Swimming In Syrup Is As Easy As Swimming In Water

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 31 май 2024
  • In this video I test out the proposition that swimming in syrup is as easy as swimming in water. Based on a research paper published at the University of Minnesota (aiche.onlinelibrary.wiley.com...)
    Get Your Experiment Box Here: theactionlab.com/
    Checkout my experiment book: amzn.to/2Wf07x1
    Follow me on Twitter: / theactionlabman
    Facebook: / theactionlabofficial
    Instagram: / therealactionlab
    Watch other popular videos from my channel
    Gömböc-The Shape That Shouldn't Exist
    • Gömböc-The Shape That ...
    Shooting a Nerf Gun Backwards While Driving At The Bullet's Speed Forward
    • Shooting a Nerf Gun Ba...
    Superhydrophobic Knife Slices Water Drops in Half
    • Superhydrophobic Knife...
    Real-Life Invisibility Cloak Can Hide Anything! How Does It Work?
    • Real-Life Invisibility...
    What's Inside the Worlds' Fastest Heat Conductor?
    • What's Inside the Worl...
    Can You Use Umbrellas Instead of a Parachute?
    • Can You Use Umbrellas ...
    Opening a Bottle of Liquid Nitrogen Under Water!
    • Opening a Bottle of Li...
    Warning: DO NOT TRY-Seeing How Close I Can Get To a Drop of Neutrons
    • Warning: DO NOT TRY-Se...
    *Any experiment you try is at YOUR OWN RISK. The Action Lab assumes no responsibility for any injury if you attempt anything you see in this video or on The Action Lab channel.
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 4,3 тыс.

  • @holyaubergine
    @holyaubergine 3 года назад +29084

    Everyone who thought he was actually going to swim in syrup: My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined

    • @mrpineapples4752
      @mrpineapples4752 3 года назад +878

      I....I have been bamboozled

    • @SHRIIMPSUCKS
      @SHRIIMPSUCKS 3 года назад +613

      imagine how sticky that would feel. i have a terrible day when I get syrup on my pants but my entire body?

    • @Chlrintruc
      @Chlrintruc 3 года назад +540

      Man I am relived he isn’t wasting 1000s of dollars worth of syrup for this.

    • @vigilabo3007
      @vigilabo3007 3 года назад +132

      Wait...he isn’t...

    • @gwennnn.h
      @gwennnn.h 3 года назад +267

      Me reading this before watching the vid

  • @TayJayMC
    @TayJayMC 3 года назад +15547

    “Blood is thicker that water”
    Syrup is thicker than blood
    Pancakes are more important than family

    • @abracalebdabra
      @abracalebdabra 3 года назад +300

      Wise...

    • @GauravSharma-dy8xv
      @GauravSharma-dy8xv 3 года назад +53

      😂

    • @StealthTheUnknown
      @StealthTheUnknown 3 года назад +241

      That is always misquoted to mean the opposite of what it was supposed to: “the blood of the covenant is thicker than the water of the womb.” As in, the things you agree to and buy into have more influence over your life than your family. Make or join your covenants wisely

    • @TrueZenquiorra
      @TrueZenquiorra 3 года назад +84

      Poop is thicker than Syrup. so...........

    • @Skoolitz
      @Skoolitz 3 года назад +72

      @@TrueZenquiorra MOM I NEED MORE POOPCAKES

  • @improvingguitarist1595
    @improvingguitarist1595 2 года назад +2305

    Omg I can just imagine how uncomfortable it is to be covered in syrup.

    • @LSniumUwU
      @LSniumUwU 2 года назад +87

      You can pee in a pool of syrup and drink it afterwards.

    • @angularsaxophone5820
      @angularsaxophone5820 2 года назад +38

      @@LSniumUwU Yummy

    • @raeyan4244
      @raeyan4244 2 года назад +44

      @@LSniumUwU thats distusting lmao

    • @fnglilbruh
      @fnglilbruh 2 года назад +72

      @@LSniumUwU of course the person who says that is a furry.

    • @fnglilbruh
      @fnglilbruh 2 года назад +42

      @@LSniumUwU slow with trends. Aren’t ya?

  • @j0code
    @j0code 2 года назад +601

    I think increasing the viscosity would feel like switching to a bigger gear on a bike - it gets harder to move, but you can move faster by moving your feet (or arms) less, so it has about the same speed either way

    • @giraffe1219
      @giraffe1219 2 года назад +46

      This is a fantastic comparison IMO

    • @lookupverazhou8599
      @lookupverazhou8599 9 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@giraffe1219Fantastic indeed.

    • @eatyourvegetables1449
      @eatyourvegetables1449 7 месяцев назад +27

      Which makes me think though (He may have explained it in the video already and I am just too impatient to watch it all) won't there be a certain point where the viscosity is so high that pushing basically becomes so hard it's unachievable, and therefore swimming in water would be faster. Because when you up the gear on a bike, there is a certain point especially at an incline where you just can't physically push against it. Although I assume this video is also talking a little hypothetically, as in, if you had infinite amount of strength to push against the liquid

    • @WWEMikano
      @WWEMikano 7 месяцев назад +3

      @@eatyourvegetables1449 Yes, 5:13

    • @iamdave84
      @iamdave84 7 месяцев назад +1

      What if the swimmers were wearing flippers? That would increase the amount of the liquid they push against, but barely change their form.

  • @mitchellheimann
    @mitchellheimann 3 года назад +4288

    I only clicked on this video to see people swimming in a pool full of syrup. Disappointed.

