Ramanujan Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 май 2016
  • A sort of review of The Man Who Knew Infinity. And a review of other videos that came out this week.
    standupmaths: Ramanujan, 1729, Fermat's Last Theorem • Ramanujan, 1729 and Fe...
    Mathologer: Ramanujan. Making sense of -1/12 • Ramanujan: Making sens...
    singingbanana: The Riemann Hypothesis • The Riemann Hypothesis
    singingbanana: Ramanujan Summation • Ramanujan Summation
    Numberphile: Partitions • Partitions - Numberphile
    Other videos I found too late to recommend in the video:
    Tipping Point Math: The Man Who Knew Infinity • The Man Who Knew Infinity
    MindYourDecisions: Ramanujan's Radical Brainteaser • How To Solve This Craz...

Комментарии • 233

  • @twertygo
    @twertygo 8 лет назад +235

    You really look like that one guy from Numberphile! I can't believe I didn't see those similarities before! You're almost congruent!

    • @jacksouthgate4354
      @jacksouthgate4354 8 лет назад +38

      +twertygo Gotta say, that Matt Parker guy he featured looks really familiar as well!

    • @xdxd-oc4hd
      @xdxd-oc4hd 8 лет назад +2

      +Jack Southgate GUYS THIS IS ANOTHER CHANNEL FOR THIS GUY DOING THINGS THAT HE LIKES ,FROM NUMBERPHILE

    • @ChaimS
      @ChaimS 8 лет назад +12

      +papas sou (thenerfgamer09) I'm pretty sure they're both joking...

    • @fran6b
      @fran6b 8 лет назад

      +Chaim S
      Papas sou is probably joking too !

    • @xdxd-oc4hd
      @xdxd-oc4hd 8 лет назад

      francis bélanger i am not ... but i do not know how they thought and didn't know that , that was him.

  • @xnick_uy
    @xnick_uy 8 лет назад +61

    Now that you mention it, the resemblance is uncanny!

  • @azlhiacneg
    @azlhiacneg 8 лет назад +69

    Wow, you look and sound like that guy from Numberphile! You also have the same names! Such a coincidence! The world is so small!

    • @Jat_Bodyguards
      @Jat_Bodyguards 8 лет назад

      +azlhiacneg lol

    • @MCSre
      @MCSre 7 лет назад +1

      He IS the same guy frow numberphiles

    • @Deguiko
      @Deguiko 7 лет назад

      wooooooowwww

    • @FeindrplaysMC
      @FeindrplaysMC 5 лет назад +1

      @@MCSre r/woooooosh

  • @lucidmoses
    @lucidmoses 8 лет назад +108

    It's obvious that your totally different people. He has a better mic. :p

    • @dan339dan
      @dan339dan 8 лет назад +4

      +Lucid Moses Harsh :D

  • @MrCardeso
    @MrCardeso 8 лет назад +117

    Please do a collab with the guy from Numberphile, and make if funny like one of Nat's videos!

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  8 лет назад +25

      +Mario G. Cardiel Little known fact that Nat is actually three different people.

    • @MrCardeso
      @MrCardeso 8 лет назад +2

      +singingbanana Those are fantastic news! It triples my dismal chances to date one of them.

    • @sambishop3211
      @sambishop3211 8 лет назад +1

      +Mario G. Cardiel Who is this Nat? Does she do maths videos?

    • @chairwood
      @chairwood 8 лет назад

      +louisng114 ew shes asian

    • @MrCardeso
      @MrCardeso 8 лет назад

      +Sam Bishop James is a fan of Nat, Nat is a fan of James, and I am a fan of both. Nat = CommunityChannel, as indicated.

  • @unvergebeneid
    @unvergebeneid 8 лет назад +95

    Nah, you look nothing like Matt Parker. ;)

    • @1kuaq
      @1kuaq 8 лет назад +4

      +Penny Lane You mean Brady?

    • @frozzenwaterfall
      @frozzenwaterfall 8 лет назад +1

      +1kuaq (that's the joke right there)

    • @ChaimS
      @ChaimS 8 лет назад +1

      +rbapf You made my day! :D

  • @shri03992
    @shri03992 8 лет назад +41

    Wow, never noticed the looks, but come to think of it, your name seems oddly similar to that professor's from Numberphile as well... If I didn't know better I'd be convinced you two were one and the same guy!

