US, Japan, and Philippines hold joint coast guard drills | DW News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- The US, Philippines and Japan have begun joint naval drills for the first time, in the strategically important South China Sea. They're being held in waters off the Bataan province of the Philippines, and will last a week. They include maritime law enforcement training and search-and-rescue missions.
The nations are boosting how they cooperate to deter growing Chinese assertiveness. Beijing claims large maritime regions that overlap the exclusive economic zones of other nations - including the Philippines.
Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#SouthChinaSea #drill #China
Chinese Coastguard vessel: _"In the face of the friendly relationship between China and the Philippines, we hope you can cooperate with our peace. Do not take inappropriate behaviours which will interfere with maritime security."_
Proceeds to cut off Philippine Coastguard vessel. 🙄
and if you accuse china of being an (anachronic) imperialist they will deny it vehemently and say it's because 'historical reasons' that they do what they do (today's international laws are not for them to obey even if they ratified them - hypocrite much?)
The Chinese coast guard's speaker couldn't accurately convey the intended tone and meaning of his pre-written response since he's obviously not experienced at speaking English. The response was spelled out as:
_We hope you can cooperate with "our peace." _*_*winky face*_*
China is liar.
@winstonorilla4322What are you brabling about? "Seeing is owning" is not a chinese saying.
1:50 there the troublemaker
Thank you Japan 🇯🇵 🇺🇸 for supporting the Philippines 🇵🇭
@melbaltazar29
🫡👍👍👍 THANKS to Japan and All Allied countries standing for the Philippines Rights over its lawful territories ! ❤️💕
Go Philippines we are in our rights
Given your national resources, Phl could hv been a world power too, unlike now, a slave nation to US, a very risky position.
Y did ur past president suck up to china?
What China is claiming is totally wrong
nope is not. but i wouldnt expect you to understand facts as a typical western puppet that you are.
Have they been right ever?
yeah, they basically want every single space of the South "China" Sea, look at how close their 9 dash line is to other neighboring countries. They are claiming everything. lol
just look at "National Map of Shame" on google.. see how ridiculous chinese are.. its dangerous to pay tribute to chinese emperor during ancient times.. chinese emperor will view you as part of China if you pay tribute to them.. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Y'all bashing here. But remember that China is the world's second biggest power, whike they still have the post-war territories drawn by the west on a map, that were designed for an economic backwater country.
In their eyes, that is not appropriate.
Return the 7 Chinese artificial islands to Mother Nature. Spread the dredged up coral reefs back into the sea.
@@LiberalismcelebratesDeathoh, thank you for confirming receipt of my feedback. 😂
@@LiberalismcelebratesDeathsweet! A great close to the week. Teamwork buddy.
Should be a fairly easy job, considering it is all tofu-dreg .
a small team of Uighur prisone…uh, I mean…re-educatees, with shovels should be able to complete that task in a week.
Those 7 islands based on Chinese view : thanks to great mother nature’s masterpiece to give birth to those natural islands. 😅😅😅 China will accelerate its path to build more natural islands.
Actually, the US military may be interested in taking those artificial islands themselves. It would be for the best interests of the United States of America after all. 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
The Hague decision in 2016 is legally binding and final *whether China likes it or not.*
_Countries are enforcing it._
The Hague decision? you mean those puppest of the ICC? i live in the Netherlands and trust me they are not any better then our puppet government. they obey the law of the US. they follow every single lie of the US and nothing more.
The Hague's decision was not "legally binding".
Even UN ICJ rulings aren't "legally binding".
The UN ICJ also ruled that Diego Garcia was to be returned to the Chagossian people in 2016 ... how's that going?
Enforcing? How dare you😅😅. United stated carrier fleets retreated from South China Sea just the day after “ruling”. It is impossible to remove china out of South China Sea unless the eruptions of world war 3.
@@leahcasey2678 The UN rulings are binding on member states of the UN. Not complicated pal.
China joined UNCLOS with conditions. China do not accept solve any sea territories disputation within the frame of UNCLOS. Otherwise, China will quit UNCLOS. The Hague tribunal is not part of United Nations. I do hope you understand this point.
The more Philippine economic growth, the better
totally agree
the more it grows, the more healthy politician pockets become🤣🤣🤣
@@chrysllerryu4171 ooppsss... Not only politicians, but the military generals are highly corrupted too...
I hope they can counter the crime and corruption that has plagued the Philippines for too long. Such wonderful people deserve peace and prosperity! 🇺🇲❤🇵🇭
Whoa, slow down, partner! China's got a grip on trade in the Philippines 🇵🇭, they've got double the trade compared to the US 🇺🇸, making others feel a little blue 💙.
If the Philippines pull the plug, they might end up as the jokers on the world stage 🤡.
Adios to better jobs at home, and hello to being renowned as the world's finest housemaids 🏠🧹 and gardeners 🌻.
How's that for a plot twist? 😉
The Philippines' humbleness to ask Beijing to not harass its people for 6 years is not being taken seriously by the Chinese govt. we've been neutral and even sided with China for that amount of time.
now that we know that our requests has been falling on deaf ears, we ask US to help us instead.
now they have more problems than our ships patroling our own waters.
