Pearl Mimic Pro vs Roland TD-50 vs Alesis Strike Pro sound demo with drum-tec
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
- www.drum-tec.com
In this little video, we would like to give you a brief sound impression of the Pearl Mimic Pro, the Roland TD-50 and the Alesis Strike Pro electronic drum sound modules.
All three modules are hooked up to the drum-tec pro series electronic drums. While we have combined Roland MG cymbals & the VH-13 Hihat controller with the Mimic Pro & the Roland TD-50, we have used the Alesis Strike cymbals & HiHat controller with the Strike Pro module.
You can find all components in our online shop:
www.drum-tec.c...
www.drum-tec.c...
www.drum-tec.c...
Please feel free to leave a comment or ask any question you might have. You can also get in touch with our service team directly through info@drum-tec.de
Video was shot @ drum-tec West / Spytunes Recording Studio, Mainz
Drumming by Ralf Schumacher
This guy could make trash cans sound incredible.
Haha, thank you very much ;) you can find more drumming/music on my personal channel over here if you like:
ruclips.net/user/digitaldrumming
Kind regards!
I totally agree! Every time I see Ralf play, I wonder what the hell I'm doing behind a kit! 😂
He did. It's called the TD-50!
@@482jpsquared :-D
The Mimic pro is the best module to come out. BUT I have to say that Alesis is putting all the efforts to bring the best bang for your buck.
what about the ATV one? from the sound standpoint they sound decent both of them. alesis is ok, roland sounds horrible to my ears
I am very impressed. Alesis has come a long way, and the strike pro is no joke. The strike pro sounds really good, and at a steal compared to the others.
TBH, I think any criticism of sounds of the Alexis is funny, I own a 2Box module and when I want new sounds I just find what I like and put them in the module. Can’t do that with any of the others. That’s the beauty of multi layered samples being played from a module. The mimic cannot or will not allow new samples.
@@thomasknipe4969what about the latency of the alesis? I read and heard its slow compared to roland. What is your experience in the alesis when it comes to fast playing, how would you judge it?
I am planning to buy the strike pro, did some research with superior drummer 3 and that REALLY makes the drums come alive!! I'm sold on that program
I come here trying to learn what electric set is the best and leave thinking I shouldn't even bother cause I'll never be as good as this guy
;-)
Skylar Learn. Practice. You’ll get there.
Invalid comment. Drums are not a competition. No matter what you do, there is a 100% chance you'll never be the best
Put the hours in and you will become a beast. There’s really no secret to it.
This guy could play on a cookie box and it will be sound great. Great drummer!
:-D thank you very much!
Word! Through this entire video, I was thinking, "This dude is sick!" 🤣🤣🤣🥁🎵🎶🎶🎵🎶
I mean the Mimic Pro is definitely the best sounding by far in my opinion. For only $2700 the Alesia Strike Pro with all the pads it comes with, and the (not half bad) drum module is really a steal in my book!
Obviously sound wise, the Mimic sounds the best, but damn that Strike module surprised me. I expected it to sound much worse. I'd say its downfall would be the crash cymbals but I preferred the tom sounds over the Roland TD50, personally. It likely isn't as refined as the Roland module but for the INSANE price difference, Alesis has done some damn fine work this time.
Agreed. I also thought the Alesis toms sounded better than the TD 50. The cymbals didn t sound good on the Strike though. Considering the price difference between the Roland and the Strike Module.....geeze.....I was surprised too that Alesis was somewhat competitive at least with their "tom" sounds. I m sure with tweaking the TD 50 tom sounds are much better than in this video.
Derek Frampton I've always preferred high end Yamaha stuff over Roland. I also had the DM10 module and after playing the Strike Pro I can definitely say it's in a whole other league. Alesis has my approval, especially when in my local stores the Strike Pro is $3,800 and the TD50 is around $13,000.
