Fundamentally this guy needs to fundamentally stop using the word fundamentally at an almost fundamentally constant rate. Fundamentally speaking of course
Well, the Russians are currently gaining Ukrainian territory, there is no doubt about that, but how much have they actually gained in just over a year? In 2023/24, the front has shifted an average of just 10 km to the west. As a result, 500 to 1,300 Russian soldiers die every day and thousands of tanks, armored personnel carriers, trucks and artillery pieces have been sacrificed. These losses cannot be sustained forever, especially since Russia is very large in terms of area and also wants to be ready to defend the rest of the country. Putin apparently thinks that Russia is still as strong as the former Soviet Union. No, the former Soviet Union had almost 300 million inhabitants, while Russia only has 142 million people. In this respect, the potential for recruitable soldiers and also the industrial capacity have halved since 1990.
The analyst says Russia has "hundreds" of the S-400 systems. These seems like a gross exaggeration. I don't find a single source that suggests that Russia has more than 100.
Are you kidding? Russia has supplied multiple s400 to india, iran and so many African countries recently. You should come out from your bubble time to time.
Probably means launchers . A full system has multiple launchers and includes a command post , radar etc . Most of the time it is launchers whum are destroyed , these are more easy to replace and russia probably has a lot .
Actually Ukraine is losing ground everyday the media just doesn't talk about it. They are busy with Israel and the American election. Let's hope they start focusing on the war again so people will know what is going on 🇺🇦
This expert recently usually replies “ well f16/ strikes into Russia “ don’t make a difference … can u pls make it verbal that Ukraine simply needs more weapons ? Thanks 🙏🏻
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦💪🇺🇲 @user-vp6vf8wm2s, Comrade Putin bot, the cost of aiding Ukraine is infinitesimal compared to the cost of not supporting them. Ukraine fights not only for themselves but for the freedom and stability of the larger free world. Stopping Putin's aggression is vital to all who understands the serious threat that despotism imposes, both near and far. But you already know that comrade.
@@PavlovsDog-yf1wuThis is complete nonsense. Ukraine is fighting for the interests of global corporations. The globalists bought the Ukrainian elite and now Ukrainians are paying with their lives for the interests of the globalists and for the comfortable life of their comprador government.
Right, why even try to fight Russia? Nothing will work, F16s are just toys for Zelensky to show off...because using Russian fighter jets was a much better strategy...it's not the weapons but the soldiers that operate them "Frank the Military Analyst" that makes a difference, Saudi Arabia has some of the best American made weapons and it would be crushed in a hot war.
It's a bit worrying that the West with all it's economic power can't enable Ukraine to defeat Russia. What happens when the Kremlin decides its our turn?
@@peabase They are if they use patriot systems and any other system like storm shadow which Ukrainian can't operate which includes surveillance and their satellite. So stop telling yourself these lies.
"fundamentally" russo resources aren't infinite. It's impossible to build more tanks, ships, airplanes, air defense systems than Ukraine destroys. Before 2022, russia has less than 100 s-400 systems to cover the biggest border in the world. Not "hundreds"
Even Western resources are not infinite, as the shortage of artillery shells shows. And many in the West are getting tired of paying for them. Because it is the taxpayer who pays with his hard-earned taxes. Finally a question based on History. What should the West do if Russia, running out of conventional resources and suffering too many losses, decided to switch to nuclear ones in order not to lose the war against Ukraine? I remind you that in 1946 after years of war with Japan the USA managed to conquer, at the cost of huge losses of marines, only small islands like Iwo Jima and Okinawa, but not even a square mile of the main territory of Japan. What did Truman do then to quickly end the war? And, correct me if I'm wrong, it does not seem to me that God has granted only the USA the right to use nuclear weapons.
Russia has many other means of air defences... on many days occasions last month UFA surrendered whole units, even to drones. Reports of 2000 UFA casualties a day during last 2 weeks of july. If Russia's resources aren't infinite, they're surely sufficient for another 5 years of total war on Ukraine. Time, money, materials, casualties don't matter for Russia. They will never accept defeat. For them it's about NATO. It's about making a statement to the world. US will not threaten Russia 500 km from Moscow.
Zelensky was thinking that these games would be over soon after counterattack in 2023. Little did he know nor has learned anything from the past from countries that went to war against Russian.
@@piratesofthebarentsseaVladimir Zelensky had multiple offers to leave the country. But didn’t tuck his tell and runway. This is the character of a war leader. Stop criticizing a great leader.
What gains? Some wheat fields here and there,and some random abandoned small villages? Is that really gains,or are they insignificant, very costly in russian lives,and relatively unimportant...I vote for the latter...
more than 50 square kilometers, that's a very vast swathe of land. They're also encroaching dangerously close to a logistics hub for Ukraine. So please, don't dismiss these gains as insignificant
I completely disagree. The land chews up enormous resources for unimportant changes in land controlled by a country that is the biggest in the world. What matters is logistics and economics. At this time, Ukraine can't destroy Russian logistics because of limited supply of missiles and restrictions on being able to use them. For economics, Ukraine is making some progress by attacking oil depots, but has apparently stopped attacking major oil refineries. That might be because Russia has diverted air defense assets to them, or is complying with Biden administrations desire to not disrupt the oil market. I would assume that at some point, Ukraine starts making marine drone attacks on Russian shipping. By getting rid of submarines, Ukraine has more flexibility in deploying these drones.
