Who's better - compared to who? We need to stop comparing apples with oranges. Surely, Allie can do and sing anything, she has a unique tone, and a personality that catalysts her performance no end; she's incredible at singing softly and she's incredible at going all in and full bore. Saibh is very different, her niche is much narrower, yet within her sweet little niche she's incredible and she can do what Allie can't do. The difference is the niche, and while Allie is simply in her own league (and it would be unfair to not acknowledge that), Saibh can truly shine as bright as Allie in her segment. I find Saibh incredible.
Both girls have an amazing talent and a beautiful voice. I listen to both of them. Allie does have a very distinctive voice that i would recognize of i heard her on the radio. Allie is very special 💖 however, Skelly is also special in her own way or i wouldn't be listening to her and she wouldn't have so many subscribers. The best to both of them❤❤
They're both very good and wish them both only the best. I would feel bad diminishing either by preferring the other. Allie has 5.55 million YT subscribers & nearly 1 billion views. Earning her some serious bucks for a busker. Saibh seems to be a bit more seasoned singer but so far has a long way to catch up with Allie's appeal.
I like both but I think Saibh focuses more on quality and making her own music while Allie tends to make one cover after the other and often sings with full voice. More personal tracks and more soft songs would benefit her to add variety, but both are young and nice ladies who put you in a good mood when it's raining, and you never know it might happen in Ireland ;) I wish them both the best and youtube in itself is enough competition between them, let them be friends with each other too :D
Obviously Allie. I can't WAIT to see how Allie will interpret a song. I want to hear ALL my favorite songs sung by Allie. Saibh has a pretty voice. And that's it for me.
I think Allie had the voice & pop-star looks but hasn’t progressed as a performer. I agree with many that she is increasingly “shouty” these days &, for me, she doesn’t command attention when performing. The huge number of RUclips subscribers isn’t a current reflection of active viewers - most videos only get a few hundred thousand views after, say, 2 months, with those getting 1m+ views few & far between these days despite having close to 6m subscribers. Saibh still has pop star looks, doesn’t have such a strong voice but is definitely a better performer in my opinion. Her RUclips subscriber numbers may be tiny in comparison but are growing organically & she receives a far stronger proportion of views relative to subscribers. I feel Saibh’s career is being better managed & she is more likely to achieve the longevity that I fear will evade Allie if she doesn’t move to different management. Just my opinion as a subscriber to both.
Worse review ever. Seriously some of the footage used in this Hack are not even the original artists. Who actually forced you to do this and WHY? Both performers are talented why compare unsubstantiated facts between the two girls. Anyway rant over I want my 5 minutes back!
I'm not sure I understand the premise of your video. "Who Is Better" you ask, yet... you declare Allie's supremacy throughout your presentation. If you ask the question, a statement should never be given. Arguments of status, accomplishment, worth, and success should be offered for both and let your viewers decide and place their thoughts in the comments section. They're "involvement" should make for a better experience than what you've assembled here. Click baiting looks like it works but after a while, it dies off because no one wants the disappointment anymore. If you have a good story, an interesting angle, or entertaining content, do not deceive the experience by your title. Legitamacy may take longer to build, but it will last longer.
I disagree with the comment on the video that Allie is more talented than Saibh. I think Saibh is the better singer. Allie at times overdoes it and sounds screeching. Saibh doesn't do that.
Very well explained although I have my doubts about their net worth, that's more of a guess than a truth, there are a ton of videos circulating about Allie's net worth and they are all very different.
two difrant voice allies voice is very powerfull she has a natural yodel in her voice, only 1 other singer ive ever heard the same patsy cline, saibh has a smooth soft voice very pleasant to the ear im my book there tied huggs saibh
This is really easy Allie is good but note she struggles beyond covers and that street sound. Saibh is producing original material and can move her range. Sadly Allie has been over promoted and not given time to blossom, she is still self concious and looks regularly to camera (dad ) for guide. Allie will not be heard of in 5 years but Saibh will have a career somewhere in music.
@@duncaninspain Is it DISGRACEFUL to sing with Allie, get thousands of subs and millions of views, then as soon as she gets a record contract dump her ?
Mais quel intérêt? Deux personnalités... Deux sensibilités... une approche artistique différente, ce ne serait pas très courtois de comparer ces deux personnes....💕💞💕💞 pour les deux artistes...j'ai une préférence mais je ne le dirais pas...