  • @kamoroso94
    @kamoroso94 8 лет назад

    It's so cool to see all these math channels making similar videos and recommending each other, warms my heart lol

  • @robin5171
    @robin5171 8 лет назад +38

    Now that you say it... you DO look like the guy from Numberphile. /s

    • @mihirkamat504
      @mihirkamat504 7 лет назад +1

      Robin van der Burg He IS the guy from numberphile.

    • @EchoHeo
      @EchoHeo 6 лет назад +1

      Mihir Kamat
      Thats the joke

  • @elongationStation
    @elongationStation 8 лет назад +3

    Hey Dr Grime, I just wanted to say thanks for making these videos. I have seen your personal channel and your appearances on numberphile, etc.
    You are one of the reasons why I chose maths for an A level. Being quite stressed about the sudden need to pick my subjects, I saw that I started enjoying maths partly due to you and your videos. I particularly enjoy your logical maths.
    Thanks again, and keep the videos coming!

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  8 лет назад +4

      Thank you Louis - I make these videos so people can see what maths is like. If you're about to start A-levels, I think you might enjoy it. Good luck.

    • @elongationStation
      @elongationStation 8 лет назад +2

      singingbanana Yes, I begin in September. Thanks for responding! Love the videos

  • @ParthaDey97
    @ParthaDey97 8 лет назад

    Loved the mini video series!

  • @MartiniComedian
    @MartiniComedian 8 лет назад +43

    Who told you that you look like "the guy from numberphile"???
    Jeez, people, wake up!!!
    :P

    • @AnirudhGiri
      @AnirudhGiri 8 лет назад

      +Aditya Khanna oh you...

    • @AuroCords
      @AuroCords 8 лет назад +1

      +Alex Martini - Comedian must be one of them crazy conspiracy theorists XD

    • @MartiniComedian
      @MartiniComedian 8 лет назад

      LOOOOOOOOOOOOL

    • @rafaelmosca9770
      @rafaelmosca9770 8 лет назад +1

      +Alex Martini - Comedian
      Wait that guy at 0:55 looks also like a guy from Numberphile, LOL.

  • @felipea.barretto7503
    @felipea.barretto7503 7 лет назад +2

    Hey! Just saw your enterview with Rafael Procopio! I was so thrilled to see you there, I'm a huge fan of yours :DDD

  • @AutoKay
    @AutoKay 8 лет назад

    Video editing has gone to a new level.. Two different channels.. Same looking guys.. Don't know each other... Epic.

  • @AntoshaPushkin
    @AntoshaPushkin 8 лет назад +2

    I love the fact that now there are films about scientists such as this one, "The Imitation Game" about Alan Turing, or "The Theory of Everything" about Stephen Hawking because they popularize science a lot and make nerds look better (:

  • @Reylaymon
    @Reylaymon 8 лет назад

    i hope you keep making more videos!

  • @thomaspickin9376
    @thomaspickin9376 8 лет назад

    I've seen these videos before but I really enjoy Mathologer's. I think it really gives a good idea of -1/12 as adding positive numbers together and getting a negative tends to get an angry response from some people. This really goes into how it's more assigning a value that we can use and works and extends the current definitions and it takes away a bit of the 'weirdness' of it all. I wouldn't be here though unless I enjoyed all your videos too though :D.

  • @volbla
    @volbla 8 лет назад

    Complex analysis seems bloody funky! I wanna take a course in that now.

  • @rushellcarlson6561
    @rushellcarlson6561 8 лет назад

    I just wanted to say that I suck at math but I think your videos are interesting and entertaining. Thank you for making them.

  • @AnindyaMahajan
    @AnindyaMahajan 8 лет назад

    how could have i missed it?!?! i have been watching both your and numberphile's videos for so long! what's more eerie is that it turns out the numberphile's guy name is also dr. james grime
    :3

  • @shashanksistla5400
    @shashanksistla5400 8 лет назад

    Yay new video!

