The Secret Ingredient for This Delicious Soup? Rocks. | Short Film Showcase
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- The Short Film Showcase spotlights exceptional short videos created by filmmakers from around the web and selected by National Geographic editors. We look for work that affirms National Geographic's mission of inspiring people to care about the planet. The filmmakers created the content presented, and the opinions expressed are their own, not those of the National Geographic Society.
➡ Subscribe: bit.ly/NatGeoSu...
➡ Get More Short Film Showcase: bit.ly/ShortFil...
About Short Film Showcase:
A curated collection of the most captivating documentary shorts from filmmakers around the world. See more from National Geographic's Short Film Showcase at documentary.com
Get More National Geographic:
Official Site: bit.ly/NatGeoOf...
Facebook: bit.ly/FBNatGeo
Twitter: bit.ly/NatGeoTw...
Instagram: bit.ly/NatGeoInsta
About National Geographic:
National Geographic is the world's premium destination for science, exploration, and adventure. Through their world-class scientists, photographers, journalists, and filmmakers, Nat Geo gets you closer to the stories that matter and past the edge of what's possible.
The Secret Ingredient for This Delicious Soup? Rocks. | Short Film Showcase
• The Secret Ingredient ...
National Geographic
/ natgeo
When I was younger, we read a book called stone soup and made it!
The three Chinese monks!
How did it taste?
@@gregfalco4528 like dog water
@@gregfalco4528 like stone water
:’)
Great short film. I love the sense of reverence and tradition around this dish, and the pride and warm of family.
Do you smell what the rock is cooking?
Konata Izumi most underrated comment in history.
This deserves way more thumbs up
I do smell what the people champ is cooking lol
Lmao!
I'm dying XD
In my elementary school, we read a child's book about stone soup. Our teachers used to take us every so often to make stone soup out in the local river. With California weather, making stone soup was a nice way to spend the day.
We did that in NY as well. We went to river and made the soup in school. Childhood memories 😀
4:26 I feared the foot would slip and dip into the soup pool.
Gordan Ramsey would say that foot is raw
i’m so proud to be from oaxaca. beautiful culture and traditions from indigenous people.
One thing is for sure, that soup rocks!
Beautiful language. Please never let it die.
It will die, same for other languages in a thousand years or more
I am from Mexico, but never knew of this, very cool to learn more about my culture
This is also actually an old parable where visitors trick a city into making them soup. It has been served in Europe, China, and the Americas and the story goes back very far.
I love that the men are cooking and the women chillin 😋
Wow! I had a book called 'Stone Soup'
This is like deja vu
Amber Branks they stole the idea for that book from our indigenous people
@@aris6463 It’s actually an old Hungarian fairytale.
@@tylerpatti9038 u didn't have to expose him like that💀
That song made me cry. How beautiful this short was.
this is actually a very common dish in old European history as well, its easy to heat a stone but its hard to heat a clay bowl without shattering it, so the obvious solution is to boil stuff with superheated stones.
We learned about Stone soup in my 4th grade class. Our teacher was one of the few who actually taught us about several traditions of where Stone soup is eaten. Usila was one of them. We even got to make our very own Oaxaca inspired soup & it was absolutely delicious. A true dish of culture.
The heated rocks are there to keep the water boiling so the fish can cook in it. This suggests the custom dates from a period before the indigenous people had any cooking utensils that could withstand high heat.
bringing a community together trough soup reminds me of the book "stone soup"
Another win for Oaxaca. I want to go visit over there hopefully in the next year. I am American but I love the food and the Mezcal so I need to go over there for the experience.
+Joe Biden's Shotgun Do it. Oaxaca is beautiful.
It’s been two years bro, have you gone?
hifiveguyy lol
Its been 4 years
It’s been 5
lets wait till Gordon Ramsay say something about it
THAT STONE IS RAW!
John Lemon 😆😆😆😆
he doesn't criticize traditional food.
he probably say F*Ck
John Lemon who’s Gordon Ramsey?
We did this in Central America as well. I invited a celeb from Unicef and my family made stone soup by gathering various foods from the sea and land.
That's pretty cool!
+Your Leader your comments trashy.
