Old scriptures and The Muslim confusion | Part 1| آج کا مسلمان اور آسمانی کتب

Поделиться
HTML-код

Комментарии • 109

  • @ghuraba_fs
    @ghuraba_fs 3 года назад +44

    Dear Ustaaz, you are a treasure. May Allah preserve you aameen
    الهم زد فزد الهم بارك

  • @wajihaakhaan
    @wajihaakhaan 2 года назад +3

    Sir lots of respect for you ilm ka samnamdar hai ap Allah apko jazae Khair ata kre ameeen

  • @bhtvofficial108
    @bhtvofficial108 3 года назад +2

    Jazak Allaho khairan kaseeran

  • @shahidzia4365
    @shahidzia4365 3 года назад +7

    `.
    may ALLAH guide all of us.Ameen

  • @ponderthesigns1813
    @ponderthesigns1813 3 года назад +4

    masha allah

  • @yusramushtaq6578
    @yusramushtaq6578 3 года назад +19

    Very big fan of you sir...Allah pak bless you...we need more people like you to bring change... May Allah pak bless us such a nice people

  • @abdulrb204
    @abdulrb204 3 года назад +2

    Jazak allah...

  • @sabaali9768
    @sabaali9768 3 года назад +2

    eye opener. Jazakallah khair

  • @syedmuhammadali6282
    @syedmuhammadali6282 3 года назад

    MashAllah 🥰 bhot achi information ha

  • @saadulhassan1222
    @saadulhassan1222 3 года назад +1

    JazakAllah

  • @SA-dc7oq
    @SA-dc7oq 3 года назад +1

    mery teen bachy hy 14'12'8.sochti thi apny bachu ko kisy batoon k poori dunya ma jo hu raha hy aor dosry nationalities jo ker rahi hain un ka hum muslims k sath kia talaq hy. as muslim isolate feel hota tha .ajj sir sahil ki batin sun kr sab swalon k jawab mill gay hain .masla falasteen samj agiya .........

  • @asiaahmad1559
    @asiaahmad1559 3 года назад +2

    Very informative MashAllah

  • @ABC-uw7gu
    @ABC-uw7gu 2 года назад

    جزاک اللہ❤❤❤

  • @serena3264
    @serena3264 2 года назад

    سبحان اللہ، بہت عمدہ، جزاکم اللہ خیر

  • @asiaahmad1559
    @asiaahmad1559 3 года назад +2

    Very informative

  • @serena3264
    @serena3264 2 года назад

    جزاک اللہ خیر

  • @osamaakram3627
    @osamaakram3627 3 года назад +3

    Thank you sooooo much sahil bhai ❤❤❤❤

  • @AbubakarFarooqui
    @AbubakarFarooqui 3 года назад +3

    Sahil Adeem sahib ❤❤

  • @riazhussain462
    @riazhussain462 3 года назад +5

    انجیل جو حضرت عیسیٰ پر نازل ہوئی موجود ہی نہیں ہے موجودہ۔ انجیل حضرت عیسیٰ کی سیرت ہے جو نامعلوم لوگوں کی تحریر کردہ ہے

  • @ujalakhan9249
    @ujalakhan9249 3 года назад +2

    Jazak Allaho khairan kaseeran❤❤❤

  • @safeenazmadarbaccus4960
    @safeenazmadarbaccus4960 3 года назад +10

    It's seems very interesting stream,, thank you very much sir,,
    If possible to put english subtitle for people who don't understand urdu or weak in understanding urdu, would be great sir as it's really very informative,,

    • @Hello-jw4ej
      @Hello-jw4ej 11 месяцев назад

      If you don't know Urdu then learn dear ....
      It's high time for us that if we don't know then we have to learn that