  • @sitearm
    @sitearm 8 лет назад

    nice review short review nice and short review lol
    ps i watched your other three ramanujan vids very nice
    pps that numberphile guy - pft! - who knows where brady gets those people ; p

  • @kg583
    @kg583 8 лет назад

    That moment when you're already subscribed to all four channels in the description.

  • @darokun
    @darokun 8 лет назад

    Ohhhh! Now I know why is it that I felt I had seen you before!! That professor from Numberphile! Of course!

  • @jaime3067
    @jaime3067 8 лет назад

    love your vids! found myself quite interrsted in maths

  • @FadeToBlack279
    @FadeToBlack279 8 лет назад +14

    So the guy from Numberphile is your twin brother? May I call you... the Twin Grimes? (long pause here, include cricket sounds if you wish)

    • @FadeToBlack279
      @FadeToBlack279 8 лет назад

      or maybe it's your Cousin Grime?

    • @saintcelab3451
      @saintcelab3451 8 лет назад +1

      +FadeToBlack279 Ha i see what you did there. The Twin Grimes.

    • @FadeToBlack279
      @FadeToBlack279 8 лет назад

      Larry Lyü yeah I know, it's such a bad pun but I just couldn't resist

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  8 лет назад +7

      +FadeToBlack279 Applauds

    • @FadeToBlack279
      @FadeToBlack279 8 лет назад +2

      singingbanana (bows) Thank you, it has been an honor. I assume you must hear those kind of jokes a lot seeing that you're friends with Matt Parker.

  • @TimJSwan
    @TimJSwan 4 года назад

    Are you going to make more videos?!

  • @damienw4958
    @damienw4958 8 лет назад

    Yay for ramanujan

  • @EmmettJayhart
    @EmmettJayhart 8 лет назад

    Hi everyone! This week I'll be making loads of videos. *Proceeds to not upload a single video for months*

    • @Liliou
      @Liliou 7 лет назад

      Hi , I also miss his videos mate. :( But in the beginning i think he said "this week I've been making loads of videos" because he uploaded 3 videos in a row before this one talking about Ramanujan. ^^

  • @ritamchakraborty40
    @ritamchakraborty40 8 лет назад +1

    i am following this channel regularly and also numberphile.. i have seen a couple of videos on sum of n natural no. upto infinity is (-1/12) and you have also shown that it is also applied in string theory in physics...
    but it cant be true.. i would request you to upload the proof of that theorem so that there can be some sort of explanation to that....
    also if possible add some videos on the lost notebooks of ramanjan.. and proof of partition and the prime number theorem of ramanujan..

  • @ferncat1397
    @ferncat1397 8 лет назад +1

    The black hoodie makes you look even more like the Master though XD

  • @oreallysir
    @oreallysir 8 лет назад

    oh no its your long lost twin who can never be seen in the same room as you

  • @moanilsson3448
    @moanilsson3448 5 лет назад +1

    I'm a simple girl. I see James Grime in a hoodie, I click.

  • @jackriver1999
    @jackriver1999 3 года назад

    As a filmmaker with an interest in maths, I agree entirely with your criticisms of the movie. I would have taken an entirely different approach with a Ramanujan biopic. Maths is such a sexy subject, the most creative subject, with the most wondrous patterns and structures.

  • @TheDamizyx
    @TheDamizyx 8 лет назад

    You should make a vid about the Puzzle "36 cube". i think you'll like that.

  • @ozdergekko
    @ozdergekko 8 лет назад

    I love all of your videos (and numberphile in general). But you and at least one of the women are just lovely. And the klein-bottle-guy. Do you always smile?

  • @InvitingShores
    @InvitingShores 8 лет назад

    The annotation links in the video don't work yet.

  • @211teitake
    @211teitake 8 лет назад

    And if you have been, thanks for watching.

  • @adityakhanna113
    @adityakhanna113 8 лет назад +1

    Thank you, Dr. Grime. i have said it a few times, I'll request you too *pushy*
    Could there be a formal movie review on numberphile of this movie?

