Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Metallica: Worst to Best
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
- Ranking the albums of arguably the biggest thrash metal band of all time, Metallica!
More Worst to Best: • Worst to Best
s/o to @trevoryj for the drawing in the intro: trevoryj?h...
===================================
Subscribe: bit.ly/1pBqGCN
Official site: theneedledrop.com
TND Twitter: / theneedledrop
TND Facebook: / theneedledrop
Support TND: theneedledrop.com/support
===================================
Y'all know this is just my opinion, right?
![[BLACKSWAN] ‘Roll Up’ Official Music Video](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ulvCwyKrwqw/mqdefault.jpg)
1. St anger
2. Lulu
3. Angelic to the core
4. The dark side of the moon
5. Abbey road
6. Citizen Kane
7. Smells like teen spirit
8. Xxxtentacion
9. Speedin bullet to heaven
10. Enter sandman
I agree with your list
Where is despacito
You forgot smoke on the water
This was really funny, but it gave me an annurysm.
Abbey Road needs to be lower
gimme food gimme fries gimme salad on the side
This has the same effect as the johnny bravo mockingjay
😂 😂 😂 👌
HOOO YE HEEE
Sounds like a death grips bar honestly
SHAAA
An interesting thing about Metallica’s discography is everyone’s widely differing opinions and tastes. Justice is easily my favorite Metallica record.
Same
My top two are Ride The Lightning and And Justice For All. Justice is an absolute masterpiece
Justice is my favorite only when it is the restored bass version, if not then it is #3 behind RTL and Master
Actually I think it’s one of the bands whose albums are ranked very similarly by its fans. Regardless of your personal preference Master of Puppets is undeniably their best album, closely followed by Ride the Lightning and the Black Album. Some people change the order of these but they’re definitely considered their best. After those most fans would put AJFA or Kill ‘Em All depending on the level of aggression they prefer and after the 5 great albums no one really cares but St Anger goes last without a doubt
Saint Lulu is my personal favourite.
The most heartbreaking thing about St. Anger is that it should’ve been their return to glory. Over a year of internal conflict and overcoming personal demons, James going to rehab, everyone clashing as they try to find the magic they once had... I mean, coupled with the really good documentary Some Kind of Monster, this should’ve been a renaissance album. But it just... fell really flat instead. It’s a damn shame.
St. Anger is made all the more frustrating because not only SHOULD it have been better, it clearly COULD have. There are sketches of legitimately great Metallica tracks on there...Sweet Amber, Unnamed Feeling, All Within My Hands...parts of those songs are genuinely incredible, they're just so bloated and aimless. The production is terrible, the drums sound god-awful, the whole "no solos" mandate was just moronic...just mistake after boneheaded mistake. Had they used what's on the record as a starting point, refined the hell out of the songs, added some damn solos, and cut a good 2-3 minutes off each track it could have been one of their best.
It's a good thing we had Death Magnetic... wait that album's production kinda sucked too.
Hardwired it is then.
If you find renditions of the songs that fix the obnoxious snare drum and poor production it's really not *that* bad of an album --- some hits, some misses, but I find myself actually enjoying it overall when it has the polish it deserves. Of course better polish on the sound doesn't change the fact it's overall a failed experiment on Metallica's part, that came off the heels of their most popular era. If James was in better shape and the band undergoing less turbulence overall I agree that maybe St. Anger could have been the kick-off to a new creative era for them, but unfortunately they were in no position to make the next Master of Puppets or Black Album, so now here we are. At least we got "Frantic."
@@bendykirby4828 those albums were barely interesting though
Back then St. Anger was the first metal album I ever listened to and without the context of everything they did before it was a really cathartic experience to hear it. Because of that to this day I hold the album in high regard even if their 80s run up until the Black Album ended up overshadowing it when I became more familiar with their history.
It has a place, an important one for me at least and I think that it was significant to many teenagers of the early 2000s in that way. Which is not to say that it became a classic but that the very distinct sound it had resonated with me and among all the well-deserved criticism it got and still gets there are fans out there who appreciate its existence.
1. Enter Sandman
2. Enter Sandman
3. Enter Sandman
4. Smells Like Teen Spirit
5. Enter Sandman
6. Enter Sandman
7. Enter Sandman
8. Enter Sandman
9. Weezer's Black Album
And I just bought weezers black album
Matthew and Dalia Steer take it back
Leo thegore 😂
Hey man you forgot smoke on the water
Matthew and Dalia Steer This is why White is heaven than Black’s hell.
Man... 16 years later and we still discussing about Lars snare on St. Anger lmao
the drums sounded like shit 16 years ago and will do in a 1000
@@erradate6425 Back in the day I didn't liked, but it grew on me nowdays
@@brunoleonardo210 tbh despite the hate I always found it to be interesting. but it sounds more like an experimental weird ass album from an underground nu metal band rather than a big come back from the most popular thrash metal band
@@erradate6425 I definitely dig what you are saying !