  • @syedasrar9821
    @syedasrar9821 2 года назад +1

    Haa sir aap sahi ho because my India se hoo Hindu scripture almost in se tho behthar koshish ki hai unka scripture Vedas k through clearly guide kartha hai ekyam evidithayam. Wo bhi maanthe Hain k khuda ek hi hai but wallahu aalam goutham budha raam Krishna inki spiritual teaching bahuth hi high pitch ki hai kyunke mere dosth Hindu bhi Hain unme bahuth ache bhi Hain but wo log khud apni Vedas ki kithaab nahi padthe sirf wo school aur University ki studies k peeche uske baad Shaadi bas isi me Inka saara Zindagi ka time nikaljaaths hai aur ham unko clearly samjha nahi paarahe hai .

  • @shafaqahmad6867
    @shafaqahmad6867 2 года назад

    Quran

  • @shaziarashid18
    @shaziarashid18 Год назад

    Subhan Allah! Sir, you are a gem 💎
    May Allah be happy with your efforts 😊

  • @sabaqamar3503
    @sabaqamar3503 2 года назад

    These are the questions bothering me from a long time. Yes we need to know all this for dawah and to deal with people following different religions.

  • @khadeejatulkubra5214
    @khadeejatulkubra5214 3 года назад +3

    its a lot beneficial

  • @Shah_Builders
    @Shah_Builders 2 года назад +2

    Good lecture, but it only concludes the current Injeel only. I was looking the continuation of this topic which include Torait and other hindu scriptures. Can you please help me in this.

  • @zararattar3514
    @zararattar3514 3 года назад +6

    It seems after 1hr: 10 minutes the lecture starts again. Is it???

  • @hassananjum3782
    @hassananjum3782 3 года назад +2

    Injeel mn emaaniyaat hain aur taureet mn shariyyat hai..magar shariyyat ki implementation k lye emaaniyaat ka strong hona required ha, jo k kamzoor ho chuki thein, so Hazrat Esa AS ko injeel di gai takeh insaanoon k aqaaid darust kiye jaein..
    Aur tamaam nabiyyoon ne pehlay emaaniyaat darust kein, phir implementation ko taraf gaye

    • @abuzarghifaari418
      @abuzarghifaari418 2 года назад

      Ye aapne kis hawale se bataya, meherbaani kar k, wazaahat karen.

  • @rehanfazalrehanfazal5430
    @rehanfazalrehanfazal5430 2 года назад

    Allah aapko mazeed ilm ata farmaye amen.

  • @kosarfirdaus4548
    @kosarfirdaus4548 2 года назад

    Sahil Bhai is a blessing

  • @_ABCDEF11
    @_ABCDEF11 3 года назад +2

    Please come toward our own track...

  • @LeadersMirrorPeople
    @LeadersMirrorPeople 3 года назад

    AsalamoAlaicum
    I agree with his criticism and caution. I asked before; if I have to reach him, what is best way?

  • @Muslimah-shorts
    @Muslimah-shorts 3 года назад +3

    Jazak Allahu khairan kaseeran. Your sound is very low please increase it.

  • @wajahatch7268
    @wajahatch7268 2 года назад

    the kid made my day

  • @shamshadahmed5088
    @shamshadahmed5088 2 года назад

    I love you sahil bhai really

  • @zarinarab8525
    @zarinarab8525 2 года назад

    I wanted to know about how dajjal is created and Ye jo Inteshaar hua hai islamic philosophy me hadis Qur'an ya kisi law ko le kar ye actually kab n kyun shuru hua

  • @asadizonlizonline
    @asadizonlizonline Год назад

    ahadees ikhatti krnay k liyay jo methodology muhaddis hazrat ne use ki hay, kia woh past se mutaliq knowledge hasil krny k liyay behtreen ya accurate tariqa hay? ?

  • @khadeejatulkubra5214
    @khadeejatulkubra5214 3 года назад +5

    pls upload the 2nd part,too

    • @ASimpleArgument
      @ASimpleArgument  3 года назад +1

      Second part will be live tonight at 10PM stay tuned.

