Breaking news: Zelensky will receive the Nobel Prize in physics for this year. He and his generals staff managed to invent a new kind of quantum entity called Schrödinger's Offensive. The offensive is successful and failure at the same time, since the result of its fate is linked to a random subatomic event that may or may not occur in our hearts.
I had the imprudence to write about the “Schrödinger counter-offensive” at the beginning of summer on Denis Davydov’s channel. Without overwhelming air and artillery superiority, the superposition of success will depend on the state/presence of the MSM observer and can be both a successful defeat and an unsuccessful victory. His admirers threw me under the bus. 🤣 And they still see the success of the offensive.
The Russian tank got a scratch. Oryx: This is a destroyed tank and has no turret. The western tank threw back the turret. Oryx: This is not a loss, it will be returned and this scratch will be repaired. Kim's propaganda applauds 👏
Problem is, Oryx reports the truth about the loser Russian troops who can’t win a war because of their incompetence! But Russian shills are to stupid, typical Russian mindset
@@watershedmetal2 2022: Western tanks are a game changer. They are designed to resist Soviet weapons. 2023: Anyone else remember what an unexploded Leopard and Bradley look like?😝😝
History legend failed in history , many times when he talked about history was a mess except few popular stories, and now the same person talks about current events ,
How to achieve success in offensive: Step1 announce publicly where exactly you going to attack Step 2 wait 6 month for your enemy to build fortifications Step 3 attack exactly where you announced you going to attack Step 4... Step 5 Profit
From how it looks to me, this whole war is being used by NATO as an oppertunity to deplete Russia by sacrificing Ukrainians. The EU and NATO both only seem to be giving them enough to keep fighting, but never enough to acually achieve some sort of "victory". Not to mention they wont give them weapons without promises they wont use them outside of Ukraine... So basically, only if they are using to blow up their own cities and infrastructure...
Two Russian solders are sitting in a Kiev cafe, drinking coffee, while a column of Russian tanks is “parked” nearby. Army convoys are passing by. And one of them says to another: - I regret one thing - we lost the information war.
Just seeing the tired soldiers at 17:46 really hits you with the reality of war. One moment you are chilling and the next your life is gone in blink of an eye. Often numbers don’t leave that much of an impact until you actually see the faces of soldiers and the destruction up close. Most likely none of them survived. RIP
Недавно появилось видео где солдат сбивает три fpv дрона подряд, он настолько отчаялся в конце, что вылез сбить дрон прикладом автомата. Можно отдать должное украинцам хоть они и враги для нас. Но в целом героизм на войне, это дебилизм в тылу
It's wild that this goofy educated dude who's always cracking jokes is a more honest and serious analyst than the 99% of Western commentators who have just gone completely off the deep end and lost all touch with reality
The NAFO are claiming that the offensive is a huge success because they dealt massive casualties to Russia and are averaging kia's of 10 Russians killed per NAFO soldier lost
Yeah. It's like mainstream analyst from Wall Street commenting Tesla vs several youtubers -> the first ones were all wrong with their predictions about imminent failure Tesla, while the second ones were all correct and they offer so much better, really convincing arguments based on pure comoon sense, although they haven't graduated from Ivy League universities.
I think only realistic people thought and knew that eventually russia will prevail. Russia has so much more capital, resources, manpower, technology etc. Then ukraine ever could dream of having.
This offensive was the first offensive that had a trailer and the Ukrainian leadership was the first one to announce the time and place of their offensive
this is because England is an ally and prevented peace from happening. but at least boris johnson taught the Ukrainians how to battle british style. be a sportsman, announce you intentions and fight „fair“. no secrecy, no hidden movements, no surprises: „lets meet on the battlefield over there in… lets say.. spring?“ if i am late, let’s battle in summer, I‘ll bring some Leopard tanks, maybe Abrams… prepare… it’s going to be fun!“
We live in a time and era where you a well aware of your enemies intentions before they do it. Ukraine might not have said anything and Russia would still have known that Ukraine was bulking up troops in a certain region and what potnetial targets they were going to go after.
@@GrayD1ce Well UK doesn't really tell where D-Day would start or land and if they do they just tell lie or misinformation like they says they going land on south of France or on Normandy while in reality much further away than Nazi can predict
The summer offensive, followed by the fall offensive, followed by the winter offensive. Senator Graham should be proud. A never ending war of attrition.
@@jamesryan4325 These corporates puppets, aka politicians need a massive event so they can let their bad bets with the economy have a scape goat when Greater Depression part 2 releases world wide.
"Military experts" have recently explained at length in the western media that Ukraine's attrition combat technics are far superior to NATO/US combined arms tactics. That all the mistakes in the war were due to American lack of understanding of how to properly fight a war like this and giving their crazy ideas to poor Ukrainian soldiers.
I have always been surprised by NATO training standards that NATO has ever stormed at all, except for the villages of shepherds who are armed with rusty machine guns, what their instructors could teach them if they have no idea what an assault on the defense line is, I think any Ukrainian veteran who has been fighting since the beginning of this war would teach them much better
Well, that's pretty much how West fights - shoot and bomb everything to dust, sent in other to mop up. No need to do meet grinder. West has been trying to get out of attritional warfare - read up "Muscle Bound Superpower".
@@janw839 When you have nothing to answer in essence, always move the conversation to another topic. The theme “Russia is evil” or “everything is even worse in Russia” is perfectly suitable in any situation :) Aren't you tired of it yet?..
@@РусланМетелкин-л2к I didn't see a serious comment anywhere, so what? NATO training doesn't have to be bad, just because an experienced fighter in ukraine has more experience and could add important knowledge. 🤷♂️ Absolutely nothing is preventing the further education by a ukrainian veteran. So the comments here are nothing but a joke.
It shouldn't be even called a "counteroffensive" in the first place because it doesn't really fit the definition of one. That should have been our first clue about competence of Ukrainian and NATO planners.
Remember how they announced it? I'm sorry for Elensky, things could turn different if he whore the same glasses his sugar daddy wears. I forgot the name, they are normally related to the military, war, death.
I love how before they called russia "military failure" and didnt manage to do anything. WHILE WITH HELP OF ALL WESTERN COUNTRY'S ukraine didnt even do 1% of what russia acheived 💀💀😂😂😂
You have to see the mercenaries who left the front because of "atrocities" which is soldiers sadly being hit by mines. When even a mercenary isn't ready for combat from the west, how will the average Joe as a conscript do?
To sum up: > 4 months. > One village half-captured. > More than 90,000 KIA AFU troops. > Frontline hasn't changed. > First line of defense hasn't been reached. The power of NATO.
@@andrewrogers3067 nato soldiers disguised as volunteers have been present ( volunteers and mercenaries speaking English and various languages been getting scouted lately ) They been getting prepared for major super large offensive and it failed
@@andrewrogers3067 NATO supplies the weapons, the ammo, the training, the intel, the finances, the vehicles. The only thing it doesn't supply is the manpower. Which is only a technicality at this point given Ukraine's desire to join NATO.
Russia in 4 months: 100K KIA , zero villages taken, 3 Su-34/35 shot down by friendly fire, Black Sea Fleet tactical retreat. New army rushed to the front without proper training. We are winning truzt ze planzzz
I identify as a Ukrainian advance troop squad. So far I have advanced 1000km, and Moscow told me it's ready to surrender to the rainbow brigade. Pronouns unite!
So, let's summarize: In Severodonetsk, Ukrainian forces found themselves stuck in a cauldron with a tiny exit, constantly bombarded by Russia with all types of weapons. They had the brilliant idea to send in units to hold the territory, and predictably, these units lost half of their men just getting to their positions, got hammered at those positions, couldn't be properly resupplied, and had to rotate out, taking casualties in the process. To add to the hilarity, they then filled the unit with conscripts who had less than a week of training and repeated the same routine. Then, in Bakhmut, Ukraine experienced déjà vu, as they once again ended up in a cauldron with a tiny exit, enduring a relentless assault from Russian forces. Of course, they repeated the same hilarious routine-sending troops, who predictably got annihilated both on their way to the positions and while at the positions. Proper resupply remained elusive, and they had to retreat, taking even more casualties. Now, in the grand finale, Ukraine is stuck in yet another cauldron with a tiny exit, as Russian forces continue their non-stop bombardment. They've decided to keep the humor alive by desperately throwing in unit after unit, resulting in casualties on the way to their positions and even at the positions themselves. Facing challenges in proper resupply, they're forced to retreat, taking even more casualties. What an absolutely side-splitting use of my tax money and Ukrainian lives, isn't it? xDD
To be a competent military historian and geopolitical commentator is one thing ... but to also be this funny, entertaining and captivating just puts you in a league of your own. Hats off to you sir!
bro, this rethoric you can turn around and its exactly as real. both sides are just idiotic. most idiotic is europe. letting talked into to mutch shit fro the US, altough russia is our next neigbour not US...
And may the crocks that planned and backed this nonsense live eternally in their master Satan home. Victoria Nudelman will eternally vomit the victim's blood. She will probably enjoy it for a while but after that she will implore the Lord for redemption, too late Vicky, too late. Madeleine Albright is waiting for you in Satan's kingdom.
@@ivan200804Lvov Kiev are Natzee infested. Western Ukraine should be split up by Poland, Hungary, Romania, whoever has a historical claim before the invention of "the borderland". Take Odessa up to Transnistria, and the ethnic Russian speaking population will be liberated from the UkNATOstan Banderarites.
It's just sad that this has become a bit of a mouthpiece for Russia. It's easily discredited in the obvious rationalisation that we all knew failure was a possibility because Ukraine is a much smaller country fighting a much bigger neighbouring country that continually escalated the conflict with fresh recruits, constants budgetary increases etc. The truth is that any success is proof that they have the ability to hurt and stop Russia. Lets be honest, this war started with Russia thinking they could conquer all of Ukraine in a few days and are now here several years later, that's a monumentally larger failure no? Now Ukraine is hitting back, regardless of the speed they are accepting this is a necessity and a constant war to defend their own territory based on repeated Russian aggression. The real question is how long can Russia fall behind economically compared to the rest of the world? Between the decline in the ruble, sanctions, international isolation and constant spending on war there is no real victory in sight for Russia. Every day they spend in Ukraine is a prolonging of the bleeding of their own economy. They may be able to weather it on the surface but the long term damage to their economy compared to where it could have been is going to be utterly ridiculous. It's not just economy either, how many tanks, ships, ammunition, equipment and soldiers have we seen Russia lose? Hell, it's a damaging war for both sides but Russia will not be the power it wished to be for a god damn long time now. Europe and Nato are so unafraid that they keep to their own sides and just carry on as normal, for us Europeans it's just background noise now sadly. I wish the Ukrainians the best but sad to see this youtuber be a bit too pro russian in this case and lose perspective of how badly Russia failed in it's entire goals. That comparison would put a delayed spring offensive into perspective.
Don't cancel. When Putin has it, he will improve it, just as he did with Crimea. Crimea was a shithole before Russia took over. Ask those Crimeans if they want Ukraine back in charge. They don't.
@@Salabar_ Energy costs went already down by at least 30%. Not sure if the US is a safe choice though, you either pay energy costs in Europe or get looted by some mob in the US 🤷
@@subflexsubflex8878 I'd say the biggest problem are the media. From the messages we are getting one would expect the war is almost over, it's just this small little bit help they need. Like they almost have the win in their pockets, but it all depends on this equipment they need. And then another, and another 🤷 Ukraine is clearly loosing the war, but you don't hear that anywhere, so people just think we are doing the right thing.
