The Diary of a Young Girl - Anne Frank - So You Haven't Read
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 окт 2024
- Use code EXTRACREDITS16 for up to 16 FREE MEALS + 3 Surprise Gifts across 6 HelloFresh boxes plus free shipping at bit.ly/3qksy9M !
As Holocaust Remembrance Day approaches we'd like to honor a very special book "The Diary of a Young Girl" by Anne Frank. This gives us a first-hand look into a young Jewish girl's life as she lives in a secret annex during World War II.
Support our channel by watching ad-free on Nebula: nebula.tv/vide...
--- Interested in reading it for yourself? Check it out at your local library! ---
Buy Local: www.indiebound...
Amazon: amzn.to/3jlSy1v
Audible: amzn.to/3NXNe2m
--- Thanks for participating in this week's discussion! ---
We want you to be aware of our community posting guidelines so that we can have high-quality conversations: www.extracredi...
--- Want to support the people who make this show? ---
Become a Patreon Member & Vote on future Extra History episodes! bit.ly/EHPatreon
Or show off your fandom with our merch! extracredits.st...
--- Want more Extra Credits? Subscribe and follow us on social media! ---
Twitter: bit.ly/ECTweet
Facebook: bit.ly/ECFBPage
Instagram: bit.ly/ECisonIn...
Twitch: bit.ly/ECtwitch
Website: extracredits.site/
--- Interested in sponsoring an episode? Email us: extracredits@standard.tv ---
♪ Intro music: "Coffee Beans" by Mike Wuerth
♪ Outro music: "So You Haven't Read Theme" by Tiffany Roman
#SoYouHaventRead #DiaryofaYoungGirl #AnneFrank
Anne frank
"despite everything that happened I honestly believe that people are good at heart"
Anne Frank. ❤
The last point is so profound. I did read the Diary in middle school. I did NOT know that two of her friends were STILL alive. I'm in my thirties now so it's a profound realization that when I read that book, those same two friends were my parents' age now.
Anne Frank and Martin Luther King Jr. were the same age, just to put in perspective.
Both Hanna and Gabi did what most Jews did after WW2 (including my grandparents) and migrated to Israel. They currently live in Jerusalem.
We are honored to have them as part of our community
At one point Frank said she'd like to go to Hollywood and be a scriptwriter. She could certainly have succeeded.
@@Grim_Sister
Is that why a third of Holocaust survivors in Israel live in poverty?
My school board removed this book for being "inappropriate" so I bought the book myself and read it. I asked others i went to school with about the book and they sadly had no idea this book exists. People need to talk about this in schools more instead of removing it. History repeats itself when people are not taught about it.
Its infuriating how these people classify anything that challenge their bigoted views as "inappropriate". The Handmaiden's tales, how to kill a mockingbird and so on.
Welcome to the dangers of Marxism. It’s only gonna get worse
Own them by buying yourself a copy. Plenty of editions are on Amazon. We can't allow the sensitivity mob to erase knowledge of the Holocaust. Especially first-hand accounts like this.
@vehx9316 Lol, what bigoted views do you think you're referring to?!
It got removed because they thought the subject matter was too dark for young kids, which I think is incorrect.
We read a play version in my high school. We’d have people in the class read for the characters. I can’t remember which one I’d read for but I remember we tried to keep the same people for each character. I began to associate my classmate’s voices and my own with those characters. Definitely one of the better reads from high school. It’s sad schools are taking this away. History isn’t pretty. Humans have done horrible things to each other. We must remember
Huh, so did I.
We did that as well.
I actually find concerning the practice of "hiding" the ugly parts of history. That can create the false sensation into the new generations that atrocities can't happen. And that false sensation will inevitably produce atrocities sooner or later.
Don’t worry, if we all pretend it didn’t happen, everyone will be happy, FOREVER!
so did i and i was always Mrs. Frank
I'm reading Frank's diary at the moment. Because of its nature, you can either start at the beginning and work forwards like I'm doing, or dip in anywhere.
I'm finding that reading a couple of entries in the morning is a really good way to start the day, plus a few more before going to sleep.
How a 13yo manages to write with such maturity is astonishing
@Iamnotracistlmao why be racist
@IamnotracistlmaoAnne frank Special Unit: Robot Tank
@@thej8656dude, don’t give attention to replies like these. Just report them.