@@brunoleonardo210 glad we agree aha.
Death Magnetic and Hardwired were the 2 "real" come back to me eventho they are not nearly as good as their early material
I love how describing bass as "incredibly audible" is a compliment
When he put AJFA at number 5 I proceeded to grab my guitar, and played the entirety of Blackened and AJFA’s intro for the next 11 minutes
What a shame eh
Relatable
Yeah AJFA is #1 to me even though the production is definitely shit
You actually busted out the e-bow to play the beginning? Those things are fun!
@Colt 45 shit up nerd
My dad flipped out when he saw Black album get put after AJFA lmao
Me too
Me too
your dad has taste LMAO ajfa is a top 3 album for them
Me to
welllllllllllllllllllllllll kills em all is better
Though St Anger is considered the worst it brought us one of the greatest rockumentaries ever made, and I respect the band for allowing the world to see a bunch of egotistical millionaires at their low point.
Yeah, they were pretty shitty people to each other at that point, but the making of St. Anger was what got them over it, and without that record, we probably wouldn't have Metallica anymore. Their legacy would have ended with Load and Reload, and despite the fact that I like those albums, that would not be a very fitting end to Metallica's career.
it ought to have, theyre absolute boo-boo defu x2 currently if you catch my drift
Nick Reza Hardwired was pretty good
Yes, the funniest rockumentariy ever. Unintentionally funny
I think people just hate st anger because the snare sounds like a trash can.
The best Metallica album is obviously Nevermind
I would say their best album is Ok Computer but I respect your opinion
My personal fav Metallica album is Enema Of The State
I prefer their later album Yeezus
@@zackzallie8735 nah, their best album is Pinkerton
@@nathan_hall7445 it's definitely Led Zeppelin III
After hearing "Awkward guitars on To Live is To Die" I died inside
This guy is uncultured with the best Metallica album
@@cohenwalsh5003 Get over yourself. I _very much_ disagree with Fantano but this whole "anyone who doesn't like early Metallica is uncultured" attitude is a load of elitist bullshit. People will like and dislike what they please, no one is better or worse for it. Most classical musicians would look down on us metal heads in the same vein as any pop star. it's all relative.
@@a.t.3192 literally shut up. St. Anger is my second favorite
@@cohenwalsh5003 Regardless, unironically calling anyone "uncultured" is pompous and cringe af.
@@a.t.3192 I’m sorry to break it to you buddy, but classical is very relevant in the metal. cliff burton was a huge classical fan, neoclassical metal exists, metal in a lot of cases is just as (or even more) technical as classical music, a huge percentage of metal solos are classical influenced, and the middle section of Orion is pretty much classical with distortion. Just because the music is aggressive doesn’t mean it can’t be melodic or complicated, get educated.
You kinda forgot to mention that st. Anger was made during a time where the band was literally falling apart
Ja-nathen so was Saturday Night Wrist but that record is amazing
@@mo0se3 Exception to the rule
Yeah, if you watched Some Kind Of Monster’s documentary
It was just a bad misguided project, no real other excuses.
big something deftones don't have a bad album.
My favorite Metallica album is Rust in piece
Ikr? Freddie Mercury's singing on that album is awesome
Loved that song where they featured Ozzy and Pitbull
MaxxVII don’t forget Frank Sinatra playing the banjo 🪕
Funny thing is that Megadeth also had a very similar album called Rust in Peace
What about Lord of This World? Actually, I think that’s Led Zeppelin
1:24 St. Anger
3:44 Death Magnetic
5:33 Hardwired To Self-Destruct
6:36 Load/Reload
9:39 And Justice For All
12:07 Kill 'Em All
13:45 The Black Album
16:30 Ride The Lightning
18:18 Master Of Puppets
MoP and RtL are easily the bands most 'mystical' and sonically thematic and explorative outings, that actually capture the emotional states of the subject material, more along the lines of a Metallica-Zeppelin rather than the Metallca-Nickleback emotional 'song' driven style album outing.. the substance makes the sandwich. I agree with the first 2 - they are MY fav in same said order!
Thank you! I couldn’t wait to form an opinion on this band any later!
I agree with this except to swap and justice for all with the black album, then to put load/reload above the black album. The black album is awful lol
Is this the dudes ranking? Jesus. Thanks for posting it and saving me the wasted time of watching someone make and justify this shit list 😅
Load/reload above Death Magnetic and Hardwired is absolutely criminal
"There's so much ambient noise around Lars' drums..." wow, I've never heard the concept of overtones described more accurately by a non-drummer.
