@@thebutzel9752there is a 3rd. Ashla is a Togruta youngling. She was in the classroom with Yoda when obiwan came to talk about how he couldn’t find Kamino
2:28 Pente speaking POSITIVELY about Ki adi Mundi? This really IS the spooky month! What if Rako Hardeen killed Anakin? What if Ahsoka won the Dark Saber in combat?
Yo that last idea could be pretty funny. She has no idea what the heck she is doing and doesn’t understand mandalorian politics so she goes to the students who she helped for advice.
- What if Anakin drank from the Font of Power and/or bathed in the Pool of Knowledge like Abeloth did? - What if Vader returned with Thrawn to Lothal? / What if Thrawn won the Battle of Lothal? - What if the Clone Wars were brought to Earth? (Cold War era or modern day Earth) - How would nuclear weapons play into it, if at all? - How would countries align? (Ex. NATO x Republic) - What if Anakin was secretly the template for the Clone Army?
What if Anakin wasn't the only vergence in the force? Not as in "What if Anakin had a sibling" but something more widespread. The experiment had a far greater impact than Plagueis and Sidious expected, leading to a batch of "chosen ones" being born all across the galaxy
Interesting. If I had to guess, probably Palpatine's manipulations towards female Anakin would be that the Jedi are going to take her children from her by force after birth, and that they "would be willing to kill anyone who gets in their way, such as your husband." Assuming Palpatine is behind Anakin's nightmares, then this scenario likely has female Anakin having nightmares of male Padme dying at the hands of Jedi while trying to protect the baby(s). I also wouldn't be surprised (given female Anakin likely would trust her father/uncle figure Palpatine with knowledge that she's pregnant) if Palpatine added the manipulation that the Jedi would kick Anakin out of the Jedi Order if they figure out that female Anakin is pregnant, which is far more likely given...you know...they're Jedi and can sense things and all.
@@JediMasterZimi mean the jedi would know female anakin would be pregnant especially when she doesnt show up/participate in a lot of battles late in pregnancy. i feel like obi-wan would put two and two together and be one of the few jedi trusted in the secret and keep it safe so to speak. i hope this makes sense.
Now this is going to be interesting, and I'm quite curious to see where Pente Patrol goes with this. I did see the idea suggested for some fanfic, like, forever ago, but it was only a brief thing and wasn't explored much. I'm fascinated to see where and how Pente Patrol takes this.
It's an interesting story, it's not like what many people have told before. I was a little sorry that Shaak Ti didn't tell Ahsoka who she was. Thank you very much anyway, I've been waiting for this "What if... story" for a very long time
This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see Shaak Ti being Ahsoka’s mother getting shown some love. This is definitely an interesting scenario and it should definitely get shown some more love. Plus I think we can all agree that this is probably one of the most interesting/unique scenarios in SW…but it’s a welcome one. Also if Shaak Ti was Ahsoka’s mom…then it would definitely be an interesting opportunity to show another side of her character and make it even more interesting. It was also nice to see Shaak Ti having a strong bond with Ahsoka getting shown some love, since she usually never gets the chance to have this connection to people like this that much or to do more crazy stunts like this (more so than usual) and it was a nice change of pace to see her take the initiative and definitely made us all impressed. Plus it was nice to see Ahsoka get that opportunity to be a strong leader and being guided by Shaak Ti as well as having a role in aiding to help prevent certain events from happening…afterall it was nice to see her have a solid plan, afterall this was probably the smartest course of action she could take, so it was nice to see her come up with this plan to shift the power balance of the galaxy, since she knows that there’s still opportunity and hope in the galaxy. Also it’s always nice to see just how determined Shaak Ti truly is…also this was definitely something Shaak Ti would do. Also I think Shaak Ti would be an amazing mother to Ahsoka and Ahsoka being Shaak Ti’s daughter…it just makes sense. It was also nice to see Shaak Ti being involved heavily in amazing stories like these. Shaak Ti is one of my favourite Jedi from SW since she just has such a calm, gentle and motherly presence…so it’s nice to see you involve her in an amazing ‘what if’ story like this. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s
Honestly with this What If, I hope the exposure gives people more ideas. I'd love to read this long form and with more elements. Like an entire multi chapter. One with this, and maybe one where the Bond between Shaak Ti and Ahsoka becomes so close for Shaak Ti, it is an Attachment, which leads to her deciding to tell the Truth to her. Maybe even pair this all with Luminara and Barriss.
There was a really good fanfiction about Shaak Ti being Ahsoka's mother I read about a few years back. It takes place immediately after the temple bombing and Ahsoka leaving the order. Shaak Ti feels immense guilt over her departure and confesses to being her mother to the council, and she also temporarily leaves the order to find Ashoka and make sure she's ok. It's a very interesting read, but it's sadly unfinished.
For the Jedi to say don't break the code, they sure know how to break it. Aayla Secura and Kit Fisto getting busy at one point. Anakin with Padme. Ki-Adi-Mundi though he was just a donor. Now Shaak Ti in this what if scenario lol but good video Pente👍🏽👍🏽
Good vid! There was a really good fanfiction about Shaak Ti being Ahsoka's mother I read about a few years back. It takes place immediately after the temple bombing and Ahsoka leaving the order. Shaak Ti feels immense guilt over her departure and not doing anything to defend her innocence and she confesses to being her mother to the council, and she also temporarily leaves the order to find Ashoka and make sure she's ok. It's a very interesting read, but it's sadly unfinished.