A useful thing to keep in mind: Anne Frank and MLK Jr. were born in the same year. If not for the actions of evil men, we might still have had them both with us today.
Same with Malcolm x, Fred Hampton and Harvey milk
Another thing to keep in mind is her story is still happening today, to others, all around the world. But we may never hear their stories.
yup, Vsauce mentioned that. Queen Elizabeth 2 is actually older than them.
It's not super likely, even in the best of health it's rare to make it to 90, but the fact that it's even possible is both astounding and horrifying.
I agree with you 💯
I’m very glad you covered this. In my personal reading I came to the choice of currently reading this book or Schindler’s list… I chose Schindler’s list. I will certainly read this book when I can
Schindler's list is also a very good read of the times of WW2...
So many good people have been lost over this mania... v_v
@@LordBloodySoul
*To think, that one person, once seated on a position of power, can decide the fate of hundreds if not millions.*
One day people will discover the truth
Please do read it.
Bruh the fact that you mentioned that schools are pulling this book out of the curriculum is crime. Its still one of the most important books to read even now about 70-80 years later.
*Especially* now.
@@RustBot42 Exactly.
“Oh, but it’s too heavy for the children..” /s
Parents who think this way aren’t prepared to have tough conversations with their kids anyways. So why not let a book, teachers and classmates do it for them and save them the embarrassment of not being prepared to educate their kids about some topics? It’s not an easy topic for kids, THATS exactly why they shouldn’t ban books about it.
@@RustBot42 What do you mean by that exactly? Is there some current event that makes this book relevant?
Heck, I remember learning about the camps in 4-5th grade! I turned out fine along with my classmates and now researching WW 2 history is a hobby of mine.
I feel that shielding kids from tough topics is insulting to children’s intelligence. It’s extremely insulting to survivors of WW 2 in general and their families. And it is insulting to Germany and its citizens who have done a great job at owning up to their past crimes/evils.
Any parents who shields their kids from history because it’s scary, or fact based sex ed is a terrible parent.
Is confusing Denmark and the Netherlands going to become a running gag on this channel? I remember the same mistake being made in the Thirty Years' War series.
Danish, Dutch... Tomaydoh, Tomahdoh... 🤷♂ But yeah, I also remember that mixup from a previous video on this channel. Still loving this channel, but I would swiftly delete this video and re-upload a corrected version if I were them. Nobody has to know ;)
Im assuming its a matter of typos being autocorrected into inaccuracies.
They should do a "So you haven't read European Topography"
Something's rotten in the state of Holland.
@@tithund Holland is a province, not a state.
Never was. Gelderland and Friesland where though
It's said that even though Miep has Anne's diary in her possession, she never opens it and reads it. And when Otto Frank (Anne's father) returns and has possession of Anne's diary, he never opens it and reads it either, until the day he truly knows that Anne is confirmed dead. 😢
So you made a little error. Anne Frank lived in the Netherlands, not Denmark. You used Denmark and Danish instead of the Netherlands and dutch
Between writing, editing, recording, and editing again, how did no one catch this?
This show how much they really care.
it's possible it's a running gag
That’s just Americans for you
When do they do that? I can't find it in the video.
And to think that there are bastards out there who say this never happened
As a matter of fact, i have, and it's absolutely heart breaking. She keeps saying what she'll do when the war is over, but..well...we all know how it ended
Unless I'm hearing wrong - you're saying "Danish edition" rather than "Dutch edition"
Also "after denmarks capitulation"
There's also "the dangers of anti-semitism" instead of "the dangers of fascism" .
@@Budehgong I think *that one* was intended.
@@anttibjorklund1869 They do tend to go hand-in-hand, after all.
@@EricTheKei kicked out of 109 gyms and it's always the gym's fault bro
I thank you so much as a Dutch Israeli Jew for making this.
its always so good to see things to remember our history and i am grateful.
Hope you're doing fine right now
Also a dutch israeli hew but i live in the netherlands
HI 5!
And here's why you have to triple-check your scripts: You can make a short, powerful, important summary of a book, but the only thing anybody will take away is that you can't tell two European countries apart.
Rest well Anne frank ,your legacy will not be forgotten ,you'll be forever remembered. ❤❤❤😭😭😥.
