Roman legionaries build fortress wall

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 июн 2009
  • Re-enactment of the building of a fortress ditch and wall by Roman legionaries.
    The wall was reconstructed by members of Stichting Romeinenfestival (Roman Festival Foundation) at the Kops Plateau in Nijmegen, Netherlands. This is the exact same location as the original wall of the camp of the Tenth Legion.
    PHALERA Filmworks specializes in historical video clips, suitable for educational purposes like history lessons.

Комментарии • 645

  • @christopherg2347
    @christopherg2347 5 лет назад +1105

    Spartan to his Army: "What is your Profession?" "War!"
    Roman to his Army: "What is your Profession?" "War, Carpentry, Building, Hunting, Cooking, Logistics, ..."

    • @anthonylouschwank8578
      @anthonylouschwank8578 5 лет назад +31

      so true xdxdxd

    • @admiralsquatbar127
      @admiralsquatbar127 4 года назад +135

      One had an empire, the other one was conquered.

    • @kpsiex
      @kpsiex 4 года назад +59

      @Free Spirited Cat rome destroyed itself then it's vacant lands got conquered.

    • @marcelo497
      @marcelo497 4 года назад +19

      And that´s why the romans were more powerful

    • @alessandrorandi7678
      @alessandrorandi7678 4 года назад +35

      Rime wasn’t never conquered.
      First the empire collapse alone, then the germans arrived

  • @basileusmichael1244
    @basileusmichael1244 5 лет назад +937

    -Sir we finished the wall but the Gauls are coming.
    -build another one.
    Julius Caesar 52 BC Alesia.

    • @noproblem2big337
      @noproblem2big337 5 лет назад +65

      Yes, Julius Caesar was a mastermind strategist when it came to siege warfare, and the gauls paid dearly

    • @r1singthorn4451
      @r1singthorn4451 5 лет назад +65

      -Sir the Gauls are attacking the inside wall
      *2 Minutes later*
      -Sir the Gauls are attacking the outer wall!
      Caesar: "Send in the cavalry in a flanking maneuver"

    • @insertname5407
      @insertname5407 5 лет назад +7

      *BUT THIS TIME IS GONNA BE BIGGER*

    • @garliconionshallot
      @garliconionshallot 5 лет назад +9

      @@twitchstaff4226 same shit nerd

    • @danietkissenle
      @danietkissenle 4 года назад +20

      @@twitchstaff4226 B.C. don't start up with that revisionist history nonsense

  • @adammetcalf8954
    @adammetcalf8954 5 лет назад +746

    That guy hammering the pole for no reason at the start reminds me of age of empires.

    • @dozysplot
      @dozysplot 5 лет назад +50

      Lol!! You can just imagine the director saying..” look! Take that hammer and look busy or I’ll get another extra instead!”

    • @Ryan-wx8of
      @Ryan-wx8of 5 лет назад +17

      He's hammering it straight!
      But considering how weakly he swings it, it'll probably take all day. Right around the same time those guys lifting the pickaxes with their back and arms will be hospitalized.

    • @GuinessOriginal
      @GuinessOriginal 5 лет назад +1

      Adam Metcalf love to know how they managed to do those machined bits of 2 by 4

    • @kvidobenak
      @kvidobenak 5 лет назад +2

      Union Labor

    • @budmeister
      @budmeister 4 года назад +3

      @@GuinessOriginal I'm sure they had hand planes to make the boards back then.

  • @hellishboy6065
    @hellishboy6065 3 года назад +80

    Props to the camera man for going back in time to film this

    • @jamesabestos2800
      @jamesabestos2800 Год назад

      Rarity indeed

    • @MarkH10
      @MarkH10 23 дня назад

      props to the producer for cutting expenses by using the same Broll over and over again. Same tools in same dirt.

  • @phantom-xb6wv
    @phantom-xb6wv 5 лет назад +266

    Crazy how soldiers were builders, farmers, engineers, soldiers and conquerors.

    • @proof4469
      @proof4469 5 лет назад +29

      Also professional basketball players

    • @juanmestre6195
      @juanmestre6195 3 года назад +13

      @@proof4469 they didn't have basket balls those days instead they used barberians heads

    • @gnochhuos645
      @gnochhuos645 3 года назад +4

      Spanish villagers after Supremacy

    • @Simpson17866
      @Simpson17866 2 года назад +5

      "Hey look, buddy, I'm a legionnaire - that means I solve problems. Not problems like 'what is beauty,' because that would fall within the purview of your conundrums of philosophy. I solve practical problems."

    • @Scotto6977
      @Scotto6977 Год назад

      Sought of like a barber in India

  • @ilonasapel3072
    @ilonasapel3072 7 лет назад +815

    "Join the army" - they said, "It will be fun" - they said...

    • @MaiDKHOA-ly1tc
      @MaiDKHOA-ly1tc 6 лет назад +24

      no soldier complains when they get to rape female prisioner

    • @davidegaribaldi1503
      @davidegaribaldi1503 6 лет назад +99

      Ilona Sapel "oh don't worry is just a quick mission in Germania, Teutobourg is called I think..."