  • @Thomy-xo3uw
    @Thomy-xo3uw 3 года назад +4362

    If you win in swimming like this, you'll have a sweet victory

  • @Lolzmira73
    @Lolzmira73 2 года назад +476

    I also have the I’m thinking shirt lol. I actually got it as a gift

  • @mlevin7
    @mlevin7 2 года назад +107

    I think with the more viscous liquids you can swim the same speed but it takes more exertion. The amount of force that you’re able to apply on the syrup is greater than the amount you can apply on the water, but that still means you have to push harder. So with the really viscous syrup, you reached the limit of the amount of force that the turtle could apply so it couldn’t swim as fast. If you had significantly stronger motors it might still be able to swim as fast or only a little slower. It makes no sense that an effect would just disappear outside of a specific range of viscosities. It would have to slowly fade (meaning that the speed slowly decreases) as the viscosity increased.

    • @griml0gic420
      @griml0gic420 7 месяцев назад +7

      I agree. The turtle swimming slower is not a property of the liquid but of the turtle system being too highly damped by the syrup. It ain't got the gas!

    • @bscutajar
      @bscutajar 7 месяцев назад

      Exactly, the skin drag vs form drag argument didn't make much sense, your reasoning was what I was thinking as well. As long as the swimming object has enough power to move the propellers/flippers with the same rate, they will move with the same speed.

    • @kikixchannel
      @kikixchannel 5 месяцев назад

      It's not a matter of the effect disappearing. It's a matter of one of the effects being 'used up'.
      When viscosity grows up from water, if you use the SAME amount of strength, while you need more strength to move through the more viscous liquid, more of the strength you used to move actually is applied. But at some point, the increase in strength needed will be higher than the gain from higher efficiency.
      Let's add some numbers to it.
      Let's say you move at 1km/h if you put in 100 energy in water. You put in 200 energy but because the water is thin, only 100 units of that energy are actually propelling you forward.
      Now, you put in 200 energy into a more viscous syrop. Because it's more viscous it takes 150 energy to move at 1km/h in it, BUT thanks to that trait, 150 energy from the 200 you use is also propelling you forward, so you still move at the same speed.
      Now, raise the viscosity much higher and you get to a point where to reach a speed of 1km/h you need to provide more than 200 energy, say 210. It doesn't matter that almost all the energy you use is used to proper you forward (it cannot be 100%, as that would be a solid object). You just have to raise the energy to move faster, so for example, you will have to use 212 energy. That's 12 energy more than you could have used in the less viscous liquids.
      This is the point made in this video. The moment you raise the viscosity past the stage where the efficiency increases at the same rate as energy requirement, you have no choice but to increase the energy input for the same effect. But if you are comparing your best time in water, you simply CANNOT increase energy input, hence you WILL be slower.

    • @kikixchannel
      @kikixchannel 5 месяцев назад

      @@bscutajar But they need to input more energy for the same effect, therefore no, you cannot swim at the same speed in a much more viscous fluid as you can in water. You cannot suddenly become stronger simply by swimming in a thicker fluid. If you could, then your time in water would be shortened and you still would have been doing a worse time in the viscous fluid.
      You are changing the problem here from a body with a fixed ability, to two separate bodies with different abilities. That's an entirely different experiment, and one that never needed any sort of confirmation as it is absolutely clear that so long as you provide enough energy, an object can move through literally anything at any given speed (below the speed of light, and assuming it can withstand moving through said environment).

  • @caydensaxon7596
    @caydensaxon7596 3 года назад +4715

    Who else clicked on this thinkin he actually swam in syrup

  • @thecasualfront7432
    @thecasualfront7432 3 года назад +15671

    I can’t believe this, I was joking not long ago about making Olympic swimmers swim through syrup to make it more interesting 🤣

    • @user-fw1mm3gf5v
      @user-fw1mm3gf5v 3 года назад +185

      Now it's possible!

    • @snootdingo9365
      @snootdingo9365 3 года назад +135

      I was thinking about a little, yellow, cheese flavored stalagmite that's edible! Everybody, meet CHEETOS!!!

    • @ThePrufessa
      @ThePrufessa 3 года назад +45

      And now we know that it wouldn't be more interesting at all. It would be exactly the same. Unless you use a syrup that's at least 3x more viscous than water.

    • @horacio6537
      @horacio6537 3 года назад +4

      That happened!

    • @user-fw1mm3gf5v
      @user-fw1mm3gf5v 3 года назад +2

      @@ThePrufessa Yeah, but eh-

  • @mexicanshrek2811
    @mexicanshrek2811 7 месяцев назад +34

    As a swimmer, I can say that these results are true under the assumption that swimmers apply a constant force on the water, and in some ways this is true. But for strokes that rely more on a gliding lotion the added resistance from the water will make a huge difference, not to mention the added stress on ligaments and joints from the higher impact forces. I mean it’s a rotator cuff injury waiting to happen. But for plastic turtles who apply an almost constant force it’ll probably work just fine.

    • @ericjohannsen
      @ericjohannsen 5 месяцев назад +1

      I imagine getting a breath of air in syrup will be challenging...

  • @xuestaygeekin
    @xuestaygeekin 2 года назад +5

    I thought my laptop was loading until i realized that its just the design on his shirt

  • @KEVMAN7987
    @KEVMAN7987 3 года назад +1305

    I remember when Mythbusters tested this. Still interesting.
    Imagine going for a swim and having to shower afterwards not to wash off the chlorine, but the stickiness.

    • @TheBiscuitFactory
      @TheBiscuitFactory 3 года назад +79

      Who said I wanted to wash off the stickiness

    • @Red_Ryry
      @Red_Ryry 3 года назад +9

      Yeah I clicked on this remember that episode and they proved that it was faster.

    • @pedroks7756
      @pedroks7756 3 года назад +3

      @@TheBiscuitFactory Kevin Gomolchak

    • @Beabufr
      @Beabufr 3 года назад +4

      I can just lick myself

    • @neptune9647
      @neptune9647 3 года назад +7

      Get down with the stickiness.

  • @wesleyward5901
    @wesleyward5901 3 года назад +1964

    Being covered in syrup is the worst part about this.

