Natasha, Liz and Jenny is the better line up in my opinion But I am so totally grateful they made a reunion saying Jenny is always welcomed if she wants to be back in the group again!
Yori Yu Sadly they were talking pish when they said she was welcome back anytime. They are currently touring in New Zealand with bloody Michelle Heaton in the band as a temp for Liz. I'd bet anything Jenny wasn't asked first.
Michelle Heaton from what i've heard is a "decent" filler. Not better than Liz but Certainly better than Kerry/Jenny vocally. If it was just Tash with Kerry and Jenny...Lawd be a fence around her vocal chords..She'd have to carry the entire setlist (even more than she is right now)
Kerry katona is my favourite member of the group and I met Max in sand le mere and preformed in front of me it was amazing part of my life and also hydie I have met in the same and I played with them both
Gotta say even though I have all their CDs and I really I loved them majorly!(really was huge fan) with Natasha being my fav. and then Liz. I just... I wish Jenny was there. I know Kerry was there first but I preferred that line up.
uououo uououo uo uouo uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouozsosw uozemo username on uoxsmozsmzsmo uozsmossmozsosuomosemoswmoz so I am so uouo uouo u uouououuonmuoweuoswuo euo someones uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouozsosw uozemo someoneuo uouo uouououuonmuoweuoswm
uouo now uozsuozsmozsouomoxsuomomoxsuomouomzsuozemozozs uouo uouo uo uo us uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouuozozsuosmozwmossmosuozuozossasmoswuozozsmoxsmououozsmossuoxozsuuozsmozs uouo too uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouuozozsuosmozwmossmosuozuozossasmoswuozozsmoxsmououozsmossuoxozsuuozsmozsmos uouo
Being in the band for far longer does not equate to "original". Original means you're there right from the start, regardless if you left after just one album. Having said that, both Kerry and Jenny were awesome.
I always like how Deborah Harry sings "The tide is high but I'm (short pause) holding on". No one else seems to try to replicate that feature. *Oops! That pause is with the background vocals. It adds a lot of interest.* [Insert embarrassed face here.]
They'd ask Jenny but she had other commitments so she couldn't do the gig at the time Kerry was there first so it's only right they ask her to pop back for the big reunion
The hatred towards Kerry in some comments is unjustified. Kerry participated to this reunion cos Jenny herself had refused to join the girls.Tash and Liz needed the 3d one for the visuals. Let's tell it like it is, Jenny and Kerry can't sing to save their lives, they were lucky to have Natasha doing all the proper good vocals in the group. They were decoration while Natasha was the vocalist that owned every song. She owned this performance too, she's the best and I love her voice. She's the Queen 💙
Kerry came back and the other 2tohappytohave her back. It was the big reunion so it made sense to have the original line up. All this Kerrybashing is totallyunjustifying
Credit when it’s due, when Kerry missed the first line and joined slightly after you could hear her, and it sounded really good. Anyone who says otherwise is just a hater.
Might be an unpopular opinion, but I think that if Kerry never left they could've been as successful as they were with Jenny. I can only totally imagine the music videos of Eternal Flame and You Are with her. I wish she would've looked like how she looks recently for the Big Reunion.
Well theres no denying with Kerry's exposure to worldwide television AFTER AK...Kerry became a bigger name and star than any of the other AK girls combined!
Not to be rude about it but Kerry just didn't have the looks to be in a girl group, and her voice wasn't good enough to make up for it. Bringing her back for a big reunion when the group had it's actual success during the Jenny era was insulting. It would be like a Girls Aloud reunion with Javine replacing Sarah.
I know Kerry Katona is an original member together with Liz but still. The line up with Natasha - Liz - Jenny was the best thing ever. I feel like they should have contacted former Sugababes member Heidi Range since she's also an original/former member of Atomic Kitten.. and not to be rude.. but Heidi looks and sounds better than Kerry
To be honest...Atomic kitten is what Tash needed. Liz is a formidable vocalist in her own right but Liz/Heidi/Kerry vocally was "High/Higher/Highest" They needed a deeper distinct voice like Tash
2 years late to this party but... no, she isn't "prettier" here compared to when they were a hit. she did however age well albeit poor clothing apparel choices *GLares at that ugly ass umbrella skirt thing* Atomic Kitten is the only 90's pop band to stand the test of time. (imho)
Jenny was pregnant when they started filming so she didn't join and they asked Kerry to come back...now Jenny doesn't want to come back because of Kerry.
