I thoroughly look at all of the smaller details added to Stalker 2 as more or less a template for gameplay modding as it gets a lot of the basics out of the way like animated consumables, first person body, and weapon attatchments.
I think this video barely scratches the surface of the differences. Mutant loot, base building, repair items, cooking, crafting, tools, general items, weapon and armour parts, artefact crafting, weapon and armour upgrades and the work bench, player made stashes, sleeping bags, choosing how long to try to sleep, day night cycle length, keybind customisation, limb health system, timed medication effects (medications that show they are working for several minutes), A-life, camp fire saving, weapon magazines mod, quests... I am sure I could keep going on and on. Stalker 2 is a good base, but it has no meat on its bones at all yet. I am enjoying it, but after I finish it, I don't see me playing it again for a long time. I am definitely going to do another playthrough of gamma before I do another of Stalker 2.
In the process of studying the game, we discovered all the details. It will be a long, detailed video, including the snow mod weather. It’s going to feel very unfair. We also have a lot of details showing that even with mods, the gamma cannot fix the issues with the old engine the game is based on. Stalker Gamma is not for everyone. New players will probably struggle to play the game. It’s fair to say the Stalker 2 doesn’t have the same feeling as Gamma.
@@stageiiwappie950 It depends I guess on how vanilla you want your experience and what game/s in the series you want to play. I hear radiophobia is a great remake (modernized) version of the original Shadow of Chernobyl. If you care for the story, I assume there are mods for Clear sky and Call of Pripyat that update the games without going to hardcore. In my opinion, if you want the current best Stalker experience, get stalker anomaly (free) and the gamma mod pack and launcher (free). It will require a bit of time and effort for installation plus it will be a lot to wrap your head around with its systems once you get into the game. Watch some videos of people playing Gamma and see if it looks like the experience you want.
@@troypinkerton9876 I want to play the three original titles first with vanilla story and mechanics. Only bug fixxes, engine, and visual improvements is what i want for the first playthroughs. I looked into gamma, but want to save it for after because it combines? all games and may impact the questlines story
@@stageiiwappie950 Ok, fair enough. You will have to do some googling then on what people recommend as a set of simple mods to update the games visuals etc. (sorry, I can't really help you in this regard as its been so long since I played them and in a mostly vanilla state). Gamma has its own story line and I guess it references some things that happened in the previous games, but yes, it combines all the previous maps together. If you are planning to do vanilla/ish playthroughs of the previous 3, then I agree you should leave gamma until last.
both games are great. i enjoy it. the thing is for those who new : Stalker anomaly gamma, is heavily modded stalker game Stalker 2 is a base game. Mods always make games great now imagine if modders start to work on stalker 2 on anomaly gamma scale, it will be much better. since its use new modern engine!
they cant do anomaly/gamma for stalker 2 the systems people would need to run it would be too much. and the anomaly dev already said their is still so much to do with 1 that it will be many years before he even though about a anomaly 2 maybe by then pc hardware wil be strong enough to handle it. as of now stalker 2 is barley running on a monster system like a 4090 and a 5800x 3d cpu its pretty bad so like the dev said it will be many years before it can happen. modding in stalker 2 is limited because of how bad the performance is they cant add alot because if they do nobody could play it. they are mods now that make the game more demanding a rtx 4090 only gets like 30 fps and barley hits 60 at 1440p.
comparing mechanics that don't even exists in stalker 2 with anomaly (desguise system, dizzies, mask overlay, etc), while you don't even show the mechanics that exists in stalker 2 that don't exists in anomaly (animation for attachments, new weapon attachments like the magazine upgrades and the underbarrel shotgun, the new mutants and anomalies, having a actual story and cutscenes)
also, this comparation don't even makes sense, since both games are different things, so different that even grok the creator of gamma says that comparing both is just something that don't even makes sense, since anomaly/gamma have mechanics that are not even mean't to be in stalker 2 in the first place and both games focus in complete different things, while stalker 2 is focused in story and being gameplay friendly to new players, gamma/anomaly is focused in hardcore gameplay, sandbox, reallism and survival mechanics.