The Alesis Strike Pro, is a flat out BEAST. Everyone has their preference, but for the sound, plethora of multi layered recorded instrument options with optional dual layering, AND THE PRICE TAG! It’s Strike Pro all day. I’m a heavy hitter and I’ve never encountered any trouble with any of my Alesis E-Drums. From my 13 year old DM5, my daughters 8 year old Nitro Mesh, and 10 year old DM6 my 7 year old DM10 Surge, to my 14 piece (6 toms 8,10,12,12,14,14) 14 snare, 14 kick Strike Pro’s, 3 DM10 (X-toms 8’8’10’) 12’ Piccolo X-snare Real Heads, ‘D’ pad samples and effects 8,8) 11 Surge ‘smartrigger’ cymbals (16,16,16 14,14,14,13,13,13, 14 X-hats, 13hh) all run by dual (2) Strike Pro Modules. It’s not only the biggest, most beautiful E-Kit, I’ve ever owned... it’s also the best sounding E-Kit I’ve ever owned. Though I’ve never been a fan of ANY brands rubber e-cymbals, I will say Yamaha and Rolands (I’m that order) have better stick feel. Alesis gets constantly dogged because of the price tag. I believe that if some of you Roland guys could have a Strike Pro kit for a week to ten days to truly play, and familiarize with the 10,000 ‘voices’, you’d NEVER overpay for the Roland name again.
@@cadenceangel I have the solution. Throw in a couple of your favorite cymbal sounds from other kits, (obviously gonna have to make a kit from scratch) and BOOM, you're done ;)
I like the alesis.. nice tight sounding kits
i can't believe that with the quality of Roland drums and modules, they ship with these awful plastic sounding drums. So many advanced playing capabilities but they can't manage to get rid of that plastic clicky shotgun effect. In the 80's that was understandable, but in 2017 come on guys.... Awesome drumming though!
Thank you! :)
tommaso 27
I know what you mean. Especially when I go from playing my Roland td17 to my Tama kit. Those stupid heads on my acoustic kit sound way way to plasticky and clicky. Geeeeez!!!!
It's velocity and attack. They "fixed" the machine gun effect issue on the TD-20 (and following modules) by rolling off the attack when playing a roll, making it less noticable on the cymbals but with the toms and snare, it didn't always work as well because of the velocity of each strike would often "peek" the input. In other words, each strike word register at 100% velocity even though the player still had a ways to go before getting to 100% and the module didn't account for different drummers playing at different intensities. (My 100% isn't the same as your 100% but the module doesn't care.) Hopefully, that's been fixed with the latest modules.
Picked up a Mimic Pro a while back, (This video was a strong factor in picking it) Still coming back to this video just for Ralph's grooves :)
Thank you very much David, that's great to hear! :)
Man, the Rolands sound awfully "papery". Thanks Slate & Pearl for actually bringing samples that actual engineers use daily and putting them into a module.
That’s always been the case w/ Roland drum sounds…very thin and not realistic…
The mimic sounds more realistic of the 3 hands down!
The real test is in actually playing it. Because sounding good is great. But if the sound you hear is not the sound you expect to hear by the way you played it. Then it’s all nearly for not. Because where and how you played it are just as important if not more so when you are considering the experience. Not just the sound...
Yes I failed to take this important consideration into view when I bought my Strike. The sounds are decent but the playability is laughable.
I'd say Mimic Pro for the realism, Strike Pro for the fun factor, TD-50 for somewhere in between.
The mimic pro is the best sounding module on the market as of 2019. Period. Eats my roland for lunch.
Scott Lowell guess even Alesis is eating my Roland... Alesis even have a Delicious kit.
can i layer my own samples?
Seems that way to me too but Slate's samples are still not the best in my opinion. Platinum Samples packs are to this day still the absolute best sampled acoustic drums ever made. (The three main packs). If the mimic had those, I'd buy it for sure.
The Pearl Mimic Pro sounds so realistic like real drum sets.
No doubt, the Pearl Mimic sounds much better than the TD-50. However, I am not convinced with the triggering. I bet the Roland TD-50 still triggers better. The Alesis Strike is a low budget tool. Would rather buy a used TD-20 and use sample software.
You are not convinced with the triggering after looking the video? how can you judge triggering looking at the video?
