TM Krishna: Concert for Peace - Salatullah Salamullah
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- TM Krishna was the featured artiste at the first FEA-curated Concert for Peace held at the Keneseth Eliyahoo Synagogue in Kala Ghoda, Mumbai. In this video Krishna performs an Arabic song in Raga Anandabhairavi.
Krishna is accompanied by Akkarai Subhalakshmi on violin and NC Bharadwaj on mridangam.
The event was sponsored by JSW.
மதநல்லிணக்கம் வளர்க்கும் பெருமதிப்பிற்குரிய அண்ணன் கிருஷ்ணா அவர்களுக்கு மனமார்ந்த நன்றிகளும் வாழ்த்துக்களும் ... 💐💐💐உங்களைபோன்றவர்களே நமது நாட்டிற்கு இப்போதைய தேவை ...
To all the haters:
1. The costume and setting has nothing to do with ISLAM. This is a Jewish costume, and the stage is set in a Jewish synagogue. Judaism and Islam, for your information, are literally enemies. If this was a gig to appease muslims, choosing a Jew outfit is the least sensible thing to do that.
2. Please stop asking "why only Hindus are secular". We all know the answer- because Hinduism is a beautiful way of life. It embraces the good in everything and gives people freedom to think. Hindus see every religion a way to attain spiritual height. Hinduism don't teach hate as much as other religions do ( Please don't confuse Hinduthwa with Hinduism, Hinduthwa is a politically motivated, hate filled, fascist ideology)
3. Ananthabhairavi is a ragam. A ragam could be used to sing various songs. Even if I sing only "ta raa raa raa ta raa raa raa" for 17 minutes in this tone, that is still ananthabhairavi. Listen to the music first, then to the lyrics.
4. Music has always been innovative. Indian music, being the essence of various cultures, have always been innovative. This is also a humble attempt at that.
5. Releasing this video on Christmas eve sends a message. Embrace the music of every religion. Spread love, not hate😘
Yaseen Habeeb You seem to make too much sense. Hindutva boys can’t handle that, man.
Thank you!
Lol, nutjob Abrahamic, India will never ever be an Abrahamic majority state,mark my words😏
@@lordakhenaten5826 who said India will be an abrahmic state? India will always be a sovereign socialist federal democratic republic, as Ambedkar designed it.
@@ayeluru 😅. Hindus will understand brother. Hinduthwa boys don't understand anything
I’m from Lahore Pakistan, huge love & respect for your music. From Sindhi bharavi to kanda music all of my very own culture deserves praise
Sorry,but it's Sindhu Bhairavi and kaanada
Its just a way to express its relation with indus river area . In Sansikrat it is called sindhu while in Indo persian languages its Sindhi
Very innovative, thanks.
All reformers are not liked by their contemporaries.
Even the great Poet Subramaniya Bharathi was abused and ignored by the conservative during his life time.
The very same category is singing his songs these days.
This song was sung by Dr. KJ Yesudas 30 years ago... Raga: Anandabhairavi...he is the one who made this song
Das sir paadiyal eehe, TMK paadiyal ooho. Nothing can be done.
Music is above religion. The ultimate has also no religion Krishnaji tries to bring the noble art closer to ultimate God.Absolutely great attempt
True. God has no religion because he is beyond all culture and also provided temporary humans to walk through culture.
A true artist and a great human being who conveys his thoughts only through music
Salute sir
I browsed most of the comments here and from what I gather, more than 90% of the people who have commented have a one track mind - that is their hatred towards Islam.
Mr. TMK's performance here is not in a MOSQUE, but in a Jewish Synagogue, a totally different religion. So, I suggest you get your heads out of wherever it is stuck and appreciate TMK in his effort to bring religions together for better understanding of each other for peace and harmony. After all, MUSIC is the language of the Gods.
That doesn't mean they hate muslims
music is HARAM in Islam Krishna is insulting muslims
Yes because these other religions have always been so harmonious with Hindus.
@@jithendtk9381 and you are an expert on Islam?
@@jithendtk9381 as a practicing muslim, i was never brought up to believe that music was haram
I am a die hard fan of TMK's singing. Hear him almost every week. But arabic and anandhabhairavi was a horrible misadventure which i would happily forget and continue listening yo TMK.
Jiddu Krishnamoorthy, Theosophical society influenzes have their own limitations. Inclusiveness is good without losing ones own authenticity.
Sure TMK will reflect on this experience. These things happen when one is bored and thinks of some change in life/excitement. Very hard to keep singing same kritis for entire life, though many have done so.
vah! what an elating concoction of secularism weaving through Carnatic music. Need more TM Krishnas in this world.
Very true 💗
After the controversies, searching all performance of TMK and enjoying like never before..🙏
No faith in humanity after checking the comment section.
But nothing change the fact that TMK is phenomenal. What an inspiration.
Inspiring people to not to be like him a urban naxal
The words he pronouncing is salaathullaah salaamullaah praising prophet rasool sal.. Goosebumps while hearing wabill haadi rasoolillaah... thanks sir.
Thank him for not singing verses in Koran which exhorts Muslims to butcher Jews, Christians and idolaters.
Beware sir! Some of our friends are declaring admirers of TMK as non-believers. I am no great admirer of TMK but i fail to see the connection of religion and art (or the lack of it) in this case.
True indian ♥️ heard it's KJ Yeshudas version too, both are beautiful 💐 Respects sir.. Diversity is the essence of India
¿KJY version?
_excusez-moi_ but iyam not too good with abbreviations.. or millennial generation internet slangs
Yeshudas, the one who composed it
@@sailaab This Carnatic version of the hymn Salatullah, set in Ananda Bhairavi Raga was originally composed in the late 1980's by Dr. K. J. Yesudas, also known as Gaanagandharvan (Celestial Singer). Here he is singing his composition on TV back in the day, with excellent pronunciation of Arabic:
ruclips.net/video/KqcTjoNd3rQ/видео.html
Very beautiful, and courageous in these times! Fascist-minded purists will always struggle to understand the universality of sacred music like what is contained here. Music is beyond religion, great artists like TM Krishnan understand what simple minds cannot. Remember human minds work like parachutes, when open they save your life when closed they lead to death.
Loved the music, the singing, the lyrics and the ragam!
Art has no boundaries don't put religious biases on it. Listen how did he connect arabic lyrics in carnatic music. Unprecedented creativity.
