Thanks for uploading specifically this chapter of Islamic Banking. Because whenever we send anyone, most of them say that the video is too long, and some even missed chapter 3, which I believe is the most important one to watch.
@@asharib.naseer first video is good as well it is a important topic so people must learn and know it was a good and detailed topic you covered up and also showed how they do this all. there are also hidden charges they take before you open account and ask them they don't tell you but as soon as you get the account they tell you the charges only then.
The objections you’ve raised have already been answered by scholars in their books. If you don’t know about these answers, feel free to ask, and I’ll guide you. Fair research would mean mentioning those responses as well.
I researched on these as well before making video. By showcasing Shariah Laws in comparison to Banking policies. If you have counter question please feel free to ask on basis of arguments (Dalial).
@asharib.naseer Sharia law doesn’t rely solely on the book Hidayah. Although Hidayah covers many issues, later scholars often give rulings that differ from it. Even if we assume, for a moment, that Hidayah is an ultimate book, it would only apply to the Hanafi school, not to other schools of thought. Islamic banking, however, is not limited to Pakistan and India. It’s practiced in almost all Muslim countries, and respected scholars from each country are examining and overseeing this system. If you read Ghair Soodi Bankari - Mutaliqa Fiqhi Masail ki Tehqeeq aur Ashkalaat ka Jaiza , it might address many of your concerns. And if you can read Arabic, studying Fiqh al-Buyu' would also be beneficial.
@@SyedRizvi-gp3dt Miss leading?? Comes up with Dalial not just tanqeed. Hamza Khan didn't mention any thing related to miss lead. Moreover, As far as my understanding by reading both Asharib and Hamza point of view. I believe both are right. Becasue Asharib also mentioned laws from Quran Kareem which is (تعاون باہمی) Mutual Corporation. I've also an experience of Car Leasing from Meezan Bank and I feel the same that it charge same as conventional bank. I believe Asharib use Fiaqha Hanfi becasue in our region there are most follower of this Fiqha. If he uses other Fiqha as well then it will be contradictory situation.
@@smartch3364 Look, Islamic banks are not charitable organizations; they are also business entities. When determining whether something is permissible (halal) or prohibited (haram) in Islam, we don’t look at the end result; rather, we examine the method. Now, if an Islamic bank charges a profit rate similar to a conventional bank, or even a bit higher, this doesn’t make the transaction invalid. For example, if a bottle of alcohol costs a hundred rupees and a bottle of juice costs the same, there’s no problem with that. Scholars have worked hard to create ways to keep financial dealings within the permissible boundaries. However, the full goals of Islamic banking have not yet been achieved, and that’s a separate discussion. One reason for this is that people often prefer taking loans instead of partnerships in business. But if all banks were interest-free and based on profit-sharing models like Mudarabah or Musharakah , then we could start realizing the broader objectives of an Islamic economic system-such as directing wealth towards the people. However, the permissibility of a transaction is not based on whether it achieves these ultimate objectives.
Good Content You created, but you need much more research...! And also to set Video title and description. Your goals (e.g., understanding the topic, evaluating credibility). Specific aspects to focus on (e.g., content, production quality)
ہر معیشت کا ماہر اس کا حل بتاتا ہے کہ اسلامک بینکنگ، اسلامک معاشی نظام میں ہی ممکن ہے۔ اب اسلام کے مکمل سسٹم کو سمجھنا ضروری ہے۔ انشاءاللہ جلد اس پر ململ ویڈیو بناؤں گا۔ شکریہ
@@asharib.naseerپہلے آپ تو بتائیں آپ کس فیلڈ کے ماہر ہیں معاشیات کے یا اسلامی قانون کے؟آپ نے جو اعتراض کیے ہیں ان کے جوابات بھی تو علماء نے اپنی کتابوں میں لکھے ہیں ان کا بھی تو تذکرہ کرنا منصفانہ تحقیق کا تقاضا تھا۔اگر کتابوں کا علم نہیں ہے تو پوچھ لیں ان شاءاللہ تعالیٰ رہنمائی کر دوں گا۔
آپ کہہ رہے ہیں کہ اسلامک بنک یہ نہیں بتاتا کہ انویسٹمنٹ کہاں کی ہے؟ جب کہ بنک کی سالانہ رپورٹ میں یہ سب تفصیل موجود ہوتی ہے کہ انویسٹمنٹ کہاں کہاں ہوئی ہے
You just took some part of the podcast, and showed it as his final view about Islamic Banking. He was just mentioning shortcomings in the system. He didn't said that Islamic Finance is similar to conventional system. He even emphasized that Muslims should have their own Financial system, to sustain in this competitive world. He has been Investment banker for 29 years. and currently he is the CEO of Cordoba Capital, an investment management company based on Islamic Principles. Do your research before making such kind of videos.