I'll remember this fanfiction. I'm still waiting for the sequel. There is also a fanfiction where Shaak Ti intervened and still decided to protect Ahsoka.
Great What If, and I understand that it's about Shaak-Ti and Ahsoka, but with how similarly Anakin and Ahsoka are, all the while their masters work so close with eachother, I think Anakin and Ahsoka should've of had a secret relationship, or at least have been friends.
I would think if Shaak Ti was Ahsoka's mother, Ahsoka would have a skintone that is more red. Ahsoka's skintone has been contextualised as being inherited from Pav-Ti Tano, so an Ahsoka Ti would be a bit redder. More than likely, Ahsoka would also have different face markings too, because if one goes and looks closely at the TotJ episode, Ahsoka's canon markings are Pav-Ti's shape - lines framing the centre of her forehead - cast in Nak-Il's style - straight lines and angles. Maybe whoever Shaak slept with would cast an interesting pattern on Shaak's white eye-patches, maybe lightening up Shaak's red a bit.
Day 85 of asking for one of these ideas. 1. What if Jyn Erso survived and went onto fall in love with Luke Skywalker? 2. What if The Sith returned during the High Republic era? 3. What if cal and Merrin had a daughter? 4. What if Bo-Katan and Din Djaran fell in love? 5. What if the Jedi didn't forbit attachments? 6. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the galactic civil war? 7. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the First Order-Resistance war? 8. What if Kylo Ren never destroyed Luke's Jedi order? 9: what if Omega was force sensitive? 10: what if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the Clone wars.
Well I think they hinted to the fact that Omega is *slightly* force sensitive in Bad Batch but probably not to the extent of Jedi, which is prolly where your scenario comes in and changes that
@@slayermcrx7519 yeah. Like she is literally a fully cloned Jedi. Or like a clone of Palpatine. I would say for that scenario have the first hint come during the episode with Gungi. Nothing much. Just show her have a slight force connection. But then wait until a point in season three possibly during the escape or the episode after that where she uses the force with a Force push to protect crosshair.
@@KingKindred 8 would be a pretty big change. Rey would actually be taught at the Jedi temple. Plus it would be nice to see if the Republic would bring in the Jedi to deal with the First Order.
Little Kid me always assumed that. It would be a cute dynamic. I still chuckle at an art piece someone online of the two interacting, where Ahsoka feels a bit of jealousy over Shaak Ti having such long Lekku.
When I listened to the beginning of this, what if and they got to the part where attachment baby ahsoka and shaak ti with her Not wanting to form that attachment It reminded me of a fanfiction i read. It's a what if scenario of ahsoka Took care of Luke and Leia And it Dived into the psychology of the mother and baby Attachments they form And in star wars it would be It would be more powerful and a lot stronger Ahsoka rejected it, but She eventually gave in because they needed it. And especially now with a dark galaxy, they were born into They couldn't have that attachment or love with padme because she was gone, so ahsoka made the choice to build that bond vader calls her out on that. Eventually, when he tries to bond with them
15:43 he said the thing! What if Ventress killed Barriss Offee and un-framed Ahsoka for the temple bombing? At first she’s only out for revenge after getting bonked on the head by a metal pole and having her stuff stolen, but then she realises what’s actually going on and helps Ahsoka more altruistically than before. What if Ahsoka died during the Clone Wars but Anakin subconsciously created a Force projection of her and doesn’t realise she’s not really there? A bit like WandaVision but without the mind control/illusion part, just Anakin slowly coming to terms with what actually happened. What if Ezra Bridger pulled Darth Vader into the world between worlds instead of Ahsoka? What if Ezra saved Kanan Jarrus and back to the future-d himself out of existence? What if Tup’s chip failure triggered order 99 instead of order 66? What if an overworked, overtired Kaminoan intern was working on the inhibitor chip code late one night and made a mistake, so “execute order 66” activated orders 60 and 6 instead? I do a lot of coding for my job and it’s entirely feasible for this to happen if you make just the right (or wrong?) mistake, plus order 6 is “destroy all communications” IIRC so Palpatine can’t do a thing about it as the wheels come off his grand plan.
Damn, I think my comment got deleted. Okay, short version it is. Love the dynamic between Shaak Ti and Ahsoka, and that Shaak Ti had to struggle and grow to pull this out while remaining true to the Code. Did not expect everything to derail so much just because of a Jedi having a kid (does that mean Syfo was right?), but loved having Yaddle and Silman survive and that Bail became Chancellor; shame the Clones didn't get to exist, it's always sad when that happens, no matter if it benefits the Galaxy. Seeing Palpatine fail so miserably was truly an enjoyable treat. He really earned the title Darth Sidious the Unwise in this timeline. This time I'm adding two to cheer myself over the lost comment: What if after the Vote of No Confidence on Valorum, instead of Palpatine the one who became Chancellor was Mina Bonteri? What if, instead of slaves from Tatooine, Shmi and Anakin were Togrutas from Shili?