How could he not be aware of Lars's Drum Snare. It's like the biggest meme with St Anger.
@@DrZuluGaming he is, he just doesn’t want to mention it because it’s a dead horse
Shut up nerd
I'm still amazed by the jump Metallica made in song writing and quality from kill em all to ride the lighting it's crazy
He was still writing on ride the lightning
@@mackenzieperrault7382 from what I know it was one song .....call of cthullu
Mackenzie Perrault he wrote like one riff on the title track and on call of ktulu
Thanks to Mr. Cliff Burton!
Kill em all is my number 1 lol.
Kidz bop albums from best to worst
Andrew J don't you mean best to super-best?
dont u dare criticise these "gold standard" albums.
Number 32: All of them.
Andrew J good god there’s like 100+ albums
No, he means super-best to super-duper-bestest
AJFA is my favorite Metallica album 🤘 Don’t care about production or “lack of ideas”, this one hit me hard
it has no bass so it's a sin
legit man as if he dissed to live is to die aswell such an insane song
@@bassofd00m boost the bass sound and u will hear why its low af
Same here it really is
Same I love justice so much. Just the raw anger and aggression. Who’s cares about the production or the fact that there’s no vass
Fun facts:
1. Death Magnetic is one of the loudest albums ever mastered.
2. The snare drum on St Anger is actually a trash can.
The backlash to the dynamic compression resulted in the album getting a new mix for 2015.
Symphony Of Destruction is definitely my favorite Metallica song. Love Tom Araya's vocals on the song.
Symphony is good but scott ians drumming on pleasure to kill is a cut above imho.
MJNation Don't forget about dimebag darrells bongo solo on that track!
Pretty cool how Metallica is influenced by Ed Zeppelin.
Didnt curdt kobayn do that song?
2AM SOUL Yeah he did a cover of the song on the Superunknown album.
Buckethead worst to best, 12 hour video
yes
Thomas nah it would be a multiple part video lol
that sounds incredibly boring
frank you sound boring
Corte
I've heard a few of his songs and I see this buckethead catalogue meme every once in a while so I goggled "buckethead albums" saying to myself "how much would it be? 15?16?"
And HOLY shit 48 fucking albums
I’m so glad he gave the black album it’s deserved recognition. You can cry about how they sold out all you want, but with songs that well written and memorable... who cares
I do because it was the gateway for their mediocre output in the mid 90s to early 2000s. Sure, there are some good songs on it, but the album is a noticeable drop in quality compared to what they did in the previous three albums. People only give it recognition because it sold a bunch of copies, if it didn't people wouldn't be defending it so hard.
Imo load and reload are better
@@okagron "There are some good songs on it". The shit's classic, not just good.
@@AFellowCyberman nah
@@jfqd445 *worse
Best: Ride The Lightning. Worst: I AM THE TABLE
Master IMO
We need Pink Floyd worst to best melonhead
Ottonelli I think the Wall will be No. 1 on his list as when he did his what is a 10 video, he had the album cover with the title on his small green screen.
Though it should be Animals or Dark Side of the Moon
Anyone else that loves AJFA? My favourite metallica album
I got a soft spot for it. would rate it higher than the black album at least
@@gg-er1vv Yeah. 1.AJFA, 2.MOP 3.Kill Em All 3.Ride the Lightning, my TOP 4 Order. then the black album etc
*YESSS* Justice > Puppets (very close) > Kill/Lightning > Black Album
I think it's some of the best songs Metallica has ever written. My personal favorite. But the complaints about the mixing are totally valid, it's really a shame that bass is so low. It was close to perfection.
YASSS
10:18 The guitars fade out, to be replaced by the pounding of drums, which explode into an earthquake of power cords. This sudden replacement of mood shows the abruptness of Cliff’s death, and the anger that the band feels towards its injustice.
Dynamics people... dynamics
I love Death Magnetic. It brings back late 2000's and early 2010's nestolgia.
Easily my fave post black album
It is so under rated
The Day that never comes is a Top 10 Metallica song for me!!
If Metallica does make an album with the best of load and reload they should call it Load:reloaded
Please Stop 😂😂
Re-load: Re-reload
Nah, overload
they should have named the black album pre-load
Overload
Even though I know it's a chair I always see ride the lightning's cover art as a microphone
Hoshi Studios haha same for me
Hoshi Studios oh shit. I thought it was a mix too. Lol
Same, and I know it’s a blood splatter from a hammer but I always see Kill ‘Em All’s cover as a boy going like ‘shhhh’ with his finger xD
Max Otto
Close but it’s the artists semen and bull blood mixed between two sheets of perspex
Max Otto
Hmmm.
Ride The Lightning is them at their best. Best solos, best choruses, best vocals, and you can tell they put their full heart into it.