Honestly, I'm not much into this band, but after looking through the comments, I have an issue with and don't like people who are like "it's not X without Y", etc. It really makes me angry because I don't see what the big deal is. Two out of three isn't bad, or X out of X+1 isn't bad.
can someone please kindly answer a question for me ? are the atomic kitten band actually using autotune and pitch correction in this particular live performance of this song of tide is high ? or are they actually using their own real singing voices they were born with ?
Why did they sing this song? Kerry wasn't even in the band when they released this, Jenny was. They shouldn't have sung a song Kerry wasn't there for :/ Tash sounds fab on this performance though
Kerry wasn't there for most of their songs, she left the group before the first album was even released. If they only did songs she was there for then they wouldn't have enough for a show.
Dani L LOL no need to educate me on AK history, I've been a fan since the beginning. And Kerry was there for the first album, they released it originally with her, then re-released it after Jenny joined. And I get that, it's just kinda annoying to see them act like she was there when they released The Tide Is High xD
Megan O Yeah I realise that now. However most of the world wouldn't even know who Kerry was because the first album to come out internationally (including in my country) was the re recorded version. In fact the first single to release in my country was Whole Again, once again the re recorded music video. I don't think they are trying to act like she was in the group when they recorded that song, it was a huge hit for them and most of their fans would be pretty disappointed if they only sang songs from their first album.
thats cause you werent born in the 90's when this band was around so don't you dare call people who actually know good songs and dont listen to songs that are out now cause the 90's was the best year for music.
Sounds different that Kerry is singing this (no offense to her). I've seen and heard her sing and as part of AK, but Jenny was the one who was recognized by fans as the 1/3 of AK. Kerry was part of AK for 1-2 years but Jenny was there for 4-5 years.
I don’t rate Kerry or Jenny as singers altho K’s verse on ‘Whole Again’ is the better of the 2. But here as a trio and live when they sing together they sound good, even Kerry.
Ꭿmanda Jonεs This was just a one off thing and they haven't started again.. And Kerry was the original Atomic kitten singer and she can sing but it's a very long time since so her voice needs to be trained back again slowly but they didn't have time to do it.. The other 2 never stopped singing so they are fine.. So you judged wrong.
i absolutelty did not judge incorrectly, if you can really sing, no matter how out of shapeyour voice is you will not sound this bad... We have different opinions, just because we disagree doesn't mean either opinion is wrong... we can simply agree to disagree.
Just amazing! Great voices, a great vibe and the harmonies were just fab!!!
I love Kerry! She isn't terrible, I hate people who say she is terrible,awful etc.
i can't even sing only one who can actually sing is Natasha :)
@@Beckyh921 You obviously havent heard Kerry on her own, girl's got pipes!
@@pippimaxim Which she uses to eat.
Look at Natasha she was born to be on stage she is a queen
Liverpool like
I grew up listening to them. Wow...They have grown old and still they sings. I love u attomic kitten. U r still very beautiful
I love Natasha's extensions. So pretty!
Fantastic ladies ❤
FANTASTIC!
Tash was born to be a performer and her voice is amazing, she's such a Queen 😍
weird without jenny Frost, , i love atomic kitten with jenny, .i stiil watch vid atomic with jenny.. again and again...i miss u jenny...
Aw same here..i miss jenny❤️
@@queeneliz2130 l love you ki bf kitten
I don't recognize them anymore! But still love the song! Brings back memories :)
it was always this line up for me
Natasha, Liz and Jenny is the better line up in my opinion
But I am so totally grateful they made a reunion saying Jenny is always welcomed if she wants to be back in the group again!
Yori Yu Sadly they were talking pish when they said she was welcome back anytime. They are currently touring in New Zealand with bloody Michelle Heaton in the band as a temp for Liz. I'd bet anything Jenny wasn't asked first.
smck 2016 actually liz doesn't promote overseas since she is scared of flights
Yori Yu I know that but I still don't think Jenny was asked back before they lowered themselves to asking Heaton. They stabbed Jenny in the back imo
Jenny was asked but couldn't make so you got Atomic Kitten
Michelle Heaton from what i've heard is a "decent" filler. Not better than Liz but Certainly better than Kerry/Jenny vocally. If it was just Tash with Kerry and Jenny...Lawd be a fence around her vocal chords..She'd have to carry the entire setlist (even more than she is right now)
Never heard Kerry Katona sing before!
They still have that thing😁🙌🙌💕💕
Natasha is so beautiful :)
Yay I miss them good job.