Exactly 100 % true
True NO need follow dress code... He is absolute cheap singer
Music is haram in Islam.
Wonderful. Great souls and great talents promote harmony. This is also an act of piety. Stay blessed and connected ever with divine.
Ananda Bhairavi always reminds me of goddess Meenakshi and soulful thoughts Shyama shastri.
😫😫😭😭
With reference to the above comments I would like to remind that any other religious prayers or compositions were sung in their original style.
May it be namaz or any thing.
You can check of any dignitaries of Indian musicians.
But changing the whole background of such holy compositions will just look like exploitation of the tradition.
I myself have presented a sufi song wearing tilak.
If his dignity Mr Krishna would like to show his secularism then he could do it in the same way as he did a year ago at Afghan church.
What is the need for the Jewish or islamic cap.
Out of focus episode ഇറങ്ങിയതിന് ശേഷം ആയിരിക്കും ഇത് trending ആയി കൊണ്ടിരിക്കുന്നത് 😂❤
out of focus കണ്ട് വന്നത്
The name of the concert itself is "concert for Peace".As a musician he is trying his best level for the communal harmony.The song representing Islam is"salathullah" and other one is "Om Tat Sat Sri Narayana Tu"representing Hinduism.Same artist and same costume....Lot of people just searching for their religion than the music even this album...shame...
Music is haram in Islam. This man is insulting you guys.
I pitty the comments. I sincerely feel shame on the attitude of people. Is Carnatic music religion based ? Or Is Music is bound by religion ? Music is way above all. The vibes is something which can change emotions . The mighty Ananda Bhairavi and it's grace cannot be understood by you people who actually don't know what music is.
Yes, Carnatic music is purely based on Hindu philosophy and traditions... you need to read more @ this...
Sreejith Nair , yes we know only anandha bhairavi in its true form and so much used to listening in a certain way. But it’s your choice to mix yogurt rice and chicken kuruma and eat! Don’t feel shame for us!
@@rdb2349 what Hindu sandhu bondhu ?? How many paraiyar carantic musicians r there ?? What Hindu? Carnatic music is purely caste based u fool
@@Sharadmahendar12 Have you heard of Dr. Yesudas? Our great MS Subbulakshmi, ML Vasanthkumari? ++ Most of the Most nagaswaram and Tavil vidwans like T Rajaratnam Pillai , SempanarKoil brothers , Karaicuruchi Arunachalam , AKC Natarajan are all non brahmins.... They all respect Hindu tradition...
Please any put the link for song kele sukabhashini ...by sir TM Krishna..
I can't find this on Spotify. Can this be made available there?
No clown it’s not there
You can find orginal and better ones in Spotify
This is a beautiful track. Also, Ajmal do not mind the asuras here who are here to spread hate.
Asuras, learn from Mr. TM Krishna ji.
Lovely music; Muslims are my brothers, sisters, teachers, and neighbors; I am a Hindu Brahmin; I support T N Krishna's "respect and reverence" for all faiths;
We live in the 21St century. Your words cannot dictate my thoughts.
Your Brahmin credentials mean nothing. Your caste is a threat to Dharma now. You had Adi Shankaracharya once. Now you have Mamta Banerjee and tmk.
I would want muslims to show the the same acceptance for Hindus. Try singing a Bhajan in a mosque.
TM Krishna ❤❤❤
That’s great ❤️❤️❤️
Sir you can be of any caste. But the fact is TMK is a hypocrite.
What he is wearing is a kippah not a skull cap …
How beautiful 🎶❤️🎻. Lovely to hear Anandabhairavi through "Salahthullah" 🎶👏🏻👏🏻👌🏻
On seeing the comments I just remember the statement given by sadguru... You can just say some religion are violent and some are peace, but all these are make up. If triggered in a certain way everyone will turn violent! What this man have done? He just sang a Jewish song in a synagogue. What is the problem in that? I am a brahmin but studied in a Christian school and since I sang well, I sang the prayer for 10 years! Will I be sent to yamalog? And my music teacher is a Christian and she holds a PhD in music. Everyday she sings on ganeaha, Krishna, Rama and what not! Will she be sent to the hell? These are the same group of people who invites yesudas to sing in their temple for margazhi! At that time no god comes in the way! What logic is this?
Aha! This shows your absolute ignorance. It's not a Jewish song at all. It's a song in Arabic language asking for the god to bless the jihadis of Battle of Badr!! Singing a song with cruel intent(citing the mindset of asking peace for jihadis) in a soothing raga doesn't make a religion peaceful !!!
@@dineshnavada Dinesh... Sorry I was ignorant about the lyrics before your comment. But now I went and search for it.. and it is sounding nothing bad in my eyes. And the lyrics says the lord to bless the warriors of battle of badr and to bless the commander in chief yassin.! And to bring peace in the world. Do we have no songs on bravery of kaethigeya or Shiva? But now I am thinking why he sang this song in a synagogue :-)) ..but my dear friend think about it, if the live crowd can be acceptable to render a Islamic song on a synagogue why can't me and you be tolerant?
@@arunkk004, I don't see any problem with him reciting the Arabic song in a synagogue. But the problem is, why should he do so with muslim attire and Carnatic music? Also the intension of the song is also disturbing where it asks lord to bless jihadis who wage war to expand Islamic state. Also his Arabic is equally worst. He sang this song just to showcase that he is so called "secular". By the way, where does the song talk about world peace?
@@dineshnavada Dinesh Navada 1 the cap is not that of a Islamic tradition, it is a short cap which is worn at the synagogue. Again, what's the problem in wearing it. Just the way you tie a turban or kerchief when going to gurudwara he tied it. 2. South Indian Classical is a type of a singing. You have songs on nature, on India, on various god, on well being, even secularism in that case I didn't find a reason why you are against a rendition on another god? 3. In the translation I read warrior and not jihadis.. the line read "bring peace upon the blessed soul of the warriors who fought at badr" I am not an expert in literature but from what I read that is the first battle fought by Mohammed and I didn't find anything wrong in this since ever god/demi god/ messanger has fought atleast a war(I might be wrong, if you have an exact and neutral translation kindly share with me) 4. Being from Tamil Nadu and have no expose towards Arabic his pronunciation is definitely not going to be perfect. He is a human being and not Google translator to process in all languages
Arun Kumar , 1. Wearing a Jewish cap, singing a song on Islamic god in a Carnatic raga? What is the point he is trying to make?