Yeah, I used short clip of podcast and researched his background as well. But not just relaying on that clip. Instead I prove Islamic Banking model in term of Shariah Laws. Please watch full video. I believe you watched few seconds and wrote a comment.
شروعات سے ہی بنیاد غلط ہے۔۔ ہدایہ مبتدئین کی کتاب ہے ۔۔ فتوی فتاوی شامی سے دیا جاتا ہے ۔۔ اس کے علاوہ مالی معاملات میں کافی وسعت ہے اور لوگوں کو حرام سے بچانا ضروری ہے لہذا یہ راستہ اختیار کیا گیا ۔۔ خیر آپ کی ہر ایک بات کا جواب موجود یے لیکن ٹائپ کرنے کی استطاعت نہیں
Thanks for uploading specifically this chapter of Islamic Banking. Because whenever we send anyone, most of them say that the video is too long, and some even missed chapter 3, which I believe is the most important one to watch.
Great explanation, very well 🎉
Islamic Banks: Profit Halal Ya Haram? | Mufti Taqi Usmani SB Ke Fatwa Ka Jaiza
ruclips.net/video/MgvZshMoFbc/видео.htmlsi=YxoTXJFc0Wmfm3hM
محترم آپ کے اکثر سوالات و اشکالات کے مفصل جوابات و تنقیحات موجود ہیں ۔
ازراہ کرم متعلقہ کتابیں دیکھ لیں
آپ کا اگر مطالعہ ہے تو اپ دلائل پر مبنی سوال کیجئے۔ شکریہ
I am very happy to see this video 🎉. Please one video on crypto trading and stocks market please ❤❤❤
Sure I will
I will wait for it@@asharib.naseer
upload again?
No bro it is 2nd part.😊😊
People are saying the previous on Banking too long.
So this one covers only Chapter-3.
@@asharib.naseer first video is good as well it is a important topic so people must learn and know it was a good and detailed topic you covered up and also showed how they do this all. there are also hidden charges they take before you open account and ask them they don't tell you but as soon as you get the account they tell you the charges only then.
@@asharib.naseer Ok, Gen z face low attention span that's why......
Exactly!
Please also create a detailed video on Bitcoin. As he mentioned in the video.
Insha Allah, I will
The objections you’ve raised have already been answered by scholars in their books. If you don’t know about these answers, feel free to ask, and I’ll guide you. Fair research would mean mentioning those responses as well.
I researched on these as well before making video.
By showcasing Shariah Laws in comparison to Banking policies. If you have counter question please feel free to ask on basis of arguments (Dalial).
@asharib.naseer Sharia law doesn’t rely solely on the book Hidayah. Although Hidayah covers many issues, later scholars often give rulings that differ from it. Even if we assume, for a moment, that Hidayah is an ultimate book, it would only apply to the Hanafi school, not to other schools of thought.
Islamic banking, however, is not limited to Pakistan and India. It’s practiced in almost all Muslim countries, and respected scholars from each country are examining and overseeing this system.
If you read Ghair Soodi Bankari - Mutaliqa Fiqhi Masail ki Tehqeeq aur Ashkalaat ka Jaiza , it might address many of your concerns. And if you can read Arabic, studying Fiqh al-Buyu' would also be beneficial.
@@MuhammadHamzaKhan98 thank you bhai i also feel some miss leading info in this video.
@@SyedRizvi-gp3dt Miss leading?? Comes up with Dalial not just tanqeed. Hamza Khan didn't mention any thing related to miss lead.
Moreover, As far as my understanding by reading both Asharib and Hamza point of view. I believe both are right. Becasue Asharib also mentioned laws from Quran Kareem which is (تعاون باہمی) Mutual Corporation. I've also an experience of Car Leasing from Meezan Bank and I feel the same that it charge same as conventional bank.
I believe Asharib use Fiaqha Hanfi becasue in our region there are most follower of this Fiqha. If he uses other Fiqha as well then it will be contradictory situation.
@@smartch3364 Look, Islamic banks are not charitable organizations; they are also business entities. When determining whether something is permissible (halal) or prohibited (haram) in Islam, we don’t look at the end result; rather, we examine the method.
Now, if an Islamic bank charges a profit rate similar to a conventional bank, or even a bit higher, this doesn’t make the transaction invalid. For example, if a bottle of alcohol costs a hundred rupees and a bottle of juice costs the same, there’s no problem with that. Scholars have worked hard to create ways to keep financial dealings within the permissible boundaries. However, the full goals of Islamic banking have not yet been achieved, and that’s a separate discussion.