  • @phampton6781
    @phampton6781 8 лет назад

    "A lot of scenes of people talking in rooms"Us singingbanana and Numberphile fans will love it then!

  • @RickyRoro777
    @RickyRoro777 8 лет назад

    I originally subscribed to Numberphile because I thought it was your channel.

  • @GyanPratapSingh
    @GyanPratapSingh 8 лет назад

    you should do a collaboration video with Mathologer sometime!

  • @PissTeviEzis
    @PissTeviEzis 8 лет назад

    Is anything new coming out soon? :

  • @damienw4958
    @damienw4958 8 лет назад

    Ha, beat you to it, already watched all those videos!

  • @Zoxesyr
    @Zoxesyr 8 лет назад

    please make an episode on the ABC conjecture!

  • @PeterHopeTindall
    @PeterHopeTindall 8 лет назад

    Now you mention it, you REALLY do look like that guy from Numberphile! :-)

  • @MIT2004
    @MIT2004 8 лет назад

    1:31 I think that's the first time I heard say "uh hum"

  • @Zedoy
    @Zedoy 8 лет назад +1

    So singingbanna you are saying you are not dr James grime from numberphile so who are you please tell me.(because I love you so much and you are awesome you are one of my favorite mathematicians if I want to rank you from my favorite mathematicians I put you rank/number 1)Thanks For Replying If You reply!😀

  • @ediza.8485
    @ediza.8485 8 лет назад

    In Pi/4 of your latest videos on Ramanujan, you forgot to say "And if you have been, thanks for watching". Phytagoras theorem confirmed!

  • @ChrisSPCs
    @ChrisSPCs 8 лет назад +1

    Wow he looks like that guy Big Pun left dead in the middle of little Italy, little did he know they riddled some middleman who didn't do diddley.

  • @nightmare9566
    @nightmare9566 8 лет назад +2

    I honestly don't know how many people pulling the "You look like the guy from numberphile" are joking, and how many are actually serious...

  • @vimotriciimpressae
    @vimotriciimpressae 8 лет назад

    How do you motivate yourself when you are discouraged?

  • @alexander51413
    @alexander51413 8 лет назад +1

    A mathematician in a hoodie!

  • @Minecraftster148790
    @Minecraftster148790 8 лет назад

    137k subs. My favourite number is 137. I would have done an exclamation mark but I didn't want people to think my favourite number was 137 factorial

  • @logancollier4505
    @logancollier4505 8 лет назад

    heres a problem. Using the RSA algorithm using big prime numbers to encrypt a message such as "bad chef" generates some pretty big and seemingly random numbers. These numbers are to big and are seemingly so unrelated, is there any one function you could use on all of them to get them back to letters or 1-26 and then reverse it?

  • @Milkermaner
    @Milkermaner 8 лет назад

    The mathematician who knew sassiness

  • @ToonGamesProject
    @ToonGamesProject 8 лет назад

    James, am I allowed to ask how old you are? I'm 16, and im starting to get really interested in maths, and looking at things like the Riemann Hypothesis, and Fermat's Last Theorem etc.

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  8 лет назад

      I'm 35. Have you read Fermat's Last Theorem by Simon SIngh? I recommend it.

    • @ToonGamesProject
      @ToonGamesProject 8 лет назад

      +singingbanana Oh wow you replied! I've heard about that yes, and I've seen the video on Numberphile as well.

  • @munjee2
    @munjee2 5 лет назад

    The guy from numberphile doesn't have a red mark on his upper right cheek though

  • @jolle938
    @jolle938 8 лет назад

    What do you make of this function?
    -ln(x^5*sin(x/cos(x^3))

    • @huttarl
      @huttarl 5 лет назад

      Add a right-parenthesis on the end, and you can see it graphed here: www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=-ln(x%5E5*sin(x%2Fcos(x%5E3))%EF%BB%BF) Looks like grass growing around a tree.

  • @TheMaplestrip
    @TheMaplestrip 8 лет назад +8

    Hmm, you do look a bit like Brady. It's probably the blonde hair.

  • @DanAI17
    @DanAI17 8 лет назад

    Wait a second... Have we ever seen him and the guy from numberphile in the same room??

