It's not just because he's an older man or the original singer. When you watch other videos of him singing, whether he's young or old, you can truly feel the depth of emotions in his performance.
You call that an entertainer. China seems like they are hitting a wall with true entainer talents. Yes, young Chinese guy sings good but. that you going take you only so far in Japan. en entertainers likes Misia, Tamaki, will take you beyound.
As my mother was ready to depart from this world, 行かないで IKANAIDE was naturally playing in mind. What was left in the evening was a cold room filled with tears of ocean.
Actually, most professional singers in Japan agree he’s one of the greatest singers ever, some even say he’s the very best to this day. He is a national treasure.
in our generation,he is the most beloved Japanese singer by hongkongers, I 'll never forget how amazing of his concert, I just love his voice n love dimash,tks fr the reaction n tks being brought me that memories🥰🥰
This version is so gut-wrenching! The first few times I viewed this, I was a sobbing puddle of tears! This is not like his original recording in 1989. Check out that original version, as it's more "mainstream/poppy" sad song. This version in his later years is so much more; direct from his soul!! 🎶♥️🎶♥️
My God thanks so much to share this! im found of Dimash but never heard the owner he is incredible! I cried at the same time as you! And what you say is very respectful and intelligent. Thanks a lot for this.
Hola,creo que Koji Tamaki es un gran cantante,le sigo hace unos años y me encanta,trasmite los sentimientosen toco tipo de canciones,a mi me encanta,espero que te guste,un saludo
Я рада,что такую красивую песню спел Димаш. Она не отстает от исполнения великого японца. Молодой голос Димаша сильный,но ту грусть ,что передал японец, приобретают с годами . О Боже,как красиво поют оба.не могу сказать,кто тут лучший. Оба восхитителны! Слушаю и того и другого,душа рвется на кусочки.Спасибо вам,Кодзи и Димаш.
I watched some old japanese series, what I realise is the old series and the songs are full of emotion, deep. So recently I found this song, it has the same deep feeling like the musics and story from old japanese series. When we listened to old music from diff countries, we feel that too. Seriously I think we dont do similar art anymore.
Hola! Ya toda la composición de esa canción es brutalmente desgarradora, ver tu reacción ha sido bárbaro! Te diré que es hermosa la sensibilidad que tienes como artista, nos la transmites, te he visto por años y tus reacciones están entre mis favoritas, es bueno tener un corazón tierno! Nuestro mundo necesita personas llenas de amor. Saludos desde mi hermosa: 🇨🇷COSTA RICA 🇨🇷
The difference between Dimash’s version and Koji’s version is the difference between sadness and pain. Dimash’s technical genius is unrivaled but his emotions seem manufactured. I enjoy watching reactions to Dimash’s more than listening to him sing. Koji’s emotions, on the other hand, are genuine and deeply moving. Peace
Es un MAESTRO realmente. Canta e interpreta profundamente desde la emoción. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This man is a legend in Japan. The thing about Japanese singers is they put their heart and soul into their musicianship. I haven’t heard Dimash do this song but I’ll take Koji’s version, the original voice, any day. I’m not really fond of covers because a lot of people forget the original artist and give credit to the ones who cover. This song has beautiful lyrics and music. It’s a classic. I get tears in my eyes each time I hear him sing this song. ❤
Hola H, ha sido un buen momento, una muy tierna reacción, de alguna forma, emocional. También conocí a Koji Tamaki por Dimash ( quería escuchar la versión original) y su voz e interpretación me atraparon; en mi humilde opinión ( no he estudiado musical, ni siquiera toco un instrumento) Dimash le hace honor al Sr. Tamaki, es como si fuera la versión joven y la versión madura de la canción! No soy capaz de comparar, pues Dimash le puso su toque, su sello personal e igual el Sr. Tamaki, me encanta y me disfruto las dos versiones ! Bueno al final me gusto acompañarte en una reacción mas! Un abrazo desde Colombia
In the video, Mr. Tamaki says that he is singing this song for Hong Kong. For Hong Kong in perhaps 2015, or 2016... Since then, the Chinese government has suppressed the Hong Kong pro-democracy movement. Some of the Symphony's members may have fled Hong Kong. I think that this may be why this performance in Hong Kong is especially heartbreaking
Lo que me parece mas hermoso de todo esto, es que Dimash interprete esta bella canción y que gracias a eso podemos conocer al autor de la misma. Debo decir que a través de Dimash he podido disfrutar de cantantes fenomenales, que crean hermosas canciones, con gran contenido y bellas melodías, algo que se ha ido perdiendo en nuestro mundo occidental. Me gustan las dos interpretaciones. Gracias por esta linda reacción ❤
@@tonytony.c5691no opino igual que tu, a mi me llega mucho la interpretación de Dimash y se hará mucho mejor con los años, él no es solo técnica, la música es subjetiva...
