My surprise is that, you can't hear this hadiths from any of ahlu sunnah wahabiyyah Alfa's bcos it involved Sohaba's like Seyiduna Umar RTA ( Though, I don't believe on it) But they are always ready to read any Hadiths that tarnished the image of the holy prophet and or his house holds. This is to say, they loves Sohaba's than the holy prophet Muhammad SAW.
So, What was the Prophet going to write, that is not already established in the Quran? How is the Khalifah not expressly in the Quran, if this is such critical Please, tell us
Is it in the QUR'AN that prophet family must be regard and honored or not?. If there is nothing prophet want to write that is not in the QUR'AN, that means all hadith books is nothing because every thing is already established in the QUR'AN.
USTAS Toliat. My opinion on this is that this Hadith can't be true just like many others. The handwriting of human beings is here. I am not inclined to any sectarian belief, either Sunni ,shia etc. I am objective about many things in life and have seen that human being follow the politics in religion rather than reality. It is either we overlook our predecessors mistakes or admit that there are many handwriting of Islamic enemies in our literatures outside the Quran.
Sheik Taliat Asalam alaykum Wallahi, I can never belief that prophet Muhammad SAW was poisoned (Hausubillahi) No No No ..... Poisoned the holy prophet, the hadith, you even said those poisoned him are his close Sohaba's and Sheidah Aishat. Wallahi iro buruku ni Secondly, the hadiths that say, prophet SAW told Sohaba's to give him pen to write something that will be a guidance for them forever, am also doubting this as well bcos of some reasons like: What did he want to write that is not established in the holy Quran What did he want write that can not be saying verbally I don't think any Sohaba's can do that to the holy prophet SAW in his present What did he want to write after he has told them on several occasions that he's leaving the holy Quran for them as guidance Where was Seyyidah AISHAT, Seyyidah Fatimat, Seyiduna Alliy, Hassan and Hussain, Seyiduna Abubakir and others then Anybody that beliefs on this hadiths is indirectly or directly believing that the holy Quran is not completed Sheik Taliat, let us reason before we accepted or beliefs on RUBBISH, SENSELESS and BASELESS statements. These are among rubbish fabricated Hadiths in the books of hadiths like Sohihu Bukhari and Muslim. Though, you can not see any ahlu sunnah wahabiyyah followers to talks on this kind of hadiths Don't forget, any history or anything inside any books of hadiths are authored after years of the prophet demise. Asalam alaykum Waramatullahi Sheik Taliat
Why we Muslims always argue what's not what to argue on it , alfa toliat is quoting from ahlu sunnah salafiyah books. We dont need to folt him or condemn him. We will rather folt those book. Like sohih bukhari, sohih Muslim and other books, Alquran is the holy book for we muslims .
A liar must have a good memory so that he won't contradict himself. They couldn't give the prophet pen and paper to write but you have been telling us that the prophet was illiterate. He couldn't read or write .
@@tundetaiwo654 No Shi'a will ever utter such nonsense that the noble Prophet was illiterate. Interestingly, there are evidences in the Qur’ān as well as both Sunni and Shi'a hadith corpus that the noble Prophet read and write. In fact, the Imams of the Ahl al-Bayt called whoever said the Prophet was illiterate as LIAR.
@tunde taiwo, you put on suit must be an educated person or knowledgeable person, I no you must be ahlu sunnah or ahlu sunnah followers. Sheikh toliat is quoting from ahlu sunnah books and you are still calling him a liar , why can't reason meh.
And some people are still believing this lies this Shia guy is vomiting. Rosulilah(saw) illiterate prophet wanted to suddenly write.ok. This guy forget to kno w all Hadith are graded according to the sources through which it comes.
U cannot understand because u are myopic and if Sheikh Toliat is to be cursed, then u have to firstly curse ur predecessors i.e sohih Bukhari and other writers alike. Was Sheik Toliat d one that penned down this narration? Be open-minded pls!
@ogunkoya, dont attack our sheikh toliat, or telling us that Islam is astray religion Capital no, it's you that you have to listening very well and digest and dont be dogmatized by Ahlu sunnah salafiyah books and ideology.
Ori yin ti daru sir
My surprise is that, you can't hear this hadiths from any of ahlu sunnah wahabiyyah Alfa's bcos it involved Sohaba's like Seyiduna Umar RTA ( Though, I don't believe on it)
But they are always ready to read any Hadiths that tarnished the image of the holy prophet and or his house holds.
This is to say, they loves Sohaba's than the holy prophet Muhammad SAW.