You could say the same thing for AJFA
@@deadlyknights1119 no bass + dont care
Definitely not James’ best vocals. While it’s probably his best early vocals, his voice in the load/reload era is far better
escape and trapped under ice boring as hell
Master is them at their best. Perfect album.
Justice after kill em all? Justice was their peak of writing and arguably a contender for #1 spot
Those aren’t Viking chants on the frayed ends of sanity, they’re mimicking the munchkins from the wizard of oz
And the MUNCHKINS' chant was loosely derived from vikings chants.
Not munchkins. The witch's guards.
What?
Definitely NOT Munchkins, but the Witch's guard as noted by Andrew. However the chant had no hidden meaning, it just sounded evil and ominous. Many have contemplated actual words and origins etc, but the script literally has nothing more than "0o-eeeh-ya, eoh-ya" written down. Sounds like they changed it slightly for filming, but Metallica including it sounded great to me, I didn't think it was campy or funny, I thought it respectable and a great intro sound for the tune.
@@rangamsarmah2061 1) not Munchkins, Witches guards, 2) nothing to do with Vikings but that is a cool story.
I wish he mentioned one when he was going over “and justice for all”
Jacob Dixon too popular
@@retroz3757 it doesn't matter if it' popular, it's objectively one of their best songs. Its top tier when considering lyrical content, technical skill, and songwriting.
S queezy oh sorry I was drunk I don’t what I said sorry I’m sorry 😐
@@retroz3757 Ok...so?
conveniently left out because his motive is to trash the album and you cant trash a perfect song
1. THERE
2. IS
3. NO
4. BAD
5.METALLICA
6. ALBUM
7. St. Anger
As many here, I would rank "And Justice for all" a lot higher (certainly in the top 3). It is their most progressive album. I've listened to it a million times and it never gets boring. The riffs, the breaks and the solos are great. The production is a matter of taste. I love the super percussive, super tight, extremely clean sound, and, to be honest, I never missed the bass until I read everywhere that it needs more bass. The sound is indeed flatter and not as heavy as the sound on "Master of Puppets" or the Black Album, but many progressive arrangements probably wouldn't have sounded that good with such a fat and heavy sound.
Yeah I'd probably have it as #3 or maybe even #2 behind Master of Puppets
I just don't get it. I think other than death magnetic, and justice for all has the most filler of any other Metallica album tbh. It has some fantastic moments that really stand out but overall I think it's one of their least consistent albums, the drums are probably the most consistently great parts to it but I think every single song was drug out so much longer than it had to be - I mean damn dude did they really need to double down on repeating 2 part choruses like 10 times every song? They had already done it too much on master of puppets, I love disposable heroes and pepper messiah but god damn they drug those out with choruses we didn't need to hear so much. AJFA was them doubling down on that and going way way worse with it in my opinion. If they'd have cut out a lot of the filler I'd agree that it's great but they really stretched it out in a really lazy way IMHO. (The lack of bass makes it even worse to me because it makes it sound like a demo. It's passable in terms of listenability for me since I am mainly a guitarist but I love bass as an instrument and I can't help but wonder how much more interesting the album could've been if it had bass throughout actually because a lot of times the interesting chord changes and harmonies are made much better depending on how the bass is interacting with it. Not having bass on a thrash album kind of wrecks it in my opinion because the guitars tend to be doing simple chords so much, 80% of it is either power chords via 5ths or 4ths and that on it's own is not sonically interesting - the bass is what adds the extra layer to the chords and the rest of the music because whatever extended parts there are to the guitar's power chord is played on the bass. I just don't get any of it man, there was a lot of potential on AJFA but I think they all stabbed themselves in the foot with how they went about it.
@@dudeman5303 welcome to thrash metal.
Kill em all: thrash metal
Ride the lighting: thrash metal
Master of puppets: thrash metal
Ajfa: thrash metal
Black album: heavy metal
Load: blues rock
Reload: hard rock
St anger: nu metal
Death magnetic: thrash metal
Hardwired: heavy metal
Joel Marioni I wouldn’t say that that St. Anger is Nu. It’s like an undiscovered genre of metal.
St anger: trash metal
Kill em All is not a thrash metal album.
@@drewp.weiner5065 yes it is
Drew P. Weiner are you high, sir? Kill em all is most definetly a thrash album, one of the first actually
St.Anger is too high on this list...
rly tho
I fucking love St. Anger man and invisible kid is good in my opinion. I get he doesn't like it but don't brand it like it's pure shit.
Psycho Icon St Anger is one of the best Metallica albums don’t @ me.
I still give it a spin at least once a year. Yeah, it's not great but it's cool to hear the usually perfectly mastered Metallica play a raw, garage band record.