    • @helmbreaker8622
      @helmbreaker8622 5 лет назад +8

      Looks fun to me

    • @nigelsheppard625
      @nigelsheppard625 5 лет назад +23

      @@MaiDKHOA-ly1tc they raped the male prisoners to humiliate them and to underline the fact they'd been defeated. Male slaves were raped for this reason also.

    • @tuxedosteve1904
      @tuxedosteve1904 5 лет назад +12

      @@davidegaribaldi1503Varus ! Dont listen to Arminius!

  • @AzureSkyCiel
    @AzureSkyCiel 4 года назад +336

    >Romans build these massive forts in less than a week
    My god... they're like the Amish on steroids.

    • @zuuzuuka
      @zuuzuuka 4 года назад +53

      It took them 3 hours actually. They'd build one every evening after a march and take it apart every morning before a march. That's why its called a marching camp. If the army remained in place for longer the fort would be gradually upgraded with stone, mounted ballistae, deeper moats, thicker gates etc. But even the basic 3 hour version would've been a better defence than most barbarian (celtic and hermanic) permenant forts.

    • @MDP1702
      @MDP1702 4 года назад +46

      @@zuuzuuka The one in the video isn't a marching camp, but a something between a temporary and permanent camp. For example when you build a wall during a siege (eg. Alesia), this kind of wall would be build. A marching camp that they created daily is much more simplified. Basically this ditch with an earth rampart from the dug earth right behind in and stakes to form a wall.

    • @ScurvyBoi
      @ScurvyBoi 4 года назад +13

      To be fair when you have workers in the thousands it may not be THAT impressive, still pretty neat for an entire army to know these skills instead of a select few.

    • @thalmoragent9344
      @thalmoragent9344 3 года назад +12

      @@ScurvyBoi
      True, the fact they all knew how to build and could contribute to the making of these forts only make them a more capable and unique fighting force to deal with.

    • @SteveSmith-ty8ko
      @SteveSmith-ty8ko 3 года назад +3

      @@thalmoragent9344 I recall one instance in which the Roman army and its engineers were put to the ultimate test. I forgot the name of the battle, but I believe Caesar was leading it. He was besieging the enemy, surrounding them and building walls and fortifications to keep them in. Soon, reinforcements for the Gauls arrived. Instead of abandoning it, he build walls and fortifications on the other side. Placing the Romans between the Gauls they were besieging, and the Gauls that were besieging them.

  • @larrysingleton2864
    @larrysingleton2864 10 лет назад +505

    Marius had long ago showed us that the legionary has a weapon that is the bane of the civilized world, one more formidable than the dual-edged Roman short sword, more affective than the bronze-headed javelin, of greater defensive strength than the concave bronze-sheathed shields. It is a weapon in which the legionary is trained from his first day of induction and which he uses daily, in peacetime or in war, on the march or hunkered in camp under siege from flaming missiles. And upon their arrival at Themiscyra, every able-bodied Roman immediately whipped out this most fearsome of all weapons:
    The Legionary's shovel.
    Before even breaking to rest or scouting for supplies, the Roman troops had unpacked their shovels and commenced digging, and the dirt flew, and the dust rose. In the space of an afternoon, a Roman camp for thirty thousand men had been constructed just beyond range of our catapults. Before dark it had been ringed on all sides with a trench twelve feet deep and three feet across, the dirt thrown up into an embankment ten feet high inside the ring. Topped with a thick palisade of sharpened stakes. Inside, four sturdy walls were constructed of felled trees, guarded by squat log towers twenty feet high, stationed every fifty feet and surmounted by bolt-hurling field catapults. Inside, a space of a full two hundred feet was left between the walls and the tent line, a distance calculated to prevent our missiles and burning arrows from reaching the tents. This space was occupied by prisoners, cattle, plunder and supplies. Withing a few hours, the Romans had constructed a stronghold that would be the envy of a lifetime's work of many civilizations poorer then theirs. A fortress impregnable.
    Yet this was not a permanent stronghold they had built. This was the Roman's usual daily campsite, Every day of a legionary's working life he would dig such a trench, construct such an embankment, hew trees, and build such palisade. All to be torched at sunrise, when the legions marched off to their next encampment. Javelins, when thrown, may miss their mark entirely. Shields may cave upon impact with a Scythian battle-ax; and a sword, though reliable at close quarters, still dulled, broke upon ribs. Or shivered if struck upon armor. But the shovel...the shovel was the legionary's best friend, his most faithful protector, the one weapon that allowed him to sleep soundly at night, behind his magnificent trenches and embankments. The shovel could stop a cavalry charge cold, stymie hordes of barbarians. Rome conquered not with its brutal leaders, not with the strength of its soldiers, not with the ingeniousness of its weapons...but with the most rustic, pigheaded, inglorious, gods-bedamned tool of them all...the shovel.
    Michael Curtis Ford “The Last King
    Read one of the best books you'll ever read; Gods and Legions”

