@@andrematos5673 Tribute to Freddie Mercury is a first time he sing without guitar in 1992. James sing with Iommy and Bryan May on guitars and the others Queen's members
I'd love to hear the audio in the actual release to get a sense of how well James's vocals actually sounded,the vocals from S&M set a very high standard(even if the vocals were slightly autotuned you could tell that his performance was solid regardless)and they separated S&M from being just a live album and more of a Studio album even if it isn't
@@JaymzH2 Well I still maintain it sounds fucking fantastic. It's such a pet peeve for me that autotune is automatically some huge sin to so many people.
Can't imagine how the people there must have felt .. having heard this version live....it gave me goosebumps..just watching it on big screen on premier night...
It's one of the best concerts they've ever had. I saw a dark Hetfield through his playing, he had something heavy pushing on his soul, and it gave me the impression that at this concert he remembered who he was and the old hetfield emerged a little bit but in combination with his nostalgia about the golden youth days. maby that's the reason he went again for rehab, it was something about him at this concert, unresolved issues, it was a very silent hetfield compared to other live performances, even the unforgiven, it was about him that part. i hope he gets well because for me as a fan, any version of hetfield is ok. if the golden days are behind, i am totaly fine with the happy james as long as he is still playing. Maybe watching the show at the theater helped also. :) P.S.: probably knowing that at some point in time you will be physically unable to do what you want, and all of that live vibe will be present only in your memory, and all of this will be gone one day, maybe it's a pretty hard pill to swallow. fuck, all things end, but the memory remains. :)
Oscar Molino James was adamant to have this song a spot on Death Magnetic. There were James Metallica songs, and there were songs personal to him like NEM, unforgiven, Shine, God That Failed, Low Mans Mama Said and Dyers
I was chatting with a guy on Instagram, he asked what song i hoped they played...I instantly replied Unforgiven 3. Stoked on this one! It's the best Unforgiven!
It’s not for the casual metal fans... which is probably why it made it onto the setlist of the most mainstream metal band for their very mainstream concert film in theatres, which is mostly for casual metal fans because it’s Metallica Bruh
I saw S&M2 in the theater in Dublin Ireland last night and this was absolutely beautiful!! The whole theater was silent! I feel this S&M topped the first
James actually made a mistake during the "Forgive me, forgive me not" section. He sang one beat late, or rather, he sang the low "Forgive me, forgive me not" three times instead of two like the studio version. Hence, that's why it ended so anticlimactic and he never sang "why can't I forgive me". You can already hear that the orchestra moved on to the solo section, and James just stopped singing altogether. If you start singing along from 5:58 "forgive meeeee, forgive me noooot, forgive meeeee, forgive me, why can't I forgive me" you'll hear that it would make sense then.
Watched the gig in the cinema last night. For the whole first half I felt that the orchestra was noticeably more silent than the band, and I couldn't tell if it was down to my cinema or the sound mix. After the intermission everything felt more even and I could tell that the orchestra had its place (as if someone had a word about the sound). Aside that gripe I liked this song the best along with Anasthesia - holy shit that was awesome. The conductor earned his money tonight.
@@roncriswell2685 They mention him in the beginning of the film before the concert starts (source: seen yesterday in cinema, yes it was awesome, not as live, but still)
cool that James just sung it, and the strings and stuff were cool, but I think they missed a golden opportunity to not propel and launch that ending and solo into the stratosphere without the rest of the band. Maybe the proper cinema/release version will sound better in the mix, but to me it sounded to flat and weak without the ending.
Just a thought. Most Metallica albums are in E standard tuning except for Load Reload and St Anger. I wonder if the charts were written in E then just transposed down a semitone for live or if they were written in Eb.
David Oakes death magnetic is in Eb, the whole album. When they play the older songs live, they tune down to b to accommodate for James’s vocals being lower than when he was younger. With that said, chances are that because they were dealing with James’s range being lower, they likely charted everything in Eb, because you don’t want to have the accompaniment sounding great, but a singer who sounds out of tune or is struggling to hit the higher notes of a song. What I’m more curious about since I never played orchestral music is: is do the symphony tune flat, or do they play flat in standard tuning? If they tune, do the stringed instruments need to be set up and adjusted the same way a guitar does? Like, bridge height, intonation, etc.