Didn't they dump human waste in Philippines waters?
Revive a SEATO type defense organization but only within Asean. If a defense pact can be made by Malaysia, Philippines, and Indonesia, China will rethink its aggression.
🇺🇸💖🇵🇭
China always says..... BLAH BLAH BLAHHHH 🤣🤣🤣
🇯🇵 🇵🇭 🇦🇺 🇺🇸 ❤
Dapat kasi naging one of the states na lang ang Pilipinas para wala nang problema nung dati pa.
E kaso mayabang mga pulitiko sa atin puro nman state side nasa kukote nangangarap mag sipag aral sa h.universirty sarap sana ng buhay ng mga pilipino parang guam, hawaii 😁
This Guy aint lying, he knows whats going on.
It's gonna be interesting to see the coast guard in action when (wish I could underline that) things go cray cray with the prc.
This is like back in 1937-1939. Everyone knows something is coming. We don't know when. We don't know what it will look like. And we don't know what will happen after.
But we can all feel it in our bones. In our hearts. And on our skin.
Hopefully the prc will back down. I doubt Pooh Bear Xi will given his background, history and psychological profile.
"No man is an island."
Even a bully can't stop people gathering together to reinforce moral standards. Reinforcing security and stability for peace is what really matters.
It's obvious the one being in troubled are the one who shows aggression and the one doesn't obey the international rule of law.
taking pride of having a great military might doesn't make you any less vulnerable to great loses.
China claims of south china sea is baffling, they dont have any Island there, those sea are belong to the ASEAN and International water.
artificial island that they built 😂. smart china
"We have to understand... *insert introductory course material on foreign politics*"
Now you know what will happen if you don't stop bullying your neighbor
"We should safeguard the stability and peace in the regions surrounding the SCS and that should include nations staying quiet and welcoming while we encroach in their sovereignty and EEZ." - CCP
No war pls 🙏🙏
The Philippine Sea territory is the largest in terms of area, that's why China wants to claim most of it ...
America's dogs always present for service !!!
Where is SPAIN? How come Spain is not part of these exercise?
I think it depends on the countries economy, there is a big economy changes in the world if economic situation decrease they cannot afford their policy.
Imperialist American vs Hypocritical Imperialist China
I think fire in South chania sea
Lezzz Goooo
No one can beat China. 😅
this is the product of aggression by Chengwa
Solution: keep area neutral. No one can own it! no-win-sum-solution.
Actually the Philippines do it, but it's greedy neighboring countries lust of Territories, like Vietnam(the Whole Spratlys), Malaysia(North Borneo, parts of Spratlys), China(the Whole West Philippine Sea)and Taiwan(for Batanes Islands,Northern Philippines) is slowly targeting and sadly occupied Philippines Islands meant for Fisheries and Environmental Research.
Mahirap pagkatiwalaan ang mga tsikwa mga traydor Yan mga makasarili pag kaharap ka mabuti pero pagnakatalikod kana Doon ka sasaksakin
Mga gahaman kahit hindi nila pag aari Lalo na pag mapapakinabangan nila bale wala na sa kanila ang pagkakaibigan
After poking the Russian 🐻, America is now set on poking the Chinese 🐼.
But poking the Russian hamster is so fun.
The Chinese panda looks asleep most the time.
@@davidnoelfranks1124 that's when the 🎉party🎉 begins! 😁
@@davidnoelfranks1124 Who says they haven't? Your question raises a follow up question: If Russia pokes back, does anyone notice?
China pokes all its neighbhors that are weak. Until the US comes to visit its neighbors. Same for Russia. Then Russia and China turn into little sissies and cry in the comments section about how it is unfair that they have to contend with someone their own size and not the little kids they are used to bullying. What a pathetic.. ....... you know what.
poor china hahaha
War veterans
US should reconsider reviving SEATO to allow non-NATO allies to join, and merge with existing NATO so that those countries are protected by Article 5.
stay dumb please. always funny to see dumb people talking like they know stuff.
@@davidnoelfranks1124 Yeah they are actually, Russia has had at least 7 Kinzhal hypersonic missiles shot down over Ukraine so far by just the Patriot air defense systems alone. Russia can't even handle a country on their border with a fraction of their population but you think Russia can take on the US? One of only 3 countries with a larger population than Russia, and the greatest military on the planet, compared to Russia being the 2nd strongest army in Ukraine
@@davidnoelfranks1124 majority of China neighbors have that even the Philippines again can China stand up to all of them?
So this guy is just reading his script 👎🏼
What a nonsense comment
Who is the trouble maker! USA! 😂
China is the troublemaker. And so is all of humanity. Stop crying about America.
No. It's China.
China is stop lying.
The Cairo Declaration of World War II stated that China, as a victorious country, took over the territory of the South China Sea after Japan surrendered, and the proposal to divide the South China Sea along the twelve section line was recognized. At this time, the Philippines and Vietnam were colonies before the war and were occupied during World War II. are not independent yet,The controversy in the South China Sea was deliberately created by the United States during the Cold War to contain China.
but china signed the UNCLOS or the united nations law of the sea. Which effectively and definitely subjected china and other signatories to this. The UNCLOS came later. Hence, overriding whatever has been agreed to in the past that is directly or indirectly contrary to it.
