What If Ahsoka Was EXECUTED For the Jedi Temple Bombing

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
  • What would've happened if Anakin's Padawan was Convicted of Bombing the Jedi Temple and sentenced to Execution?
    #skywalker #StarWars #AnakinSkywalker #anakin #starwarsedit #theclonewars #maytheforcebewithyou #obiwankenobi #macewindu #shorts #short
    PPSW Merch: ppsw.myspreads...
    Community Discord: / discord
    Support the Channel: / ppsw
    Twitch Account: / pentepatrol
    THUMBNAIL BY: Tilian_Creative: www.picuki.com...
    Pente Patrol Team:
    Voice Actors:
    Concordia Jedi: / @concordiajedi
    James: / jamesmck345
    Jordan: / @spectrum_country1028
    Silver Bullet:
    Bly: / @jackogeography3950
    Cole: / connerthehonker
    Editors PPT:
    Jakub: / jakeup
    Nnaemeka: nwosennaemeka....
    Saito: www.instagram....
    ATLAXS: / @atlaxs
    Writers:
    Cameron Hall: linktr.ee/sppr...
    Support My Other Channels!
    PPR: / @pentepatrolreacts
    PPMP: / @pentepatrolmusicprodu...
    Support This Video's Musicians!
    The Way of Water - • 🎥 Epic & Trailer (Free...
    In Search of Solitude - • 🌳 Classical & Cinemati...
    Permafrost - • 💭 Meditation (Free Mus...
    Fire & Thunder - • ⚡ Free Epic Music (No ...
    Unexplored Moon - • 🌙 Copyright Free Orche...
    Eight Mountains - • Eight Mountains by Savfk
    The Epic Hero - • 💪 Orchestral Trailer P...
    Dunes - • ⏳ Soundtrack (Free Mus...
    Refusing the Ultimatum - • 😟 Tense & Orchestral (...
    Passage of Time - • ⏱️ Cinematic & Backgro...
    Love - • ❤️‍🔥 Romantic & Piano ...
    Resolutions - • 👼 Hopeful & Angelic (F...
    What Happens When We Die - • Sad Soundtrack (Free M...
    The Preparation - • 🔭 Soundtrack (Free Mus...
    Eglair - • 🚤 Epic & Cinematic (Fr...
    Instructions for Living Life - • 🎹 Piano Instrumental (...
    Terminus - • 🎖️ Free Epic Heroic Mu...
    Still A Long Way To Go - • 📽️ Free Film Orchestra...
    Magic - • 🍬 Free Classical Fanta...
    Pirates of the Quarantine - • ☠️ Free Pirate Music -...
    Long Way to Go - • ⛓️ Sad & Beautiful Orc...
    Age of Wonder - • 🌁 Cinematic & Epic (Fr...

Комментарии • 455

  • @matthiasthemagician6803
    @matthiasthemagician6803 Год назад +269

    You skipped over the part where Anakin throws Tarkin into a woodchipper.

    • @Orange-inkling
      @Orange-inkling Год назад +24

      Yep

    • @TheFrenchToastDetecive
      @TheFrenchToastDetecive 5 месяцев назад +12

      Feel like he would have thrown him in a venators engine or a de-atomizer

    • @Tyrannosaurusstudios
      @Tyrannosaurusstudios 5 месяцев назад +13

      naw he would throw tarkin into the sequels

    • @matthiasthemagician6803
      @matthiasthemagician6803 5 месяцев назад +11

      @@Tyrannosaurusstudios A fate worst than death

    • @WolfTrooperRex
      @WolfTrooperRex 4 месяца назад +15

      I can see it now…
      -Anakin attempting to go through the healing process*
      Tarkin with a smug ass smile: Such a shame you led a child to war. I think she was at the wrong place at the wrong time…
      Anakin: …
      Rex: …
      Fives: …
      -Tarkin walks off*
      Anakin: …You boys down for a bit of treason?
      Rex: Against my better judgement…
      Fives: I’ll get the woodchipper…

  • @soularprimestudios5930
    @soularprimestudios5930 Год назад +763

    Anakin would want nothing to do with the Jedi Order or Palpatine for calling the execution. He would find the real bomber and either kill them or turn them in to prove a point of how rigged the Senate and the whole structure is. He would be hurt and angry and he would start something new with Padme.Hell I can even see Obi Wan leaving too because of this...

    • @marikam2998
      @marikam2998 Год назад +68

      Well, if Anakin would remember, for example, the betrayal of Dooku, who was trusted. But from whom the Jedi never expected betrayal, Anakin was not surprised. And we are offended by the fact that the Jedi easily believed in the possible betrayal of Ahsoka. And Ahsoka's ability to betray. Jedi too many times with unexpected betrayals among their own. In the end, it was many Dark Jedi who became very Dangerous. And Powerful Sith. For example, Dooku, unlike Palpatine, in Attack Of Clones could use Force Lightning through one-handed use. While Palpatine himself had to use two hands to use Force Lightning.

    • @WanderingMiqo
      @WanderingMiqo Год назад +53

      Yeah I don't think there would be any way that Anakin would just let the bombing go, especially when it cost Ahsoka her life. He would be even more adamant in finding out the truth, because he KNEW that Ahsoka was innocent. Once he found out the truth he would hold the Jedi and everyone who participated in the trial accountable, and would never forgive them.

    • @marikam2998
      @marikam2998 Год назад +6

      @@WanderingMiqo Well, we're still talking about the Spitfire. impulsive. Egocentric. And the Selfish Anakin who was not capable of wisdom. Discretion. And impartiality. What they didn’t say, but if Mace didn’t trust Anakin, he wouldn’t trust Anakin with the protection of the Jedi Temple in case Mace. And the members of the Jedi Council will lose. And die fighting Palpatine. On top of that, Mace didn't expect Anakin to cut off Mace's arm. And that Anakin would let Palpatine kill him also says Mace trusted Anakin. And I definitely never expected a knife in the back from him.