Rostov-on-don is the same submarine they damaged in a missile strike last year. And now they claimed that they sank it. So basically, they only taken out 1 damaged sub, the is if their claim is true.
The russian goals here are not some wheatfields and some small villages..its key cities,like Kharkiv, Odessa, Kiev,and so far they have failed,miserably...they have sacrificed immense amount of soldiers, and spent insane amounts of money and resorsources on this war,and they have very little to show far it..thats not sustainable for forever...not even in a dictatureship regime like russia..
What about Ukraine? Zelensky has siphoned hundreds of billions of dollars from US and EU taxpayers and what has he got to show for it? How much territory has he taken back from Russia, if any? Moreover, Zelensky's term has already expired. He has no more legal mandate to govern. He has cancelled elections for the presidency and stays in office and wields the power to send Ukrainian men to their deaths fighting the Russians. So which regime is a dictatorship here?
@@prestigehunter9729 telling some ignorant commenter what the objectives of the SMO are...which any one can find online in about 10 seconds makes me a bot..? ffs grow up
I don't know but it seems like rather a lazy attitude to say "they'll just deploy another". The Ukranians have been forcing Russia to move systems from all over the place and that when they "deploy another" it means leaving a hole somewhere else for drones to reach refineries or airfields.
@@timmurphy5541 and again i havn't looked at it since the beginning of the war, but back then they were VERY expensive to produce. i know it's a bit different now that they are in a war economy
Russia also has no missiles form 2022 according to western and Ukranian media. Production does not stand still and Russia is known for outproducing anything enemy throws at it.
Talking as if Ukraine is able to do that by its own. This war is between the western 'free world' and Russia. Ukraine is just the executor while all western countries provide the intel, weapons and military personnel. Your ignorance is baffling.
Atleast in your simple understanding you should be able to know that it's Russia against USA led Nato. Ukraine has no power or whatsoever to fight Russia
Russia has decided to expand. It doesn't matter what we do, Russia will keep trying in Ukraine or elsewhere otherwise their political regime will fall.
@@DanielNistreannonsense, Russia is the first that agreed for peace. Minsk 1 and I3, the Istanbul negotiations, ect. All sabotaged by the warmongering US led west.
Ukraine has asked permission to fight in the offense against Russia. Pres Zelensky have refused the peace terms offered by Putin which includes the surrender of occupied areas & have forwarded his own peace terms that those attacks on military targets inside Russia would cease the time Russian troops leave Ukraine.
But every little bit adds up over time. Without any help, Ukraine probably would have lost 40%-60% of their land, but if they got more aid, they could have held more territory or gone on the offensive. At least the fear and threats from russia continue to be diminished among Western nations/allies.
It is a major effect for RUSSIA! Not a positive one though. Besides the fact that there are alway a lot of soldiers on boats, and submarines and ammunition. All of which cost a LOT of money - which is gone now.
Some expert. No effect on the war? They just launch cruise missiles, said it himself. Those missiles attack civilian targets around Ukrainian cities, maybe fewer missiles will be launched next time. How's that for an effect on the war?
"Everyone think [sic] Ukraine is losing"? Whatever gave you that idea? Russia making marginal gains at immense cost in lives and materiel, that's what we're thinking.
To treat this like it is a serious question: Ukraine is doing well against a larger opponent, given the arms it has been supplied, combined with restrictions on using them in an effective manner. Ukraine is gradually losing ground and taking a heavy beating to its power infrastructure. But, just like Germany and Japan and Vietnam, it is rare that a country collapses in a war just because it is taking heavy losses, at least in the WW2 sense. Instead, this is more like WW1, where at some point one side will decide that the loses are just too great. Right now, Ukraine could keep fighting like this for a decade if the West continues to support it. So really it is a question of who gives in first, the Western public or the Russia public. The Western public is fickle, but far richer than the Russian public. So it really is not clear who will win. I mean, Americans just stuck with Afghanistan for 20 years before giving up.
Frank's analysis seems bs, he said hundreds S-400 systems which could imply 200-300 or could be 600....if you google it, it states 56 so who is Frank's source? Shoygu
so you really think Russians have less than 100 of those systems??? you really must be deluded. the 56(which was of 2022) is just for public domain, no super power country will ever reveal their true number of their arsenal, but smart countries like the US, UK, China and India always uses the thumb rule, they multiply that public domain number by 2.
Military numbers are always a bit dodgy, especially when affected in a fog of war. Given the Russian S-400 is in some ways just a modernised and upgraded S-300 it probably is correct here.
@@josephhall1049 Well I didn't know you know him personally and he shared his sources with you, in this case he was talking about launchers and not the command center of, so perhaps he should make a distinction between how many launchers and how many command centers for these launchers Russia has....saying Russia has hundreds off these is vague and misleading, I am not a journalist but a real "military analyst" would probably make that distinction, right buddy?
Where did they get this expert? The application of IHL is nonreciprocal. The fact that Russia is violating IHL does not give Ukraine the right to do so.
They have hundreds of launchers... but for the longest border in the world. They can't rebuild the launchers (or other components) all that quickly. This means air defenses are weakening across the board. The F-16 with the HARMs will mean even more trouble.
HIMARS became irrelevant. As for F-16, it's a speculation and another "gamechanger". Russia always been know to outproduce their enemy in whatever it needs. Remember "Russia out of missiles" in 2022? This is just the same "out of defence system" today.
