Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro: A Critical Analysis Of The Claim That Anti-Zionism Is Anti-Semitism

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 31 янв 2025

Комментарии • 57

  • @francefradet2116
    @francefradet2116 Год назад +17

    God bless you Rabbi Shapiro. I share your videos on Facebook. Ignorance is never an excuse for evil.

  • @rippy4freedom
    @rippy4freedom Год назад +8

    Nice to meet you Rabbi Yaakov

  • @Adi.Shabad
    @Adi.Shabad 3 года назад +11

    תודה רבה כבוד הרב! תודה על כל פעלכם להצלתנו!!!!!

  • @celdidi207
    @celdidi207 3 года назад +14

    Love Rabbi Yaakov

  • @msa11387
    @msa11387 3 года назад +14

    Powerful video! Knowledge and understanding lead to at least tolerance.

  • @s.y.4968
    @s.y.4968 9 месяцев назад +3

    This was so amazing thank you Rabbi Yakov

  • @DT-xz7hb
    @DT-xz7hb 7 месяцев назад +1

    Thank you for taking the time to make sense of all of the lies! Free Palestine

  • @AKIB1991LASKAR
    @AKIB1991LASKAR Год назад +9

    Rabbi I have a lot of respect for you ...!! Thank you for opening our eyes, and show us what real Judaism is...As Quran mentioned is about people of the book are needed to be respected by a Muslim, Prophet Muhammad PBUH offered a pillow when Torah is offered to him by Jewish leaders in Medina, He fasted during Ashura as Muslims still do to this day , for Redemption of Moses PBUH and his people from Egypt....and we really respect the nation of Moses PBUH(Those who obey the commandments)....as peace remained among us for more than a thousand years among us (cousin nations) before Zionism(which actually a disgrace to Judaism)....may those days return in the holy land (Al Quds)....Salam Alaikum..

  • @Amidat
    @Amidat 6 часов назад

    Thank you for your wonderful videos

  • @yossifelder6775
    @yossifelder6775 3 года назад +10

    געוואלדיג❤️

  • @Ilaab1995
    @Ilaab1995 Год назад +3

    Concerning Morton's last question. The problem is that most people are not able to differentiate. That is due in part to propaganda, but also because of personal development in terms of Lawrence Kohlberg's thoughts on morality. That is a huge challenge when combating real antisemitism.

  • @slloyd7926
    @slloyd7926 Год назад +3

    You look well Rabbi Shaprio.
    I remember your early ones on True Torha Jews.

  • @nusaibahibraheem8183
    @nusaibahibraheem8183 Год назад +5

    😂😂 33:30 North Korea is not worse than Israel. Americans need to leave North Korea alone.

    • @Amidat
      @Amidat 6 часов назад

      As he said he is an American. If he lived in a non western country - his view would likely be different. that's life

  • @ludvighansson2586
    @ludvighansson2586 2 года назад +3

    Hello Rabbi Shapiro, I don't know if the Satmarer Rebbe wrote on this or not. But I was wondering when the Meilech HaMoishiach comes and restores the Kingdom of Israel, if the Lashon Koidesh will be restored as the language of day-to-day affairs, or if Yiddish will remain? Thanks.

    • @הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם
      @הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם 2 года назад +3

      אידיש לדברי חול ולשון הקודש לדברי תורה ומצוות

    • @ludvighansson2586
      @ludvighansson2586 2 года назад +2

      @@הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם Thanks for your response. If I understand you correctly you hold that Yiddish and loshn koidesh will remain as they are. Is this how the Satmarer Rebbe held? If you could bring a source for this I would appreciate it, because someone told me that it would be like in Beis Rishoin again with Loshn Koidesh spoken only. Thanks.

    • @הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם
      @הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם 2 года назад +2

      @@ludvighansson2586 The מחלוקת is actually about what will be when Moshiach Will come. Some Rishonim are saying that it will be a world what we can’t understand like The Jews will serve hashem every minute 24 seven with no break, without eating or sleeping and other things the body needs on this world. that means we will talk Lashon Hakodesh all the time.
      But others say that we will still do some גשמיות. That means In that time we will talk Yiddish. I will try to look up the מקורות.