    • @tweso1499
      @tweso1499 Год назад +10

      @@marikam2998even so, Dooku’s usage of the power is nowhere NEAR as powerful as Sidious’ REGARDLESS of the amount of hands being used.

    • @marikam2998
      @marikam2998 Год назад +4

      @@tweso1499 However, the example of Dooku shows that Dark Jedi can be more Dangerous. And Powerful Sith. Than the Sith that are initially simply very Dangerous. And Powerful Force Adepts of Dark Side Force. Therefore, the Dark Jedi has more experience in studying. And in the use of Force than of Sith as like Bane the example. To be honest, I won't never forgive Lucas even for taking away the Jedi ability to easily deflect Blaster's blaster shots with the help Tutaminis how Anakin easily deflects Han's blaster shots with the help Tutaminis. This already suggests that the Jedi in Clone Wars could easily cope with the blaster shots of the Droids if Lucas let them. I still can't understand why the Republic created the Clone Army when it could have created something like, for example, the Terminators? Because against the Terminators, the Trade Federation Droids would definitely have no chance of winning the Clone Wars. To be honest, Star Wars started dying in the Original Movies. From the Prequels. In cartoons. From the Romans. And in the Star Wars comics in which there are battles. And they decided to replace the Sith Wars with the Jedi with wars. And the battles of the Rebels with the Imperials. On the participation of the Jedi in the Battle of Naboo. At the Battle of Geonosis. And the Clone Wars. And they decided to replace the Sith with droids. To the Trade Federation. On the Geonosians. And other opponents. Recall at least the Stratus Army because of which the Padawans died in the Battle of Jabiim. Now Disney just keeps killing Star Wars. Although it wasn't Disney that started killing Star Wars. A Comic Book Writers. And Star Wars novels along with Lucas. And Filoni. Still, in Bane's time, everything really was as it should be. Politicians. And politicians played a secondary role. And Wars. And the battles of the Sith with the Jedi played a paramount role. But no to Authors of Romanes. And comics along with Lucas. And Filoni had to. And forever in the truest sense of the word to take. And end it. For example Telekinesis, with the help of which they can easily telekenetically throw aside any Droids. Separatists. And Genosians like Penelope. And Prudence in the Charmed Ones is easily thrown telekinetically towards the Evil Witchers with the help of Telekinesis. And the Evil Witches who were considered to be in the Charmed Ones. And call them demons. Jedi can't. And they shouldn't be weak opponents. And bad warriors. After all, these are not Clones that Ventress easily cracks down on before his first battle with Anakin. Jedi have different skills. And abilities. They are like the Jedi version of Shinobi. And Kuonichi with Naruto. They can wield that Light Whip. It's the Double-Bladed Lightsaber. That Lightsaber. They have all the qualities to be good warriors. They are good judges. Those are good politicians. Come to think of it, we've never even seen a Jedi in the history of Star Wars. And the Sith could fight. And to fight each other without the use of Lightsabers. Which means we've never seen a Sith fight a Jedi. And fight seriously. And full power without the use of Lightsabers. And the creators of Star Wars should be very ashamed even for this.

  • @tekoneiric
    @tekoneiric Год назад +123

    If Ahsoka had gotten executed, Anakin would have became a complete dark side force berserker. He would have cut through Sidious, Tarkin and whoever or whatever else he thought responsible. He'd be ripping Venators out of the sky and tossing them around like toys. We never really got to see him reach his peak power. His rage would driven him way beyond what Sidious would ever hope to manifest.

    • @TheHighborn
      @TheHighborn 6 месяцев назад +7

      The doom slayer sw style

    • @lastlombaxx
      @lastlombaxx 6 месяцев назад +6

      It'd probably be like how starkiller went berserk in force unleashed 2

    • @davidmauriciogutierrezespi5244
      @davidmauriciogutierrezespi5244 5 месяцев назад +6

      I can see this as Palpatine feeling into the Force for Anakin after killing Ahsoka and the animation stopping with Mace Windu's voice in the background _It was at this moment, the Sith Lord knew, he kriff up_

    • @WolfTrooperRex
      @WolfTrooperRex 5 месяцев назад +3

      Well in terms of classification of Sith Lawds… we have the Sith Highlord, Sith Apprentice, Sith Berzerker, Sith Acolyte, and Sith Trooper…
      Anakin will be all at once. Much like Starkiller

    • @Andy_the_Collector925
      @Andy_the_Collector925 3 месяца назад +2

      Sideous, watching a Skywalker propelled Venator hurdling straight towards him and his office:
      "OH SWEET SISSIFIED MAGGOT DARK SIDE OF THE FOR-"
      *Is immediately destroyed*

  • @SpammytheHedgehog
    @SpammytheHedgehog Год назад +139

    Anakin: And now... this Galaxy shall know Pain.

    • @Anonymus_M8
      @Anonymus_M8 7 месяцев назад +9

      Anakin on the higher ground surrounded by dead Jedi and would just be holding a dead Yoda with one hand and Obi Wan just stand there on the lower ground

    • @434444334
      @434444334 5 месяцев назад +5

      ALL MIGHTY FORCE PUSH

    • @envorytalhasi1346
      @envorytalhasi1346 4 месяца назад +2

      SHINRA TENSEI

    • @Jetryder223
      @Jetryder223 4 месяца назад

      It was just like this, when my apprentice was killed right before my eyes... by Soldiers of the Republic. Because of the existence of love, sacrifice is born, as well as hate. When one comprehends, one knows pain.

    • @Somethingfs-sx1ft
      @Somethingfs-sx1ft 2 месяца назад

      Palpatine: Good, Anakin, Good

  • @wargamesmaster
    @wargamesmaster Год назад +271

    I wonder if Dooku would remember why he is fighting the Republic because of what happened to Ahsoka and feeling Anakin's pain (which might be similar to how he felt after Qui Gon's death) and try to convince Anakin to change sides (not to fight for the Sith, but for CIS worlds).