When did China win an international war? 😂 China lost to the British, and to the Japanese during World War 2. If the US did not bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki then Japan would never surrender. China lost and was never a victorious country. Soon, you'll also lose the war you started.
There are two china's. Get over it.
Bruh, the 12-dash line was not even made by mainland China; it was made by Taiwan. Are you really all thieves and grabbers? It was just given to China by international law after World War II and also revoked by international law after the Cold War, so just as it was given to them by international law, they should get it back by international law. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Haha. That China is the Republic of China, not CCP viruses People's Republic of China, that backstabbed the Nationalists.
Taiwan is a province of China, so China can do whatever it wants in its own water space.
@Ahmet Tekin Nonsense!
Is Xi sharing the same historical map with Putler?
@Ahmet Tekin what are you on about lol.
@Ahmet Tekin Taiwan is part of China China still owns Taiwan its their Sovereignty not of Taiwan. learn something
@Ahmet Tekinwhy would he. also he did come to Taiwanese air space because its THEIR air space. Taiwan is owned by china so who ever is there other then china and Taiwan is in violation of air space. you're not smart i see.
See what we should do is make some artificial island in the South China Sea and claim US territorial waters there. And then make a NATO base there and hold drills with Japan, Taiwan, S Korea, Australia and the Phillippines.
No need. Phillipines is a rather big ship with 7000+ vessels ... and could be supplied in shorts.
Sounds good to me.
I missed the lads name, but he is a very interesting and kind speaker🥲
Love Philippines from Japan! 🇵🇭🇯🇵
Wow we have a new guest allies 🇯🇵🇵🇭🇺🇲
Likewise! Fr ph
🇯🇵🇵🇭🇺🇸🇩🇪 let's go
Same here brother. ❤
War veterans
when you have war nations in ww2 and post-ww2 all on the same side 🇺🇸🇯🇵🇰🇷🇵🇭🇻🇳
At this point, you know you are doing the right thing when the CCP complains.
That is a childish statement. The CCP is a much more reasonable government than is often discribed, even though I don't agree with authoritarianism. Compare them to russia for a second.
you hit it right in the head lol
really? are we seeing two different chinas?
@@JG-xi4tu Is it reasonable to build military bases in the Philippines' backyard?
Reasonable to cut off other vessel 😅
Japan and Philippines should craft mutual defense treaty.
They are both cannon fodder if war breaks out.
Thats vood id3a they should do it
Japan and philippines already has defense treaty.its trilateral defense treaty usa japan and ph
They are already planning it several years ago. Just waiting for Japan to confirm it.
Philippines has a maritime rights and territorial claim in the Spratlys Islands. We can defend our own national interests that under of Exclusive Economic Zone. 🇺🇸🇯🇵🇵🇭
🇺🇸💖🇵🇭
You need to align with other countries to protect you rights in the SCS against China. All other countries are increasing their defense budget to deter a common aggressor China.
Okay pinoise
Delusional statement. Phils can defend itself against china? What funny statement.
Well then, good luck to you on your own
Long live Philippines 🇵🇭 US 🇺🇸 and Japan 🇯🇵 partnership ❤️
Soon, Australia 🇭🇲 and South Korea 🇰🇷 would join us as well.
Against the Biggest Bully of the world, 🇨🇳
a master with his 4 dogs to hunter a dragon, you will fail of course.
@@pipiqiqi4010 dragon?more like paper dragon 😂😂🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@yuigahama3189 whether is it a paper dragon? you can ask your master. if it is a paper dragon really, i think your master had killed it many decades earlier.
you read history and geopolitics?
Taiwan(ROC in Nanjing then) claims 11dashline since 1945, such claim got supported by West and Soviet, US navy even gave 4 warships to Chinese took over Taiping and Dongsha in 1946, why international sociaty didn't oppose ROC's claim then? why US didn't give South China Sea to Phillppines then? because ROC is most important ally with West and Soviet as biggest contributor against Japan in Asia during WWII, but American Phillippines, French Vietnam, British Malaya were still colonies in 1945, if US master gave a gift to his Chinese friend then Phillippines slave couldn't say NO then, today's world order is WWII order.
China(PRC in Beijng) inherited ROC's same claim after Chinese Civil War 1949, but gave up Bach Long Vi island to North Vietnam in 1957 and claim 9dashline since then,
Vietcong used to support PRC claim in South China Sea when CCP and Vietcong were allies against USA then, but Vietnam inherited same claim like South Vietnam after 1975.
Philippines took ROC Taiwan's Thitu island in 1971 and Taiwan gave up to take back under USA pressure, because ROC's biggest threat is PRC.
