Brunanburh, 937 ⚔ Forgotten battle that made England

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 409

  • @HistoryMarche
    @HistoryMarche  Год назад +19

    🚩 Skip the waitlist and invest in blue-chip art for the very first time by signing up for Masterworks: www.masterworks.art/historymarche
    Purchase shares in great masterpieces from artists like Pablo Picasso, Banksy, Andy Warhol, and more.
    🚩 See important Masterworks disclosures: www.masterworks.com/cd

    • @geraintthatcher3076
      @geraintthatcher3076 Год назад

      You should do Edward 1st conquest of Wales and Robert the Bruce Invasion of Ireland

    • @michealmcneal2259
      @michealmcneal2259 Год назад

      Theres a good reason all the kings used to wear helmets....to hold what little brain matter they had in their skulls. It kept trying to escape, because they refused to use it. (Early english history proves it) lol.

    • @TheJoker-fv7ez
      @TheJoker-fv7ez Год назад

      Great video, never thought I'd see the battle of Brunanburgh covered, thank you very much.
      I've been a huge fan of your videos for a while, keep up the great work 👍

    • @johnruddick686
      @johnruddick686 Год назад +10

      You can find a better sponsor masterworks is pretty much a scam.

    • @nss309
      @nss309 Год назад

      ​@@michealmcneal2259how?

  • @UnTotal1-Requess
    @UnTotal1-Requess Год назад +103

    I've been watching these videos not only for entertainment and to expand my historical knowledge. But to learn strategies and tactics so I can finally win some battles in total war.

    • @Unknown31212
      @Unknown31212 Год назад +12

      You are a man of culture I see

    • @amirfarhang5169
      @amirfarhang5169 Год назад +6

      me too but the difference is ,,win on mount and blade banner lord

    • @phenr1r
      @phenr1r 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@amirfarhang5169both man of culture i see

  • @SolidAvenger1290
    @SolidAvenger1290 Год назад +67

    "We the West-Saxons. Long as Lasted, in companies. Troubled the track of the host that we hated. Grimly with swords that were sharp from the grindstone. Fiercely we hack’d at the flyers before us." - Excerpt V of the Old English Poem of the Battle Of Brunanburh by Alfred Tennyson
    The outcome at Brunanburh might have contributed to the English state today, not because Æthelstan won, but because of the possible consequences had he lost.

    • @nss309
      @nss309 Год назад +2

      Same difference.

    • @wohendumwing3ee9
      @wohendumwing3ee9 8 месяцев назад +1

      You basically said nothing in this comment.

    • @christianfreedom-seeker934
      @christianfreedom-seeker934 5 месяцев назад

      The modern British State was formed over several important wars. But Hastings was key.

  • @celestialmusic6657
    @celestialmusic6657 Год назад +86

    This mentions some events portrayed in the viking series 'The Last kingdom' ! Loved that one, available of netflix btw.

    • @renealbrechtsen9743
      @renealbrechtsen9743 Год назад +12

      The Last Kingdom is one of my favorite series :)

    • @yojlik
      @yojlik Год назад +14

      The Saxon Stories (13 novels) by Bernard Cornwell, which The Last Kingdom is based on, are excellent reads if you like historical fiction!

    • @nss309
      @nss309 Год назад +2

      Netflix's nonsense.

    • @chrissperry1514
      @chrissperry1514 Год назад +5

      @@nss309 the show is really well done for a netflix series and is very close to be historically accurate with real locations that are still around.

    • @nss309
      @nss309 Год назад +3

      @@chrissperry1514 it has some interesting characters and nice music, but the overall look of the time and place is like watching history's vikings.