I mean, what did they expect rejecting negotiations and getting into a war of attrition with us. A war of attrition vs Russia is literally unwinnable, and Zelensky should've knew that back in spring 2022
Zelecocainsky doesn't give a flying f for AFU cannon fodder. Butcher of Kiev just sells ukrainian blood and meat, exchanging them for U.S. $$$ From a failed clown/comedian to a billionaire.
I want to take a time to show my condolences to those men and women that have lost their lives in this conflict that started in 2014 and have just increased in human suffering since then, no matter if you're pro-Ukraine, or pro-russian as me war it's just the result of human inability for mutual understanding. God bless you all and forgive us for our mistakes in life.
This isn't due to mutual misunderstanding. This started due to thirst for a war so the military-industrial complex can earn billions, just like big farma did cause of covid.
17:46 You know the situation in the front is super duper bad when your troops don't even care anymore and just accept their death so willingly with a blank and tired expression.
A couple weeks ago, NATO head Stoltenberg was answering questions in the EU Parliament. Clare Daly mentioned to him a "half a million dead" in Ukraine. And he did not contest it. If we take BBC´s and Mediazona numbers, that point to 33k russian dead (plus the 15k Wagner dead) then the russians have lost around 50k dead. This means that NATO already knows that Ukraine suffered upwards of 450k DEAD! This is more than the US lost in WW2, or the british lost, in that same war! This isn´t just disastrous, this is slaughter of epic proportions. For over a year Ukraine has been constantly attacking a dug in force, that has a 10 to 1 artillery advantage. It is just insane how anyone could expect any other result!! Ukraine is now conscripting women, young boys, and sick men! This is a throwback to Germany 1945, and no one seems to care! And yet Zelensky is sight seeing throughout Europe and America, like a tourist with a tin cup begging for more warm bodies to throw at this slaughter...
I have a friend from Cuba who is fighting for Russia. And he says that every day in Zaporozhye up to 30-50 Ukrainian soldiers surrender themselves to the Russians through a special connection.🤷
Российская армия создала для них специальную частоту, на которой можно выйти в эфир и запросить сдачу в плен. Загугли 149.200 Волга. Российской армии не нужны лишние жизни Украинцев, мы все равно их считаем братьями.
30-50 Smart Ukrainians. They can peacefully work in Siberian prisons until the war is over. Better to work in labour camps, instead of getting shattered by artillery fire.
In fact, this area near Rabotino is not oversaturated with soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. This is not Bakhmut before his fall. It's a flat field, as you can see in the video. There are no natural shelters on it. There are hills there, but they remain behind the Russian army. The ridge of hills with the first line of defense was overcome only in one place. In the direction of the Verbovogo. If you look at the elevation map, you will see the gap between the hills. And to climb into this gap was simply suicide. But we are dealing with an army that sends its special forces units to Crimea by boat for the sake of a photo of the Ukrainian flag on the Crimean beach. Knowing that these detachments will be destroyed in the Crimea or if they try to return. For them, the preferred tactic is to fall into an obvious trap. On a flat field, any accumulation of APU is visible, and it is immediately destroyed. The area near Rabotino is not oversaturated with soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, if we are not talking about their corpses. What can be said about the villages occupied by the APU during the counteroffensive. The APU aspired there, thinking that the villages would become fortifications for them. Theoretically, you can also hide in bomb craters. But it doesn't help much from new bombs. They put mines there so they won't be kicked out. Those who plant mines die under artillery fire. A new unit of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is being sent there, and it is being blown up by these mines. And the artillery is working on them again. The good safety of armored vehicles in some units of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is also explained by the fact that they quickly realized that it was useless to send armored vehicles there. The fact is that sending soldiers there without armored vehicles is all the more useless. They refuse to understand until now. It will be one of those places where at every step you stumble upon human bones.
That last few sentences about armored vehicles tells me you know nothing about actual tactics. Like you got ammo to actually say some factual stuff to hype up RU's campaign but then you throw some dumbass incorrect opinions in there like its reality. If your factual people might believe you and your daddy putin might pay you more.
@@schmidcl77the Germans don't know where and when the allies would land, and the allies are launching grand deception campaign to ensure it These mf make a trailer video about it, every media knows where they would attack, every media knows with what weapons they would attack, and they launch no deception campaign whatsoever
As a former soldier in the Canadian military I cringe at what the Ukrainian front line troops are going through. Absolute Exhaustion. I recall getting back to Canada after a much less stressful deployment and just wanting to curl up on my boyhood bed and sleep forever. There I was a captain, being served soup in bed by my mother.
Dont trust this guys channel. He is a pure propagandist for Russia. As much as you should not trust the other side, this one is also filled with nonsense.
Who would have thought that tanks designed to be protected mostly from the front wouldn't be well equiped to deal with a constant aerial threat given the US has maintained air superiority in every conflict since WW1
The failed mortain german counter offensive in the summer of 1944 is the classic example of what happens when you launch an armoured assault without air superiority. Literally the same thing happened here at zaporizhzhia.
This is far more stupidier in fact. They did not have air superirity but neither artillery superority. And they attacked at the easy to guess points that the russians have mostly fortified. We even see now that the russinas are evn gaining the FPV drone superirity that was supposed to be ukrainian secret weapon. And the UMPK are raining while the JDAMs are not. And the long range Tornado/Smerch strike seems now more common that HIMARS strikes. HIMARS seems to be hidden so far from the front that they usually barely strike 10 km behind the front ...
you did expect a lot.... Dont lie. But i knew it was going to be a total failure. the real thing about this war is that it will last quite long, and Ukraine might lose all of its land depending on its manpower and military aid.
I have say I expected it to have a lot more impact especially after how throughout the first half of the year msm downplayed the effectiveness of the Russian defences against western military equipment. I still expected them to fail … but not to fail this badly.
They do but the order to retake Ukraine at all costs came from the families. If you recall, Rothschild family members made speeches throughout western parliaments on how important it was to not let Ukraine fall into Russian hands. They will surely escalate and reinitiate the war when they feel they are ready.
they do understand it. But the reason NATO doesnt like an attrtion warfare is because they had had strong german Influence along second half of 20 century, and if i remember well, germany did poorly in both world wars because of Attrition, while Russia was at a better position during USSR.
За 4 месяца украинцы так и не смогли не то что прорвать, но даже подойти к первой линии обороны русских. Всё, что им удалось - это ценой огромных потерь преодолеть предполье и прочно засесть в огневые мешки, которые для них приготовили русские. На карте (особенно в Работино) прекрасно видно, что украинцы заходили в мешок и их с 3 сторон уничтожали авиацией, артиллерией, минами, ПТУРами и РСЗО. Умный человек вышел бы из этих мешков и избрал бы другую тактику и остановил бы этот конвейер смерти. Но постоянно в течение этих месяцев в огневые ловушки гнали всё новые и новые партии украинского пушечного мяса. В результате оказалось, что жизнь одного украинца была нужна, чтобы захватить 0,38 квадратных метра. Это более чем в 5 раз меньше площади среднестатистической могилы.
That's the crazy part of it it was clear by end of August that it would be near to impossible to breakthrough yet the clung to the hope of the Russians panicking and running away. When that didn't happen all hell broke loose and the Ukrainians found themselves locked into a bigger political battle than Bakhmut.
@@asavelakuse6865тогда вряд ли стоит вести беседу с тем, кто не умеет пользоваться сервисом перевода. Это абсолютно несложно и доступно любому человеку.
As an American, I’m so sorry for my country’s involvement in this disastrous war. Heartbreaking for Ukraine and for Russia. My own senator who I can’t stand is one of the evil mind’s responsible for this war. Lindsey Graham will be judged one day for all the Ukraine and Russians who have been killed.
The United States has the largest military budget and a very low standard of living. If money had been spent on schools and hospitals, and not on war, life would have changed a lot.
I know its morally wrong especially with all the death and suffering in Ukraine. But I'm glad I got my 600$ from the bet my friend and I made in late May he said by October 1st Ukraine would hold all its strategic objectives and push the Russian Army back across Crimea. To really dig in the wound I said lets wait another 5 days, by the 6th he looked so miserable. And its all thanks to History Legends, thanks for the 600$ man~
Robotyno is not even village. It's just very small settlement. Around 500 people lived there before the war. All of them left that place before actual fighting started there.
Its the terrain that matters. The important parts of Rabotino are still under Russian control. Thus the only area Russians allowed their enemy are the open areas. While the buildings within the hamlet itself are overlooked by sheer cliff. To hold this meager defensive position it required constant commitment of personnel from Ukraine creating a killing field. If Ukrainians actually took the whole province then Robotino would have been a very strategic victory thus it was important! However we can see they failed to capture this high ground and so the capture of the hamlet itself indeed seems as irrelevant as you say. Simply put it would matter but even in Robotino they failed the objective.
I'm not sure how accurate that 500 figure is considering that Ukraine was gradually being depopulated for decades before this conflict and little hamlets like that were probably hit the hardest due to all the young people gravitating towards larger urban centers. It might've only had a couple hundred pensioners residing there full-time by 2022.
@@Robert-hy3vv because Russia dug in, a lot, for the glorious ukrainian counteroffensive. Ukraine kept sending troops and equipment to die so Russia just held their positions
I can't disagree more, no focus on Russian losses.....and no clear understanding and explaining of what has happened. Sry but it just sounds like blaming Ukrainen for having casualties, without looking on Russian casualties. If we don't know how Manny Ukraine losses had compared too the Russians losses. How can you conclude it has completely failed?
Ukraine is winning so they started to design body armor/plate carriers for pregnant women. How inclusive of them! They're surely winning, they deal so much damage to Russia that they now can safely send pregnant women to the front lines. So brave in my opinion 🥰
it actually went through the first line while russias largest push in a few months ended with over 60+ destroyed vehicles (with pictures and photo evidence) in one section alone
This is what happens when you announce to the whole world that you're gonna conduct an offensive,moths in advance,let your enemy fortify it self and send your troops in under the assumption of "They will retreat,they won't defend". 4:10 This guy is ODing on a copium
Ukraine always announced offensives since Russia failed miserably at taking Kiev. What they actually did and when sometime coincide with their announcements, sometimes not.
even if u dont announce in advance the outcome will be same you are facing mighty Russia fighting US and Nato alone they capture land and fortify it, they know they are facing NATO not Ukraine alone thats why they dug in
как человеку говорящему на русском и имеющему родственников воюющих с обоих сторон очень грустно смотреть на смерть как наших ребят так и на украинских🥲
Я - беларус, и мне тоже очень печально наблюдать, за этими жертвами братских мне народов. Реально на Украине это как рабство, людей хватают и скармливают на фронте за бабло запада. Печально это все.
My friend group I grew up with here in California are all Russians and Ukrainians... it really is sad knowing how similar to each other they are in culture yet they are full on killing each other. There is no side I can or will root for in this war, I just hope it ends
As any American you have my sympathy, I am sorry my nation has orchestrated this. My sorrow and tears are with Ali who died, hopefully you can all be reunited one day and free from the evils in the west. With love and empathy from the USA.
@@GoldenGod69 Politicians would win, actually. Lots of people made big cash during the war, both in Russia and from the rest of the world. And as always - mostly average citizens would suffer the most. Seems like humanity will never learn this.
Would be interesting to see the drone footage from the drone that was following the drone. The Russians do this often. To verify damage or destruction of the targets. I’ll reckon there likely wasn’t much left of those boys.