Actually Corey both Death Magnetic And Hardwired were recorded in E but Metallica has played live in Eb since the mid/late 90s. And tunes the newer songs down just like the older stuff previous to Load.
Better version of the song. If only it was like this on the album, although the album version was class, this would have ended The Unforgiven trilogy perfectly
Metallica needs to do a song with Lindsey Stirling that would rock she's awesome on the violin and Metallica cross are awesome combine those two together I think that would be great
This is going to be released in very high quality soon. I'm surprised Metallica did not ask people not to record this and spoil it like some bootleggers at a gas station
If you look at their instagram they did post signs saying no audio or video recording. Of course there's always gonna be people that do anyways. I'm thinking that's why all these recordings are of people sitting way in the back not near the front.
rapidslime I saw a vid of someone sitting directly behind the orchestra so that isn’t the case. I think it was Halo on Fire but I had to click off the video cause the guy next to the recorder was singing super out of tune and it ruined James’s vocals😂
It’s the running I think that throws him off. With the guitar it kind of puts you in the right place especially when you always sing it while playing. Hearing it totally different and the sound of the song is completely different. A rock singer alone with a symphony doesn’t really ever happen probably because the range has to be so different.
Dean makredes true, no RUclips video has ever sounded anything close to what metallica actually sounds like live, even the high quality pro shot ones don’t have a resemblance
Yes. This will be released in high-definition full movie theater quality October 9th. It's kind of f***** up that this guy released this crappy version.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Ooooooh my goooood finally, same black shirt and hair in 1999
Just saw the movie.... This is the top moment of the concert... I'm speechless....
what movie
ruclips.net/video/sp9m8nfF5rY/видео.html
Oh my God! James’ voice only with the symphony! What else could I ask for? Goosebumps
waitin for s&M3 in 2039
No need bro you just can say waiting Metallica next concert next month that's all
@@Corvus922 hahahaha if they live maybe 103 years old😂
James will be 76 in 2039
Alperen Dizdar shut up
xd
Man his stance is always the same when he doesn't have his guitar with him when he is singing, what a performance man.
That's his power stance--with or without his guitar. 😎
He's born that way
I can't wait to hear it in a better quality.
Absolutely brother,can't wait for the Blu-ray and CD of this show\m/
This was definatelly the highlight of a night I will never forget!
I saw them play it live in Lincoln in 2018. BUT THERE WASN'T A SYMPHONY BACKING THEM!!!! freaking awesome!!
I was at night 2 and this performance was amazing!
Considering he went into rehab weeks after this adds a whole massive level of significance to this amazing performance.
My thoughts exactly 😭
Yes it does.
I don’t see why.
@@Kado_Tornado well then you clearly have never listenned to the lyrics.
I wish I could've been there. I'd like to see a concert where they perform all 3 Unforgivens consecutively.
I would go for a concert where they play only the three of them and thats it
Yesterday I had goose bumps during the song in the cinema.
First time I saw James performing without guitar...weird, but I love this new version!!
He already performed Whiplash in 93 and Seek and Destroy without a mic, it's pretty funny you should check it out
He also sang one without a guitar with apocalyptica back in 2011.
ruclips.net/video/JjS-4B1tmog/видео.html
Well , I saw James performing many times without guitar
For example
-Queen tribute
-When James burned his arm
-performing with guns and roses
@@soy-caleno-y-que6490
@Joe Wasikowski
@André Matos
thanks I'm gonna check this for sure!
@@andrematos5673 Tribute to Freddie Mercury is a first time he sing without guitar in 1992. James sing with Iommy and Bryan May on guitars and the others Queen's members
I'd love to hear the audio in the actual release to get a sense of how well James's vocals actually sounded,the vocals from S&M set a very high standard(even if the vocals were slightly autotuned you could tell that his performance was solid regardless)and they separated S&M from being just a live album and more of a Studio album even if it isn't
Even here sounds pretty awesome
I was lucky enough to see this live and the whole band was tight as fuck. A truly spectacular performance
Slightly autotuned..? They re-recorded all of the vocals for S&M and put tons of autotune on it...