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 Год назад +145

    Here's another important battle in english history, battle of bosworth, the end of the Plantagenet Dynasty and the beggining of the Tudor Dynasty, the battle that brought an end to the wars of the roses, would LOVE seeing you cover it man! Hope your dad is better

    • @shahsjddjejdjd2551
      @shahsjddjejdjd2551 Год назад +9

      I believe he has mate

    • @antorseax9492
      @antorseax9492 Год назад

      ​@@shahsjddjejdjd2551 Nope

    • @ryankassulke
      @ryankassulke Год назад +17

      He mentions Bosworth in the intro mate

    • @antorseax9492
      @antorseax9492 Год назад +1

      @@ryankassulke And?

    • @nss309
      @nss309 Год назад +8

      ​@@antorseax9492it makes the comment kinda pointless.

  • @qwaz67
    @qwaz67 Год назад +38

    According to High School classes, England didn’t exist before 1066.

    • @Rynewulf
      @Rynewulf Год назад +19

      Our Norman ruling class that still holds the wealth and political positions certainly does like to think that way

    • @Rynewulf
      @Rynewulf Год назад +10

      @@mattg56 its also easier to send us off on behalf of The Empire, when its not pointed out that we're a pre existing conquered people beholden to the elites, and thats exactly why we're even in a Union in the first place.
      Suddenly devolution and questioning Parliament and the Crown make more sense when we see our history is comparable to Wales, Scotland and Ireland rather than us altruistically bringing them together

    • @mijanhoque1740
      @mijanhoque1740 Год назад +4

      Yup. I mean I’m from England myself and didn’t even learn any of this until I got to Uni and even after it.

    • @ajstevens1652
      @ajstevens1652 8 месяцев назад

      It's insane how the Norman ruling class erased English history for centuries and still suppress it today.

    • @Angelcynn_2001
      @Angelcynn_2001 7 месяцев назад +1

      Norman propaganda

  • @brylleandreibt
    @brylleandreibt Год назад +12

    Just finished watching the Last Kingdom and 7 Kings minutes ago. Really glad i found your video. Thank you.

  • @Ezael
    @Ezael Год назад +13

    So many accidents, someone recruited a great spymaster on Crusader Kings

  • @icecoffee1361
    @icecoffee1361 Год назад +34

    Love the fact I live possible 10 minutes from possibly one of the defining battles in British/English history. So much over the years has been spoken about this battle and one day I hope they find exactly where it happened on the WIRRAL 🎉

    • @CerdicTheGreat
      @CerdicTheGreat Год назад +2

      I live on top of where another seminal battle was fought. It is here that Ecgberht beat the Mercians and established the dynasty and Wessex as a powerful country.

    • @williamanderson5437
      @williamanderson5437 Год назад +4

      Nearby Brimstage is also referred to in historical documents, only a mile away - and about two miles North is Tranmere Rovers - the only Norwegian named team in England. Norwegians breaking away from Norwegian's who had settled in Dublin, had settled on The Wirral Peninsular in 902ad. Many places (ending in -ton or -by), bear Norse names, including Thingwall - the local 'Parliament/Meeting Field'.

    • @BigMrFirebird
      @BigMrFirebird Год назад +1

      Don't hold your breath.

    • @BigMrFirebird
      @BigMrFirebird Год назад

      @@williamanderson5437 -ton names are usually associated with Anglo/Saxon settlement, not Scandinavian.

    • @crystalmethking
      @crystalmethking 11 месяцев назад +1

      10 mins here too. History on our doorstep!

  • @13f20-pl2fj
    @13f20-pl2fj Год назад +10

    I read about this battle in 'Egil,s Saga' which is one of the Icelandic Sagas. In it the main character, Egil Skelgrinson participated on the battle while in the service of Aethelstan the Faithful as he was called in the story. It gives a decent account although King Olaf is misidentified as the King of Scotland.

    • @BigMrFirebird
      @BigMrFirebird Год назад

      Which is why sagas shouldn't be taken too seriously in history.