@@mrkeykush693Wait more 6 months maybe 1 year and you will see Russians orks in the streets of Istanbul Main target is to weaken Putler and the russian economy. 5 millions men Engineers Doctors and IT experts simply left the country akd the brain drain going on Russia will collapse soon. After Putler, reset of the system akd new normal relationships with this beautiful country
Isn't it weird that both Weeb Union and History Legends went on vacations at the same time? Did they get the paycheck at the same time or...they are more then friends?
It’s interesting how the Russian army has progressed since February 24, because before drones were rare, but now they are literally spent on one drone for one Ukrainian, mobile wheeled mortars/artillery have appeared (phlox is a recent novelty, if I’m not mistaken), tornado rocket artillery can now fire like Haymars, a new sniper rifle instead of the old SVD and so on. It was a stupid that NATO did not force Ukraine to sign a peace agreement after Kharkov
Apparently Tornado-S (Krasnopole shells) have many quality issues. This why we don't hear much about them, or their successes. As usual, Russia posses design, but fail to produce it technologically in quantities and quality.
You can offer to sign an armistice to the ennemy when you have destroyed its army or won a decisive battle. Kharkov offensive was a succes in term of gained territory, but it did not defeat any Russian army. Russian opered a tactical retreat because they were outnumbered, but they stabilised the front and finnally stopped the Ukainian offensive. A football match does not end after the first goal. So Russia would not have signed a peace agreement after Kharkov, unless on their terms, which Ukrainians could not accept.
Mercenaries leaving the front from the Ukranian side is the most funny and sad thing ever because of "atrocities", that being a soldier being hit by a mine and fallen comrades sadly. But when these western mercenaries aren't ready for combat, how will our average Joe do as a conscript?
I still think average Joe is better than NATO "veteran." Clean slate versus the guy who's used to having AC and MC Donald's on base while he bullies villagers? Average Joe won't know any other warfare. The "vet" will experience massive culture shock.
@@Rspsand07 If our "Joe" is going in because he wants it, he'll perform better, but as a conscript, that's where he fails. But it comes down from man to man.
@@Rspsand07not really. A lot of tactics still are used to conventional warfare. Just new tactics got added on to handle a different type of warfare during GWOT. Try harder
@vincenavv It's not about skill it's about expectations. Western soldiers haven't the expectation to endure long term suffering the way civilians do, even the Western ones.
Absolutely, meanwhile Western politicians come out with comments like, "price worth paying" "best money we have spent" or "this is cheap for us" how sick in the head do you have to be.
Remember Lindsay Graham during his visit to Ukraine: "It is good investment(money and weapons sent to Ukraine), as long as Russians are killed". That genocidal maniac along with John McCain (hope God will forgive him for what he was instigating) are the reason for war between Ukraine and Russia. Ukrainians still can't see that The US is using them as ram against Russia. From Russian perspective that ram will be dismantled one way or another. If Ukrainians don't sit and capitulate under Russian terms, there will be nothing left of Ukrainian state I'm afraid.
it doesnt matter how many, it matters that some mother and father lost their son because the 2 idiots refuse to negotiate and behave like monkeys to eachother@@nkosipwl
I told my army pals that I doubted they'd breach the first fortified line. Looks like I was spot on, the Russians had way too long to prepare, the Ukrainians should have fielded their resources, not moved for a year, letting the Russians push out, leave their positions and let nature reclaim them, then when they had gotten a bit further away, smash the Russian offensive while it was going and attempt a massive role up. That'd also give them time to get more AA coverage. But, NATO don't want a win, or a loss, they want a blood letting.
It was very refreshing to see someone who does not just completely simp for ukraine or russia. Majority of other channels out there have an extreme bias for ukraine while claiming to be "unbiased". I think your assessment was spot on, Ukraine has suffered some extreme losses, and has lost a lot of equipment, and most likely zelensky will scream and cry the west is at fault for not providing more monetary and military aid.
Zelenksy really got annoying can't blame him tho but atleast have some dignity relying on the people support and pissing high ranking officials wont end well.
Nah it's pretty sad to see this kind of BS. Ukraine repaired 8 'combat losses' of Leopard 2 tanks and returned them to Combat. That means Ukraine got 8 new Leopard tanks but Russia lost 35 in last 2 days and Russia shot down 2 su-35's in the last week in the general area of the Robotyne breakthrough. Not menitioned here. So Russia is so stressed about Ukraine's progress against Russian defences that it's crews shot down 2 of their best fighter / attack aircraft. No analysis of the challenges of the defences that Ukraine overcame already and is currently facing, just a hit piece against Ukraine because they didn't meet someone else's hype over the counter offensive.
That vid of the four AFU in the pickup was ice......you really could see the fatigue on the guys face and the fact none of them even raised their arms to cover their faces before the drone hit. All these young guys are dying for nothing. They are fighting for an artificial "cause" and not even having a hope of winning.
The failure of Ukraine offensive was to be expected, Russia wasn't slow to catch up with using fab drones. This coupled with there advantage in artillery, aircraft and well dugging fortifications paid off for them.The russian took advantage of the distraction of bakhmut to prepare their defenses and it worked.
Bakhmut wasn't a distration. It was a failed attempt to keep trying to take a city they didn't have. Even if that was the goal, they waisted way too much manpower, equipment, vehicals, ECT. for a 'distraction'. Your idea of tatics is as poor as the preformance of the Russian army overall.
@@ElementalWarrior1999 Let’s give him a chance. Maybe when people are reporting about Russian disastrous offensives, it’s not considered “disastrous” until they hit over 10,000 men lost and over 100 tanks lost and over 300 IFV’s lost and over 50 aircraft lost on a single offensive. I’m sure he will use the same language about the Russian’s Avdiivka offensive being a total disaster and about how their men from the top command all the way down to men on the front line being incompetent morons because he is completely unbiased and only reports the truth. Surprised he hasn’t already reported about it but maybe he’s waiting until he can condemn the Russians for making another major strike against civilians or some other war crimes. Let’s see what he has to say. Of course, if the next video that comes out says that the Russian’s Avdiivka offensive was a great success because they managed to take 200 metres of farm land for the loss of over 3000 Russian men, over 30 Russian tanks, over 100 Russian IFV’s and over 30 aircraft, we might have to start questioning whether he is really unbiased and really telling the truth but let’s see what he says
I visit this channel every 2 months to cringe and read the comments under the videos. You look at the best ones like there: "Puppets of the West", "Counterattack failed", "There are fewer losses in Russia".
remember when they were saying russia is losing 10:1 when attacking? when attackers take more losses than the defenders? in this offensive, ukrainians are somehow immune to that logic 😂
It’s Pretty easy to calculate how much losses are taken. It’s all based on fire power. Most casualties in this war are taken from artillery/mortars/MLRS systems, about 80%. And Russia has a massive advantage in all of that. Some sectors 1/4 and others 1/10 let’s take the average of 1/7. If we use BBC mediazona numbers of Russias confirmed losses. Russia has lost 30k Kia through out this war(not including wounded) multiply that with the artillery advantage of Russia and you should get a rough estimate of Ukrainian losses since the start of the war. 210k Ukrainian Kia. It would also explain why Ukraine is desperate to drag people off the streets to throw them in a ditch a month later to die to a enemy they can’t see. Let’s also take into account unconfirmed deaths. Which both sides have. Because people go missing or are unidentifiable corpses. There is a greater amount of dead than what I wrote. I’d say there are about 50k-60k Kia Russians and 250k-280k Kia Ukrainians. Ether way Ukraine is fucked. Russia has a larger reserve of troops they haven’t even used yet that they mobilized (300k) and got volunteer contractors(200k) in the last year that are still in the rear training to go on an offensive in the unknown future. Meanwhile Ukraine is struggling to reconstitute a division that isn’t made of forcibly mobilized.
@@TEXASRUSKIsorry but the figures you are mention are basically not possible. Best to calculate losses is to compare with other wars. Ukrainian field army has a nominal strength of about 500K, based on numbers of brigades, and maybe 50-60 percent are combat troops. In total maybe a million Ukrainian men have been drafted. 210K KIA is about the half of their nominal strength and that just sounds unrealistic. That is from relative perspective much more than the losses of French army during the first 18 months of WW1. And we all know that France suffered terrible losses in the beginning of ww1. Even the Werhmacht didn't had proportionally such losses during the first 18 months on the Eastern front. And we are talking about Moscow, the first battles in Stalingrad, the siege of Sevastopol...I think 70K Ukrainian KIA is a realistic figure and Russian losses should be around 100k KIA.
@@TEXASRUSKIbasing casualty numbers just on artillery is not correct. First the Ukrainian artillery shoots much more acurate. Secondly, look at history. The Red Army had multiple times more artillery than the Werhmacht but still the Soviets lossed much more men.
One sided view of the story and quote manipulative. You should spend the equal amount of time to highlight Russian losses. There are plenty of info in telegram Chanel’s.
Aside from combat losses, how badly do you think the Ukrainian vehicle fleet is suffering from a lack of parts? Sure they can cannibalize some of the losses, but they are fielding a mash of vehicles from half of the world.
What does it matter if they have spare parts or not!! The Ukrainians have no more soldiers!!! Starting this week they sent combatant military units made up only of Ukrainian women !?!?!?!!?.. It's a disaster and it will be even worse if no one stops the na*zi actor ....
As Veteran I am utterly disgusted at the warmongering of the EU & Western governments (including my own) that not only supported this criminal atrocity, but were directly responsible for creating the conflict.
At first, Ukraine tried NATO style assaults with columns of vehicles. That failed because of mines, artillery, drones and ATGMs. Then they switched to infantry waves or assault squads. It's easier to cover up losses this way but they still couldn't advance. Then they announced they'll be trying to grind up Russian artillery capabilities. But the extensive use of artillery caused them to lose more precious artillery pieces so near the end of July/beginning of August they switched back to the meat assaults again. This method spares the vehicles (which Alex talked about regarding one specific brigade's losses) but it comes at a higher price regarding human losses. The lack of spare parts should also be considered. According to Ukrainian sources, around 1/3 of their artillery pieces are under maintenance at all times because of their extensive use. This obviously comes with benefits and disadvantages. But having a large portion of vehicles destroyed basically stops you from cannibalising the damaged ones for spare parts for the working fleet. And NATO supplied a lot of trash vehicles that were not usable before so they were only good for spare parts but they're counted as active units. For example, if a country announces they'll send Ukraine 100 units of a specific vehicle from storage, most or some of them won't be in working condition so Ukraine can't actually use all 100 of these vehicles. One example is I think the Netherlands bringing out leopard 1 tanks from museums.
Without air superiority and long range missiles Nato Tactics are completely useless in trench war. The west trickles out weapons and ammo without any serious intentions for victory. More for the West industrial military complex and politicians profits. Sadly they don’t really care for Ukraine. Nor will they commit to full war with Russia. Terrible Tragedy.
This war was doomed from the start. The Western countries are not going to send their best equipment nor are they going to go head on with Russians. What a waste of human life...and for what? Some faint hope of joining the EU? The way the EU is treating Ukraine, they are much better off joining forces with the Russians or remaining neutral. The US and the EU are content to sit back and watch the Ukrainians get slaughtered.
Years ago I used to get news about Russia from Russian news sites but now as they are all blocked here in the UK I go to your site for news of what`s happening. I am ashamed of my governments failure to act in the interests of peace and in their aiding and abetting the lies and war that Ukraine and Russia suffer. I hope the nightmare will end soon and reconciliation find a path, thank you for keeping us informed about the real world.