Agreed they need to release more stuff so this can go even further down the list, yes Load and Reload are no picnic but if another band made those albums people would like them more it's just junk compared to the rest of the stuff they did.
The biggest thing that I’ve got out of this video is that Melon likes the line “my lifestyle determines my deathstyle.”
It’s a good line. Bite me
@@world_of_manny_malibu It is not.
Metallica have more amazing albums than most bands have albums
Not really LOL. They have 4 amazing Albums and then two pretty good ones.
Look at Megadeth if you want 10+ rocksolid albums ;).
@@j.j.4150 That's just my opinion. Music is subjective. I prefer Metallica over Megadeath by a lot.
@@leam89 I think that Metallica’s first 4 albums are collectively better then Megadeth’s entire discography. But if you take away those first four Megadeth’s discog is infinitely better then Metallica.
@@bloodflowerrrs1555 Metallica have 6 great albums in my opinion. The first five and the last one. But yes if you take away all Metallica's great albums then yes Megadeath would be better.
@@bloodflowerrrs1555 have you not listened to peace sells or rust in peace? It's not even fair, the musicianship, writing, guitar playing, everything is so above Metallica.
I prefer Ride The Lightning over Master Of Pupets because it has a nicer tone.
same, ride the lightning is definitely their tightest and most succinct work
I always thought MOP was the best because of its atmosphere but recently I listened to both again and I enjoyed RTL better. The drumming on MOP sounds really terrible at times, the lyrics are stupid and the slower songs (like Sanitarium) gets boring.
No.
More innovation IMO , love it way more
@Lord Takyon Escape is really whatchu mean
Do a Beatles one! I want to get all excited beforehand, before immediately becoming bitter and upset when my opinions differ from those of some internet melon.
Positive Comment what's your #1
Abbey Road #1
Larks' Tongues In Aspic Mine as well, I think sgt pepper almost makes it, but doesn't have the soul and drive of abbey.
My opinion:
The Beatles #1
Abbey Road #2
Revolver #3
Magical Mystery Tour #4
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band #5
Ranking these masterpieces is really tough.
he's turned the beatles against us
I agree with basically all of this, but Ride The Lightning will always be my favorite. I know I’m in the minority with that but it’s such a fast, raw, amazing album.
Ride The Lightning #1 the most melody, the most harmonies, gorgeous album to the ears.
Agreed
PINK FLOYD: WORST TO BEST PLEASE
Buckethead: Worst to Best all 300+ albums if u dare.
Akis21IsHere LMAO
The problem is Buckethead may do another 50 while Anthony is making the video.
Best: Electric Tears
Worst: .... *picks random album that isn't electric tears.
Akis21IsHere he will probably release albums while he records it
Viper worst to best when
the "death style - life style" was Kirk's line, he is always the best part
I love The Day That Never Comes. I remember getting so hyped to that shit. I think the reason I loved it is because I wasn't attached to their older sound or songs. I listened to this on a clean slate. I need to give it a listen, it's been a while.
Still kicks ass. I don’t get the comparison that it sounds like a worse version of The Unforgiven at all. One? Maybe could see the comparison between those two, but definitely not the Unforgiven lmao
It’s been 3 years man have u gave it a another listen and what did u think
My favorite Metallica song is Through the River
I'm glad someone else caught that
This guy has no idea what he's talking about
LOL I catch that too
*Never?
@@theeverythingchannel5457 15:40 bro
Pink floyd worst to best is essential, I still debate internally animals vs dark side for #1
It's Wish You Were Here tho
Wish You Were Here M8Y
Animals is their best album
idk i could see him go with animals just because dark sides the more "mainstream"
i think he said animals in a liveshow
My ranking
10 - St Anger
9 - Reload
8 - Load
7 - Hardwired to self destruct
6 - The Black Album
5 - Kill Em All
4 - Death Magnetic
3 - ...And justice for all
2 - Master of puppets
1 - Ride the lightning
death magnetic 4th place
yeah sure bud
@@byel2844 All Nightmare Long, The Day That Never Comes, Cyanide, That Was Just Your Life, Broken, Beat and Scarred. Death Magnetic was awesome why would be wrong with it being at 4th place?
@@elcacahuate7l979 people who can’t think for themselves hate it.
The day that never comes is my favorite metallica song for no reason, i just really like it
'Ride the Lightning' is the best Metallica album and easily one of the greatest Thrash Metal albums in the history of music.
And that’s a fact
Ride the Lightning (the song) have one of the coolest intros I've ever heard.
Id argue justice is its equal.
so far so good so what
iKnowNothing and it was written by lars haha
Death magnetic: easily the most UNDERRATED album. Broken beat & scared, All nightmare long, That was just your life, all bangers.