    • @CharlieHepp
      @CharlieHepp Год назад +8

      thrawn did tell her Ahsoka say to Anakin was lost his mind go mad side be similar to how he felt go mad she did.

    • @anvos658
      @anvos658 Год назад +23

      Honestly if there was a time Dooku could have gone rouge from Palpatine's plan, and decided to put the CIS first, I would have put it at the moment he was ordered to betray Assaj Ventress, realizing everybody was a disposable tool to Palpatine. Though this itself probably does lead to Dooku being the founder of a third order that hybridizes the Jedi and SIth.

    • @gavinthedragon
      @gavinthedragon Год назад +12

      @@CharlieHeppI think I’m having a stroke after reading that sentence

    • @WatcherCCG
      @WatcherCCG Год назад +4

      @@anvos658 Grey Knights represent!

    • @metalanarchy5186
      @metalanarchy5186 Год назад +4

      He might but Dooku hated Anakin

  • @Rex-The-Wolf
    @Rex-The-Wolf Год назад +118

    Either anakin falls worse to the dark side or he deems the senate and the jedi corrupt and abandons the republic entirely, or he work with padme to give palpatine the boot and demote tarkin, thats what i think

    • @zsparaco6925
      @zsparaco6925 Год назад +11

      Agreed… no matter what course of action Ani takes regarding snips being executed , it will be a path of HUGE emotion and lots of destruction.

    • @Rex-The-Wolf
      @Rex-The-Wolf Год назад +5

      @@zsparaco6925 the video was amazing! I wont spoil it, but it was perfect!

    • @plasmawarper5837
      @plasmawarper5837 10 месяцев назад +1

      Tarkin would get the Ozzel treatment

  • @soularprimestudios5930
    @soularprimestudios5930 Год назад +231

    I think Obi Wan could potentially leave the order because of this out of guilt 50 percent chance and for Plo Koon a 25 percent chance.Of course this is after it's revealed who did the Anakin would leave 100 percent.

    • @unluckyme213
      @unluckyme213 Год назад +9

      yeah i thought that too

    • @soularprimestudios5930
      @soularprimestudios5930 Год назад +5

      @@unluckyme213 Yeah but in this what if when released Anakin was unable to find out it was Barris. If he never finds out who dose it this the outcome would probably be what we got.

  • @dianesinger9729
    @dianesinger9729 Год назад +166

    Sad that Ahsoka had to die. I did enjoy the growth of Anakin despite his loses of Ahsoka. His emotions were all over it and how he learned to deal with the hate and reconcile.

    • @zsparaco6925
      @zsparaco6925 Год назад +15

      Good thing she never actually dies 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌💘💘💘

    • @cooldawg5575
      @cooldawg5575 Год назад +11

      Ima just say: anakin would probably find the world between worlds and save Ashoka accidentally and then save satine for obi-wan

  • @mattstorm360
    @mattstorm360 Год назад +196

    This might not work out as well for palatine as he would be responsible for executing the wrong jedi... Anakin might hold that against him.

    • @alpha34098
      @alpha34098 Год назад +21

      And that's exactly what happened in the end

  • @hamstey1603
    @hamstey1603 Год назад +95

    This video gave me an idea for a what if
    What if Anakin joined Dooku?
    At this point in time, Anakin is very similar to Dooku (at least when he was still a Jedi). They both heavily question the council/republic and both use "unorthodox" methods to achieve goals for "the greater good". I believe that this could be possible especially after Ahsoka's trail regardless if she dies or not.
    Maybe hearing how Dooku questioned the order a ton and then leaving would definitely make Anakin question if he was on the right track. He could likely have heard this from Jocasta Nu.

    • @ZeKermet
      @ZeKermet Год назад +5

      This is a good one

    • @SirDriperHat
      @SirDriperHat Год назад +6

      I doubt he could join the CIS and more at this point of the war,
      He would consider the clones as there brothers I arms.

  • @locoarticwolf2181
    @locoarticwolf2181 Год назад +57

    Anakin will be even further in the Dark Side…not only that but if he becomes Vader and is with the Empire, then Tarkin might suffer an “accident”.

  • @monst3r_child832
    @monst3r_child832 Год назад +42

    honestly i'm surprised that barris wouldn't be consumed by her guilt and either take her own life or submit herself to the council, after all, Ahsoka was her friend and she probably didn't expect for her to be executed. other than that i think this was a good story, and the remorse of the clones was tear jerking, if it wasn't for the title of the video i almost half expected for the clones to let ahsoka go in secret.

  • @zsparaco6925
    @zsparaco6925 Год назад +58

    I really LOVE that Obi Wan took Ani to Padme’s house. That was deep to me

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Год назад +11

      I was waiting for this comment!!

    • @tyler1017077
      @tyler1017077 Год назад +3

      Yea at that point in time obi wan figured something was going on between them. I like that part as well and would make complete sense for obi wan’s character.

    • @zsparaco6925
      @zsparaco6925 Год назад +5

      @@tyler1017077 one of my all time favorite Obi/Ani moments is when Rex is “standing guard” while Ani is inside the barracks talking to Padme and Obi throws a dig “Did you at least tell her i said hello” 💞💞

    • @zsparaco6925
      @zsparaco6925 Год назад +3

      @@PentePatrolStarWars you my friend get the little things right in your “what ifs” and thats why you get such positive response yo! We thank you

  • @TrueStarwars
    @TrueStarwars Год назад +36

    Damn this is just dark
    Palpatines plan was more successful that he would have thought

  • @Orange-inkling
    @Orange-inkling Год назад +3

    I’m pretty sure Anakin wouldn’t ever want to see tarkens face ever again

  • @hehu4025
    @hehu4025 Год назад +23

    Barriss wouldn't stop. She was devastated at the time, emotionally unstable.
    There are 2 options
    Or she would repeat the bombing and the risk of Anakin discovering the truth (He would kill her)
    Or she would have left the order. She had had such thoughts before, so after realizing what she had done, she could leave.
    My idea
    What if Barriss and Ahsoka left the order together (for example The Republic found Ventress guilty )

  • @jeraldhall4603
    @jeraldhall4603 Год назад +24

    This DID NOT go as I expected, not complaining, that is actually a compliment. I had hoped that at some point Barriss Offee would be outed as the one who had done the bombing. While it would have done nothing to bring Ahsoka back, it would have been cool if Ahsoka's name had been cleared. I can see Palpatine having some sort of record implicating himself in framing Ahsoka. Again I am not trying to criticize the story, just saying this would have been cool and this is how you could have done that. I listened to this story a second time and implemented these ideas, it really didn't change anything, but it did feel more complete and brought closure to Ahsoka's story in this story.