  • @johnvanstone5336
    @johnvanstone5336 Год назад +29

    If we only knew where this actual battle was ! This battle was of massive importance and significance and Athelstan must rank next to Alfred in the best of the Anglo-Saxon kings

    • @EvoraGT430
      @EvoraGT430 Год назад +2

      Shame the Normans suppressed the Anglo-Saxon history so effectively that most English people have never even heard of their first true (and great) king.

    • @williamanderson5437
      @williamanderson5437 Год назад +6

      As of 2023, it was around Storeton Woods, Wirral (read 'War Lord' by Bernard Cornwell for more information, inc notes by Wirral Archaeology).

    • @BigMrFirebird
      @BigMrFirebird Год назад

      @@williamanderson5437 Did they answer what's a Scottish army doing so far away from home, on the Wirrall yet?

    • @clownofthetimes6727
      @clownofthetimes6727 Год назад +4

      If you type Brunanburgh on Wikipedia it lays out some contenders. I am a big fan of Burnley being the site. One of the clues for me is Walton spire. A dark age battle marker, menhir that was chiseled down to a more respectable and civilised size and had a cross attached to it by the local christian priest in Victorian times.!!!! Absolute vandalism!
      But it is in a good spot and has things like Saxfield street to add to its allure. Several papers discuss it better than I could,

    • @BigMrFirebird
      @BigMrFirebird Год назад

      @@clownofthetimes6727 As things stand, one claim is as good as another.

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 Год назад +32

    YES! Athelstan the Glorious! One of the Best Kings the English ever had! Thanks For this man! Love your content and hope your dad is doing better 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤

    • @EvoraGT430
      @EvoraGT430 Год назад +3

      Shame the Normans suppressed the Anglo-Saxon history so effectively that most English people have never even heard of their first true (and great) king.

  • @KHK001
    @KHK001 Год назад +11

    Amazing video! And hope your dad is recovering well HM.

  • @BillCody931
    @BillCody931 Год назад +4

    thanks for doing Athelstan the first ruler of the English. He is often overlooked in favor of his Grandfather Alfred the Great.

    • @EvoraGT430
      @EvoraGT430 Год назад +2

      Shame the Normans suppressed the Anglo-Saxon history so effectively that most English people have never even heard of their first true (and great) king.

  • @TihetrisWeathersby
    @TihetrisWeathersby Год назад +10

    Last Kingdom and Vikings fans stand up!

  • @ridvirgo1994
    @ridvirgo1994 Год назад +4

    I'm Uthred, son of Uthred.......(opening music intensified).... DESTINY IS ALL!

  • @BJ-wx5xq
    @BJ-wx5xq Год назад +11

    His grandfather only English ruler to get the epithet the great , but I believe Athelstan was more than deserving of the title as well , great video about the line of ecgberht🎉

    • @adventussaxonum448
      @adventussaxonum448 Год назад +2

      I believe contemporary sources called him Athelstan the Magnificent..

    • @greva2904
      @greva2904 Год назад

      Alfred was only christened ‘the Great’ by the Victorians when they gained a patriotic interest in ancient British history. Till then he was only known as Athelstan.

    • @Funeeman
      @Funeeman 10 месяцев назад

      Most definitely.

    • @Darrenski
      @Darrenski Месяц назад

      Actually Cnut was widely known as the great

  • @BV1646
    @BV1646 Год назад +12

    When is a new hannibal episode? Really looking forwars to see the series continued

  • @crusaderknight379
    @crusaderknight379 Год назад +4

    As a man born as a english man i give this video a 20 out of 10

  • @ArthurChristiaanOtte
    @ArthurChristiaanOtte Месяц назад

    The movie Seven Kings must die was about this battle, I think. This is much clearer what really happened! Thank you!

  • @JgonzaloTBEJARANO21222021
    @JgonzaloTBEJARANO21222021 Год назад +12

    I learned about this battle from the movie Seven Kings Must Die, sequel and final point to Uthred's story in The Last Kingdom. Where Uthred and Aethelstan face the Danes, and King Constantine of Scotland.