    • @larrysingleton2864
      @larrysingleton2864 10 лет назад +15

      Roman and Greek History, Etc.
      If you're into “Roman” stuff Michael Curtis Ford's “Gods and Legions is the book to read. If you're into history I suggest you get Ammianus Marcellinus' History. The ass kicker here is that Marcellinus actually went to battel with Emperor Julian. The Loeb Classic is almost an adventure novel all by itself.
      As far as Gladiators go a couple of “difinitive” books are The Way of the Gladiator by Daniel P. Mannix and Spartacus by Howard Fast. Here are books from my library. Ass kickers every one.
      Ammianus Marcellinus History
      The Battle for Gaul by Julius Caesar
      The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire by Edward Gibbon
      The Way of the Gladiator by Daniel P. Mannix
      Spartacus by Howard Fast
      Julian by Gore Vidal
      Gods and Legions by Michael Curtis Ford
      The Ten Thousand by Michael Curtis Ford
      The Last King by Michael Curtis Ford
      The Sword of Attila by Michael Curtis Ford
      The Fall of Rome by Michael Curtis Ford
      Gates of Fire by Steven Pressfield
      Tides of War by Steven Pressfield
      The Virtures of War Steven Pressfield
      Alexaneder the Great by Paul Cartledge
      The Spartans by Paul Cartledge
      Eagle in the Snow by Wallace Breem
      The Eagle and the Raven by Pauline Gedge

    • @ferdia748
      @ferdia748 9 лет назад +4

      why did you post this?

    • @larrysingleton2864
      @larrysingleton2864 9 лет назад +4

      Conor Beggs F-ing Google; they cut 3/4 of my damn comment.

    • @larrysingleton2864
      @larrysingleton2864 9 лет назад +4

      Conor Beggs I'll try again. (Google: a total pile of stinking dog crap.)
      The Legionary's shovel II
      Marius had long ago showed us that the legionary has a weapon that is the bane of the civilized world, one more formidable than the dual-edged Roman short sword, more affective than the bronze-headed javelin, of greater defensive strength than the concave bronze-sheathed shields. It is a weapon in which the legionary is trained from his first day of induction and which he uses daily, in peacetime or in war, on the march or hunkered in camp under siege from flaming missiles. And upon their arrival at Themiscyra, every able-bodied Roman immediately whipped out this most fearsome of all weapons:
      The Legionary's shovel.
      Before even breaking to rest or scouting for supplies, the Roman troops had unpacked their shovels and commenced digging, and the dirt flew, and the dust rose. In the space of an afternoon, a Roman camp for thirty thousand men had been constructed just beyond range of our catapults. Before dark it had been ringed on all sides with a trench twelve feet deep and three feet across, the dirt thrown up into an embankment ten feet high inside the ring. Topped with a thick palisade of sharpened stakes. Inside, four sturdy walls were constructed of felled trees, guarded by squat log towers twenty feet high, stationed every fifty feet and surmounted by bolt-hurling field catapults. Inside, a space of a full two hundred feet was left between the walls and the tent line, a distance calculated to prevent our missiles and burning arrows from reaching the tents. This space was occupied by prisoners, cattle, plunder and supplies. Withing a few hours, the Romans had constructed a stronghold that would be the envy of a lifetime's work of many civilizations poorer then theirs. A fortress impregnable.
      Yet this was not a permanent stronghold they had built. This was the Roman's usual daily campsite, Every day of a legionary's working life he would dig such a trench, construct such an embankment, hew trees, and build such palisade. All to be torched at sunrise, when the legions marched off to their next encampment. Javelins, when thrown, may miss their mark entirely. Shields may cave upon impact with a Scythian battle-ax; and a sword, though reliable at close quarters, still dulled, broke upon ribs. Or shivered if struck upon armor. But the shovel...the shovel was the legionary's best friend, his most faithful protector, the one weapon that allowed him to sleep soundly at night, behind his magnificent trenches and embankments. The shovel could stop a cavalry charge cold, stymie hordes of barbarians. Rome conquered not with its brutal leaders, not with the strength of its soldiers, not with the ingeniousness of its weapons...but with the most rustic, pigheaded, inglorious, gods-bedamned tool of them all...the shovel.
      Michael Curtis Ford "The Last King"
      Read one of the best books you'll ever read; Gods and Legions"
      Roman and Greek History, Etc.
      If you're into "Roman" stuff Michael Curtis Ford's "Gods and Legions is the book to read. If you're into history I suggest you get Ammianus Marcellinus' History. The ass kicker here is that Marcellinus actually went to battel with Emperor Julian. The Loeb Classic is almost an adventure novel all by itself.

    • @larrysingleton2864
      @larrysingleton2864 9 лет назад +24

      Conor Beggs I just refreshed the page and the whole thing magically appeared. Gawd! I hate Google.
      I like Roman history and like to share the neat stuff I've read.

  • @DaHuntsman1
    @DaHuntsman1 11 лет назад +63

    The Centurions were basically modern day US Marine Drill sergeants without restrictions on steroids when it came to discipline

    • @mosesmarlboro5401
      @mosesmarlboro5401 4 года назад +4

      Marines have Drill Instructors, not Sargeants. That's the army.