I cannot judge it by watching, that is why I am not convinced:)
Vdrum Tips I agree. Drum tec may not have the mimic "dialed in" as well. It definitely seems as if the TD 50 is tracking the nuances in his playing much more accurately, particularly the hi hat and ride
TD50 just has less dynamic range here. I mean light strokes are sounding louder on TD50. Mimic tracks all the ghost/light notes in that video - I can hear all of them in my headphones .
I don't agree that the Mimic sounds way better than the TD-50. I'm having a hard time deciding which is best actually. Strike is not as good but that is to be expected considering its price point. Still a good module for the price though.
Drummer with so much soul still can’t even make the TD 50 sound anything but lifeless. It sounds good but when you’re going after pearl it doesn’t compete.
Thanks for this video and all the others you’ve produced. It helps me a lot with my buying decisions 💜
Hey Adam, thank you very much, glad to hear that! :)
once you see this guy playing, you end up watching all drumtec videos :)
Thank you very much for your nice feedback, glad you like the videos! :)
Same here! Been watching Drum-tec videos for a month now... but next week I'll have my own kit (TD-17KV or KVX) and I will lock myself in the attic for at least two weeks...
A great drummer like this one can make garbage cans sound good.
;-D thank you very much!
Considering the mimic is just the module on its own costs the same if not more than the the whole alesis set up….I’d go for the alesis. Plus Roland much like PRS and DW drums are so over priced for what they are. And I’ve heard the alesis sounding so much better than it does on here.
One feature these manufacturers should consider, especially because a lot of times these are used standalone.. A way to sample the room the kit is in and adjust the reverb to match what real kit would sound like in that space. A way to superimpose the kit into that setting.
They should`ve done this differently: Play all the kits but DON`T state which take has been played on which module! Then let all these smart people in here who commented favourably about the mimic and td-50 while bashing the Alesis write down their opinions on each recording and rate them as well. After having gotten some hundreds of votings this way drumtec should publish the results. I guess we´re all would be surprised: Alesis-wise......... that modul is a killer when you take all the features into account. Can`t even believe that they could do this for such a small price! After having played one today I´ll get rid of my TD-20X ASAP and likely will never look back again. The TD-30 could not make me think like that, the TD-50 or mimic might, but their insane insane price tags will very likely end any considerations in that direction for me.
Just purchased a Drum Tec to play with my Mimic Pro
Great to hear, happy drumming & have lots of fun!
Thank you for doing this comparison. It is difficult to get into a store and try this. I appreciate your time and effort..
You are very welcome, thank you for your feedback! :)
Do you know if this module has a click option? Doing a comparison of the Pearl versus the Roland TD - 50.
I listened to them and the mimic pro sounds great, the TD50 well, it triggers well and the Strike has the ability to add your own multi layered sounds. I think that is whats missing in these sound comparisons. The mimic has everything except open architecture like the Alesis and the 2box has. The TD50 has the ability to improve its sound with sample layering. I still think the Strike has the higher ceiling if your willing to put the work into it.
I chose the alesis strike pro, because I just liked the look and only needed the features on the drum. I don't really care about the sound of the module, because I only need an electric drum hardware for midi on various software with much wider sound control options that are not found in any drum kit module. Because until recently, it was best to buy sound the vst digital drum. sd3 is the best
Strike doesnt detect ghost notes half as good as the others. (Seems to me). Mimic stands out by sounding superior! Thanx for great vid and playing!!:)
Thank you, glad you liked it! :)
I'm pretty sure there are settings to make the triggering more accurate
There is a way to do that with the alesis I own the dm10x pro. They have a very hyper sensitive trigger it's just the way you program it.
@@HLDrums You're right, that's why all those "vs" videos are non sense ... triggering speaking
@@gnogno35 I don't know.. Had a dm10 and despite all the settings and tweaking never liked the triggering.
I also think they haven't done a lot to these samples since then. The first kit sounded incredibly familiar to me from the old dm10.
Looks like the Mimic sounds more natural but Roland triggers more natural?
MIMIC is the real winner.
Roland sounds best, but the Strike is amazing value for the money
great video but i will stick with my td 30 and midi with addictive drums , this video determined that for me ,thanks
Roland still has no clue about how toms and bass drums should sound. Awful.