@@sleepyjoe7843 oh, the F-16 will definitely change the game. The Ukrainians have been trained and instructed by multiple airforces that have used them for half a century. This aircraft can use HARMs in all modes, which means Russia can kiss their air defense radars and GPS jammers goodbye. Which means that their own aircraft have to hang back more, and Ukrainian artillery including HIMARS and ATACMS will gain efficiency again.
@@icu17siberia Military uses RISK CPU's, which are around 45 nm, not CISC (3nm). RISK can be made by Russia and even CISC but it's useless for consumers. For consumer based products only one company is able to produce/allow other to produce chips with lowest NM to date. That's a Dutch company ASML. Yes even USA can't produce these chips on it's own.
Ситуация следующая, российско-украинская война, число погибших на стороне РФ, за один год составляет 300 000 погибших. Однако в американо-афганской войне число погибших с американской стороны составило 120 солдат за один год. Это напоминает мне времена Иосифа Сталина, дело не в человеке. Сейчас у нас есть нечто подобное. «Мария Фатимская сказала: «Если Россия не обратится, она распространит свои ошибки». К сожалению, ошибки все еще существуют. Этой войны вообще не должно быть! B069
Another sub bites the dust Another sub bites the dust And another one gone, and another one gone Another sub bites the dust (yeah) Hey, I'm gonna get you too Another sub bites the dust
y'all think your reporters could pose some talking points that aren't pro-russian? every reporter question is like "looks like ukraine is losing. what next?"
Another sub bites the dust Another sub bites the dust And another one gone, and another one gone Another one bites the dust (yeah) Hey, I'm gonna get you too Another sub bites the dust
have you seen how much territory they've been able to take and how many soldiers/equipment they've lost? would not really be proud of that.. and this sub was made in 2014 and cost 300M USD, if it's already rusty and outdated then russia is really wasting their money on bad equipment
Everyone I am a Bangladeshi student. There are Many things happening in Bangladesh. The Bangladeshi government khilled student hugely. They also stopped the mobile data and also stopped Facebook including many other social media platform. We are in a great problem and they killed students unnecessarily. If the government stop internet we cannot connect with each other. The whole country will filled with blood. Please help Bangladeshi student please help us in this protest . Please help our country please help us. we are not criminal please check our background if government is are right why they are stop
@@caboosej8749 I think you are confusing Kindness with Weakness 🙄 ....Have you noticed that Kiev Lvov and Odessa are still standing 😉. Doesn't take much to change that .
@@Random_Dude42Because there was a coup d'etat in Ukraine or (as Ukrainians say) a revolution. It always happens that way. So as a result of a revolution, the Russian Empire ceased to exist, then the Soviet Union, and now Ukraine. Also, a revolution is almost always accompanied by a civil war, which is what happened in Ukraine in 2014.
@@piratesofthebarentssea You're on to something, but it's not Ukraine's turn to cease to exists. It's the Russian Federation that's living on borrowed time. It's not a question of if it will fall apart, but in how many parts.
@@peabaseYou can repeat the word honey as much as you like, but it won't make your mouth any sweeter. Ukraine has already lost Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk regions. And is currently losing Zaporizhzhya and Kherson regions.
NATO is losing? The NATO states, as well as other states, are only supporting Ukraine against an aggressor who is violating the international law of a European neighboring country. If NATO soldiers were actually involved, Russia would no longer exist.
We Bangladeshis are becoming very helpless. Does the United Nations not see this? Bangladesh government is committing genocide in our country save us🇧🇩
U are fighting your gov but its far from a genocide, I hope things will go the peoples way and you can get rid of your pretend democratic leader. I hope u remove the power from the elite that have ruled your country for way too long.
They should rename that submarine from "Rostov-on-Don" to "Rostov-on-the-bottom"...
More like sinking imaginary submarine for the social media copium victory
@@meteorknight999 yes everything is a conspiracy and russia never loses anything lol
@@meteorknight999 Yeah? If Russia went home than social media could embrace the dunces. How about that??
Stop playing war games on internet.
@@meteorknight999 you"re probably referring to 54 Himars and 28 F-16 that Russia already destroyed in ukraine?!?
From flying shovels to flying submarines 😂😂😂
😂😂😂
You forgot flying turrets! 🤣
@@Christophe_derBerge-op9zh Crimea by 2022
Fundamentally this guy needs to fundamentally stop using the word fundamentally at an almost fundamentally constant rate. Fundamentally speaking of course
You're basically ... and fundamentally ... correct.
Listening to DW gives you the impressions that Russians are losing very bad at the battle fronts.
well the Russians seem to have the only navy in the world that is getting smaller. maybe the NK guy can lend his buddy Putin some.
Well, the Russians are currently gaining Ukrainian territory, there is no doubt about that, but how much have they actually gained in just over a year? In 2023/24, the front has shifted an average of just 10 km to the west. As a result, 500 to 1,300 Russian soldiers die every day and thousands of tanks, armored personnel carriers, trucks and artillery pieces have been sacrificed. These losses cannot be sustained forever, especially since Russia is very large in terms of area and also wants to be ready to defend the rest of the country. Putin apparently thinks that Russia is still as strong as the former Soviet Union. No, the former Soviet Union had almost 300 million inhabitants, while Russia only has 142 million people. In this respect, the potential for recruitable soldiers and also the industrial capacity have halved since 1990.