  • @hakkbak
    @hakkbak 8 лет назад

    Are you in Cambridge in Michaelmas term? I want to meet you! And explain why physics > maths :DD

  • @Anodoin
    @Anodoin 8 лет назад

    Can we fans come together and buy this man a camera with a better image quality than a mid-80's tele?

    • @yxlxfxf
      @yxlxfxf 8 лет назад

      The camera is ok, I think the issue is the low lighting.

    • @DanDart
      @DanDart 8 лет назад

      +Famfly J like that there's enough lighting unlike so many

  • @DLMonsteer
    @DLMonsteer 8 лет назад

    You do look like the guy from Numberphile omg I just realised 😱😱

  • @francoistrempe
    @francoistrempe 8 лет назад +7

    now that you say it, you do look like the guy from numberphile!

    • @Zak24_
      @Zak24_ 7 лет назад +1

      He is the guy from numberphile. I don't think he actually meant that

  • @osirismother
    @osirismother 8 лет назад +1

    you suit a hoodie...more casual wear please!!

  • @alndhogr7009
    @alndhogr7009 8 лет назад

    whay we can not slove 2^x=8

  • @andreguimaraes9347
    @andreguimaraes9347 8 лет назад +12

    You keep saying "Mathologist" instead of "Mathloger" xD

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  8 лет назад +9

      +André Reis Flip. I think I slurred mathologer's and mathologist.

  • @ishwar8119
    @ishwar8119 8 лет назад

    Actually those two people are the same(James Grime)

  • @prathameshsawant5574
    @prathameshsawant5574 8 лет назад +1

    Do you have one more channel named Dr. physics? Your voice is similar that guy.

  • @gildedbear5355
    @gildedbear5355 8 лет назад

    wait... you're not the guy from numberphile?! well, there goes my theory that all of the various mathematics channels on RUclips take place in the same universe! way to wreck my dream...

  • @-ion
    @-ion 8 лет назад

    Y-you're not the guy from Numberphile? Mind blown.

  • @Scripter-bx6zy
    @Scripter-bx6zy 8 лет назад

    It's a Parker Square of a movie, then?

  • @pegy6384
    @pegy6384 8 лет назад

    Numberphile Dr. Grime has never been filmed in a hoodie--that's how I tell whether I'm on your channel or the other one.

  • @go2shehroz
    @go2shehroz 8 лет назад +1

    you are the guy from numberphile ik it

  • @anshikasingh6555
    @anshikasingh6555 8 лет назад

    a professor
    from the Federal University of
    Oye Ekiti in Nigeria, has
    solved the Riemann
    Hypothesis . Sir do this news is right

  • @Thezenmaster45
    @Thezenmaster45 8 лет назад

    +singingbanana You did not complete the sequential order of videos to watch,sir

  • @daylenriggs
    @daylenriggs 8 лет назад

    Whoa dude. Put on a purple shirt and you could be the numberphile guy's twin.

  • @hewhobringsthenight9907
    @hewhobringsthenight9907 3 года назад

    im still tripping as i just have been told this guy and the numberphile guy isnt the same person

  • @tjejojyj
    @tjejojyj 7 лет назад

    Before you make some more videos you should invest in a better microphone. A decent lapel microphone can be had for about US25. It's the only thing letting your down. (Maybe borrow/steal Brady's?). I had been gradually working my way through Numberphile's back catalogue and now I've diverted on to your. All good stuff although I would like a video about Godel's incompleteness theorems.

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  7 лет назад +2

      And this sort of comment is why I don't like to make videos anymore. I make these videos for free and in my free time.

    • @rooftop1510
      @rooftop1510 7 лет назад

      Ignore those people!!! I love your videos, it keep me enthusiastic about math like how I was when I am younger. You are motivating me to do a post grad in math. (:

    • @tjejojyj
      @tjejojyj 7 лет назад

      +singingbanana Cripes! If it wasn't clear enough in my comment I think your videos are tremendous. Too bad if you have stopped production :-(

  • @iugoeswest
    @iugoeswest 8 лет назад +2

    parker square!