@@JaymzH2 Well I still maintain it sounds fucking fantastic. It's such a pet peeve for me that autotune is automatically some huge sin to so many people.
Can't imagine how the people there must have felt .. having heard this version live....it gave me goosebumps..just watching it on big screen on premier night...
It was my favorite moment of the night. I teared up. And im a casual fan. My hubby is a hardcore fan.
It's one of the best concerts they've ever had. I saw a dark Hetfield through his playing, he had something heavy pushing on his soul, and it gave me the impression that at this concert he remembered who he was and the old hetfield emerged a little bit but in combination with his nostalgia about the golden youth days. maby that's the reason he went again for rehab, it was something about him at this concert, unresolved issues, it was a very silent hetfield compared to other live performances, even the unforgiven, it was about him that part. i hope he gets well because for me as a fan, any version of hetfield is ok. if the golden days are behind, i am totaly fine with the happy james as long as he is still playing. Maybe watching the show at the theater helped also. :)
P.S.: probably knowing that at some point in time you will be physically unable to do what you want, and all of that live vibe will be present only in your memory, and all of this will be gone one day, maybe it's a pretty hard pill to swallow. fuck, all things end, but the memory remains. :)
This song is very personal to JH
Erwin Agustin why??
Oscar Molino James was adamant to have this song a spot on Death Magnetic. There were James Metallica songs, and there were songs personal to him like NEM, unforgiven, Shine, God That Failed, Low Mans Mama Said and Dyers
I was chatting with a guy on Instagram, he asked what song i hoped they played...I instantly replied Unforgiven 3. Stoked on this one! It's the best Unforgiven!
@@gianwinters and the hole st anger album
juan felipe st anger was collaborative effort JH was fucked up then
This Music is perfect and it's not for the casual metal fans
@@Jakevoss96 hahahah american pre-judge
@James Hetfield dont take it personal dude
@@Jakevoss96 yeah its good for popheads who call them selfs metalhead But they havent listened to anything but metallica and megadeth
@@kkhh2840 i have listened to Exodus, Morbid Angel, Death, Gojira, Obituary, Beyond Creation, Misery Index, King Gizzard, Testament, Artillery, Persefone, Ne Obliviscaris , Be'Lakor, Lacuna Coil, Shadow Of Intent, Twilight Force, Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, Rhapsody, Havok, Exhorder, Vektor, Devastation, Dawm Of Demise, Aura, Immolation, Immortal, Abbath, Dimmu Borgir, Mayhem, Burzum, Rush, Mastodon, John Mayor, Stevie Wonder, Aerosmith, Michael Jackson, Protest The Hero, Dream Theater, Quuensryche, Dillinger escape Plan, Arch Enemy, Avantasia, Elvis, Bill Haley, Skinless, Burning Human, In flames and many, many more.
Don't assume we're all popheads.
It’s not for the casual metal fans...
which is probably why it made it onto the setlist of the most mainstream metal band for their very mainstream concert film in theatres, which is mostly for casual metal fans because it’s Metallica
Bruh
What an emotional and moving performance from James. Wow was totally blown away by this.
He is such a talented singer...
I was there! It was so amazing!!!
I saw S&M2 in the theater in Dublin Ireland last night and this was absolutely beautiful!! The whole theater was silent! I feel this S&M topped the first
Absolutely incredible.
Can't wait for an official release
Metallica Forever
I was so ready for that damn solo!!!
James actually made a mistake during the "Forgive me, forgive me not" section.
He sang one beat late, or rather, he sang the low "Forgive me, forgive me not" three times instead of two like the studio version.
Hence, that's why it ended so anticlimactic and he never sang "why can't I forgive me". You can already hear that the orchestra moved on to the solo section, and James just stopped singing altogether.
