
"Frayed..." is one of my favourite Metallica songs. The same with "Dyers Eve". Those tracks are underrated, because they don't play them live. "Frayed..." is too long for them I think and "Dyers Eve" is impossible to play for Lars.
Leaders doesn't want anyone playing better then him or overshadowing him, that's why he turns down the bass so you can't hear it, and turns his drums up so you can only hear him
blackhatch46 There wasn't any drumming, but I get that you meant that the bass as a percussive instrument is better than the drumming in the original recording.
***** I dont think it was referring to the album (which is my favorite Metallica album) as much as it was referring to Lars who is kinda notorious for not being the greatest drummer. I could be wrong though
I would love to hear the entirety of Dyer's Eve! So fucking good!! That said, what an awesome end to May-tallica, thank you for all the great videos! =)
Dude they totally removed jason from the mix just to fuck with him, making the album sound like it's always coming out some crappy laptop speakers - it's not just "missing a little bass".
+nicolhaidi to fuck with him? Couldn't it be that Cliff died a few years prior to this and having the bassist in the track was just "too soon" for them? I understand Bass is vital but personally I think the drums sound amazing in that album so I forget about the bass being low.
Austin Pitts I mean, imagine you've just recorded the best album the band has ever released, put real work into it, and then you go listen to it and find out that all of your tracks are missing. No bass. Personally I'd be pretty fucking pissed. I'm' surprised he didn't leave the band right away
Jebus Thesavior Well Classical music is already amazing enough, but not all pieces need to be "metal'd up" just for the sake of being "metal'd up." However I can understand the fun of it, but that's meant for jams instead of actual videos, live improvisations, or recordings.
Now that I get the joke, this is all the more hilarious, not to mention awesome as hell. Kickass, man. Kickass. \m/ I'd love to see full versions of these songs.
+Gabriel Hole-Jones I heard that supposedly, Lars actually thought the album would have sound "better" with little or no bass. That's why you can't hear the bass line in "One"; they purposely removed it.
I don't want to sound like a Metallica hater, cause i love them (well, Black album and before) seen them live many times, but....you think they would have pussyed out like they did, if Cliff was still alive???
+jorgito93700 however, he was not open to writing music for the industry like metallica did and somewhat does...they would have a much different attitude towards money and their fans if cliff was still alive, and maybe wouldn't have written some of the songs they write if he was still alive
+The_Slayer _Cannibal The only album I can really consider a sellout is the black album.And it's still great for me.Death Magnetic is more a sellout than the load albums for me, because sometimes it felt like they were doing thrash just for doing thrash,at least they tried new things with the loads.
Now play St. Anger with only solos
taxidermy what solos
a little bird exactly
it would sound better than the original :)
Go watch zero Metallica songs in 4 minutes. It has all them
lemsdarkapprentice I don't hate the album.
Jason watched this with a tear in his eye. Well done!
metfan4l whos jason
I found you again lol
metfan4l lmfao
Fade to Lars lol love your username
Atl Fre HE FOCKING LEFT DA BAND!!!
I hope Newsted has seen and heard this
najtrows Jason did awesome things ,that you cant hear it was Lars fault
Yea, I think he meant that he'd be happy to see justice done to the bass
4cMaiden I don’t think he really cares after all these yesrs
Devon Bustard he said he's still excited to see all the "and Justice for Jason" stuff
Gruesome Wolf Gaming I’m actually lost
"One" should be a bass cover by itself
I tries searching for a full all bass cover of One but after like a half hour of searching, nothing.
I would like to hear eye of the beholder on just bass
ruclips.net/video/6sHvUv_w18I/видео.html not the same song, or even rob, but thought I should share this. The dude is incredibly skilled
Cliff could have done it
Look up one by apocalyptica it's a entire cover of one but on cellos
When you mute the video, it sounds like the album!
haha
I get it!
Lol
Yeah i fucking get it mr Arreola
lol
to live is to die is just, perfect
Knight Gash i agree, be great to hear the whole song like that
it was cliff's last work
mauricio reiofmreui yes. We are aware.
mauricio reiofmreui Parts of his work.
@@Superball01 which parts? Lol I'm pretty sure cliff didnt write any of that song
It's official. Bass is now a percussion instrument.
That's what makes bass the best instrument ever
Bass can be everything.
Bass has always been a quasi-percussion instrument. It's a drum with strings.