As we know darth vader was a natural engineer and could use mechaguru or whatever so what if he used skill to create nanobots to repair his lungs and burns while also making limbs that could conduct the force to make lightning. This could relate to inquisitor baris as she used nanobots in the bomb and he may remember nanobots and their uses. He could could also conduct experiments diguised as torture to fool sidious, learning to heal wounds, make force sensitive droids/limbs and using nano bots to manipulate mididclorians to strip or enhance the force in individuals. What I was thinking was that he used nanobots to remove scar tissue especially around the lungs and he would be dipped in bacta or bacta would be applied this would allow him breath which means he can meditate more deeply. And for the limbs, it is possible to make material force sensitive and I was thinking he make limbs skeletal looking like in attack of the clones but would then cover the we either grafed flesh from his body or flesh made from his blood and other ingredients like perhaps kyber crystal this would make the force flow from him easier and perhaps with the sith alchemy in the limbs making his force lightning more powerful. Basically an uber vader who is perhaps stronger than full potential anakin.
I'm glad you made this I always felt that Ti was Ashoka's REAL mother and she just gave her up to friends to pretend she was part of another tribe. But in my fan fic Mace Windu is the father. Also Yoda Yaddle and Groku are a family obviously, some times the most simple answer is the truth. Yeah like you have these mysterious Elf beings all in the same order at the SAME TIME they all look alike but sonehow it's just a coincidence? YEAH RIGHT sure it is right. 😅
Keep having this idea where an alt jedi order teaches better control and use of emotions, and instead of going out to "take" infants for the order, though they still do that, they have more freedom to go out and "get some strange". One night stands perfectly fine in the order.
A very good what if shame Shaak ti never told Ahsoka but your reasons make sense. What if Shaak Ti left the order with Ahsoka? What if Deathwatch killed Dooku? What if Ahsoka stayed on Mandalore after defeating maul? What if Shaak ti was made the Grandmaster of the Jedi order? What if Ahsoka won the Darksaber and lead Deathwatch? What if Cal kestis and Ahsoka were a Dyad in the force? What if the temple bombing never happened? What if Obi wan and Satine had a son? What if legends Luke Jedi order was pulled through time back to the clone wars?
Okay, Now I kinda want to see that Top one a bunch. So many combos. Main Clone Wars Timeline where Ahsoka and Shaak Ti leave together, and one with this what If. Maybe paired with a Barriss and Luminara one. Perhaps the idea that her own Daughter would Potentially be executed does strike an Extreme nerve in her. Adds a Greater sense of Horror for either Masters as well, with ones' Daughter almost being Killed, and anothers' Turning Terrorist.
@@Xylospring Ohh definitely it has lots of potential and with how good the what if Plo and Anakin leave the order with Ahsoka and what if Obi wan and Anakin left the order with Ahsoka. I say this has some very good potential. Ohhh definitely I’m very positive those maternity instincts are gonna be roaring and Shaak Ti ain’t gonna be able to hold them back.
I'd like to see some additions to what ifs with bits of diffeences even woth them for pivotal parts, like here for what if Shaak Ti did tell the truth, and on if She did develop attachment to Ahsola and when.
Come to think of it...Okay, there is too much fun to be had with this idea. Potentially one that also has Luminara and Barriss as Mother and daughter, and for one that follows the main Clone Wars Timeline moreso, but with this element in the background.
What if the jedi never left thaython ( the story can be the same up to the first clone wars movie just that jedi never move to the republic capital planet and stayed on thaython which the temple is bigger and the jedi have a whole planet to themselves which means more members a limit of 20 or 30k would be good they also made sure to remove the planet from the Galatic map so no surprises attacks ever happen on them and all visitors are strip of any tech so that they arent trace back ) thaython would be a cool planet because its a force planet and it also means that its easier for the jedi to train on and have a better connection then Corasant
What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis. Also what if Anakin feel in love with mon montha
Not throwing shade here, but I watch several SW What If channels and I love how every one of them is like “If literally anything was different in the timeline the Jedi would have won” 😂
Sometimes Timelines can be like that. Just something as small as a tiny thing can cause ripples in any event. Andrew Jackson, a Former President of the US was almost killed Twice. The assassins' Guns, both of them, Jammed. That is a "What if BOTH Guns Jammed" What if Scenario in our reality. Come to think of it, that Luck is so insane it's stupid.
here’s my belief the no attachments rule is silly. If you are sentient, you will become attached to other sentient lifeforms. now, one thing I actually do believe is parents shouldn’t be the one who trains the student in the ways of the Jedi, because the inevitable attachment might hinder the students ability to learn how in the real world I think it’s a bad idea to have your child be a part of your class so when you throw in the craziness of the Star Wars universe I think it makes that point even more important
Where was anakin? While I understand it wasn’t all about him he would kinda be a presence in the temple I think it’d be funny if him and Ahsoka were trouble makers together 😂
What if anakin was found by jedi belonging to another sect like corelia or those nomadic jedi who allow attachment. What if anakin went to dathomir in revenge of the sith to search for ways to save padme. What if yoda decided to swap the masters of ferus olin and anakin. So anakin with siri. Obi with ferus What if ahsoka and anakin crash landed on bendu's planet. Also what if darth vader joined thrawn in meeting the bendu and went on a spiritual journey back to the dust ball tatiotene. What if the whills turned padme into a literal force angel to save vader.
What if anakin spirit in the world between worlds saved padme by making her a force ghost or new mother if the ones. She could make him help ben solo and others saying you got to help people who are suffering from your past actions. What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.
Hi Pent Patrol, please let us know when you will be releasing What If the Sith Empire Returned During the Clone Wars Season 3? I know in the last discussion you had stated that you had completed six episodes of season 3 and was hoping that you have completed more. Thank you.