  • @x-track5190
    @x-track5190 Год назад +121

    This will push Anakin even more to the darkside

    • @SirDriperHat
      @SirDriperHat Год назад +54

      But it would also make him hate the chancellor for his betrayal

    • @WordsOfARaven
      @WordsOfARaven Год назад +16

      @@SirDriperHat it would have still pushed him to the dark side

    • @triforceofcourage100
      @triforceofcourage100 Год назад +18

      Maybe but if the process he finds out that Palpatine is the sith lord and wants him as his apprentice Anakin will not join him. The logical solution at that point would be that Sideous orchestrated the whole thing to push him closer to the dark side. That might actually embolden him against the darkness. Either way he’s still leaving the Jedi order

    • @x-track5190
      @x-track5190 Год назад +10

      That is true he might become enraged with Palpatine and reject the sith and abandone the Jedi. But that wouldnt stop him from being a prey of the darkside. Remember the jedi and Sith arent the only force users there are others. How use the force.

    • @triforceofcourage100
      @triforceofcourage100 Год назад +3

      @@x-track5190 I did say might

  • @CrazyKungfuGirl
    @CrazyKungfuGirl Год назад +15

    I feel like it would be more likely that he would kill tarkin like immediately. This is the same guy who slaughtered an entire village over his mother's death after all...

  • @3eEtranger
    @3eEtranger Год назад +6

    When..
    When I heard Pente say that about the 2 troopers and Ahsoka I started to cry

  • @locoarticwolf2181
    @locoarticwolf2181 Год назад +44

    Okay wow…this tugged at my heartstrings and was a emotional ride…great job!
    One of the best stories you put out to date, your improving more and more.
    I really love how Anakin’s close friends/loved ones helped them and reinforce his trust in the Jedi. He was more humbled too and I truthfully thought Padme was going to die and he’d be more prepare for the lost as a Jedi.

  • @jedi2685
    @jedi2685 Год назад +20

    Most people expected Anakin to go full Darth Vader but u gave the twist. Also love how obi wan dropped Anakin off at padmes. Now my what ifs. Attempt no. 20
    What if obi wan Kenobi was framed for the Jedi temple bombing.
    What if obi wan and Anakin Skywalker were the chosen ones.
    What if obi wan Kenobi was Count dooku's biological son or grandson.

    • @josh2Sides2
      @josh2Sides2 9 месяцев назад

      I like all these but especially the last it could be that Kenobi finds out that he's related to Count Douku

  • @Ahsla
    @Ahsla Год назад +15

    I believe Anakin would have felt the bond break and so would have known that Ahsoka was dead.

  • @andrewobrien8325
    @andrewobrien8325 Год назад +10

    6:31 Mate can I just say? You're doing a fantastic job of setting the scene and all, I can honestly visualise it and it's making me tear up a bit.....WELL DONE! I always wanted to see a what if on this scenario and your doing a cracking good job!

  • @JacksonBegleymusicguy
    @JacksonBegleymusicguy Год назад +12

    Anakin would probably try to kill Palpatine, where he would then find out he’s the Sith Lord, then Order 66 happens early

  • @stevenbrown1762
    @stevenbrown1762 Год назад +9

    No matter what story is told, the weight of the galaxy is placed on Anakin's emotions. He was a very powerful force user and dualist and whether he stayed with the Jedi, joined the dark side, or joined dooku, the galaxy would still be at the hands of Anakin considering him next to any of these forces would be huge

  • @Toumahitoedits
    @Toumahitoedits Год назад +26

    Anakin will be really mad, Ahsoka dying would mean anakin turning to the dark side of the force.

    • @DLR1997
      @DLR1997 Год назад +1

      Not as much as if Padmé died

    • @Cookiesrfood
      @Cookiesrfood Год назад +5

      I do think Anakin probably turns to the dark side because of this but he would now hate Palpatine and would never join him. I can see Anakin using the Jedi to kill Palpatine and then he would discover some of Palpatine's Sith secrets and become a Sith himself. The other possibility is that Anakin just completely leaves the Jedi order and the Republic behind and lives with Padme trying to help her root out corruption in the Senate and corruption in the rest of the galaxy such as slavery in the outer rim.

  • @Toumahitoedits
    @Toumahitoedits Год назад +64

    God, I’m crying over Ahsoka’s death…😤😫😩😭

  • @eidoneverchoosen1171
    @eidoneverchoosen1171 Год назад +16

    What if the jedi council refused to give up ahsoka to the republic.

    • @vipor_bruce5414
      @vipor_bruce5414 Год назад +2

      It may end up being Order 66 early

    • @eidoneverchoosen1171
      @eidoneverchoosen1171 Год назад +2

      @@vipor_bruce5414 oh yeah. Considering sideous be able to stir up the hatred for the jedi even more.

    • @matthewschocke4094
      @matthewschocke4094 2 месяца назад

      ​@vipor_bruce5414 but Anakin would go hardcore on them

  • @dakotalange2858
    @dakotalange2858 Год назад +19

    What if Revan stayed and helped rebuild the Jedi order after he was redeemed to try to prepare for the darkness in the unknown regions after kotor

  • @RyanTheDark
    @RyanTheDark Год назад +10

    Anakin is going to tear the entire galaxy to the ground.