Herb Toker b
It doesn't matter if its unique or not, or if everybody did it like people are saying here, it looks really good. And its clearly a nice tradition, I like that its still here after centurys, it doesn't matter if others have it, its their tradition and I hope its perserved. What is special about it? its still here.
Stones can be reused right?
The song is so beautiful. It's like a peak into their lives, into another world 🐳
Beautiful tradition and a wonderful way to stay in touch with mother nature, Loved the music❤
Ahhhh so it's basically a fish soup cooked using hot stones. That doesn't make rocks a secret ingredient though. The secret ingredient of chicken soup isn't the pan either.
actually there using specific rocks and there is an abundance of minerals that would leach out adding a flavor
I mean who's to say it couldn't be? Perhaps the 'pan' the chicken is seared on is a salt block?
Loooool
What do you want to ruin this tourist trap?
It makes difference in flavor, so it count as secret ingredients in my book.
BEAUTIFUL..WELL MADE. THANK YOU FOR SHARING....
amazing good video
0:40 the voice crack LOL
It's basically like the "SINIGANG" dish in the Philippines.
Who else did this in Harvest Moon? 🙋♀️
Who sings the folk song at the end? How do I find that kind of music?
I remember when I was in 1st grade I think, when my teacher hosted a story telling and the story was "Stone Soup" I didn't join because I can't memorize it and I was scared of public speaking. It was hosted at the top of my school which is the stage. Then some of my classmates (not all) memorized the story when the day finally came, they brought props to make it more realistic. (They didn't cook the soup though) and me and my friends just watched them.
I miss the old days 😭
If you go to Korean restaurant and order bubimbap, there's going to be two version. One with stone bowel and one without. The one with stone bowl is always going to be about $2 more expensive. ALWAYS choose the stone bowel version.
This is was so fascinating. I love NatGeo.
i came here from some ordinary gamers when he mentions townsend making rock soup.
that's awesome, I love it! Keep your traditions alive.
the older i get the more i want to know about the cultures of my ancestors homelands, mexico is full of various peoples who are unique but beautiful all the same.
The beauty of human culture when in balance with nature... I love the sense of pride and tradition... nice short film thanks for sharing it! People that prefer fast food, by all means please, keep on eating fast food, more real food for the rest of us :)
So nice men cook for women and children , there is nothing like this in our Indian custom. Indian men treat women like slaves.
You know the food is good when you smile right after a bite.
I can’t believe I watched this whole video at 2am.
Mongolians do this a lot even today. It’s mostly a celebratory or festive dish. Pressure cookers especially for this kind of cooking with rocks are commercially sold. This is not that rare.
The trick is selecting only the best rocks. If you miss one spoiled rock, it may ruin the entire batch.
Why does everyone in the comments hate it so much omfg
Dedicate this to my beautiful beautiful Chicago PD family 🙏🙏🙏🙏💋💋💋💋💋💋
To be honest it's actually quite brilliant
is it only an American-continent thing to cook with heated rocks in a pit in the ground? Farther north we have clambakes and fish boils, which is the same principle. I just figured that was what everyone did if they found themselves on a beach with raw food and no stove. It's safer to cook the rocks and then use them to boil the food than to put the food over an open fire, because high fat or high water content foods cause the fire to sputter wildly. probably good for pork too. It's cool that stone soup is actually a thing though, anybody else remember that kid's book?
Stone boiling has been used by many cultures for many many many years, what makes this method any different? Looks like it would taste good with the fresh seafood. Also, the rocks you use for doing this must be porous or they will explode! Don't try this unless you know your geology.
You know you're a lousy hunter when all you can catch are rocks.
The girls didn't do anything 🙄 just sitting around for the pup to be done
+JonasX 650 its tradition for the men to make it
+Fitk Olco tell that to your mother and a few billion females
+unpopularopiniondude You're just too stupid bye
The stone isn't an ingredient... It's a cooking method. They don't eat the rocks... This method dates back to the Stone Age and isn't specific to this region. But I guess there isn't many people who would use it since the apparition of better, safer and more convenient technologies...
it's 3:42 am, why am i watching this
Their language sounds like a mixture of Cantonese and Thai. Interesting.
Sounds like absolute heaven!!!
Very interesting, & great video!