Anakin should get elected chancellor after a vote of no confidence. All of Palpatine’s propaganda works a little too well. In rebels when they go to rescue Luminara Unduli Ezra should find Anakin. Ezra would probably recognise him from old holograms that he watches. Vader could be a clone, it isn’t like Palpatine didn’t have the chance. You’ve done Anakin trains Galen Marek during clone wars. You could have Obi Wan train him next. He’s proven he can handle powerful students.
What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.
So an up and coming cult member has a child, then gives that child to the cult, before abandoning both for a time. Then she returns to the cult, and becomes one of it's leaders. She then develops a deceitful relationship with her abandoned daughter. This is supposed to be a good thing? The more I learn about the Jedi, the more I agree with Darth Vader. The Jedi Order needs a permanent dirt nap.
Anyway love your videos probably the best what ifs for story. My favourites being: What if padme died anyway if anakin stayed light. What if sideous abadoned anakin. The original vader upgrading his suit. Basically I love your stories of anakin hitting his lowest point that the only way is up.
What if vader healed himself (after finding out palpatine uses slavery) to overthrow sidious and reform the empire to an effective government eradicating slavery and corruption instead of palpatine empire of ego and sadistic pleasures.
While a nice story this pretty much has no actual connection to Ahsoka at at all We came here for an emotional story and not "Everything works in the background"!
Day 8: what if all the jedi knights and masters with their padawans went to geonosis with both palpatine and dooku and have them all go back in time to the old Republic era during the sith wars before most the jedi who do die on geonosis die in the original timeline but withpalpatine and dooku separate from the jedi so dooki never told obi wan about the sith because palpatine was there
What if someone-just a random person in some encounter-used an electric taser on Darth Vader and it caused his suit to malfunction and kill him? (I'll let you decide when would be either the most consequential or just funniest point in the timeline for it to happen).
Come to Think of it...If George and Filoni wanted to, they could even just make this a thing back then, and the lack of interaction would even work with the Jedi being bad at Psychology. Could even be viewed through purposeful Detachment.
Meh No reveal of mother-daughter, was a lil disappointing. And much of the story covered to cause an effect of Ti’s choice to have a child over all. Not bad … 6.5/10
I wish Shaak Ti and Ahsoka did interact with each other during the Clone Wars.
Agreed, doesn’t make a lot of sense the only two Togruta Jedi we see on screen during this time just… never talk to each other
@@thebutzel9752there is a 3rd. Ashla is a Togruta youngling. She was in the classroom with Yoda when obiwan came to talk about how he couldn’t find Kamino
Am I the only one disappointed that Ahsoka didn’t have any interactions with Shaak Ti?
To be honest I half expected it considering that they are of the same race so there was always that connection
Well, now this gives my brain a small worm in it thinking about Luminara and Barriss being Mother and Daughter as well.
That as well as now wondering different variations for what if Shaak Ti told Ahsoka the truth, and did start to form an attachment, and when.
“No Ahsoka…I am your mother!”
“No, that’s IMPOSSIBLE!”
@@Achuidian179 "NOOOOO- actually that might be a good thing."
”Search your feelings, you know it to be true.”
Nooooooooo-wait that makes sense
@@sebastianahlin9677 Still have no idea what that line was supposed to mean. They should have worded that better.
2:28 Pente speaking POSITIVELY about Ki adi Mundi?
This really IS the spooky month!
What if Rako Hardeen killed Anakin?
What if Ahsoka won the Dark Saber in combat?
Yo that last idea could be pretty funny. She has no idea what the heck she is doing and doesn’t understand mandalorian politics so she goes to the students who she helped for advice.
one jedi gets laid and has a kid, and avoids a war that would have cost billions of lives......The jedi need to rewrite their code.
Very much so.
@@blarg987665 Exactly.
Shaak Ti to Ahsoka: I am your mother.
Darth Vader to Luke: I am your father.
"It's like poetry, it rhymes."
Obi wan “I am your dad”
Korgi “I know”
I love Shaak Ti being Ahsoka's mom. I did like the Sith getting destroyed
A GREAT STORY AGAIN! I can see why not REVIELING herself as Ahsoka's mother was the right thing in the end.
i so happy you made this. literally my favoite what if in all of star wars
- What if Anakin drank from the Font of Power and/or bathed in the Pool of Knowledge like Abeloth did?
- What if Vader returned with Thrawn to Lothal? / What if Thrawn won the Battle of Lothal?
- What if the Clone Wars were brought to Earth? (Cold War era or modern day Earth)
- How would nuclear weapons play into it, if at all?
- How would countries align? (Ex. NATO x Republic)
- What if Anakin was secretly the template for the Clone Army?
What if after the Phantom Menace, Jango Fett freed Shmi Skywalker instead of Cliegg Lars freeing Shmi?
What if Anakin wasn't the only vergence in the force? Not as in "What if Anakin had a sibling" but something more widespread. The experiment had a far greater impact than Plagueis and Sidious expected, leading to a batch of "chosen ones" being born all across the galaxy
What if Anakin Skywalker was born a girl and Padme Amidala a boy?
How would *Revenge Of The Sith* change in this scenario?