PRC Beijing retook Paracel island from South Vietnam 1974, PRC retook Johnson South Reef from Vietnam 1988, but PRC didn't take all Spratly Islands when PLA navy was still tiny.
so from Taipei perspective especailly from KMT, Phillippines and PRC are both invader in ROC territory, but clearly PRC is bigger threat than Phillippines to Taiwan island.
because Taiwan is too weak and heavily dependent on USA so Taiwan kept silent, ROC now only controls Taiping and Dongsha island, DPP didn't even criticize Phillippines anymore.
so from Beijing perspective, ROC is civil war loser in exile, Phillippines is invader, PLA can just retake all islands within 9dashline,
but CCP didn't want to push ASEAN to pro-USA, then PRC calmed down tension and welcomed Duterte because he is pro-China invader,
but when Marcos becomes pro-US invader, then PRC would give Phillippines maximum pressure, like arming Scarborough Shoal again.
so what China implies: if you want peace then don't side with USA, just keep following Duterte's route then I won't harrass you.
too less countries, where is United Nations Command Force?
China should respect and obey the internatiol law UNCLOS ,
South china belong to south asia country
🇵🇭🇹🇼🇲🇾🇻🇳🇮🇩
UNCLOS is just a international treaty rather than law. United States didn’t
even sign to join it. The tension in South China Sea the conflicts between China and United States per se.
Yeah. If only Malaysia would show some guys and side with the rest of south East Asia ......
@NEO The flag of Monaco is graphically similar to the flag of Indonesia, with differences in their dimension ratios (Monaco's at 4:5 and Indonesia's at 2:3
🇺🇸🇯🇵🇵🇭 Strong Allies Together
The US has a history of abandoning it's allies when it is for the best interest of those in US government though......
@@walterdayrit675 abandoning it’s allies? Sourcemarsyusip 😂
Two bugs
@@squizi8238 The US abandoned the South Vietnamese to the communists in 1975. The US abandoned Somalia to the warlords in the 1990s. The US abandoned Afghanistan to the Taliban terrorists in 2021.
Hmmm.....I sense a pattern here. 🤔
@@walterdayrit675 those country are not even allies with the usa
Lets goooo 🇺🇸 🇵🇭 🇯🇵 !!!!!
When you have historic rivals, hold joint military exercises. You know you are in trouble. 😊
Yep China is in Trouble, Spratlys nor Taiwan will be in their hands. All they can do is cry about it for another thousands of years.
R u chinese
No its not historic rivals you mean to say territorial grabber a thief????...who's entering philippine backyard wanna grab the piece of philippine territory...not a so called rival more of a thief!
@@melyaborot1707 You all didn't understand the context of what Jeffrey Chen was saying. When he says rivals cooperate, he means Japan, the Philippines, and the US, which have a long history of conflict among themselves; first, PH vs. US in the 1989-1902 Philippine-American War and Japan vs. US-PH in World War 2, were all rivals in the beginning and are now cooperating at the same cost against China because they are in trouble.
@@JC0820 You forgot, what about US CHINA VS. JAPAN in world war 2?
The only way to avoid a war in the SCS is:
- China 🇨🇳 must obey UNCLOS ruling in 2016.
ah the master puppet speaks as well. China doesnt have to do anything. its the US who provokes war with them. China is completely in their right to do what ever they want.
The Hague ruling? It is not consistent with UNCLOS 😅😅😅
@AhmetTekinA UNCLOS annex 294 .Disputation should get the approval of both sides. Unilateral arbitrary rule? Bro Philippines is just a tool for United States. International law without enforcement is just waste toilet paper. The United Nations even do not have any enforcement on any international conflicts without permission of security council. Whether you like it or not, the real international is power rather than words.
@winstonorilla4322 Bro, think in the way as a normal human beings. The Hague tribunal has no enforcement to guarantee its ”rightful” judgement. It just gave Philippines a casus belli to start a war with China. With China’s raising power, Philippines will be kicked out of South China Sea. Love and peace.
@@RichMidasPapa AND UNCLOS MEANS NOTHING TO THE CCP, RIIIIIIGHT?!!
For the first time... that's how we got alll those islands. This has been a long time coming.
She means, "Ask our permission first." 😅 The Philippines Navy needs some much bigger boats. China is not interested in compromise, nor is Xi interested in "Competition."
Let’s go USA. Assuring sovereignty of those threatened by xi jinping and co
🤣🤣🤣
Many islands of ASEAN have been claimed by China as China's territory, it's not only Separately Island, also Natuna.😂😂😂😂😂 China have been made the map by their self, the map was so different with another and then China would claimed as China's territory
Not South China Sea! It is ASEAN sea!😅
Exactly.
True 😂
Its only SEA Sea, South East Asian Sea
wELL AGREE NAMAN AKO SA SINABI NI dONmCLLIN
China likes to say the they named the South China Sea and hence they own everything in the SCS. If China claims the SCS, then the Philippines will claim the Philippine Sea. That is the largest sea in the world. China will not be able to sail to the US if the Philippines claim the whole of the Philippine Sea. India will then claim the Indian Ocean and bar Chinese vessels from sailing there as well.
you read history and geopolitics?