  • @rhysjones6559
    @rhysjones6559 Год назад +7

    This brought tears to my eyes, incredible story telling

  • @locoarticwolf2181
    @locoarticwolf2181 Год назад +13

    Expanded it a bit and with rest of Ideas (Updated)
    -What if Ashoka Redeemed Vader on Malachor?
    -What if Vader turned Obi-Wan to the Dark-Side on Mustafar?
    -What if Luke Never gave up in the Sequel Era when Ben became Kylo?
    -What if Luke actually Trained Rey then helped her in person when the Resistance needed them?
    -What if Palpatine and a Redeemed Anakin lived at the end of RotJ?(Like those Infinites comics)
    -Wha if Clone Medic Kix succeeded in warning the Jedi of Order 66?
    -What if Maul figured out that Obi-Wan wasn’t his real enemy and joined forces with him on Tatooine?
    -What if Maul and Vader teamed up on Malachor?
    -What if Dooku told Anakin Palpatine was the Sith Lord before he died?
    -What if Legends New Republic fought the First/Final Order?
    -What if Grevious Survived his encounter with Obi-Wan?
    -What if the Empire was Good and the Rebels were Evil(Swapped)?
    -What if Tenebre/Vitiate/Valkrion returned during the movies in the same vain of your Darth JarJar or Jedi Palpatine fics?
    -What if The Rule of Two was abolished after the Clone Wars?
    -What if the Sith Empire returned during the Galactic Civil War?
    -What if Vader lived at the end of RotJ, not redeemed and in charge of the Imperial Remnant?
    -What if Thrawn was a Republic General in the Clone Wars?
    -What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy?
    -What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic?
    -What if Thrawn was a Jedi?
    -What if a Imperial Rebellion separate from the Rebels started,led by Vader and Thrawn.Which really took off around the DS1 destruction with it’s members thinking Palpatine was incompetent/Revenge and needed to reform the Empire?
    -What if Vader never burned on Mustafar?
    -What if Grevious was a Republic General but still hated the Jedi?
    -What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 and later trained the Skywalker Twins?
    -What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc, basically replacing Vader?

    • @Muluga
      @Muluga Год назад +1

      You sure have a-lot of ideas😂

    • @alpha34098
      @alpha34098 Год назад

      "What if Legends New Republic fought the First/Final Order?". This is a "imposibility" because of some factors:
      - By the time that these events would have happened in the Legends Continuity (which would be set between 45 ABY which was the last appearance of the OG Trilogy heroes (except Chewbacca) in the Crucible Novel and 126 ABY, which is the year the events of the Star Wars Legacy Comics start to take place and, by that time they're dead), the New Republic was disbanded and replaced by Galactic Federation of Free Planets (aka Galactic Alliance)
      - The fact that Chewbacca will not be in this story since he was killed in Sernipidal in the early stages of the Yuzzhan Vong War (25ABY, 2 decades before the Events of the Crucible Novel), which adds another point of contention with Disney's Canon, but one that is easy to fix by adding Lumpawaroo (which is his son) into the story
      - The fact of Kylo Ren is another point of contention. I do mention this because both Anakin Solo (which is the last son of Leia Skywalker and Han Solo and the most likely to become Kylo Ren) and Jacen Solo are both dead by this time (the former died en 27 ABY in Mission to Myrkr after he sacrificed himself to ensure the threat of the Voxin (an Anti-Force weapon bio-engineered by the Yuzzhan Vong) would never be unleashed and the latter (who became Darth Caedus at the time) died in 41 ABY at the hands of her sister Jaina Solo in the Battle of Uroro Station (which was the final Battle of the Second Galactic Civil War))

  • @anvos658
    @anvos658 Год назад +9

    An interesting consideration that instead of pushing Anakin to the dark side, this completely backfires on Palpatine and makes Anakin trust him less and the jedi more.

  • @libertyprime5923
    @libertyprime5923 Год назад +6

    Ahsoka gets executed
    Me: (internal screaming)

  • @luciferneverchanges5841
    @luciferneverchanges5841 Год назад +8

    Anakin would have lost his shit and abandoned the Jedi and tried to kill Tarkin and maybe even kill Palpy. Also, I think Anakin would have felt her death.

  • @prod.7aco194
    @prod.7aco194 3 дня назад

    Damn that part where the clones are trying to comfort Ahsoka damn near made me tear up that was one of the saddest parts of any video you’ve made. Really well written

  • @kimzyeryoz9639
    @kimzyeryoz9639 Год назад +6

    So basically Palpatine could have avoided this outcome by simply giving Anakin a consoling gift basket after the trial

  • @user-hd5jg7pp9w
    @user-hd5jg7pp9w Год назад +4

    Ohh I remember suggesting this, glad you decided to make it

  • @juliemcintyre428
    @juliemcintyre428 Год назад +8

    If this happened Anakin wouldn't want anything to do with the Jedi and would leave without ever coming back. I can also see Obi-wan eventually doing the same.

    • @1014p
      @1014p 4 месяца назад

      Yes this is most likely. Might even push him to create his own order. Although at that time Anakin was more grounded and less tilted in how he reacted to events.

  • @JLoC.2479
    @JLoC.2479 Год назад +6

    Execution got me in tears, anakin should have sought out dooku to replace savage and ventress, what if pong krell escaped? Dooku makes him apprentice replacing ventress&savage, since hes a master let him use lightning w free hands(400lbs 8 - 9foot 4arms naturally ambedextrous, only jedi to master form4&6 jarkai w twin saberstaffs and lightning) make him same look but brown black robes w grey clone armor instead of white w sepratist or sith symbols w twin hinged saberstaffs crimson to replace green , violet/purple replace blue

  • @magpiekritik3123
    @magpiekritik3123 Год назад +11

    ... Hmmm ... Looking forward to it ... I also too have a suggestion
    What if Barriss Offee killed Anakin in their duel before the end of Ahsoka's trial
    (Anakin's death would greatly disrupt Palpatine/Sidious plans but maybe he would see potential of a new apprentice in ether Barris or Ahsoka)

    • @Lauren_567
      @Lauren_567 Год назад

      He’d probably just go get Maul back honestly

    • @magpiekritik3123
      @magpiekritik3123 Год назад

      @@Lauren_567 I believe Pente Patrol has made similar What If's involving Maul

  • @andrewwiggins7968
    @andrewwiggins7968 Год назад +2

    24,102 views Premiered Jan 29, 2023 #shorts #short #AnakinSkywalker
    What would've happened if Anakin's Padawan was Convicted of Bombing the Jedi Temple and sentenced to Execution?