    • @ASimpleArgument
      @ASimpleArgument  3 года назад +1

      Assalamualaikum,
      Dear Subscribers,
      Please log into zoom meeting/RUclips live session tonight for a very informative and unique topic.
      Topic: Eeman bil Kutub
      10PM PST

    • @ASimpleArgument
      @ASimpleArgument  3 года назад +1

      Join Zoom Meeting
      zoom.us/j/8578806625?pwd=L1E4YjAzN0I5d0w5eTFhNnVnTm1YQT09
      Meeting ID: 857 880 6625
      Password: 1981

  • @masoomamalik1737
    @masoomamalik1737 3 года назад +3

    Please recommend books related to history

    • @HanzalaChTv
      @HanzalaChTv Год назад

      *Sahil Adeem Recommended Books*
      drive.google.com/drive/folders/17djrBg_R10N_F_dIcpM9uMT5ryyNb9fF
      *Tafseer*
      *Seerat*
      *Tareekh*
      *Philosophy*
      *Psychology*
      *Critical thinking*

  • @Muhammadaliraja.
    @Muhammadaliraja. 3 года назад +1

    salam Sir please zoom ka link de dein kbi mauka mila to sahil bhai se kuch sawal puchne thy plz

  • @zohamamoon9281
    @zohamamoon9281 2 года назад

    Phly to Quran hadis pr mukammal garift ho to in books ko prhny ka faida b ha.
    Aam musalmaan jo Quran nhi prhty wo kya prhain or Samhain gy.

  • @akeditz8988
    @akeditz8988 2 года назад

    59:35 sir jab mare zehen ma be ye sawal ata ta jab ma istara ki bhat sunta ta ke ye ades zahef hai etc

  • @ha9297
    @ha9297 Год назад

    Where can we buy these books which came before quran?

  • @akeditz8988
    @akeditz8988 2 года назад

    Sir Sumerra text ke bare ma jankari meligi

  • @moneyvermaaa
    @moneyvermaaa 2 года назад

    Dr israr Ahmed, g ki (rehm allah ) image khi galt na set ho jaye kisi user k liye isliye ih swaal unhone sahil sir g se bich mai puch liya

  • @saquibsheikh4411
    @saquibsheikh4411 3 года назад +1

    Sir books ke nam bhej sakte hai kya

  • @sajjadhusain3467
    @sajjadhusain3467 Год назад

    Kindly tell me the name of a person who combined chiristinity & semetic religion

  • @renaissance7917
    @renaissance7917 Год назад

    Aaj to apkai channal pai add b aata h

  • @israrahmed1871
    @israrahmed1871 3 года назад +2

    Kia Hindu's scriptures are Devine or what you said before

  • @amth3400
    @amth3400 3 года назад

    Ye 3 filed ka hadees ka reference dijiye na?

  • @pskindergarten8679
    @pskindergarten8679 2 года назад

    Sound sound sound pls

  • @syedasrar9821
    @syedasrar9821 2 года назад

    Masha Allah sir alhamdulillah wallahu aalam dushman Hain aapke tho aap seedhe raasthe pe chalne aur khuda ki di huwi knowledge se doosro ko bhi batha rahe ho .isiliye keep going on till death inshallah we will meet in the day of judgement or else if Allah subhan Kareem ne chaha tho Deen ka kaam kareinge insha Allah Allah subhan Kareem aapko dushmano se bachaye aameen.

  • @syedqamaranwar14
    @syedqamaranwar14 2 года назад

    Now out of office, Chirac recounts that the American leader appealed to their "common faith" (Christianity) and told him: "Gog and Magog are at work in the Middle East. . . . The biblical prophecies are being fulfilled. . . . This confrontation is willed by God, who wants to use this conflict to erase his people's enemies before a New Age begins."