Taiwan(ROC in Nanjing then) claims 11dashline since 1945, such claim got supported by West and Soviet, US navy even gave 4 warships to Chinese took over Taiping and Dongsha in 1946, why international sociaty didn't oppose ROC's claim then? why US didn't give South China Sea to Phillppines then? because ROC is most important ally with West and Soviet as biggest contributor against Japan in Asia during WWII, but American Phillippines, French Vietnam, British Malaya were still colonies in 1945, if US master gave a gift to his Chinese friend then Phillippines slave couldn't say NO then, today's world order is WWII order.
China(PRC in Beijng) inherited ROC's same claim after Chinese Civil War 1949, but gave up Bach Long Vi island to North Vietnam in 1957 and claim 9dashline since then,
Vietcong used to support PRC claim in South China Sea when CCP and Vietcong were allies against USA then, but Vietnam inherited same claim like South Vietnam after 1975.
Philippines took ROC Taiwan's Thitu island in 1971 and Taiwan gave up to take back under USA pressure, because ROC's biggest threat is PRC.
PRC Beijing retook Paracel island from South Vietnam 1974, PRC retook Johnson South Reef from Vietnam 1988, but PRC didn't take all Spratly Islands when PLA navy was still tiny.
so from Taipei perspective especailly from KMT, Phillippines and PRC are both invader in ROC territory, but clearly PRC is bigger threat than Phillippines to Taiwan island.
because Taiwan is too weak and heavily dependent on USA so Taiwan kept silent, ROC now only controls Taiping and Dongsha island, DPP didn't even criticize Phillippines Vietnam anymore.
so from Beijing perspective, ROC is civil war loser in exile, Phillippines is invader, PLA can just retake all islands within 9dashline,
but CCP didn't want to push ASEAN to pro-USA, then PRC calmed down tension and welcomed Duterte because he is pro-China invader,
but when Marcos becomes pro-US invader, then PRC would give Phillippines maximum pressure, like arming Scarborough Shoal again.
so what China implies: if you want peace then don't side with USA, just keep following Duterte's route then I won't harrass you now even you are invading Chinese territory.
Everyone knows Phillipines wants USA to deter China, but CCP attacked USA, India, Soviet, Vietnam on border in last Cold War when China was poorer than Africa,
USA failed to deter CCP to intervene in Korean War and Vietnam War then, so can USA really deter CCP to intervene Fourth Indochina War today?
Vietnamese suffered 3 Indochina War as proxy war in Cold War, it's much much more brutal than today's Ukraine War between USA and Russia,
like CCP vs France in First Indochina War,
like CCP vs USA in Second Indochina War,
like CCP vs Soviet in Third Indochina War,
Three Indochina Wars killed at least 3 mllion locals, Phillippines was lucky because they don't know what is proxy war battlefield looked like,
they will know soon.
@@lvjinbin28 China will be the battle field and Xi will be eaten by dogs
@@lvjinbin28 Your history is bullsh!t mr. 50cents ROC was the claimant and even during those times some claimants have dissatisfaction even if US and some allies did acknowledge that ROC have claims and and then ROC has fallen and kicked out of the mainland during 1949 to early 1970s PRC was not even recognize as the legitimate government of China until US change sides and dump the fallen ROC in Taiwan plus even if you justify that you have a right to claim a fallen governments or countries territorial claims it will not work on this era its like Italy trying to claim the former roman empires territories your 9 dashline was already dumped by the Hauge and was deemed unlawful under international law/UNCLOS only China is insisting that the decision is unlawful plus the fact that those claims already died under UNCLOS laws when every country has a specified and fix territorial waters at 12 nautical miles from its shores and an EEZ you can try to claim and use those old ancient maps of Chinese fallen dynasties and claims of the fallen ROC but its pointless since lands and seas was redrawn already international laws was made and no one can own a sea nor an ocean only to themselves
It's unexpected to see US, Philippines and Japan in one team. In WW2, they've all had wars with each other.
Well US and Japan were allies during WW1, during those time philippines is under american rule basically during WW1 US, Philippines and Japan is in one time
World war 2 it was the US and the PH against Japan, conflict was resolved until one nation threatened all three. Now they stand united with other nations to combat one common enemy
west philippine sea not south china sea. chinese illegal claim ... because of the oil and gas in the spratley island belong to the philippines.
As a filipino, i supported this idea 100%..
As a filipino you are licking American boots
U r pawn 110%
@@xz1891 U r a prawn 200%
Bobo
@@wowulam7411 I'm your merica daddy, come to suk
Don is one of the finest political analysts in the Philippines. Always great to listen to his balanced analysis
Can you count how many times he said the words "salami slicing"?
He just said that China is exerting its influence (through soft, hard, sharp power) in other South East Asian countries and mentions the military exercises. However, he forgot to mention the recent military exercises of US, South Korea, and Thailand. The nations that China is coercing (Laos, Cambodia, Singapore) doesn't even have a stake on the disputed nine dash line. Both Laos and Cambodia are economically weak countries while Singapore is walking a tight rope between US and China. How reliable are these nations when China finally pulls the trigger?
He said so much generic and vague statements but not much nuance/details.