2. Carnatic music is not just a system of music. It is the whole bunch of spiritual values linked with music. When you sing a song like this, Carnatic audience (well, atleast me) can't just associate with it.
3. Those warriors of Badr that the song is talking about are the people who attacked the Quraish community to expand the Islamic state. That's why I used the word "Jihadi".
4. So you're telling that one can be excused of any mispronounciations of sAhitya citing that he is from different geographical region? What is the point in singing lyrics if you can't sing it properly? You can just do rAgalApa, tAna in any raga. Why should you learn lyrics when you can't pronounce it properly?
Music has no religion . This makes sense
Yet music is pleasing to God
religion has no humanity
@@kdsdv3264 😂👏🏼
Surely if music has no religion then Hindu krithis on Rama and Muruga should appeal to Muslims and Christians. No need for this stunt of changing the lyrics to appear secular.
@@elborrador333 I don't remember saying 'people have no religion'
Being a Muslim, I really enjoyed this music. Hats off to TMK.... Singing Carnatic🕉️ inside Synagogue🕎 with Islamic lyrics☪️.... Bravo... This is my India ❤ 🇮🇳
This isn’t India. This is TM Krishna.
How do you feel if he sings a sriram Bhajan in a masjid ? Does your India allow it ?
@@chandrashekharhs9738 Come to Kerala and see such beauty here.
@@chandrashekharhs9738 ruclips.net/video/fgzJ2v3z7hE/видео.htmlsi=UfY1AhKkYITlfvUk
@@chandrashekharhs9738 Abdul Kalam chanted Hindhu mantras! did you appose?
TM Krishna is a genius.
Good music, has no boundaries, welcome TMK’s diversity and reach out.
Awesome as always. Just look into his talent and music pls. Religious comments hurts everyone and leads to abuse of words. 🙏🙏🙏. Music when sung in praise of supreme power.. God be it any god., is very sacred. Pls refrain from using abusive language.
Sorry sir... I'm nobody to be lecturing but this is not the way carnatic music is meant to be sung. Would Muslims sing Qawwalis wearing kumkuma and vibhooti with a portrait of rama, Ganapathi or Krishna next to them? Absolutely not.
May be tomorrow some Muslim will. What's the problem if the pioneer is a brilliant Hindu guy?
@@shoonnya What a simp you are 😂. Anyway, who said Kufi cap is a religious mark of Islam? It's a cultural mark of Arabian countries. Just like hijaab has nothing to do with Islam. It is a cultural mark of Wahabbism. There are thousands of indigenous ways of covering the head. The intention here is theatrics, to make a political statement using music. It's no genuine love for Islamic culture.
well. that they din't do it, is not a deterent for us to not do it and show the way. expansion is life, so let carnatic music expand beyond boundaries of religion, let it be expression bakthi to one's chosen belief in the god or universe or omnipresent. Fyi it did expand to christianity 200 years ago itself. check Shastriyar and mayavaram vedhanayagam pillai
@@abhinavdas3089 there are several rock bhajans.
BTW, Muslims HAVE been doing this for years. I have myself attended concerts by Zakir Hussain with a Ganesh idol next to him. He is a ganesh devotee. And also I have attended concerts by Vilayat Khan playing with Shankaracharya himself sitting next to him on stage, or did you even know that Hirabai Badodekar was a Muslim? Her birth name was Zebunnisa. She was the daughter of Abdul Karim Khan, the founder of Kirana gharana. So keep your silly bigotry to yourself.
Thank you and wonderful performance
I very much like Suprabhatam month of Markali early morning from the temple loud speaker great
good to know Pakkir bro.
but it is okay in rural areas.. in bigger towns and cities.. speakers really shouldn't be allowed during night.. as in only from sunrise to sunset.
be it in marriages, festivals, temples, churches, masjids or private homes playing loud music/ having party.
Wearing Kippah, the Jewish traditional cap while singing in a synagogue suits the purpose of the concert. Except the commentators here, everyone who was present there would certainly be happy to enjoy the music.
Does he think people from Arabic countries like this ‘adaptation’? The lyrics are part of a popular prayer and RUclips has several rendering of this sung by people of the Middle East. Just ‘search’ and you get many to choose from!
Why should people from Arab countries have to like it?? Is he singing for their approval?
Amazing rendition by TMK . He is truly an epoch maker. The butt-hurt Nazis and fanatic in this comment thread haven’t really understood the meaning of music. Music is all about destroying boundaries. If K J Yesudas can sing about Krishna, then TM Krishna can sing about Yesu. The art grows only when it spreads to the world. Culture is about dissolving barriers. The violin itself was appropriated/adapted for Carnatic music from the Christendom where it was used in the church and orchestras. Lots of love to everyone.
Did your father produce this music if not then keep silence
First learn to give it's real credit where it belongs to other just like you people made surya namaskar to sun salutations you can do same fraud with this thing too later you all will claim it as abrahamic
This is fucking music of tmk. He is a baffoon and can find a place in circus
Lol Nazi when your butt gets burned a lot you start throwing such words and think you are very smart, if they were really Nazis you wouldn't be making such comments with getting your arse handed to you.
Music is haram da you idiots
Let us look at the irony here. When Daasan sang this - there was no hatred or bigotry. Is it because Daasan is a Christian, and TMK is a TamBrahm? TMK just sang it more soulfully (IMHO), as it really brings out the essence of Ananda Bhairavi. It is really TMK's remix of Daasan devotional version ruclips.net/video/KqcTjoNd3rQ/видео.html. There is also a light music version, which is discordant for me personally, but I respect those who appreciate it as well
No one said anything when Daasan sang o4 when TMS or any singer sang songs of deities of other religions - It is the crazy way he purposely projects make things worst.
Srinath Alamela , please think before you type. Daasan or Muhammad rafi singing hindu bhajans are different. Rafi did not keep tilak when he sang hindu bhajans, daasan, is a trained Carnatic singer with pure heart never ever disguised himself to appease anyone. Now tell me, why the heck you compare them to this fellow? He is trying something different, but this is rubbish!
@@rapid5208 Rapid 520, Please look at my comments about cultural memes. I don't like to make these discussions personal and I will keep it that way. So when Daasan applies Vibhuti is he also appeasing? What about the great Parveen Sultana?