I concur on this point. My church bought TD 25 just b4 they released TD 17....n I hv been so disappointed with d toms, kick n even snares... Meanwhile ...these aweful samples don't even hv dedicated outs to tweak individually ...n d worst of it ....it lacks even dedicated eq's on each samples sampling capabilities unlike its baby bro TD 17......n shamefully they r still on d shelves selling ....what a shame.
Don't forget the awful snare sounds.
@@CAMOAH1 the sounds in a Roland unit aren't actually "samples" the way that you might find on BFD or Tunetracks software. They are computer simulations of samples based on an algorithm. It's how Roland gives you instantaneous load times and really weird tuning options....because it isnt limited to what you might do to a .wav sample and still sound somewhat natural.
In addition....the new modules were programmed by the keyboard and effects team at Roland....not the drum team who have been working on the TD series for decades. Consequently, the sounds kind of suck.
The secret to the Roland modules is lots of tweaking. The sounds are in there but you gotta fiddle.
@@riffism Not true. They are actually highly processed samples. The entire Roland rom is less space then a single kit on the Mimic... just for the protocol .. that must tell you a lot about the quality of the samples in question.. ..and the fact they are still using a ROM in 2017 - (reusing same old tech since 200x) - that is the reason the core sound library is not upgreadable
My guess would be TD-50 for playability/sensitivity and Mimic Pro for sounds. Strike Pro if you're on a budget
Chris Baker on point tbh
I wish that Alesis had their ADAT (even SMUX) for transferring 8 channels without DA-AD, just like an SD recording (if they write 8 channels separately on SD). For home usage :)
even he fucking hates playing with the alesis module, look at his face when he does lol
The Mimic has a much wider dynamic range than the TD50 and a lot more samples. The default kits show the range. I actually have reduced the dynamic range in mine so the quiet notes are louder. The hi hat also performs much better than the TD50 but it is quiet in the presets. If you were to run the Mimic video through compression,you would be able to hear the detail in a similar way to the TD50. The Mimic allows compression on EACH MIC of each drum,which is incredible. There are also many other controls to adjust the dynamic range.
Splendid video!
Soundwise I'd say Alesis < Roland < Pearl
Playability wise (assumption) maybe Alesis < Pearl < Roland.....What's Ralfs opinion of them?
*_ROLAND TD-50 LOVE!😍🥁❤️_*
Do you think the td27 is better than the td50? I'm looking at the 27 because of the 28 usb multichannel out. I dont understand why the td50(flagship) only has 10 channel usb out.
Hey Adam (sorry for the delayed reply, the RUclips notifications are off sometimes obviously), the TD-27 has a great price/performance ratio, as it offers some of the most interesting features of the TD-50 (digital pads compatibility, VH-13 compatibility, positional sensing, more in/outputs than the smaller TD-17, usb multichannel etc). Still, if you want to be using the module live & need 8 direct outputs & the physical faders for volumes for example, the TD-50 still is the only current Roland option which offers this. Kind regards!
All three modules sounded good. The Mimic was a clear winner in my opinion. One thing to remember is the Mimic has 65 acoustic kits, no useless t808,909 garbage. For someone looking for acoustic only sounds like my self the Roland and Alesis fall way short. I believe the have 6-10 acoustic kits each.
Interesting. Pearl was a clear winner for me. I did like the second Alesis kit quite a lot. I'm a long time TD-12 user but I really don't like the snare sound on any of the Roland kits in this video, although that's partly personal taste rather than that they're just "bad" I guess. But yeah, I came to this video cos I'm considering buying a Mimic Pro and this did nothing at all to dissuade me haha. So thanks for the video (and lovely playing :) )
Hey Alec, glad to hear! :) have you also checked out some of our more recent Mimic Pro demos already?
ruclips.net/video/WGd3Do4XBDA/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/mhmCvCBoJXE/видео.html
Kind regards!
Came for the modules, stayed for the drummer's performance.
Thank you very much! :)
The grunge mimic snare sounds amazing!
Mimic Pro is the one I’d go for. Lazy Roland hasn’t done anything interesting.