@ DOriginalKillua99 the discussion has clearly gone over your head. Even a simple person like me clearly understood what he meant. With the focus on the Philippines, Chinese aggrsiveness has already occupied certain features claimed by Philippines without pulling a trigger as u say. China does not need to pull triggers to achieve its goals as the analyst has clearly pointed out. While those countries u mentioned do not have direct stakes, they are part of ASEAN which china has been efficiently dividing through non military means as it continues to strengthen its presence in maritime southeast asia. That was the context. Which is why he said the alliance must address this loophole. You clearly are just commenting to attack not to understand. Lastly, Thailand may be US ally but it is not willing to bypass china so do not count that
@Mateo Louis I agree with you. Time is too short for a comprehensive discussion on that topic but still he explained everything in a non-specialists can understand. Kudos to DW and Sir Don
@@doriginalkillua99 You mean the myth created by uneducated peasants of the CCP and concluded that "South China Sea" including the West Philippine sea was all theirs despite not having any maritime culture as ancient as those of the islanders? Does the "Indian Ocean," all belong to India alone because early western cartographers were just as simple minded and thought that Asia was either China or India and forgot other cultures in between????
Its West Philippine Sea not South Chinese see... hahahaha
🇯🇵🇺🇸🇵🇭
Watching from Philippines
🇺🇸💖🇵🇭
Let's go!! 💪💪🇺🇸🇵🇭🇯🇵
Nice to see that the US and non-corrupt countries in the east are cooperating
And also the Phillippines.
Since when was the US a non-corrupt country?
Let's talk about WMD, Diego Garcia, Syrian oil fields, stolen Iranian oil/ships in international waters, over-the-horizon-drone strikes on innocents, stolen PPE from Cuba and Mexico, the use of Napalm, and radiation poisoning the people of the Marshall Islands.
Yikes!
@@mr2981 My thoughts exactly 😂😂
The act of teamwork is a good thing still, just funny to see the Philippines being called non-corrupt
they’re as corrupt as us make no mistake but hopefully change is coming in all countries for the better.
@@davidnoelfranks1124 Really? That's the best you could come up with?
America's buffer states. Keep up the good work boys.
Buffer states, also known as sacrificial pawns.
Viva Pilipinas! 🎉🎉🎉🎉 We will fight to protect not to bully.! ❤ 😎
*China🇨🇳 have maritime disputes with Taiwan, Japan, Vietnam, Philippines.*
make maritime border agreement & peace!
You can't achieve peace if there's China
How can China claim islands that are indigenously inhabited by the Filipinos for thousands of years?
Rather than showing just the Chinese claimed 9 dash line (2:30), it would be more appropriate to show the exclusive economic zones of all nations. These are ratified, the Chinese 9 dash line has been rejected by the international court in The Hague and is broadly rejected by the international community. The 9 dash line should never be shown on its own, as it is illegitimate.
If any japanese soldiers dare land on Chinese soil, he will suffer what the massacred Chinese suffered in Nanking.
What russia and china share is that they do not have borders, only areas of interest and security. The similarity of the behave of both are shocking similar.
Just look at the map, makes no sense at all that it should be Chinese territory. All countries except China in the area should be able to make a deal regarding the borders and rules of the sea.
中国对南海宣示主权的时候，菲律宾并未建国，你的意思是只要距离近，就是自己的领土对吗？越南是不是距离中国很近，那越南是不是应该属于中国
Two thousand years ago, when China was establishing a unified country, the border had already reached the South China Sea, and the Philippines only had monkeys.
A thousand years ago, when the Chinese exchanged trade with Arab countries through the Maritime Silk Road, there were only monkeys in the Philippines.
Six hundred years ago, when China's huge Zheng He fleet sailed in the South China Sea, Indian Ocean, Red Sea, and as far as East Africa, there were only monkeys in the Philippines.
In 1405 (the third year of Yongle in the Ming Dynasty), Zheng He sailed to the West and visited the Philippine Islands. According to the imperial edict of Emperor Yongle, Zheng He named Xu Chailao, the leader of overseas Chinese in the Philippines, as the governor of Luzon, and took charge of the financial, military, and cultural power in the region.
History cannot be taken for granted. If you look at the map of Greece, all the islands in the Aegean Sea belong to Greece even if they are close to Turkey.
@@令喆孟 The laws regarding borders in the water are working fine. Most countries have normal claims to the water outside their country and with small adjustments of 10-15% I think everyone can come along and live in peace. But China is just way of saying they own everything and are threatening every little country with China's huge military instead of looking for solutions and listening to what other countries have to say.
@@大国寡民-p4t 2000 years ago Jesus walked on water. No one care about what happened 1000 or 2000 years ago, China should respect its neighbours and try to find solutions instead of threatening to use military force.
We call the area ‘the south China sea’ and wonder why China thinks it can claim it as its own. Step 1 - change the name to something more inclusive which recognises the shared nature of the area.
i don't know about you in the west... but we call it the WEST PHILIPPINE SEA. it's the media.