Without detracting from Dimash’s performance of this composition, these two talents perform it beautifully in different ways. Dimash's performance conveys youthful love suffering. At the same time, Koji Tamaki with his performance represents the feelings of a mature, I would say, seasoned man. but both performances equally stir the heartfelt emotions.
On December 9 2021, Goro Matsui gave a short interview to the DJFC Japanese fan club, where he shared in more detail what got him caught up in Dimash’s performance of the legendary composition. Goro Matsui wrote “Ikanaide” together with Koji Tamaki in 1989. The poet shared that at the time, Tamaki rarely sang the song at his concerts. It took a long time before the singer started performing it on stage again. “This song is very difficult to comprehend like this even for the original singer/composer. I believe to be able to sing this song, you need to have “the time” which is many life experiences to fully express the song's lyrics, not just with singing ability.” “I happened to find Dimash singing “ikanaide” by chance. The first thing that surprised me was his crystal clear tone and his expressive voice that conveys the lyrics of the song. I’ve heard other Asian singers sing “Ikanaide” in their native languages several times. However, even though they all sing great, none of them seemed to quite capture the sound/reverberation and meaning of the original lyrics/words, and perceive the emotions between the lines. In this song, the phrase ~ Ah, ikanaide~ is repeated several times in the chorus. Although they are the same exact words, each line has a different meaning. I feel that Dimash seems to know it.”
It's been ten years since girlfriend died of cancer. but, I can't stop crying when I hear this... i ka na i de 行かないで → Do not go away. 逝かないで → Please don't die, don't leave me alone. This is double meaning.(日本人にはそう聞けちゃう) At that time, I was in a remote area, so I went to the palliative ward where she is housed every weekend. At first, she was able to take a walk in the hospital, but every time I met her, she became emaciated. On the Tohoku highway on my way home, I couldn't stop crying and hit the steering wheel... "Why is she?" No matter how much I cried and shouted, she would never come back. Mr. Tamaki's songs and the way he sings them vividly remind me of how I felt at that time.
![Kim Lau with the Buchholz City Orchestra - Ikanaide [Don't Go], ( 行かないで ). A Layman's Reaction](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t8UdcTwO2fU/mqdefault.jpg)
It's not just because he's an older man or the original singer. When you watch other videos of him singing, whether he's young or old, you can truly feel the depth of emotions in his performance.
100%. He's a great technical singer but what makes him phenomenal is the way he carries the songs.
It's like he's not only an amazing singer, but secretly one of the best actors in the world.
You call that an entertainer. China seems like they are hitting a wall with true entainer talents. Yes, young Chinese guy sings good but. that you going take you only so far in Japan. en entertainers likes Misia, Tamaki, will take you beyound.
He is a legend! The world needs to know more about him.
As my mother was ready to depart from this world, 行かないで IKANAIDE was naturally playing in mind. What was left in the evening was a cold room filled with tears of ocean.
Actually, most professional singers in Japan agree he’s one of the greatest singers ever, some even say he’s the very best to this day. He is a national treasure.
初めまして。彼の歌の中でも、行かないで は魂に響きます。行かないで と 逝かないで。日本語で2つの意味があり、私は大切な人を亡くしこの歌を聴くと涙が止まりません。私の心の中でずっと心の中で彼は生き続けます。
You can feel the true soul in his expressiveness.
Koji Tamaki is a legend. His Ikanaide emotional expression is always superb, I live for that. Tears and tissues at the ready❤
in our generation,he is the most beloved Japanese singer by hongkongers, I 'll never forget how amazing of his concert, I just love his voice n love dimash,tks fr the reaction n tks being brought me that memories🥰🥰
He is just too good, LEGEND in asia music
His singing voice makes you feel as if your soul has been touched.
This version is so gut-wrenching! The first few times I viewed this, I was a sobbing puddle of tears! This is not like his original recording in 1989. Check out that original version, as it's more "mainstream/poppy" sad song. This version in his later years is so much more; direct from his soul!! 🎶♥️🎶♥️
His voice is so powerful that almost carries emotion while listening ❤❤❤
So happy you experienced KOJI TAMAKI. He is one of the best singers in Japan. I strongly recommend his "Den en", too!
his AKOGARE album is the best ever, every single song is a masterpiece
I love Dimash with my entire heart. and when he sings the song, he breaks my heart. But when Koji sings this song he breaks my soul.
AMEN to that 🙏
My God thanks so much to share this! im found of Dimash but never heard the owner he is incredible! I cried at the same time as you! And what you say is very respectful and intelligent. Thanks a lot for this.