The details we compared were all analyzed fairly and logically. The drugs they use have side effects, and even small details create an atmosphere of being in a post-apocalyptic world, not a playground walking from one side mission to another. We didn’t include a ton of features that mods can offer, as it would be unfair to Stalker 2. Attachments in Gamma don’t have animations, but it has a lot more than Stalker 2. We are trying to be fair to both games.
@davidfrazier6308 nice bait bro, and "old game"? or do you mean the mod with 17 years worth of stolen assets from various modders and different games? because the old games don't even have half of these features. 🤔
@@davidfrazier6308 of course old games perform better. There were no such graphics as we have now. Also comparing a game with 3 years of development with a mod for a game that came 13 years ago?
oh my god i cannot believe an official stalker game holds more similarity to other official stalker games and less similarity to non-official, non-canonical, heavily modified fan creation WEIRD
I will say people are wrong that stalker 2 dosent feel like a stalker game its very similar to the og stalker games. I think some people when they think of stalker actually think of mods. Comparing it to being like a far cry game is just wrong.
Honestly, there’s a lot of potential for S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2. If it gets a similar treatment as CDPR gave Cyberpunk 2077, it could have a lot of longevity. Especially once modders get their hands on it like they did with Anomaly and Gamma.
I mean, yeah, one is a base game, and the other is a base game with a few hundred mods and thousands of hours worth of updates 😂. Ofc the one with more time to cook has more features
Stalker 2 is great don't get me wrong. I'm 180 hours deep but sometimes you get that lacking feeling, like it needed some more time hope they keep updates coming. And gamma is pure suffering and bliss😂 and felt more guns were lacking but probably because gamma spoilt us too much.
Stalker gamma simply best 🤷🏼♂️ not only infinite replayability also diff made by yourself you can add more Stalkers more mutants make the game more ez more hard many different ways… story or survival its on you. You can even build your own base lol graphic is nice and now finally 60 fps contant … i now gonna try new patch in stalker 2 but gamma is far superior cuz it shows strugle of the zone being nobody to somebody by your own expirience … after 1000 hours + on gamma its like elder ring but in the zone… 1 fumble can end everything.. gamma compare to stalker 2 is walk in park 💀 real expirience in the zone is as monolith hardcore in gamma xd
ну гамма не сказать что самая красивая сборка, я играл в сборку где и анимация надевания шлемов/брони есть, где когда выпил воду бутылка лежит там, куда её бросил игрок и т.д.
Ну на сталкер 2 тоже моды есть, ты сравниваешь оригинал со сборкой, это как-то тупо. Если скачивать сборку для сталкер 2 и сравнивать с аномали, то разница на лицо
И что для меня лично поменяло, что собака хромает? Вы в сталкер виртуальных собак заходите понаблюдать и поизучать? Картинка в моде - полная херня. Мыло натянутое на движок времен моей молодости. Выброс тоже - нелогичное нечто. Если он бы происходил в том виде, что в моде - все бы здания уже лежали в руинах, деревья были бы повалены после трех-четырех выбросов. А все механики "про ранение в ноге" - это вот как раз таки затягивание геймплея и отвлечение внимания от отсутствия контента. У Сталкера 2 есть такое преимущество, которое нивелирует любые моды - это огромная и очень проработанная карта, на которой можно заниматься чем? Сталкерством. Все остальное - езжайте в тарков, там и ранения в колено, и три вида антидепрессантов.