Weirdly enough, I am more interested in watching the episodes about books I actually have read.
Me too, because I generally like to know as little as possible about a book before I read it.
Thank you so much for making these episodes! Especially this one, as it means a lot to me since my great grandparents fled the nazi attrocities.
I remember watching a film adaptation of her life in Middle or High School (can't remember which). Interesting story.
She was only a few years younger than my grandparents, they were only teenagers when the Japanese took control of the Philippines. I wish I had greater appreciation for history when they were still alive, because not asking them about their time during the occupation is one of my greatest regrets
Some scars on the world will never heal nor be forgotten, and this period is unquestionably among them 😟
I hope these scars will never heal, so that we are always reminded of this horrible period and in that way prevent history from repeating itself.
Horrible
@@ZechsMerquise195 Most of the scars have healed but most people think it's still important to remember.
@@kaltaron1284 Indeed.
@@ZechsMerquise195 I mean, scars technically are healed tissue no? People can heal and grow from generational trauma without forgetting the dangers learned. Healing doesn’t mean forgetting. Even personal trauma isn’t treated by making the patient block and forget what happened.
The WW2 time are surely one of the most darkest hour of human life..
Hope people remember how bad war is, for each parties.
Thank you for reminding us of
Yom Hashoa
יום השואה
Let us remember how evil good people can be, so that we can choose our actions with kindness in mind in the future.
I know I suggested Maus, but this is also a really good one to cover. As a Jew, thank you.
I don't see how Denmark capitulating has anything to do with this.
The fact that the Netherlands Denmark mistake is in this clip MULTIPLE times makes me feel like maybe you guys aren't exactly paying close attention to these scripts any more. Like how can I trust your word on important historical nuance if you can't even distinguish two entire nations?
Added the fact that Anne being Dutch is such common knowledge. Did nobody realize this while recording?
might be a running gag on the channel, I could be wrong though
I remember reading this in seventh grade. We only read a small portion aloud, each character having a different reader. I wish I could have read the entirety at once. Even though I know how her story ends, I can’t help but relate to the spunky, teenage Anne.
I'm literally her. 😢😂😭
Same
Read this for 6th grade ELA ages ago, glad I did, an amazing read.
"When freedom burns The final solution Dreams fade away and all hope turns to dust When millions burn The curtain has fallen Lost to the world as they perish in flames"
The Final Solution
Sabaton
Words are true.
i remember reading about this in history class in 8th grade, it's sad how ONE mistake got them caught, if that chandelier in their hideout didn't fall, the intruder wouldn't have even known they were there, the holocaust is probably the worst atrocity in history :(
Thank you for this! I've always been a fan of her, and have spent a lot of time in the Anne Frank museum on my Oculus Quest 2.
I have a reading disability, but I hope to read this one day. Hopefully even in the original language!
She wanted to be a journalist and a writer. At least in part, she became a bestseller! How she changed the would will never replace how she should have been allowed to change the world!
I read this book for the first time when I was 12. I wept at the end when this wonderful person who I had gotten to know had been murdered.
I read this book when I was about 12-13 myself, so I always told my mom in disbelief: she was _my_ age. She went through these horrors at the current age I am. (I don’t know how to express the emotion I felt, so utterly disgusted at the whole thing, having so many people suffer. When I finished the book, it explained how, when and where she died, and to think that if she had survived a few months…
R.I.P. Anne Frank and her friends and family. They were great people ❤🧡💛💚💙💜
We loves too Anne Frank
@@Countryball_StudioRedstone86 broken english💀
You when you realise some people don't have English as a primary language: 😮@@SpitfireEssa
@@Diamond_X_Diamond womp womp
This video came at the right time.
Right now in English class as the time of typing this, we are gonna read books about the Holocaust from survivors
I was lucky enough to visit the museum in Amsterdam, honestly a must visit if your in Amsterdam
One you probably need to plan for though, sadly; I've visited Amsterdam with a friend and were hoping to go, but the queues were collosal so we couldn't get in. Had pancakes on the other side of the nearby river and sat and remembered.
Yea and while being there you could also visit Narnia
the juxtaposition of the story of anne frank to the hello fresh ad is certainly an experience
Ah yes Amsterdam is in Denmark. Someone didn't listen in geography class.