I've always known the story of stone soup but I hadn't realized it was a real dish somewhere
This sounds very nutritious. Tons of minerals from the rocks, and ZERO processed ingredients typical in American soups
*****
And you keep eating pigs you fatass American!!
These two are a clear example how society would collapse....
***** real morals, real valour and freedom you say? Real food..define "Real" food and what is "real" morals and valour pls enlighten me.
***** and what do you think those chemicals are for? I'm not saying I like my food pumped full of chemicals but some of them are quite essential now days I don't suppose you would want to shove your meat in a jar of salt every time your transporting meat (example)+ you haven't fully answered my question.
***** your ignorance is too great for me too ( since you basically bypassed most of what I said) (those chemicals some of them are what keeps that bottle of milk of yours in the shelves for months) but like you said keep eating rocks if that makes you feel any better. guess what that's life people die the rich get richer and the poor, well can basically go to hell (metaphorically) + where do you think the food that you buy in the markets come from? Water, electricity, public utilities? Most of the taxes your paying is what keeps that society of ours running (not implying that it's flawless but still) And what life would you call as living with morals Valor honour and dignity? Living in the caves eating rocks preeching to God? (Not to sound like a dick) I would rather live in today's society than in the Stone Age But you know what they say "To be patriotic; hate all nations but your own, to be religious; all sects but your own, to be moral; all pretences but your own"
I would love to try some of that soup 😋
This reminds me of skyrim.
Also I love this ambiance. The music and soup is amazing.
Sanji knows what he's cooking
This looks good! I hope I can try it someday
This is just how you make soup when you don't have metal pots.
Maybe its MiniStoney soup or perhaps Rockyleakie.
You know what a beautiful gift that God has giving me a receipt from the river course or all of us are going to be there
Taiwan Aboriginals also use this method, except they cook fish in large bamboo containers
Stone or the rock is the key ingredient without which soup is incomplete and cannot be called stone soup.
People used fire-heated rocks to cook all over the world, not just here.
Hungarian Folk tales brought me here
ahhh..... using one of the very first ways humans cooked..........heating stones and putting them in pots(back then made made of animal hides) and letting the heat from the stones cook the soup/food..............
I think the idea of cooking with hot stones game out because aof poverty they didn't have cooking utensils.
this film was beautiful
The Pie family aproves of this dish
they speak native language?
Yes and also Spanish, there are 68 Official Languages in Mexico but most of the people speak only Spanish
Interesting how Central American Oaxacan native language sounds like some ancient asian language, which supports the Asian migration theory. Interesting!
What a clever way to cook!
O Majhi re.. apna kinara.. nadiya ki dhara hai.. O Majhi re..
So you cook your soup with hot rocks and call it stone soup but the Hungarian story says a soldier found a stone and tricked an old lady into making soup?
Provoking a miscarriage you left me expecting I can’t believe that
Beautiful language
The beauty of this made me tear up a bit.
every person as they take a spoonful their faces light up! That must be some soup!!!
A healthy tonic, full of minerals from the good old earth.
Where is this place?
Did anyone else think this would be something like Stone Soup from Dibo the Gift Dragon?
I can totally see some American tourist takes this ancient recipe and makes tons of money. Chiptole style
The restaurant is owned by Jennifer Schwartz
great vid. this is awesome! right up there with the caveman bbq! ill try this sometime!!
Looks good
There was a childrens story like this I remember. About the mysterious delicious stone soup
Why would someone invent such a painstaking procedure to brew a fish soup ?
When I was in Kindergarten, we made rock soup. Never understood why until seeing this video.
As fucked up as this seems, I'm willing to bet it tastes pretty awesome.
Rocks also release minerals
Reminds me of that Dibo the gift dragon episode...
and here i thought the stone soup was just a fantasy story...
Ah, so a hot stone is used to boil the water. Interesting tactic.
Foods have been cooked with hot stones all over the world. What is there that makes this kind of dish unique? Are the stones some specific mineral?
I read about the stone soup in highschool but it was fictional. But it really does exist.
Its funny because in portugal there is also a Stone soup
João Miguel yeah they copy that from the indigenous that they raped and slaughtered by The Million by the Spaniards Did
Good Video