😂😂😂
The analyst says Russia has "hundreds" of the S-400 systems. These seems like a gross exaggeration. I don't find a single source that suggests that Russia has more than 100.
Are you kidding? Russia has supplied multiple s400 to india, iran and so many African countries recently. You should come out from your bubble time to time.
He has his sources as a journalist, you didn’t have any credible source.
So I like to use the general rule of thumb: if you can Google a number for a national resource, the actual inventory is x2.
@@cks7709 And now, nobody wants Russian military equipment. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
Probably means launchers .
A full system has multiple launchers and includes a command post , radar etc .
Most of the time it is launchers whum are destroyed , these are more easy to replace and russia probably has a lot .
It is VERY heartwarming to see Ukraine turning the tide. The only thing holding it back is the lack of support from the West!
Turning what tide?
What you fail to say is that this has not stopped innocent people from both sides from dying needless. They should both stop this useless war.
@@deedat81 The tide of being forgotten by Western media.
What is this extreme copium over imaginary strikes that are lied by ukrn
Actually Ukraine is losing ground everyday the media just doesn't talk about it. They are busy with Israel and the American election. Let's hope they start focusing on the war again so people will know what is going on 🇺🇦
This expert recently usually replies “ well f16/ strikes into Russia “ don’t make a difference … can u pls make it verbal that Ukraine simply needs more weapons ? Thanks 🙏🏻
Do you have money? In US dollars
More weapons, or more men?
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦💪🇺🇲
@user-vp6vf8wm2s,
Comrade Putin bot, the cost of aiding Ukraine is infinitesimal compared to the cost of not supporting them. Ukraine fights not only for themselves but for the freedom and stability of the larger free world. Stopping Putin's aggression is vital to all who understands the serious threat that despotism imposes, both near and far. But you already know that comrade.
@@PavlovsDog-yf1wuThis is complete nonsense. Ukraine is fighting for the interests of global corporations. The globalists bought the Ukrainian elite and now Ukrainians are paying with their lives for the interests of the globalists and for the comfortable life of their comprador government.
Right, why even try to fight Russia? Nothing will work, F16s are just toys for Zelensky to show off...because using Russian fighter jets was a much better strategy...it's not the weapons but the soldiers that operate them "Frank the Military Analyst" that makes a difference, Saudi Arabia has some of the best American made weapons and it would be crushed in a hot war.
Never heard of Submarine air Base, must be flying submarines
Sevastapol isn't Russian territory any more. What was the Rostov-on-Don *thinking*?
Embarrassing yourself again. Do they not teach punctuation marks at the Glavset/Olgino troll school? And like by all your 'subscribers'?? Tut Tut 🤣🤣🤣
@@pensacola2015Eat your food stamps
@@zoom777 Weak.😂 Aren't you still feeding on leather boots from the bodies of dead orcs, or have you moved on to something even more soulless?
@@pensacola2015I am not Russian, don't know what stuff you are on, must be same as Elanesky
Giving Ukraine everything it needs to win this war and Ukrainian integration into the EU and NATO is the west’s best self defense.
Now I believe NATO won't defeat Russia.....
@@AliKondo-gb8ix NATO is not actively taking part in this fight, Skippy.
@@AliKondo-gb8ixRussia will defeat itself
It's a bit worrying that the West with all it's economic power can't enable Ukraine to defeat Russia. What happens when the Kremlin decides its our turn?
@@peabase They are if they use patriot systems and any other system like storm shadow which Ukrainian can't operate which includes surveillance and their satellite. So stop telling yourself these lies.
No, the S-400 is nothing like Patriot, lol.
لك الحق في الدفاع عن ارضك ،احسنت اوكرانيا 🇺🇦 *الله*و رسوله معكم اوكرانيا 🇺🇦
11 month old bot account 🤢
"fundamentally" russo resources aren't infinite. It's impossible to build more tanks, ships, airplanes, air defense systems than Ukraine destroys. Before 2022, russia has less than 100 s-400 systems to cover the biggest border in the world. Not "hundreds"
As long as most of their factories are intact they can sustain the loses and still build hundreds more armaments every month
Even Western resources are not infinite, as the shortage of artillery shells shows. And many in the West are getting tired of paying for them. Because it is the taxpayer who pays with his hard-earned taxes.
Finally a question based on History. What should the West do if Russia, running out of conventional resources and suffering too many losses, decided to switch to nuclear ones in order not to lose the war against Ukraine? I remind you that in 1946 after years of war with Japan the USA managed to conquer, at the cost of huge losses of marines, only small islands like Iwo Jima and Okinawa, but not even a square mile of the main territory of Japan. What did Truman do then to quickly end the war? And, correct me if I'm wrong, it does not seem to me that God has granted only the USA the right to use nuclear weapons.
Russia has many other means of air defences... on many days occasions last month UFA surrendered whole units, even to drones. Reports of 2000 UFA casualties a day during last 2 weeks of july. If Russia's resources aren't infinite, they're surely sufficient for another 5 years of total war on Ukraine. Time, money, materials, casualties don't matter for Russia. They will never accept defeat. For them it's about NATO. It's about making a statement to the world. US will not threaten Russia 500 km from Moscow.