So you didn't really demonstrate who is the better singer and performer, but kept saying Allie is more talented for no other reason than she makes more money. Their voices are similar, but Allie's is a little more raw. Did you hear her Christmas album on Spotify? You didn't miss anything. Very forgettable.
Allie does not respond to her following, with her it's all me me, and some more of me, She is gross. Saibh is the total opposite, with Total appreciation and respect. Noticing your following goes a long way in the music industry.
NO CONTEST #saibhskelly is a well rounded talent from her vocals, her writing, and her delivery. All Allie does is showcase her breasts instead of her vocals. Her attempt to be sultry overshadows her performances , cheapens it
You realize neither one of these talented young ladies have anything to do with this troll video. Your criticisms ofAllie here is the cheapest you can get. Clearly you have a double standard.
@@larrycross4114 my "opinion " of Allie is what it is, im sorry you don't agree or see it. She's being sexualized and it cheapens her performances. Sorry you don't agree
Please don’t compare, they are both talented in different ways. Both are great.
I agree 100%.❤❤
Why comparing? They are both great singers who do their best in following their dreams.
Your video is hyenism and feeding off the glory of others. Nothing more.
I'm a Saibh fan.
Who's better - compared to who? We need to stop comparing apples with oranges. Surely, Allie can do and sing anything, she has a unique tone, and a personality that catalysts her performance no end; she's incredible at singing softly and she's incredible at going all in and full bore. Saibh is very different, her niche is much narrower, yet within her sweet little niche she's incredible and she can do what Allie can't do. The difference is the niche, and while Allie is simply in her own league (and it would be unfair to not acknowledge that), Saibh can truly shine as bright as Allie in her segment. I find Saibh incredible.
Both girls have an amazing talent and a beautiful voice. I listen to both of them. Allie does have a very distinctive voice that i would recognize of i heard her on the radio. Allie is very special 💖 however, Skelly is also special in her own way or i wouldn't be listening to her and she wouldn't have so many subscribers. The best to both of them❤❤
Saibh has incredible talent
Saibh is good, very good, glad you made that point to., Both great talents
Please don't pair these two in competition. They are both amazing singers in their own right.
Both are great!. Allie has great range, but for me, Saibh is easier to listen to.
They're both very good and wish them both only the best. I would feel bad diminishing either by preferring the other.
Allie has 5.55 million YT subscribers & nearly 1 billion views. Earning her some serious bucks for a busker.
Saibh seems to be a bit more seasoned singer but so far has a long way to catch up with Allie's appeal.
I like both but I think Saibh focuses more on quality and making her own music while Allie tends to make one cover after the other and often sings with full voice. More personal tracks and more soft songs would benefit her to add variety, but both are young and nice ladies who put you in a good mood when it's raining, and you never know it might happen in Ireland ;)
I wish them both the best and youtube in itself is enough competition between them, let them be friends with each other too :D
Obviously Allie. I can't WAIT to see how Allie will interpret a song. I want to hear ALL my favorite songs sung by Allie.
Saibh has a pretty voice. And that's it for me.
They are both great 👍😉
Saibh, hands down more talented
I think Allie had the voice & pop-star looks but hasn’t progressed as a performer. I agree with many that she is increasingly “shouty” these days &, for me, she doesn’t command attention when performing. The huge number of RUclips subscribers isn’t a current reflection of active viewers - most videos only get a few hundred thousand views after, say, 2 months, with those getting 1m+ views few & far between these days despite having close to 6m subscribers.
Saibh still has pop star looks, doesn’t have such a strong voice but is definitely a better performer in my opinion. Her RUclips subscriber numbers may be tiny in comparison but are growing organically & she receives a far stronger proportion of views relative to subscribers. I feel Saibh’s career is being better managed & she is more likely to achieve the longevity that I fear will evade Allie if she doesn’t move to different management.
Just my opinion as a subscriber to both.
Worse review ever. Seriously some of the footage used in this Hack are not even the original artists. Who actually forced you to do this and WHY? Both performers are talented why compare unsubstantiated facts between the two girls. Anyway rant over I want my 5 minutes back!
I'm not sure I understand the premise of your video. "Who Is Better" you ask, yet... you declare Allie's supremacy throughout your presentation. If you ask the question, a statement should never be given. Arguments of status, accomplishment, worth, and success should be offered for both and let your viewers decide and place their thoughts in the comments section. They're "involvement" should make for a better experience than what you've assembled here. Click baiting looks like it works but after a while, it dies off because no one wants the disappointment anymore. If you have a good story, an interesting angle, or entertaining content, do not deceive the experience by your title. Legitamacy may take longer to build, but it will last longer.