Wait till you hear about the lovely Swiss city of Stockholm 🤭
Chinese city of tokyo
Welp at least we know this channel is made by American RUclipsr…
Oh, and the capital of London, the city of England!
The Bolivian city of Sydney
Wrong tiny flat country with inscrutable language. You may want to reupload 😅.
Compared to countries with actual mountains Denmark and the Netherlands are quite flat. Compared to each other Denmark is somewhat less flat. At least in my experience as a half Danish person living in Amsterdam.
@@olevandongen96 Wait till your hear about Tuvalu and Kiribati. Super tiny and super flat!
@@kenster8270 Doesn't Tuvalu make most of its money from being in charge of the domain name .tv? Kiribati sounds like an atol, too
Own a graphic novella book about her. Watched her story half a dozen times. If the 8 were around today....
I think I own a copy of her book somewhere. RIP to the Frank family.
Despite everything that happened i still believe that people.are good at heart
-anne frank
I read it in middle school. She was a very good writer.
Is the Café where you are setting at real? Because the name is greman for "the present past". This seems to be quite fitting
The cafe's name is different for each episode to match the setting/theme of the book :).
@@safe-keeper1042 Really? That's kinda clever! Like the Simpsons intros back in the 2000s. :)
Thanks so much for watching and learning about literature with us! If you're interested in helping support the show then why not try Hello Fresh? Use code EXTRACREDITS16 for up to 16 FREE MEALS + 3 Surprise Gifts across 6 HelloFresh boxes plus free shipping at bit.ly/3qksy9M ! Also, we've corrected Danish/Dutch dialog on the video! Thanks again for all of your comments and amazing attention to detail, so we can provide the most accurate information in our videos!
Amsterdam is not in Denmark
reupload please
can you do the Secret life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd next plz
attention to detail? this is just basic geography
Amsterdam is in the netherlands
Danish?!?!
The letters at the end are the hebrew letters zain and lamed (z and l) and together they mean zal which stands for "zichrono lebracha" which is pretty much the hebrew RIP
By that do you mean that it's a prayer for the dead?
@@Ggdivhjkjlno, it's not a prayer.
@Ggdivhjkjl its RIP in hebrew which translated ruffly means "to tresure thier memorey"
תודה שהוספתם ז"ל (זיכרונה לברכה)
Reading this in the events of the genocide and starvation happening in gaza hits differently
Just a correction, you imply that Amsterdam is in Denmark, but it's in the Netherlands.
Edit: it's at 1:55 in the video
glad to hear you guys talk about this because everyone should know and read this important book and on that note it has been too long and it is time for a re-read
the video, didn't much discuss what was written but just gives tons of context, which while similar, isn't the same. As if the goal instead was to advertise the book
It is. All of these are meant for you to read the book yourself, not replace it.
Amsterdam is not in denmark
Yea it is from Poland!
Her diary ends just days before the inhabitants of the annex were captured!
Thank you extra Credits for covering this as I am Jewish myself people need to know about the holocaust
As an Israeli jew i much thank you for making this video, and telling the world about Anne Frank’s life.
Thank you very much
Hope you and your family are safe during this horrible time❤
Ummm, Amsterdam is in the Netherlands, not Denmark. She wrote in Dutch.
I knew I'd cry as before I clicked the link and, hoo boy, I was correct. I am thankful that you did this one differently than other "So you haven't read" videos. Thank you for covering this work.
תודה
my great grandfather who died january this year was 4 years older than her
Miep Gies was such a brave woman, as were all the people who helped the people in hiding!
It's important to remember the people who helped and concealed as well as the people trying to escape and hide.
We actually had a extract of this book for our literature class, but the extract was so small that I can honestly say that I've merely glanced the book cover of the book. I thought going into this video that I'd know mostly what was being said but I WAS SO WRONG. Watching this video made me realise how stupid the idea of extracts are. Like summarising context can oftentimes just squash any emotions built up from reading the actual thing and it can alienate some important past conversation between characters. I hate that I was literally given such little content compared to the book. Schools really try to keep you as ignorant as possible. They literally made it so hard to find this book in the library and stuff. They don't even have it sometimes! It's infuriating!