Un gran cantante, transmite sus sentimientos en sus canciones. Me encanta
Excelente
Koji Tamaki legendary singer from Japan
really heartbreaking, luv your tears.....greets from germany
🙏😥❤️
This reaction is beautiful.
Hola,creo que Koji Tamaki es un gran cantante,le sigo hace unos años y me encanta,trasmite los sentimientosen toco tipo de canciones,a mi me encanta,espero que te guste,un saludo
You should find this song 1989 version! Koji looks sooo Kool!!!!!
Koji sings a reflection of sad beauty that transcend into timeless emotion.
This is why he is a legend in Japan.
It's really a very beautiful song. Wow!😊
Я рада,что такую красивую песню спел Димаш.
Она не отстает от исполнения великого японца.
Молодой голос Димаша сильный,но ту грусть ,что передал японец, приобретают с годами . О Боже,как красиво поют оба.не могу сказать,кто тут лучший. Оба восхитителны! Слушаю и того и другого,душа рвется на кусочки.Спасибо вам,Кодзи и Димаш.
согласна с вами, у японца уже есть осознание потери
Sorprendente
I watched some old japanese series, what I realise is the old series and the songs are full of emotion, deep. So recently I found this song, it has the same deep feeling like the musics and story from old japanese series. When we listened to old music from diff countries, we feel that too. Seriously I think we dont do similar art anymore.
Merci pour cette réaction. Il y a tellement d'émotions dans sa voix. Hello from France.
Anzen Chitai and Kouji Tamaki still and will be my favorite band/singer from my whole life.
Un legendario sin ninguna duda 🫶🏻
Es un gran cantante
Sus letras son muy hermosas
Eso es lo que se llama una leyenda
La version de Dimash me faisait déjà pleurer, mais là, j'ai encore plus d'émotions. Et malgré son âge, sa voix est incroyable.
I cried with you......😢😢😢😢
Hola!
Ya toda la composición de esa canción es brutalmente desgarradora, ver tu reacción ha sido bárbaro! Te diré que es hermosa la sensibilidad que tienes como artista, nos la transmites, te he visto por años y tus reacciones están entre mis favoritas, es bueno tener un corazón tierno!
Nuestro mundo necesita personas llenas de amor.
Saludos desde mi hermosa:
🇨🇷COSTA RICA 🇨🇷
Auténtica voz
Muy bueno
The difference between Dimash’s version and Koji’s version is the difference between sadness and pain. Dimash’s technical genius is unrivaled but his emotions seem manufactured. I enjoy watching reactions to Dimash’s more than listening to him sing. Koji’s emotions, on the other hand, are genuine and deeply moving. Peace
I love him❤ Maybe "Melody" for your next reaction? Thank you. (It's Koji not Koi) 😍
Es un MAESTRO realmente. Canta e interpreta profundamente desde la emoción. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This man is a legend in Japan. The thing about Japanese singers is they put their heart and soul into their musicianship. I haven’t heard Dimash do this song but I’ll take Koji’s version, the original voice, any day. I’m not really fond of covers because a lot of people forget the original artist and give credit to the ones who cover.
This song has beautiful lyrics and music. It’s a classic.
I get tears in my eyes each time I hear him sing this song. ❤
Hola H, ha sido un buen momento, una muy tierna reacción, de alguna forma, emocional. También conocí a Koji Tamaki por Dimash ( quería escuchar la versión original) y su voz e interpretación me atraparon; en mi humilde opinión ( no he estudiado musical, ni siquiera toco un instrumento) Dimash le hace honor al Sr. Tamaki, es como si fuera la versión joven y la versión madura de la canción! No soy capaz de comparar, pues Dimash le puso su toque, su sello personal e igual el Sr. Tamaki, me encanta y me disfruto las dos versiones ! Bueno al final me gusto acompañarte en una reacción mas! Un abrazo desde Colombia
Es tan especial,que su musica llega directa al corazón, siempre que le escucho cantar me gusta más!!!
Eres una leyenda
Koji Tamaki es un gran cantante y compositor,la musica de Ikanaide es suya,es maravillosa!
Thank you for such an emotional, heartfelt reaction.
Dimash sang like he begged someone not to leave. Koji sang like he has lost that person already 😢
Exactly 🌹
Ohhh que hermosa melodia👌❤️
Amazing
Toca con todo su alma ❤
Beautiful song, love both versions
10:10 He sang this line in Cantonese instead of Japanese which caused the audience to applause.
Excelente cantante
Que buenos videos amigos
In the video, Mr. Tamaki says that he is singing this song for Hong Kong.
For Hong Kong in perhaps 2015, or 2016...
Since then, the Chinese government has suppressed the Hong Kong pro-democracy movement.