    • @ditto-w
      @ditto-w 3 года назад +53

      2) Cover yourself in syrup

    • @novacyther7677
      @novacyther7677 3 года назад +44

      3)go to a pool
      4)swim
      this is a joke

    • @lettuce5385
      @lettuce5385 3 года назад +21

      @@ditto-w 3) wait for it to swimming pool

    • @t6amygdala
      @t6amygdala 3 года назад +4

      Fuck syrup

    • @martianmurray
      @martianmurray 3 года назад +1

      Pancake towels would help

  • @jorgecarral251
    @jorgecarral251 2 года назад +7

    Great thought experiment! I would try an experiment where more of the toy is more submerged. Right now it seems the turtle is staying mostly out of the viscous liquid, so the increase in drag is only experienced by the belly surface. As a swimmer, you aim to go as high as possible, but majority of your body is still underwater. Try a toy submarine!

  • @troydorr4867
    @troydorr4867 2 года назад

    I love your channel! Not only do you do cool experiments. But you explain why the you come to a certain conclusion. 🤔

  • @VincentJGoh
    @VincentJGoh 3 года назад +1051

    As a swimmer, what I can tell you is that if you were to put me in syrup, I might be able to swim just as fast, but I wouldn't be able to swim for nearly as long. I believe this is what we were seeing with the turtle in the extra-thick syrup. The first thing you need is enough power to propel yourself forward in whatever liquid you're in, and if you don't have enough power to push against the fluid, you're doomed. Indeed, swimmers often make things harder AND easier on themselves by wearing drag suits (or even just all their clothes) and wide paddles.
    Swimming with hand paddles makes you much faster, but your arms tire out a lot sooner. You can push harder because the surface area of your hand becomes bigger, but if you lack enough musculature to push yourself forward, it doesn't really matter. You could pair your paddles with a drag suit to maintain the same speed as unencumbered, but you would fatigue sooner. (This would be a valuable exercise for a swimmer-basically, it's just building muscle and fatigue resistance over a shorter time. It may cause joint problems, though, because you're really loading the shoulders and elbows. I doubt anyone would do this for long.)
    I'm not a physicist, but even on its face, this seems like it would require more energy. You can swim just as fast because you can *push harder* to overcome more drag. Pushing harder by definition means more force.
    What you should test is how long can a battery powered device continue to propel the craft in the more viscous fluid versus in water. I suspect it would last fractionally as long in the syrup. Probably half as long for a liquid that's twice as viscous, but it probably also relates to what the average output of the motor is.

    • @susantparida8369
      @susantparida8369 3 года назад +20

      Wow. Just wow

    • @kresnabudiman698
      @kresnabudiman698 3 года назад +22

      Underrated comment

    • @CyberCactus
      @CyberCactus 3 года назад +80

      I thought about this for a minute, but in truth, what's happening isn't that the turtle is pushing harder. If the turtle had to push harder, and thus use more power, in order to be able to make it through the syrup at the same speed, it would have been slower in this video. This is due to the fact it has the exact same motor as the other toy and uses the same motor whether in water or syrup, and no matter what always uses the same amount of power, unlike a human.
      If the turtle were using for example 10W of power to get across the water, it wouldn't suddenly start pulling 20W of power to get across the syrup at the same speed. It would still be using the same motor at the same power, meaning that if it truly needed more power to keep its pace then it wouldn't be keeping pace with the toy in the water in the first place.
      What's happening, as he said, is simply that each stroke the toy takes with the power it would be using in water should be slowed down by the syrup's viscosity, but is instead counteracted by how far the turtle gets pushed due to how easy it is to propel itself through the syrup comparative to water.
      Using the same amount of force, it is able to push itself further, but also is slowed down by viscosity, meaning it ultimately ends up the same speed and the same amount of energy used.

    • @StickyIckyOOHWAY
      @StickyIckyOOHWAY 3 года назад +24

      @@CyberCactus i thought of this too, but this is a matter of two things here: torque and maximum speed. the torque of the motor is enough to keep the flaps spinning at max speed in the syrup as in water, and since the maximum speed of the motor is the same in both liquids, there is no difference. (It probably also consume more energy, but im not really sure about that, im not very literate in electronics.)
      If the motor was not as powerful, you would indeed see the difference in speed, as it would slow down in syrup. in fact it actually did, in the more viscous liquid. the motor's torque was overmatched by the viscosity, as it could barely move its flaps.

    • @CyberCactus
      @CyberCactus 3 года назад +15

      @@StickyIckyOOHWAY Well if the toy was merely able to keep itself at max speed in the syrup, but had to pull more power to be able to do so, then it would logically have to be pulling less power from its motor to go the same speed in the water. This would require some kind of cap or limiter to be in place preventing the toy from pushing its little paddles harder than it does while it's in water. Otherwise, it would always use the same power and the same expended energy across liquids. I doubt the little toys he used in the video had any limiter that prevented them from putting the same amount of power into the water as they did into the syrup, and without limitations in water the max speed simply would have been *higher* in the water than it would in the syrup if the syrup were requiring more energy to wade through, due to the paddles having the same power from the motor which results in an easier time moving the paddles in the first place.
      I agree that the motor's lack of torque was a major contributor in why it wasn't able to move through the much more viscous liquid at the end. These fluid dynamics are strange but it seems there is simply a point in viscosity in which things stop moving easily, but until that point everything moves the same, like he went over at the end of the video. I'd love to see more demonstrations of the experiments so I can actually understand it better, at the moment admittedly I'm just theorising. You could absolutely be right and I'm missing something but so far I'm still convinced about my energy argument.