  • @sabahmufti775
    @sabahmufti775 2 года назад

    How I can join ur class

  • @zufishannoon9162
    @zufishannoon9162 2 года назад

    قرآن اور آسمانی کتب پہ ایمان ہی مکمل ایمان ہے ۔۔۔ باقی کتب میں غلطی ہو سکتی ہے اس پہ بھی ایمان ہونا چاہیے ۔۔۔ انٹرنیٹ پہ موجود صحیح بخاری میں کچھ جگہ ایسی احادیث بھی ہیں جنہیں انسانی نفسیات سے متصادم کہا جا سکتا ہے۔۔ یا جن کی پوری ساٸینس سمجھے بغیر ہمیں ان کو آگے پھیلانا نہیں چاہیے ۔۔۔

  • @UbaidHasanVlogs
    @UbaidHasanVlogs 3 года назад +1

    anything contradict with Quran can not be the word said by Prophet Mohammed (PBUH), this is the reason till date we are debating over the authenticity of ahadeeth but never ever dare to challenge the Holy Quran, because its the word of Allah SWT and preserved by him alone, your philosophical lectures or debates highly appreciated but you can not criticize those scholars who have endowed their whole life for deen, yes to understand deen you need teachings (Hadees) of Prophet but if a Hadees goes against the sunnah of Allah SWT and fail rationally then it can not be the word of Prophet Mohammed.

  • @smpgamer7273
    @smpgamer7273 3 года назад +2

    nooh alaihislam ki puri details me jankari milegi?

    • @ASimpleArgument
      @ASimpleArgument  3 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/YZXp0N_ed2g/видео.html

  • @sajidhasnat4457
    @sajidhasnat4457 2 года назад +2

    They are not letting him talk by asking stupid questions

  • @sheikhahmed6777
    @sheikhahmed6777 3 года назад +1

    Sir apne Michael H Hart ke taluk se kaha usne St.Paul ko Hazrat ESA se uppar takha h jabki Hazrat Esa 3 no par h or paul 6 th par

    • @ASimpleArgument
      @ASimpleArgument  3 года назад +2

      Good that you've referred the book. But when you read it you'll find out the words of Hart that himself wrote that Paul is way more influential on chietianity than Jesus AS

  • @ShahrukhKhan-cr9eg
    @ShahrukhKhan-cr9eg 2 года назад

    Love from India

  • @farhanakazmi8080
    @farhanakazmi8080 2 года назад

    We should read other books to understand their perspective. We need to learn about comparison of Islam.

  • @umarashfaq
    @umarashfaq 2 года назад +1

    49:40 I've never heard Dr. Israr say anything like that. He actually talked abt munqareen e Hadees. So that is a questionable claim made by the speaker in this talk.

    • @nature2569
      @nature2569 2 года назад

      Learn to appreciate

    • @umarashfaq
      @umarashfaq 2 года назад +1

      @@nature2569 I'm sorry if you took offense from my comment. I do appreciate the speaker for his time n effort but it's my right to question. May be he is right and probably has seen the footage of Dr. Israr ahmed and would make us privy to it. But all I got was your vague comment.

    • @nature2569
      @nature2569 2 года назад

      @@umarashfaq 😊

  • @aneelbatalvi8449
    @aneelbatalvi8449 3 года назад +2

    Dear sir . you said eight hundred years muhadiseen have worked for the sanctity of hadith. You seem to be endorsing bukhari as authentic . how do you explain the atrocities of khulafa of bani ummayah and the abbasids .how do you explain the atrocities on syeds through out history.
    And how can you vouch for the authencities of books compiled in there era of such cruel khulafa.

    • @AbdulKareem-tg2ul
      @AbdulKareem-tg2ul 3 года назад +2

      No any corrupt or cruel khalifa put any influence on hadith narrations. e.i: Imam Ahmed bin hanbal have gone through lot much pain because of talking haqq.