Логично!!! Ну, разработчики могли бы добавить мелкие детали, как эффект от медикаментов, которые создают атмосферу постапокалипсиса. А так понятно, что некоторые механики испортили бы впечатление новичкам. (Translated)
@ Им сперва бы глобальными проблемами заняться, как баланс и баги, а потом можно будет понемногу добавлять части мутантов, ПНВ и остальные фишки которые были в оригинальном сталкере. Даже киберпанк по крайней мере в контентном плане вышел намного успешнее, а сталкер это просто FAR CRY в сеттинге заброшенного советского города, где из контента только собрать артефакт и выполнить максимально однообразные задания, помимо ещё более скучного сюжета конечно. Рывка между новой и прошлыми играми нету, кроме как графической составляющей, которая пришла с потерями в ФПС
@ а какой рывок ты предполагаешь? РПГ прокачку? Рывок есть - в самой карте. Стрельба, физика, здесь все новое. Это чистое вранье говорить, что сталкер 2 - это просто старые части с новой графикой. Да, новых механик нет, но те, что есть - это заново сделанные. А не перенесенные из предыдущих частей. Так а что в Сталкере должно появится такого, что тебе не хватает? Бывают люди пишут - нет ничего нового. Чего не хватает? Аванпостов? В сталкере это убьет атмосферу напрочь. Прокачки? Каких навыков тогда? Карманных краж?) Сталкер в Диснейленд должен превратится? В ассасин Крид?
both games are bad? ngl your a fool for saying that, i love them and its okay to say you didnt enjoy them, or they wasnt for you, but to say both games are bad just shows you know nothing about game development or anything bro
You can't say a game is bad if it didn't met your expetations. Gaming as a whole is in a weird state right now, where devs don't have enough time to put gameplay features and make their game stable, and instead focus on photorealistic graphics. As a whole i feel like it's somehow the fault of the consumers as well for wanting dumbed down games with good graphics. Let's hope Stalker 2 gets the A-Life system it deserves, and one step up from the X-Ray one as well.
Stalker 2 is not finished and pretty broke so is not even able to compare it to a finished working game. Now S2 is a fraud, and GSC reputation going down fast. 60€, the price for a lesson learned.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
It's all thanks to the people who worked to create all the mods for the game.
Including the people who created mods for Stalker 2 as well.
STALKER 2 is more "casual" if i can call it that. STALKER Gamma tries to be hardcore. Both are good in their own right
💯
I thoroughly look at all of the smaller details added to Stalker 2 as more or less a template for gameplay modding as it gets a lot of the basics out of the way like animated consumables, first person body, and weapon attatchments.
There is Dizziness in STALKER 2 - but it's only caused by alcohol.
Ahaha
I think this video barely scratches the surface of the differences. Mutant loot, base building, repair items, cooking, crafting, tools, general items, weapon and armour parts, artefact crafting, weapon and armour upgrades and the work bench, player made stashes, sleeping bags, choosing how long to try to sleep, day night cycle length, keybind customisation, limb health system, timed medication effects (medications that show they are working for several minutes), A-life, camp fire saving, weapon magazines mod, quests... I am sure I could keep going on and on.
Stalker 2 is a good base, but it has no meat on its bones at all yet. I am enjoying it, but after I finish it, I don't see me playing it again for a long time. I am definitely going to do another playthrough of gamma before I do another of Stalker 2.
In the process of studying the game, we discovered all the details. It will be a long, detailed video, including the snow mod weather. It’s going to feel very unfair. We also have a lot of details showing that even with mods, the gamma cannot fix the issues with the old engine the game is based on.
Stalker Gamma is not for everyone. New players will probably struggle to play the game. It’s fair to say the Stalker 2 doesn’t have the same feeling as Gamma.
I havent touched stalker for way over a decade, only played vanillas. How should i start again
@@stageiiwappie950 It depends I guess on how vanilla you want your experience and what game/s in the series you want to play. I hear radiophobia is a great remake (modernized) version of the original Shadow of Chernobyl. If you care for the story, I assume there are mods for Clear sky and Call of Pripyat that update the games without going to hardcore.
In my opinion, if you want the current best Stalker experience, get stalker anomaly (free) and the gamma mod pack and launcher (free). It will require a bit of time and effort for installation plus it will be a lot to wrap your head around with its systems once you get into the game. Watch some videos of people playing Gamma and see if it looks like the experience you want.
@@troypinkerton9876 I want to play the three original titles first with vanilla story and mechanics. Only bug fixxes, engine, and visual improvements is what i want for the first playthroughs.