@JB-xm8qi“the South China sea”这个说法是英国人提出的，中国不这么称呼
South China Sea is the dominant term used in English for the sea, and the name in most European languages is equivalent. This name is a result of early European interest in the sea as a route from Europe and South Asia to the trading opportunities of China. In the 16th century, Portuguese sailors called it the China Sea (Mare da China); later needs to differentiate it from nearby bodies of water led to calling it South China Sea.[4] The International Hydrographic Organization refers to the sea as "South China Sea (Nan Hai)".[5]
The Yizhoushu, which was a chronicle of the Western Zhou dynasty (1046-771 BCE), gives the first Chinese name for South China Sea as Nanfang Hai (Chinese: 南方海; pinyin: Nánfāng Hǎi; lit. 'Southern Sea'), claiming that barbarians from that sea gave tributes of hawksbill sea turtles to the Zhou rulers.[6] The Classic of Poetry, Zuo Zhuan, and Guoyu classics of the Spring and Autumn period (771-476 BCE) also referred to the sea, but by the name Nan Hai (Chinese: 南海; pinyin: Nán Hǎi; lit. 'South Sea') in reference to the State of Chu's expeditions there.[6] Nan Hai, the South Sea, was one of the Four Seas of Chinese literature. There are three other seas, one for each of the four cardinal directions.[7] During the Eastern Han dynasty (23-220 CE), China's rulers called the sea Zhang Hai (Chinese: 漲海; pinyin: Zhǎng Hǎi; lit. 'distended sea').[6] Fei Hai (Chinese: 沸海; pinyin: Fèi Hǎi; lit. 'boiling sea') became popular during the Southern and Northern Dynasties period. Usage of the current Chinese name, Nan Hai (South Sea), gradually became widespread during the Qing Dynasty.[8]
In Southeast Asia it was once called the Champa Sea or Sea of Cham, after the maritime kingdom of Champa (nowadays Central Vietnam), which flourished there before the sixteenth century.[9] The majority of the sea came under Japanese naval control during World War II following the military acquisition of many surrounding South East Asian territories in 1941. Japan calls the sea Minami Shina Kai "South China Sea". This was written 南支那海 until 2004, when the Japanese Foreign Ministry and other departments switched the spelling to 南シナ海, which has become the standard usage in Japan. "West Philippine Sea" is the official designation by the Philippine government of eastern parts of South China Sea that are included in the Philippines' exclusive economic zone. The term is also sometimes incorrectly used to refer to South China Sea as a whole.
In China, it is called the South Sea, (南海; Nánhǎi), and in Vietnam the East Sea, Biển Đông.[10][11][12] In Malaysia, Indonesia and the Philippines, it was long called the South China Sea (Tagalog: Dagat Timog Tsina, Malay: Laut China Selatan), with the part within Philippine territorial waters often called the "Luzon Sea", Dagat Luzon, by the Philippines.[13]
By your "logic" the Philippines might as well claim the Pacific ocean and rename it as the "East Philippine Ocean"! 😂😂😂
It should be "South East Asian Sea" SEAS
China salami slicing strategy in the South China Sea has resulted in 2016 Hague Tribunal ruling. And as a result of that China has 7 white elephants, militarily neutered, in the SCS.
I wonder from whom they learned the salami-slicing strategy: wink wink !.
you read history and geopolitics?
Taiwan(ROC in Nanjing then) claims 11dashline since 1945, such claim got supported by West and Soviet, US navy even gave 4 warships to Chinese took over Taiping and Dongsha in 1946, why international sociaty didn't oppose ROC's claim then? why US didn't give South China Sea to Phillppines then? because ROC is most important ally with West and Soviet as biggest contributor against Japan in Asia during WWII, but American Phillippines, French Vietnam, British Malaya were still colonies in 1945, if US master gave a gift to his Chinese friend then Phillippines slave couldn't say NO then, today's world order is WWII order.
China(PRC in Beijng) inherited ROC's same claim after Chinese Civil War 1949, but gave up Bach Long Vi island to North Vietnam in 1957 and claim 9dashline since then,
Vietcong used to support PRC claim in South China Sea when CCP and Vietcong were allies against USA then, but Vietnam inherited same claim like South Vietnam after 1975.
Philippines took ROC Taiwan's Thitu island in 1971 and Taiwan gave up to take back under USA pressure, because ROC's biggest threat is PRC.
PRC Beijing retook Paracel island from South Vietnam 1974, PRC retook Johnson South Reef from Vietnam 1988, but PRC didn't take all Spratly Islands when PLA navy was still tiny.
so from Taipei perspective especailly from KMT, Phillippines and PRC are both invader in ROC territory, but clearly PRC is bigger threat than Phillippines to Taiwan island.
because Taiwan is too weak and heavily dependent on USA so Taiwan kept silent, ROC now only controls Taiping and Dongsha island, DPP didn't even criticize Phillippines Vietnam anymore.
so from Beijing perspective, ROC is civil war loser in exile, Phillippines is invader, PLA can just retake all islands within 9dashline,
but CCP didn't want to push ASEAN to pro-USA, then PRC calmed down tension and welcomed Duterte because he is pro-China invader,
but when Marcos becomes pro-US invader, then PRC would give Phillippines maximum pressure, like arming Scarborough Shoal again.
so what China implies: if you want peace then don't side with USA, just keep following Duterte's route then I won't harrass you now even you are invading Chinese territory.