  • @hanimuhammadakber9066
    @hanimuhammadakber9066 2 года назад

    ﺍﻟﺴَّـــــــﻼَﻡُ ﻋَﻠَﻴــْــﻜُﻢ ﻭَﺭَﺣْﻤَﺔُ ﷲ‎
    Sir , do make a video on the initiative taken for seemingly trying to unite 3 Ibrahimic religions under one roof.
    Is it good for us as we will at least focus on the things that are common among us or is it bad as muslims already have confused Identity?
    And most importantly why are they trying to do this? I don't think so they have got any good intent. Or is it just my skeptism?
    I think it's because it's happening in UAE.
    And the kind of things, they are doing makes everything suspectible.

  • @jahanzaibmashkoor5929
    @jahanzaibmashkoor5929 2 года назад

    Ehere is part 2

  • @PMUMERKHAN
    @PMUMERKHAN 3 года назад

    2:58 3 type

  • @shaanahmed3242
    @shaanahmed3242 2 года назад

    Mashallah very informatic discussion but poor quality of voice and background noice intruption child craing

  • @Muhammadaliraja.
    @Muhammadaliraja. 3 года назад +1

    Esa koi Nabi Nahi Hai Adam A.s se le kr ab tak jisne dajjal k bary m na aagah kiya hadees ka maf'hoom yeh hai sir Noah. A.s kahan se le aaye aap...

  • @ZH-Rocks
    @ZH-Rocks 3 года назад

    Apka shouq hey app parhein..deedat zskir naik aur bhi logon ne perhin comparetive religion study k liye..aam shaks ka kiya kaam??

  • @learntillend9340
    @learntillend9340 2 года назад

    Too difficult to digest the reality and truth !

  • @israrahmed1871
    @israrahmed1871 3 года назад +1

    Brother I listen you n different other scholars but one thing disturbing me is that according to GHAMDI sb in current time the big gift or system to run the world society is democracy thought or system .. which giving by west .. he said in his lecture that the politic ( siyasat ) is not subject of religious it's the need of time n current society.. so what you think is there any complete solution of governance has given by region...plz arrange a complete session plz plz

    • @ASimpleArgument
      @ASimpleArgument  3 года назад

      We will inshaAllah

    • @sibmo5602
      @sibmo5602 3 года назад

      All due respect to Mr Ghamidi, but people in Europe are nowadays realizing the lies behind democracy especially now where the global economy is collapsing and we are entering in a sanitary dictatorship ... Like Iqbal predicted yeh tehzeeb apne khanjar se khud apna khatma kare gi.. May it be Switzerland or France ... so it makes me laugh when our own people always want to be more European than the Europeans themselves ...

    • @israrahmed1871
      @israrahmed1871 3 года назад

      @@sibmo5602 yes it is but want to know the religious methodology about running a state country etc about Ghamdi sb democracy is purely religious method or he says that the ( siyasat) is not the subject of religion so what is real picture plz

    • @israrahmed1871
      @israrahmed1871 3 года назад

      @@sibmo5602 that's very explicit economy society ethics marriage institution and other social sciences are in devastating point of west especially

  • @ZH-Rocks
    @ZH-Rocks 3 года назад

    Apko chahey k sabko quran o hadees ki proper taleem hasil kerney ka bolna chayeh na k kisi king james ki bible perhney ko..fuzul mein mis guide mat kareyn

  • @kitterkot5634
    @kitterkot5634 2 года назад

    Dr.Zakir has deep authority (dunyawi tor py) on all scriptures...Dr Zakir sy pehly kya koi “bolnay joga tha” ek hindu ko k us ki apni kitab myn Nabi Pak (sws) ki amad k bary myn prediction hy....hd hy ....jo Quran myn direct ehkamat hyn wo to implement kro....jo (western countries have already implemented) ....= Riasat-e-Madina) .....Pak India Bangladesh ka ALLAH he Hafiz hy....too much to say....anyways instead of going A-Z this triangle going Z- to don’t know where.....btw amazingly with high surprise (Iran & Afghanistan) ka kbi is aspect myn nam nae suna jata....(do think)
    NO OFFENSE TO ANYONE!!!!!