Cypress Grove I love Broken Beat And scarred and All Nightmare Long and The day that never comes. I do wish the album was recorded a little heavier though. The recording sounded a bit hollow but I still like those songs
There are a lot of great songs I agree. If only the production was better. I rate it number 5 personally
James's vocal is weak on DM, production is dry, it deff has some pretty good songs on it tho even if they arent all great.
I'm with you man, a lot better than self-destruct and both load albums for sure
MicShazam I do like some but I agree that the production was horrible. The Hardwired album is so much better.
Leper Messiah is my favorite Metallica song. Super underrated, and the guitar parts are awesome
Yes!
I've also noticed that a lot of Master of Puppets tracks are about manipulation in some way. Like a puppet being manipulated. Also, I personally really like the transitions in To Live Is To Die. I feel like it represents just how quickly the stages of mourning occur
yeah, To Live is To Die is a great song, and a great way to mourn the loss of Cliff Burton considering it was based on a demo recorded by Cliff.
I noticed that the song One is referring to war in some kind of way but this is just a theory
@@alexboucher4103 hehe
And justice for all number 5?
FUCK
it's my favorite album
Same
Same
Yeah musically it’s great but the production on and justice sucks balls and there’s no bass it’s a defective masterpiece
It deserves #5
@@natehtf5760 no, it deserves to be above kill ‘‘em all
Kill Em Lars
Ride The Lars
Lars Of Puppets
And Justice For Lars
The Black Lars
Lars
ReLars
Lars Inc.
St. Lars
Lars Magnetic
Hardwired... To Lars Destruct
72 Lars
DoisLados hard-wired... to Lars
Larswired... to self destruct
Ride The Lars sounds wrong, as if it sounds like Lars is the name of a generic dick
Ha! Ride the lars...
For lulu. Larlu
the To Live is to Die slander will not be tolerated
Lulu is absolutely one of the albums of all time
Led Zeppelin best to worst
Vee I *best to best to best to best
1. ...and justice for all
2. ...and justice for all
3. ...and justice for all
4. Lulu
Moshi moshi
What? ...And Justice For All is so much better than ...And Justice For All
5. Led zeppelin 4
Ride the lightning is by favorite Metallica álbum, but the strange thing is that most of my top ten favorite Metallica songs are from the "And justice for all" such as eye of the beholder, harvester of sorrow, one, blackend, dyers Eve, frayed end of satinity.
For me (2019 lol)
10: Load
9. St. Anger
8. ReLoad
(Here on are amazing)
7. Death Magnetic
6. Hardwired To Self Destruct...
5. And Justice for All
4. Metallica (Black Album)
3. Kill Em’ All
2. Master of Puppets
1. Ride Ze Fucking Lightning
edit: due to me being dumb 3 months ago, I am moving load to 9th and stanger to 10th (2020)
Edit 2:
10) st anger (like it much more now, dark times + st anger = understanding lyrics and liking it more, but still not as good as it should have been
9) load, really have it close to reload, just like st anger I still like it much more than I used to, mainly because of the lyrics again but yeah
8) basically said it in load, just has more faster and heavier shit
7) hardwired, don’t get me wrong I love this album too but not everything is fast, lyrics are great too but not as good as
6) death magnetic, fast as fuck, love it, only thing is James voice is probably at its second worse here, somehow it got better for hardwired and has since too, saw em at lollapolloza
5) kill ‘em all, just way too raw, still love all the songs too (I love basically all their songs) but it’s just an above average thrash album and it’s good
4) black album, if it was faster holy shit, but still heavy as balls, which was awesome, also love the ballads here too, and a lot of songs, with some speed and heaviness
3) justice, the top 3 are basically interchangeable but it’s not RTL or MOP, so yeah, also love the tone, and James peak in all things, including beer
2) RTL, favorite album ever, literally no skips, best tone IMO, and Still raw enough too, creeping death too, best song to me
1) master, just amazing, so fast, so much anger, Orion, can’t go wrong here, and sanitarium like dude
Tiers because it’s hard to rank
1) perfect: master and RTL
2) great: justice, black
3) decent: kill em all
4) not good: load/reload, st anger, All coulda been better
The worst Metallica album is Load? Really?
LOAD???? ARE YOU **** KIDDING ME?
100% agree
@@archeomax05soli10 Load isn't that bad
Move Load up you nerd
David Bowie: Worst to Best would be awesome
ST BG best to best?
I agree he has so many good albums but for real he recorded some bad music too. Never Let Me Down, Hours, Tonight for example
A weekly Worst to Best would be awesome.
That video would be like an hour long
Yes please
Metallicas writing style determines their reading style.
And their life style determines their death style.