+Castlemaster712 I have never agreed with anything more.
Fieldy from Korn always knew it
Ok now I want the whole One song played on the bass, gosh it sounds awesome
Same
Same me /so is To live is to die is beautiful as well :) and the whole s*it just AWESOME! :D
+Daniel Dawid Roslan also blackened
I went trough the comment section and there are actually quite a few people who would want a bass cover. Perhaps if we upvote those and maybe write Rob a message he'll eventually do it :)
One is one of the best modern songs. It's a masterpiece. Compare it to Mozart, etc. In a few hundred years it will be studied as classical music. I'm saying this, and I'm really not that much of a Metallica fan.
02:53 It gives me so much chills every time..
I always hear this when i feel that everybody hates me
DethClaw lock Well okay then champ😁
This IS the best part of to live is to die :(, but many ppl don’t think so
@@ladasodaexplains3355 literally everybody knows its the best part
That was excellent Rob. Props for all the time put into this.
Joooosh,you're awesome!!!You two should make a band,guys
Josh Steffen You two should make a collab of some sort :)
That's would be an awesome collaboration!
Brody Clayton I agree, both talented. I would love to see a collab :)
#JoshAndRobProject xD
You need to make a full bass cover of "One". Your version of pretty badass.
+K. J. Allen I totaly agree
+Xtreme GamerZ TR Not really, you can't exactly play it right on a bass anyway. He rewrote it so he could play it.
You can't play that part on a bass. Fret limitations. He rewrote it
+K. J. Allen I second this!
His version was b(ad)ass. Yeah, I'm leaving now.
Listen to it!! It's the only time you will find the Words And Justice for All and Bass together!!!
Lavish Haha lol
Cobain 92
Fun Fact: There is bass in the album. If you listen hard enough to Eye of the Beholder or One you can hear something lower than guitar
your comment now has 666 likes
Actually on RUclips you can look up and justice for Jason and someone re added the bass and it makes all the tracks have more bite and more heavy
James Bassfield - Rhythm Bass
Kirk Basset - Lead Bass
Basson Newbass - Bass
Lars Bassrich - ????
+GrakAttack Lars Bassrich - Double Bass (former)
XD
percussive slap
RIP Cliff Basston
+GrakAttack Bass percussion
Who else wants a full One cover
he did one already
don't you mean a full BASS cover
when it's the only song you know from the album
@@notmozart8866 breh
So...like...are you some sort of musical wizard who can play every single instrument ever?
Damn.
+IcyblueGaming He goes over the question you asked in a video on his second channel.
Actually he's only playing Bass Instruments
and he has a drum set in the background
no biggie, Hardly a Musical Wizard
he might be a really good Bassist, i'm not putting the guy down,
Im just saying
what he did here
doesn't constitute wizardary or playing EVERY SINGLE instrument
Martin Kuliza That's why I asked ;)
IcyblueGaming oh...?? i thought you asked because you perceived this guy to be someone who could pick up anything from a guitar to a sax to a piano to an oboe to a violin to a harmonica to a harp or a theramin for that matter and just play anything.
Any guitarist and bassist could be pretty much a player of any string instrument tbh. (Atleast that's how i see it).
1) Bassened
2) And Justice For Bass
3) Eye of the Bassholder
4) Bass
5) The Shortest Bass
6) Harvester of Bass
7) The Bass Ends of Sanity
8) To Live is to Bass
9) Dyers Bass
lmao
+aLex nEvermiNd no it's bass
Ay, por Dios!!! Jajajajajajaja
To live is to bass
4) Basone? (Basoon???)
+Duesux Machinin Bassoon!
You need to make the One bass cover a separate video
Nick Bacon zf
I'd prefer To Live is To Die,but yeah,agree
Um KillaQueen No eye of the beholder
In an alternative universe this was the version that was released and a huge endless controversy still rages amongst fans about the lack of rhythm guitars and solos. However, no one is complaining about the lack of drums.
That's St. Anger
Happy Maytallica to all!
Here's a playlist of all of them: ruclips.net/p/PLjRyh8JaC_eRBwDExfcN3xUxaT2UiZHiP
Demis Degano
Rob Scallon this is great, man. where does all this gear come from?