@@trustandbelieve9173It don’t take a month to build that lmfao
America will be making more shells then russia by next year .@trumpforever6706
Zelensky has aged 10 yrs since 2022.Damn! war is pure misery.
But Zelensky became hundreds of times richer.
Can't look good and beg at the same time
Zelensky was thinking that these games would be over soon after counterattack in 2023. Little did he know nor has learned anything from the past from countries that went to war against Russian.
@@piratesofthebarentsseaVladimir Zelensky had multiple offers to leave the country. But didn’t tuck his tell and runway. This is the character of a war leader. Stop criticizing a great leader.
@@sleepyjoe7843 Zelensky and the west believed their own propoganda..but propoganda doesn't win wars
Freedom is not free, it will not come without a price.
It costs $1.05
yes cost to pay by Ukraine is 12 trillion
Take a shot every-time this analysts says “fundamentally”.
I'd be passed out drunk.
Praying for Ukraine, and for US leaders to maintain their resolve to supply and support Ukraine
😂
What gains? Some wheat fields here and there,and some random abandoned small villages? Is that really gains,or are they insignificant, very costly in russian lives,and relatively unimportant...I vote for the latter...
Avdiivka and all cities 25km further are just some wheat fields? Sure keel lying to yourself.
Get out of your bubble of ignorance: YOU DON'T GAIN VILLAGES OR TOWN, YOU GAIN LAND! Villages, towns, cities can be built out of conquered land. Geezz
So then why ukraine care about fighting..if they don't value this land
more than 50 square kilometers, that's a very vast swathe of land. They're also encroaching dangerously close to a logistics hub for Ukraine. So please, don't dismiss these gains as insignificant
@@esQmoThey take 1000 casualties a day just to capture small fields, that’s crazy!
So?. Submarines don’t matter in this war. Who controls the land matters.
was it even worth repairing?
@@icu17siberia well the Russian navy thought so. and Ukraine just waited until they had plugged the hole from the last hit. LOL
I completely disagree. The land chews up enormous resources for unimportant changes in land controlled by a country that is the biggest in the world. What matters is logistics and economics. At this time, Ukraine can't destroy Russian logistics because of limited supply of missiles and restrictions on being able to use them. For economics, Ukraine is making some progress by attacking oil depots, but has apparently stopped attacking major oil refineries. That might be because Russia has diverted air defense assets to them, or is complying with Biden administrations desire to not disrupt the oil market. I would assume that at some point, Ukraine starts making marine drone attacks on Russian shipping. By getting rid of submarines, Ukraine has more flexibility in deploying these drones.
Just random kid typing random stuff, you know nothing about how this real world works.
Russia is still trying? It's just embarrassing from the start and now it's just pathetic.
Russia holds 20% of Ukraine 😂😂
I think it's NATO alliance who is humiliated here by fighting one Russia but not get closer to win .
You mean russia still hasn't occupied all of ukraine how embarrassing and they think they can handle a military like the united states haha
Ukraine is also still trying.. They will never get their territories back... So, what exactly should y o u be about??
@@garyoak2974 compare the budged for defense of Russia and the US and you might understand something..
This the turnaround point
that DW talks about since 2023 ?
is this a clever comment?
for the submarine? Yes it is.
@@vivavideo-videofilmer nope 😂
Rostov-on-don is the same submarine they damaged in a missile strike last year.
And now they claimed that they sank it. So basically, they only taken out 1 damaged sub,
the is if their claim is true.
wait until sub has $300m in repairs, before sinking again.
The russian goals here are not some wheatfields and some small villages..its key cities,like Kharkiv, Odessa, Kiev,and so far they have failed,miserably...they have sacrificed immense amount of soldiers, and spent insane amounts of money and resorsources on this war,and they have very little to show far it..thats not sustainable for forever...not even in a dictatureship regime like russia..
What happened to Zelensky who said they will be in Crimea by now in 2023? That's what I call failed miserably.
the Russian goal is de miltarising and de nazifying UKraine...you never bothered to read the objectives of the SMO did you..?
What about Ukraine? Zelensky has siphoned hundreds of billions of dollars from US and EU taxpayers and what has he got to show for it? How much territory has he taken back from Russia, if any? Moreover, Zelensky's term has already expired. He has no more legal mandate to govern. He has cancelled elections for the presidency and stays in office and wields the power to send Ukrainian men to their deaths fighting the Russians. So which regime is a dictatorship here?
@@briancarno8837Found the Russian bot.
@@prestigehunter9729 telling some ignorant commenter what the objectives of the SMO are...which any one can find online in about 10 seconds makes me a bot..? ffs grow up
Can you fundamentally rephrase this explanation of said fundaments to describe logistical funds…
Mantap Ukraina maju terus
Lol)))
... It's been a while since I have looked into it but he said that Russia has hundreds of s400... Is that true or is he thinking of the s300?
I don't know but it seems like rather a lazy attitude to say "they'll just deploy another". The Ukranians have been forcing Russia to move systems from all over the place and that when they "deploy another" it means leaving a hole somewhere else for drones to reach refineries or airfields.
@@timmurphy5541 and again i havn't looked at it since the beginning of the war, but back then they were VERY expensive to produce. i know it's a bit different now that they are in a war economy
Its prob the 300s, dont think theres that many s400
Russia also has no missiles form 2022 according to western and Ukranian media. Production does not stand still and Russia is known for outproducing anything enemy throws at it.