Swede here, I usually did the same and read news from RT along the regular ones but suddenly it stopped working for the same reasons, so much for our "free and open" society 🙄
@@gorasul12 The immense propaganda for NATO started some 1.5 years ago. Suddenly we shouldn't be neutral anymore? Sweden, Europe and the world benefitted from our neutrality...and then the world got totally nuts! Now we want a big target on our back and join the potential "loosers" as we hand off our foregin policy to Washington? WTF...
Yes, an example of this is what happened in Belgord. I was waiting for the Russians to respond with fury, but that did not happen. This means that you should not let your emotions control you.
Ukraine’s Summer Offensive identifies itself as successful
🤣🤣🤣 underrated comment
Bro is a means tho
People don't realize this war is more than just territory.
It's a culture war. The liberal socialist West vs conservative east.
Unfortunately your words are true 😞
Just like Russia identifies itself as a major power? 🤣🤣🤣😅
If the aim of this offensive was to capture a town of 40 people in the grayzone, then its been a blinding success
The aim was to take crimea by August. We'll they didn't even made it through melitopol
Ukraine is going to lose that town of 40 people in the gray zone.
Very funny post 😅
After 20 months the 3 day special military operation is going splendidly🤣🤣🤣
@@mikker29y are mad ukraine super duper ultra deluxe premium counter offensive is a huge failure ?
Breaking news: Zelensky will receive the Nobel Prize in physics for this year. He and his generals staff managed to invent a new kind of quantum entity called Schrödinger's Offensive. The offensive is successful and failure at the same time, since the result of its fate is linked to a random subatomic event that may or may not occur in our hearts.
I had the imprudence to write about the “Schrödinger counter-offensive” at the beginning of summer on Denis Davydov’s channel.
Without overwhelming air and artillery superiority, the superposition of success will depend on the state/presence of the MSM observer and can be both a successful defeat and an unsuccessful victory.
His admirers threw me under the bus. 🤣
And they still see the success of the offensive.
XD
😂😂😂
The fact that you joke about people dying proves u have no heart. Or soul
Russian humour
The Russian tank got a scratch. Oryx: This is a destroyed tank and has no turret.
The western tank threw back the turret. Oryx: This is not a loss, it will be returned and this scratch will be repaired.
Kim's propaganda applauds
👏
use Lostarmour
It will be returned in Poland.
Problem is, Oryx reports the truth about the loser Russian troops who can’t win a war because of their incompetence! But Russian shills are to stupid, typical Russian mindset
I thoroughly enjoyed watching a mighty t90 get dissolved by an ATGM today. No survivors.
Putin: There are no western analogs to this 😂
@@watershedmetal2
2022: Western tanks are a game changer. They are designed to resist Soviet weapons.
2023: Anyone else remember what an unexploded Leopard and Bradley look like?😝😝
Nothing is better than 3 HistoryLegends videos in a week
hooray!
He's talking about current affairs again
👍
Sex is better, bro. sorry! :)
At least the video offensive was successful
he's given you enough copium until the weekend
History legend failed in history , many times when he talked about history was a mess except few popular stories,
and now the same person talks about current events ,
How to achieve success in offensive:
Step1 announce publicly where exactly you going to attack
Step 2 wait 6 month for your enemy to build fortifications
Step 3 attack exactly where you announced you going to attack
Step 4...
Step 5 Profit
It's exactly the script of South Park, and just as grim as those elves.
Step 2.5 Record “Shshsh” video
Step 0: Learn how to spell "Offensive"
thats how mafia works
Lol
This isn't a summer offensive anymore. It's a yearlong sacrifice.
Zelensky has succeed in sending tens of thousands of Christians to their death. This will open up the land for Khazarian jews.
My condolenses to those fallen warriors because of flawed leadership
no this is an offensive of success, the megalopolis of robotnye has been liberated
@user-ub9my1hu7d no because Ukraine fight for the devil
From how it looks to me, this whole war is being used by NATO as an oppertunity to deplete Russia by sacrificing Ukrainians. The EU and NATO both only seem to be giving them enough to keep fighting, but never enough to acually achieve some sort of "victory". Not to mention they wont give them weapons without promises they wont use them outside of Ukraine... So basically, only if they are using to blow up their own cities and infrastructure...
Two Russian solders are sitting in a Kiev cafe, drinking coffee, while a column of Russian tanks is “parked” nearby. Army convoys are passing by.
And one of them says to another:
- I regret one thing - we lost the information war.
Zelensky - “The counteroffensive has succeeded, in our hearts.”
He don't got enapf booliets...
@@alexanderburaga1907 I NEED MORE BOOLETS
@@cloke3076 BIGGER WEPONZ
My ass.
Boolitz, tonks and cocanium!
Urina will win!
Just seeing the tired soldiers at 17:46 really hits you with the reality of war. One moment you are chilling and the next your life is gone in blink of an eye. Often numbers don’t leave that much of an impact until you actually see the faces of soldiers and the destruction up close. Most likely none of them survived. RIP
They died for nothing. I hope they find peace ❤
It broke my heart, they're the unwilling who will die in a stupid war
Недавно появилось видео где солдат сбивает три fpv дрона подряд, он настолько отчаялся в конце, что вылез сбить дрон прикладом автомата. Можно отдать должное украинцам хоть они и враги для нас. Но в целом героизм на войне, это дебилизм в тылу
@@Bastrakov74 Ну, типа, да. Герои нужны, когда кто-то проебался.
I think war has been described as very long periods of sheer boredom with short moments of sheer terror.
It's wild that this goofy educated dude who's always cracking jokes is a more honest and serious analyst than the 99% of Western commentators who have just gone completely off the deep end and lost all touch with reality
Too wild to actually be true. You suggesting that he has a point is what is wild.
@@rmdomainer9042it's not wild according to logic or rationality based on documented facts. Maybe you think it's wild based emotional manstration?
The NAFO are claiming that the offensive is a huge success because they dealt massive casualties to Russia and are averaging kia's of 10 Russians killed per NAFO soldier lost
Yeah. It's like mainstream analyst from Wall Street commenting Tesla vs several youtubers -> the first ones were all wrong with their predictions about imminent failure Tesla, while the second ones were all correct and they offer so much better, really convincing arguments based on pure comoon sense, although they haven't graduated from Ivy League universities.
@@rmdomainer9042🤡
The saddest thing about all this was that everyone who isn’t an idiot was saying this exact thing would happen for a year.
I think only realistic people thought and knew that eventually russia will prevail. Russia has so much more capital, resources, manpower, technology etc. Then ukraine ever could dream of having.
This offensive was the first offensive that had a trailer and the Ukrainian leadership was the first one to announce the time and place of their offensive
this is because England is an ally and prevented peace from happening.
but at least boris johnson taught the Ukrainians how to battle british style. be a sportsman, announce you intentions and fight „fair“. no secrecy, no hidden movements, no surprises: „lets meet on the battlefield over there in… lets say.. spring?“ if i am late, let’s battle in summer, I‘ll bring some Leopard tanks, maybe Abrams… prepare… it’s going to be fun!“
Not so, during ww2 the British liked to use artillery to let the opposing side know this was the fight
We live in a time and era where you a well aware of your enemies intentions before they do it. Ukraine might not have said anything and Russia would still have known that Ukraine was bulking up troops in a certain region and what potnetial targets they were going to go after.
@@GrayD1ce Well UK doesn't really tell where D-Day would start or land and if they do they just tell lie or misinformation like they says they going land on south of France or on Normandy while in reality much further away than Nazi can predict
@@SeQuBu Clearly not, or the Black Sea fleet commander wouldn't have gotten shwacked a few days ago lol
The summer offensive, followed by the fall offensive, followed by the winter offensive. Senator Graham should be proud. A never ending war of attrition.
And yet he wants escalation, seeming to crave WW3,
@@jamesryan4325 These corporates puppets, aka politicians need a massive event so they can let their bad bets with the economy have a scape goat when Greater Depression part 2 releases world wide.
"Military experts" have recently explained at length in the western media that Ukraine's attrition combat technics are far superior to NATO/US combined arms tactics. That all the mistakes in the war were due to American lack of understanding of how to properly fight a war like this and giving their crazy ideas to poor Ukrainian soldiers.
ukrain attacks and dies in mass . Russia backs up a little to advance again latter as strong as ever .
@@jamesryan4325 send him there for few days.
No, no, no. Ukraines offensive is not failing it's just, very, very slow. Source: NAFO.
Yeah, just like the Moskva...it wasn't sunk, it just transformed into a submarine.
@@KondorDCS haha, cope nazi cope
🤣😂😅 👍
Nafo-Mofo Cultists, what a sad bunch of worthless worms...
@@KondorDCS condom IQ69 still yapping about old Moskva, Ukroids lost their entire fleet in 2 days... and most of their coast 😀
I have always been surprised by NATO training standards that NATO has ever stormed at all, except for the villages of shepherds who are armed with rusty machine guns, what their instructors could teach them if they have no idea what an assault on the defense line is, I think any Ukrainian veteran who has been fighting since the beginning of this war would teach them much better
Pride has evicted logic in the West
@@themissingpeace7956 ehm...yeah, and in russia there's just pure logic and facts! 😆
Well, that's pretty much how West fights - shoot and bomb everything to dust, sent in other to mop up. No need to do meet grinder. West has been trying to get out of attritional warfare - read up "Muscle Bound Superpower".
@@janw839 When you have nothing to answer in essence, always move the conversation to another topic. The theme “Russia is evil” or “everything is even worse in Russia” is perfectly suitable in any situation :)
Aren't you tired of it yet?..
@@РусланМетелкин-л2к I didn't see a serious comment anywhere, so what?
NATO training doesn't have to be bad, just because an experienced fighter in ukraine has more experience and could add important knowledge. 🤷♂️
Absolutely nothing is preventing the further education by a ukrainian veteran.
So the comments here are nothing but a joke.
I love how Ukrainian fans accuse HistoryLegends of being a Vatnik 😂
Sounds like emotional damage to me.
100%
COPIUM
He is a serb nationalist. Make of that what you will 🤪
@@cburgess2805 Are there any Serb that aren't nationalist tho.
@@cburgess2805 That's like saying Turks are nationalist. You won't find any that aren't nationalist.
Never thought that NATO tactics is simply human wave attacks
It’s clear they are no match for the sophisticated advanced Russian way of war.
Not much diferent from storming Z units in russia side
@@mottaaa586Even Storm Z haven't suffered such casualties
Nato invested its money into new machines and training of soldiers. Russia invested in shovels, and it paid off.
Lol
@@Mortabluntthere is nothing sophisticated about multiple lines of defense and minefields
It was first called the Spring Counter Offensive but lasted until the Fall
It shouldn't be even called a "counteroffensive" in the first place because it doesn't really fit the definition of one. That should have been our first clue about competence of Ukrainian and NATO planners.
Remember how they announced it? I'm sorry for Elensky, things could turn different if he whore the same glasses his sugar daddy wears. I forgot the name, they are normally related to the military, war, death.
@@codaalive5076 "whore" is well spelled here about how to sell the nation for a buck
They were using Australian calendars. It's Spring over there :)
But we are on day 500+ days of the 3 days to take Kyiv. 👍. A stalemate at this point.