Some of the Symphony's members may have fled Hong Kong.
I think that this may be why this performance in Hong Kong is especially heartbreaking
Lo que me parece mas hermoso de todo esto, es que Dimash interprete esta bella canción y que gracias a eso podemos conocer al autor de la misma. Debo decir que a través de Dimash he podido disfrutar de cantantes fenomenales, que crean hermosas canciones, con gran contenido y bellas melodías, algo que se ha ido perdiendo en nuestro mundo occidental. Me gustan las dos interpretaciones. Gracias por esta linda reacción ❤
不太同意，他只是炫技，無感情
@@tonytony.c5691no opino igual que tu, a mi me llega mucho la interpretación de Dimash y se hará mucho mejor con los años, él no es solo técnica, la música es subjetiva...
Es verdad una buena presentación
Very very good
Genial!! Excelente trabajo👍🏻✨
I love this japanese singer and Dimash likes his song ❤❤❤
I❤tamaki san .. mr. Lonely and melody are my fav .
Bonita letra 🎶
Excelente
玉置浩二さんは日本が誇る素晴らしい歌手です。リアクションしてくれてありがとうございます。私は今月、玉置浩二さんのコンサートに行きます♪
Koji used to have a Band called Anzenchitai Its very popular and the first band to perform at the Buddacan Japan!
❤❤❤❤ me encanta ❤❤❤
Me encanto tu video sigue asi
Love Dimash, but like you I like Koji's version of this song better too!
Without detracting from Dimash’s performance of this composition, these two talents perform it beautifully in different ways. Dimash's performance conveys youthful love suffering. At the same time, Koji Tamaki with his performance represents the feelings of a mature, I would say, seasoned man. but both performances equally stir the heartfelt emotions.
Buen video, maravillosa voz
On December 9 2021, Goro Matsui gave a short interview to the DJFC Japanese fan club, where he shared in more detail what got him caught up in Dimash’s performance of the legendary composition.
Goro Matsui wrote “Ikanaide” together with Koji Tamaki in 1989. The poet shared that at the time, Tamaki rarely sang the song at his concerts. It took a long time before the singer started performing it on stage again.
“This song is very difficult to comprehend like this even for the original singer/composer. I believe to be able to sing this song, you need to have “the time” which is many life experiences to fully express the song's lyrics, not just with singing ability.”
“I happened to find Dimash singing “ikanaide” by chance. The first thing that surprised me was his crystal clear tone and his expressive voice that conveys the lyrics of the song. I’ve heard other Asian singers sing “Ikanaide” in their native languages several times. However, even though they all sing great, none of them seemed to quite capture the sound/reverberation and meaning of the original lyrics/words, and perceive the emotions between the lines. In this song, the phrase ~ Ah, ikanaide~ is repeated several times in the chorus. Although they are the same exact words, each line has a different meaning. I feel that Dimash seems to know it.”
As duas versões são lindas e emocionantes , a do Dimash e do Koji Tamaki. 👏👏👏👏👏❤️❤️🇧🇷
Exatamente é emocionante
Que buena transmisión
Exelente
Buena Voz🤗
finally reactor who can compare and react to original :)
Un buen contenido
Very nice
Excelente video
Great choice, Tamaki is the winner here
Koji Tamaki and Anzen Chitai my favs.
Hermosa melodia
Muy buen comentario
Muy bueno
With the backstory of both songs & this performance you’re right about Dimash’s ❤️
Brings Everything✨🫶✨
🤍2U&ALLU🤍🦌💫🌎🕊️🇺🇸
Buenas letras
Excelente comentarista
Una maravilla🤩🤩👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
染みるよね😢
Different emotions come with both versions, I can't compare nor decide which one I like more.
A great eye cleanser!
he has a different energy!
Muy buen video
You should listen to his other song like Melody, Friend , Kanashimini Sayonara.
Very good
Muy bn sigue asiu
It's been ten years since girlfriend died of cancer.
but, I can't stop crying when I hear this...
i ka na i de
行かないで → Do not go away.
逝かないで → Please don't die, don't leave me alone.
This is double meaning.(日本人にはそう聞けちゃう)
At that time, I was in a remote area, so I went to the palliative ward where she is housed every weekend.
At first, she was able to take a walk in the hospital, but every time I met her, she became emaciated.
On the Tohoku highway on my way home, I couldn't stop crying and hit the steering wheel...
"Why is she?"
No matter how much I cried and shouted, she would never come back.
Mr. Tamaki's songs and the way he sings them vividly remind me of how I felt at that time.
No lo había escuchado antes 😸
He puts a soul in his singing, something Dimash can't. Because Dimash is a technical beast but that's just it.
Totally agree. I find Dimash soulless in his singing.