Shashi is so eloquent he can convince his audience that the silent man sitting on his chair is not speaking not because he does not know how to speak but because he is wise beyond wisdom and does not need to speak.
I agree with him but In his reasoning I found the discussion of this question lacking - I wonder, can an accepting culture be accepting of unaccepting, non pluralistic ideologies which demean aspects of it, call them polytheistic, idol worshipping etc? And if yes, for how long? And who will ultimately change, the accepting ideology, or the exclusivist ideology?
@@verityveracity6704 An assumption that an illetrate Narendra Gautamdas Modi must rule India and incompetent people should work for the BJP. It s amazing the so-called protectors of democracy practice religious jingoism.
It’s such a shame that such an erudite and progressive idea can’t get traction for want of leadership, not one lacking in articulation, as clearly seen, but more so in the ability to enact
@@anthrax0pranav ignore people him, just wannabe's. They don't have a clue about history and philosophies, just "andh bhakts". To them people like Shashi tharoor are fools and Modi and Rahul are geniuses
I agree he is talking about the ideal India and lacks pragmatism. He represents a constituency, where a section of people have to appeased for him to stay in power.
AN amazing man and a gift to all but, particularly India (Bharat, don't want to piss anyone off) . India has produced some remarkable people in all fields of life. Dr. Tharoor is the man who knows the language and the oratory skills to bring it out and showcase these achievements. .
When people talk about Ambedkar, i just wonder that why they don't talk about Ambedkar's view on islam & muslims & how he exposed them. I would suggest people to read a book called Pakistan or Partition by BR Ambedkar. Whatever he predicted regarding this jihadi cult have proved to be right & he clearly mentions that these people are a headache & unnecessary burden for any society. And he also said that it's better not to keep them in India after partition.
@@heheboiii3566 yes well a lot of the “forefathers” were British coolies. Bharat is a Hindu rastra and always will be. And obviously majority of the people feel the same became they keep voting for the Hindu party….that’s democracy. Sounds like you’re a fascist who doesn’t respect democracy.
Shashi tharoor’s brilliant Defence of Rahul Gandhi’s speeches abroad. No apology needed. Rather Modi must apologize for his utterances of shame being Indian. PM did disrespect of the Nation that made a chaiwala a PM due to vibrant Democracy, whom He is bent upon Destroying today. Arrogance of Modi would be his downfall.
Respected tharoor sir, Need your comments on our wrestler protested at jantar mantar and violence in Manipur, Plz bring us your comments plz, After all u r our leader,.....?
In the comments, I can see, majority of people were amazed by his english speech rather than by the content he said. He described the Hindu rashtra very well but he has completely misguided about the agendas of current govt(BJP). Depriving the rights of minority section or any kind of discrimination against them is not their goal. Tharoor wanted unity among all the people but the people themselves are creating a rift and politicians adding fuel to that. Current govt also wants unity but not at the cost of scapegoating Hindus.
Hats off to MP Shashi Tharoor a thinker and die hard Indian divergent to BJP and RSS. Demolished idea of Hindu Rashtra Idea of narrow minded politicians and Hindutva idea. Excellent narration of Democracy of India
Once Congress made efforts towards hiding Ambedkar and now political compulsion making congress to accept Ambedkar.....well atleast verbally......you can't trust Congress Congress=BJP as Ambedkar mentioned : it is useless to make a distinction between the secular and priestly Hindu. Both are kith and kin. They are two arms of the same body, and one is bound to fight for the existence of the other.
Tharur maybe an eloquent speaker but he can spin doctor the truth It is about time that congress people start recognising what the present government has achieved better than the congress
yes...what has this government achieved? you mean the split in society?Divide and rule? Yes? Nearly as good as British Raj! only done by Indians to Indians ...so worse
let's appreciate the role of elites and Brahmins to keep this country together. No matter matter which state you are in you will find a high minder brahmin in power. Shahi is being modest not recognising the role his community to the birth of the idea of India and keeping it so for everyone else.
Mr Tharror, all goodi goodi things is talking about is because of the civilization our forefathers have practiced and taught to his generation. And that civilization is Aryan civilization.. which 99% population of the country belongs
Ask the Government to speak about Chronie Capitalist being covered.....we said Shashi , ms journalist you are making points which were only increase your trp and wasting time of Country
Maximum by minority, minimum by majority,,,lo ban gai sarkar,,,this is the whole idea of speech.... until CONGRESS don't consider every citizen of india EQUAL till then ....they are not coming in power.
Sheer blabbering aimless or mild manner discouraging and undermining Modi adminstration's policy; using slick words. While massaging Rahul's ball he forgot China taunt for which he (Rahul) declared ;peaceful nation'.