Srinath Alamela , that’s the beauty of those stalwarts. They don’t do this type of political stunts especially to show their frustration against a government. For them, music is bhakthi and they don’t use it to satiate their ego.
@@rapid5208 And they don't do it on stage it stunt - Dassanna believes in Iyappa also and wears Tilak or vibhudhi at temples on his visit. Not to show off on stage with the intention to create controversy. He really is for peace not Tmk. Anything overdone is vulgar and leads to aversion and that's what he is creating.
He's GREAT music is no relegion also God for commen in the world
Music can erode differences among the religions. LONG BACK Great Semmangudi sri srinivasa iyer carnatic stalwart says - in 1990 s - If LTTE were given opportunity to listen carnatic- that/ LTTR they give up the Arms.
It is true
I liked TMK's singing - he has applied the Caranatic Raga well. But, wearing cap didn't make sense. Thanks for sharing.
Isnt that, his freedom of choice? why question something that he has not intended.
Perhaps it’s a mark of respect? Is it required for him to wear the Kippah in the Synagogue?
Fantastic! TMK
our Dasettan had sung this long back very nicely. Around 30 years before!
Yes
Ananda Bhairavi just melts.... He performs on 26th here. Exited about it. My only question is how that hat sat on his head without falling down?? He just moves too much as always....😁 Just for fun.
The mic is very good this time. Kudos FEA
😀
They probably used hair clips to fasten the kippah to the hair.
Real Indian mucian, great sir
Thanks to DR Shalini for bringing me here... TM Krishna is a revolutionist .
Outstanding. Really music is next to the God
The God is Dead that's what our ustad said. But certainly invoked α β γ rays altogether in the brain
Appreciate the boldness of accompanying artists who also come from orthodox families . Subbulakshmi wearing a black saree is also a bold statement. Keep going TMK. Imbeciles will remain where they are.
Kudos Krishna, you are a bundle of musical surprise
Ennada nadekkethe🤔,weird but beautiful☺☺
He is true human being breaking away from cast , religious boundaries. By the way it is Jewish cap not Muslim cap.
Why there is so much of an issue when an artist sings about a God in Carnatic style. There are no such issues in Hindustani which is very much Indian as Carnatic is. I know of an excellent singer from Kerala who has graduated in Carnatic music who cannot get a stage because he is a Muslim. I feel very sad about the situation.. thanks a lot to FEA and Krishna for doing this wonderful job. Really proud
I, too, give heartfelt thanks to FEA and TMK for taking a stand for what is right.
Sajith Pallippuram because Maybe I have spent lot of money in buying cds for Bhakti which I can’t use anymore.
@@ಕೃಷ್ಣಾಭಾಗವತ I think the racist people who hate TMK for his overtures look at music simply as entertainment. People who really understand music know that it is not simply for entertainment; good music is supposed to make you a better person.
Cos he's planting such thoughts about divide in the name of religion which doesn't exist in the first place in people's minds and alienating himself. Music has always been open. It's his way of doing certain things which bothers other musicians.
@@gamechangerk6664 Are you in some other solar system, or are not just not familiar with current events on Earth?
TM Krsna is a man of great humanity, much depth and super talent. India needs people like him.
long back a gentle man had the audacity to bring in western instrument (violin) into the carnatic fold. many purists complained on both sides. Many western practitioners even cringe at the way violin is held in carnatic performance. does it matter? today it has become an integral part. historically, both carnatic and hindustani have common root as far as I know, ..eventually deviating in development path due to cultural influences from different regions. carnatic is still largely if not completely limited to bhakti only and that too only that of vedic community. Hindustani covers a more diverse range of subjects I think. I personally always wished to bring carnatic music to wider world just like what happenned to pretty much all music/knowledge in human history. its art! painting techniques developed to paint christian religious subjects in the west have been adapted for all kinds of purposes today including for vedic religious art. no one complains. no one should. similarly, if TMK is using his immense understanding and popularity in this field to bring the art to more, it is great. isnt it? I wish more kritis are written in more languages instead of every one just learning the old ones. Many of the popular ones are not even the mother tongue of practitioners making it extra difficult to memorize and connect to the lyrics. the old ones were also new in their times...written by TMKs of their era, adding more to the field. Let the flow continue. these arts belong to human kind...the whole of it.... founders are mere temporary custodians. just my thought.
❣
Nishanth Salahudeen , very well said! Please take him to huj pilgrimage next time and make him sing a rama song in Mecca! That would be awesome! Isn’t it?
@@rapid5208 am talking about music my dear. Not religious beliefs. This guy is an atheist as far as i understand. I remember him saying that he enjoys the raga when he sings "rama" and not any religious piety feeling. Religious people can use loudspeaker to play slokas which confirm their thought process. Atheist can use same loudspeaker to play rock music. Its just a tool, a medium. Thats it. Art is like that. It is a collection of short cuts to human cognition, the bare minimum stuff which can evoke certain feelings.. thats a window into human mind. It has nothing to do with allah or rama or christ. So, please dont get confused. I hope all the people who eat biryani is not asked to go to mecca as well...
@@rapid5208 oh... perhaps you meant to say that the meccans wont like it. So what?! Thats a completely different topic. I still feel that you got confused between art and religion. He sang an islamic composition (not all muslims like that composition. Just saying). Even the basic tune is what is traditionally used to sing it. That means the basic set of notes (swaras) is already there. What this guy did is to fit it into the framework of a raaga and also performed it in south indian style. If we start thinking that a style is a religion... then nothing more to say. There we can agree to disagree and live peacefully. His dress, cap etc has to do with what he has to say to the soceity. Perhaps he means "it doesn't matter ". Well, he is an atheist, so that fits well. Besides, when south indians absorbed violin into carnatic music, your european cousin would have asked "let them play hallelujah in madurai meenakshi temple". The world is luckily slightly bigger than such thought process... so that we can celebrate people like L subramaniam today.