  • @Ben-jc8pu
    @Ben-jc8pu 3 года назад +1047

    He asks questions that a child would ask, but since he is an adult he can actually answer them and I love it

    • @volayiwola15
      @volayiwola15 7 месяцев назад +21

      Children asl really interesting questions. Society has just learned to shut them down😂

    • @parkermichel8296
      @parkermichel8296 7 месяцев назад +12

      bro just defined being a scientist

    • @buzzybees8604
      @buzzybees8604 6 месяцев назад +2

      @@volayiwola15 Yeah I feel that when you're younger you're usually more curious, and you learn easier too

  • @bro8686
    @bro8686 2 года назад +5

    The last few test in the syrup box were unfair since it would have got into the joints

  • @keltieem
    @keltieem 2 года назад +1

    Those lil guys don’t have to worry about the core strength that keeps them up though

  • @thog1234
    @thog1234 3 года назад +677

    Once again, I love how you have taken a physics problem, demonstrated the principle, shown the math and peaked my curiosity. Nice work.

    • @Snoigel
      @Snoigel 3 года назад +9

      I totally agree! His videos are very enticing and once you start you don’t wanna stop! You want answers!

    • @BariumCobaltNitrog3n
      @BariumCobaltNitrog3n 3 года назад +14

      Actually, it *piqued your curiosity.
      Piqued - stimulated
      Peaked - maximized
      Peeked - looked

    • @dupisdisasterpiece1058
      @dupisdisasterpiece1058 3 года назад +1

      I disagree

    • @ders972
      @ders972 3 года назад +1

      @@BariumCobaltNitrog3n relax... knowing is enough, correcting others' spelling is for busy bodies who have nothing to contribute other than corrections because they are overly critical.

    • @IssaalaaRacing
      @IssaalaaRacing 3 года назад +1

      Better than schools istg...

  • @elmortalsoldier1393
    @elmortalsoldier1393 3 года назад +1163

    A plastic straw in a turtle, how ironic...

    • @sergiotequidalozoya3875
      @sergiotequidalozoya3875 3 года назад +7

      Lmao

    • @rynzoku8662
      @rynzoku8662 3 года назад +5

      im no brain so i dont get it

    • @michaelesposito2629
      @michaelesposito2629 3 года назад +28

      That’s not how irony works.... at all

    • @mogamboyt8866
      @mogamboyt8866 3 года назад +3

      🤣🤣

    • @CorporalTailsDude
      @CorporalTailsDude 3 года назад +10

      @ATHARV KAWLE I think he meant that the straw ban didn't really do anything to help the wildlife since that doesn't stop more harmful material like metal from also becoming litter, so the ban is utterly pointless since it's not just plastic rubble killing the turtles

  • @Shinobu_slay0
    @Shinobu_slay0 6 месяцев назад +1

    Not me expecting him to actually fill a whole pool with syrup and having humans swim in it

  • @maxmeyer9777
    @maxmeyer9777 7 месяцев назад +28

    Ehrenloses Thumbnail

  • @roughwoof
    @roughwoof 3 года назад +621

    *Am I the only one that thought he is crazy enough to actually fill a pool with syrup?*

    • @nafisaparveen4275
      @nafisaparveen4275 3 года назад +10

      I also thought the same...he is crazy in doing researches lol😂😂😂

    • @roughwoof
      @roughwoof 3 года назад +7

      @@nafisaparveen4275 *THANK YOU!*

    • @bernhardt1557
      @bernhardt1557 3 года назад +21

      It would be way too expensive

    • @vioblion2053
      @vioblion2053 3 года назад +3

      @@bernhardt1557 yes

    • @greysonevans3381
      @greysonevans3381 3 года назад +10

      Mr.Beast should do it

  • @bensontedd7415
    @bensontedd7415 3 года назад +1479

    "Let's do a small scale test"
    * Adds 4 jugs of syrup.
    Yep very small scale😂

    • @j4cinta5
      @j4cinta5 3 года назад +168

      pretty small compared to a full sized swimming pool

    • @RJesse15
      @RJesse15 3 года назад +2

      @@j4cinta5 lol

    • @retrosnek5016
      @retrosnek5016 3 года назад +19

      Yea man its like 1/4 of an Olympic swimming pool

    • @AelwynMr
      @AelwynMr 3 года назад +7

      And he paid for it. He should just have made it with sugar and water, it would also have been clear instead of brown!

    • @bensontedd7415
      @bensontedd7415 3 года назад +3

      @@retrosnek5016 it's called a joke, jokes are usually not %100 accurate.

  • @Bunsdo
    @Bunsdo 7 месяцев назад +1

    Damn the myth busters nostalgia.. so awesome to see that science and myth busting has found a new home on RUclips for the new generation

  • @thaanuvi
    @thaanuvi 2 года назад +13

    On the long run would it make the swimmer more tired to swim in a more viscous liquid or not

    • @beady0081
      @beady0081 2 года назад

      I'd say no as the turtle traveled at the same speed. If pushing was harder (and therefore more tyring) it would have gone slower as it can only push at one speed.

    • @DadaIorian
      @DadaIorian 2 года назад +1

      There’s an optimal viscosity that allows more of your limb energy to transfer into forward movement. Each person's own swimming strength would determine how viscous that is.

    • @m0002856
      @m0002856 2 года назад

      @@beady0081
      I assume it would matter how viscous the fluid was.
      The turtle in pure syrup didn’t produce enough force to move through it hardly at all, but I wonder how a human would faire?
      The turtle is obviously a mechanical toy meant to move through water. A human can adapt. Maybe swimming normally through pure syrup doesn’t work as well but you can adjust your technique to compensate in some other way. Who knows. I don’t think humans are going to value swimming through syrup enough to master the art lol

  • @errortoast
    @errortoast 3 года назад +4183

    Can we just appreciate that he put his hand in syrup for us

  • @cxx23
    @cxx23 3 года назад +642

    I love that you switched the turtle toys between the first and second swim tests.
    That eliminates any possibility of power differences changing the results.