  • @ch62013
    @ch62013 Год назад +6

    This will get dark. What if Shmi Skywalker WAS AN Mandalorian?

  • @unluckyme213
    @unluckyme213 Год назад +6

    well that's one way to make me sob. such a great story, and they are getting better and better. there isn't one of your what ifs that didn't make me at least sad

  • @Alex-yy5wo
    @Alex-yy5wo Год назад +1

    Anakin would blow up like Super Saiyan Goku on Namek

  • @elcowabungahe-man6156
    @elcowabungahe-man6156 Год назад +2

    Great narrative is incredible how things could change by a single decision

  • @johnpittsii7524
    @johnpittsii7524 Год назад +7

    What if Anakin fell in love with Bo katan . Also what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or master pong krell

    • @Jango_Fett22
      @Jango_Fett22 Год назад +2

      Anakin would have been cheating on padme if he dated Bo katan

  • @danielharman572
    @danielharman572 Год назад +5

    Ezra using the world between worlds to save asoka from death by drawing her into the world between worlds and administrating an antidote thus saving her life would change the future in ways that would be interesting to see. So many possibilities to discover and explore it could be fun. Keep up the good work. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

  • @MarkoDash
    @MarkoDash Год назад +6

    this is how you get Vader early, a Vader who still has 3 of his limbs.
    edit: i suspect Palpatine would have to atleast appear to try and save her, otherwise you have a knightfall level darkside boosted Anakin/Vader coming for Palps.

  • @anthonykodaski6161
    @anthonykodaski6161 Год назад +2

    Tears. Even though you are clearly not in a good recording set up, you still brought me tears with Asoka’s death.

  • @MrScaryPasta
    @MrScaryPasta Год назад +6

    I don’t think Anakin would join the Dark Side if Ahsoka died. It’s true he’d unleash the full extent of his power, which is being powered by his emotions, but he would not join the man who killed his Padawan. If anything Anakin would kill Palpatine once he realized the Clone Wars was all his doing.
    Plus it was the war that turned Barriss Offee to the Dark Side. Therefore giving Anakin even more of a reason to kill the Sith Lord responsible for all the suffering caused. Not to mention the death of Qui Gon, and the countless murder attempts on Padme too.

    • @panniguin862
      @panniguin862 Год назад +1

      I mean, joining the 'dark side' doesn't necessarily mean joining Palps, there's other darksiders and even Sith like Maul around so for all we know Anakin could kick off another sect outside of the rule of two shittery.

  • @josephfenech9401
    @josephfenech9401 Год назад +6

    Anakin will definitely irreversibly turn to the dark side, enemy of the Jedi and Sith!!! While keeping his morales and code!

  • @tommyalmeyda1253
    @tommyalmeyda1253 Год назад +2

    Luved it!
    Thanks!

  • @swissball99
    @swissball99 Год назад +2

    Jedi mind tricks pov: i...exist?
    Anakin when he becomes a master: i am on rhis council and i am a master

  • @obuniaaron3700
    @obuniaaron3700 Год назад +8

    Can't wait to see anakins reaction

  • @SirDriperHat
    @SirDriperHat Год назад +6

    What if the Grand Army of the Republic have used an army of conscripts/volunteers mixed with the clone army

    • @wargamesmaster
      @wargamesmaster Год назад +4

      For that to happen, the CIS would need to become more of a threat to the galaxy, including organic recruits of their own and MUCH better droids (and maybe replace old models by new ones, like the B1 by the BX (since the commando droids were just prototypes destined to replace the B1 model at some point in the future).

    • @eidoneverchoosen1171
      @eidoneverchoosen1171 Год назад +1

      Better what if both the grand army of the republic and the separatists army used, clones, droids, humans and aliens soldiers on both sides armies. Order 66 would be different, and both sides truly be Grey no true black or white, good or evil sides.

    • @wargamesmaster
      @wargamesmaster Год назад +2

      @@eidoneverchoosen1171 So... WWI in space?

    • @SirDriperHat
      @SirDriperHat Год назад

      @wargamesmaster what did the other commented?

    • @wargamesmaster
      @wargamesmaster Год назад +1

      @@SirDriperHat He erased his comment? Weird, he just said that both sides would be on equal terms (clones, humans, aliens and droids) and the war will not be as black and white as originally and the manner he presented his argument reminded me of WWI (people going to war not out of hatred or glory but to protect their homes and fight for their country).

  • @joshadley
    @joshadley Год назад +4

    that kicked ass

  • @SamCaiman14
    @SamCaiman14 9 месяцев назад +1

    There are 4 ways I see this going, all of this assuming Barriss is caught:
    1) Obi Wan, Anakin, Plo are about to leave. Yoda takes personal responsibility and offers Anakin to be Grand Master not as a make up because he takes it as a calling from The Force that the Jedi have lost their way and the Chosen One is there for a reason.
    2) The Jedi Order pulls out of the Clone Wars. They can no longer trust the Republic and relocate their seat to another planet.
    3) Anakin, Plo, Obi and Yoda leave the order. Mace Windu being in charge and he falls to Order 66. They all face Sidious and end the empire immediately.
    4) Ahsoka awakens the Daughter's powers and survive or Anakin awaken that in her by trying to revive her. This is assuming she is not immediately incinerated.
    The reason I dont see this working out for Palpatine in any scenario is that, unlike the Jedi, he had sole executive authority to pardon Ahsoka. And Anakin would never forgive him for that. He knows the council was divided. Palpatine would have no excuse.