Rob Scallon do a cover of Raining Blood on cello
Rob Scallon Hey Rob, thank you for doing this and the Anesthesia upright bass cover. It's really inspiring to see how unbelievably creative your approach to bass is (especially solo), and I really hope to see more of you playing bass in the future. I think "One" was particularly well done, and it could be cool to see a full bass cover of that. Thanks again man, I look forward to see what's next for you.
Rob Scallon Unrelated question, do you still skate around? Haven't seen much blading stuff from your recently, and you are miles ahead of me, so it's fun to watch your sessions.
Oh and great work on this vid, the Bass guitar is definitely an unappreciated instrument! :P
Still can't hear the bass.
EliPorterMahn you must be deaf then, I'm sorry
He's joking. Also, if he seriously couldn't hear the bass, he would probably have shitty headphones, not be deaf lol.
@@thesmiteguy7619 bro, there was only bass, he would of been more than deaf If he didn't hear it
@@vidiac2012 r/wooosh
Are you idiot?
If Lars mixed this video it would be silent.
Roddor thank god Fluff did it
0:45 Why did you include the snare from St. Anger?
Rough😂
savage
Not snare, trash can
Bass 'Em All
Ride the Bass
Master of Bass
And Justice For Bass
The Bass Album
Bass
Re-Bass
St-Bass
Bass Magnetic
Just wanted an excuse to do that.
Hardwired To Self-Bass
Lulu :^)
Hard wired to bass
Bass inc
S & B(ass)
Live Bass: Binge and Purge
exact opposite of the original album. and I love it
Please make a video of full To Live is To Die song on bass...that just sounded amazing!
2:00 I’m in love with that cello and upright bass
Wow for once you can actually hear the bass from that album
that is the joke yes
I was thinking the same thing and I was gonna put a comment like that
But I have good bass ears so doesn't matter in my case
So I can hear the bass in and justice for all anyway
+ColdfacekillerJr PSN uh huh.... Sure you can...
Come over my place so I can give you my ears and you'll see.... Um hear?
kylethetoybox i can hear it too...
You should make a song that is like off time, with drum fills where they dont go, or bad timing, or random solos but try to make it cool idk
slorr55 metallica shreds one! searcj this : Metallica Shreds, resurrected
slorr55 Isn't that called progressive? :^)
The Vengeful Many or psychodelic
Frownland- Captain Beefheart
+FlyingDonutz Laughed hard.
Frayed is the most underrated song in Metallica history.
Great video as always btw!
Meh, It is super underrated but I somehow feel like Trapped Under Ice, Bleeding me or even Dyers Eve is just as underrated.
I feel that the unforgiven 2 and 3 are very underrated
Yes, the reason why i love so much Frayed is for the main riff, and is not that simple achieve that fat sound playing it!
Just like Unforgiven 2, not that easy but sounds great!
"Frayed..." is one of my favourite Metallica songs. The same with "Dyers Eve". Those tracks are underrated, because they don't play them live. "Frayed..." is too long for them I think and "Dyers Eve" is impossible to play for Lars.
And they could play Master of Puppets? That song's longer than Frayed Ends of Sanity!
Damn. Lars would hate this.
I don't think current Lars would, but maybe?
Nah,becus its not jason playing it
Leaders doesn't want anyone playing better then him or overshadowing him, that's why he turns down the bass so you can't hear it, and turns his drums up so you can only hear him
0/10 couldnt hear the bass
Grimroll bass...
Grimr
There was a bass? I thought it was a symphonic guitar with a bass skin.
are you guys dumb there ia bass in it obviously how dumb can you be to think these are guitars
@@JaellesDrums r/wooosh
1:22 After years. Still Loving that smooth bass playing for "One".
Truly amazing. Thanks a lot
4th Anniversary of video fun fact:
The 'cello' sound from To Live interlude is actually Jason's bass with a swell effect.
I love listening to the opening riffs of the title track, One and To Live Is To Die on bass, it sounds so relaxing
This would piss Lars off so much.
Everything pisses him off
at least Jason is happy
I don't care as long as Jason's happy.
@@larsswig912 yeah but he never recorded the bass ...and justice for all
@@tzctlpc he did tho..? what are you smoking?
I'd love to hear a full version of One like this; the bit you played was fucking beautiful.
Dude you're incredibly talented
This video got me into Metallica about one year ago and I still love it. Thanks and keep up maytallica and all your other great content.
i Want "ride the bass" or "Master of bass"
+Matías Navarrete bass em all
+Артем Бирюков bass magnetic
Bassalika
+Артем Бирюков megabass
+Артем Бирюков rust in bass
Can we get a full bass cover for one?