Yesss I love this
Interesting. If I had to guess, probably Palpatine's manipulations towards female Anakin would be that the Jedi are going to take her children from her by force after birth, and that they "would be willing to kill anyone who gets in their way, such as your husband." Assuming Palpatine is behind Anakin's nightmares, then this scenario likely has female Anakin having nightmares of male Padme dying at the hands of Jedi while trying to protect the baby(s). I also wouldn't be surprised (given female Anakin likely would trust her father/uncle figure Palpatine with knowledge that she's pregnant) if Palpatine added the manipulation that the Jedi would kick Anakin out of the Jedi Order if they figure out that female Anakin is pregnant, which is far more likely given...you know...they're Jedi and can sense things and all.
The entire star wars galaxy gender Swap
@@JediMasterZimi mean the jedi would know female anakin would be pregnant especially when she doesnt show up/participate in a lot of battles late in pregnancy.
i feel like obi-wan would put two and two together and be one of the few jedi trusted in the secret and keep it safe so to speak.
i hope this makes sense.
@@Leonardo-cw1dd Agreed. Female Anakin would not be able to hide. Obi Wan Kenobi is the only hope.
Now this is going to be interesting, and I'm quite curious to see where Pente Patrol goes with this. I did see the idea suggested for some fanfic, like, forever ago, but it was only a brief thing and wasn't explored much. I'm fascinated to see where and how Pente Patrol takes this.
It's an interesting story, it's not like what many people have told before. I was a little sorry that Shaak Ti didn't tell Ahsoka who she was. Thank you very much anyway, I've been waiting for this "What if... story" for a very long time
This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see Shaak Ti being Ahsoka’s mother getting shown some love. This is definitely an interesting scenario and it should definitely get shown some more love. Plus I think we can all agree that this is probably one of the most interesting/unique scenarios in SW…but it’s a welcome one. Also if Shaak Ti was Ahsoka’s mom…then it would definitely be an interesting opportunity to show another side of her character and make it even more interesting. It was also nice to see Shaak Ti having a strong bond with Ahsoka getting shown some love, since she usually never gets the chance to have this connection to people like this that much or to do more crazy stunts like this (more so than usual) and it was a nice change of pace to see her take the initiative and definitely made us all impressed. Plus it was nice to see Ahsoka get that opportunity to be a strong leader and being guided by Shaak Ti as well as having a role in aiding to help prevent certain events from happening…afterall it was nice to see her have a solid plan, afterall this was probably the smartest course of action she could take, so it was nice to see her come up with this plan to shift the power balance of the galaxy, since she knows that there’s still opportunity and hope in the galaxy. Also it’s always nice to see just how determined Shaak Ti truly is…also this was definitely something Shaak Ti would do. Also I think Shaak Ti would be an amazing mother to Ahsoka and Ahsoka being Shaak Ti’s daughter…it just makes sense. It was also nice to see Shaak Ti being involved heavily in amazing stories like these. Shaak Ti is one of my favourite Jedi from SW since she just has such a calm, gentle and motherly presence…so it’s nice to see you involve her in an amazing ‘what if’ story like this. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next.
I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s:
1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling.
2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever.
3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this.
4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st)
I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s
Honestly with this What If, I hope the exposure gives people more ideas. I'd love to read this long form and with more elements. Like an entire multi chapter. One with this, and maybe one where the Bond between Shaak Ti and Ahsoka becomes so close for Shaak Ti, it is an Attachment, which leads to her deciding to tell the Truth to her.
Maybe even pair this all with Luminara and Barriss.
Interesting idea for a story, I'm surprised at the direction it went! And at the lack of Skywalker.
It would be interesting if Shaak Ti was Ahsoka's mother
I definitely imagine Ashoka being rebellious more then usual
There was a really good fanfiction about Shaak Ti being Ahsoka's mother I read about a few years back. It takes place immediately after the temple bombing and Ahsoka leaving the order. Shaak Ti feels immense guilt over her departure and confesses to being her mother to the council, and she also temporarily leaves the order to find Ashoka and make sure she's ok. It's a very interesting read, but it's sadly unfinished.
For the Jedi to say don't break the code, they sure know how to break it. Aayla Secura and Kit Fisto getting busy at one point. Anakin with Padme. Ki-Adi-Mundi though he was just a donor. Now Shaak Ti in this what if scenario lol but good video Pente👍🏽👍🏽
I kinda wanna see a What If using all of these and placing them in some way together.
Good vid! There was a really good fanfiction about Shaak Ti being Ahsoka's mother I read about a few years back. It takes place immediately after the temple bombing and Ahsoka leaving the order. Shaak Ti feels immense guilt over her departure and not doing anything to defend her innocence and she confesses to being her mother to the council, and she also temporarily leaves the order to find Ashoka and make sure she's ok. It's a very interesting read, but it's sadly unfinished.
I'll remember this fanfiction. I'm still waiting for the sequel. There is also a fanfiction where Shaak Ti intervened and still decided to protect Ahsoka.
Great What If, and I understand that it's about Shaak-Ti and Ahsoka, but with how similarly Anakin and Ahsoka are, all the while their masters work so close with eachother, I think Anakin and Ahsoka should've of had a secret relationship, or at least have been friends.
I love all of his videos he makes with the “What If’s”
I would think if Shaak Ti was Ahsoka's mother, Ahsoka would have a skintone that is more red. Ahsoka's skintone has been contextualised as being inherited from Pav-Ti Tano, so an Ahsoka Ti would be a bit redder. More than likely, Ahsoka would also have different face markings too, because if one goes and looks closely at the TotJ episode, Ahsoka's canon markings are Pav-Ti's shape - lines framing the centre of her forehead - cast in Nak-Il's style - straight lines and angles.