    • @Jürgen_von_Schumacher
      @Jürgen_von_Schumacher Год назад +1

      So he was a traitor in the end. Looking at true history, there were many times where the danes could have won.

  • @Isidorios
    @Isidorios Год назад +1

    When all of your enemies unite in a coalition against you, and yet you are victorious anyway, you are mighty indeed.

  • @Tortuga629
    @Tortuga629 Год назад +178

    The UK is facing a much bigger threat than "under-investing".

    • @Jack-xg1kg
      @Jack-xg1kg Год назад +38

      Quite. I didn't really appreciate having a bit of modern political ideology at the start of a history video.

    • @TBombaclot
      @TBombaclot Год назад +96

      A different barbarian invasion. This one not so easily recoverable from.

    • @boo0p707
      @boo0p707 Год назад +4

      ​@MrLevigraz what barbarian?

    • @lithobolos
      @lithobolos Год назад

      ​@@TBombaclot fash trash

    • @megathicc6367
      @megathicc6367 Год назад +4

      ​@@TBombaclotWhat barbarian?

  • @HannibalBarca137
    @HannibalBarca137 Год назад +9

    I love the intro it was different and I think it was the best intro you ever made yet please keep doing the types of intros, keep this amazing work up. When will Hannibal be out. Keep the work up!

  • @LordJayAndrew
    @LordJayAndrew 7 месяцев назад +1

    Incredible guys! Thank you!

  • @roseytgaming7076
    @roseytgaming7076 Год назад +9

    One of your first videos still on the cannel is the battle of vaslui, druing stephan the great and as a romanian is one the biggest vicotries for us against the ottomans. But we also had other enemies like polish and i'd love a video for the battle of cosmin forest. A great story lies around it and a victory while all seemed hopeless would make a great video

  • @juanzulu1318
    @juanzulu1318 Год назад

    This white circle on the map to show what the speaker describes is very helpful. 👍

  • @keatonisballin
    @keatonisballin Год назад +3

    Great video, as always. One of my favorite channels.

  • @aveekmanna912
    @aveekmanna912 Год назад +4

    Hoping fr u quick recovery fr yr father....... Plz complete hannibal series😢

  • @mohammedsaysrashid3587
    @mohammedsaysrashid3587 Год назад +4

    Another great video .. i hope others coming .it was an informative and important episode about English history during medieval term 939 AD where Athilstan king United most English territory and defeated north correlation opponents at 939 AD ...thank you respectful (history Marche ) channel for sharing this remarkable video .

    • @DrivermanO
      @DrivermanO Год назад +1

      Actually 937! Aethelstan died in 939.

  • @aethellstan
    @aethellstan 10 месяцев назад

    ahhh those were the days, i remember the battle well...

  • @ConstantineJoseph
    @ConstantineJoseph Год назад +1

    Sir what’s plan A?
    - It’s the shield wall
    And what’s our plan B?
    - we’ll fall back again on our trusted shield wall

  • @zod56
    @zod56 Год назад +3

    Another great video. Keep them coming!

  • @gustavknugen2015
    @gustavknugen2015 Год назад +1

    great video once again! just love the narration and topics this channel provide.

  • @respectboy4966
    @respectboy4966 Год назад +1

    The Last Kingdom series is pretty good

  • @coyote4237
    @coyote4237 Год назад +2

    Thank you. Always well done.

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 Год назад +23

    You're Amazing man! Your music, narration and visuals always make for an out of this world learning experience! Recommendation: Cover the Conquest of Cordoba by Ferdinand III of Castile or the Conquest of Valencia by James I of Aragon! Great Reconquista figures. You're awesome. Hope all the best to you father man!

    • @HistoryMarche
      @HistoryMarche  Год назад +11

      Thanks so much Daniel! Much appreciated. I'm working on Aljubarrota, it's not James I of Aragon but it's close. I'll definitely work on more Iberian history topics, as I lack them on the channel.