    • @isaiahmacias5276
      @isaiahmacias5276 3 года назад

      @@mosesmarlboro5401 sergeants*

    • @isaiahmacias5276
      @isaiahmacias5276 3 года назад

      No be cause marine DIs didn’t whip kill or beat there soldiers

  • @tomservo5347
    @tomservo5347 5 лет назад +195

    The Roman Legionary was an engineer as much as soldier. That centurion would be yelling, cursing, and hitting slackers with his grape-vine stalk 'discipline stick' designed to inflict pain-not any debilitating injury. The Roman foot soldier was more scared of his centurion than any enemy as almost all veterans bore more scars from beatings than combat. Of course the centurion lived in fear of a mutiny, where the most sadistic centurions usually had their throats cut. The Romans learned keeping soldiers busy with engineering projects served a double purpose-the building improvement and busybodies don't have time mutiny. So if there was no campaign going on, soldiers were set to work building roads, aqueducts, and other permanent structures. Hadrian's Wall was more a way to keep soldiers occupied than anything.

    • @mwnciboo
      @mwnciboo 5 лет назад +22

      I think you'll find they were "Labourers" rather than engineers...A small cadre of specialists in every Legion were engineers / Surveyors etc. Most were just labourers.

    • @Riyun72
      @Riyun72 5 лет назад

      Kinky

    • @gerardosalazar161
      @gerardosalazar161 5 лет назад +2

      Actually the correct rank would be an Optio, who was similar to an XO. He would convey the Centurion orders and carry and stick to emphasize his authority. By law he had the power of life or dead over the enlisted men and punishment could go from a broken knee to a cracked skull.

    • @hereIam1965
      @hereIam1965 5 лет назад +2

      The section leader of the 7 men under him would have kept order if not he would be replaced with a more suitable or ruthless section leader. There would have been a cohort commander to keep check and command the 8 or so sections commanders. Then a major ( Opto ? ) Cohort commander in charge of the 8 or so cohort commanders.Above them the centurion. Command and control order and authority as well as discipline. Very much like today's army. Each rank from the bottom up would have total respect for the ranks above. Thus a deadly formidable FIGHTING force

  • @mivapusa
    @mivapusa 5 лет назад +156

    02:05
    Centurion! That man is slacking off, his basket isn't even half full!

    • @felipewerner6670
      @felipewerner6670 5 лет назад +9

      you will not last too much with that big tongue michael, i guarantee that.

    • @eeeonsphere3327
      @eeeonsphere3327 5 лет назад +7

      Where's the general!? 1:07 those aren't the hands of a Centurion!

    • @zerogbot23
      @zerogbot23 5 лет назад +9

      10 lashes to the slacker and 20 to you for selling out your brother

    • @mivapusa
      @mivapusa 5 лет назад +1

      @@zerogbot23 I am the Mars-be-damned _Tribune_ , Foderatii dog

    • @Sksk27547
      @Sksk27547 5 лет назад

      Hahaha true

  • @13thBear
    @13thBear 5 лет назад +14

    Gee, the actors sure seemed to be working really hard simulating the work they weren't doing.

  • @Lo-tf6qt
    @Lo-tf6qt 8 лет назад +318

    Imagine doing that everyday and taking it down

    • @RH-ls5od
      @RH-ls5od 8 лет назад +4

      +Shix Lo but didn't the romans leave them so if they go down the road they built they could stay?

    • @Lo-tf6qt
      @Lo-tf6qt 8 лет назад +1

      Im not so sure myself

    • @moonhorse100
      @moonhorse100 8 лет назад +59

      +Shix Lo They were usually left built with a few garrison men to lookout as an outpost for the romans, they create a perimeter and each garrison is what they are called help each other out the ones in close proximity

    • @noggyandcrold
      @noggyandcrold 8 лет назад +29

      +moonhorse100 thers marching camps and outpost, marching camp is build every day and taken down everyday(its a marching camp they build in this video) , outpost is usally garrisoned by half a centuria of legionarys or axulliarys.(thes camps where usally close to fortreses or citys to serv as a deterent and so they could see the enemy comming and fall back to thier legion

    • @Freyia935
      @Freyia935 8 лет назад +2

      There were 1000 men in one legio sometimes more depending on what period but they all took turns building

  • @MichaelJackson78100
    @MichaelJackson78100 5 лет назад +663

    And they made the barbarians pay for it!

    • @Mr.LaughingDuck
      @Mr.LaughingDuck 5 лет назад +36

      Yeah! Just like how Genghis Khan took one look at the Great Wall, and said "Nope!", and promptly fled back to Mongolia where he and his sons stayed for like forever.

    • @waitwhat69247
      @waitwhat69247 5 лет назад +12

      @@Mr.LaughingDuck didnt he go around it or something?

    • @blitcut9712
      @blitcut9712 5 лет назад

      @m. rude Not if you can fly over it.

    • @LordBruuh
      @LordBruuh 5 лет назад +1

      @@Mr.LaughingDuck Didn't the mongols end up conquering china though?

    • @nguyenming1987
      @nguyenming1987 5 лет назад +10

      @@LordBruuh 1400 years after the wall was built

  • @sikViduser
    @sikViduser 3 года назад +6

    "Caesar we're outnumbered, outskilled and surrounded. we're running out of supplies and the enemies over the horizon, what should we do?"
    Caesar - "Build a wall."