India was partitioned not because of religion but Congress withdrawing its consent to 1946 cabinet mission plan of strong autonomous states due to pressure from business houses profiteering under centralized British rule. These business houses were also the chief patrons of Congress which is why Congress had to withdraw its consent. 1947, was not independence but transfer of power from the British to the allies of the British. Before 1947, only roughly 51% of today's India was British India rest were 565 independent kingdoms under the suzerainty of the British crown. Forced centralized rule in both India and Pakistan, countries which never existed prior to arrival of East India Company, is the root cause for corruption, concentration of power in the hands of extremely few, extreme poverty, backwardness and secessionist movements in large parts of the nation. The way forward is going back to 1946 cabinet mission plan where power rests with the states and centre represented by every state of the union and not one political party only in charge of defense, communication, currency and foreign affairs.
Not sure what the interviewer is trying to achieve - promote an anti-constitutional, narrow minded viewpoint? Aghast that India Today is giving Hindutva a platform to legitimize itself.
@@CarpeDiem-ml5ld vivekanands hindutva where he held a pastor by his collar and threatened to throw him in the ocean when he was spitting venom against hinduism.
Excellent talk but has some nonsense/lies inserted for political correctness. 75 years is also reflection how majority is humiliated and ignored in the name of secularism. Hindu temples not allowed by themselves but run by Govt where as Wafq is granted millions of acre is one example. there is difference what's narrated vs reality. Mayawati referred twice as symbol of new India but wont support or recognize Murmu as president, reflects Tharoor as politician. Unfortunately Tharoor spoke more as politician . Modi's foreign audience was Indian not front of foreign audience.
@5:42, Shri Tharoor mentions surname (Mulla)of commander of INS KHUKRI. Has he deliberately avoided his first name (Mahendra Nath)? This is how a narrative is set by intellectuals in a subtle manner. The formula is to deprive the gullible, docile majority of their previous glories. Make sure their moral is low and then brutally rule them. That is called secularism, anti majoritiniasm, all that intellectual somersault. Didn't expect from Tharoor. Below link for clarity. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahendra_Nath_Mulla
@Jack Yup, have grown up and out of blindly believing these shallow intellectuals. At one time they peddle a narrative called "Terrorists and terror has no religion" and when that narrative lost currency, these jokers came up with another fake concept called "Hindu Terror". Have grown up and out of the spell of such intellectual tyranny. 🙄🙄🙄
All of tharoor's comes to an end when he is finished with his mugged up essay written by him (i guess) about what the idea of india is and how india was great until 2014 , after that he goes on to say the same kinda propagandist stuff that other modi opponents have been saying 2014 that india is ruled by hindutva bla bla bla. For once and for a serious change of thought i would like to hear sashi tharoor speak something interesting and different than what he is saying since 2014.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Roc Steady (feat. Flo Milli) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HozPPyqW0dY/mqdefault.jpg)
Shashi is so eloquent he can convince his audience that the silent man sitting on his chair is not speaking not because he does not know how to speak but because he is wise beyond wisdom and does not need to speak.
A Silver Tongue snake
@Janus what exactly is your complaint?
Love u sir from Kashmir
Such a speech is a speech of a PM who loves his country!
Why doesn't india make this man as P.M .? It,ll be nice to see such a classy man to be face of country
Tharoor never cease to amaze me with his rationality and reasoning, and offcourse his oration is immaculate.
You mean his fancy accent and exotic vocab
I agree with him but In his reasoning I found the discussion of this question lacking - I wonder, can an accepting culture be accepting of unaccepting, non pluralistic ideologies which demean aspects of it, call them polytheistic, idol worshipping etc? And if yes, for how long? And who will ultimately change, the accepting ideology, or the exclusivist ideology?
Rahul must bring Shashi Tharoor for Foreign policy committee of INC.
@@verityveracity6704 An assumption that an illetrate Narendra Gautamdas Modi must rule India and incompetent people should work for the BJP. It s amazing the so-called protectors of democracy practice religious jingoism.
It’s such a shame that such an erudite and progressive idea can’t get traction for want of leadership, not one lacking in articulation, as clearly seen, but more so in the ability to enact
please ... did you even understand what he uttered exactly !
@@SPeri6 what gives you the impression that I didn’t? Your own opinion I guess? Perhaps you ought to be a little more explicit in a public challenge
@@anthrax0pranav ignore people him, just wannabe's. They don't have a clue about history and philosophies, just "andh bhakts". To them people like Shashi tharoor are fools and Modi and Rahul are geniuses
@@hyperxfury2661 Says the Abdool shashi tharoor is a fool who uses fancy accent and exotic words to sound smart to colonised Indian minds
I agree he is talking about the ideal India and lacks pragmatism. He represents a constituency, where a section of people have to appeased for him to stay in power.