    • @danielsantiagourtado3430
      @danielsantiagourtado3430 Год назад +2

      @@HistoryMarche great to hear man!

    • @affan3095
      @affan3095 Год назад

      ​@@HistoryMarchecan you make a video about Mughal Empire and Delhi sultanate which prevented Mongols invasion of India.

  • @krzysztofb.3979
    @krzysztofb.3979 Год назад +1

    Always reliaiable and interesting content wigh good, historical background. TY!

  • @MrBulky992
    @MrBulky992 Год назад +3

    Isn't there a bit missing? There were more Viking invasions after 939 quite a bit before Aethelred the Unready which are not mentioned. There were Viking kings in York until the death of the last, Eric Bloodaxe, in 954 AD. Lucky Aethelstan's successors got rid of them by the time of King Edgar the Peaceful (Aethelred's father).

  • @ralambosontiavina7372
    @ralambosontiavina7372 11 месяцев назад

    Great work as always !

  • @antoniomoreira5921
    @antoniomoreira5921 Год назад +1

    There's a splendid battle analysis by Schwerpunkt, I strongly recommend it to anyone interested in the event

  • @Beachdude67
    @Beachdude67 Год назад +2

    I'd suppose you can't step foot in a field anywhere in England where a battle hasn't occurred sometime in the last 2000 years.

  • @them9884
    @them9884 Год назад

    My favourite history channel by far!

  • @kotominehirage8253
    @kotominehirage8253 Год назад +9

    Adoro esse canal pelas várias legendas 🥰🥰👌

  • @williamanderson5437
    @williamanderson5437 Год назад +3

    The Brunanburh Battlesite is just off the M53, on Wirral, around what is now Storeton Woods. Nearby Red Hill Road said to be so named as it ran red with blood from that Great Slaughter. The Invaders arrived at Parkgate? on the Wirral side of the River Dee, fleeing back after the Battle. The high ground at the top of Storeton Hill overlooks the M53, Clatterbridge, Mount Road, Brackenwood & Red Hill Road, Thousands of artifacts have already been discovered, note 'War Lord' by Bernard Cornwell. Brackenwood Golf Course is currently being Metal Detected as of 2023/4..

    • @BigMrFirebird
      @BigMrFirebird Год назад

      You believe that. Meanwhile, anyone seriously interested in finding the battle site rather than promoting the Wirrall would have to study Scottish early medieval history as well as the usual Anglo/Scandinavian bias on this subject.

    • @brantsemallory726
      @brantsemallory726 Год назад

      @@BigMrFirebird And yet all the actual experts agree on the general location. It was not fought in north Yorkshire as you seem to hope. Nobody serious ever mentions the battle ground being anywhere near scotland - which was not even called that at the time to use your own naming arguments against you.

    • @pipins3616
      @pipins3616 6 месяцев назад

      Close but not just where you say

    • @pipins3616
      @pipins3616 6 месяцев назад

      Red Hill was so named because of the sandstone either side of the cut, but the Quarry was mined by the Romans

  • @jimmillward3505
    @jimmillward3505 Год назад +1

    i love your videos, great voice, great narration and research and fabulous animations

  • @Thyranel
    @Thyranel Год назад +1

    Amazing video ❤❤❤

  • @pixlbit9514
    @pixlbit9514 Год назад

    That sponsor segway was legendary.

  • @phemstros
    @phemstros Год назад

    Brunanburgh is for me the single most consequential battle in history given its cementing of national identity through unifying different peoples and faiths under its structure. This extends to Scots/Irish/Welsh who fought in both sides that day, as well as Danes who did the same. It was a choice between one world and a better one. The stability provided the base that the Romans first saw and built over, which had fallen away, which formed the state that William I saw had to be seized and then expanded upon. By extension, this fed into all aspects of life and form the basis of everything today via the empire, through principles of law and commerce everywhere.