  • @rc59191
    @rc59191 2 года назад +8

    It never ceases to amaze me how they could get these things built within a few hours. That rivals the time our troops can get a modern firebase setup using Hesco bastions and heavy equipment.

    • @damionkeeling3103
      @damionkeeling3103 2 года назад +2

      I suspect the pallisade was quite primitive for the marching camp but actually digging the perimeter is impressive in itself. For an army on campaign it seems they built one of these things every evening after a day's march which also means pulling up the palisade every morning. They were super fit which must have given them an edge in battle too.

  • @shastasilverchairsg
    @shastasilverchairsg 3 года назад +5

    When I was in the military, there was a certain phrase used to describe what the centurion was doing at 0:42: Eye Power.

  • @Intranetusa
    @Intranetusa 5 лет назад +68

    This is a more permanent wooden fort built over several weeks and not a marching camp fort that the Romans built everyday. The palisade of their daily marching camp was protected by smaller wooden stakes (sudes) they carried while marching. Only the more permanent forts/outposts had towers and wooden walls, and those took much longer to build. In the book "Roman Legionary Fortresses 27 BC-AD 378" by Duncan Campbell, the author talks about different types of temporary and permanent fortifications. The more permanent forts (compared to their daily camping forts) were still often made of wood, while the biggest and most permanent ones evolved into rammed earth, stone, & brick fortifications.

    • @saneman8147
      @saneman8147 5 лет назад +4

      Correct, was thinking the same, even still there was a huge amount of work building a daily camp ie dirt moat, mound and palisade etc

    • @SuperChuckRaney
      @SuperChuckRaney 4 года назад +3

      @@saneman8147 they spent 3 hours before dark on the night's fort.
      10,000 men woirking for 3 hours is a TON of labor hours.
      30,000 man-hours to be exact. for instance if you work EVERY DAY all year for one person ...is only 2,000 man hours.

  • @carmendaniel3734
    @carmendaniel3734 Год назад +10

    I love all these videos about Romans. They were brilliant. So far ahead of their time. With running water, bath houses, beautiful architecture. Thank you for sharing with us. Sending much Aloha from Honolulu. ❤️🌺

  • @morgan97475
    @morgan97475 4 года назад +23

    Once again, the greatest weapon ever: the Infantry trooper.

    • @cjthebeesknees
      @cjthebeesknees 11 месяцев назад

      Man, such enigmatic creatures.

  • @gumtreessaltwater6273
    @gumtreessaltwater6273 5 лет назад +25

    God dam the Romans where good at warfare and construction

  • @donjames3349
    @donjames3349 5 лет назад +71

    boss my back hurts.
    Boss: *Whiplash to back*

    • @jurisprudens
      @jurisprudens 5 лет назад

      Legionaries were not slaves, they were not whipped indiscriminately.

    • @hanguyen5101997
      @hanguyen5101997 5 лет назад +5

      @@jurisprudens it a joke.

  • @Mr.56Goldtop
    @Mr.56Goldtop 5 лет назад +14

    Incredible. These people were brutes! To be able to march 25 miles then build this fort, EVERY DAY! Just astonishing!

    • @Tonyx.yt.
      @Tonyx.yt. 5 лет назад +8

      this is how they conquest all mediterranean countries and most of europe

    • @dking6021
      @dking6021 5 лет назад +4

      they did not build this every day those are far simpler ones

    • @hindugoat2302
      @hindugoat2302 5 лет назад +3

      2000 years ago, the average man was much stronger than modern man
      our genetics progressively get weaker as we live easier lives and rely on technology more

    • @dking6021
      @dking6021 5 лет назад

      @@samspade2657 Ok... so what?

    • @dking6021
      @dking6021 5 лет назад

      @@samspade2657 I'm not sure what you are responding to really. Like ok so some roman soldiers lived slightly longer then non soldiers. Like so what? they did not live longer on average then people born in modern times.
      So you do have to explain it as it seems to not be addressing anything

  • @bowenc24
    @bowenc24 4 года назад +5

    When you see stuff like this, it really isn’t surprising that their legions conquered so much.

  • @krankenhaus1991
    @krankenhaus1991 4 года назад +1

    Rome wasn't built in a day, these boring tasks made Rome magnificent
    and mighty.
    After 2000 years we are still amazed by their great achievement.

  • @eeeonsphere3327
    @eeeonsphere3327 5 лет назад +32

    1:08 those aren't the hands of a Centurion.

    • @tommyzDad
      @tommyzDad 4 года назад +2

      LOL. So soft-looking. He's really the cornu player, or worse, the double flute. ;)

  • @loszhor
    @loszhor 4 года назад +3

    Very interesting! Thanks for uploading!

  • @vincentgordon7021
    @vincentgordon7021 5 лет назад +8

    Even in today's war, our entrenching tool, was our second best weapon besides our rifles.

  • @narukami7
    @narukami7 13 лет назад +1

    Excellent work.
    Once again your group has produced an outstanding video.

  • @Jaccayumitty
    @Jaccayumitty 5 лет назад +4

    Good video, but I suspect there's far too much sawn timber in it. Cutting wood along the grain with a manual saw takes a huge amount of labour and is only done when finished appearance is important. They'd cut trees that were already of the desired thickness and square them off a bit with an adze if necessary, or they'd split the wood lengthways with wedges. The wood that wall was built with came from a timbermill. Understandable compromise though.