Wish he could be prime minister or president. A beautiful mind and heart. A wonderful person..
Such a great speaker, clear thoughts
AN amazing man and a gift to all but, particularly India (Bharat, don't want to piss anyone off) . India has produced some remarkable people in all fields of life. Dr. Tharoor is the man who knows the language and the oratory skills to bring it out and showcase these achievements. .
👍👍👍💐💐💐
When people talk about Ambedkar, i just wonder that why they don't talk about Ambedkar's view on islam & muslims & how he exposed them. I would suggest people to read a book called Pakistan or Partition by BR Ambedkar. Whatever he predicted regarding this jihadi cult have proved to be right & he clearly mentions that these people are a headache & unnecessary burden for any society. And he also said that it's better not to keep them in India after partition.
Nothing is late. We can ask anti Indians to give up citizenship and go to Pakistan or change. We will win. India will win.
Yes you are right.
hater
Well said brother
Brilliant as ever 🎉 @Shashi Tharoor the able son of #India has been
Rare statesman
Sadly not everybody will get the message 😢
Beautiful words
Always love to hear his speeches from Pakistan
What an insight
The Idea of India dreamed by our founding forefathers is dying.
It was dying but Modi has revived it now. Hindu rasta Is gonna be stronger than ever.
@@patelaakash267 Hindu Rashtra wasn't the Idea of the new republic and it's leaders.
@@heheboiii3566 yes well a lot of the “forefathers” were British coolies. Bharat is a Hindu rastra and always will be. And obviously majority of the people feel the same became they keep voting for the Hindu party….that’s democracy. Sounds like you’re a fascist who doesn’t respect democracy.
@@patelaakash267 Hindu Rastra is as evil as Nazi Germany , from where Savarkar got the idea ..you are not an Indian at all
Shashi tharoor’s brilliant Defence of Rahul Gandhi’s speeches abroad. No apology needed. Rather Modi must apologize for his utterances of shame being Indian. PM did disrespect of the Nation that made a chaiwala a PM due to vibrant Democracy, whom
He is bent upon Destroying today. Arrogance of Modi would be his downfall.
Respected tharoor sir,
Need your comments on our wrestler protested at jantar mantar and violence in Manipur,
Plz bring us your comments plz,
After all u r our leader,.....?
I wish Dr. Vikram n Mr. Sai Deepak speak after him their idea of India!
I like your English @drshashitharoor
Today group please atleast revisit the headline you have given to this video, There was not any solid conversation on Ambedkar😢
In the comments, I can see, majority of people were amazed by his english speech rather than by the content he said. He described the Hindu rashtra very well but he has completely misguided about the agendas of current govt(BJP). Depriving the rights of minority section or any kind of discrimination against them is not their goal. Tharoor wanted unity among all the people but the people themselves are creating a rift and politicians adding fuel to that. Current govt also wants unity but not at the cost of scapegoating Hindus.
all the questions reflects how deep degradation of journalistic ethics is here
Hats off to MP Shashi Tharoor a thinker and die hard Indian divergent to BJP and RSS. Demolished idea of Hindu Rashtra Idea of narrow minded politicians and Hindutva idea. Excellent narration of Democracy of India
On the other side of Sindh, pronunciation became hindi Hindu...
Very elegant as always and a peaceful talk sending the message across, rather than the BJP politicians who yell and shout displaying anger!
This talented man needs to leave Congress asap a sinking ship
no
@@kasardevi8 why
He is a REAL Indian!
I believe these simplistic POVs won't work any more, Shashi! Also, several statements you made don't stand up to scrutiny.
Once Congress made efforts towards hiding Ambedkar and now political compulsion making congress to accept Ambedkar.....well atleast verbally......you can't trust Congress
Congress=BJP as Ambedkar mentioned : it is useless to make a distinction between the secular and priestly Hindu. Both are kith and kin. They are two arms of the same body, and one is bound to fight for the existence of the other.
India is more united now than in the last 75 years
Tharoor must be in BJP that's india want
4:35
background is irritating... can you switch off the background LED's
Tharur maybe an eloquent speaker but he can spin doctor the truth
It is about time that congress people start recognising what the present government has achieved better than the congress
yes...what has this government achieved? you mean the split in society?Divide and rule? Yes? Nearly as good as British Raj! only done by Indians to Indians ...so worse
Shashi used his eloquent verbose to evade Ambedkar completely, his ideas of Indian polity and democracy!!
Brilliant Shashi Tharoor is lying about what rahul said in london. How does explain him standing in jnu in 2016 with tukde tukde gang.
Sorry what is the tukde tukde gang? What were they fighting for?
@@TusharSAzadi? “Afzal hum sarminda hei…”?
