@@TheLegendofMariah we know our girl always dubs these TV performances, but I'm sure it was all live. If you wacth the full performance (and the other 2 ones) you can tell certain bits have been dubbed, buy hey nothing wrong with that. I love these performances at Corden, she did an amazing job and looked bomb af!
@@theroof6538 When she did "Christmas Time" on Corden, it was one of her most special performances of the year to me... That even beats out seeing her in Detroit months before (March 8th or 9th if I remember right)
2 things... 1) Until seeing it lined up next to all of these other performances, I did not appreciate the 2019 whistles, from the James Corden's show performance, anywhere near as much as I should have. 2) It never really registered how many different iterations of the first "whistle note" she has given is over the years. The original is pretty complicated so I get why she had to simplify it here and there. Based off of what we see in this video, it's interesting to see what her new take is going to be as she switched it up each year.
And with the covid she got rest , I'm so happy 4 her , when she do come slay 4 all of us she comes hard still , after all these years she still the queen omg . Team mariah go mariah she on fire
Her pitch was pretty bad in 2014 which explains why she lip syncs whistles a lot more now than in the past. But 2018 she got her pitch control and it’s when she starts to actually sound good
Nutrigenomics, mitochondrial nutrients, herbs and reading the Psalms for more consistency with health. Touring must be hard. Nevertheless, always love the beautiful singing.
@Dubairiah 2004 im not pretty sure, but i think since 2014, she started lipping the first part of the first whistle and then she either continues singing it live, or simply dodge it with "woo" but idk
2:35 it’s so cute how the kids imitate her 😭
Oh Santa should be a #1
Mtv Unplugged Era i agree its so underrated it hurts 😩
Mabye it will this year
@@cautionworldtour8352 i doubt it
Mariah Freaking Carey im just saying it is a possibility
It definitely has the potential!!
The last clip wins no question
lol definitely. its the only time she sang it 100% live
the only artist. who can whistle anytime she wants, it's really part of her vocal abilities.. she's the queen 👑
Yup
Yeah and she doesn't need autotune to Have the whistle sound good like some artists
actually she has nodes and cant whenever she wants. sometimes she wakes up and is just like I cant whistle today bc of her condition.
Love her ad-libs in '18.
The last one at Corden show is my fave 'cause it sounds natural (even when it was dubbed).
how are you sure it was dubbed?
@@TheLegendofMariah we know our girl always dubs these TV performances, but I'm sure it was all live. If you wacth the full performance (and the other 2 ones) you can tell certain bits have been dubbed, buy hey nothing wrong with that. I love these performances at Corden, she did an amazing job and looked bomb af!
@@theroof6538 When she did "Christmas Time" on Corden, it was one of her most special performances of the year to me... That even beats out seeing her in Detroit months before (March 8th or 9th if I remember right)
@@ArtbyKurtisEdwards 8th I guess
The late show had new pre recorded tracks, it wasn’t dubbed.
omg her voice is a real instrument
5:21 This Is The Best Live
5:21 - 5:39 🤩🤩🤩 that whistle run was 😍😍
2019 was the most natural sounding one
0:43 the best runs everr
A whistler who can do anything with her whistle
*y’all thought I died?*
*Think again sweetie*
Fr i ask who are you
OMG I LOVE UR AIWFCIY PERFORMANCE WITH DAVID BOWIE
Daydream World Tour Rotterdam *honey you and your flat G5 aren’t going anywhere*
Music Box Tour *I forgot who you are too aren’t you Tomato mozzarella’s pet?*
Sleeping Husky *Awwww thanks!*
2019is better the late late show, i love the performance.
I love... did u hear that super fast run at the end of the first whistle. She was going to attempt the studio run
*oop it’s a sayian-*
She can go high and say something in the high range wow fire
Her agility is absolutely mind-blowing! Why is she so underappreciated! 😭
FACTS she's AGILE asf in every register
Underappreciated? She is considered the greatest vocalist of all time
@@itsjinxnow4814 underappreciated ≠ underrated
She’s appreciated very much, what do you mean 😭 she’s very famous back then
@@moontuple she’s still now :)))
Oh santa about to be #1
Did u hear that super fast run at the end of the first whistle... super agile.... wow. She was going to attempt the studio version run 😍😍😍
She was on fire in 2014😍😭
I was truly
@@me.iammariah9051 not you taking my place smh
@@rosemont2283 IT'S MY ERA
2018 wins easily😍 so many live whistles
2019(james corden) is so underrated, the agility🥺😍
That’s what I’m saying
“oh mariah” making the ground always shake with her fire vocals 🙄 (pun intended)
There are more and better ones from 2014 you could’ve added imo, but from these the 2018 ones and Corden are the best
4:41 "yass gurl!!!"😭😭😭 me too
1:18 & 1:58 crack me up because they sound like a deranged child or young animal screeching.