@@sleepyjoe7843 everything has limits, including Russian production.
let me get this straight, ukraine has 'sunk' the same sub that it said it sunk previously, which is in dry dock? 😂😅
Fundamentally 😂 at least this word he knows
Making Russia look like the incompetent goofs they are! 😂😂🤣🤣
Why incompetent?
Having casualties is incompetence ?
Talking as if Ukraine is able to do that by its own. This war is between the western 'free world' and Russia. Ukraine is just the executor while all western countries provide the intel, weapons and military personnel. Your ignorance is baffling.
Atleast in your simple understanding you should be able to know that it's Russia against USA led Nato. Ukraine has no power or whatsoever to fight Russia
Ukraine attacking weak Naval but not attacking elite Russian Units
Total bollocks
Anyone get the vibe Frank is promoting a "Ukraine is destined to lose" narrative?
Yes. Baffling isn't it?
Russia has decided to expand. It doesn't matter what we do, Russia will keep trying in Ukraine or elsewhere otherwise their political regime will fall.
So we should let them win or else they will lose?
@@isaacingleby8771 If they win they will go for a riskier target.
@@DanielNistreannonsense, Russia is the first that agreed for peace. Minsk 1 and I3, the Istanbul negotiations, ect. All sabotaged by the warmongering US led west.
@@DanielNistrean so what point are you trying to make here, do nothing or do something?
@@isaacingleby8771 The point is: Escalate now, do not wait. Prepare to fight a war. Either yourself or increase aid to Ukraine.
Ukraine has asked permission to fight in the offense against Russia. Pres Zelensky have refused the peace terms offered by Putin which includes the surrender of occupied areas & have forwarded his own peace terms that those attacks on military targets inside Russia would cease the time Russian troops leave Ukraine.
Time to bust out the thesaurus and check options for fundamentally
more symbolic than major effect for ukraine
You must be an expert
A sub is not a symbolic thing...
But every little bit adds up over time. Without any help, Ukraine probably would have lost 40%-60% of their land, but if they got more aid, they could have held more territory or gone on the offensive. At least the fear and threats from russia continue to be diminished among Western nations/allies.
It is a major effect for RUSSIA!
Not a positive one though.
Besides the fact that there are alway a lot of soldiers on boats, and submarines and ammunition. All of which cost a LOT of money - which is gone now.
@@alexanderrobins7497 Russia produced more ships in 2 years than it lost. How does it "adds up over time"...
SLAVA UKRAINI
🐑
Some expert. No effect on the war? They just launch cruise missiles, said it himself. Those missiles attack civilian targets around Ukrainian cities, maybe fewer missiles will be launched next time. How's that for an effect on the war?
the war is one of conquest, that's why
No significant effect. It is an attritional war on a massively long front.
It will have no affect on the conflict.
Why do you say "civilian targets"?
@@esQmo because a school and hospital is a civilian target you smashed clam
To lose a submarine is a major blow.
You believe clownlenzy
Ukraine keep telling everyone it's winning. So why does everyone think Ukraine is losing and losing badly?
Russia has won the war in three days, correct?
"Everyone think [sic] Ukraine is losing"? Whatever gave you that idea? Russia making marginal gains at immense cost in lives and materiel, that's what we're thinking.
To treat this like it is a serious question: Ukraine is doing well against a larger opponent, given the arms it has been supplied, combined with restrictions on using them in an effective manner. Ukraine is gradually losing ground and taking a heavy beating to its power infrastructure. But, just like Germany and Japan and Vietnam, it is rare that a country collapses in a war just because it is taking heavy losses, at least in the WW2 sense. Instead, this is more like WW1, where at some point one side will decide that the loses are just too great. Right now, Ukraine could keep fighting like this for a decade if the West continues to support it. So really it is a question of who gives in first, the Western public or the Russia public. The Western public is fickle, but far richer than the Russian public. So it really is not clear who will win. I mean, Americans just stuck with Afghanistan for 20 years before giving up.
Frank's analysis seems bs, he said hundreds S-400 systems which could imply 200-300 or could be 600....if you google it, it states 56 so who is Frank's source? Shoygu
so you really think Russians have less than 100 of those systems??? you really must be deluded. the 56(which was of 2022) is just for public domain, no super power country will ever reveal their true number of their arsenal, but smart countries like the US, UK, China and India always uses the thumb rule, they multiply that public domain number by 2.
Military numbers are always a bit dodgy, especially when affected in a fog of war. Given the Russian S-400 is in some ways just a modernised and upgraded S-300 it probably is correct here.
your source is google while Frank is a seasoned journalist with presumably credible sources...
@@josephhall1049 Well I didn't know you know him personally and he shared his sources with you, in this case he was talking about launchers and not the command center of, so perhaps he should make a distinction between how many launchers and how many command centers for these launchers Russia has....saying Russia has hundreds off these is vague and misleading, I am not a journalist but a real "military analyst" would probably make that distinction, right buddy?
@@josephhall1049 You don't look things up on google? Mr Researcher?
Браво Украина❤
Your comment won't save any Ukrainian..
@@oliveryt7168 Yeah sound more like German fanatic shout from 1940s.
Random keyboard warrior /bot
Is that Dave Chappelle in white face?
Germany give Ukraine 10 times more aid then what you already given.