Everyone knows Phillipines wants USA to deter China, but CCP attacked USA, India, Soviet, Vietnam on border in last Cold War when China was poorer than Africa,
USA failed to deter CCP to intervene in Korean War and Vietnam War then, so can USA really deter CCP to intervene Fourth Indochina War today?
Vietnamese suffered 3 Indochina War as proxy war in Cold War, it's much much more brutal than today's Ukraine War between USA and Russia,
like CCP vs France in First Indochina War,
like CCP vs USA in Second Indochina War,
like CCP vs Soviet in Third Indochina War,
Three Indochina Wars killed at least 3 mllion locals, Phillippines was lucky because they don't know what is proxy war battlefield looked like,
they will know soon.
@@lvjinbin28 Thank you for your perspectives and fine long essay, brother, sir. They are fairly accurate. Here's my opinion, your view and PRC view is one and only. No relevant nation recognizes that view. PRC continues to threaten Taiwan and bullies US allies like the Philippines. PRC is now a strategic rival to the US. The US and its allies have the Hague Tribunal ruling of 2016 as an international legal basis to oppose PRC imperialism ( 9-dash line) in the South China Sea. "They will know soon". Lmao. If PRC attacks Taiwan, US will intervene without any legal Treaty. If PRC fires water cannons or lasers at Filipinos, it is an act of war according to US/Filipino Mutual Defense Treaty. The Filipinos "will know soon" When? When the cows come home? Lmao. PRC artificial islands do not have fresh water or mountains to hide weaponry and is 600 miles from PRC. They are against large islands with lots of fresh water and mountains. Excellent PRC military strategy. Lmao. "They will know soon" lmao. Putin is learning that "they will know soon" lesson in Ukraine. This is what PRC "they will know soon" lesson should really really look very very seriously. The US is not finished as a superpower yet. PRC is using its "gift" SCS against US selfish national interests. Brother, war is a terrible alternative as Putin and Ukraine are experiencing as we speak. Time for peaceful, diplomatic and meaningful negotiations in the South China Sea.
Japan is no doubt our true Ally and bestfriend ....but America ? .....not really ! But they're the most powerful country in the world .so yeah we can't help but to stick with them .
the US is japan’s biggest ally too
China is very far from Spratly Islands...do not claim that is not yours.
Good to see that the USA presence in that area is for peaceful purposes
Sure......😏
Tell a joke, USA is peaceful🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Fact: The US, in it's 247 years of existence, has currently only experienced less than 30 years of actual peacetime. Throughout most of US history, it has nearly always been at wartime.
@@jimgreen3533 Well you are a joke to begin with.
they should get Vietnam navy to join .
@Ahmet Tekin before this tri lateral drills, United States this week also conducted a training on Coast Guard personnel of different ASEAN country happen somewhere in Mindanao here in the Philippines.
@Ahmet Tekin ASEAN already did it tho
@winstonorilla4322
Bruh, China and Vietnam has bad blood since history lmao... It's like Ukraine and Russia but in Asia🤧🤧🤧🤧
very good analysis by this gentleman Don Mclain Gill
😂 Rodogie 🐕🦺Duterte is a China K'9 Pet's to the Philippines
Let's Go banzai 💪🇯🇵🇵🇭🇺🇲
Correction: West Philippine sea
Good. They should blind them back with a laser.
🇬🇧🇮🇱🇺🇸The Sixth is coming to an end. Revelation 17. 😂
Ezekiel 27(26). Let’s see who is the boss.
This shows how we Filipinos are disgusted with the greedy and tyrant oppressor.
Just imagine situation of fisherman in the Philippines
Having a hard time to do fishing because china claiming thats thier territory..but Philippines cant can do anything because the most of the businessman from china .
The Philippines need balance emotion instead pointing the rights. The usa helping the Philippines more on about who are powerful country. Philippines needs to balance the two country.
Very good 🌹
Time will come this small countries will come as one to fight for them.
I underestimated jr. Thought he would be selling out Philippines to China for $1b within a year. 😅
same. who would have thought. hahaha i wonder what the communist chinese party is feeling knowing their presidential investment did not bear fruit.
the analyst: countries like MANILA... as a BISAYA: ui, pag sure... kay mag lahi mani'g amo... LOL no problem... labon kay gubot kaayo mo dha nga part.. hahahahaha
God bless Philippines 🇵🇭 UNCLOS
Nagkaroon din kc nang pagkokolang ang dating pangulo nasi PRRRD pinabayaan nia
Philippines should join the QUAD.
better NATO
then it will not be called QUAD anymore, duh
I love his English
I wish the media would use the correct terms. China has not been assertive its been aggressive and belligerent. Assertive suggests being open to others opinions while expressing its own. This is not the case. China aggressively demands other bend to its rule, ie, "correct their incorrect behaviours" without stating what behaviours and how china wants them to behave. Its all very vague yet belligerent all at the same time.