Their harmonies are amazing! 😊
Yes, they have some track backing them up, but it's normal, especially when yoh are on busy tour😊
wonderful performance from these awesome ladies !!!! gotta show my mother Jane this stuff ! :)
MWASDGHJKLHHKHLLHJGKGLGJGLGNWASDGHHMKLHKYLKGLGJFLLFKTLFLKGL
Wah... I really love to see them all reunion
Natasha! ❤️❤️❤️
Kerry katona is my favourite member of the group and I met Max in sand le mere and preformed in front of me it was amazing part of my life and also hydie I have met in the same and I played with them both
who remembers this from the lizzie mcguire movie ??
I do.
LOVE IT!
Goooo Kerry 👍🏻💪🏻
Forever Atomic Kitten 💘💖❤💗💕💞💟😘😘😘
i LOOOOOOOOVE this song
Reunite M2M next!! Another great Pop Band from the 90's!!
+Michael I. Haber OOOH i hope it! *-*
I approved this
We can only wish
liz and natasha look amazing omfg! *__*
Miss you ❤️
Wow, Tash and Liz still got it!
Awesome
I also felt Natasha was the groups leader. what a queen
I agree,Natasha-Leader/Main Vocalist.Liz-Lead Vocalist.Jenny-Vocalist/Visualist
+iKETOURAGE Lol lets keep the k-pop positions in Korea :p
+YCH_Nation 😂😂😂you got me
The group actually has two lead singers, Natasha and Liz. Natasha is the best singer though, Liz is second. Kerry and Jenny are unclassified.
Who is Natasha the girl with the pink skirt?I am sorry just found them I am 12
Gotta say even though I have all their CDs and I really I loved them majorly!(really was huge fan) with Natasha being my fav. and then Liz. I just... I wish Jenny was there. I know Kerry was there first but I preferred that line up.
o my gosh.. bring back jenny pleaseee...
2:54 bless him
Amen
This is my favourite song from Atomic Kitten
I only recognize the one with the short hair. However, this has been my jam since middle school. I love them :)
i love Tash 😘
MWASGDHJKKLFJRKJRLKJRKJRKFLDJNWASDFHJKKLFJFLJFLJFLFMFLFJF
RWASDGHJKKLGMGLFJKTLJKRLJRL
I miss u gal...
Goosebumps! ❤️
-2018
❤ 2023 October ❤. Luv from Australia 🇦🇺 ❤😊
uououo uououo uo uouo uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouozsosw uozemo username on uoxsmozsmzsmo uozsmossmozsosuomosemoswmoz so I am so uouo uouo u uouououuonmuoweuoswuo euo someones uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouozsosw uozemo someoneuo uouo uouououuonmuoweuoswm
uouo now uozsuozsmozsouomoxsuomomoxsuomouomzsuozemozozs uouo uouo uo uo us uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouuozozsuosmozwmossmosuozuozossasmoswuozozsmoxsmououozsmossuoxozsuuozsmozs uouo too uouououuonmuoweuoswm uouuozozsuosmozwmossmosuozuozossasmoswuozozsmoxsmououozsmossuoxozsuuozsmozsmos uouo
Go girls
Love kittens
wow i really miss the good old days.. hahayst.. Michael I. Haber I like that too M2M.. i love that girl band..
I never considered Kerry to ever be pat of the original band. She was there for one album and left. Jennu has been there wayyy longer.
The fact remains she was part of the original band
@@acesfn7316 and Kerry is more famous nowadays because she did a couple of reality TV shows so I guess it works to have her over Jenny
Being in the band for far longer does not equate to "original". Original means you're there right from the start, regardless if you left after just one album. Having said that, both Kerry and Jenny were awesome.
Liz ❤
I always like how Deborah Harry sings "The tide is high but I'm (short pause) holding on". No one else seems to try to replicate that feature.
*Oops! That pause is with the background vocals. It adds a lot of interest.* [Insert embarrassed face here.]
They'd ask Jenny but she had other commitments so she couldn't do the gig at the time Kerry was there first so it's only right they ask her to pop back for the big reunion
Take 5 the tide is high is the best not atomic kitten
Tash and Liz said they were glad to have their baby sister back at the Big Reunion
Kerrys hsir love it
My favorite song in Atomic Kitten but I need Jenny not Kerry.
same here.. jenny's voice is better and she's clearly more gorgeous than kerry
What happened with Jenny? Why Kerry came back?