  • @MyrdinAnnoth
    @MyrdinAnnoth 7 лет назад +55

    Which documentary is this out of ? These type of documentaries that show actors performing the actual setting are the most enjoyable :)

    • @phalera
      @phalera  6 лет назад +9

      Myrdin it's not from a documentary. It's a self made clip. You may also enjoy The Wooden Sword, at www.hethoutenzwaard.nl

    • @elijah-he975
      @elijah-he975 5 лет назад

      Myrdin You should watch Roman Empire on Netflix then, they hired real actors and settings to replicate what happened in real life

    • @user-te9vx8bx8y
      @user-te9vx8bx8y 5 лет назад +1

      @@elijah-he975 What's a "real actor" and how can you hire a setting?

    • @TwistedAlphonso1
      @TwistedAlphonso1 3 года назад

      @@user-te9vx8bx8y or.....idk just an idea.....you can google it

  • @fuferito
    @fuferito 4 года назад +7

    01:47
    Pretty sure that's veneer particle board...
    The Romans were really advanced.

  • @antoniomartellini3443
    @antoniomartellini3443 5 лет назад +4

    The legionaries are not building a field but a strong fixed in some strategic point. The encampment of the legion camp was formed by a two-meter long dirt rampart at the top of which two-meter stakes were planted which the legionaries carried with them. The fields always had four doors and the tents for eight legionaries were always planted in the same place. Most of the European and British cities have arisen around these camps.

  • @miguelconti2304
    @miguelconti2304 3 года назад +2

    Great video! The romans are truly unbelievable

  • @Gabsboy123
    @Gabsboy123 3 года назад +1

    Legatum - civil engineer
    Centurion - foreman
    Legionnaire - laborer

  • @MrEazyE357
    @MrEazyE357 5 лет назад +2

    I love how the one dude picked up like 1/10 of a basket of dirt.

  • @KOLDBLU3ST33L
    @KOLDBLU3ST33L 5 лет назад +7

    The Roman army must have been in very good shape.

  • @TAttiusMaximvs
    @TAttiusMaximvs 4 года назад

    Good video Marc

  • @SirEnglishBatman
    @SirEnglishBatman 3 года назад +3

    POV: You're besieging Alesia with the lads.

  • @misticoxz293
    @misticoxz293 6 лет назад +50

    The romans did their fortification in full armour

    • @jennylee9278
      @jennylee9278 6 лет назад

      It's more challenging that way.

    • @cosmos6077
      @cosmos6077 6 лет назад +16

      because they were inside enemy territory

    • @moviejose3249
      @moviejose3249 6 лет назад +6

      Only when making their on the march camps

    • @michaelgoldsmith9359
      @michaelgoldsmith9359 5 лет назад +2

      Movie Jose nope always when I’m enemy territory it was to react fast and when I’m friendly territory it was training

    • @Intranetusa
      @Intranetusa 5 лет назад +2

      This is a more permanent wooden fort built over several weeks and not a marching camp fort that the Romans built everyday. The palisade of their daily marching camp was protected by smaller wooden stakes (sudes) they carried while marching. Only the more permanent forts/outposts had towers and wooden walls, and those took much longer to build. In the book "Roman Legionary Fortresses 27 BC-AD 378" by Duncan Campbell, the author talks about different types of temporary and permanent fortifications. The more permanent forts (compared to their daily camping forts) were still often made of wood, while the biggest and most permanent ones evolved into rammed earth, stone, & brick fortifications.

  • @NoraFulcanelli
    @NoraFulcanelli 6 лет назад +2

    Watching these actors dig is painful

  • @johnnyb7628
    @johnnyb7628 5 лет назад +3

    "The soldiers get to work". Reminds me of my days in the Marine corps. Plenty of working parties.

    • @johnnyb7628
      @johnnyb7628 4 года назад

      @Al Strider They had alot of disiclipine up until late antiquity, then they were a gaggle fuck, hence why they fell.

    • @alessandrorandi7678
      @alessandrorandi7678 4 года назад

      They didn’t fell because they was conquered, their army lose some battles, but they stil the more powerful soldiers and army of the world.
      The roman empire wasn’t never conquered.
      It only collapse alone for internal conflicts and anarchy, then without ma army because the empire was dead the italian lands was easy for be conquered by the germans tribes.

  • @danmeehan1390
    @danmeehan1390 5 лет назад

    Another excellent presentation

  • @oldbaldfatman2766
    @oldbaldfatman2766 5 лет назад

    Feb. 4, 2019---Thanks for the video. Imagine the work needed to get all those trees ready to be used.

  • @FingerinUrDaughter
    @FingerinUrDaughter 4 года назад

    i like how the guys with shovels arent actually shoveling any dirt. very authentic.

  • @philipmarlowe2415
    @philipmarlowe2415 5 лет назад +2

    Lucky for them they decided to build near a lumber yard to obtain all that nice finished lumber

  • @eldrugoalex
    @eldrugoalex 4 года назад +2

    I learn about this in case of zombie apocalypse.