Taurus Taurus Taurus
How much are this "experts" payed for bullshido😂
Ukraine is winning everywhere but Russia is advancing, how can it be…ohhhh it be !
Well now I see Russias problem, they’re wasting money on submarine airbases
Ukrainian claims? CLAIMS?
How about showing hard evidences?
The noun 'evidence' is uncountable, which means its plural form is also 'evidence'. Don't you wish the British Council still operated in your country.
@@peabase Irrelevant bla bla bla...
Focus on the facts.
@@fingerprint8479 Try to improve your delivery. It's painful to watch.
Finally military analysis that sees the reality of the situation in this conflict.
Frank needed some rubles in his bank account
Nevertheless, nothing will deter Russia from completing its objectives in Ukraine. Nothing...
The "Le May doctrine" by drone....hilarious
Where did they get this expert? The application of IHL is nonreciprocal. The fact that Russia is violating IHL does not give Ukraine the right to do so.
Russia is a joke big joke
Russia is a big joke and nato the whole circus, they have a comédian as puppet of americans
Ukraine and NATO are the mother of all jokes.
Resinking of Russian sub - clever.
What kind of "Buk" SAM was that in the clip?
A very strange looking missile though...
They have hundreds of launchers... but for the longest border in the world. They can't rebuild the launchers (or other components) all that quickly. This means air defenses are weakening across the board. The F-16 with the HARMs will mean even more trouble.
HIMARS became irrelevant. As for F-16, it's a speculation and another "gamechanger". Russia always been know to outproduce their enemy in whatever it needs. Remember "Russia out of missiles" in 2022? This is just the same "out of defence system" today.
@@sleepyjoe7843 oh, the F-16 will definitely change the game. The Ukrainians have been trained and instructed by multiple airforces that have used them for half a century. This aircraft can use HARMs in all modes, which means Russia can kiss their air defense radars and GPS jammers goodbye. Which means that their own aircraft have to hang back more, and Ukrainian artillery including HIMARS and ATACMS will gain efficiency again.
@@Andreas-gh6is Right, another gamechanger advertisement. What you gonna do after this one fails? Asking for nukes?
@@sleepyjoe7843 what do you personally own that has a Russian made chip in it? Or will they produce weapons with vacuum tubes?
@@icu17siberia Military uses RISK CPU's, which are around 45 nm, not CISC (3nm). RISK can be made by Russia and even CISC but it's useless for consumers. For consumer based products only one company is able to produce/allow other to produce chips with lowest NM to date. That's a Dutch company ASML. Yes even USA can't produce these chips on it's own.
Good work! Slava Ukraini!
Ситуация следующая, российско-украинская война, число погибших на стороне РФ, за один год составляет 300 000 погибших. Однако в американо-афганской войне число погибших с американской стороны составило 120 солдат за один год. Это напоминает мне времена Иосифа Сталина, дело не в человеке. Сейчас у нас есть нечто подобное. «Мария Фатимская сказала: «Если Россия не обратится, она распространит свои ошибки». К сожалению, ошибки все еще существуют. Этой войны вообще не должно быть! B069
copium is real
Another sub bites the dust
Another sub bites the dust
And another one gone, and another one gone
Another sub bites the dust (yeah)
Hey, I'm gonna get you too
Another sub bites the dust
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
Russia has to preserve its high value assets because it can't gets chips from prior suppliers and won't use its own domestically produced chips
You almost had it. It is Seva-STO-pol, NOT Se-VA-stopol.
Next, you're going to moan that anglophones don't pronounce "Paris" like the French do, right?
@@peabase There is no reason to stress the wrong syllable. The original pronunciation sounds fine in English.
@@ericwood3709 Parish. Pareeeeeh!
y'all think your reporters could pose some talking points that aren't pro-russian? every reporter question is like "looks like ukraine is losing. what next?"
But they are. Just look at the geo located maps
Have you tried key American news channels? They’ll spew the bs you want to hear
Ukraine is losing ground in Donetsk oblast. Nothing significant but some fields and villages and rubble.
@@DaniRaj666Ukraine consists of fields, villages and rubble.
@@piratesofthebarentssea No that is more like Russia. Mordor fascists, nothing else.
Is it called 'temporary' or 'permanent' occupied scrubmarine?🤔
This must be the slowest news on the internet ...
He sure says ‘again’ a lot
Modern Russian submarines are designed to stay submerged indefinitely..
Even in Germany there are trolls, social manure
but not in the GREEN:LEFTIST spectre
Clownsky's fans are very active..
Chingon, Gringo.
In germany there are extremly many trolls. No wonder, half of the people in the eastern provinces (the old GDR) ist putins fifth colounm
Even you are trolling sometimes.. so, what's your point?
Not a big deal, but reciprocity is pronounced not with hard Cs, but with soft Cs like the letter S. So like recipe, and city.
Without Trump, Putin will come to the negotiating table sooner than later.
Two weeks, huh?
Ukraine War overshadowed by Mideast War.
a submarine airbase- well now
Remember, 1 year ago Ukranians were seizing the russian lines towards aziv sea 🤣
Don't come crying when Russia replies 😮
Why you are crying now😂
Oh no, Russia might invade Ukraine.
Another sub bites the dust
Another sub bites the dust
And another one gone, and another one gone
Another one bites the dust (yeah)
Hey, I'm gonna get you too
Another sub bites the dust
Nato you mean...