Maybe whoever Shaak slept with would cast an interesting pattern on Shaak's white eye-patches, maybe lightening up Shaak's red a bit.
Day 85 of asking for one of these ideas.
1. What if Jyn Erso survived and went onto fall in love with Luke Skywalker?
2. What if The Sith returned during the High Republic era?
3. What if cal and Merrin had a daughter?
4. What if Bo-Katan and Din Djaran fell in love?
5. What if the Jedi didn't forbit attachments?
6. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the galactic civil war?
7. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the First Order-Resistance war?
8. What if Kylo Ren never destroyed Luke's Jedi order?
9: what if Omega was force sensitive?
10: what if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the Clone wars.
1, 4, 5, and 8.
Well I think they hinted to the fact that Omega is *slightly* force sensitive in Bad Batch but probably not to the extent of Jedi, which is prolly where your scenario comes in and changes that
@@slayermcrx7519 yeah. Like she is literally a fully cloned Jedi. Or like a clone of Palpatine.
I would say for that scenario have the first hint come during the episode with Gungi. Nothing much. Just show her have a slight force connection. But then wait until a point in season three possibly during the escape or the episode after that where she uses the force with a Force push to protect crosshair.
@@KingKindred 8 would be a pretty big change. Rey would actually be taught at the Jedi temple. Plus it would be nice to see if the Republic would bring in the Jedi to deal with the First Order.
6, 7 and 10 please 🙏
There is no way anyone will look at them and not assume they were mother and daughter. She looks just like her.
Little Kid me always assumed that. It would be a cute dynamic. I still chuckle at an art piece someone online of the two interacting, where Ahsoka feels a bit of jealousy over Shaak Ti having such long Lekku.
When I listened to the beginning of this, what if and they got to the part where attachment baby ahsoka and shaak ti with her Not wanting to form that attachment
It reminded me of a fanfiction i read. It's a what if scenario of ahsoka Took care of Luke and Leia
And it Dived into the psychology of the mother and baby Attachments they form And in star wars it would be It would be more powerful and a lot stronger
Ahsoka rejected it, but She eventually gave in because they needed it. And especially now with a dark galaxy, they were born into
They couldn't have that attachment or love with padme because she was gone, so ahsoka made the choice to build that bond
vader calls her out on that. Eventually, when he tries to bond with them
15:43 he said the thing!
What if Ventress killed Barriss Offee and un-framed Ahsoka for the temple bombing? At first she’s only out for revenge after getting bonked on the head by a metal pole and having her stuff stolen, but then she realises what’s actually going on and helps Ahsoka more altruistically than before.
What if Ahsoka died during the Clone Wars but Anakin subconsciously created a Force projection of her and doesn’t realise she’s not really there? A bit like WandaVision but without the mind control/illusion part, just Anakin slowly coming to terms with what actually happened.
What if Ezra Bridger pulled Darth Vader into the world between worlds instead of Ahsoka?
What if Ezra saved Kanan Jarrus and back to the future-d himself out of existence?
What if Tup’s chip failure triggered order 99 instead of order 66?
What if an overworked, overtired Kaminoan intern was working on the inhibitor chip code late one night and made a mistake, so “execute order 66” activated orders 60 and 6 instead? I do a lot of coding for my job and it’s entirely feasible for this to happen if you make just the right (or wrong?) mistake, plus order 6 is “destroy all communications” IIRC so Palpatine can’t do a thing about it as the wheels come off his grand plan.
Anakin: no a** kicking? Ah man!
Damn, I think my comment got deleted. Okay, short version it is.
Love the dynamic between Shaak Ti and Ahsoka, and that Shaak Ti had to struggle and grow to pull this out while remaining true to the Code.
Did not expect everything to derail so much just because of a Jedi having a kid (does that mean Syfo was right?), but loved having Yaddle and Silman survive and that Bail became Chancellor; shame the Clones didn't get to exist, it's always sad when that happens, no matter if it benefits the Galaxy.
Seeing Palpatine fail so miserably was truly an enjoyable treat. He really earned the title Darth Sidious the Unwise in this timeline.
This time I'm adding two to cheer myself over the lost comment:
What if after the Vote of No Confidence on Valorum, instead of Palpatine the one who became Chancellor was Mina Bonteri?
What if, instead of slaves from Tatooine, Shmi and Anakin were Togrutas from Shili?
As we know darth vader was a natural engineer and could use mechaguru or whatever so what if he used skill to create nanobots to repair his lungs and burns while also making limbs that could conduct the force to make lightning. This could relate to inquisitor baris as she used nanobots in the bomb and he may remember nanobots and their uses. He could could also conduct experiments diguised as torture to fool sidious, learning to heal wounds, make force sensitive droids/limbs and using nano bots to manipulate mididclorians to strip or enhance the force in individuals.
What I was thinking was that he used nanobots to remove scar tissue especially around the lungs and he would be dipped in bacta or bacta would be applied this would allow him breath which means he can meditate more deeply. And for the limbs, it is possible to make material force sensitive and I was thinking he make limbs skeletal looking like in attack of the clones but would then cover the we either grafed flesh from his body or flesh made from his blood and other ingredients like perhaps kyber crystal this would make the force flow from him easier and perhaps with the sith alchemy in the limbs making his force lightning more powerful. Basically an uber vader who is perhaps stronger than full potential anakin.