I like mimic sounds better but Roland has the digital snare (which they didn't show in this video) which I think is a game changer. Well, at least for those who can afford it......
wow, very nice. You are firing the videos now one after another. Great comparison. Mimic is the winner for my opinion. It triggers very well ( own experience) and the sound is superior.
Yes I went on a 2 week holiday, so there was some video firing before :D thank you & kind regards!
AMAZING demo comparison!!! I just miss the aD5 with the new released sounds... Do you have plan to demo those new sounds? Thank you so much!!!!
We will be demoing ATV aDrums very soon :) Kind regards
My ears started hurting hearing the strike after hearing the mimic and td-50. Its not even bad, but its noticeable to my sub conscious
I agree with you on this.
posi sensing snare wins out, way more real reacting
Man your drumming is so smooth!!
Thank you Miguel! :)
The Mimic snare is where it's at.
I liked the Pearl the best, but was pleasantly surprised by the Alesis.
Thanks for video. Your playing is truly inspiring! Jaw dropped more than a few times. :)
Thank you very much :)
Great drumming but I'm never gonna be able to afford any of these drum sets. I think the Pearl Mimic won though.
Roland sounds more natural
I always stayed far away from e drums. Hated them. Now I'm in a battle of not able to play in apmt. Years. I miss it so...I'm going to attempt to purchase my first edrum kit. The demo here of the pearl sound way better to me than what I've heard in past. I cant stand the robotics. I hope I have the money one day to buy one. May have to unload all the other gear I bought over the years trying to fill the void. Keyboard workstations and guitars etc.
Robert Clark so what did you end up getting?
The score: 1 - Ralph, 2 - Pearl, 3 - Alesis, 4 - there is no 4 ;)
;-D thank you!
That Bubinga kit from Roland sounds very Simon Phillips. I wonder if they sampled it off the Tama Starclassics.
The Roland kits sounded pretty good except for the rim shot on the 50th Anniversary Kit. I could live with those sounds for a live rock gig. The Mimic sounded very good. The drums sounded good on the the Strike but I did not like the cymbals a whole lot. That's just my take on my computer speakers. :-)
All three sound fantastic, hard to say with absolute surety which is the better. It would have to come down to how they play. I have only played the TD50 and it's a very impressive machine.
If the strike plays as well as the TD50 and Mimic, it would have to be the Strike as a better buy purely on the fact it's half the cost. But, if cost isn't an issue.... It's between the mimic and the TD50 for me. The TD50 for the fact the USB ride and snare a step ahead of the curve, but the touch screen amongst a few other things might have me preferring the Mimic.
With all this said, I come to check out the sound of these modules and had to listen again because the first time I was just loving this guy play!!!
Thank you very much :)
Dude, you're an INCREDIBLE player....
sadly for Roland , Alesis sounds better...so , #1 Mimic , #2 Alesis , #3 Roland shotgun sounds...come on guys , you have nice hardware , so put some good realistic drums to it.
Pearl Mimic rules!!!
and you did it again every day I enjoy watching the videos you make it's amazing the sound of these three modules are incredible.and I finally ordered my kick drum so I can wait I'm so excited....keep it up drum Tec forever
Thank you! :)
np. Thank you for making some awesome products
Im in love with the snare sound of the "Grunge Kit" on Mimic
All sound great....fantastic playing and overall production..great job!
Thank you very much! :)
Pearl wins by far.
Not sure how often you guys reply on here, but how much do yall mess with the KitFx settings on the Alesis Strike Pro? I've only recently found that turning most of it off gives all the acoustic kits a much cleaner sound, and I noticed on this video that the kits sound arguably better than what I hear haha. Anyways, great video as always!
Hey Drew, actually we reduced pretty much most of the FX on the Alesis standard settings. What kit are you referring to? The Alesis kits from the video all are rather dry actually. Kind regards
The ride on the td50 is plugged via usb. Can you tell a big difference in dynamics???
Hi, the CY-18DR is 18" in diametre and has a different surface/rebound and bigger bell than the smaller Roland cymbal pads. It plays/feels exceptionally well & realistic, probably the most realistic ride cymbal pad on the market in my personal opinion. But you need the TD-50 to use it though... Kind regards!