Laura márquez I think Jenny was pregnant at the time?
I didn't know It, thanks for your answer 🤗
Laura márquez She was pregnant in the music video
So, no one is talking about how good they live sing? OK
Liz i love yah
wowowoW!!!!!
The hatred towards Kerry in some comments is unjustified. Kerry participated to this reunion cos Jenny herself had refused to join the girls.Tash and Liz needed the 3d one for the visuals. Let's tell it like it is, Jenny and Kerry can't sing to save their lives, they were lucky to have Natasha doing all the proper good vocals in the group. They were decoration while Natasha was the vocalist that owned every song. She owned this performance too, she's the best and I love her voice. She's the Queen 💙
Kerry came back and the other 2tohappytohave her back. It was the big reunion so it made sense to have the original line up. All this Kerrybashing is totallyunjustifying
Kerry is undoubtedly the bigger start tho of the two
@@pippimaxim Bigger in the waist.
@@JDoe-gf5oz such a dumb comment
@@naamancreaser8593 Yet true.
Credit when it’s due, when Kerry missed the first line and joined slightly after you could hear her, and it sounded really good. Anyone who says otherwise is just a hater.
Might be an unpopular opinion, but I think that if Kerry never left they could've been as successful as they were with Jenny. I can only totally imagine the music videos of Eternal Flame and You Are with her. I wish she would've looked like how she looks recently for the Big Reunion.
Well theres no denying with Kerry's exposure to worldwide television AFTER AK...Kerry became a bigger name and star than any of the other AK girls combined!
Not to be rude about it but Kerry just didn't have the looks to be in a girl group, and her voice wasn't good enough to make up for it. Bringing her back for a big reunion when the group had it's actual success during the Jenny era was insulting. It would be like a Girls Aloud reunion with Javine replacing Sarah.
I know Kerry Katona is an original member together with Liz but still.
The line up with Natasha - Liz - Jenny was the best thing ever. I feel like they should have contacted former Sugababes member Heidi Range since she's also an original/former member of Atomic Kitten.. and not to be rude.. but Heidi looks and sounds better than Kerry
Heidi never recorded songs with them as far as I know. I think Mutya and Keisha should join Heidi to reform the second line-up of Sugababes again.
xxxTIN0xxx Liz and Kerry did some demos with Heidi. I think she did record demos of Right Now and See Ya with them.
To be honest...Atomic kitten is what Tash needed. Liz is a formidable vocalist in her own right but Liz/Heidi/Kerry vocally was "High/Higher/Highest" They needed a deeper distinct voice like Tash
As long as they are happy I don't see any point in hating
jenny decided not to join the group during this reunion. respect. just enjoy their music 😊
love lizzy... 🌹🌹🌹 😍 loved tash but shes almost, umm..unrecognizable? 🤔 i miss jenny... ☹️️
De mis girls band favoritas. Pero falta Jenny... saludos desde Perú.
The chorus though......
tash looks way prettier now. she aged gracefully. wow
2 years late to this party but... no, she isn't "prettier" here compared to when they were a hit. she did however age well albeit poor clothing apparel choices *GLares at that ugly ass umbrella skirt thing* Atomic Kitten is the only 90's pop band to stand the test of time. (imho)
@@uihettyhg6881 a 90's pop band? crazy cause their album was released in the 00's and she became famous after their second.
If to dance
all i could think about while the song was playing was Lizzie McGuire singing it! lol xx
same here! xD
Go kerry
the mics were not set right
Cute!
Culte en cours
Live
How old are they
Only to dance
nothing in the world only
That song was from Lizzie McGuire movie
Oh dear oh dear 😳 😕 😞 😢
Everytime i see atomic kitten w/o Jenny, im like: "the f***, Jenny!!! Where are you???" 🙁😓😭
drag queen
pregnant at this time 💖
Roccontrolz22 i know. Thanks 😊
she decided not to do it for some reason
Where is Jenny Frost
That song is from the Lizzie McGuire movie
What happened to the other one?
Jenny was pregnant when they started filming so she didn't join and they asked Kerry to come back...now Jenny doesn't want to come back because of Kerry.
They were off key, but still beautiful.
It made sense to bring back Kerry for the big reunion. She was in the original line up. I have heard worst versions of this song.
Well, the original two (if you look it up) was Kerry and Heidi...back in 1998.
@@pippimaxim well this is the only lineups I have seen. Never really follows the journey of Atomic Kitten.
Jenny 😭
Atomic kitten will never have their comeback if kerry still in the group...