Yes indeed they are both great singers 🇳🇱😉👍
I disagree with the comment on the video that Allie is more talented than Saibh. I think Saibh is the better singer. Allie at times overdoes it and sounds screeching. Saibh doesn't do that.
Saibh wins hands down. Allie is way to screechy
Naturally endowed is an understatement
saibh is #1
Saibh is my favourite.
Saibh may be talented, but it is not her voice that she uses to get ahead.
Saibh is a better singer👌
💕Allie and Saibh are very close in there Voice and Guitar💕Maybe they should 🎶🎶🎶🎸🎸🎶🎶🎶🎸🎸🎶🎶🎶 Together??!!💕💕💕💕🌞
Very well explained although I have my doubts about their net worth, that's more of a guess than a truth, there are a ton of videos circulating about Allie's net worth and they are all very different.
I'm a Saibh fan - always have been
Allie a une voix puisante et un rytme de danse superbe , Saibh a le talent , le style et le charme !
Saibh by a country mile FACT
Best Screecher Allie BUT Best Singer Saibh easily
I vote for Saibh
two difrant voice allies voice is very powerfull she has a natural yodel in her voice, only 1 other singer ive ever heard the same patsy cline, saibh has a smooth soft voice very pleasant to the ear im my book there tied huggs saibh
This is really easy Allie is good but note she struggles beyond covers and that street sound. Saibh is producing original material and can move her range. Sadly Allie has been over promoted and not given time to blossom, she is still self concious and looks regularly to camera (dad ) for guide.
Allie will not be heard of in 5 years but Saibh will have a career somewhere in music.
Saibh is just cute and wears low cut tops. If she stays on her ..... she will do well.
@@nova_juan disgraceful
@@duncaninspain But is it TRUE ??
@@duncaninspain Is it DISGRACEFUL to sing with Allie, get thousands of subs and millions of views, then as soon as she gets a record contract dump her ?
@@nova_juan Terrible, delete your post
Definitely saibh
late too the party but saibh more talented, comes accross as a better personality too. 🤥
Saibh e puro talento tem a voz natural ❤🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Saibh I have her original songs on CD
Allie is way better in every category..
wont you be surprised when Saibh finds more commercial success
@@davidg4595 Its already going quite the opposite of what you are suggesting...
@@jeffreycoyle Some great facts you are itemizing there.
Mais quel intérêt? Deux personnalités... Deux sensibilités... une approche artistique différente, ce ne serait pas très courtois de comparer ces deux personnes....💕💞💕💞 pour les deux artistes...j'ai une préférence mais je ne le dirais pas...
So you didn't really demonstrate who is the better singer and performer, but kept saying Allie is more talented for no other reason than she makes more money. Their voices are similar, but Allie's is a little more raw. Did you hear her Christmas album on Spotify? You didn't miss anything. Very forgettable.
There is no comparison between the two stars, Allie is unic and the best one
Lauren Doyle
Allie does not respond to her following, with her it's all me me, and some more of me, She is gross. Saibh is the total opposite, with Total appreciation and respect. Noticing your following goes a long way in the music industry.
NO CONTEST #saibhskelly is a well rounded talent from her vocals, her writing, and her delivery. All Allie does is showcase her breasts instead of her vocals. Her attempt to be sultry overshadows her performances , cheapens it
You realize neither one of these talented young ladies have anything to do with this troll video. Your criticisms ofAllie here is the cheapest you can get. Clearly you have a double standard.
@@larrycross4114 my "opinion " of Allie is what it is, im sorry you don't agree or see it. She's being sexualized and it cheapens her performances. Sorry you don't agree
I like Saibh Skelly much more than Allie Sherlock. Sherlock tends to yell too much, and makes weird and ugly faces when she sings!
Allie Sherlock the best
Angel Face... ( Allie Sherlock ..Do you want marry with me? I am a poor man. But I will honest to you. Irwan
Angel Face... ( Saibh Skelly ..Do you want marry with me? I am a poor man. But I will honest to you. Irwan
Both.
channel reported.
@ Mia Jaimson..... what is there to report ?
Show me on a doll where Saibh being better, hurt you. You've had a year to think about it so let us see.
Saibh wants it and she has the heart, + she writes better material. Allie just phones it in, anymore.