Lol yes what was she thinking? 😂😂😂 We love her, but those were very funny
Yep, the live whistles sometimes don't really blend nicely with the pre-recorded part.
Ok daydream whistles bias
At least that's prove it's live !
2 things...
1) Until seeing it lined up next to all of these other performances, I did not appreciate the 2019 whistles, from the James Corden's show performance, anywhere near as much as I should have.
2) It never really registered how many different iterations of the first "whistle note" she has given is over the years. The original is pretty complicated so I get why she had to simplify it here and there. Based off of what we see in this video, it's interesting to see what her new take is going to be as she switched it up each year.
And with the covid she got rest , I'm so happy 4 her , when she do come slay 4 all of us she comes hard still , after all these years she still the queen omg . Team mariah go mariah she on fire
She’s a queen
YESSSS:::: MARIAH, ARIANA AND JENNIFER
Its ok Mariah we all getting old and you Cant expect to hold those notes forever
She might retire one in a life time , and move over and do movies or something else .
But she can though, she can definitely still hold it
Yaaassssssssshoneeeeee whistles allday long🎼🎵🎶😇💪
nothing changed omfg queen
Love the energy in 2014
please update this with the new 2023 whistle
Time to upload a newer version of this comp
That Hallmark Christmas event in 2015, she very much looks like E= MC2 era lmao🤣
#1 IN 2020
1:18 sounds like she was trying to get it on key😂😂but she was like fuck it atleast I hit ts😂😂😂
Her pitch was pretty bad in 2014 which explains why she lip syncs whistles a lot more now than in the past. But 2018 she got her pitch control and it’s when she starts to actually sound good
Solo12313 *Um-* ruclips.net/video/U-ySRku8o7g/видео.html
💙MIAM Era💙 firstly we’re discussing whistles, not the belts. Even then it was clearly the studio playback (because the original has a G5 in)
0:40 DAMN
unexpected!
That whistle note is what a rainbow would sound like 😆
Not yet dahlinnn, christmas not yet
The agile whistle I've ever heard😮
Succes!!!
Guys where are pre dubut, first vision, Music Box Era, Triumphant Era, MIAM Era, Infinity Era and Caution Era?
wdym?
@@TheLegendofMariah girl they're gone
@mariah frickin carey is queen the comment section just feels incomplete without them
MIAM Era got into a tragic drowing accident in an ocean of autotune...she will be missed...
Hunter Of MC *I am AA tour but RUclips said I had to change my name so I just made a second account named MIAM*
I need to know if 0:46 is live. She sounds like a flute.
its 100% not live, it sounds very processed and unnatural.
you forgot the Dec 22 2014 Oh Santa's whistle. It is the best in 2014 Beacon.
Piano ka ghorl 😭
3:27
The guy hitting a C#5
😅
i’m sorry why the FUCK does she have THE AUDAUMDACITY to do the first riffs because- like HUH!!?! gives us all a ChANCe for Gods sake
Just missing the one with ari now
is it a plane
is it a bird
no it's Mariah
2015 mariah look like stress for divourcement.
Cada vez le cuesta más 😩 no termina el melisma en el primer whistle pero es increíble que lo largo de su carrera aún lo haga exelente técnica vocal
VDDE. POR ELA TER FEITO DESDE CEDO E NOVA NO AUGE. MAS AINDA É UMA LENDA VIVA Q CANTA MTOOOOO😊😊❤❤
Nutrigenomics, mitochondrial nutrients, herbs and reading the Psalms for more consistency with health. Touring must be hard. Nevertheless, always love the beautiful singing.
3:55 to 3:59 🏆 she betta get that mf LIVE whistle with the LIVE run out of her mf throat although she’s been doing ts for 3 decades with nodules 🔥
1:58 What was that ? Is that MC whistles voices ?
Yeah it created an echo. I think she was too close to the microphone 🎙
Mariah would be ms. Claus but she was too good for Santa Periodt
4:45 What date is that.
berlin
Adjust the title. Through or throughout are the correct terms.
i know
2016's and 2018's have the best tone and 2019's was definitely was the worst tonally
:)
are those runs real?
ofcourse
Bb7 at 1:39 ?
😱 kinda sounds like it
It does🥺
Why it sound robotic tho
It was lipped, and she used autotune
@Dubairiah 2004 Im 100% sure, cause its the studio version lol
the second 2019 clip was completely live (the only time)
@Dubairiah 2004 im not pretty sure, but i think since 2014, she started lipping the first part of the first whistle and then she either continues singing it live, or simply dodge it with "woo" but idk
@Dubairiah 2004 but the 2010 is def fully lipped lol, the autotune was so obvious
I wish she didn't lipsync all the time