I agree! I think it was out of place for Quick Water to randomly become a villain because of how strong and independent of a character she was in DOTC. she was willing to stand up for what's right then suddenly believed killing Shadowstar would save her clan? I never understood where that mindset came from. As for th journey, it stretched out wayyy to long to be enjoyable
Yeah they ruined quick water. They could have had clear sky fill that role. And yeah midnight and part of moonrise were fine but they rest like dawn? No.
Honestly I like the sun drown place plot ,along with Twigbranch and Violetshine drama. The rest I completely agree with, I wish they would have made Shadowstar’s life more interesting ,she was my favorite cat from dawn of the clans. Overall good video
I hated it when Lionblaze trespassed and allowed Ratscar to beat him up(The Last Hope) only because he wanted to show Cinderheart that he can be beaten. Lionblaze almost started a war because the relationship between Thunderclan and Shadowclan was already bad due to Flametail's death. Besides, the Dark Forest was already planning to attack sooner or later(and Lionblaze knew that) and all the Clans had to unite instead of fighting each other. P. S. Would you like to make a Top-10 your favourite names or Top-10 most underused characters?
Omigosh sun-drowned place and the whole Feather/Crow thing was a good idea at first but I just don't like the drama and the fact that the badger told them something completely useless. They could've left the forest without Midnight telling them to do so! I agree with all of these!!!( I just subscribed!!)
Und dann ich, die in "Schicksal des WolkenClans" einfach die Geschichte rund um Stock spannender fand, als den Rest des Buches (habe das halbe Buch einfach vergessen, weil ich es so uninteressant fand) 🙃
I respect yours and others' opinions and I really enjoyed this video, so I'm going to be respectful about this. I think these plots were really cool! At least most of the them. The only two I agree with that were kinda boring is the drama and the cats' theory of Jayfeather killing Flametail. I mean, come on, Firestar. You really thought your good medicine cat would kill another good medicine cat? And Bumblestripe and Dovewing. PICK ONE CAT OR THE OTHER. Just to add on and share this for no reason, but I thought the solar eclipse was a great idea and FREAKING EPIC!!
No hate at all, but i don't understand why people hate the New Prophecies so much. It introduced minor characters such as Crowpaw, Tawnypaw, and Featherpaw and Stormpaw as actual important cats and not just background cats that only existed to butter up Firestar. It also made for a lot of cute moments such as when Squirrelpaw was stuck in the fence and while the toms were arguing, Tawnypelt and Feathertail were actually helping. I also did not like Stick's character at all. The hate he showed toward Harley and the unnecessary need to kill enemies was not okay, and he was so blind to that that he killed his own daughter on *accident*. He also made Leafstar question Sharpclaw's loyalty. (I also do not like Sharpclaw becuz he could have chosen whether to like the daylight warriors or not and whether to tell Leafstar about the night training and after all of that he was forgiven?!)
No joke i completely skipped dawn because of how boring it was. Midnight was boring too but i did manage to finish the book, i absolutely loved moonrise, but i couldn't stand dawn. After shadowclan got evacuated i was just done and quit reading it.
I really like the storys especially the sun drown place one i found it exciting and interesting i really don't find it boring nor the others 🤷 but i respect your opinion.
None of them I found really boring but the cinder and lion drama was stupid lion said multiple times that he loved cinder but then she said "no I'm distracting you"
Awesome! Srry to be that person but can I get a pin?
Yes :)
Thank you!!
I think the sun drown place and Shadowstar"s life were good ideas that weren't used right.
I agree! I think it was out of place for Quick Water to randomly become a villain because of how strong and independent of a character she was in DOTC. she was willing to stand up for what's right then suddenly believed killing Shadowstar would save her clan? I never understood where that mindset came from. As for th journey, it stretched out wayyy to long to be enjoyable
Yeah they ruined quick water. They could have had clear sky fill that role.
And yeah midnight and part of moonrise were fine but they rest like dawn? No.
Honestly I like the sun drown place plot ,along with Twigbranch and Violetshine drama. The rest I completely agree with, I wish they would have made Shadowstar’s life more interesting ,she was my favorite cat from dawn of the clans. Overall good video
4:14 I hate how good that fan-art is-
Agree
No hate in the comments please. It's okay if you disagree. I just found these plotlines not enjoyable to read 🫶
Hi! I loved ur part 1 "Sacred eyes"! When are u gonna make pt. 2?