    • @DanDart
      @DanDart 8 лет назад

      this was a well made video and was a magic square of a video, not some parker square

  • @uditchowdhury9518
    @uditchowdhury9518 6 лет назад

    Wait.. aren't you James Grime ? .....

  • @username17234
    @username17234 8 лет назад +1

    These crazy people, you don't look like Brady at all.

  • @dogeasaurusrex7421
    @dogeasaurusrex7421 8 лет назад

    Why didn't you tell us you had a twin? Brady is awesome!

  • @sprajosh
    @sprajosh 7 лет назад

    The guy on numberphile is not you? I seriously thought you have two maths based channels in RUclips

  • @TheHacker00077
    @TheHacker00077 8 лет назад

    wait I don't get it is this guy and the guy from numberphile not the same person???

  • @Tsskyx
    @Tsskyx 8 лет назад +1

    Talking about how similar you look to some people, to me, you look like Martin Freeman, only younger.

  • @Wegnerrobert2
    @Wegnerrobert2 8 лет назад

    wait omg is this ACTUALLY the guy from numberphile?
    The asian professor who always does stuff with physical objects

  • @anonymouse740
    @anonymouse740 8 лет назад

    You do look quite similar to that Numberphile guy! Perhaps you could get Numberphile to link to your channel and get even more subscribers?
    Also he has a better mic!

  • @ankitthakurankit4764
    @ankitthakurankit4764 Год назад

    I thinkit was a joke but please confirm me he is the numberphile guy right??

  • @DanDart
    @DanDart 8 лет назад

    You look like him...
    so who would win in a maths-off between Dr James Grime and Dr James Grime?

  • @Mumra2K
    @Mumra2K 8 лет назад +2

    Use RUclips "cards" please for those of us on mobile, thanks.

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  8 лет назад +2

      +Mumra 2K Aah, fair point. I'm a bit behind on RUclips's new features. I'll have a look.

    • @Mumra2K
      @Mumra2K 8 лет назад

      singingbanana Firstly, thanks for the reply, sorry if I appeared curt. Yes, cards are really cool. support.google.com/youtube/answer/6140493?hl=en
      You can also use them to engage your audience with polls extremely easily using Cards. I'd love to see future videos from you which would include polls, for fun or feedback.
      Love your work, I've been following for YEARS along with other Brady affiliated videos. Please continue doing RUclips.

    • @singingbanana
      @singingbanana  8 лет назад

      +Mumra 2K Excellent. I will do that later.

  • @NickZack
    @NickZack 8 лет назад

    Hey you look like the guy from Numberphile.

  • @CrabSpy
    @CrabSpy 8 лет назад

    Who would ever confuse a banana with a guy?

  • @SlipperyTeeth
    @SlipperyTeeth 8 лет назад +2

    You look nothing like that guy from Numberphile.

  • @karlcupid1274
    @karlcupid1274 8 лет назад

    Is he your twin banana then yea?

  • @ThomasJDavis
    @ThomasJDavis 5 лет назад

    Yeah. Honestly, I got the impression that half of the movie's message was based in promoting theism and it even seemed, to some extent, to mock non-believers. It promoted a platonic view of numbers, strawmanned nominalism when Toby Jones's character says Newton "invented gravity". It just felt like there was some bad-faith screenplay.

  • @jqerty
    @jqerty 8 лет назад +2

    I've watched and I haven't been thanked for it :/

    • @jqerty
      @jqerty 8 лет назад +1

      Roter Widerling
      Thank you as well

    • @DanDart
      @DanDart 8 лет назад

      But have you really been watching?

  • @wmprokipchak
    @wmprokipchak 8 лет назад

    I do wish that you pronounced his name as every Indian narrated youtube video I've found does, Ruh-MAHN-u-jen, not Ram-uh-NEW-jen.

  • @bwroth355
    @bwroth355 8 лет назад

    oh great and wise professor Grimes, I am in need of guidance. my friend posted this evil little riddle and I'm not sure of the answer...
    If you choose an answer to this question at random, what is the chance you'll be correct?
    A) 25%
    B) 50%
    C) 60%
    D) 25%