Awesome playing man.
I'm planning to buy an electric drum all my life have played acoustic drums.
The real question is how bad it is that if your electric drum broken?
Is it common? Or the repair price is high?
Thanks
Hi Fio, the drum-tec pro series from this video has a 5 year warranty :) even with the lower level diabolo series you'll get 3 years, feel free to get in touch through service@drum-tec.de for any further questions and check out www.drum-tec.com, kind regards!
These are one of the best e-drum modules currently. There are a few other wonderful ones, ATV, Efnote, 2Box, etc., but I understand this test, because for one: these are the big selling brands.
I still think the cymbals are the weaker points in the total e-drum experience. It's not the sounds, it's the trigger technology.
But I'm seeing the constant development curve upwards, and it will not take too long before there will come a moment when those e-cymbals will also make us wonder with our eyes closed: "is it real or not"?
There will always be real drumming, but these things make some situations (like recording, silent practicing) a whole of a lot easier, quicker, and therefore: cost saving.
What I also like to see is when drum manufacturers start putting their effort again into high quality compact e-drum pads that feel as natural as the real e-drum kettles used now.
I think there's an even big market (probably bigger) for those, compared to the full size kettle e-drums.
Hey Drumtec you guys should make a Video on Why We should Buy your Drum pads stuff like Diabolo stuff like that VS Other competition such as Roland Yamaha etc
I thought we just did...? ;) We don´t advertise by telling you what to do, we prefer letting the products speak for themselves in our product demos. And there are plenty on all of our drum-tec e-drums by now, please just go to our channel & experience the kits in all different configurations with different sound modules (Mimic, TD-11, TD-15, TD-25, TD-30, TD-50, ATV aD5, Alesis Strike, Superior Drummer, Addictive Drums etc...). For any further product info please get in touch with our service team through info@drum-tec.de directly. Kind regards
@@drumtecTV The perfect reply! I love the approach of letting the products speak for themselves. I have been curious, however, about your professional opinion too.
i want the rolland cymbals with the toms of mimic or alesis
To my ears the Roland sounds better overall, but definitely the cymbals. Just also watched a TD-25 vs Strike Pro vid and the difference was even more apparent.
wow the pearl sounds just perfect! i still cant believe how "crap" roland sounds for any price. lots of mashine gunning going on, especlially with the toms. alesis just sounds super dry and flat
Would it be fair to say you were uninspired when playing the Alesis module? If so was that due to mainly to the triggering or the sounds? I got the impression you were more expressive and dynamic on the other modules. The Roland VAD306 is much cheaper in Australia than the Alesis, but the sounds aren't as good. But if I can be more expressive on the Roland would it be worth sacrificing the sound quality? Thanks mate.
Hi, you are right the Roland cymbals (especially the hihat) trigger / play much smoother & more expressive on both Mimic Pro as well as TD-50 than the Alesis Strike Pro. Same goes for the drum-tec pads actually, which do work with the Alesis module but won't offer the same range of functionality & playability as with TD-50 / Mimic. Kind regards!
I'm just here copping all these awesome licks. Great playing.
Thank you Owen! :)
PLATOS ALESIS+BOMBO PEARL+REDOBLANTE Y TOMS ROLAND+BATERIA DW=100%
vic firth
have the mimic over a yer now-really happy the only thing i miss is positional sensing on the snare (i believe its a roland patent)and the ability to create own multilayered sounds - like octabans-chromatic cowbells e.t.c. as we are doing zappa music...yes one could bring a computer blahblah- but it is never that conveniant like a single module-hook it up switch it on thats it.
Great drumming the pearl mimic sounds great but i love the Roland TD 50😀
Mimic pro has the best sounds. But if I have to buy a kit for myself, I'll go with the Strike Pro.
Agreed. The Alesis tom sounds were really good too. I mean for 2300 US dollars.....
C’mon Roland gets the win. Cymbals and snare are incredible, the toms its onñy matter of tunning and other parameters. Alesis has envolved and the mimic si great Roo... but Roland it’s still the best
If we're just judging based on sound quality from a drum module, where was the KAT kt4 in this vid...? Great video though.