  • @farhanakazmi8080
    @farhanakazmi8080 2 года назад

    Muslim need to learn about other books to understand about their perspective.

  • @shamimshaikh3946
    @shamimshaikh3946 2 года назад

    Aalim ka nahi ilm ka ehtaram hota hai isi Beena per burogoka hum ehteram kartehain ilm alah detahy

  • @ZH-Rocks
    @ZH-Rocks 3 года назад

    Bhaiii.hum ko in prr iman rakhna hey perhna lazim nahi..huzur pbuh ne fermaya k akhir uz zaman mein sirf wuran aur uska rasool aur ahley beit hi kaafi hongey.app khamakhan sabko ye books perhney ka khe rahey hein...
    Plz jo log seedey saadhey hein inko quran aur hadees tak hi rakhein..humko kiya bible mey in logon ne kuch bhi likh diya ho

    • @osama60634
      @osama60634 2 года назад

      tu phir aap Christian ko dawat kaise denge ?

    • @ZH-Rocks
      @ZH-Rocks 2 года назад

      @@osama60634 jo log dawat deyna chatey hein unko kab mana kiya hey..me to aam logon ko jo ye bol rahey hein bible perho uski baat ker rahi houn k plz quran ko translation k saath perhney ki targheeb dein pheley.

    • @osama60634
      @osama60634 2 года назад

      beshak pehle quran parhe serat parhe phir aage barhe . or apne kaha ki jo log dawat dena chahte wo parhe bakhi scripture lekin jaha tk mera ilm h dawat dena ru hr iman wale ki zimmedari h

    • @ZH-Rocks
      @ZH-Rocks 2 года назад

      @@osama60634 ji..beshak merey tamam gher walon ne essa hi kiya hey..jo meney objection ki thi woh ye ki thi k app logon ko quran ki talimaat ki taraf dawat dejiye na k un prr zor dein k woh pheley bible bhi perehen..and i dont think jisko gher muslimon ko dawat deni hey wo is video ko dekh raha hoga..aur dawat deney k liye apni kitab ka ilm lazmi hey..apna rawiya akhlaaq hi kaafi hota hey akser to..masla yehi hey khud momin banna nahi meger dosrey ki fiker hey..app sirf bible perhker kisi hindu ko kesey dawat dengey phir to, ya parsi ko sikh ko???albatta quran ki 1 ayat bhi kaafi hey tableegh k liye to.

  • @salmansaysit
    @salmansaysit 2 года назад

    Bible has all person narrative.
    1st : Thou shall not worship any God beside me.
    2nd : My kingdom is not of this world : "Jesus"
    3rd : If Christ hasn't risen from the dead your faith is worthless. "Paul"
    Firstly Muslims mostly hasn't made at attempt to even to open Quran question is reading other scriptures is a far cry.
    direction

  • @haseebaftab1255
    @haseebaftab1255 2 года назад +2

    In my belief the biggest confusion spreader in modern day era of Islam is Mr. Ghamdi , im sure he is working on some agenda and want to mis guide Muslims by spreading other perspective on basic issues of Islam. So people should take deep look on his views to understand that he is defacing the orignality of Islam . So anyone contradicting Sahil sb views in light of Ghamdi views should think again , because he is not authentic source to rely your beliefs on

    • @m.hamzataimoor2250
      @m.hamzataimoor2250 2 года назад

      Haha Ghamidi Sahab is the greatest scholar of this era

    • @atifliaqat8159
      @atifliaqat8159 2 года назад

      @@m.hamzataimoor2250 farebi hai. Ghalib guman hai ke ye jinn hai insan hai hi ni. Isko jinnon ke realm main paya gaya hai.