  • @adamk9303
    @adamk9303 Год назад +6

    What if Plo koon was at the temple when Anakin attacked

  • @kahneanimated2655
    @kahneanimated2655 Год назад +6

    Bro, ppsw do you have a vendetta against ahsoka or something. As the quote goes "This is getting out of hand"

    • @1014p
      @1014p 4 месяца назад

      Ashoka is probably the best thing added to the series. Not sure about the live action, they chose a pretty stiff actress to portray such an agile Jedi style.

  • @thedutchnerd3895
    @thedutchnerd3895 Год назад +4

    I have some ideas
    what if dooku killed yoda in aotc
    what if evan peel survived the citadel
    what if dooku trained obi wan kenobi
    what if yoda trained obi wan kenobi
    what if anakin skywalker was born in the old republic era
    what if anakin skywalker left the jedi order as a padawan
    what if ahsoka never left the jedi order
    what if anakin skywalker trained kannan jarrus and
    what if order 66 failed

  • @ch4rliegaming
    @ch4rliegaming Год назад +5

    anakin would leave the jedi order and hate palpatine
    anakin would turn into a like dark side state and murder the real bomber
    and probably members of the senate

  • @metroranger7295
    @metroranger7295 Год назад +2

    I could see a lot of younger Jedi following Anakin into exile, I don't think they would join the CIS BUT I don't think they would stay within the Republic.

  • @linda-0587
    @linda-0587 Год назад +6

    ….Anakin’s killing everyone 😆

    • @kahneanimated2655
      @kahneanimated2655 Год назад +2

      Even padmé?

    • @linda-0587
      @linda-0587 Год назад +2

      Okay, maybe not Padme….and *hopefully* not Obi-Wan…but the Chancellor and Council….yeah, he’s going to *HATE* them, and for sure leave the Order

    • @linda-0587
      @linda-0587 Год назад +3

      Huh…he took that better than I was hoping he would 😭

    • @matthewmann8969
      @matthewmann8969 Год назад +2

      Except Obi Wan, Plo Koon, Padme, Shaak Ti, Yoda, And Bail those would be the only exceptions yeah.

  • @Now_Roxas
    @Now_Roxas Год назад +3

    Havent watched but my gues is
    Anakin commits genocide
    The republic goes to shit
    Maul takes over

  • @rrensdenn4382
    @rrensdenn4382 Год назад +5

    Would have loved to see padme offer to name liea after ahsoka or shmi and have anakin smile but refuse. (Have an image of the ghost of them 2 behind him) (for sake of argument let's just say shmi was just force sensitive enough to project herself to him briefly

  • @00martoneniris86
    @00martoneniris86 Год назад +4

    What if master Fay traind Anakin Skywalker do this one for Masso 2010

  • @CalaebThomsen
    @CalaebThomsen Год назад +4

    if that's not a good idea i'd like to hear what you think about that got the feeling the clones are trying to arrest the chancllor because they are kind of pointing their gun their the chancllor

  • @NormandySR2XO
    @NormandySR2XO Год назад +2

    I could see Anakin leaving The Jedi Order over this and not only that but wanting to get out of the galaxy altogether by relaunching The Outbound flight project.

  • @00martoneniris86
    @00martoneniris86 Год назад +4

    What if trilla survived
    What if Cal kestis killed Darth vader on fortress inquisitorius
    What if trilla killed Cal kestis cere junda on fortress inquisitorius
    What if Darth vader killed cere junda Cal kestis on fortress inquisitorius

  • @umbreonmaster8921
    @umbreonmaster8921 10 месяцев назад

    6:50 - 7:40 I teared up as this description was happening. The music fit this perfectly.

  • @LCBK
    @LCBK 5 месяцев назад +2

    What if Ahsoka was executed for the bombing then Anakin brought in the real culprit Barris

  • @DarthRevan8976
    @DarthRevan8976 Год назад +2

    I would have thought that after learning of his little sister's death, Anakin would have not only hated the republic for it but also gone full Darth Vader on the jedi order

  • @jeffheithaus9120
    @jeffheithaus9120 Год назад +4

    I have a very interesting idea. What if General Kalani join the Rebel Forces? I feel the Tactical Droid have location of many forget and abandon Droid Factors the Rebels could have gone to and start up and reprogram Battle Droids to help their forces out.

  • @gabrielmalpica5866
    @gabrielmalpica5866 Год назад +5

    What if Anakin Was Born in the Old Republic Era

  • @PuppyLoverSilver
    @PuppyLoverSilver Год назад +3

    I feel like Anakin wouldn't inform the Council about Palpatine telling him the Tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise, because he wouldn't want Padme to have the same outcome as Ahsoka. From there, I feel like the story would pretty much go the same way. Interesting video, though!

  • @dakotalange2858
    @dakotalange2858 Год назад +4

    What if Darth bane was found by the Jedi before the sith

    • @joseestevezhernandez558
      @joseestevezhernandez558 Год назад +2

      Problem is Bane was an imperial soldier when they found out he was force sensitive... I reallu doubt the jedi would had a say on that. Sith didn't limited themselves to train toddlers like the jedi

    • @dakotalange2858
      @dakotalange2858 Год назад +1

      At that time the Jedi don’t either the reforms weren’t in place yet so he could’ve been trained

  • @ericcrabtree7075
    @ericcrabtree7075 Год назад +6

    What if the Sith practice the light side of the force but are still rivals to the Jedi

  • @adriandj3141
    @adriandj3141 Год назад +2

    Anakin would have gone ultra sith mode and he would have 0 reservations about slaughtering the Jedi.
    At that point the order had already burned their trustworthiness in Anakin’s eyes and letting Ahsoka be executed would be the last straw.

