OMG! I totally forgot about this. I am so glad I saw a random tweet about Melanie Amaro. Seeing her name made me recall this amazing performance instantly! I love it!
@21SPICY I agree with you - I didn't say she isn't fantastic on a regular basis! I'm just having this feeling that I wouldn't have bought her album if she just sang everything like Hero. This week, she showed some versatility - it's still her, but she can take some risks.
Fairplay to Carly for singing it so well when she's only 13. On the other hand, I would like to see her even attempt that last note Melanie sang. Personally, I think Melanie wipes the floor with Carly. That last note is just otherworldly, it's that good.
@DripperBen101 Anyone with two ears is with you! If either one comes in second, I'm ok as long as the other comes in first. But I think that both of them have great careers ahead of them.
Carly definitely blows her away on this song anyways.She lives the song as she sings it and connects with the audience more.Melanie is however a master at the high notes. They are both future superstars for sure.
She is extremely good and does what I call a clean version of this song . Have a look at Carly Rose Sonenclar ,Melanie is deserving of a long career in Singing . Every so often you see a performance that staggers you . Carly Rose is 13 years old and her performance of this same NIna Simone song is clearly Superior . She is as good as any performer has ever been in any of these singing /talent reality shows . Do yourself a favour and check Carly Rose out .
That last note. I said got damn.
Lol you said GOT damn
OMG! I totally forgot about this. I am so glad I saw a random tweet about Melanie Amaro. Seeing her name made me recall this amazing performance instantly! I love it!
Not only the last note's awsome, but also how she finishes it with a vibrato! Amazing!!!
Greatest performance I’ve ever seen
Melanie killed this sound! Love how she is stepping it up!!!!
the last note killed me.
Melanie.just.gave.me.goose.bumps.
Dam cant stop watching thiz video. She iz so awsome
Finally! Switching it up.
That last part gave me shivers
I fall in love her voice *-*
Absolutely amazing.
fuuckk last note killed me....josh and melanie both need a contract
That note she hit at the end gave me shivers all.over
extremely good!!!
@21SPICY I agree with you - I didn't say she isn't fantastic on a regular basis! I'm just having this feeling that I wouldn't have bought her album if she just sang everything like Hero. This week, she showed some versatility - it's still her, but she can take some risks.
Novita from X Factor Indonesia..she's sing this song last night...I think she's amazing too.. like Melanie...:)
luv her voice
wow. you are fantastic.
Awesome key at the end!
Both Carly and Melanie are amazing, they just have totally different styles, so they cannot be compared
Fairplay to Carly for singing it so well when she's only 13. On the other hand, I would like to see her even attempt that last note Melanie sang. Personally, I think Melanie wipes the floor with Carly. That last note is just otherworldly, it's that good.
get it girl!!
she should win this competition!!! who's with me?
Well, Carly Rose could be amazing her own way, but she'll never reach that fu****g last note!
Melanie, Carly, Jeff... they're all amazing. The end.
TheSmileygirl90 tf u put Jeff in there for 💀
@DripperBen101 Anyone with two ears is with you! If either one comes in second, I'm ok as long as the other comes in first. But I think that both of them have great careers ahead of them.
That note at the end. That won her the competition, I believe.
Carly definitely blows her away on this song anyways.She lives the song as she sings it and connects with the audience more.Melanie is however a master at the high notes. They are both future superstars for sure.
Ralph Lavoie Were you on crack
That.Final.Note.
:O
you cant compare carly and melanie the styles differ too much both awesome
1st!
Josh and melanie for the top 2!
who's with me??
But she hit them notes though
I love trying to attempt the final note .. sometimes i succeed sometimes i fail
If she duet with Novita Dewi from Indonesia,i think it will be great!they r really good
She is extremely good and does what I call a clean version of this song . Have a look at Carly Rose Sonenclar ,Melanie is deserving of a long career in Singing . Every so often you see a performance that staggers you . Carly Rose is 13 years old and her performance of this same NIna Simone song is clearly Superior . She is as good as any performer has ever been in any of these singing /talent reality shows . Do yourself a favour and check Carly Rose out .
حلو
Melanie and Carly Rose should do a duet of this song!!!
I don't like Melanie that much but this is beyond amazing
Why are y'all comparing Carly to her.Melanie is older so she has a more matured voice.CArly is still young so when she gets older she will be great
Slay bish!
@DripperBen101 me... #TeamMelanieAmaro
No comparison to carly (a wanna be disney singer at best) Melanie should only be compared to Whitney and there's only a thin line between the two
@aussiegreen she switching nothing. u just been listening to the dumb judges! shes predictable alright, Predictably GOOD!!
Better than Carly rose soneclare
I didnt like it.. but the way she ended it was jaw dropping
Shut*
Carly isn't a wannabe.. I like carly more though.
How can she ruin that song so much.. listen too the original then u know what im talking about.. bad choise
Well u are literally the only who who felt that way so sucks to be u
carly rose is better