    • @josephjoestar953
      @josephjoestar953 2 года назад +19

      I'm glad he did it as well, I was hoping he'd do that just to see if there was any variation

    • @_wewww
      @_wewww 2 года назад +1

      @〆ELLℹ️🅾️TT★ wait how is it supposed to be sarcastic?

    • @NubeBuster
      @NubeBuster 7 месяцев назад +1

      But as you can see the syrup makes the turtle float more. imo the test is a bit scuffed

    • @ikamu9844
      @ikamu9844 7 месяцев назад +2

      @@NubeBuster But I'd guess the same thing would happen for humans? So I guess it should be fine

  • @AndersWelander
    @AndersWelander 8 месяцев назад

    Will be useful some day when I'm on a hike and must choose between swimming across a lake of water or a lake of syrup. Nice video as always.

  • @M_Alexander
    @M_Alexander 9 месяцев назад

    "The turtle could barely get through that syrup" is a great sentence

  • @mkmuaqibizzuddin6885
    @mkmuaqibizzuddin6885 3 года назад +415

    But does syrup increase the energy per stroke? It's almost like a gear reduction. The lower the ratio, the more torque you have. Thus less energy needed per turn. Syrup is like this case but the opposite. Need explanation. Halp

    • @Ryannn1212
      @Ryannn1212 3 года назад +23

      My iq is not so high

    • @vittoriopaonessa
      @vittoriopaonessa 3 года назад +42

      @@Ryannn1212 it's not your iq is your knowledge

    • @shikharkumar734
      @shikharkumar734 3 года назад +14

      @@vittoriopaonessa bruh

    • @xxzoroxx4840
      @xxzoroxx4840 3 года назад +25

      Syrup with not require more energy per stroke... Because if u think about it the speed of movement is the same in both liquids... If it required more energy per stroke then there would have been a reduction in speed as well

    • @xxzoroxx4840
      @xxzoroxx4840 3 года назад +12

      If more energy was required then u would have to stroke faster to keep up with the speed in water.... But in the case of the toys shown, the speed of stroking was the same as well as the displacement of the toys

  • @whatchulookinat5890
    @whatchulookinat5890 3 года назад +362

    The turtle in the regular water is just a paid actor.

  • @265lgkp
    @265lgkp 7 месяцев назад

    Thank you! You are gold 🎖

  • @kevinmartin7760
    @kevinmartin7760 2 года назад +1

    A lot of this depends on how the speed of the "motor" varies with the drag. In your last example the paddle-arms were barely moving at all so of course it went slow. What would the results be if the turtle were designed so the arms moved at the same speed regardless of load?
    One difference between the experiment in the paper and your tests is that the guar gum has little effect on the density of the water, whereas the syrup you used would substantially increase the density, and so the swimmer/turtle would float higher in the fluid, which would in turn have an (undetermined) effect on the speed. The reduced cross-sectional area and the higher viscosity would have opposite effects on the form drag and it is not clear which effect would be stronger. Floating higher could also affect how well the driving surfaces (turtle's paddles, swimmer's arms and legs) engage with the water.
    In any case, swimming at the same speed in a more viscous fluid would definitely require more work and be more tiring.

  • @jainendrasingh8080
    @jainendrasingh8080 2 года назад +1408

    Everybody: "who thought that he will actually swim in syrup"
    Me: that turtle is cute

    • @plasmathingy1432
      @plasmathingy1432 2 года назад +6

      I want one

    • @sill_528
      @sill_528 2 года назад +3

      The toy or a pet?

    • @Abdullah-mf4qn
      @Abdullah-mf4qn 2 года назад +3

      copycat

    • @trueredlucky954
      @trueredlucky954 2 года назад

      Mythbusters allready did it! Search it up, good episode.

    • @eewag1
      @eewag1 2 года назад +3

      I thought he would actually swim in syrup

  • @forlorneater6595
    @forlorneater6595 3 года назад +219

    Me at 3am: sees *title*
    Also me: I don't need sleep, I need answers

    • @andylines8040
      @andylines8040 3 года назад +2

      To be fair that syrup wasn’t very viscous

    • @forlorneater6595
      @forlorneater6595 3 года назад

      @@andylines8040 no I guess not but still... Doesn't sound like it should work regardless of the viscosity

  • @edthedemonslayer6969
    @edthedemonslayer6969 3 месяца назад +1

    It's all fun and games until the syrup goes up your nose or in your ear 💀

  • @zukodude487987
    @zukodude487987 5 месяцев назад +1

    The turtle had syrip leaking which might create dragon on the turbines.

  • @amazingtoad7244
    @amazingtoad7244 3 года назад +490

    Me a Canadian: hey that’s a normal Friday

    • @LightPlayz1098
      @LightPlayz1098 3 года назад +5

      And I have that box of Serup for 50$ dollars

    • @honeycomb937
      @honeycomb937 2 года назад +4

      lake ontario is just syrup

  • @tswan62
    @tswan62 3 года назад +92

    I was one of the "professional" swimmers that participated in this study. It was pretty wild.
    The guar gum liquid wasn't sticky, more slimy. There was a big layer of it at the bottom because it was hard to keep it in suspension, as the pumps created turbulence that would have altered the results.

    • @Matthewsala
      @Matthewsala 3 года назад +4

      So did the settling out affect the viscosity? Was it actually thinner in the part you swam in?

    • @tswan62
      @tswan62 3 года назад +17

      @@Matthewsala they were closely monitoring the viscosity of the upper portion of the pool in which we were swimming, so I'm sure they achieved the desired test conditions (to whatever extent it could be expected).
      The bottom of the pool however, was a gloriously disgusting mass of about 3-6 inches of goo, with a consistency somewhere between papier mache paste and wet boogers.

    • @robmangeri777
      @robmangeri777 7 месяцев назад +1

      That’s a pretty cool experience! Did it feel any different other than the sliminess?