Not more
What if Anakin had Wolverine powers and had beskar coated bones
I'm glad you made this I always felt
that Ti was Ashoka's REAL mother
and she just gave her up to friends
to pretend she was part of another tribe.
But in my fan fic Mace Windu
is the father. Also Yoda Yaddle and
Groku are a family obviously, some
times the most simple answer is the truth.
Yeah like you have these mysterious
Elf beings all in the same order at
the SAME TIME they all look alike
but sonehow it's just a coincidence?
YEAH RIGHT sure it is right. 😅
What if Anakin rejected the force?
Roll credits
Keep having this idea where an alt jedi order teaches better control and use of emotions, and instead of going out to "take" infants for the order, though they still do that, they have more freedom to go out and "get some strange". One night stands perfectly fine in the order.
What if Anakin became a shadow jedi
I kinda like this idea. It's a cute one. Like Qui Gon being Anakins' father.
My Comment On Previous Video's Was What If Ahsoka Tano Was The Daughter/Padawan Of Shaak Ti
What if Mother Talzen raised all her children together 😊
A very good what if shame Shaak ti never told Ahsoka but your reasons make sense.
What if Shaak Ti left the order with Ahsoka?
What if Deathwatch killed Dooku?
What if Ahsoka stayed on Mandalore after defeating maul?
What if Shaak ti was made the Grandmaster of the Jedi order?
What if Ahsoka won the Darksaber and lead Deathwatch?
What if Cal kestis and Ahsoka were a Dyad in the force?
What if the temple bombing never happened?
What if Obi wan and Satine had a son?
What if legends Luke Jedi order was pulled through time back to the clone wars?
Okay, Now I kinda want to see that Top one a bunch. So many combos.
Main Clone Wars Timeline where Ahsoka and Shaak Ti leave together, and one with this what If. Maybe paired with a Barriss and Luminara one.
Perhaps the idea that her own Daughter would Potentially be executed does strike an Extreme nerve in her.
Adds a Greater sense of Horror for either Masters as well, with ones' Daughter almost being Killed, and anothers' Turning Terrorist.
@@Xylospring Ohh definitely it has lots of potential and with how good the what if Plo and Anakin leave the order with Ahsoka and what if Obi wan and Anakin left the order with Ahsoka. I say this has some very good potential.
Ohhh definitely I’m very positive those maternity instincts are gonna be roaring and Shaak Ti ain’t gonna be able to hold them back.
I'd like to see some additions to what ifs with bits of diffeences even woth them for pivotal parts, like here for what if Shaak Ti did tell the truth, and on if She did develop attachment to Ahsola and when.
Come to think of it...Okay, there is too much fun to be had with this idea. Potentially one that also has Luminara and Barriss as Mother and daughter, and for one that follows the main Clone Wars Timeline moreso, but with this element in the background.
What if Dooku took over the Sith of the old republic era by being sent back through the world between worlds?
What is Batman went to the Star wars universe
Darth theorist did something like that.
@@77wolfbladeThat was a pretty one.
I feel like he'd just be an overglorified Boba fett
@@krakkenjack I want both to fight
So basically this was what if the jedi discovered the dooku was behind the clone army before they were made
What if Rex convinced Jesse during Order 66?
What if Anakins half brother Owen Lars was secretly force sensitive ?
What if Anakin and Padme had quadruplets?
What if Anakin trained a Nautolan/Kel Dor/Wookie padawan instead of Ashoka/after Ashoka was expelled from the order
Anakin having a Wookie padawan sounds fun.
What if Anakin teleported to the Mel Gibson Mad Max universe and he mistakenly thinks it's tattoine and then realised that it's a different planet
I swear I've seen this what if on a fanfic sight
What if… Ashoka listened to Maul on Mandalore, and used his their bonding to both reform Maul to a degree, and his teaching to become a Grey Jedi.
What if when Qui Gon Jinn found Anakin he was being raised by tuskin raiders
Ngl I thought this when clone wars came out in 2008 for a sec!
What if the jedi never left thaython ( the story can be the same up to the first clone wars movie just that jedi never move to the republic capital planet and stayed on thaython which the temple is bigger and the jedi have a whole planet to themselves which means more members a limit of 20 or 30k would be good they also made sure to remove the planet from the Galatic map so no surprises attacks ever happen on them and all visitors are strip of any tech so that they arent trace back ) thaython would be a cool planet because its a force planet and it also means that its easier for the jedi to train on and have a better connection then Corasant
What if Saesee Tiin trained Anakin?
What if Phoenix Wright: spAce Attorney defended Ahsoka in court
What if their was a droid uprising on both sides of the Clone Wars
What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis. Also what if Anakin feel in love with mon montha
Awww. I wanted a snips freak out.
Not throwing shade here, but I watch several SW What If channels and I love how every one of them is like “If literally anything was different in the timeline the Jedi would have won” 😂
Sometimes Timelines can be like that. Just something as small as a tiny thing can cause ripples in any event.
Andrew Jackson, a Former President of the US was almost killed Twice. The assassins' Guns, both of them, Jammed.
That is a "What if BOTH Guns Jammed" What if Scenario in our reality.
Come to think of it, that Luck is so insane it's stupid.