I looked into gamma, but want to save it for after because it combines? all games and may impact the questlines story
@@stageiiwappie950 Ok, fair enough. You will have to do some googling then on what people recommend as a set of simple mods to update the games visuals etc. (sorry, I can't really help you in this regard as its been so long since I played them and in a mostly vanilla state). Gamma has its own story line and I guess it references some things that happened in the previous games, but yes, it combines all the previous maps together. If you are planning to do vanilla/ish playthroughs of the previous 3, then I agree you should leave gamma until last.
both games are great. i enjoy it. the thing is
for those who new :
Stalker anomaly gamma, is heavily modded stalker game
Stalker 2 is a base game.
Mods always make games great
now imagine if modders start to work on stalker 2 on anomaly gamma scale, it will be much better. since its use new modern engine!
Thank you for explaining to new players. Stalker 2 with mods will be much, much better.
they cant do anomaly/gamma for stalker 2 the systems people would need to run it would be too much. and the anomaly dev already said their is still so much to do with 1 that it will be many years before he even though about a anomaly 2 maybe by then pc hardware wil be strong enough to handle it. as of now stalker 2 is barley running on a monster system like a 4090 and a 5800x 3d cpu its pretty bad so like the dev said it will be many years before it can happen. modding in stalker 2 is limited because of how bad the performance is they cant add alot because if they do nobody could play it. they are mods now that make the game more demanding a rtx 4090 only gets like 30 fps and barley hits 60 at 1440p.
comparing mechanics that don't even exists in stalker 2 with anomaly (desguise system, dizzies, mask overlay, etc), while you don't even show the mechanics that exists in stalker 2 that don't exists in anomaly (animation for attachments, new weapon attachments like the magazine upgrades and the underbarrel shotgun, the new mutants and anomalies, having a actual story and cutscenes)
also, this comparation don't even makes sense, since both games are different things, so different that even grok the creator of gamma says that comparing both is just something that don't even makes sense, since anomaly/gamma have mechanics that are not even mean't to be in stalker 2 in the first place and both games focus in complete different things, while stalker 2 is focused in story and being gameplay friendly to new players, gamma/anomaly is focused in hardcore gameplay, sandbox, reallism and survival mechanics.
The details we compared were all analyzed fairly and logically. The drugs they use have side effects, and even small details create an atmosphere of being in a post-apocalyptic world, not a playground walking from one side mission to another. We didn’t include a ton of features that mods can offer, as it would be unfair to Stalker 2. Attachments in Gamma don’t have animations, but it has a lot more than Stalker 2. We are trying to be fair to both games.
@@ahobacha don't be mad that a old game does things better than your new game oh and performs much better. coping is hard i know.
@davidfrazier6308 nice bait bro, and "old game"? or do you mean the mod with 17 years worth of stolen assets from various modders and different games? because the old games don't even have half of these features. 🤔
@@davidfrazier6308 of course old games perform better. There were no such graphics as we have now. Also comparing a game with 3 years of development with a mod for a game that came 13 years ago?
В аномали звук помирания от радиации и перелома ноги прямиком из Таркова)
The real answer: they’re both beautiful
💯
oh my god i cannot believe an official stalker game holds more similarity to other official stalker games and less similarity to non-official, non-canonical, heavily modified fan creation
WEIRD
You got affected
Idk how there are some people who think the new game is more similar to farcry, I don't think they've played og stalker or farcry.
@@adfkzaha24 you got tickled with a feather 🪶
S2 does not hold to og games. Unless you count how buggy CS was on release.
I will say people are wrong that stalker 2 dosent feel like a stalker game its very similar to the og stalker games. I think some people when they think of stalker actually think of mods. Comparing it to being like a far cry game is just wrong.
tfw i compare features from anomaly that dont even exist in s2
Honestly, there’s a lot of potential for S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2. If it gets a similar treatment as CDPR gave Cyberpunk 2077, it could have a lot of longevity. Especially once modders get their hands on it like they did with Anomaly and Gamma.