If you start singing along from 5:58 "forgive meeeee, forgive me noooot, forgive meeeee, forgive me, why can't I forgive me" you'll hear that it would make sense then.
Good thing there's 2 shows, he'll get it right the second time. (I hope he did)
Wow, it’s almost as if he’s human or something?! 😱
Damn James is fantastic 🤘🤘🤘 he sings so good right here 🤘🤘🤘
very nice voice of James ....well done Papa Het😁👍👍
1999 / 2019
I LOVE METALLICA \\m//S&M 2
James after this gig: "you did very well on these songs, You're hired!" (next tour full of symphony)
1:46 i thaught it was 1999 James
Its a hologram!
Oh my god! This is amazing!
It was so awesome!
Watched the gig in the cinema last night. For the whole first half I felt that the orchestra was noticeably more silent than the band, and I couldn't tell if it was down to my cinema or the sound mix. After the intermission everything felt more even and I could tell that the orchestra had its place (as if someone had a word about the sound). Aside that gripe I liked this song the best along with Anasthesia - holy shit that was awesome. The conductor earned his money tonight.
I loved this. I almost teared up last night. Amazing voice and heart that goes into his songs
Omg!!!!!!!! So lucky are those that went! Why so Fucking epic! G-d his voice, so amazing.
Their best version of this song ever by far
Very great song tank you from argentina
हेटफीलड जी ने कमाल कर दिखाया इस गाने में।
I can't wait to watch this in theaters
James voice is legendary.
Damn it, it's so epic!!
missing michael kamen !!!
We want fixxxxxxxxxxxxxxer
keep dreaming
@@frischregen3905 yes bro
Unfortunately they might not play it.
Just listen to it
My god. You’re never going to get fixxxer live. Just let it go.
what a song man . thanks to MR JH
Within 5 years Artificial Intelligence will create new Metallica songs that you'll be convinced was a long lost Metallica song that was just released.
He is on fire😍😍😍😍😍😍🔥🔥🔥🔥
M.Kamen is watching :(
He took a lot of flack back in the day for working with Metallica. God bless him.
I wish they did a tribute for him before the show
@@thequintessential5503 they will probably put something together for him in the Blu-ray release\m/
@@roncriswell2685 They mention him in the beginning of the film before the concert starts (source: seen yesterday in cinema, yes it was awesome, not as live, but still)
The Quintessential actually they did
Wow.... wow.... Just... Wow.
My wife loves this song this is an interesting version wonder what she'll make of it.
@@davidpearson6346 your comedic reply is original. Well done you, give yourself a pat on the back.
David Pearson 😛
Thanks for uploading man
Wish I could’ve been there in person. Tickets were too expensive even for last row
Quit working at McDonald's and you might be able to put some cash away in your savings for things like concert tickets.
@@assordante2205 Maybe you like paying $500 for tickets in the nose bleeds, but I have better things to do with $500.
cool that James just sung it, and the strings and stuff were cool, but I think they missed a golden opportunity to not propel and launch that ending and solo into the stratosphere without the rest of the band. Maybe the proper cinema/release version will sound better in the mix, but to me it sounded to flat and weak without the ending.
Paul Shand Walker ya I’m pissed. This is anticlimactic and lame
They prevented Lars's fails, that's why band never entered
James is literally 98% of that band.
Oh god,amazing🤘🤘🤘
YES
Just a thought. Most Metallica albums are in E standard tuning except for Load Reload and St Anger. I wonder if the charts were written in E then just transposed down a semitone for live or if they were written in Eb.
David Oakes death magnetic is in Eb, the whole album.
When they play the older songs live, they tune down to b to accommodate for James’s vocals being lower than when he was younger.
With that said, chances are that because they were dealing with James’s range being lower, they likely charted everything in Eb, because you don’t want to have the accompaniment sounding great, but a singer who sounds out of tune or is struggling to hit the higher notes of a song.
What I’m more curious about since I never played orchestral music is: is do the symphony tune flat, or do they play flat in standard tuning? If they tune, do the stringed instruments need to be set up and adjusted the same way a guitar does? Like, bridge height, intonation, etc.