    • @johnsch8634
      @johnsch8634 7 месяцев назад +2

      Guar gum is one of those things that sound fun to play with, but as soon as you actually do it's just a disgusting mess.

    • @tswan62
      @tswan62 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@robmangeri777 less than I would have thought. Hard to ignore the squish of the guard gum that settled to bottom of the pool between your toes though!

  • @FUKTxProductions
    @FUKTxProductions 7 месяцев назад

    omg i love your shirt! i had a similar idea for one but it was the win95 loading bar

  • @KilluminatiATYB
    @KilluminatiATYB 2 года назад +1

    Someone going to their local grocery store: "damn, they're all out of syrup.. Now what will i put on my pancakes"

  • @brandonlee8123
    @brandonlee8123 3 года назад +223

    Imagine opening your eyes undersyrup...
    At least it would be balanced with accidentally swallowing the pool syrup

    • @tuttelmaster7801
      @tuttelmaster7801 3 года назад +21

      What if they pee in the pool tho

    • @tuttelmaster7801
      @tuttelmaster7801 3 года назад +36

      Actually would the pee rise to the top layer since the syrup is a denser liquid so when you swim at the top its though the pee layer nasty

    • @georgeskhater487
      @georgeskhater487 3 года назад +31

      I hate all 3 of you equally right now

    • @tuttelmaster7801
      @tuttelmaster7801 3 года назад +2

      Your welcome

    • @Star_II3S
      @Star_II3S 3 года назад

      @Somebritishguy™ You oof

  • @midgetconi1811
    @midgetconi1811 3 года назад +656

    Why is no one talking about the mythbusters episode where they actually swam through syrup

    • @stinksorstonks1498
      @stinksorstonks1498 3 года назад +12

      Link?

    • @midgetconi1811
      @midgetconi1811 3 года назад +129

      @@stinksorstonks1498 you can literally just look up "mythbusters swimming in syrup" and you find clips from the episode but here you go ruclips.net/video/ub82Xb1C8os/видео.html

    • @aida8012
      @aida8012 3 года назад +85

      @@midgetconi1811 i hate you

    • @stinksorstonks1498
      @stinksorstonks1498 3 года назад +20

      @@midgetconi1811 lmao i was lazy ty

    • @nurseii9018
      @nurseii9018 3 года назад +42

      @@midgetconi1811 bro you made me scream “I hate you” so early in the morning 😭
      I’m never gonna click on a link again..

  • @plutomaniaa7
    @plutomaniaa7 2 года назад +1

    Me watching this while not having syrup in my country so i always have to import: *intense screaming and crying*

  • @bjorn564
    @bjorn564 6 месяцев назад +1

    The Mythbusters already tested this in 2009. Episode 118. It was PLAUSIBLE
    Adam and Jamie began by digging two long trenches and lining them with plastic sheeting to serve as swimming pools. They filled one with water and the other with high-viscosity syrup made from 750 pounds (340 kg) of guar gum and 10,000 US gallons (38,000 L) of water. Adam and Jamie each swam three lengths in the water to establish their average times, then did the same in the syrup. Adam’s time in syrup was 28% slower than in water; Jamie tired quickly and withdrew from further testing. They also performed tests with other syrup formulas with lower viscosity. Adam again swam three lengths in each pool and found that his syrup time was now only 2.8% to 5.4% slower than in water. Next, they invited Olympic gold medalist swimmer Nathan Adrian swim through each substance. Nathan’s times were erratic because his technique was so highly honed for pure water, and his results were thrown out. Based on the results for light and medium syrup, which they considered to be within the margin of error for their testing method, Adam and Jamie declared the myth plausible.

  • @spacejesus4747
    @spacejesus4747 3 года назад +62

    Me- *Swims in syrup*
    "You see, I'm something of a scientist myself."

    • @mamtajuthani4150
      @mamtajuthani4150 3 года назад +1

      Dhar mann

    • @melon4249
      @melon4249 2 года назад

      the difference between screwing around and science is writing it down

  • @amangill6407
    @amangill6407 3 года назад +617

    Oh, my internet isn't slow.. It's his shirt lol! xD

    • @user-fw1mm3gf5v
      @user-fw1mm3gf5v 3 года назад +24

      Wha?- Sorry, i'm thinking.

    • @amangill6407
      @amangill6407 3 года назад +6

      Thanks for the likes though... you might as well read my name. Help me win this challenge. Thanks

    • @user-fw1mm3gf5v
      @user-fw1mm3gf5v 3 года назад +7

      @@amangill6407you can do it. I believe in you.

    • @amangill6407
      @amangill6407 3 года назад +3

      @@user-fw1mm3gf5v Haha... you acting sus. xD

    • @user-fw1mm3gf5v
      @user-fw1mm3gf5v 3 года назад +4

      @@amangill6407 XD I saw you vent!

  • @xalerant
    @xalerant 2 года назад +1

    Me having sky zone flashbacks in the pit with all the foam cubes:

  • @hughbryant898
    @hughbryant898 7 месяцев назад

    Related to this is the thixotropic properties of some viscous liquid. The stress or agitation applied to a viscous liquid may increase fluidity.

  • @ChillyJack
    @ChillyJack 3 года назад +76

    "I'm not sure how well a human would do in that."
    Well if the Great Molasses Flood of 1919 that killed 21 people is any indication, not well.

    • @bernhardt1557
      @bernhardt1557 3 года назад +3

      Sam onella fan

    • @ChillyJack
      @ChillyJack 3 года назад

      @@bernhardt1557 Who?

    • @bernhardt1557
      @bernhardt1557 3 года назад +5

      You dont know Sam O'Nella? Nevermind then. Its just that he has a video about it

    • @mrcapitalism007
      @mrcapitalism007 3 года назад +4

      @@bernhardt1557 is that fucking molasses Jenga?

