charlie was a good character.. he had a lot of love he had a hard time sharing.. desmond rules.. I forgot about his foresights early in the show that lead to the end..
so....how come nobody ever points out that the room he drowns in wouldn't actually fill all the way up. The water comes in through the window...meaning it's only going to fill up to that point unless the air has some other means to escape.(to which he would eventually run out of air) And beyond that, it looks like Charlie could fit through the window. I don't know if there would be somewhere he could swim to...but ya just a bit of a hole in his death.
warioman91 I don’t know about the physics of the room filling up, but as for Charlie being able to escape it doesn’t matter because Charlie chose to die. That’s why he locked Desmond out of the room and locked himself in it, he realized the only way to save everyone was for him to die
@@theamericanyoutuber I dont think you understand the physics at work. Go get like a thin plastic cup that you can poke a small hole in it on the side. Then put it fully underwater somewhere with the bottom sticking up of course. The water level you're thinking of is certainly well above the entire cup. But the water level we care about is the height of the hole in the side of the cup. That is the limit to where it should fill up to. You then get an amount of air left above that point. Because as the water pours in through the hole, air has to be flowing out to displace the water coming in. But once it reaches the level of the hole, air doesn't simply flow down to get out. This is why you can have underwater pockets of air.
@@TheEpic22 never responded but ya I only just now realized that this Is the right answer. It's got nothing to do with a "could he have been saved" but a he didnt want to be saved for causal purposes.
The oxygen supply would still run out far more quickly than it would take others to save the person, regardless if I’m wrong or not. Better to be willing to die, sacrificing yourself, and be able to float into unconsciousness via holding your breath till you pass out. Just saying.
Desmond is really at the very center of EVERYTHING in Lost.
Desmond tried so hard, DAMMIT!
Aaron holding Charlie at 4:33 like he knows he'll never see him again. My heart hurts
i LOVE jealous charlie!!!!!
"whatcha doin beother?"
lol
charlie was a good character.. he had a lot of love he had a hard time sharing.. desmond rules.. I forgot about his foresights early in the show that lead to the end..
If I am terminally ill, I want no other than a Scottish doctor telling me I’m gonna die!
I ship them so hard
what episodes are 1:07 and 2:02 from?🩷🫶🌷
so....how come nobody ever points out that the room he drowns in wouldn't actually fill all the way up. The water comes in through the window...meaning it's only going to fill up to that point unless the air has some other means to escape.(to which he would eventually run out of air)
And beyond that, it looks like Charlie could fit through the window. I don't know if there would be somewhere he could swim to...but ya just a bit of a hole in his death.
warioman91
I don’t know about the physics of the room filling up, but as for Charlie being able to escape it doesn’t matter because Charlie chose to die. That’s why he locked Desmond out of the room and locked himself in it, he realized the only way to save everyone was for him to die
If the water level is higher than the window, then no, it would fill the entire room.
@@theamericanyoutuber I dont think you understand the physics at work. Go get like a thin plastic cup that you can poke a small hole in it on the side. Then put it fully underwater somewhere with the bottom sticking up of course. The water level you're thinking of is certainly well above the entire cup. But the water level we care about is the height of the hole in the side of the cup. That is the limit to where it should fill up to.
You then get an amount of air left above that point.
Because as the water pours in through the hole, air has to be flowing out to displace the water coming in. But once it reaches the level of the hole, air doesn't simply flow down to get out.
This is why you can have underwater pockets of air.
@@TheEpic22 never responded but ya I only just now realized that this Is the right answer. It's got nothing to do with a "could he have been saved" but a he didnt want to be saved for causal purposes.
The oxygen supply would still run out far more quickly than it would take others to save the person, regardless if I’m wrong or not.
Better to be willing to die, sacrificing yourself, and be able to float into unconsciousness via holding your breath till you pass out. Just saying.
Desmond
Wheres the slowed down version where shes checking his butt lol
Can someone tell me the real names o both characters?
Henry Ian Cusick and Dominic Monhoghan(?)
Dom is an incredible actor, he was in LOTR too !
@ZwankaInc cool story brotha
LOL, Charlie is so annoying.
YOU'RE annoying.
@@DudeLongcouch No Charlie is annoying
@@Vestlus1 YOU'RE annoying