Let’s be honest, price and sounds alesis is the best period
I have a TD-30 and have contemplated replacing it, but I'm not sure. I like the drums in the Mimic Pro more, but the cymbals in the Roland seem to trigger SO much better (they do in my TD-30 as well). Regardless, all of these kits sound great, mainly because of the fantastic playing of the person doing the demo. Great job!
Thank you so much! :)
Funny how people comment about playability. Video doesn't say nothing about playability. You need to try it yourself. I've been with Roland for years. It triggers good, it's reliable, but it sounds like cheap toy comparing to Mimic. Strike sounds better than Roland. But they both years behind Mimic.
The Mimic also costs more than an entire Strike Pro kit, so you've got to take that into mind. Of course the Mimic sound miles better, but it isn't justifiable to me for that price.
Yes but Strike kit pro have many flaw, cone falling from inside the pad, default hi-hat is "poor" to "average", module can stop at anytime, there is much issue and bad reports, not biased reports it's one that I know reported to me on a daily basis, even the toms cone falling, and the hi-hat is not up to Roland standard, in fact using roland pad trigs better with alesis strike module,. But for many it's not issue for them and the price is factor.
Well that's good for you I guess, I've had Alesis products and never had an issue. The hi hat isn't poor, it was something that was addressed in a software update. The cones falling from the snare pad has also been addressed in current models. This is a brand new product, trial and error. You can even fix the fallen cones yourself. Clearly you have your biased view though so I won't bother trying to change that.
Personally, I'd rather get the entire Strike Pro kit and a VST for basically the price of one module.
"Not up to Roland standard" ummm yeah, there is a reason the Roland TD-50KV costs almost $11,000 AUD and the Strike Pro costs $3,500 AUD. Saying "the hi hat is poor" and "the hi hat is not comparable to Roland" are not the same thing. Of course price is a factor for most people, who the hell has over 10 grand to spend on an electronic drum kit? A small minority of the people in the market.
You realize a Strike module can easily become a Mimic module right? Or Roland or anything else. It is completely customizable from a sound point of view.
Sound wise, TD50 lush tails and overtones of the drums and cymbals are the best. The kits he demo in the Mimic are awesome overall kits recorded there, and the Strike is very good for the price but nothing near. Now lets face it, who plays like Ralf anyway? Killer chops dude!! I really like your drumming!
Thank you very much pal :)
Its definitely a toss up between the pearl mimic an Roland td 50 but Roland modules behave better capturing more nuances which most modules can't do and the strike isn't even close
Bass kick sounds let the Roland down where as the cymbals let the Alesis down. The Mimic has no weak sounds at all in my opinion.
Let‘s be honest Roland isn‘t about sound, it‘s about durability. The TD50 lost in the Comparison but my TD17 overlived all of my Alesis Drums. Pearl Mimic won imo!
But the Video wasn‘t about the comparison cause this Dude stole the Show!
;-D
roland only does good on their cymbals tbh. MINUS THE HI HAT!!! Their hi-hats have sounded awful for the LONGEST TIME and i don't know why. If there was a module with pearl drums and hats with roland cymbals i'd save up for it in a heartbeat.
Prefiero Roland....., de lejos. Las otras marcas son buenas pero prefiero el sonido de Roland, además por la sensibilidad quw tirne en diferentes partes de la superficie del redoblante
The pearl module is a much better then the roland and the alesis is really bad
pearl is the king all the way!
Comparisson with Yamaha Flagship would be interesting as well.
Hey Georg, maybe in the not so distant future :) kind regards!
@@drumtecTV But hasnt yamaha gone into e-drum hibernation? Seems like very little is happening since the dtx 900 came along seven years ago. (yeah, Im only interested in the high-end stuff;)
Having played Roland TD 20 for years and my friend has the TD30 I held off because it wasn't a big improvement over TD20 in my needs but that TD50 SOUNDS Jarrah ply and Prism Jarrah is awful. I've never heard a Jarrah play kit in real life to compare it too. It doesn't sound natural. I'm disappointed with Roland.