  • @RomanCourier
    @RomanCourier 4 года назад +1

    Leuk gedaan! Misschien een beetje laat na tien jaar om het te zeggen, maar het herinnert me eraan dat ik Nijmegen zeker wil bezoeken :)

  • @user-to4on1fd8g
    @user-to4on1fd8g 4 года назад +2

    Молодцы! Всё очень хорошо показали, натурально, исторически! И кирка Долобра, Фалеры и военный ремень Балтиас. 👍

  • @drew4564
    @drew4564 Год назад

    That one dude just hammering on the support for no reason 🤣🤣🤣

  • @tianx9275
    @tianx9275 5 лет назад +2

    and imagine they have to build miles of these in just merely days is crazy

  • @10THPROPHET
    @10THPROPHET 4 года назад

    This must've been hell to reenact.

  • @deanaldridge4277
    @deanaldridge4277 Год назад +1

    I would have liked to see how the wood was cut, prepared, and moved. The planks in this video, looked like they came from B&Q. Still a very interesting video. Thank you Marc Sanders.

  • @TheNinindi
    @TheNinindi 3 года назад +2

    Looks like they used their legion discount on those 2x6's at home depot

  • @MrMooemoney
    @MrMooemoney 2 года назад +1

    That looks like perfect made lumber you get in modern times... Perfect shape. No way it looked like that.

  • @Msalazar6sicVI
    @Msalazar6sicVI 13 дней назад

    The guy just mindlessly hitting that wood with a hammer 😂😂😂😂

  • @firstname4476
    @firstname4476 5 лет назад +1

    Imagine doing a days work like this and then fighting a battle at the end of it !

  • @hugodesrosiers-plaisance3156
    @hugodesrosiers-plaisance3156 3 года назад

    Surprisingly simple design.

  • @Man_fay_the_Bru
    @Man_fay_the_Bru 4 месяца назад

    Antonines wall runs through my back garden in Scotland, those romans didn’t fck about because it’s still clearly visible

  • @boondoggle1000
    @boondoggle1000 7 лет назад +22

    I was always led to believe through reading books on the history of the Romans and their own people or slaves that you would not find trees, especially hardwood trees of that length to cut and carve/plane down to make enormous beams for bridges, walls etc in the geographical areas where this would take place 2,000 years ago or so......I will say one thing though,,,even to this very day I was and always will be so fascinated as to how they made such fascinating structures like the Coliseum in Rome for instance , pyramids and so much more out of stone!! So fascinating to think of the skill these stone cutters had and the craftsmanship involved and what blows my mind is that so many of these ancient artifacts are still standing to this day!! Funny thing is, with all the technology we have in the world today with machines, tools, high priced architects designing homes, factories, bldg's etc... and after a few years you can see cracked foundations, bowed out walls, well u get the idea how mankind knew what they were doing thousands of years ago compared to our "building" society of the current world...sorry, didn't mean to rant here, just, like I said so amazed at what was done the right way and a spectacular piece in the end,,,don't even get me started on the craftmanship of the Sphynx, LOL....

    • @eth8064
      @eth8064 7 лет назад +5

      boondoggle1000 its all money mower days, budget houses means poor material and building material.

    • @ThePizzaGoblin
      @ThePizzaGoblin 6 лет назад +4

      I know this is an old comment, but I'll reply anyway. A lot of the really big roman structures are made out of concrete, not quarried stone. They were the first to discover it, and the knowledge of how to mix it was largely forgotten when the empire fell.

    • @vysearcadia522
      @vysearcadia522 6 лет назад +4

      The structures still standing today have been maintained... you can't get roman structures sitting there and not decay. Someone had to be there to preserve it. Its always been this way. Always will be. The fascinating stuff is the parts of those buildings that have not required any maintenance. But to say that Roman and Greek architecture hasn't had any preservation modifications made to them is a folly statement.

    • @jmcfintona999
      @jmcfintona999 6 лет назад +1

      boondoggle1000 northern Europe was nearly all forest when the Romans conquered it Britain too. That's why it has some of the best farmland in the world and possibly why the birthplace of farming in the middle East has so little good farmland anymore.

    • @DMahalko
      @DMahalko 5 лет назад

      The Coliseum used iron bars in the construction to hold it together. However after the collapse of the empire and the rise of Christianity, people no longer cared about these structures, and so would remove the iron to make weapons. What's left of it is actually very fragile with all these structural components removed.

  • @Djstar-jl8ch
    @Djstar-jl8ch 6 лет назад +6

    At school I’m learning the Romans so imma watch dis

  • @krekodaktil208
    @krekodaktil208 Год назад

    3:01 There's always been that one guy wearing a helmet that just stands there and commands.

  • @z0r080
    @z0r080 3 года назад

    Where did they get those nice wooden planks?

  • @cjthebeesknees
    @cjthebeesknees 11 месяцев назад

    Makes perfect sense, a standard Roman legion functioned just like a colony of Ants.

  • @Gloopular
    @Gloopular 3 года назад

    The perfectly squared lumber - a fine invention by the Romans !

  • @henrywcrook
    @henrywcrook 5 лет назад +1

    Whered they find the home depo to get that lumber?