  • @sim0n17
    @sim0n17 Год назад +2

    sacrifice to the algorithm

  • @carltonbauheimer
    @carltonbauheimer Год назад +1

    For a second i thought the Masterworks ad read was going to get based about another invasion of Britain going on.

  • @alex_erazo
    @alex_erazo Год назад +1

    Sounds like the battle referenced in 7 kings must die on Netflix ⚔️

  • @TihetrisWeathersby
    @TihetrisWeathersby Год назад +4

    That Ad transition was so smooth, Respect the grind

  • @ghosthorse77
    @ghosthorse77 Год назад

    I haven't forgotten it.

  • @bobsauve
    @bobsauve Год назад

    Great video!

  • @The_ZeroLine
    @The_ZeroLine Год назад +1

    People need to read Cromwell’s Warlord series or Saxon Tales if they love these stories.

  • @soulsishiredits
    @soulsishiredits Год назад +1

    sir battle of edington of 875 AD also play an important role in english history but at intro you did not show why

  • @mathiasdionne7807
    @mathiasdionne7807 Год назад +1

    how do you do all that thing? it is a game or it an edit that you make? it so cool. your videos are amazing continue like that men!

  • @Hisoricvids
    @Hisoricvids Год назад +3

    Cool! Man you have changed a lot!❤ i recommend the battle of Durbe, Raseiniai,Rossbach and Manzikert! Ill apreciate it👍👍👍

  • @britainman3459
    @britainman3459 18 дней назад

    I finally found this video huzzah!

  • @roddammit5510
    @roddammit5510 Год назад

    Thank you

  • @alanjameson8664
    @alanjameson8664 Год назад

    Aethelrud Unrud was not unready, he was uncouncilled, just as chicken pox has nothing to do with poultry, and everything to do with its intense itching.

  • @DallingerM
    @DallingerM Год назад +1

    Ooooooh ... I’m from the Wirral 🙌🏽 not often we get some recognition

  • @michaelsinger4638
    @michaelsinger4638 Год назад +1

    Athelstan is an underrated ruler.

  • @tituslaird1265
    @tituslaird1265 Год назад

    Comment for algorithm, thanks for making history fun and exciting!

  • @YoreHistory
    @YoreHistory Год назад

    Another great video! Cheers.

  • @gw7624
    @gw7624 8 месяцев назад

    Aethelwulf... man, what a name.

  • @1bert719
    @1bert719 2 месяца назад

    Cause of siblings death? "Got in my way!" 😉

  • @MrDawnRise
    @MrDawnRise Год назад +1

    Is the Masteworks CD not a scam?

  • @matty7788
    @matty7788 4 месяца назад

    Kinda ironic the battle happened near a place where we say "scouse not English"

  • @brokenbridge6316
    @brokenbridge6316 Год назад +1

    An old history teacher of mine once said that God is an Englishmen. And I can't help but think he's got a point.

    • @Jack-xg1kg
      @Jack-xg1kg Год назад +1

      Our history is fascinating and I've loved learning about it all my life. That said, I think learning more world history helps put us in perspective. Compared with what else was going on in the world during this period, England was a relative backwater and our battles little more than squabbles between petty warlords. England's period of real significance is relatively modern and unfortunately fading fast already.

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Год назад

      @@Jack-xg1kg---I agree with you about perspective. That's important.

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Год назад

      @Anglo_Stokie_Lad22---You do realize that I admitted that he had a point right?

  • @LAH92
    @LAH92 9 месяцев назад

    I've read that the battle actually took place South Yorkshire, South of York and about 10miles north Of Doncaster at Robin Hoods well 🤔

  • @jackgreen1698
    @jackgreen1698 11 месяцев назад

    An excellent video

  • @alynwillams4297
    @alynwillams4297 9 месяцев назад +1

    A battle the Britons in Wales and the Britons in Cornwall made a wise choice to stay out of. Otherwise they could have ended up like hen ogledd.

