Good topic.. "Historian and his facts, not the facts".. I thought that the history is about the facts. But never thought about the subjectivity. Thanks a lot.
The book is so interesting and the basis of my study. Am a Masters of Education student at Makerere University, majoring in history Education. Thank you
Yes, it's a great book. Wish you the best of luck with your study. There will be a new version of an EH Carr video up soon. If you have any questions, feel free to get in touch.
I've done chapters 1-3. Chapter 2 (Society and the Individual): ruclips.net/video/b5SeSPYgu1A/видео.html Chapter 3 (History, Science, and Morality): ruclips.net/video/pfENENc0G0U/видео.html They are both on my channel if those links don't work.
@@muhammadikramtheoceanofwis8116 Very interesting subject and question, but I don't think I've covered that in a recorded lecture yet. Maybe I'll do it soon.
Thank you for this interesting lecture Sir. I must say Carr criticise himself in the first chapter, as we read first he says the facts are "alike a fish on a fishmonger's slab and historian takes home and cooks according to his taste". But later on somewhere he says " the historians sunk in the deep ocean and collect the fish (facts) according to his needs"?. Your views on this, please. Once again thanking you, for this lecture!
Thank you for the comment. I will consider it if I have time. I have chapters 1, 2, and 3 on my channel. Please let me know if there's another specific chapter you require.
@@nurulahmad7340 I don't have any plans to do it at the moment as I'm working on another project but I'll try and do it at some point for you. If you have any questions about it, do let me know.
I am a Gambian history student... This is one of the thrilling topics I read about EH Carl. Thank you Sir
Thank you for saying so. I'm glad the information was useful. Perhaps you can apply the ideas to Gambian history and teach us about that one day?
@@DavidTizzard You're most welcome. Yeah, his ideas are applicable here as well. We shall share
@@Nepta12 Great. Looking forward to it!
Good topic.. "Historian and his facts, not the facts".. I thought that the history is about the facts. But never thought about the subjectivity. Thanks a lot.
E.H. Carr does some really great stuff. I think a lot of his ideas would have been evident in the talk I gave in Gwangju.
The book is so interesting and the basis of my study.
Am a Masters of Education student at Makerere University, majoring in history Education.
Thank you
Yes, it's a great book. Wish you the best of luck with your study. There will be a new version of an EH Carr video up soon. If you have any questions, feel free to get in touch.
It was a nice touch (at 1:09:00) to compare Collingwood's philosophy of history to method acting.
Thank you - not sure where it came from but it seemed appropriate at the time haha
sir if you could upload the rest of the chapters! please
I've done chapters 1-3.
Chapter 2 (Society and the Individual): ruclips.net/video/b5SeSPYgu1A/видео.html
Chapter 3 (History, Science, and Morality): ruclips.net/video/pfENENc0G0U/видео.html
They are both on my channel if those links don't work.
great lecture Sir
Thank you for saying so.
@@DavidTizzard please send me your whatsapp number, i am student of PhD
@@muhammadikramtheoceanofwis8116 If you have a question, you can ask me here
@@DavidTizzard please if you mention me in your lecture regarding varying concepts of history through the ages. If you have it. Thanks
@@muhammadikramtheoceanofwis8116 Very interesting subject and question, but I don't think I've covered that in a recorded lecture yet. Maybe I'll do it soon.
Thank you for this interesting lecture Sir.
I must say Carr criticise himself in the first chapter, as we read first he says the facts are "alike a fish on a fishmonger's slab and historian takes home and cooks according to his taste". But later on somewhere he says " the historians sunk in the deep ocean and collect the fish (facts) according to his needs"?. Your views on this, please.
Once again thanking you, for this lecture!
Great lecture. Thanks a lot.
U can also upload rest of the chapters
Thank you for the comment. I will consider it if I have time. I have chapters 1, 2, and 3 on my channel. Please let me know if there's another specific chapter you require.
@@DavidTizzard I need chapter 5 sir...
@@nurulahmad7340 I don't have any plans to do it at the moment as I'm working on another project but I'll try and do it at some point for you. If you have any questions about it, do let me know.
Sir can u upload chapter 4,5&6?if possible 🙏
Thank you for the interest. I will try to do a whole series of them when I get time. One for each chapter.
@@DavidTizzard thank u so much sir☺️
Thank you
You're welcome!