Was hoping the different colors of books would have different language titles for the book. Small detail, I think it's a compliment that I expected that detail, rather than an insult that it wasn't there
Personally I consider ‘If this is a man/the truce’ by Primo Levi a more impactful work on the holocaust. Could be nice to cover in a future episode
The restrictions since Denmark capitulated???
The Netherlands are not Denmark, so I am confused.
Maybe they capitulated at the same time, but I would still appreciate a little correction/clarification. ❤
Just so you know, Mrs. Hannah Elisabeth Pick-Goslar (Hanneli) passed away on 28th October 2022.
Remember the idea of extra astronomy:)
What is sad is that Holland (Netherlands) would never be militarily liberated by the allies. Only after the surrender of the Axis.
Can you do a video about the warsaw ghetto uprising?
1:53 descriebes some of the restrictions since denmark?
why are you confusing the netherlands and denmanrk
Man that ad-read was so jarring after the subject of the video.
Well, the video had me crying, but thankfully your attempt to pronounce "Yom HaShoah" provided some levity at the end, there. I appreciate the effort throughout, but keep in mind the vowels tend to be longer in pronunciation.
I actually thought they got the vowels pretty much right, though accenting the middle syllable in the latter word (it's supposed to be accented on the last syllable) may have made it sound wrong.
The זל at the end, on the other hand, had a pretty misformed ז. (This is leaving aside that there's a more specific acronym used when speaking of victims of Anti-Semitism; the general ז"ל is still suitable as well.)
As an Israeli Jew I want to say thank you for the nice masge in Hebrew and for this incredible video the events of the holcost and the story of Anne Frank is something to remember
תהי נשמתה צרורה בצרור החיים!
What does that message mean exactly? If you don't mind
It's been a year since you commented this, but I hope that you and your family and friends are safe during this horrible time❤ Israel is small, but it is a strong country that has been able to defend herself and her people from attacks and come out victorious each time. Stay safe and may God protect you❤
@@M00nsh0tat the end it put זל the hebrew equivelent of RIP which ruffly translates to "tresure thier memorys"
@@MaxEG-i3w Ahh thank you. Yes, I hope the world doesn't forget those holocaust victims.
I think you should do on Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet. It's a tale similar to Anne Frank's, but in reverse and it deals with the Japanese internment in the US.
There is an animated story about her diary coming up. I'm definitely going to see it.
Bruh y'all did not just kept saying Denmark instead of the Netherlands. I know Americans are bad at geography but this is just embarrassing for an educational channel of this size
Thank you so much for this. Its really informative.
RIP Anne, Edith, Margot, Otto Frank and every beautiful and innocent souls lost and affected by the Holocauat, n4zi brutality, the war, human attrocities, may God be with them and all the families, friends and loved ones✝️🙏🤍 Gone way too soon and so heartbreaking that its all totally preventable💔
Dang. Only three months longer, and she would have lived to see the end of the war in Europe
Very cool that you made this Dutch lesson :)
Dude, this happened in Denmark, didn't you watch the video :P ?
This touched my heart
I have all 3 versions of her diary I have the revised critical edition the Definitive Edition and the original published one
this is an a good vid i subed
Thanks for the sub!
I remember reading about this in an English private class (kumon).
You and your team are menches. Thank you for putting this out
Reading young girls diary’s is my favorite personal pastime
._.
It's a powerful book.
Diary
PLease do videos on greek and macedonian (alexander the great) wars and history
what? what school would remove this book?
Thank you for your work, what is the significance of the phrase/ marking at the end?
"May their memory be a blessing"? It's a Jewish expression to honor the dead.
And the Hebrew letters are the initials of the original phrase in Hebrew.
Essentially the acronym for R.I.P. in Hebrew: Z.L.
Update: Hanneli died on October 28, 2022
Off topic but the narrator sounds like narrator from Wordgirl
i read this book and still touches my heart
I see you updated your animation budget
Damn theyve been thanking the same 6 people for 4 years haha
Shows darkness, but then shows heroes
2:44
I think you mixed up the avatars for Miep and Bep. Miep didn't wear glasses until her later years.
I should go back and read her diary
I feel so sad listening to this, I need to read the diary one day but I'm afraid I'll cry even more, curse human anatomy!
As a Grandchild to holocaust survival I really felt the story in the vido יהי זכרם ברוך