Iron Hammer k
Iron Hammer I was just about to say that fuck... XD
Your typing style determines your intelligence style
LOL
I don’t understand the hate behind death magnetic. I personally think it’s one of their best.
Tom Waits Blood Money just chillin in the background.
1- St. Anger
2- St. Anger
3- Despacito
I like the way you think
4- Sandstorm
@@sernoddicusthegallant6986 indeed
5 Gangam Style
6- Wonderwall
Anthony: does video on Metallica
Fader: SO HE WORSHIPS SATAN TOO
How has he put ajfa below kill ‘em all
1. Ride the lightning
2. Master of puppets
3. AJFA
4. Black album
5. Kill em all
6. Hardwired
7. Death magnetic
8. Reload
9. Load
10. Boulevard of broken dreams
That's exactly my ranking
10:00 ”The band was running out of ideas”
Have you even listened to AJFA?!
Frayed ends and Justice intensify
RIGHT?!?!? BEST Metallica album EVER.
@@gentelmanjunkie542 I'd personally say 4th best but I can see why people love it a lot.
God fucking bless One.
To Live Is To Die is one of the most beautiful compositions ever created
DEAR MOTHER DEAR FATHER
Michael Jackson - Worst to Best
Number 1: All of them.
Treyvion Burklund
Really Good
1-Bad
2-Thriller
3-Dangerous
the other ones:meh
Crap: Invincible and the album not made by Jackson himself (Michael, Xscape ect. ect.)
Swap 1 and 2, and I agree with you
I Know... I just had to choose...i have even the original thriller vynil...
There is no bad Michael Jackson album.
Having Death Magnetic at the 2nd worst saddens me to my core. Unforgiven III, The Day That Never Comes, Cyanide, and All Nightmare Long are some amazing tracks.
Death Magnetic was actually really good imo. I wouldn’t rank it that low
Pink Floyd worst to best
Nick Mason yeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss
Nick Mason Animals is the best in my opinion. I can’t believe they put out Dark Side of The Moon, Wish You Were Here, Animals and The Wall in a 6 year period. What other band could do that?
Yessssssss
Yes, this, this makes the most sense
Dark Side
WYWH
Meddle
Animals
Piper At The Gates of Dawn
The Wall
The Divison Bell
the rest
The black album is more influential than great if that makes sense. The black album introduced many people including myself to not only Metallica but metal in general
You are totally right. It's a great metal record for "beginners" if you know what I mean. Like, it is pretty heavy, it has catchy riffs, great vocals and lyrics, great solos, all of the good stuff that metal has to offer, but at the same time it's much more tight and "clean" than their early stuff. There isn't as many instrumental parts, songs usually aren't too long, have only one solo etc.
Thrash metal isn't the easiest entrance to heavy music, you need to be already used to the sound of heavy stuff to enjoy that complicated and technical style of Justice or Master. Black Album on the other hand has songs like Wherever I May Roam or Enter Sandman that are great examples of how simple can be stronger. And I could easily play The Unforgiven or Nothing Else Matters to my classmates and the would like it.
@@Eris_Norregard Which makes zero sense in connection to what he claims.
@@DropkickNation What exactly makes zero sense?
@@Eris_Norregard Saying that more accessible is less good, like he claims.
Black Albums song writing, melodies, production etc. blow most parts of the old thrash stuff out of the water.
Just because it's less technical or more accessible doesn't mean that it's anywhere less good, as he was saying, dude.
@@DropkickNation Yeah, I agree with you on that. I don't think he meant what he said in a bad way though. When he said it's "more influential than great", I think he was simply pointing out the fact that just because it's the most to the general public known metal album, it doesn't make it the best metal album. Or that's the way I understood it.
Justice is peak metallica, nothing can rival its dark and looming tone.
Lightning and Puppets are superior
Except a bass guitar
@@SG-qx1fg lmfao
Ride The Lighting is My Favorite Metallica Album Justice For All Is A Close 2
One of Cobain’s favorite songs ever was Whiplash.
Motorhead's cover of that song is also great
To live is to die is a masterpiece
The whole Justice album tbh.
Random Metalhead yes i agere but i also Kinda agree with its a little bit dry but still My fav album
Same, besides Master.
pink floyd best to worst please
andrew southworth more like meh to best
^this Pied Piper>>>>>>>all
WYWH >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Am I the only one who thinks meddle is there best
simon kreitmayr meddle is great, echoes is a masterpiece.
Out of everything you said, load and reload being the last time they challenged themselves artistically is right on the nail, it just feels like Metallica stopped caring to be Metal and the band that made insane epics over fame and money and sadly I think that's what makes all their work afterwards nowhere near their first 5 records
Great review, I've been a fan since the late eighties- and would rank them pretty much the same - a great insight of each album- a must view if your just getting into the band.