💯
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 unique, superb game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Not
лично мне вообще не нравится сколько в Аномали мусора в инвентаре - всяких рецептов, ресурсов для крафта, три вида водки
Согласен, трудно понять, что к чему без глубоких знаний. (Translated)
1:29 what pistol is that?
HK Usp match
@ioanmihaipopescu9071 how to get? Or si a mod?
Настоящий сталкер магазины не выкидывает,а по новой их наполняет,они денег стоят
Логично
и я скажу больше, если ктото хотел зацепиться в гамме за отсутствие анимации рюкзака, то еë можно скачать
в новой версии гаммы она уже добавлена
its sad to say that anomaly is still better than an official game release.
As a stalker game gamma is not that
@@Gizz101 Thats one of the few I haven't tried yet. Would you recommend it? is it good?
stalker gamma consists of many addons it is unfair to compare it with stalker 2
Dude... You're comparing vanilla Stalker 2 to a modded Stalker lol.
devs got to us and spatially temporal anomalies😊
You can't compare.. obviously gamma have so much more content . But stalker 2 have better graphics.
Who cares about graphics?
Both are relly good in their own way.
Вопрос а зачем вообще нужно головокружение хромота и тд? Ето игра или испытание твоей нервной системы?
Хаха, ну некоторые любят испытывать нервную систему, лично сам люблю все на хардкоре играть 😄 (translated)
oh man good video
Thanks 💛
I like all stalker games
Honestly if there will be Gamma for Stalker 2, that's all I need in my life.
I mean, yeah, one is a base game, and the other is a base game with a few hundred mods and thousands of hours worth of updates 😂. Ofc the one with more time to cook has more features
Stalker 2 has been out since 2011😮😊
Nah, GAMMA simply ain't scratching the vanilla feelings for me. I prefer unmodded Clear Sky over GAMMA and that's says a lot.
Stalker 2 is great don't get me wrong. I'm 180 hours deep but sometimes you get that lacking feeling, like it needed some more time hope they keep updates coming. And gamma is pure suffering and bliss😂 and felt more guns were lacking but probably because gamma spoilt us too much.
Stalker gamma simply best 🤷🏼♂️ not only infinite replayability also diff made by yourself you can add more Stalkers more mutants make the game more ez more hard many different ways… story or survival its on you. You can even build your own base lol graphic is nice and now finally 60 fps contant … i now gonna try new patch in stalker 2 but gamma is far superior cuz it shows strugle of the zone being nobody to somebody by your own expirience … after 1000 hours + on gamma its like elder ring but in the zone… 1 fumble can end everything.. gamma compare to stalker 2 is walk in park 💀 real expirience in the zone is as monolith hardcore in gamma xd
Yeah, Anomaly is much harder compared to Stalker 2. It’s like Elden Ring vs God of War.
He keeps his mags in anomaly you wouldn't discard a mag irl anyways unless it's a high intensity moment I suppose.
Ви теж постійно наче п'яні від вживання таблеток??
Тебе 1 миллион подписчиков надо
Спасибо, может когда нибудь достигнем
ну гамма не сказать что самая красивая сборка, я играл в сборку где и анимация надевания шлемов/брони есть, где когда выпил воду бутылка лежит там, куда её бросил игрок и т.д.
Ну на сталкер 2 тоже моды есть, ты сравниваешь оригинал со сборкой, это как-то тупо. Если скачивать сборку для сталкер 2 и сравнивать с аномали, то разница на лицо
И что для меня лично поменяло, что собака хромает? Вы в сталкер виртуальных собак заходите понаблюдать и поизучать? Картинка в моде - полная херня. Мыло натянутое на движок времен моей молодости. Выброс тоже - нелогичное нечто. Если он бы происходил в том виде, что в моде - все бы здания уже лежали в руинах, деревья были бы повалены после трех-четырех выбросов. А все механики "про ранение в ноге" - это вот как раз таки затягивание геймплея и отвлечение внимания от отсутствия контента. У Сталкера 2 есть такое преимущество, которое нивелирует любые моды - это огромная и очень проработанная карта, на которой можно заниматься чем? Сталкерством. Все остальное - езжайте в тарков, там и ранения в колено, и три вида антидепрессантов.