@@sm24572 Azadi for what?
let's appreciate the role of elites and Brahmins to keep this country together. No matter matter which state you are in you will find a high minder brahmin in power. Shahi is being modest not recognising the role his community to the birth of the idea of India and keeping it so for everyone else.
So finally we are getting independence
What do you have to say about it
Shehzada is quite uncomfortable when you say j and k is integral part of india
Mr Tharror, all goodi goodi things is talking about is because of the civilization our forefathers have practiced and taught to his generation. And that civilization is Aryan civilization.. which 99% population of the country belongs
What happened Kashmir in hindu
Ask the Government to speak about Chronie Capitalist being covered.....we said Shashi , ms journalist you are making points which were only increase your trp and wasting time of Country
I would request Congress President to support Shashi Tharoor for President of UNO security council once again.
He should tell how Sunanda Pushkar died who was his third wife whose he was the third husband.
Maximum by minority, minimum by majority,,,lo ban gai sarkar,,,this is the whole idea of speech.... until CONGRESS don't consider every citizen of india EQUAL till then ....they are not coming in power.
Shashi should properly read Ambedkar before appropriating for his Gandhian Cult
Just watch Shashi and Sai Deepak together. You will realise how hollow arguments of Shashi are.
Sheer blabbering aimless or mild manner discouraging and undermining Modi adminstration's policy; using slick words.
While massaging Rahul's ball he forgot China taunt for which he (Rahul) declared ;peaceful nation'.
India was partitioned not because of religion but Congress withdrawing its consent to 1946 cabinet mission plan of strong autonomous states due to pressure from business houses profiteering under centralized British rule.
These business houses were also the chief patrons of Congress which is why Congress had to withdraw its consent.
1947, was not independence but transfer of power from the British to the allies of the British.
Before 1947, only roughly 51% of today's India was British India rest were 565 independent kingdoms under the suzerainty of the British crown.
Forced centralized rule in both India and Pakistan, countries which never existed prior to arrival of East India Company, is the root cause for corruption, concentration of power in the hands of extremely few, extreme poverty, backwardness and secessionist movements in large parts of the nation.
The way forward is going back to 1946 cabinet mission plan where power rests with the states and centre represented by every state of the union and not one political party only in charge of defense, communication, currency and foreign affairs.
Not sure what the interviewer is trying to achieve - promote an anti-constitutional, narrow minded viewpoint? Aghast that India Today is giving Hindutva a platform to legitimize itself.
Hindutva is here to stay, we don't need to legitimize it, it is a given.
Bhai e chomu ko mat bulo bahut pakat hai.
Jai hindutva 🚩
Vivekananda ka hindutva ya manu ka hindutava?
@@CarpeDiem-ml5ld vivekanands hindutva where he held a pastor by his collar and threatened to throw him in the ocean when he was spitting venom against hinduism.
What a liar
Ganta brilliant bada comu hai 🤢
Excellent talk but has some nonsense/lies inserted for political correctness. 75 years is also reflection how majority is humiliated and ignored in the name of secularism. Hindu temples not allowed by themselves but run by Govt where as Wafq is granted millions of acre is one example. there is difference what's narrated vs reality. Mayawati referred twice as symbol of new India but wont support or recognize Murmu as president, reflects Tharoor as politician. Unfortunately Tharoor spoke more as politician . Modi's foreign audience was Indian not front of foreign audience.
@5:42, Shri Tharoor mentions surname (Mulla)of commander of INS KHUKRI. Has he deliberately avoided his first name (Mahendra Nath)? This is how a narrative is set by intellectuals in a subtle manner.
The formula is to deprive the gullible, docile majority of their previous glories. Make sure their moral is low and then brutally rule them. That is called secularism, anti majoritiniasm, all that intellectual somersault.
Didn't expect from Tharoor.
Below link for clarity.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahendra_Nath_Mulla
Thanks for this eye opener
Even i was getting swayed by his ideas😮
Tharoor being perfect Librandu he had to create the smoke screen
Grow up
@Jack Yup, have grown up and out of blindly believing these shallow intellectuals.
At one time they peddle a narrative called "Terrorists and terror has no religion" and when that narrative lost currency, these jokers came up with another fake concept called "Hindu Terror".
Have grown up and out of the spell of such intellectual tyranny. 🙄🙄🙄
Sorry, how is using a last name depriving anyone of glories?
Though it's old news, Ambethkar is hero of all political parties of this country is really...... 😂
All of tharoor's comes to an end when he is finished with his mugged up essay written by him (i guess) about what the idea of india is and how india was great until 2014 , after that he goes on to say the same kinda propagandist stuff that other modi opponents have been saying 2014 that india is ruled by hindutva bla bla bla. For once and for a serious change of thought i would like to hear sashi tharoor speak something interesting and different than what he is saying since 2014.