@@Katiee658 I don't know. Considering the first one took me half a year, probably a while
@@fuzeblitz6326half a year! Wow! Welp, I'll be waiting
Ok 👍
@@fuzeblitz6326cool
I hated it when Lionblaze trespassed and allowed Ratscar to beat him up(The Last Hope) only because he wanted to show Cinderheart that he can be beaten. Lionblaze almost started a war because the relationship between Thunderclan and Shadowclan was already bad due to Flametail's death. Besides, the Dark Forest was already planning to attack sooner or later(and Lionblaze knew that) and all the Clans had to unite instead of fighting each other.
P. S. Would you like to make a Top-10 your favourite names or Top-10 most underused characters?
I agree on all of these, although I don't think they were boring, just pointless. Great video as always, keep up the great work!
I didnt like DoveTiger up until I read Tigerhearts shadow. I loved their dynamic and how he would admit he was wrong and apologize.
1:25 I find Sols plotline and whole eclipse thing kinda interesting
Omigosh sun-drowned place and the whole Feather/Crow thing was a good idea at first but I just don't like the drama and the fact that the badger told them something completely useless. They could've left the forest without Midnight telling them to do so! I agree with all of these!!!( I just subscribed!!)
Okay so I love your videos a lot but what could be useful is an explanation of each either in the video or description, keep up the great work!
Thistleclaw go away
Rizz up kids another day
Bluestar says it’s not OK
Thistleclaw go away 💀 💀
Und dann ich, die in "Schicksal des WolkenClans" einfach die Geschichte rund um Stock spannender fand, als den Rest des Buches (habe das halbe Buch einfach vergessen, weil ich es so uninteressant fand) 🙃
I respect yours and others' opinions and I really enjoyed this video, so I'm going to be respectful about this.
I think these plots were really cool! At least most of the them. The only two I agree with that were kinda boring is the drama and the cats' theory of Jayfeather killing Flametail. I mean, come on, Firestar. You really thought your good medicine cat would kill another good medicine cat?
And Bumblestripe and Dovewing. PICK ONE CAT OR THE OTHER.
Just to add on and share this for no reason, but I thought the solar eclipse was a great idea and FREAKING EPIC!!
Wasted opportunity to put "The Lazy Song" ´cause that how we kinda felt reading these parts-
My number 1: Just about anything to do with the Tribe of Rushing Water.
No hate at all, but i don't understand why people hate the New Prophecies so much. It introduced minor characters such as Crowpaw, Tawnypaw, and Featherpaw and Stormpaw as actual important cats and not just background cats that only existed to butter up Firestar. It also made for a lot of cute moments such as when Squirrelpaw was stuck in the fence and while the toms were arguing, Tawnypelt and Feathertail were actually helping. I also did not like Stick's character at all. The hate he showed toward Harley and the unnecessary need to kill enemies was not okay, and he was so blind to that that he killed his own daughter on *accident*. He also made Leafstar question Sharpclaw's loyalty. (I also do not like Sharpclaw becuz he could have chosen whether to like the daylight warriors or not and whether to tell Leafstar about the night training and after all of that he was forgiven?!)
No joke i completely skipped dawn because of how boring it was. Midnight was boring too but i did manage to finish the book, i absolutely loved moonrise, but i couldn't stand dawn. After shadowclan got evacuated i was just done and quit reading it.
I really like the storys especially the sun drown place one i found it exciting and interesting i really don't find it boring nor the others 🤷 but i respect your opinion.
None of them I found really boring but the cinder and lion drama was stupid lion said multiple times that he loved cinder but then she said "no I'm distracting you"
Love this u never disipoint us ❤
Haven't even watched the video but
1: *the entire New Prophecy*
The entirety of Riverstars home lol!
I haven't read it due to that reason 😂
WOW this video is so good 😊
I'm subscribed
😮
The journey to sun drown place wasn’t boring
To me it was. But I respect everyone's opinions ❤💞
The whole video: 15 reasons why i hate warriors(this is a joke, please dont take it too far.)