What if Ashoka become a Mandalorian after the Clone Wars? third try
here’s my belief the no attachments rule is silly. If you are sentient, you will become attached to other sentient lifeforms. now, one thing I actually do believe is parents shouldn’t be the one who trains the student in the ways of the Jedi, because the inevitable attachment might hinder the students ability to learn how in the real world I think it’s a bad idea to have your child be a part of your class so when you throw in the craziness of the Star Wars universe I think it makes that point even more important
"With a side of wholesome PP"
Please rephrase that
What if half the jedi sided with Dooku?
This is truly Star Peace
What if Bode never betrayed Cal, Cere and Eno Cordova?
What if Anakin stopped for a bagel before going to Mustafar, and Padme arrived first 😂😂😂
Where was anakin? While I understand it wasn’t all about him he would kinda be a presence in the temple I think it’d be funny if him and Ahsoka were trouble makers together 😂
What if Anakin wasn’t force sensitive, but was still the chosen one?
What if anakin was found by jedi belonging to another sect like corelia or those nomadic jedi who allow attachment.
What if anakin went to dathomir in revenge of the sith to search for ways to save padme.
What if yoda decided to swap the masters of ferus olin and anakin.
So anakin with siri.
Obi with ferus
What if ahsoka and anakin crash landed on bendu's planet. Also what if darth vader joined thrawn in meeting the bendu and went on a spiritual journey back to the dust ball tatiotene.
What if the whills turned padme into a literal force angel to save vader.
What if shar koon was plo koons daughter instead of his neice
More Revan stories please 🙏
What if anakin was a jedi shadow
What if anakin spirit in the world between worlds saved padme by making her a force ghost or new mother if the ones. She could make him help ben solo and others saying you got to help people who are suffering from your past actions.
What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories.
Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself.
What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder.
What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia.
What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance.
What if oppo rancis trained anakin.
What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death.
What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings.
What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin.
Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.
I actually read a fanfiction of this kind of scenario.
This Video Is One My Ideas Which I Have Said Before On Past Video's
something I would have thought of when I was 12
Now I'm curious.
Can you do what if the sith empire came to the age of the galactic empire series
you have probleny mentioned this before but when are you going to continue TSCW
Hi Pent Patrol, please let us know when you will be releasing What If the Sith Empire Returned During the Clone Wars Season 3? I know in the last discussion you had stated that you had completed six episodes of season 3 and was hoping that you have completed more. Thank you.
Now you peaked my interest
Gihachad Ti and yaddle being girlboss gigachads
Day 3: What if Maul joined the Jedi after a Phantom Menace
If Ahsoka meets Galen Marek in this timeline
Anyone got any popcorn?
Anakin should get elected chancellor after a vote of no confidence. All of Palpatine’s propaganda works a little too well.
In rebels when they go to rescue Luminara Unduli Ezra should find Anakin. Ezra would probably recognise him from old holograms that he watches. Vader could be a clone, it isn’t like Palpatine didn’t have the chance.
You’ve done Anakin trains Galen Marek during clone wars. You could have Obi Wan train him next. He’s proven he can handle powerful students.
What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers.
Resurrect talzin maybe.
what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave.
What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan.
What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.
So an up and coming cult member has a child, then gives that child to the cult, before abandoning both for a time. Then she returns to the cult, and becomes one of it's leaders. She then develops a deceitful relationship with her abandoned daughter. This is supposed to be a good thing?
The more I learn about the Jedi, the more I agree with Darth Vader. The Jedi Order needs a permanent dirt nap.
Anyway love your videos probably the best what ifs for story. My favourites being:
What if padme died anyway if anakin stayed light.
What if sideous abadoned anakin.
The original vader upgrading his suit. Basically I love your stories of anakin hitting his lowest point that the only way is up.
Yeah, those were all bangers, but then again most of his vids are. Pente Patrol does amazing work and is pretty consistent about it.
Hello you’re the best
FE!N FE!N FE!N
What if vader healed himself (after finding out palpatine uses slavery) to overthrow sidious and reform the empire to an effective government eradicating slavery and corruption instead of palpatine empire of ego and sadistic pleasures.
what happened to anakin?????
While a nice story this pretty much has no actual connection to Ahsoka at at all
We came here for an emotional story and not "Everything works in the background"!
@@Ushiokoroni A second variant would be much appreciated.
Shaak Ti is hot. Lol
She is indeed. Pretty
Day 8: what if all the jedi knights and masters with their padawans went to geonosis with both palpatine and dooku and have them all go back in time to the old Republic era during the sith wars before most the jedi who do die on geonosis die in the original timeline but withpalpatine and dooku separate from the jedi so dooki never told obi wan about the sith because palpatine was there
Fourth Republic
What if someone-just a random person in some encounter-used an electric taser on Darth Vader and it caused his suit to malfunction and kill him? (I'll let you decide when would be either the most consequential or just funniest point in the timeline for it to happen).
jarjar should do it
Yooo
Can we all agree the Jedi are really bad at Psychology
Yep
Come to Think of it...If George and Filoni wanted to, they could even just make this a thing back then, and the lack of interaction would even work with the Jedi being bad at Psychology.
Could even be viewed through purposeful Detachment.
Meh No reveal of mother-daughter, was a lil disappointing. And much of the story covered to cause an effect of Ti’s choice to have a child over all. Not bad … 6.5/10