I love how before they called russia "military failure" and didnt manage to do anything. WHILE WITH HELP OF ALL WESTERN COUNTRY'S ukraine didnt even do 1% of what russia acheived 💀💀😂😂😂
The much hyped up Counteroffensive might have failed, but the Grand Cash Laundering Scheme has succeeded. 👍
Well, Zelenski´s wife bought jewels back in New York when her husband was busy listening to himself in the UN worth 1 million USD 😀
@@PetrBouda-un9qo That is a great Tactical Breakthrough on her part. 👍
But they managed to defend Bakhmut as well, wait that failed too..
I can imagine the level of enthusiasm of foreign mercenaries fighting as Ukrainians, while receiving news and US withdrawal funds for Ukraine.
Bro you everywhere lol
@@gnaw8791he's literally a new Jutin.Y
@@thebamboozler2190Nah, that's a lil' much. Justin. Y was damn near omnipresent.
You have to see the mercenaries who left the front because of "atrocities" which is soldiers sadly being hit by mines. When even a mercenary isn't ready for combat from the west, how will the average Joe as a conscript do?
Reddit legionaires are taking hit after hit.
To sum up:
> 4 months.
> One village half-captured.
> More than 90,000 KIA AFU troops.
> Frontline hasn't changed.
> First line of defense hasn't been reached.
The power of NATO.
That is nowhere near the power of NATO lol USAs population alone is 3 times the size of Russias
NATO?
@@andrewrogers3067 nato soldiers disguised as volunteers have been present ( volunteers and mercenaries speaking English and various languages been getting scouted lately )
They been getting prepared for major super large offensive and it failed
@@andrewrogers3067
NATO supplies the weapons, the ammo, the training, the intel, the finances, the vehicles.
The only thing it doesn't supply is the manpower. Which is only a technicality at this point given Ukraine's desire to join NATO.
Russia in 4 months: 100K KIA , zero villages taken, 3 Su-34/35 shot down by friendly fire, Black Sea Fleet tactical retreat. New army rushed to the front without proper training. We are winning truzt ze planzzz
I identify as a Ukrainian advance troop squad. So far I have advanced 1000km, and Moscow told me it's ready to surrender to the rainbow brigade. Pronouns unite!
I identify as bullet proof.
Bro is mad
ive heard most common pronouns there are: kia/wia/mia
I identify as a Bradley tank, I did not sustain any damage and my mechanics are working fine. Now send me money, I need uhhhh... spare parts, yes.
@bloodmoon5872 about Russian special operation failure in Ukraine
So, let's summarize: In Severodonetsk, Ukrainian forces found themselves stuck in a cauldron with a tiny exit, constantly bombarded by Russia with all types of weapons. They had the brilliant idea to send in units to hold the territory, and predictably, these units lost half of their men just getting to their positions, got hammered at those positions, couldn't be properly resupplied, and had to rotate out, taking casualties in the process. To add to the hilarity, they then filled the unit with conscripts who had less than a week of training and repeated the same routine.
Then, in Bakhmut, Ukraine experienced déjà vu, as they once again ended up in a cauldron with a tiny exit, enduring a relentless assault from Russian forces. Of course, they repeated the same hilarious routine-sending troops, who predictably got annihilated both on their way to the positions and while at the positions. Proper resupply remained elusive, and they had to retreat, taking even more casualties.
Now, in the grand finale, Ukraine is stuck in yet another cauldron with a tiny exit, as Russian forces continue their non-stop bombardment. They've decided to keep the humor alive by desperately throwing in unit after unit, resulting in casualties on the way to their positions and even at the positions themselves. Facing challenges in proper resupply, they're forced to retreat, taking even more casualties.
What an absolutely side-splitting use of my tax money and Ukrainian lives, isn't it? xDD
I think i am seeing a pattern here.
Once a Cauldron, Always a Cauldron
maybe the real cauldron is the friends they made along the way.
Why am I not even surprised you even have this narrative in your head? 😂
Ukraine is really determined to polish that turd to a mirror finish thinking being in a cauldron is a wining tactic.
To be a competent military historian and geopolitical commentator is one thing ... but to also be this funny, entertaining and captivating just puts you in a league of your own.
Hats off to you sir!
on top of that he is a certified vatnik
yeah this guy rules
Like I said : one of the best !!👍
How is he competent if he talks nonsense? 😂
@@kingsharkoonHow is it nonsense? Please cite your sources that contradicts what’s he’s saying
I'm also a Redacted fan, they also give a no bullshit information just like this channel. Keep up your good work. I'm from Newcastle Australia.
Russia: Actions speak louder than words.
The West: Words of propaganda equals victory.
Goebbels looking at the West with pride: "That's my sweet child".
bro, this rethoric you can turn around and its exactly as real. both sides are just idiotic. most idiotic is europe. letting talked into to mutch shit fro the US, altough russia is our next neigbour not US...
@@dr.embersfield1551nah, it's more like: "the jews are at it again"
No way a zbot is saying this 😂🤣🤣🤣
Crazy world we live in man..
@@danielbwest No way was your reply just a pathetic Ad hominem fallacy.
May the fallen on both sides rest in peace.
🖤
chad comment
Nah The Russian invaders burn in hell for eternity
Truly, yes.
While the War Pigs play their games, the masses pay the price.
And may the crocks that planned and backed this nonsense live eternally in their master Satan home. Victoria Nudelman will eternally vomit the victim's blood. She will probably enjoy it for a while but after that she will implore the Lord for redemption, too late Vicky, too late. Madeleine Albright is waiting for you in Satan's kingdom.
I am pro Russian, but I really feel sorry for Ukrainian guys that are sent to dye for nothing. I pray this war stop soon.
Amen
why u support russia
Most Ukraine is Russian, for the exception of some Bandera fans from western Ukraine.
@@ivan200804Lvov Kiev are Natzee infested. Western Ukraine should be split up by Poland, Hungary, Romania, whoever has a historical claim before the invention of "the borderland".
Take Odessa up to Transnistria, and the ethnic Russian speaking population will be liberated from the UkNATOstan Banderarites.
@@0_pazwhy not support Rossiya?
Glory to Russian Federation 🇷🇺 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
“Is the breakthrough with us in the room?” Had me dying 😭😭😭
Why should we be fed such idiotic propaganda? 😰
It's just sad that this has become a bit of a mouthpiece for Russia. It's easily discredited in the obvious rationalisation that we all knew failure was a possibility because Ukraine is a much smaller country fighting a much bigger neighbouring country that continually escalated the conflict with fresh recruits, constants budgetary increases etc. The truth is that any success is proof that they have the ability to hurt and stop Russia. Lets be honest, this war started with Russia thinking they could conquer all of Ukraine in a few days and are now here several years later, that's a monumentally larger failure no?
Now Ukraine is hitting back, regardless of the speed they are accepting this is a necessity and a constant war to defend their own territory based on repeated Russian aggression. The real question is how long can Russia fall behind economically compared to the rest of the world? Between the decline in the ruble, sanctions, international isolation and constant spending on war there is no real victory in sight for Russia. Every day they spend in Ukraine is a prolonging of the bleeding of their own economy. They may be able to weather it on the surface but the long term damage to their economy compared to where it could have been is going to be utterly ridiculous. It's not just economy either, how many tanks, ships, ammunition, equipment and soldiers have we seen Russia lose? Hell, it's a damaging war for both sides but Russia will not be the power it wished to be for a god damn long time now. Europe and Nato are so unafraid that they keep to their own sides and just carry on as normal, for us Europeans it's just background noise now sadly. I wish the Ukrainians the best but sad to see this youtuber be a bit too pro russian in this case and lose perspective of how badly Russia failed in it's entire goals. That comparison would put a delayed spring offensive into perspective.
@@yousigiltubecope 🤓
@@yousigiltubeHAHAHAHAHAHAHA you had me laughing hard, what a good comedian
@@yousigiltubeO-M-G !!! 🙈
Shit, I need to cancel my August trip to Ukraine. I don't see the beach party happening :(
Zelensky already spent your refund money on another house.
It was a barbeque in Sevastopol - All the top brass had a blinding experience
Dammit, I had prepared a hardbass mix. Oh well, I'm sure the Russians will appreciate
I have already canceled my trip to Odesa 5 times now, I am getting desperate, please Putin do something.
Don't cancel. When Putin has it, he will improve it, just as he did with Crimea. Crimea was a shithole before Russia took over. Ask those Crimeans if they want Ukraine back in charge. They don't.
As a European, I have to say that nothing warms my heart more than seeing my f*cking taxes burn at some random vilage in Ukraine.
say thank you to Josep Borrel and all id////ts in Brussel
Is European industry moving to America due to energy costs doing anything for you?
@@Salabar_ Energy costs went already down by at least 30%. Not sure if the US is a safe choice though, you either pay energy costs in Europe or get looted by some mob in the US 🤷
@@subflexsubflex8878 I'd say the biggest problem are the media. From the messages we are getting one would expect the war is almost over, it's just this small little bit help they need. Like they almost have the win in their pockets, but it all depends on this equipment they need. And then another, and another 🤷
Ukraine is clearly loosing the war, but you don't hear that anywhere, so people just think we are doing the right thing.
Not correct. You money in offshore s people around zelenski
Waiting for angry Ukrainians talking bs in comment section
I mean, what did they expect rejecting negotiations and getting into a war of attrition with us. A war of attrition vs Russia is literally unwinnable, and Zelensky should've knew that back in spring 2022
How is a war of attrition with Russia un-winnable?
It is winnable.
The price paid would be quite high
@@manubishe Price paid will be all dead.
@@manubishe Napoleon and Wehrmacht is waaay stronger than Ukraine, still lost against Russian attrition.
Zelecocainsky doesn't give a flying f for AFU cannon fodder. Butcher of Kiev just sells ukrainian blood and meat, exchanging them for U.S. $$$
From a failed clown/comedian to a billionaire.
I want to take a time to show my condolences to those men and women that have lost their lives in this conflict that started in 2014 and have just increased in human suffering since then, no matter if you're pro-Ukraine, or pro-russian as me war it's just the result of human inability for mutual understanding. God bless you all and forgive us for our mistakes in life.
You know 2014 dombas conflict is ukrainian civil war, russo-ukrainian war started in 2022
This isn't due to mutual misunderstanding. This started due to thirst for a war so the military-industrial complex can earn billions, just like big farma did cause of covid.
Amen.
@@lenochod_one yeah the Ukraine war that started in 2014. when America overthrew the Ukraine. same war
Amen
17:46 You know the situation in the front is super duper bad when your troops don't even care anymore and just accept their death so willingly with a blank and tired expression.
Many of them are drugged and probably don't know or care what's going on.
A couple weeks ago, NATO head Stoltenberg was answering questions in the EU Parliament. Clare Daly mentioned to him a "half a million dead" in Ukraine. And he did not contest it. If we take BBC´s and Mediazona numbers, that point to 33k russian dead (plus the 15k Wagner dead) then the russians have lost around 50k dead. This means that NATO already knows that Ukraine suffered upwards of 450k DEAD! This is more than the US lost in WW2, or the british lost, in that same war! This isn´t just disastrous, this is slaughter of epic proportions. For over a year Ukraine has been constantly attacking a dug in force, that has a 10 to 1 artillery advantage. It is just insane how anyone could expect any other result!! Ukraine is now conscripting women, young boys, and sick men! This is a throwback to Germany 1945, and no one seems to care! And yet Zelensky is sight seeing throughout Europe and America, like a tourist with a tin cup begging for more warm bodies to throw at this slaughter...
They on drugzzz
yes - while Zelensky wines/dines/snorts cocaine,in luxury in the rear,along with his stolen millions !