I can't be the only one who genuinely loved Death Magnetic...
The songs are incredible on that album...I feel like I'm taking crazy pills here.
Bake me all you want but I like it better than Hardwired just because it feels heavier
It's got some great tracks. The Day That Never Comes and All Nightmare Long are the obvious standouts, and idk why Broken Beat & Scarred doesn't get talked about at all.
I agree. It's a good album, but badly produced. Better than "Hardwired....."!
I loved DM I remember sitting in a car listening to a radio station because they were going to have the first play of a song off the album. They played Day that never comes. My dad and I went crazy because we were so scared they would go for more like St anger lol.
That was just your life is my favorite Metallica song
Do Nas Worst to Illmatic
Sal A. So Nastrodamus to Illmatic?
Ah, yes the "awkward guitars" of the band's best instrumental..
Damn Melon, That AJFA take is legit one of the worst i've ever heard. Never once got the impression they were "Running out of ideas" As i would argue its them at their most creative tbh. Musically its far and away their most technical and progressive album to date, And lyrically i believe its peak James. Blackened, AJFA, One, Harvester Of Sorrow & Dyers Eve are some of the deepest, Rawest songs he's written. I think Lars is at his absolute best here, And id say the riffs on this album are easily some of their best as well. Overall despite the lack of bass and somewhat brittle production, I think musically its every bit as good and in some spots arguably better than the rest of their 80's material.
And Justice For All gets a shit rep man. I love that album. It rules. My favorite by far.
Thrash McNash same here
Totally agree. The album is like a journey.
Me to man it's on my top 5 Metallica
Thats bullshit, almost everyone likes that album.
Do people not like AJFA? It's my personal favorite album, and I've always thought people loved it.
The Wiggles, best to greatest. Make it so.
See, that's where you're wrong
All of their songs are the greatest.
ESPECIALLY Fruit Salad.
Coming in at number 23 is of course Rock And Roll Pre-school. Now right from the get go it's clear that Emma Watkins, being a new member, can't hold the same chemistry as Anthony did. Another issue I have with this album though is the weird intro skits added to the start of the songs. While an interesting idea, it falls flat as it slows down the pacing their last albums had. On top of that this album lacks any bangers. Wheres my, you know fruit salad, my hot potato. Overall, a very slack release from the Wiggles, onto number 22...
This is why I need a video. I know nothing!
I think big red car shits all over the rest of there songs
Interesting video. One of my favorite videos I've seen from you so far. Although I haven't watched many videos from you yet.
6 years later, where does 72 SEASONS stand in this list?
Wait, there is a lack of ideas or interesting performances on AJFA?..One, Blackened, Harvester of Sorrow, Shortest Straw, To Live is to Die....these are all uninteresting and tepid material to you?
Joseph Browning and Dyers Eve
Blackened is one of their best and my favourite from AJFA.
Having just listened to AJFA...yes. Those songs you mentioned aren't very interesting. Tepid is a bit much, tho.
Kenny Blankenship meh, I disagree, there’s plenty of interesting performances on the record. But it’s your opinion so it’s aight
AJFA is great
Floyd, Zep, Queen, Beatles.
Just do it
J. Page that’s really all I want from this guy
@Tony Marshall Queen doesn't have any classic albums
I will continue to say Load and Reload are amazing albums. Although I think Load is way better than ReLoad. And quite honestly, Load is top 5 for me. I think it’s great. This is my list
11- St. Anger
10-Hardwired
9-72 Seasons
8-Death Magnetic
7-Reload
5/6-(Load-Black album are interchangeable for me here)
4- Justice
3- Kill Em All
2-Master Of Puppets
1-Ride The Lightning
Man I totally agree with your number 1, it is my favourite Metallica's album until today, after 30 years of my first listening of that album. The mood and atmosphere is certainly unbeatable!. Great video!
"Through the River" is a classic Metallica tune.
Twisting.turning.through,the,river!
0:00 me when my uncles in town
Unclethony Rapistano
Everytime you say they ran out of idea it sounds more like you're running out of ideas for your criticism
Yeah he puts AJFA above the black and I personally don’t agree since there’s only like 4 songs on the black album that I REALLY like while I love all the songs on AJFA and the fact he says Kirks laziest solo is on all nightmare long when his laziest was obviously on enter sandman kinda shows he doesn’t really know what he’s talking about which makes sense
Chao Men ooooof
@@destinygaming2523 Oh my god exactly! I love All nightmare long because I grew up with GH Metallica and I loved that song. The only songs I like on TBA have to be Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, Sad but true, Wherever I may roam, and Nothing else matters. I also think that the laziest Kirk was on solos was the entirety of St. Anger because there are no solos!
4:49 how do you not like this song? Such a masterpiece