Honestly, I'm not much into this band, but after looking through the comments, I have an issue with and don't like people who are like "it's not X without Y", etc. It really makes me angry because I don't see what the big deal is. Two out of three isn't bad, or X out of X+1 isn't bad.
can someone please kindly answer a question for me ? are the atomic kitten band actually using autotune and pitch correction in this particular live performance of this song of tide is high ? or are they actually using their own real singing voices they were born with ?
Which one was the one that was pregnant in the music video for this song
Natasha... red hair
You just said it was Kerry Katona!
Kerry wasn't even in the group when they filmed the video for this.
That's Kerry with short hair
Jennyfrost.That is why shes not there
Not Kerry's best performance.
Why did they sing this song? Kerry wasn't even in the band when they released this, Jenny was. They shouldn't have sung a song Kerry wasn't there for :/ Tash sounds fab on this performance though
Kerry wasn't there for most of their songs, she left the group before the first album was even released. If they only did songs she was there for then they wouldn't have enough for a show.
Dani L LOL no need to educate me on AK history, I've been a fan since the beginning. And Kerry was there for the first album, they released it originally with her, then re-released it after Jenny joined. And I get that, it's just kinda annoying to see them act like she was there when they released The Tide Is High xD
Megan O Yeah I realise that now. However most of the world wouldn't even know who Kerry was because the first album to come out internationally (including in my country) was the re recorded version. In fact the first single to release in my country was Whole Again, once again the re recorded music video. I don't think they are trying to act like she was in the group when they recorded that song, it was a huge hit for them and most of their fans would be pretty disappointed if they only sang songs from their first album.
Well now you have 2versions.Jennywasn't in the band when they first released Whole again
@@moxgirl5 well there clearly was a need to educate you since if you'd known that information then you wouldn't have needed to write this comment 😂🤣😂🤣
there is a bunch of old people there I burrly discovered them this year cause I wasn't born yet when they we're a big hit
thats cause you werent born in the 90's when this band was around so don't you dare call people who actually know good songs and dont listen to songs that are out now cause the 90's was the best year for music.
Kerry....hmmm
Seriously, we need Jenny Not Katona.
I only recognize the girl with the lime skirt. Who are the other two ?
Natasha Hamilton and Kerry Katona. The girl with lime is Liz McClarnon.
are thes the 3 original singers? I mean the ones in the music video?
Two of them, yes. The one with the blonde, very short hair (Kerry) left Atomic Kitten in 2001.
The 3 of them are the original line up
But not the original line up for the video of "The tide is high".
Omg killed it for them! She can't even sing!!!!
*kerry
So let's see you do it.
course she can. Just the song doesn't suit her
She sounded so bad and o have heard her in another song and wasn't great. She is not a great singer
Its a reunion..and its been a long time..dont expect too much! If your not satisfied on her go there and replace her or go find jenny
Cover thats what they do
Oh gosh... where is my Jenny ?
what the freak is Natasha wearing..... Who was so stupid to say let's put that on?.....
Sounds different that Kerry is singing this (no offense to her). I've seen and heard her sing and as part of AK, but Jenny was the one who was recognized by fans as the 1/3 of AK. Kerry was part of AK for 1-2 years but Jenny was there for 4-5 years.
+NylRei yass i agrree.. i love jenny Frost,..in atomic kitten,again,..i miss her..
Kerry is having the last laugh
I don’t rate Kerry or Jenny as singers altho K’s verse on ‘Whole Again’ is the better of the 2. But here as a trio and live when they sing together they sound good, even Kerry.
i like kerry"s voice
The song of take5 the tide is high is the best for me and all of song of take5 not atomic kitten
k so I really don't know how Kerry got this gig in the first place. She really cannot sing... :/ at all. My opinion.
Totally agree she's terrible. She's out of Tune. This why Atomic Kitten are not in the charts anymore.
Ꭿmanda Jonεs This was just a one off thing and they haven't started again.. And Kerry was the original Atomic kitten singer and she can sing but it's a very long time since so her voice needs to be trained back again slowly but they didn't have time to do it.. The other 2 never stopped singing so they are fine.. So you judged wrong.
i absolutelty did not judge incorrectly, if you can really sing, no matter how out of shapeyour voice is you will not sound this bad... We have different opinions, just because we disagree doesn't mean either opinion is wrong... we can simply agree to disagree.
they need jenny's voice and her looks to make it to the top, like seriously.. kerry is a big joke! lol