Or, they could sit down together and work on peace through dialog. No fun in that though is there🤔🤔🤔
Should I take 1/3 of your property and then ask to negotiate how much I get to keep?
@@maxidaho either that or more innocent people will continue to be killed on both sides. This is not acceptable.
@@maxidaho no war,no killing attitude
@@perryhenrickson7750 there are no innocent Russians in Ukraine.
Most of us here in the US stand with Ukraine.
I don’t know about that. Make sure you are not in a bubble.
If you say so lol
ha ha... check between your ears,
You are not speaking for me bro.
I'm sure most of you don't care about the money being spent in Ukraine, that could actually help building schools or helping sick US citizens.
Vladimir Zelenskyy?????????
Its a Long way to Triponary
They can't update the front changes but can update a single of rusty Submerine 😂😂😂
Hahahahaah Western Media reports the verified news not bla bla bla bro..
😂Where’s the Russian Navy ? 🤡
have you seen how much territory they've been able to take and how many soldiers/equipment they've lost? would not really be proud of that.. and this sub was made in 2014 and cost 300M USD, if it's already rusty and outdated then russia is really wasting their money on bad equipment
@@godfreydavid6847 western media reports verified news, joke of the year!!
Runway in downtown Kiev not out of question, according to some
Can DW stop with the "experts" tag please? 😂😂 not even close to a childish story teller hahaha
You may want to give us a sample of your "superior" expertise.
Zelensky is a comedian 😅😅😅😅😅😅
When Russia responds you cry
looks to me russia is always crying 🤣🤣
Are you insane. Who invaded who? Ukraine is the one responding.
Interesting
🇺🇦💪🇺🇦👍🇺🇦❤🇺🇦
🤡
3:14 "recipricocity"
What are they trying to archive about this??
Everyone I am a Bangladeshi student. There are Many things happening in Bangladesh. The Bangladeshi government khilled student hugely. They also stopped the mobile data and also stopped Facebook including many other social media platform. We are in a great problem and they killed students unnecessarily. If the government stop internet we cannot connect with each other. The whole country will filled with blood. Please help Bangladeshi student please help us in this protest . Please help our country please help us.
we are not criminal please check our background
if government is are right why they are stop
Well. the retaliation will hurt ...
not more then every other day is my geuss, russia just not competent enough to be an actual threat.
@@caboosej8749 I think you are confusing Kindness with Weakness 🙄 ....Have you noticed that Kiev Lvov and Odessa are still standing 😉. Doesn't take much to change that .
@@JohnCSmith-lp1qr same for Moscow ...
@@caboosej8749 Not realistic lol.... but keep up with the Hopeium 😂
@@JohnCSmith-lp1qr no hope here comrade, its the end of the line for russia no matter who wins in Ukraine, might wanna deal with that 😘
*Russia🇷🇺 have border/maritime disputes with Ukraine & Japan.*
make border/maritime agreement & peace!
@@Random_Dude42The Ukraine with which the agreements were concluded ceased to exist in 2014.
@@Random_Dude42Because there was a coup d'etat in Ukraine or (as Ukrainians say) a revolution. It always happens that way. So as a result of a revolution, the Russian Empire ceased to exist, then the Soviet Union, and now Ukraine. Also, a revolution is almost always accompanied by a civil war, which is what happened in Ukraine in 2014.
@@piratesofthebarentssea You're on to something, but it's not Ukraine's turn to cease to exists. It's the Russian Federation that's living on borrowed time. It's not a question of if it will fall apart, but in how many parts.
@@peabaseYou can repeat the word honey as much as you like, but it won't make your mouth any sweeter.
Ukraine has already lost Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk regions.
And is currently losing Zaporizhzhya and Kherson regions.
What about also going after their civilians?
Targeting civilians deliberately is a war crime.
😂😂😂😂😂 it's normal for a comedian to claim things we're used to such nonsense 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Worthless garbage. MSN has been saying this for 3 years now. They dont want to admit NATO is losing 😂
You say NATO is losing yet no NATO countries are being bombed by Russia.
Russia is losing.
NATO is losing? The NATO states, as well as other states, are only supporting Ukraine against an aggressor who is violating the international law of a European neighboring country. If NATO soldiers were actually involved, Russia would no longer exist.
Does anyone actually believe that Ukraine stands a chance vs Russia?
@@pavlinpetkov8984 been standing for almost three years now, how long can you stand?
day 894 of Putin's 3 day SMO
@@Cecil-yc6mc he is leading war of attrition... The west is prolonging the inevitable with the aid. The longer the war the bigger the casualties...
@@Cecil-yc6mcUkrainians not only has not chance against Russia but also your own comment is based on a lie coming from the west and Ukraine.
@@Cecil-yc6mc deleting comments ain't gonna help Ukraine. Putin is leading a war of attrition...
How does attacking a Submarine translate to battle -field gains? Zelensky should just surrender....
❄
Bluff for another billions...Zelensky's claim of destroying Russian assets ,if put together amounts ten thousand trillion USD.
Such uncertain reports from Ukraine never stopped and their land also never stopped losing to Russia.
We Bangladeshis are becoming very helpless. Does the United Nations not see this? Bangladesh government is committing genocide in our country save us🇧🇩
U are fighting your gov but its far from a genocide, I hope things will go the peoples way and you can get rid of your pretend democratic leader.
I hope u remove the power from the elite that have ruled your country for way too long.