My friend bought and gave me his Alesis Strike Pro and I'm very happy with it. Once I explored the sounds I found what I've expected from Roland but never received. Real kits of what I used before. Noble Cooley and Yamaha Oak Custom. Paiste cymbals and the ability to sample my own multiple layers.
Does Roland TD 50 allow multiple layers? From soft to loud? I only read one sample shots but no multiple layer sounds. Some snares have different sounds soft versus loud.
Mimic Pro is right using Slate so I may purchase that in future if I feel it is better. Roland module needs a serious overhaul already because the new menu is awful compared to old and the sounds should be top sounds of DW Maple, Yamaha recording custom Birch, Sabian, Paiste etc and not digital recreations of unknown woods and kits.
Agreed. It sounded to my ears like the Alesis Module in terms of "toms n bass" sounded best. Of course, I wasn t crazy about the Alesis cymbals. To me, I d rate them "overall" Mimic Pro, Roland (only because of the cymbal triggers) then Alesis. Considering the Roland TD 50 Module is 2200 US dollars....man, hopefully they ll rethink their next line of V Drums. I could buy an entire Alesis Strike Pro for the cost of Roland s TD 50 module. If Alesis fixes all the "bugs" etc, I ll aim for that and.... I could add a Mimic Pro to replace the Alesis Module if I can t get the sounds I want out of it. One real positive that I hear a lot about Roland>>they can take a heck of a beating for years with no problems. But man, their prices!!!
Joey Dang the Strike has better samples of cymbals to choose from that wasn't shown in this video. I have a 24" Paiste Giant Beat ride that is awesome. After the five months of ownership and firmware updates my only issues has been the hi hat. I'm not crazy about the hi hat pads. My snare did have issues but Alesis quickly replaced it for me. I did plug in other pads and they worked great with Alesis. I even tried Roland pads on it and all I had to do was adjust sensitivity and they worked great.
Alesis rep told me the Strike is for drummers that want a basic kit with quality sounds they use and not all the extras like other kits and that delivers. You can import more with the free Strike Editor software, multiple layer it with samples for realistic soft to loud and adjust rolls on all instruments. The only two things Alesis needs to fix is the hi hat and adjust cymbal rolls.
I'm loving it. I have a Yamaha oak kit and Noble Cooley maple kit with various Paiste cymbals and various snares I use that I could never get with Roland. I also layered the bass drum with two sounds to get a what I want.
Robert L : I agree BUT! After I upgraded my TD 20 into a TD 50, I started applying effects, compressing, etc and the amazing TRANSIENT application. Now I can say, each time I sit behind the kit: YES! . But you have to do the effort. I admit I never heard the other E kits before , they sound amazing. Grts
Yaboroqé that's my problem with Roland. You have to put in effort to make them sound good.
But I now have the Pearl Mimic and it is amazing. I haven't edited hardly anything yet and love it. I just can't justify spending the money on TD50 still.
2019 is coming but still roland, alesis and pearl has not produced an overall adequate competency in an electronic drum set that could easily be found acoustic drums (16.12.2018)
Sorry, don´t know what you mean & cannot agree at all :) kind regards
All sounded great except the Roland kick, thats just weird
Anyone here saying that the strike is not a good sounding e-drum must keep in mind that only factory sound sets were used. I suggest you all to watch this video of how the strike can sound when you take the time to create your own user kits : ruclips.net/video/bWkwIqZ8kxM/видео.html
Seems like the hi hat was so low in all of the mixes, but some damned good sounds here. Love that Mimic....
I should say that sounds themselves are better in Mimic, but nuances of articulation are handled WAY better by TD-50 to my ear.
Roland needs to let go
what is the hi hat settings you have in the strike module ?
tim de ramos good question! Out of the box the hihat is terrible to play. Any tips to handle are welcome!
bubingaboom kit of roland is what i liked most
Superb drumming Mr Schumacher!! Horses for courses on personal preferences. But the drumming....sweet.
Thanks very much Dan! :)
Wow TD50 the worst, sounds like a drum machine.