The guy by 14: 30 , is a totale ID iot! every French speaking that know his vidéos knows how sold this guys is! 😂
To win, Ukraine just needs $500 billion more, and 10% for the big guy
Booleets... Zelinski need more booleets ans tonks.
Did someone mention my name?
@@ShitBoi😂😂
I have a friend from Cuba who is fighting for Russia. And he says that every day in Zaporozhye up to 30-50 Ukrainian soldiers surrender themselves to the Russians through a special connection.🤷
How do you communicate with him? Internet?
149.200 Volga.
Yes they surrender verry much the last 2 week , i have same information from a Serbian volunter who Fights on Russian side !
Российская армия создала для них специальную частоту, на которой можно выйти в эфир и запросить сдачу в плен. Загугли 149.200 Волга. Российской армии не нужны лишние жизни Украинцев, мы все равно их считаем братьями.
30-50 Smart Ukrainians. They can peacefully work in Siberian prisons until the war is over. Better to work in labour camps, instead of getting shattered by artillery fire.
In fact, this area near Rabotino is not oversaturated with soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. This is not Bakhmut before his fall. It's a flat field, as you can see in the video. There are no natural shelters on it. There are hills there, but they remain behind the Russian army. The ridge of hills with the first line of defense was overcome only in one place. In the direction of the Verbovogo. If you look at the elevation map, you will see the gap between the hills. And to climb into this gap was simply suicide. But we are dealing with an army that sends its special forces units to Crimea by boat for the sake of a photo of the Ukrainian flag on the Crimean beach. Knowing that these detachments will be destroyed in the Crimea or if they try to return. For them, the preferred tactic is to fall into an obvious trap. On a flat field, any accumulation of APU is visible, and it is immediately destroyed. The area near Rabotino is not oversaturated with soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, if we are not talking about their corpses.
What can be said about the villages occupied by the APU during the counteroffensive. The APU aspired there, thinking that the villages would become fortifications for them. Theoretically, you can also hide in bomb craters. But it doesn't help much from new bombs. They put mines there so they won't be kicked out. Those who plant mines die under artillery fire. A new unit of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is being sent there, and it is being blown up by these mines. And the artillery is working on them again.
The good safety of armored vehicles in some units of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is also explained by the fact that they quickly realized that it was useless to send armored vehicles there. The fact is that sending soldiers there without armored vehicles is all the more useless. They refuse to understand until now. It will be one of those places where at every step you stumble upon human bones.
What's even worse, some people in the West believe that the same tactics of closing into a nuclear war will bring them success! 🙄
Nice essay but no one is reading that
That last few sentences about armored vehicles tells me you know nothing about actual tactics. Like you got ammo to actually say some factual stuff to hype up RU's campaign but then you throw some dumbass incorrect opinions in there like its reality. If your factual people might believe you and your daddy putin might pay you more.
@@Rubensky44read it broh....interesting stuff there
@@Rubensky44 42+ people did.
Any offensive, that is widely know months in advance, cannot be successful...
d-day. U think the alliance just went on beach and drove to Berlin.
The allies literally made the Germans believe a fake offensive was going to happen at Calais @@schmidcl77 🤣
@schmidcl77 this isn't WW2, we don't function on newspapers anymore.
@@schmidcl77the Germans don't know where and when the allies would land, and the allies are launching grand deception campaign to ensure it
These mf make a trailer video about it, every media knows where they would attack, every media knows with what weapons they would attack, and they launch no deception campaign whatsoever
@@schmidcl77Ukraine is in Berlin's shoes in this case 😂
As a former soldier in the Canadian military I cringe at what the Ukrainian front line troops are going through. Absolute Exhaustion. I recall getting back to Canada after a much less stressful deployment and just wanting to curl up on my boyhood bed and sleep forever. There I was a captain, being served soup in bed by my mother.
TURDEAU MUST GO!!
🤡➡️🚪
Thats cute
Dont trust this guys channel. He is a pure propagandist for Russia. As much as you should not trust the other side, this one is also filled with nonsense.
My friends were sitting and laughing at me back in April. I told them their leopards won’t mean shit in the face of artillery
Oh, you mean the undefeatable tanks aren't so undefeatable afterall? Who would have guessed...
say hello from russians to your stupid friends, lol)
Are those puffs laughing anymore?..
Who would have thought that tanks designed to be protected mostly from the front wouldn't be well equiped to deal with a constant aerial threat given the US has maintained air superiority in every conflict since WW1
@@ElysV135 who said that? Jeez 😂😂
Looking forward for israel video
Yeah me too, so far it seems the Palestinians took random towns without any goal in mind.
The failed mortain german counter offensive in the summer of 1944 is the classic example of what happens when you launch an armoured assault without air superiority. Literally the same thing happened here at zaporizhzhia.
Did you see what happened to the Rusisian yesterday with Aircover?
Mortain offensive or as the German's called it operation Lüttich, I assume that's the one you speak of?
There is no such air superiority against russia air defense.
This is far more stupidier in fact. They did not have air superirity but neither artillery superority. And they attacked at the easy to guess points that the russians have mostly fortified. We even see now that the russinas are evn gaining the FPV drone superirity that was supposed to be ukrainian secret weapon. And the UMPK are raining while the JDAMs are not. And the long range Tornado/Smerch strike seems now more common that HIMARS strikes. HIMARS seems to be hidden so far from the front that they usually barely strike 10 km behind the front ...
Same thing happened around Kiev in 2022. when Russia lost an entire army convoy, wher trying to take Kiev.
How can the counteroffensive be a failure when we never expected much from it anyways.??🤭
Because it met expectations, it is considered technically a success!
you did expect a lot.... Dont lie.
But i knew it was going to be a total failure. the real thing about this war is that it will last quite long, and Ukraine might lose all of its land depending on its manpower and military aid.
azov in.. how many days?
what are you on about? they said they were gonna reconquer Crimea
I have say I expected it to have a lot more impact especially after how throughout the first half of the year msm downplayed the effectiveness of the Russian defences against western military equipment.
I still expected them to fail … but not to fail this badly.
It's almost like NATO doesn’t understand what an attrition war looks like...
NATO understands pretty well since Russian soldiers THEMSELVES upload video of receiving mortar shells completely rusted through.
@@Chuck_HooksAt least they have shells unlike NATO countries 😂
They do but the order to retake Ukraine at all costs came from the families. If you recall, Rothschild family members made speeches throughout western parliaments on how important it was to not let Ukraine fall into Russian hands. They will surely escalate and reinitiate the war when they feel they are ready.
@@Chuck_HooksWell If it still works good enough i guess
they do understand it. But the reason NATO doesnt like an attrtion warfare is because they had had strong german Influence along second half of 20 century, and if i remember well, germany did poorly in both world wars because of Attrition, while Russia was at a better position during USSR.
За 4 месяца украинцы так и не смогли не то что прорвать, но даже подойти к первой линии обороны русских.
Всё, что им удалось - это ценой огромных потерь преодолеть предполье и прочно засесть в огневые мешки, которые для них приготовили русские. На карте (особенно в Работино) прекрасно видно, что украинцы заходили в мешок и их с 3 сторон уничтожали авиацией, артиллерией, минами, ПТУРами и РСЗО.
Умный человек вышел бы из этих мешков и избрал бы другую тактику и остановил бы этот конвейер смерти. Но постоянно в течение этих месяцев в огневые ловушки гнали всё новые и новые партии украинского пушечного мяса.
В результате оказалось, что жизнь одного украинца была нужна, чтобы захватить 0,38 квадратных метра. Это более чем в 5 раз меньше площади среднестатистической могилы.
That's the crazy part of it it was clear by end of August that it would be near to impossible to breakthrough yet the clung to the hope of the Russians panicking and running away. When that didn't happen all hell broke loose and the Ukrainians found themselves locked into a bigger political battle than Bakhmut.
@@asavelakuse6865 я русский и я точно знаю, что русские не побегут.
@@viasenviasenoff5521 sorry translate is off
@@asavelakuse6865тогда вряд ли стоит вести беседу с тем, кто не умеет пользоваться сервисом перевода.
Это абсолютно несложно и доступно любому человеку.
@@asavelakuse6865i just want to say that we are russians and it is our land so we will never give up. There is no land for us, just this one.
Love your channel, when Europe started to silence news channels that was uncomfortable so was is it great to find your very fact built channel 😁
As an American, I’m so sorry for my country’s involvement in this disastrous war. Heartbreaking for Ukraine and for Russia. My own senator who I can’t stand is one of the evil mind’s responsible for this war. Lindsey Graham will be judged one day for all the Ukraine and Russians who have been killed.
You don't give a shit about Ukraine. If so, you'd cared for the thousands killed by Russian terror bombings...
Thank you, Bro, for your opinion 👍
Respect, from Russia, bro.
South Carolinian here and I agree. Lindsey Graham is delusional.
The United States has the largest military budget and a very low standard of living. If money had been spent on schools and hospitals, and not on war, life would have changed a lot.
I know its morally wrong especially with all the death and suffering in Ukraine. But I'm glad I got my 600$ from the bet my friend and I made in late May he said by October 1st Ukraine would hold all its strategic objectives and push the Russian Army back across Crimea. To really dig in the wound I said lets wait another 5 days, by the 6th he looked so miserable.
And its all thanks to History Legends, thanks for the 600$ man~
Congratulations my friend :) Joseph Stalin never doubted the strength of the Russian troops)
lolz
Red army stronk.
Easy money! Congratulations to you! Don't forget to celebrate your luck at the bar!
i made $100 too from my gullible friends. They really fell into in the analysis of Sky News and BBC "experts". 😆
Ой что ты говоришь такое! На Ютубе нельзя говорить правду, тебя могут забанить!)))
Robotyno is not even village. It's just very small settlement. Around 500 people lived there before the war. All of them left that place before actual fighting started there.
Its the terrain that matters. The important parts of Rabotino are still under Russian control. Thus the only area Russians allowed their enemy are the open areas. While the buildings within the hamlet itself are overlooked by sheer cliff. To hold this meager defensive position it required constant commitment of personnel from Ukraine creating a killing field. If Ukrainians actually took the whole province then Robotino would have been a very strategic victory thus it was important! However we can see they failed to capture this high ground and so the capture of the hamlet itself indeed seems as irrelevant as you say. Simply put it would matter but even in Robotino they failed the objective.
I'm not sure how accurate that 500 figure is considering that Ukraine was gradually being depopulated for decades before this conflict and little hamlets like that were probably hit the hardest due to all the young people gravitating towards larger urban centers.
It might've only had a couple hundred pensioners residing there full-time by 2022.
you just described a village
There is no war. There is a colonial invasion by a fascist gangster state, Russia. It is slowly, all too slowly, being repelled.
@@RPcropland You got the enemy wrong.
The most honest analysis of ukraine's summer offensive I've heard so far.
ukraine gained ground in the south russia has only lost ground.
@@Robert-hy3vvthat doesn’t matter, if you got a phyrric victory by gaining that much it is not good
@@Robert-hy3vv because Russia dug in, a lot, for the glorious ukrainian counteroffensive. Ukraine kept sending troops and equipment to die so Russia just held their positions
Millitary summary is pretty fair analist
I can't disagree more, no focus on Russian losses.....and no clear understanding and explaining of what has happened. Sry but it just sounds like blaming Ukrainen for having casualties, without looking on Russian casualties.
If we don't know how Manny Ukraine losses had compared too the Russians losses.