Actually Corey both Death Magnetic And Hardwired were recorded in E but Metallica has played live in Eb since the mid/late 90s. And tunes the newer songs down just like the older stuff previous to Load.
I only wish the band was involved with this one, gotta one of my favourite Metallica songs, especially at the solo, but done really well regardless 😮
fantastic
not a huge fan of the album track, but i have to admit, this version is pretty great.
James's voice was different in Death Magnetic.
I like the original more it has more feeling for me
Holy Shit!! Waiting for the origianl version. Thanks uploader!
Kirk could have play the solo without distortion, couldn’t he?
they finally did this song live
S&M2!!!!!!
A second one? Wtf.....wish somebody told......S&M is my favourite album ever
Wow, that’s different
Yeah it took me by surprise too haha
Fucking incredible!!!
Agreed! 🤘🏼
This is god! Thanks james🙏
James voice though 👌🏻👌🏻
James doesnt know what to do with his hands while singing xD
Felt the same while watching him both shows...
These guys 🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Cause I’m buying it as soon as it does
Way better than the studio version
cool. thanks
Not bad, the intro is cool, but Kirks Solo is missing....
Get well soon Mr. Hetfield
Better version of the song. If only it was like this on the album, although the album version was class, this would have ended The Unforgiven trilogy perfectly
hell yeah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Metallica needs to do a song with Lindsey Stirling that would rock she's awesome on the violin and Metallica cross are awesome combine those two together I think that would be great
Eric Stratford Agreed!
6:20 - what happened there? The song builds to the primal "Forgive me, why can't I forgive me?" yell and he didn't do it :(
Check my video of it from Night #2. He nails it.
This is going to be released in very high quality soon. I'm surprised Metallica did not ask people not to record this and spoil it like some bootleggers at a gas station
If you look at their instagram they did post signs saying no audio or video recording. Of course there's always gonna be people that do anyways. I'm thinking that's why all these recordings are of people sitting way in the back not near the front.
rapidslime I saw a vid of someone sitting directly behind the orchestra so that isn’t the case. I think it was Halo on Fire but I had to click off the video cause the guy next to the recorder was singing super out of tune and it ruined James’s vocals😂
When’s the album coming out???
Back in the day James didn't want to sing, they wanted to get John Bush in as their singer. Now Papa Het is singing with an orchestra.
I kinda wanna watch this, but i also wanna watch it for the first time in the cinema. What should i do??
It’s the running I think that throws him off. With the guitar it kind of puts you in the right place especially when you always sing it while playing. Hearing it totally different and the sound of the song is completely different. A rock singer alone with a symphony doesn’t really ever happen probably because the range has to be so different.
When's this going to be on cd?
I’m too broke :,(
You might kill me, but this great thing much more cool in original! (
Who came here for 5:30
👏👏👏🍸
IIII ?
Nice
Metallica should've taken a couple of months rest before this show so James could recover his voice, he sounds worn down here
It's the video quality. I was there & it sounded excellent
Dean makredes true, no RUclips video has ever sounded anything close to what metallica actually sounds like live, even the high quality pro shot ones don’t have a resemblance
They only play 50 shows a year. He gets plenty of rest. And they never play two shows in two days.
I was waiting for some explosive drum parts at some point, but nah it went all "acoustic"
Was waiting for kirk to rip that solo
It is the weirdest thing that see James w/o his guitar. It makes me feel uncomfortable.
And Kirk not playing Solo
Too bad he messed up the forgive me part. almost perfect vocal preformence.
Don't worry, they'll fix it for the cinema release 😅
@@Zany_Zim Or use the 2nd night if it's better.
One of the beat Kirk's solo and he didn't play it. I know that's an amazing performance, but without Kirk I don't like it
I understand, forgive James or unforgive..
Will Be A Offical Release?
Yes. This will be released in high-definition full movie theater quality October 9th. It's kind of f***** up that this guy released this crappy version.
i think they didn't allow to capture...
I don't think the band will ever come to Greece
Wow. Fast.