Nishanth Salahudeen, here is my opinion. I did not agree when MF Hussein painted nude saraswathi a decade back and he was thrashed. But people like you said, well it’s an artistic expression. T M Krishna could have done these type of experiments during other critical situations rather than now. It’s just my opinion that he is seeking cheap publicity. Muslims will never ever be swayed by his gimmicks. But would welcome his experiment now because they feel insecured. They are always very clear in their beliefs and I respect them. As a ardent Carnatic lover, I feel using a anandha bhairavi to sing an Islamic song is only to satiate his ego. About using violin, you are talking a different context. Don’t ask why are you using telephone because graham bell invented it. Its irrelevant. He is doing this to show his hatred for BJP and CAA. He had so many chances to prove his secular credentials in the last 20 years.
Lovely to see him wearing the Abrahamic skull cap and now I just want one and only one prominent muslim artist to wear a simple red or chandan kumkum tikka on forehead. or how about a simple orange cap. Just a simple tikka or cap. This .is not tit for tat but just a simple gesture that shows appreciation. Anyone can think of a muslim artist who will do that ? Anyone ? They have great muslim musicians all over the world. Anyone ? Truth is its not needed. Why engage in such shallow symbolism. Skull cap is for islam and is abrahamic tradition to show seperation of believer from abrahamic good (yahweh or allah). You can wear hindu symbols and sing arabic songs.
Do these tricks really work Mr TM Krishna. Truth is this is about your own ego and don't think muslims are moved by this or swooning over such stupid optics. What does it even mean ? You are not a muslim so you are not required to wear that skull cap. You can sing arabic songs anyway you want. Why this stupid bending over to show off.. its purely 'look at me how liberal and large minded I am' vanity. Its not for muslims but just to provoke your own community and you want this discussion. Its just as bad if not more than the moronic saffron sanghis. For a artist to focus on this in itself shows you are not really about carnatic music or its bhavas. You want use it for your own vanity. Ugliness .
In the end I will shamelessly also admit that the rendering is just amazing and it moved me very much. As a Hindu I surrender to the divinity in his performance and he is a great artist indeed though I disagree with his antics and showoffs.
How about Begum Parveen Sultana, How about Shri Sheik Mahaboob Subhani, Smt. Kalisha Bee?
ruclips.net/video/pfR1mnw0b3M/видео.html,
ruclips.net/video/9X3vjQXx7xw/видео.html
I think he is wearing one because he is performing in a synagogue.
See parvin sultana concert
Boss, that is a kippah. Most synagogues requires men to wear one.
@@rkrishna1965 Thank you. I was hoping that someone would mention Sheikh Chinna Moulanas family.
TMK ....you are a brilliant musician with a strong view of integration which I do appreciate.....I struggle to understand this though. I’m not articulate enough to explain why this interpretation sounds very forced and uncomfortable to me but it can say unequivocally that it does. I’m all for your desire for integration but I think there’s a better way to make it effective. Simply put....this doesn’t touch my heart the way traditional Christmas carols or Sufi music does. I admit I might be ignorant.
Very nice attempt. Forget about who is singing and with what attire. It's Divine feeling listening from this great Paul. Long live TMK. Jai to Humanity.
I am fan of TMK, simultaneously not convinced with his one sided criticism of actions by this government. He should understand that Islam and the rest of the world are acting in differnet planes. Rest of the world by and large accepts all religions and nationhood. Islam by its basic tenets does not belive in anything other than Islam, they may be soft when being minority. So will he go to their plane and openly critize thte constiutionlized discrimination happening to other religions in Islamic countries. I know people like TMK are great thinkers, but why they fail to under this. Sing allah, that is your right, but call a spade a spade where/when needed.
What a comment! Spot on bro!
E At least thanks for starting with pleasantly addressing me as 'Boss' however at the end how you addressed me entirely different. That’s OK. Completely agree with u 'charity begins at home' and v have been doing it for long and will keep doing it forever. By default, our culture, whatever you call it as Hinduism or Indian culture etc. is secular in nature. Hindus by default r Secular and nobody can take it away. Periodically great leaders like Guru Nanak and Shivaji come and steady our country’s secular path. Currently a democratically elected government is trying to steady the nation in its secular path/values. The CAA is trying to correct the mistakes done by leaders while dividing county. Pakistan and later Bangladesh promised to treat its minorities well, but they not only failed, went on to constitutionally discriminated minorities. Do you know it took close to 60 years for Pakistan government to pass Hindu Marriage Act? See what is happening to Dinesh Kaneria, most successful spin bowler in Pakistan history and how he is being treated. What I am saying is that thought leader like TM Krishna should come out openly talk about the negatives of other side. Please understand Muslims don't believe in nations as we know now. They believe in Ummah. So, whether you like it or not these topics will go beyond out boundaries. Also understand any other individual (outside of the five-religion mentioned in CAA) can still apply for asylum in the open quota. They won't come under the CAA collective bargaining. The height of hypocrisy in the Islamic world is that Nobel laureate Malala openly twit about the plight of Rohingyas, however yet to say single word about how badly minorities are being ill-treated in her own country. I assume you listen to person like Fateh Tariq and Asif Aajakia. Do you know UN issued a statement stating that ill-treated Christians of Iraq should be provided asylum by other countries and some EU countries had immigration clauses to provide citizenship to such impacted Christians - none of the so-called liberals criticized such actions stating they discriminated other religions. Also do you know, if any Cuban will be provided citizenship in USA if they simply managed to land in US soil - it does not matter how they come into USA. That law won’t apply to other countries ruled by dictators - no body criticized US for that. I HAVE FULL CONFIDENCE THAT INDIA WILL REMAIN A TRUE SECULAR COUNTRY FOR EVER.
@@bkbk4726 hey India is a democracy and TMK thinks religion should not be the basis for CAA etc., it's his view. he thinks citizenship should not have the tag religion associated with it. in a democracy diametrically opposite views must be welcomed whether you like it or not. who are you to say that he must talk about muslims too? have you ever talked good about muslims?
@@montanaabdulramanraman1758 To start with I liked your name Montana Abdul Raman Raman. Yes it is democracy TMK has his right to ideas. He expressed his in open which is bound to atrract criticism and I did that. Let us not forget Indian culture alwasy support oppressed. It was Indian culture which provided shelter for Parsi religion when they were persecuted in Persia. It is Indian culture which openly alowed preaching of other religion to start with Islam in Kerala and later Christianity. Indan clture never opposed difference. Even now Muslims can apply for citizenship through regular channel. So it is blatant lie to say Indian Immigration is based on religion. CAA is a special clause with the policy to provided the persecuted minorities (which no body denies) of states which procolaimed Islam as their relgion and constitutionally targetted minorities - again this is to set right the bad work done during partition.