Логично!!! Ну, разработчики могли бы добавить мелкие детали, как эффект от медикаментов, которые создают атмосферу постапокалипсиса. А так понятно, что некоторые механики испортили бы впечатление новичкам. (Translated)
@ Им сперва бы глобальными проблемами заняться, как баланс и баги, а потом можно будет понемногу добавлять части мутантов, ПНВ и остальные фишки которые были в оригинальном сталкере. Даже киберпанк по крайней мере в контентном плане вышел намного успешнее, а сталкер это просто FAR CRY в сеттинге заброшенного советского города, где из контента только собрать артефакт и выполнить максимально однообразные задания, помимо ещё более скучного сюжета конечно.
Рывка между новой и прошлыми играми нету, кроме как графической составляющей, которая пришла с потерями в ФПС
@ а какой рывок ты предполагаешь? РПГ прокачку? Рывок есть - в самой карте. Стрельба, физика, здесь все новое. Это чистое вранье говорить, что сталкер 2 - это просто старые части с новой графикой. Да, новых механик нет, но те, что есть - это заново сделанные. А не перенесенные из предыдущих частей. Так а что в Сталкере должно появится такого, что тебе не хватает? Бывают люди пишут - нет ничего нового. Чего не хватает? Аванпостов? В сталкере это убьет атмосферу напрочь. Прокачки? Каких навыков тогда? Карманных краж?) Сталкер в Диснейленд должен превратится? В ассасин Крид?
Where to download this game s.t.a.l.k.e.r. anomaly gamma?
If you set up Stalker Gamma they way you want, it is just excellent.
If the modders starts to work on S.T.A.L.K.E.R 2..., i can't even find words what will happen...
да шмотки всеравно какие надлениш всем пофигу в сталкер 2. ..хоть шмот долга или варти в доме долга и все дальше стабой общаются
зажечь оогонь круто
Сталкер 2 - недоделанный огрызок, кривой, полный багов, но без контента. В таком случае конечно гамма лучше, хотя ее установить та еще проблема
вранье про сталкер 2. Просто он не идет на твоем допотопном компе.
@@MalyovaneeyАга, а ещё скажи, что ИИ в игре и Алайф прекрасный. А багов там вообще нету.
@ нормальный там ИИ и многие баги уже поправили.
Не сказал бы Сталкер 2 плохим, разработчики активно исправляют баги. (Translated)
@ 3070TI, 5600X, 32RAM, SSD
Кук спок
Аномали лучше
Old Modder Stalker vs Stalker 2
1:0
Stalker 2 have only drop magazines 😅
Both games are bad, I didn't enjoy stalker 2 same as old stalker games. Nice vid
I'm glad you enjoyed the video, even if you didn't enjoy the games.
both games are bad? ngl your a fool for saying that, i love them and its okay to say you didnt enjoy them, or they wasnt for you, but to say both games are bad just shows you know nothing about game development or anything bro
Your opinion is not accepted until you pass the stalker at least 5 times because only then do you feel the atmosphere
You can't say a game is bad if it didn't met your expetations. Gaming as a whole is in a weird state right now, where devs don't have enough time to put gameplay features and make their game stable, and instead focus on photorealistic graphics. As a whole i feel like it's somehow the fault of the consumers as well for wanting dumbed down games with good graphics. Let's hope Stalker 2 gets the A-Life system it deserves, and one step up from the X-Ray one as well.
@@florin9243 Wise words
Gamma > stalker 2 , maybe one day will be a gamma version of stalker 2
Stalker 2 is not finished and pretty broke so is not even able to compare it to a finished working game.
Now S2 is a fraud, and GSC reputation going down fast. 60€, the price for a lesson learned.
и я скажу больше, если ктото хотел зацепиться в гамме за отсутствие анимации рюкзака, то еë можно скачать