How can you conclude it has completely failed?
Ukraine is winning so they started to design body armor/plate carriers for pregnant women. How inclusive of them! They're surely winning, they deal so much damage to Russia that they now can safely send pregnant women to the front lines. So brave in my opinion 🥰
Where the fuck are you getting this information from 💀
Not to mention the over 60 soldiers!
@@joangordoneieio Saw an article a few weeks ago about some in their seventies. But they're winning...please keep the money flowing, America. LOL.
Ukrainan army is pregnant.. It has been fucked
that’s a no-brainer, you get 2 soldiers for the price of 1. Such a bargain!
Media has moved on from Ukraine. RIP Zelenskyy.
😂😂😂
The breakthrough is no different than the ghost of Kiev.
it actually went through the first line
while russias largest push in a few months ended with over 60+ destroyed vehicles (with pictures and photo evidence) in one section alone
@@banegas0411hi, can you provide any sources? Thanks!
„Is this breakthrough in the room with us right now“ 😂😂😂
Thank you for the support 🙏😂
Kiev, Washington and NATO have blood on their hands. That's all I got to say🤗
Ukrainian propaganda, is non ✋ stop in this campaign
It's amazing how such a small country can produce such a great amount of informational noise
This is what happens when you announce to the whole world that you're gonna conduct an offensive,moths in advance,let your enemy fortify it self and send your troops in under the assumption of "They will retreat,they won't defend".
4:10 This guy is ODing on a copium
It wouldn't matter of they announced or not. Russian satelites and drones would easily pick up troop and armor accumulation.
@@stinyg indeed. And they had to annouce it in order to gather as much gear as possible
Ukraine always announced offensives since Russia failed miserably at taking Kiev. What they actually did and when sometime coincide with their announcements, sometimes not.
even if u dont announce in advance the outcome will be same
you are facing mighty Russia fighting US and Nato alone
they capture land and fortify it, they know they are facing NATO not Ukraine alone thats why they dug in
I heard Ukraine destroyed Russia’s ability to repair its naval fleets.
как человеку говорящему на русском и имеющему родственников воюющих с обоих сторон очень грустно смотреть на смерть как наших ребят так и на украинских🥲
Я - беларус, и мне тоже очень печально наблюдать, за этими жертвами братских мне народов. Реально на Украине это как рабство, людей хватают и скармливают на фронте за бабло запада. Печально это все.
My friend group I grew up with here in California are all Russians and Ukrainians... it really is sad knowing how similar to each other they are in culture yet they are full on killing each other. There is no side I can or will root for in this war, I just hope it ends
As any American you have my sympathy, I am sorry my nation has orchestrated this. My sorrow and tears are with Ali who died, hopefully you can all be reunited one day and free from the evils in the west.
With love and empathy from the USA.
факты пишут американцы
@@GoldenGod69 Politicians would win, actually. Lots of people made big cash during the war, both in Russia and from the rest of the world. And as always - mostly average citizens would suffer the most. Seems like humanity will never learn this.
17:46 i legitamately feel bad for these guys, they're just tired from combat and the last thing they see is a drone hitting their truck
For a minute they thought they had survived hell.
Would be interesting to see the drone footage from the drone that was following the drone. The Russians do this often. To verify damage or destruction of the targets. I’ll reckon there likely wasn’t much left of those boys.
They shouldn't have been there in the first place
@@js70371 yeah not much explosive it's needed to wipe out an unarmored civilian vehicle...
Please note that in the same situation but with a Russian pickup truck in pro-Ukrainian channels they will only say a: rip truck
Since 20 months Russian going always backward
What the heck are you talking about ?
following your logic the russians would have retreated back to Moscow, but i'm still seeing a huge chunk of russian controlled land
@@mrkeykush693Wait more 6 months maybe 1 year and you will see Russians orks in the streets of Istanbul
Main target is to weaken Putler and the russian economy.
5 millions men Engineers Doctors and IT experts simply left the country akd the brain drain going on
Russia will collapse soon.
After Putler, reset of the system akd new normal relationships with this beautiful country
Hope you had a good time in Brazil, glad to have you back and the wait was worth it, thanks for another great vid @HistoryLegends 👍
Isn't it weird that both Weeb Union and History Legends went on vacations at the same time? Did they get the paycheck at the same time or...they are more then friends?
that one was funny :)@@leutrimkrasniqii
@@leutrimkrasniqiithey must be rewarded for hard work
@@petarpero958 100%
Реалан приказ, жао ми је и једних и других.Тако је било и у мојој земљи на Балкану.Неодлучују јадници.
Ya big brother v little brother
The winner is UNcle sam
@@shamilabdullah9996exactly my brother
@@shamilabdullah9996 In this case the winner isn't uncle sam, if it was, Ukraine would actually be winning.
@@Kaz.BrekkerUNcles Sam goal was not that, UNcle Sam wants Chaos
No. The hahlaks get what they vocally asked for.
It’s interesting how the Russian army has progressed since February 24, because before drones were rare, but now they are literally spent on one drone for one Ukrainian, mobile wheeled mortars/artillery have appeared (phlox is a recent novelty, if I’m not mistaken), tornado rocket artillery can now fire like Haymars, a new sniper rifle instead of the old SVD and so on. It was a stupid that NATO did not force Ukraine to sign a peace agreement after Kharkov
Apparently Tornado-S (Krasnopole shells) have many quality issues. This why we don't hear much about them, or their successes. As usual, Russia posses design, but fail to produce it technologically in quantities and quality.
So you would be Neville Chamberlain in this Analogy...yes Herr Hitler have the Sudatenland just promise no more invading???
@@serdgeedgerunner Russia just uses shovels since none of their equipment work as usual. 🇱🇸🇱🇸🌹❤️
You can offer to sign an armistice to the ennemy when you have destroyed its army or won a decisive battle. Kharkov offensive was a succes in term of gained territory, but it did not defeat any Russian army. Russian opered a tactical retreat because they were outnumbered, but they stabilised the front and finnally stopped the Ukainian offensive. A football match does not end after the first goal.
So Russia would not have signed a peace agreement after Kharkov, unless on their terms, which Ukrainians could not accept.
@@BradySharrett will you stop already with those false analogies?
"Maybe the real breakthrough was the friends we lost along the way"
(c) Zelenski
Mercenaries leaving the front from the Ukranian side is the most funny and sad thing ever because of "atrocities", that being a soldier being hit by a mine and fallen comrades sadly. But when these western mercenaries aren't ready for combat, how will our average Joe do as a conscript?
I still think average Joe is better than NATO "veteran." Clean slate versus the guy who's used to having AC and MC Donald's on base while he bullies villagers? Average Joe won't know any other warfare. The "vet" will experience massive culture shock.
@@Rspsand07 that is a good point.
@@Rspsand07 If our "Joe" is going in because he wants it, he'll perform better, but as a conscript, that's where he fails. But it comes down from man to man.
@@Rspsand07not really. A lot of tactics still are used to conventional warfare. Just new tactics got added on to handle a different type of warfare during GWOT. Try harder
@vincenavv It's not about skill it's about expectations. Western soldiers haven't the expectation to endure long term suffering the way civilians do, even the Western ones.
This is just sad man, it broke me seeing those men in the truck being taken away, all the while some Comments are treating this like a football game
Ok internet mommy. They chose to comply and this is the consequences of playing soldier.
lol this video is treating the ukrainian offensive as a football game, its history legends faults lolol
Absolutely, meanwhile Western politicians come out with comments like, "price worth paying" "best money we have spent" or "this is cheap for us" how sick in the head do you have to be.
Remember Lindsay Graham during his visit to Ukraine:
"It is good investment(money and weapons sent to Ukraine), as long as Russians are killed".
That genocidal maniac along with John McCain (hope God will forgive him for what he was instigating) are the reason for war between Ukraine and Russia.
Ukrainians still can't see that The US is using them as ram against Russia.
From Russian perspective that ram will be dismantled one way or another.
If Ukrainians don't sit and capitulate under Russian terms, there will be nothing left of Ukrainian state I'm afraid.
GOOOAL!!!
Robotyne was set up as a kill zone the Russian defenses have the high ground.
Not this cope again 😂😂
Ukrainians are winning all the way to Kiev
@@danielbwestwell what he said it's proving and stop being cope and denial are your have gay relationship with zelensky ?
@@danielbwest Keep coping it's a massacre
This post didnt age well. avdiivka is waiting for you History Legends. Where are you? Lol
None of his posts age well, this dude has been so consistently wrong about the war that it's honestly impressive
good to have you back! the salt is great.
R.I:P to all the ones who have died in this conflict, hope it is soon over.
You mean like the 120-200000 russian and 60000 to 100000 Ukrainians
it doesnt matter how many, it matters that some mother and father lost their son because the 2 idiots refuse to negotiate and behave like monkeys to eachother@@nkosipwl
@@nkosipwl was that a respons to me or?
@@nkosipwl yes, RIP to the 400,000 Ukrainazis
@@dalleravn these bots only learned about Україна 🇺🇦 in 2022
They just parrot mainstream narratives
I really thought they would at least reach Tokmak. And that was the worst case scenario in my opinion.
I told my army pals that I doubted they'd breach the first fortified line. Looks like I was spot on, the Russians had way too long to prepare, the Ukrainians should have fielded their resources, not moved for a year, letting the Russians push out, leave their positions and let nature reclaim them, then when they had gotten a bit further away, smash the Russian offensive while it was going and attempt a massive role up.
That'd also give them time to get more AA coverage.
But, NATO don't want a win, or a loss, they want a blood letting.
80% of people in the West thought that way. But dominating in the information war doesn't mean much on the battlefield.
@@ImperativeGamesMost of the pro Russian commentators I listen to expected Ukraine to push further.
And some still believe it
Yeah thought the same thing since it was close but after June. It became clear to me that AFU wouldn't even reach it
It was very refreshing to see someone who does not just completely simp for ukraine or russia. Majority of other channels out there have an extreme bias for ukraine while claiming to be "unbiased". I think your assessment was spot on, Ukraine has suffered some extreme losses, and has lost a lot of equipment, and most likely zelensky will scream and cry the west is at fault for not providing more monetary and military aid.
Zelenksy really got annoying can't blame him tho but atleast have some dignity relying on the people support and pissing high ranking officials wont end well.
@@andrewrogers3067That’s right.
Zelensky must be getting close to Musk in wealth, he must have overtaken Trump,
Nah it's pretty sad to see this kind of BS. Ukraine repaired 8 'combat losses' of Leopard 2 tanks and returned them to Combat. That means Ukraine got 8 new Leopard tanks but Russia lost 35 in last 2 days and Russia shot down 2 su-35's in the last week in the general area of the Robotyne breakthrough. Not menitioned here. So Russia is so stressed about Ukraine's progress against Russian defences that it's crews shot down 2 of their best fighter / attack aircraft. No analysis of the challenges of the defences that Ukraine overcame already and is currently facing, just a hit piece against Ukraine because they didn't meet someone else's hype over the counter offensive.
How come trolls never have facts to share just weak trash talk
17:46 - that's just such a sad still from the video, those men know they're done for and accepted their fate... absolutely heart wrenching
That vid of the four AFU in the pickup was ice......you really could see the fatigue on the guys face and the fact none of them even raised their arms to cover their faces before the drone hit. All these young guys are dying for nothing. They are fighting for an artificial "cause" and not even having a hope of winning.
War is old men lieing, and young men dieing as they say. Oh that and the same giant noses profiting from it, as always. *cough*
Yeah, that last still screen is just heartbreaking. Those poor bastards.