CAA iis something similar to the Indian reservaton system which helps the people who were oppresed for decades to come up. If you say CAA is wrong then Indian reservation system also wrong and discriminatory.
Do you know in USA any Cuban if they manange to set foot on Florida soil, they can apply for immigration. No body says that is discrimination.
Do you know UN officially said that persecuted christians from ISIS controled Syria/Iraq should be accepted by other countries - no body says that is discrimination.
Some of the EU countries said they will accept Christians from ISIS controled areas - no body says that is discrimination.
I have no issue with Muslims - still India welcomes them thru regular channel, that is it.
@@bkbk4726 so what if the Indian culture provided shelter to many. today Australia, USA, Singapore etc., are all migrant countries and you know why they are all called First world countries. it's because they are quick to adapt to changes unlike Indians who want to be stuck and are stuck in a time wrap. who cares what happened 500 years ago? look forwards and not backwards.
frankly to me your Indian culture sucks and stinks. I am no politician. India is perhaps the only country which does not value life. when a person is being lynched the world at large moves on like nothing happened. when there is an accident nobody wants to stick their head to take the injured to the hospital. question is why are we all not passionate in setting right rules like that. TMK is at least trying in his own small way to bridge the chasms. *you talk so much about CAA and the affirmative policy and how they are linked.* should we not link mankind first and remember thats what TMK is doing here by singing an Arabic song in a carnatic genre. you may not like the rendition and that's fine. criticize the way it was sung. nobody has an issue but pointing fingers at him because his view does not resonate with yours and the using that to criticize his core competence is a sign of a sick and a depraved mind set.
now you are asking me for my views on the CAA and NPR. my answer is it's none of your business. issues like these dont interest me. to be very honest I dont care as this is not my area of core competence. I am more passionate about other laws like the laws on real freedom, laws prohibiting superstition, development of a scientific temper etc. TMK has a diametrically opposite view to that of the government . it's his view. so what? this is a legislation which can be stretched to any length. his contrarian argument is it must stretch further but you are saying that the stretch is adequate. the current CAA is saying Tom and Dick are enough. many are asking what about Harry? Why only 3 nations, why not all the countries from the earth whereas the current law has limited folks to 3 countries? again, this is purely a matter of principle and how far can the country stretch. DO you really think there is an answer for this. I can show many such laws in the current statute book which can be stretched like this and many are pending before the SC for ages now.
what has his view got to to do with his music? what has it got to do with the way he is using his artistic talent? so what if he sings an Arabic song in the Carnatic raaga? so what if he is an athiest like me? please note I am supporting his artistic pursuit and his artistic views and not necessarily all that he thinks.
We are so proud of T M krishna sir.....our country needs this kind of innovation...his attire and skull cap are invisible in the presence of his mesmerizing presentation
The skull cap is traditional in synagogues. He's wearing it as a mark of respect.
Great sir. You are an inspiration. All castist bastards don't accept the change you making. God is with you sir❤❤
ഒരു പുതിയ അനുഭവം... thank u soooooo much sir
Tomorrow he will compse somthing on sex and sing melodiously with his ability, will you enjoy just because his singing nice?
He produced sound if it has to be nice there must be feeling bhav through which he expresses his soul .where is that soul
Yes why not?
Already there are tons of old carnaticsongs with detailed descriptions of sex and eroticism. Will you accept them only if they are conveyed from the pov of Radha to Krishna?
With pleasure, sex is as beautiful as anything else
Yes!! Absolutely
நீங்கள் நிகழ்கால மகாகவி பாரதியார் போல. ஒருசிலரால் நீங்கள் விமர்சிக்கப்பட்டாலும் ஒருநாள்
உலகப்புகழ் அடைவது உறுதி. நிச்சயம் வரலாற்றில் இடம்பெறுவீர்கள். உங்களின் சீர்திருத்த முயற்சிகளுக்கு எனது வாழ்த்துக்கள் சார்.
Reality is Islam is against music 😂😂
How can you not just adore this melting pot of cultures. A song in praise of an Islamic god in an ancient Sanatana tone in a Jewish synagogue. All those people whose stomachs feel twisted after listening to this, you are not a true Indian.
Great. .we are Indian s.....thanks
One thing the "self-declared" promoters of "universality or peace" do not understand is that the Hindu religion and its proponents have never had any ill-feeling against others. Remember singing along KJ Yesudas when he sang "enna solli devan" or "yeh badi maasha allah". There were no comments against him when he did that. That was done out of respect and passion.
The comments now are due to the fact that what he is doing is drama. Some are immersed in the acting and others who can see the acting call it foul.
If someone really doesn't care what others think, why take the strain to reply at all.
@E I am not a joker or a drama king like TMK or his dumbass followers who think they are unique just because they eat out of their butt. I am a completely "NORMAL" human being who like no drama but just bhakti in music.
@@vijayakumarsrinivasan6102 I'd like you to understand that bhakti isn't restricted to just Brahmanism. The word itself means devotion to a divine force. That is the same regardless of religion. And as for all these 'purists' who say that TMK is corrupting Carnatic music, it's your savarna attitude that is being spewed. The only reason carnatic music was shackled was because the upper castes had an iron grip on it - being restricted to all these sangeetha sabhas has hurt carnatic music immensely. The reason Hindustani is so popular is because it was taken to the masses and used in a variety of ways. TMK is trying to do so the same with Carnatic music by taking it to new pastures. If you don't like it please don't bother to listen. No one here is stuffing things down your throat. Let Carnatic music be liberated.
@@aravindgopinathan6371 Where is Brahminism here? As you cannot bring in anything meaningful you are talking non-sense. Carnatic music is not restricted to a few sabhas but is very much performed in temple events and lots of open forums. Carnatic music was performed even in the halls of UN unlike what few jokers like TMK say.
FYI Carnatic music is more popular than Hindustani music. All these classical art forms (carnatic, hindustani and western classical) are very difficult to master and need a lot of patience and practice. Tell me few hundred hindustani classical performers or Western performers who came from the masses - Answer is only a handful. The same handful can be shown in carnatic music as well. Talk about caste is all stupid which people like TMK only can bring up to whip up passions.
@E This is the class of this bastard and his bed fellows. The talk is about Carnatic Music which is beyond your calibre. Restrict to your field of pornography and TMK which are inseparable.