  • @bradleyeric14
    @bradleyeric14 5 лет назад +1

    In decent weather, soldiers doing manual labour strip. Loincloth is all they wear. Those guarding them are in full battledress and are at a distance towards source of possible danger.

  • @Yaponnk
    @Yaponnk 5 лет назад

    So, the legions carried as many nails as grain, good thinking there Phalera.

  • @praetorianus72
    @praetorianus72 14 лет назад

    Great job

  • @rhysmeyrick615
    @rhysmeyrick615 Год назад

    Nice that they had all that machine cut wood to hand.

  • @ShadOsman
    @ShadOsman 5 лет назад

    Gotta hand it to these Romans they even put up RUclips tutorials. Pretty handy if you ask me

  • @user-ge4uk9ui8y
    @user-ge4uk9ui8y 4 года назад

    Didn't know romans had access to modern precision sawmill cut planks with much of the sides wasted.

  • @robertaurens5665
    @robertaurens5665 4 года назад

    So where exactly did they get the clean and planed timbers? B and Q????

  • @jbearmcdougall1646
    @jbearmcdougall1646 5 лет назад

    I'm fairly sure a troop of engineers and scouts ranged ahead of the column and started the process before the army got there!!

  • @mrmountaindewdew1
    @mrmountaindewdew1 5 лет назад +4

    mmmm gotta lov the industrial Wood They get there

  • @Testacabeza
    @Testacabeza 5 лет назад +1

    Join the Legions, they said. You'll see the world, they said. It's man's life, they said.

  • @plinkbottle
    @plinkbottle 5 лет назад +1

    The video suggests they had somebody beating a drum all the time they worked. Must have driven them nuts.

  • @sg0310
    @sg0310 5 лет назад +1

    When you flex on the gauls by building a wall around their wall

  • @foreverraining1522
    @foreverraining1522 4 месяца назад

    Only difference is there wood didn't come straight from the lumber yard.

  • @diagreen
    @diagreen 13 лет назад

    love it.thanx

  • @bodyrumuae2914
    @bodyrumuae2914 Год назад +1

    What's the guy on the wall hammering for? Nudge that post into alignment the several inches they were off by? If putting in nails, would take ages to build a wall by tapping them in millimeter by millimeter each tap. Swing that hammer and drive them in.

  • @gpepeitan3373
    @gpepeitan3373 6 лет назад

    What kind of fortress is this the ones they build fast during a battle or no

  • @robertaurens5665
    @robertaurens5665 4 года назад

    Special joint, otherwise known as a dovetail joint!!

  • @frauleinhohenzollern8442
    @frauleinhohenzollern8442 Год назад

    I never know who to root for at the ambush of teutoburg forest... im a fanatic german patriot, but i deeply admire the romans 😥

  • @SeattlePioneer
    @SeattlePioneer 5 лет назад

    So where did all that finished lumber come from?

  • @overlordgaming752
    @overlordgaming752 3 года назад

    Roman legionaries would make great wild land firefighters, they already know how to form digging lines and do it efficiently. Just teach em that it’s for fire defense instead of Germanic defense

  • @doncarlodivargas5497
    @doncarlodivargas5497 4 года назад +1

    No wonder the romans could build an empire when the barbarians where stopped by that little wall

  • @twiceasodd3333
    @twiceasodd3333 2 года назад

    All we need is the red dead building music and it will be perfect.

  • @brandonk881
    @brandonk881 5 лет назад +2

    I did not know romans had power drills.
    I also did not know there was a edge of the earth and that romans built on the edge of the earth...

  • @nonye0
    @nonye0 2 года назад +1

    imagine doin all these work while being underattack by barbarians at the same time? i wish i can literally transport my soul back and watch how they did it lol

  • @Ypacarai
    @Ypacarai 5 лет назад

    Is this camp for one night or for one winter??

  • @AM-jw1lo
    @AM-jw1lo 3 месяца назад

    Leaves more questions than answers. Is this more than historical fiction? How long was it occupied, what is the archeology of the site?

  • @kampfpiper3853
    @kampfpiper3853 5 лет назад

    What series is this?

  • @stevengarland697
    @stevengarland697 5 лет назад

    Did they get the tools from Ace Hardware?

  • @southronjr1570
    @southronjr1570 Год назад

    I'm gonna take a wild guess that few of the actors had ever really used a pick, mattock, or shovel before bc they sure seemed to be rookies at it and would have some serious blisters by lunch the way they appeared to be handling them.

  • @insch.9547
    @insch.9547 3 года назад

    Woods are so expensive today

  • @jasonhalliday5141
    @jasonhalliday5141 8 лет назад +1

    well done

  • @legioxequestris811
    @legioxequestris811 2 года назад +1

    This is wery good

  • @CyberChud2077
    @CyberChud2077 Год назад

    …Where did they get the 2x4s?

  • @VOTE_REFORM_UK
    @VOTE_REFORM_UK 3 года назад +1

    Romans: “These barbarians don’t know how to build good walls, let’s show them.”
    Gauls: “Thanks guys, in fact, we are so grateful for your work that we will let you keep the settlement :) “