    • @CorinneDunbar-ls3ej
      @CorinneDunbar-ls3ej 8 месяцев назад

      The Old North didn't last, sadly, but Cumbria survived for some time.

  • @db123OG
    @db123OG Год назад

    Best content on here

  • @philb7851
    @philb7851 11 месяцев назад +1

    Uhtred was there 😉

  • @Redsauce101
    @Redsauce101 Год назад +3

    More videos on the great migration period, plz. 😁

  • @JamesJohnson-l6y
    @JamesJohnson-l6y 7 месяцев назад

    Alfred the Great's passing happened on 10/26/899. Read the Episcopal Saints feasts.

  • @Nicholas-p6m
    @Nicholas-p6m Год назад

    I love the early Anglo Saxon kings

  • @Funeeman
    @Funeeman 10 месяцев назад

    King Athelstan The Great 💪

  • @Coastcrawler
    @Coastcrawler Год назад +2

    Again an awesome video, perfectly presented and narrated. Thank you. And it reminds me that I once lost two empty halves of coconut somewhere in mercia.

  • @pitel2901
    @pitel2901 Год назад

    Hello, can you also cover tge battle of the Vistula basin? Also great video!

  • @wilfredjurassicyes
    @wilfredjurassicyes Год назад

    I really hope that dude that made carthage bellium makes another game for this era!

  • @TheIronChancellor
    @TheIronChancellor Год назад +1

    When will the next basil the bulgarslayer episode release?

  • @emadbagheri
    @emadbagheri Год назад +2

    is there a reason why there is absolutely no continuity with regards to era and date when these are made? Why this jumping around from century to century rather than a clear narrative?

  • @Ealdorman_of_Mercia
    @Ealdorman_of_Mercia Год назад

    10:29 I thought vikings/norsemen never wore those silly horned helmets.. and that it was a misconception even used today in cartoons and movies?

  • @voiceofreason2674
    @voiceofreason2674 Год назад +1

    One of the many heroes of the "Arthurian Dilemma" which is the prime question of the British Dark Age. If there is to be a High King of the island, he must be able to put an end to ALL foreign raiding. William the Conqueror ends this age in 1066, and I don't think Britain has ever been invaded again except for a few french incursions endorsed by the Scottish

    • @Jack-xg1kg
      @Jack-xg1kg Год назад

      I think a good case could be made for the Glorious Revolution of 1688 as the last time Britain was successfully invaded. The army that installed William and Mary was Dutch, achieving victory over the unpopular English king with English and Irish troops. We just don't think of it as an invasion because that old saw about history being written by the victors is true.

    • @adventussaxonum448
      @adventussaxonum448 Год назад +2

      ​@@Jack-xg1kg
      An army which was invited over, contained many English and was supported along the way by a huge number of locals, isn't quite the same as the Bastard's invasion.

    • @Jack-xg1kg
      @Jack-xg1kg Год назад

      @adventussaxonum448 The same, no. Still an invasion though. The 20k men who landed were nearly all Dutch men; the numbers of English present in the army would've been low hundreds. Elements of domestic collusion don't stop something being an invasion when the main force that affects change is foreign. A foreign army landed on our shores and was resisted by the official govt, at the time. There were interesting circumstances to it but it was still pretty much a text book invasion.

    • @duncancarmichael3723
      @duncancarmichael3723 Год назад

      Mary was a Stuart and the eldest daughter of James ii & vii. William despite his Dutch credentials was a cousin of hers, decended from Charles the first, I think.
      As for the battle, Athelstan appears to be lauded as a hero. He is a man who was motivated to conquer his neighbouring states, irrespective whether he had any legitimate rights to do so.
      His behaviour was in line with the Romans and in later years the Norman's.
      The battle was a fight between the Saxon expansionists and the rest of the people who represented the interests of the areas of Britain, which had not been or did not wish to be subjecated by a foreign influence.
      Which I would argue was their right.
      The battle was bloody with huge losses on both sides. It has been argued that Athelstan won the fight, however it was a hollow victory as he sustained heavy losses that made it impossible for him to follow up the victory with further battles or attempts at any further expansionism into his opponents territories.
      I would argue the due to his failure to progress further he did not define the English border and that it was the Scottish, Irish and Norse forces who were the ones that through their actions defined their territories and denied Athelstan his dream.