TM Krishna will be remembered for this change what he brings into carnatic music!!!!!!!!!!
Respect!
It is extremely beautiful to see such great artists accepting unity of all religions
மனிதருள் மாணிக்கம்
மனமறுள் நீங்கிய பேரருள்
TMK💪❤️💥
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Aum, Allah ho Akbar, Amen, Hallelujah, Ek pitaa ekas ke ham barrik
Firstly, Raj Nat, you are simply exhibiting your own ignorance and prejudices. Secondly, this place is a Jewish temple and like all places of worship, it is being treated with dignity and respect, something, it is obvious, you don’t seem to possess. Thirdly, learn to keep an open mind and appreciate the music for its beauty. And finally, as the title of the concert suggests, this is a Concert for Peace. It is apparent that you have no desire for peace in the world. Your agenda is to divide and spread hatred. The world can do without people like you. And if you don’t like what is being attempted here, then simply stay away and spread your ignorance and prejudice elsewhere. Shame on you.
@@FirstEditionArtsChannel You’re the problem here posting videos of this hypocrite. He will wear the kippah in the synagogue but in Guruvayoor he won’t follow their traditions. I have no issue with music in other places, but changing lyrics and putting one religion above another is what annoys me about this hypocrite.
@@FirstEditionArtsChannel All I am saying is respect all religion equally and do not be an hypocrite..I respect all religion Aum, Allah, and Amen are different names which lead to the same god. However it pains to see many hypocrite around
@@arunsreenivasan2074 well said. Sold out.
@@arunsreenivasan2074 idiot he worships music not religions enga ava da Bunda⚫
God is one. He is addressed as Satchidananda in Sanathana Dharma, Allah in Islam, Jehovah, Guru Nanak so on and so forth. It does not matter to God how you praise Him. He craves for pure love. He is pure love. Ahura Mazda or Allah or Satchidananda is neither moved by praise or blame. He manifests where there is purity of feelings.
When will foolish humanity understand and acknowledge this oneness?
Exactly. There maybe many paths but the truth is one. May people find the Divine in pure love.
OM Shanti 🙏🏽🕉️
Ekam sath vipraha bahuda vedanti
விநாச காலே விபரீத புத்தி
So nice Mr. Krishna. Hats off to you . Great
He should sing for iyyanar and mariamman bcoz muslim will not welcome this
@@Justin2cu How do you know? Are you Muslim? Indian Muslims are not religious fanatics like the RSS/RakshasSena/BJP.
Im reminded of Sanjay's advice to a rasika "BOSS ! You sing in FRENCH if you want. The purists will not pay for your salary". Its okay to experiment but bottomline this didnt work at all. If it had been anybody else it may have degenerated into stand-up comedy.
@E Brother. You've misunderstood me totally. Did I say he was a BAD singer ? I'm not qualified to judge Carnatic singing. What I said was this fusion or whatever you call it simply didnt work. It would have worked with even ML Vasanthakumari.
Please read that as WOULDNT have worked
Why hijack the traditional music of an old civilisation and claim a revolution. Will you sing the Russian or Italian or even the English hymns using these verses. Hypocrisy at its height.
Traditional music has evolved over time, what you hear in the name of traditional has being the monopoly of few due to unequal social structure. Now that in independent India everyone has the opportunity to achieve anything they set their eyes on you will see people from all backgrounds representing them.
@@crtp47 can you simg western opera praising Krishna and Shiva??
@@keithhunt5328why not?
Lot of Ustads and Muslims sing Hindustani music. What’s the issue here. Nice music.
@@itellsri agreed. Why not self compose Kriti’s based on Islamic or Christian beliefs. Why plagiarise existing compositions
can you ppl imagine any muslim singing carnatic music in the name swami thiagaraja...we are the only fools to do this ...kandravi....
Why wouldn't they sing Carnatic? I'm sure there are Muslim Carnatic singers.
Don't you know Great Hindustani Music? Try to be Real Human, beyond all limitations
Sheik Chinna Moulana
We Hindus are the real fools,i agree with that
Qwwalli is Islamic carnatic singing
Those who condemn this r 'jokers'!. When v perform abroad n churches/synagogues etc. T s welcome n appreciated. 'Vavar muni' s also prayed on way to Sabarimala!.
Excellent bro Vaalthungal keep it up 👌 👍 💪 👏 🙌 💯
Whatever The linguistic Meaning Says.... Carnatic Music Remains Carnatic Music With His Gāyaki, Rāgdāri and Vidwat,....It Sounds Very Soothing as well....It Again Proves...Carnatic Music Is Raga Music...Nothing Else....And He Is Proving That ....
Like In Hindustani, We Sing 'Kareem Nām Tero ' as well as 'Sumiran Kar Bhaj Rām Nām Ko.' We Never Think Of Hindu ,Muslim,Etc...We Just Think About The Raga.
True
100% true words...
@@kaps8083 patriotic songs also contain raaga, folk songs also contain raaga. Not just by singing Rama or Krishna u will get the bakthi directly..learn and sing the raaga with full of concerntration and sincerely. That will spread out the bakthi
@@kaps8083 it is not wrong in any aspect singing an Arabian song based on a Carnatic raaga, does any stalwart of Carnatic or any books said so? Just think if an Arabian learns Carnatic music and he/she sings an Arabian song using the same Ananthabairavi, would it be acceptable? If Krishna sang an Arabian song based on a Carnatic raaga is not acceptable then any other race rather than an Indian should not learn Carnatic or sings carnatic, as u said our music is only used to praise the deities of our religion, would it be possible? He doesn't change any Shri tygaraaja' s Kriti which set to be in which raaga that sung by maestro's decades by decades, what he does is compose an Arabian song in carnatic raaga.. that's it..in what way u think it is corrupting our music...
@@kaps8083 how do you know explain the nottuswaram by Dikshithar? Clearly he has done great wrong by taking singing Western music in a carnatic context. Or better yet, how about violins? It is a completely foreign thing to carnatic music. Shouldn't carnatic musicians just stick to instruments and techniques described in the vedas? Let me give you another example. I'll give you one more thing to wrap your brain around. Ever heard about Javalis? Most of them have nothing to do with Bhakthi. Why was it never banned? Didn't Hindus from the previous era feel the same way about all carnatic music being vehicles for Bhakthi?