I enjoy listening to you expose the ' experts ' you should do a video just breaking down those interviews.
The failure of Ukraine offensive was to be expected, Russia wasn't slow to catch up with using fab drones. This coupled with there advantage in artillery, aircraft and well dugging fortifications paid off for them.The russian took advantage of the distraction of bakhmut to prepare their defenses and it worked.
Wagner in our hearts ❤
@@bigbrobropro2152😢😢❤
Bakhmut wasn't a distration. It was a failed attempt to keep trying to take a city they didn't have. Even if that was the goal, they waisted way too much manpower, equipment, vehicals, ECT. for a 'distraction'. Your idea of tatics is as poor as the preformance of the Russian army overall.
Where is your video about Avdiivka?
He isn't payed for that one
Lol good question calling him out, this guy claims unbiased news, most of his videos always covers Ukraines failures rather than the Russian ones.
@@ElementalWarrior1999 Let’s give him a chance. Maybe when people are reporting about Russian disastrous offensives, it’s not considered “disastrous” until they hit over 10,000 men lost and over 100 tanks lost and over 300 IFV’s lost and over 50 aircraft lost on a single offensive. I’m sure he will use the same language about the Russian’s Avdiivka offensive being a total disaster and about how their men from the top command all the way down to men on the front line being incompetent morons because he is completely unbiased and only reports the truth. Surprised he hasn’t already reported about it but maybe he’s waiting until he can condemn the Russians for making another major strike against civilians or some other war crimes. Let’s see what he has to say. Of course, if the next video that comes out says that the Russian’s Avdiivka offensive was a great success because they managed to take 200 metres of farm land for the loss of over 3000 Russian men, over 30 Russian tanks, over 100 Russian IFV’s and over 30 aircraft, we might have to start questioning whether he is really unbiased and really telling the truth but let’s see what he says
I visit this channel every 2 months to cringe and read the comments under the videos.
You look at the best ones like there:
"Puppets of the West", "Counterattack failed", "There are fewer losses in Russia".
Ukrainian simp
Смотрим из России, прекрасный объективный анализ. Une analyse complete et détaillée. Bravo!
Привет. Слушай, я сколько смотрю автора не могу понять то, кто он по национальности???
Don't believe that all of we Western citizens support this NATO proxy war against Russia. We do not.
@@Dzuba4вроде бразилец или мексиканец, живущий в Канаде. Парень умный и красивый)
@@Dzuba4 живет в Канаде, а так латинос кмк
Putin will soon cut off your VPN and you will not watch this guy anymore :(
The real breakthrough is the friends we made along the way.
*lost
I legit lol'd reading ur comment
Lost along they way you mean
According to NYT, Russia has 270,000 KIA through August compared to 70,000 KIA for Ukraine. And the MSM spreads this nonsense everywhere.
Russia has only mobilized 300K, did they have technology to revive their soldier? 😂
remember when they were saying russia is losing 10:1 when attacking? when attackers take more losses than the defenders? in this offensive, ukrainians are somehow immune to that logic 😂
It’s Pretty easy to calculate how much losses are taken. It’s all based on fire power. Most casualties in this war are taken from artillery/mortars/MLRS systems, about 80%. And Russia has a massive advantage in all of that. Some sectors 1/4 and others 1/10 let’s take the average of 1/7. If we use BBC mediazona numbers of Russias confirmed losses. Russia has lost 30k Kia through out this war(not including wounded) multiply that with the artillery advantage of Russia and you should get a rough estimate of Ukrainian losses since the start of the war. 210k Ukrainian Kia.
It would also explain why Ukraine is desperate to drag people off the streets to throw them in a ditch a month later to die to a enemy they can’t see.
Let’s also take into account unconfirmed deaths. Which both sides have. Because people go missing or are unidentifiable corpses. There is a greater amount of dead than what I wrote. I’d say there are about 50k-60k Kia Russians and 250k-280k Kia Ukrainians.
Ether way Ukraine is fucked. Russia has a larger reserve of troops they haven’t even used yet that they mobilized (300k) and got volunteer contractors(200k) in the last year that are still in the rear training to go on an offensive in the unknown future. Meanwhile Ukraine is struggling to reconstitute a division that isn’t made of forcibly mobilized.
@@TEXASRUSKIsorry but the figures you are mention are basically not possible. Best to calculate losses is to compare with other wars. Ukrainian field army has a nominal strength of about 500K, based on numbers of brigades, and maybe 50-60 percent are combat troops. In total maybe a million Ukrainian men have been drafted. 210K KIA is about the half of their nominal strength and that just sounds unrealistic. That is from relative perspective much more than the losses of French army during the first 18 months of WW1. And we all know that France suffered terrible losses in the beginning of ww1. Even the Werhmacht didn't had proportionally such losses during the first 18 months on the Eastern front. And we are talking about Moscow, the first battles in Stalingrad, the siege of Sevastopol...I think 70K Ukrainian KIA is a realistic figure and Russian losses should be around 100k KIA.
@@TEXASRUSKIbasing casualty numbers just on artillery is not correct. First the Ukrainian artillery shoots much more acurate. Secondly, look at history. The Red Army had multiple times more artillery than the Werhmacht but still the Soviets lossed much more men.
Ok honest question based on all your past vids, when will you do a "Israel is defeated" vid? Or a "Hamas is wining" vid?
not anytime soon considering hamas already wants a truce
Absolutely incredible analysis from @HistoryLegends. Keep up the great work you're doing. Hooray!!
Hey, would you please make a video about Nagorno Karabakh, and recent escalation? Thank you! As always, great content!
Checkout the Turkey video 🇹🇷
@@historylegendshay when are you going back to your birth place (Russia) because no way are you from Canada!!!!!
@@richardlafave2556 I can tell you were really eager to party in Crimea this summer, weren’t you?… 😉
@@richardlafave2556You better be focus more on your one canadian citizen ,that is a real ex-SS soldier , what about him to expel?
@@KABKAKIy_KAPATEJI_DOPi think he's one of those SS descendants over there, lost for objective factual arguments turns to racist mocking
One sided view of the story and quote manipulative. You should spend the equal amount of time to highlight Russian losses. There are plenty of info in telegram Chanel’s.
Don't you know his pro-Russian ? Since you knew there's plenty of info in telegram, go indulge it yourself.
Thanks a lot for the video, great work, it's really hard to believe how delusional has the mainstream media became.
But if you think they defend interest of very few people, they are performing exactly as intended
Also people
always was
It’s not delusional, they know exactly what is happening. They give fake news to keep morale high. Imagine if USA tax payers knew what was going on
Всмысле стали??? Они всегда были!
Remember when Russia almost had Kyiv? Almost......almost.
Well, they clearly said that they will reach Kyiv on 3 days, but they never told how many time they could actually hold it
Aside from combat losses, how badly do you think the Ukrainian vehicle fleet is suffering from a lack of parts? Sure they can cannibalize some of the losses, but they are fielding a mash of vehicles from half of the world.
Exhausted. Back before they lost bakhmut their logistics was non existant. Cant imagine now
Agree...
Plus, they already received used and, much or less, broken equipment...
Ad that to equation...
And I'm sure no one is interested in the condition of the Russian vehicle fleet?
I guess not 😂..
@@DeadWayfes I'm not sure why you come to that assumption. I'm sure It doesn't come from any place of bias...
What does it matter if they have spare parts or not!! The Ukrainians have no more soldiers!!! Starting this week they sent combatant military units made up only of Ukrainian women !?!?!?!!?.. It's a disaster and it will be even worse if no one stops the na*zi actor ....
As Veteran I am utterly disgusted at the warmongering of the EU & Western governments (including my own) that not only supported this criminal atrocity, but were directly responsible for creating the conflict.
As a veteran has the same ring to it as "as a gun owner" we get it you made sure toilet paper never ran out
@@riflescientist1744🤣🤣🤣
Russia invades Ukraine and somehow the West is to blame. This video is full of Russian trolls masquerading as non Russians.
@@mr.creamy7778 74d what about you? Not knowing your place
K, Nazi lover!
At first, Ukraine tried NATO style assaults with columns of vehicles. That failed because of mines, artillery, drones and ATGMs. Then they switched to infantry waves or assault squads. It's easier to cover up losses this way but they still couldn't advance. Then they announced they'll be trying to grind up Russian artillery capabilities. But the extensive use of artillery caused them to lose more precious artillery pieces so near the end of July/beginning of August they switched back to the meat assaults again.
This method spares the vehicles (which Alex talked about regarding one specific brigade's losses) but it comes at a higher price regarding human losses.
The lack of spare parts should also be considered. According to Ukrainian sources, around 1/3 of their artillery pieces are under maintenance at all times because of their extensive use. This obviously comes with benefits and disadvantages. But having a large portion of vehicles destroyed basically stops you from cannibalising the damaged ones for spare parts for the working fleet. And NATO supplied a lot of trash vehicles that were not usable before so they were only good for spare parts but they're counted as active units. For example, if a country announces they'll send Ukraine 100 units of a specific vehicle from storage, most or some of them won't be in working condition so Ukraine can't actually use all 100 of these vehicles. One example is I think the Netherlands bringing out leopard 1 tanks from museums.
Ahem, human wave assaults.
Without air superiority and long range missiles Nato Tactics are completely useless in trench war. The west trickles out weapons and ammo without any serious intentions for victory. More for the West industrial military complex and politicians profits. Sadly they don’t really care for Ukraine.
Nor will they commit to full war with Russia.
Terrible Tragedy.
The comedian zelensky ruined Ukraine by fighting proxy war for USA when he could simply avoid war by promising not to join Nato.
This war was doomed from the start. The Western countries are not going to send their best equipment nor are they going to go head on with Russians. What a waste of human life...and for what? Some faint hope of joining the EU? The way the EU is treating Ukraine, they are much better off joining forces with the Russians or remaining neutral. The US and the EU are content to sit back and watch the Ukrainians get slaughtered.
@@ctrlaltdebug Wild-pigs-running-in-waves-assaults.
190.000 Ukraine deaths so how many injuries have they got looool thats just this summer
I said this for two years ago, Russia winning from start, Western propaganda keep lying about Ukraina chances
Years ago I used to get news about Russia from Russian news sites but now as they are all blocked here in the UK I go to your site for news of what`s happening. I am ashamed of my governments failure to act in the interests of peace and in their aiding and abetting the lies and war that Ukraine and Russia suffer. I hope the nightmare will end soon and reconciliation find a path, thank you for keeping us informed about the real world.
That is european democrasy and transparency
Swede here, I usually did the same and read news from RT along the regular ones but suddenly it stopped working for the same reasons, so much for our "free and open" society 🙄
Telegram channles can also be helpful to hear/see/watch the Russian side.
MSM has failed miserably in the propaganda war.
Russiаn here. Wеstern nеws nеver gоt blоcked here so we have sоmething to lаugh at.
@@gorasul12 The immense propaganda for NATO started some 1.5 years ago. Suddenly we shouldn't be neutral anymore? Sweden, Europe and the world benefitted from our neutrality...and then the world got totally nuts! Now we want a big target on our back and join the potential "loosers" as we hand off our foregin policy to Washington?
WTF...
Waste of American taxed
This is what happens when you use feelings to fight a war rather than your brain 😅
Yes, an example of this is what happened in Belgord. I was waiting for the Russians to respond with fury, but that did not happen. This means that you should not let your emotions control you.
Neither sides show brain