  • @Nwunchuck27
    @Nwunchuck27 Год назад +1

    damn, seems that his stability corresponded to his several sisters 😂

  • @molybdaen11
    @molybdaen11 Год назад +1

    Ethelstan mastered the intrige skilltree for sure.

  • @DaniboyBR2
    @DaniboyBR2 Год назад

    The way the ads are done, I tune off from the video when they come up right after the intro, I go do something else, and I just realize the video played after it ends and I didn't watch it.

  • @Nasir_Ashiq
    @Nasir_Ashiq Год назад +1

    Hy sir which software used for vedio editing

  • @Blackmoon9u9
    @Blackmoon9u9 Год назад

    England history is a series of mysterious accidents 🎉

  • @aidenyeskie4841
    @aidenyeskie4841 Год назад

    How do you make these cool videos

  • @David-j9h9g
    @David-j9h9g 11 месяцев назад

    have u done a vid about the massacre of the danes by Aethelstan?

  • @debdeepdas8034
    @debdeepdas8034 Год назад

    When will there be a new episode of War of the Spanish Succession? Waiting eagerly

  • @TheJoker-fv7ez
    @TheJoker-fv7ez Год назад +9

    Most people don't realise, this is the most pivotal battle in English/British history!
    If this battle was lost, there would have been no England, no England means no United Kingdom, the world's history would have been totally different too, because it means no Great Britain.
    I grew up In Bromborough and this battle field has never been found, some historians don't believe the battle took place on the Wirral, whoever finds this battle field will go down in the history books!

    • @malehumanperson7901
      @malehumanperson7901 Год назад +1

      It's meant to be on Brackenwood golf course.

    • @nss309
      @nss309 Год назад

      Debatable.

    • @Jack-xg1kg
      @Jack-xg1kg Год назад +1

      It is and isn't. If we just look at what followed it then yes it is tremendously significant. I think though that the rough borders of the countries on this island were pretty inevitable. A nation like England would always have been formed and achieved domination over its immediate neighbours.
      Consider the geography of our island. England is basically 95% of the good farming land with most of the navigable rivers and good tradeports - it was always going to be the area that supported the densest population, with the power and wealth that comes with it. Whilst the areas of land of that make up Wales and Scotland were comparatively poorer, less desirable as farm land and further from continental trade partners; combined with terrain that made them more defensible and harder for a more distant ruler (one based in the wealthier regions of the Isle) to hold without significant expense.

    • @TheJoker-fv7ez
      @TheJoker-fv7ez Год назад +1

      @@Jack-xg1kg thank you for your comment, now you've put it like that I can see and understand your point of view, and I agree. Thanks again

    • @TheJoker-fv7ez
      @TheJoker-fv7ez Год назад

      @@malehumanperson7901 I have heard this rumour myself and felt like sneaking on with my metal detector ha, then I think the gold course has had so much work completed on it that if the battle was there we have found evidence by now. Thanks for your comment

  • @jamesdeguara7736
    @jamesdeguara7736 Год назад

    I'm quite disappointed that you missed out the involvement of the Lords of Mann, otherwise very good.

  • @bobfunkhouse8437
    @bobfunkhouse8437 Год назад +2

    they think this happened in the fields near the back off my house

  • @TractorDog
    @TractorDog 9 месяцев назад

    long live the algorithm

  • @duck1t
    @duck1t Год назад

    Athelstan chose intrigue archetype in crusader kings i see