Do you see the hole in your argument? Music is for everyone. TMK is not trying to convert anyone. I am not a Hindu but I have listened to countless hours of carnatic music. It is because I love music and I appreciate art. No one thought it was strange until a few years ago. Now I can't listen to carnatic music or talk about it without someone accusing me of being a culture vulture.
I have never seen any muslim singer donning tilak and hindu attire to sing for peace or harmony like this singer wearing a skullcap. Secularism in India is onesided and always attacking hinduism
@Sohrab The Socialist isnt music HARAM as per your culture?
Yo Rama Varma, listen to 'Kanhaiyya' by Fareed Ayaz and Abu Muhammad. It's about Krishna.
They are Sufi Qawwali singers from Pakistan.
Sohrab, I have heard a lot of Bismillah Khan, Amjad Ali khan, and of late a big fan of Rashid khan. But they do not go around making comic publicity stunts like this.
Search who is kalamandalam hyderali
@Sohrab The Socialist still searching for their pics with alternate attires. Humility and show off are two different words for a good reason.
3 musicians performing an Arabic song in a synagogue in the Carnatic style should provoke curiosity, interest, musical criticism even. But we must examine any anger, hatred and strongly negative emotions, lest they arise from bigotry and prejudice. I respect these three for this project. Thank you for this music, and for provoking introspection in us all.
Greatness is not born by being the 1001th person in doing it along with the tide, but by being the first person doing it against the tide! Simply great!
When people like TMK sir are there, India will still remain as India.
Love and respect from kerala
Kerala is jihadi capital of India
@E you dont even have a name ....Haha...
Kerala is indeed jihadi capital...people like you prove that time and again...
@@psanair7902 firstly where did E say he is from Kerala. you or your ancestors are from Kerala. please Kerala ranks 1 in the HDI of India not your gutkakhor Bimaru states.
@@montanaabdulramanraman1758 Kerala is no1 is jihadi activities...
It is no1 in unemployment thanks to communism
It is no 1 as industry unfriendly state..
It is no1. In suicides
It will be no1. In lawlessness, once the mall's return from Gulf , when Gulf counties lose business....
Bimaru doesn't depend on Gulf countries....they work hard and earn a living
..
Yogiji zindabad
@E what is the employment opportunity in UP vs. Kerala????
True secularism would have come into light if he had gone to the same place wearing his "Thiruman" to this symposium to sing an Arabic song. Music and art transcends any religion but why lose ones authenticity for that ?
Yes, he should have applied thirusoornam on his forehead & skull cap, to show his secularism
its partly context.. I believe that the folks in Israel are getting really interested in the classical musics of India.. some appeasement for promotion
@E does she change her surname, while on international visits??????
Secularism stinks
True secularism stinks horribly.
.
@E atheism is good....but why the fu
..you use it only against Hinduism...
Post against Islam also you coward..
Muslims don't include us ....why the f...should Hindus include them?????
Don't sound too condescending..
This was sung and composed by Dr. K. J. Yesudas in raga Anandabhairavi... 35 years ago
இந்தக் குரல் தொடர்ந்து ஓங்கி ஒலிக்க வேண்டும். மனிதன் விடுதலை பெற நீங்கள் பாட வேண்டும்
Eccentric,behaviour. Ayyo paavam.
குல்லா போட்டு, சுன்னத் செய்தாலும் இஸ்லாம் ஆக முடியாது.
இனி என்ன பாட்டு பாடினாலும் ஒரு தெய்வமும் கருணை காட்டாது . இதுல அக்கா ஏன் படுதா அணியாமல் வயலின் வாசிக்கிறார்.
அதுதான் கருப்பு புடவைய கட்டி விட்டுட்டானுக.😥😥😥
Music is the language of the Gods.
Standing ovation to TM Krishna.
சமத்துவ நாயகனுக்கு என் வாழ்த்துகள் புதிய புரட்சியாளன் தாங்கள்
🌹🌹❤
ഇതു ഇങ്ങിനെ സംഭവിച്ചു കണ്ടതിലും കേട്ടത്തിലും അതിയായ സന്തോഷം. ഒരു അറബിക് കൃതിയായി ഇതു അവതരിപ്പിക്കാൻ മനസ്സുള്ളതും അറിവുള്ളതുമായ അത്ഭുത സിദ്ധിയുള്ള വ്യെക്തിയാണ് ശ്രീ TM കൃഷ്ണ. നമിക്കുന്നു. ഇവിടെ മനുഷ്യ മനസുകളും മതങ്ങളും ഒന്നാകും. അഭിനന്ദനങ്ങൾ😍😍😍
Hindutvas/Hindus accepted ApJKalam because he could play the Veena Yesudas because he sang devotional songs on Hindu gods.
TM Krishna returns the favour...so what
nice comment
Makes sense
TMK is Great. TKM & Team Excellent performance. 💥🤏🤏
It is not the verses that matters but the soul soothing raga aalapana matters. If you have time please hear Shaik Chinna Moulana Nagaswaram or his grandsons Kasim and Babu Brothers aalapana. For your information following their grandfather, they are the Aasthana widhwans of Thirumala. Music has no religion. You should have heard Bharthiyar’s Alla Alla sung by Shrimathi Aruna Sairam. I had the privilege to hear. Don’t go by few comments sir, our society is tolerant and we love music.
Music has no religion sir
I feel sad that not many people know this. People associate Nadhaswaram to Carnatic music and not know much about Chinna Moulana garu
I fully agree with you Akbar Saab but today, ie., on 06th August 2020, Many are scolding him on social media for saying that building Sri Rama Temple at Ayodhya is a crime and all Hindus must be ashamed of it. I don't know when he said, why he said like that and he unnecessarily invited worst criticism on himself.
@@SeethaRamaiah yes sir ... secularism sometimes make people blind
All of you think that you are doing some great service to secularity by doing these gimmicks, but Muslims hate these kind of intrusion into their space . Learn to respect some ones culture and sentiments before intruding into some one religion . Did you become a Muslim before embarking into these adventures. Leave their religion alone , don't interfere in their affairs , you don't have any rights what so ever
ஈச்சம்பாலையின் வறண்டநிலத்தின் மானுடத்தென்றலின் நறுமணத்தை உணர்கிறேன் வாழ்கவளமுடன்