  • @imember7375
    @imember7375 Год назад +7

    Well barriss is dead

  • @jasondavis1453
    @jasondavis1453 Год назад +2

    Palps had his lightsaber hidden in statues in his office.
    Palps lightsaber burst forth from a dwarti sage statue

  • @00martoneniris86
    @00martoneniris86 Год назад +4

    What if master Fay traind Anakin Skywalker

  • @oliversherman2414
    @oliversherman2414 11 месяцев назад +2

    This was a sad scenario, but still an interesting one

  • @reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134
    @reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134 6 месяцев назад

    Another great story once again , Pente Patrol is such a great Star Wars Alternate Universe writer 👏🏾 easily one of my favourites on RUclips.

  • @itzfedora_yt4577
    @itzfedora_yt4577 Год назад +7

    Anakin is gonna flip his shit

    • @Jango_Fett22
      @Jango_Fett22 Год назад +1

      I’m gonna go to clone force 99 because I know how mad the general gets so I’m hanging out with clone force 99 so Anakin doesn’t accidentally kill me

  • @zeuxconors2185
    @zeuxconors2185 Год назад +2

    Duuude I was just about to comment on a video that u should do this

  • @AbridgeKiritoo
    @AbridgeKiritoo 3 месяца назад

    ok shaak ti waiting at the stairs for anakin was amazing and brought a tear to my eye

  • @dakotalange2858
    @dakotalange2858 Год назад +4

    Valentine Day what if requests!
    What if Atris fell in love with the Meetra surik
    What if Jango Fett fell in love with Zam wesell and raised boba
    What if General Gerivious fell in love with Shaak Ti
    What if Obi wan secretly married Satine
    What if Ahsoka fell in love with lux bobtari
    What if Darth Bane fell in love with Dark lady Githany

    • @DLR1997
      @DLR1997 Год назад +1

      Bane and Githany were in love with each other, but broke up because of different ideologies

    • @dakotalange2858
      @dakotalange2858 Год назад

      Ya but she changed her mind almost made it out of the cave and was going back to him when she realized khan was insane kinda wonder what wouldn’t happened if she lived

    • @DLR1997
      @DLR1997 Год назад +1

      True but I wonder what's going to happen if she found out that it was Bane who told him about about The Thought Bomb

    • @dakotalange2858
      @dakotalange2858 Год назад

      She knew it was bane who told him as he also used another ritual that cause a huge fire or something by channeling all their dark side power

  • @w1ndgeneral226
    @w1ndgeneral226 Год назад +4

    Here's an idea for a video(though I'm not sure if you'll do it): *what if General Grievous wore the Carnage symbiote from Marvel comics?*

  • @kevinwise1997
    @kevinwise1997 Год назад +4

    What if, Obi-wan *actually* killed Maul on Naboo?

  • @Papucs06
    @Papucs06 Год назад +4

    What if Anakin and Padme had triplets?

  • @00martoneniris86
    @00martoneniris86 Год назад +4

    What if Pre vizla was force sensitive and killed Darth Maul

  • @ivebeenlookingforwardtothi5752
    @ivebeenlookingforwardtothi5752 Год назад +2

    What if Dooku survives his final duel. Like he escaped the “Invincible Hand”

    • @anvos658
      @anvos658 Год назад

      He's not, as even if Anakin didn't Palpatine would definitely arrange his assassination in Republic or Jedi custody, he knew way too much.

    • @ivebeenlookingforwardtothi5752
      @ivebeenlookingforwardtothi5752 Год назад

      @@anvos658 give me a medal for predicting this would happen. Just for u I’m changing it.

    • @anvos658
      @anvos658 Год назад +1

      @@ivebeenlookingforwardtothi5752 Well 50% of the time that still ends in Palpatine arranging assassins to try and take out Dooku before he can spill the beans. Going off script at the stage he was supposed to die is very much going rouge and since the CIS couldn't win militarily by then, Dooku's only play would be to expose Sidius and hope this would let him sue for peace, while forcing the republic to reform. Still could be a fun scenario, where he recruits Maul, Grevious, and whoever else he still can in this timeline, for a desperation play where he sneaks himself into the Senate to publicly call out Palpatine, and then Maul, jumps Sidius from above to force him to draw his lightsabers in front of the senate.

  • @spamminamxn
    @spamminamxn Год назад +4

    i think you should do part 2 if what if yoda raised luke and leia

  • @mattiasstrickler2305
    @mattiasstrickler2305 Год назад +4

    I would like to see what if analog came with obi wan to udupau in revenge of the with and how that impacts lord sidious plans

  • @00martoneniris86
    @00martoneniris86 Год назад +2

    What if master Fay traind Anakin Skywalker do this one for masso 2010

  • @mitchellpayne8988
    @mitchellpayne8988 Год назад +2

    This already has me crying at the beginning 😭

  • @georgejcox9241
    @georgejcox9241 Год назад +4

    I have A idea of A What If. What if Sabine Wren was A Mandalorian Jedi and had training from Ahsoka Tano.

  • @connormorgan6884
    @connormorgan6884 Год назад +4

    This is an interesting theory but...
    Personally I feel like if ahsoka did get executed I think Anakin would fall down a much darker path.
    This is just my opinion but I don't believe anakin would stay in the Jedi order and considering how he reacted to his mother's death, I bet you he'd massacre the courts and those who executed Ahsoka would die as well. Tarkin would be lucky if he got out of there alive.
    As for Barriss? I don't see anakin giving up to find the person responsible for Ahsoka's death. I guarantee you eventually he would find out and he'd make her suffer far more than what happened in the clone wars.
    If there's one thing I learned about Anakin Skywalker is that he is very avengeful when those he loved are killed. When he thought konobi died he went out of his way to try to kill the guy responsible not realizing konobi was still alive.
    Or even if anakin didn't massacre the courts, Ahsoka's death would most certainly push anakin away from the order and possibly even the republic.
    Pissing off anakin is basically signing a death warrant. I don't know if Anakin would join count duku in that situation but he'd most likely never see Jedi the same way again.