    • @rrb101567
      @rrb101567 3 года назад +2

      Don't worry I'm actually a hedgehog

  • @mint4876
    @mint4876 3 года назад +86

    "The turtle could barely get through that syrup" is my new favorite quote that I'm sure no one has ever said before

  • @r0bber
    @r0bber 2 года назад

    This is so random. I absolutely love it.

  • @LaptapGamer
    @LaptapGamer 7 месяцев назад

    Not me waiting for him to fill an Olympic sized pool with syrup and swim through it 💀

  • @usamiandlumineglitchstudio8600
    @usamiandlumineglitchstudio8600 3 года назад +215

    2020: Swimming In Syrup Is As Easy As Swimming In Water
    2030: Swimming In Blood Is As Easy As Swimming In Water

  • @tristanandersen4105
    @tristanandersen4105 3 года назад +33

    You should retry the experiment with ether or acetone, or some other very low viscosity liquid, to see if something four times less viscous than water has an inverse effect or not.

    • @daniel9571
      @daniel9571 2 года назад +1

      I was thinking about that too, if that is the case, then I'd be interesting to see what the "ideal" amount of viscosity would be for humans.

    • @Lucius_Chiaraviglio
      @Lucius_Chiaraviglio 2 года назад +5

      I thought so too, but you would probably want to use ethanol or methanol, because acetone would do bad things to the plastic, and ether vapor would do bad things to you (as well as ignite on the slightest excuse).

    • @GamerdevilPro
      @GamerdevilPro 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@Lucius_Chiaraviglio you can also use a container with a different material

  • @earthman7678
    @earthman7678 9 месяцев назад

    I've wondered about this actually. Because for very small scale insects and bacteria water and even air are thick and viscous by comparison. But they still manage to swim/fly around just fine. But they do it with different means. The smallest insect is called a fairy fly and it has wings that look more like long arms that it uses to literally crawl thru the air. So this answered why it still works.

  • @Mao_Mao968
    @Mao_Mao968 Год назад

    T-shirt: I’m thinking *T-shirt’s soul: what are you thinking sir?*

  • @nicktalks1676
    @nicktalks1676 3 года назад +80

    He said syrup so many times it doesn’t even sound like a word any more

  • @antiacidlemur7013
    @antiacidlemur7013 3 года назад +73

    -“This books isn’t very aerodynamic”

  • @azaanc12
    @azaanc12 2 года назад

    2020: swimming is as easy than as swimming in water
    2040: swimming in air is easier then swimming in water

  • @JonathanFisherS
    @JonathanFisherS 7 месяцев назад

    water looks so thin until your first belly buster at 12 years old off the high dive and you're scared for life

  • @Yuuki1
    @Yuuki1 3 года назад +71

    I thought he was actually going to swim in syrup but then i got Jebaited so damn hard

    • @NTGx32
      @NTGx32 3 года назад +3

      Right 😔

    • @mollieedge8336
      @mollieedge8336 3 года назад +1

      Myth busters did this years ago!!!!

    • @alexiasimoes3762
      @alexiasimoes3762 2 года назад +1

      @Somebritishgeezer™ that’s kinda rude

  • @callan2247
    @callan2247 2 года назад +259

    Me: “let’s read some comments”
    Comments: “did anyone else think he was gonna swim in syrup?” “I clicked on this thinking he was gonna swim in syrup” “I wish he had have actually swum in syrup”

  • @GabrielaArredondo
    @GabrielaArredondo 2 года назад +3

    Lemme save y’all some time.
    4:42 shows a man swimming in a pool with *guar gum* which is twice as viscous (viscous meaning having a thick, sometimes intensely sticky/gummy consistency between _liquid and solid_ as regular water.
    Now skip to 6:44 so your time doesn’t get further wasted. // why? Because he never actually swims in syrup. Misleading thumbnail.🙃

  • @etherraichu
    @etherraichu 5 месяцев назад

    I was promised an olympic swimming pool filled with clear syrup and feel cheated. I want to talk to your manager!

  • @jehmarxx
    @jehmarxx 3 года назад +182

    I can imagine How To Basic doing way more.

    • @ancovwojak6058
      @ancovwojak6058 3 года назад +6

      Swimming in eggs

    • @YOOBEAR
      @YOOBEAR 3 года назад +6

      @@ancovwojak6058 can't forget the toilet water

    • @dingdongbubble2221
      @dingdongbubble2221 3 года назад

      I hate this guy ....

    • @iangabriel5536
      @iangabriel5536 3 года назад +3

      @@dingdongbubble2221, why? He's awesome!

    • @dingdongbubble2221
      @dingdongbubble2221 3 года назад

      @@iangabriel5536 IKR its his content , but he waste so much food and money etc .. There are also people dying with hunger . I just dont liked this .

  • @mogamboyt8866
    @mogamboyt8866 3 года назад +26

    I thought he would swim in syrup , as I saw the thumbnail😂

  • @BrimmFate
    @BrimmFate 7 месяцев назад

    That sounds like I would become a danger to myself after having to feel the sticky syrup all over me

  • @davida6146
    @davida6146 29 дней назад +1

    But in the long-run, the syrup while make the person tired more quickly, leading to reduced speed.

  • @___xyz___
    @___xyz___ 3 года назад +24

    5:27 When people say syrup, this is what I think of.

  • @djpWilson
    @djpWilson 3 года назад +132

    I'm curious about the university experiment - did the swimmers tire out more quickly in the syrup than water?

    • @moonlight5889
      @moonlight5889 3 года назад +13

      Probably yes. But they were professionals so they managed to do it in time

    • @brentmagazine8496
      @brentmagazine8496 3 года назад +8

      How does one get tired swimming in sugar?

    • @RAndrewNeal
      @RAndrewNeal 3 года назад +3

      @@moonlight5889 They also timed lay swimmers.