I would like more To Live Is To Die to be honest,it was perfect on bass
your playing is just great. you are definately kick ass, rob.
you are also a lot younger than me too. you are kicking ass on bass the way i wanted to but couldnt match it if i tried. its just great to hear.
Request for 2016: MAYGADETH
Iron Mayden
Slmayer?
+SaturnValleyGamer You tried
+metalmusician6798 Maynthranx?
+metalmusician6798 May'OWar
drumming is much better than the original.
blackhatch46 There wasn't any drumming, but I get that you meant that the bass as a percussive instrument is better than the drumming in the original recording.
So why even comment? that what clearly a Lars joke. Either you missed it completely or you just yearn to correct people. Either way you're an idiot.
blackhatch46 Just tired. I just got the joke now. My bad man. It happens. I'm usually brighter than this.
***** Here comes the flaame waars!
***** I dont think it was referring to the album (which is my favorite Metallica album) as much as it was referring to Lars who is kinda notorious for not being the greatest drummer. I could be wrong though
Acoustic Part from "to live is to die " Played on Bass..... Just beautiful!!! Great transition of a song! Really Great!!!
omg! that bass cover of "one " tho😢!!!
NOW I WANNA FULL COVER, THAT WAS TO BEAUTIFUL NOT TO😢😢!!!
Metal mad libs!! Please
Marco Antonio coming up :)
Mateusz Daniel why not both? :)))
Mateusz Daniel that one too :)
Rob Scallon Musical metal mad libs! Just saying
Rob Scallon FASTAAA!!!)))
The "...and Justice for All" one is BEAUTIFUL! Good work Rob
Best Metallica album there is
So you using bass kapoo from guitar centre?
To Live Is To Die's interlude is still one of the most beautiful pieces of metal music ever written!!! Well done Rob!
That was TOO clean !!! Nailed it !!!
+bakerXderek cheeeah!!
Still better drumming that Lars.
BURN
No, Lars is decent
exactly, you don't just be decent in a band like metallica
Mouaz Chikhani even Kirk admitted they're decent musicians
The hate on Lars needs to stop.
is this the reason that I admire all your work
cheers Rob!
now do St. Anger all on a good drum kit
u can`t!!!
I would love to hear the entirety of Dyer's Eve! So fucking good!!
That said, what an awesome end to May-tallica, thank you for all the great videos! =)
wow ... you did an amazing job ... so cool to see all the different concepts ... come to fruition ... and still sound amazing
Scallon and Trujilo have same name - Rob. Coincidence??I dont think so...
True
*x-files theme plays in the background*
VladGoro25 Ron McGovney is crying.
Am I the only one who thought of Peladophobian after reading the words : "Coincidence? I don't think so" ??? xd
Tiger Blake Hahahaha! No, you're not the only one. :P
Make an acoustic version of In Your Words by LOG! :D
I second this movement! That would be SO AMAZING
But Maytallica though
You sir deserve more upvotes!
It just needs to happen, no exceptions.
PLEASE!!
bro you just make me so happy. bcoz i have so much memories with these songs
Most excellent!!!
omfg I need that 5 string now
To live is to die gave me chills
AJFA is my favorite album. I don't understand the hate for it just because it's missing a little bass.
It isn't what it could have been. The bass is very important, especially in Metallica. Pre ajfa of course. It's a shame really.
Dude they totally removed jason from the mix just to fuck with him, making the album sound like it's always coming out some crappy laptop speakers - it's not just "missing a little bass".
+nicolhaidi to fuck with him? Couldn't it be that Cliff died a few years prior to this and having the bassist in the track was just "too soon" for them? I understand Bass is vital but personally I think the drums sound amazing in that album so I forget about the bass being low.
Austin Pitts yep, that was one of the (stupid) reasons they were fucking with Jason. They never really stopped doing it, until he finally left.
Austin Pitts I mean, imagine you've just recorded the best album the band has ever released, put real work into it, and then you go listen to it and find out that all of your tracks are missing. No bass. Personally I'd be pretty fucking pissed. I'm' surprised he didn't leave the band right away
You should write up a few more bass covers or original tracks! As a bassist, it's always cool to see unique ways of using the instrument :)
I can't stop listening to this. It sounds so great.