    • @הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם
      @הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם 2 года назад +2

      @@ludvighansson2586 sorry but my English is HORRIBLE I hope you understand...

    • @ludvighansson2586
      @ludvighansson2586 2 года назад +1

      @@הציוניםימחשמםוזכרם Okay thanks for your answers, it's much appreciated.

  • @shifrafreewoman174
    @shifrafreewoman174 Год назад +1

    i am no longer a zionist. period. and i have to say i was deeply disturbed by how netura kartai went to iran embraced achmidinajahd, and never said that they were upset by the holocaust denial. i do not say they should not have gone to iran to make peace, but to embrace this guy as he denies the holocaust is not ok. Jews can be anti jewish, as Black People can be anti Black. and i agree that anti zionism is not necessarily anti semitic. it can be but it is very often not. their definition is ridiculous.

  • @susangaik36
    @susangaik36 10 месяцев назад +1

    criticism of political zionist israel (aka communism) is NOT antisemitism.

  • @krzysztofgrudzien9313
    @krzysztofgrudzien9313 2 года назад +2

    "If you have a problem figuring out whether you're for me or Trump, then you ain't black" Joe Biden

  • @abgsl
    @abgsl 11 месяцев назад

    This is what 2000 years of exile does to a person. Rachmones.

  • @nicoedits2810
    @nicoedits2810 3 года назад +1

    11:50 Is anti-zionism the same as anti-semitism

    • @nicoedits2810
      @nicoedits2810 3 года назад +1

      14:15 What Israel says about anti-semitism

  • @efeynes1225
    @efeynes1225 3 года назад

    Aligns himself with every koifer !!

  • @user-bo8nb2mi
    @user-bo8nb2mi Год назад

    To reject Zionism out of hand, to refuse Jews, alone of all peoples, the right to self-determination and therefore the right to safety, is to embrace the logic of anti-Semitism if not its conclusion.

    • @Dinerell
      @Dinerell Год назад

      States won't save anyone! Did you overslept all the wars in history? If there are people hating jews, the danger will always prevail and if it's a state you're just an easier target to hit without unwanted casualities. Being spread out actually makes jews less vulnerable because if they get attack at one place there are still more in other places. Do you really don't want to make them responsible if they don't protect otherwise if everyone just stands against you, then you will just die.

    • @nusaibahibraheem8183
      @nusaibahibraheem8183 Год назад +3

      Right to self determination on whose land? 😂

  • @rawman909
    @rawman909 2 года назад

    What stupidity. Any people hood is invented. There is no nationality as German or French. It is defined ONLY by citizenship.

    • @NickyRikki
      @NickyRikki 2 года назад +1

      Sure that’s true. But are you going to call the Japanese Chinese now ?

    • @NickyRikki
      @NickyRikki 2 года назад

      Obviously over time they created an ethnic race. Because Japanese don’t look at all Chinese and Germans don’t look black

    • @francefradet2116
      @francefradet2116 Год назад +1

      Exactly. Citizenship is defined by nationality, not by religion. Two discrete issues.

    • @citizenkent1223
      @citizenkent1223 Год назад +1

      Three words in the English tongue have no definition no denotation of human Identity, since Shakespeare:
      1) Arab, 2) Jew, 3) Turk! these terms are devoid of culture and linguistic identity!

    • @MrHelmuth1
      @MrHelmuth1 Год назад

      I’m not a Jew, only interested in history and have followed some discussions about Jewish and Zionist “identity”.
      From my humble knowledge I would come to the conclusion, that Zionism is more (or will be more) detrimental to the Jewish people than any other (external) source of movement against Jews in the whole world, as it claims to encompass all Jews in the world, and therefore all Jews are/will be considered guilty of the actions of the Zionist Israeli state.
      Am I wrong ?