Exactly Sir
So, What was the Prophet going to write, that is not already established in the Quran?
How is the Khalifah not expressly in the Quran, if this is such critical
Please, tell us
Is it in the QUR'AN that prophet family must be regard and honored or not?.
If there is nothing prophet want to write that is not in the QUR'AN, that means all hadith books is nothing because every thing is already established in the QUR'AN.
USTAS Toliat.
My opinion on this is that this Hadith can't be true just like many others.
The handwriting of human beings is here.
I am not inclined to any sectarian belief, either Sunni ,shia etc.
I am objective about many things in life and have seen that human being follow the politics in religion rather than reality.
It is either we overlook our predecessors mistakes or admit that there are many handwriting of Islamic enemies in our literatures outside the Quran.
My Sheikh, this particular Narration is 100% true unless you can prove otherwise.
Jazakumullah khaeran Sir
Sheik Taliat Asalam alaykum
Wallahi, I can never belief that prophet Muhammad SAW was poisoned (Hausubillahi) No No No ..... Poisoned the holy prophet, the hadith, you even said those poisoned him are his close Sohaba's and Sheidah Aishat. Wallahi iro buruku ni
Secondly, the hadiths that say, prophet SAW told Sohaba's to give him pen to write something that will be a guidance for them forever, am also doubting this as well bcos of some reasons like:
What did he want to write that is not established in the holy Quran
What did he want write that can not be saying verbally
I don't think any Sohaba's can do that to the holy prophet SAW in his present
What did he want to write after he has told them on several occasions that he's leaving the holy Quran for them as guidance
Where was Seyyidah AISHAT, Seyyidah Fatimat, Seyiduna Alliy, Hassan and Hussain, Seyiduna Abubakir and others then
Anybody that beliefs on this hadiths is indirectly or directly believing that the holy Quran is not completed
Sheik Taliat, let us reason before we accepted or beliefs on RUBBISH, SENSELESS and BASELESS statements.
These are among rubbish fabricated Hadiths in the books of hadiths like Sohihu Bukhari and Muslim. Though, you can not see any ahlu sunnah wahabiyyah followers to talks on this kind of hadiths
Don't forget, any history or anything inside any books of hadiths are authored after years of the prophet demise.
Asalam alaykum Waramatullahi Sheik Taliat
Please Sir, don't say wallai IRỌ ni until you prove me wrong.
Jazakumullah khaeran Sir and my regards
Why we Muslims always argue what's not what to argue on it , alfa toliat is quoting from ahlu sunnah salafiyah books. We dont need to folt him or condemn him. We will rather folt those book. Like sohih bukhari, sohih Muslim and other books, Alquran is the holy book for we muslims .
A liar must have a good memory so that he won't contradict himself. They couldn't give the prophet pen and paper to write but you have been telling us that the prophet was illiterate. He couldn't read or write .
Kindly tell me where I told you that ;the Prophet (sawa) was illiterate? My own Prophet (sawa) was not illiterate oooo.
Take care Sir
@@tundetaiwo654
No Shi'a will ever utter such nonsense that the noble Prophet was illiterate. Interestingly, there are evidences in the Qur’ān as well as both Sunni and Shi'a hadith corpus that the noble Prophet read and write. In fact, the Imams of the Ahl al-Bayt called whoever said the Prophet was illiterate as LIAR.
It means sohih bukhari and Muslim is liar book then
@tunde taiwo, you put on suit must be an educated person or knowledgeable person, I no you must be ahlu sunnah or ahlu sunnah followers. Sheikh toliat is quoting from ahlu sunnah books and you are still calling him a liar , why can't reason meh.
And some people are still believing this lies this Shia guy is vomiting.
Rosulilah(saw) illiterate prophet wanted to suddenly write.ok. This guy forget to kno w all Hadith are graded according to the sources through which it comes.
Bro, you're a liar, can't believe what I just heard from you, may Almighty Allah punish you if you're lying against these people
U cannot understand because u are myopic and if Sheikh Toliat is to be cursed, then u have to firstly curse ur predecessors i.e sohih Bukhari and other writers alike. Was Sheik Toliat d one that penned down this narration? Be open-minded pls!
This your explanation is saying that Islam is an Astray religion. That is the implication
No sir. It is the Muslims that went astray, not Islam. Therefore, this lecture is a wake up call to examine our beliefs and understanding.
@ogunkoya, dont attack our sheikh toliat, or telling us that Islam is astray religion Capital no, it's you that you have to listening very well and digest and dont be dogmatized by Ahlu sunnah salafiyah books and ideology.