One reason for this is that people often prefer taking loans instead of partnerships in business. But if all banks were interest-free and based on profit-sharing models like Mudarabah or Musharakah , then we could start realizing the broader objectives of an Islamic economic system-such as directing wealth towards the people. However, the permissibility of a transaction is not based on whether it achieves these ultimate objectives.
Please upload a video on 4k Quality. Aapka content bohut acha hy bus video quality thori enhance hojaae too maza Aajae 😍🔥
I'll see you hitting 1 Million Subscribers
The bank creates money from nothing.
Good Content You created, but you need much more research...! And also to set Video title and description.
Your goals (e.g., understanding the topic, evaluating credibility).
Specific aspects to focus on (e.g., content, production quality)
Very very good work
sahzada
goood
keep it up
Koi solution to batao
Kaise islamic bank hona chahiye
sahi
ہر معیشت کا ماہر اس کا حل بتاتا ہے کہ اسلامک بینکنگ، اسلامک معاشی نظام میں ہی ممکن ہے۔
اب اسلام کے مکمل سسٹم کو سمجھنا ضروری ہے۔ انشاءاللہ جلد اس پر ململ ویڈیو بناؤں گا۔ شکریہ
@@asharib.naseer allah aap ko iss nek kaam me madam attakre
True Hal ya hi ha ka shaoor hasil kia gaya no gwano ko syasi o mazhabi propaganda sa hta kr shi system ki taleem di gaya aur phir inqlab laya gya
@@asharib.naseerپہلے آپ تو بتائیں آپ کس فیلڈ کے ماہر ہیں معاشیات کے یا اسلامی قانون کے؟آپ نے جو اعتراض کیے ہیں ان کے جوابات بھی تو علماء نے اپنی کتابوں میں لکھے ہیں ان کا بھی تو تذکرہ کرنا منصفانہ تحقیق کا تقاضا تھا۔اگر کتابوں کا علم نہیں ہے تو پوچھ لیں ان شاءاللہ تعالیٰ رہنمائی کر دوں گا۔
is this reupload?
2nd part?
Not the second part, just the Chapter-3 of previous one.
آپ کہہ رہے ہیں کہ اسلامک بنک یہ نہیں بتاتا کہ انویسٹمنٹ کہاں کی ہے؟ جب کہ بنک کی سالانہ رپورٹ میں یہ سب تفصیل موجود ہوتی ہے کہ انویسٹمنٹ کہاں کہاں ہوئی ہے
Attached scan is bank document which states that you cant demand.
They show by themselves,
If they are making money from investors money. Why can't the investors ask them to show the daily business report.
Your target audience is like of thought behind things
The Wide Side
Dekho Suno Jano
TBT
Now THIS
Great Chain of Content
@adv.usamamayo9779 the wide side is just bullshit content. Reading news papers. No real analysis like tbt
great content 👍💯kindly make a video on what's cryptocurrency and whther its halal or haram
Sure I will
Re upload
It’s just Chapter-3. People are saying that the previous video is too long.
ایک غیر سودی بنکاری ہوتا اور ایک اسلامی بنکاری دونوں میں فرق سمجھ
تواس نے ویڈیو میں کیا کیا ہے۔ ناچ کر دکھایا ہے۔
کیا ہی بہتر ہوتا آپ کسی بینکر قابل مولوی سے بت سمجھ لیتے
You just took some part of the podcast, and showed it as his final view about Islamic Banking.
He was just mentioning shortcomings in the system.
He didn't said that Islamic Finance is similar to conventional system.
He even emphasized that Muslims should have their own Financial system, to sustain in this competitive world.
He has been Investment banker for 29 years. and currently he is the CEO of Cordoba Capital, an investment management company based on Islamic Principles.
Do your research before making such kind of videos.
Yeah, I used short clip of podcast and researched his background as well.
But not just relaying on that clip. Instead I prove Islamic Banking model in term of Shariah Laws.
Please watch full video. I believe you watched few seconds and wrote a comment.
سٹڈی کر مفتی تقی عثمانی صاحب
یوٹیوب پہ ائے ہفتہ نہیں ہوا اور مشورے چیک کرو
شروعات سے ہی بنیاد غلط ہے۔۔ ہدایہ مبتدئین کی کتاب ہے ۔۔ فتوی فتاوی شامی سے دیا جاتا ہے ۔۔ اس کے علاوہ مالی معاملات میں کافی وسعت ہے اور لوگوں کو حرام سے بچانا ضروری ہے لہذا یہ راستہ اختیار کیا گیا ۔۔ خیر آپ کی ہر ایک بات کا جواب موجود یے لیکن ٹائپ کرنے کی استطاعت نہیں