    • @btgettel
      @btgettel 3 года назад +34

      We didn't swim long enough to really tire out, and we rested a lot between repeats. Also, we randomly switched between the thickened and control pools to make sure cumulative fatigue wouldn't be an issue.

    • @tswan62
      @tswan62 3 года назад +22

      Ha - hey Brian, been a long time!
      I'll second what he said, it really wasn't tiring - swims were too short with too much rest in between to get tired.

  • @vk4289
    @vk4289 2 года назад +1

    3:19
    What is this? 🏀
    Me : Basket Ball
    Him : Sphere

  • @Brentusvent
    @Brentusvent 7 месяцев назад +1

    I expected people swimming in syrup. Nice thumbnail

  • @IloveRoxiesfeet
    @IloveRoxiesfeet 2 года назад +136

    Guys, we need mr beast to actualy do this with a real pool

  • @DiscretionaryKing
    @DiscretionaryKing 3 года назад +43

    No one:
    Spec: "Super-weighted butterfly"

    • @Aaron-nz4lx
      @Aaron-nz4lx 2 года назад

      Here for that only comment

  • @alicherif3981
    @alicherif3981 5 месяцев назад

    was expecting a swimming pool full of syrup and sum1 diving in it

  • @porterc5751
    @porterc5751 2 года назад

    You could argue that the motor in the turtle just wasn’t powerful enough to move through the thicker syrup

  • @footylad6468
    @footylad6468 3 года назад +31

    A straw....in a turtle...
    Well isn’t that ironic

  • @user-vy2bz5fl8k
    @user-vy2bz5fl8k 3 года назад +8

    These turtles combined with that paddling sound is just so adorable

  • @y4sh0
    @y4sh0 6 месяцев назад

    The turtle also took longer in the thick syrup because its movement range is just rotating and the shape of the wing is a spoon, so it had a hardtime rotating under the syrup

  • @user-rx6zv5en8f
    @user-rx6zv5en8f 2 года назад

    nobody:
    Canada olympics: and now we will begin the swimming in syrup

  • @firenutter1798
    @firenutter1798 3 года назад +42

    imagine having to wash off not from chorine but smelling like a pancake house resteraunt

  • @shyne7487
    @shyne7487 3 года назад +165

    Everybody: he had us in the whole video ngl

  • @leenakiyumi
    @leenakiyumi 7 месяцев назад +1

    itd be interesting to hear what the swimmers commented on the tests, even though they swam at roughly the same speed did they feel a higher difficulty trying to move through the syrup or did they feel their kicks would push them forward for farther? how much energy did they need to move the same amount within the same speed, was it harder or easier? did their efficiency increase ? decrease?

  • @Joseph-Colin-EXP
    @Joseph-Colin-EXP Месяц назад

    Was 1⁰⁰% hoping bro put on a skull cap and dived from a spring board. 😂😂😂

  • @Ayzlxn
    @Ayzlxn 3 года назад +26

    “Sirup” Idk why that annoyed me so much 😂

    • @Jmaaaa
      @Jmaaaa 3 года назад

      Right!? I hear that a lot, doesn't make any sense to a non-native english speaker. "Sir up"🤦‍♂️

    • @dotmatrixmoe
      @dotmatrixmoe 3 года назад +4

      As a native English speaker, this irritates me as well. Me and everyone around me pronounces it like "Seer-rup”

    • @that1scootboi624
      @that1scootboi624 3 года назад

      @@dotmatrixmoe at least he didnt say sigh rupe

    • @johnonthephone5625
      @johnonthephone5625 3 года назад

      Cry about it

    • @KoroPSI
      @KoroPSI 3 года назад

      That's what I call it lol

  • @dopatestone5744
    @dopatestone5744 3 года назад +39

    Titles video "Swimming In Syrup Is As Easy As Swimming In Water."
    Proceeds to prove why it's harder to swim in liquids as viscosity increases.

    • @tysoflowin
      @tysoflowin 2 года назад +2

      He said syrup in the title, not viscous liquids in general.

  • @pbsus7128
    @pbsus7128 2 года назад +1

    I'm only mad because you made a turtle swim in syrup

  • @goddesslena9747
    @goddesslena9747 2 года назад

    the speed of the sphere dropping in syrup is faster than my wifi speed when I play minecraft

  • @WaterDoesGaming
    @WaterDoesGaming 3 года назад +6

    2:05 When you hit shift to start a word, but have caps lock on

  • @kacpersoon3282
    @kacpersoon3282 3 года назад +54

    2:37 he knew what he was doing with this ms in the corner

    • @unknownpjh1401
      @unknownpjh1401 3 года назад

      What do you mean? Or what does it mean

    • @flamingmohmohawesome4953
      @flamingmohmohawesome4953 3 года назад +2

      @@unknownpjh1401 420

    • @Owen_loves_Butters
      @Owen_loves_Butters 3 года назад

      Because he controlled exactly how long it took for the ball to fall.
      Don’t woosh me, I get the joke, but it’s stupid.

    • @prismx1349
      @prismx1349 3 года назад +1

      Is this even a joke ? What does this mean

  • @AmberAmber
    @AmberAmber 2 года назад

    Loved it!!

  • @marijnkuijlman
    @marijnkuijlman 7 месяцев назад +1

    I wanted to see the swimmer swimming in a swimming pool full of syrup...😭

  • @allengillis2636
    @allengillis2636 3 года назад +27

    I loved when The Mythbusters did this

  • @DitsyDaisy
    @DitsyDaisy 3 года назад +62

    I'm surprised there aren't ants everywhere

  • @stranger9155
    @stranger9155 7 месяцев назад +1

    All you needed to do was ask a Canadian, they swim in ice lakes and syrup all the time, they'll tell you.

  • @seinfan9
    @seinfan9 6 месяцев назад

    Did this guy ever go ahead show a full scale demo of this? Cannonball into a pool of syrup and then try swimming through it.