Awesome :D Rob, Have you considered making a metal version of classical music?
oh mother of god Rob!
Prokofiev - Dance of Knights
i'm sure Rob would handle this piece of art well :)
19ThreeLions97 Yeah!! but I was thinking of something like Bourree by Bach xD
Jebus Thesavior Well Classical music is already amazing enough, but not all pieces need to be "metal'd up" just for the sake of being "metal'd up." However I can understand the fun of it, but that's meant for jams instead of actual videos, live improvisations, or recordings.
Rhapsody in blue.
Fuege in D minor?
Hammer Smashed Face by Cannibal Corpse on the Upright bass.
Your intonation on Eye of the Beholder was all over the place. Still loved this!
the bass at 0:11 sounds like squidward walking
Rob the 'to live is to die' in this is amazing. Do you think you could do a full version of it?
PLEASE YES
dude. that solo from TO LIVE IS TO DIE was absolutely beautiful. freaking awesome
By far the best Metallica album.
how you haven't broken the internet by now is beyond me. Must be broken.... oh wait
Now that I get the joke, this is all the more hilarious, not to mention awesome as hell. Kickass, man. Kickass. \m/ I'd love to see full versions of these songs.
OH I GET IT
Because the AJFA Album has no bass!
See, rebecca bunny flower , my idea for all mono-instrument covers of metal songs wasn't mad, just ahead of its time!
Yes!!
That totally kicked ass! Way to go Rob!
Please do some Maygadeth
Iron mayden?
patrick cruz Megaydeth
PS: I like Megadeth, it's only a joke
I would love to hear some "May"hem
manuwar88 I thougt the same lol
patrick cruz Metadeth?
The Eye Of The Beholder sounded like an Techno Song 😂
The start sounded like a techno version of seven nation army
@@tzctlpc
Petition to get techno to use this in his lore streams
Justice is my favourite album and this legit brought a tear to my eye
I actually prefer the bass version of Eye of the beholder.
MASTER OF BASS would be cool
This album sounds great when you put the bass back into it. The "...and Justice for Jason" remix is fantastic.
What about Toxicity (all the album) in bass?
+Nico Orfa I like this idea. A lot.
it funny because he plays only bass an album that was impossible to hear it......
+elmaga791 That's the joke...
There were no bass line in ...And Justice For All, search up some videos (sorry if I said that like a dick).
Ryan Farkas No, there is bass, it's just been mixed to practical silence.
+Gabriel Hole-Jones I heard that supposedly, Lars actually thought the album would have sound "better" with little or no bass. That's why you can't hear the bass line in "One"; they purposely removed it.
+Charlie Chaplin One more thing Lars ruined.
Great work, It’s quite apparent that you worked very hard on this.
Not enough To Live Is To Die.
Jason Newsted: *Sweating and heavy breathing*
i wish you did a fully bass cover of one of their songs, its so calming and perfect study music/mood!
hahahahah
Jason Newsted will be proud of this
was anybody else waiting for shit to hit the fan once he started dyers eve? lol
Dude I wanted to hear it so bad
I love your Gold Bass, it's so beautiful!
rob: *making this video*
davie504: NOT ENOUGH BASS
I don't want to sound like a Metallica hater, cause i love them (well, Black album and before) seen them live many times, but....you think they would have pussyed out like they did, if Cliff was still alive???
Cliff was very open to other styles of music,so it would have happened with him too I think.Maybe even faster
+jorgito93700 however, he was not open to writing music for the industry like metallica did and somewhat does...they would have a much different attitude towards money and their fans if cliff was still alive, and maybe wouldn't have written some of the songs they write if he was still alive
+The_Slayer _Cannibal I don't know, he liked mainstream Rock too
jorgito93700 true, but he liked writing music for himself, not for sales
+The_Slayer _Cannibal The only album I can really consider a sellout is the black album.And it's still great for me.Death Magnetic is more a sellout than the load albums for me, because sometimes it felt like they were doing thrash just for doing thrash,at least they tried new things with the loads.
I have a guitar sheet music book of all this whole album, it’s awesome
... And Justice For Jason Newsted
and justice for jason!
Love seeing To Live Is To Die getting some love, always thought that was an incredible song.
Actual drum kit not needed because Lars Ulrich
Newsted would be proud.. xD