Thank you so much sir Very good channel.. very good explanation 😊 Some of the confusions resolved.. Please explain more like evolution of atmosphere ,earth , other planets, moon , universe etc Also about solar wind Thank you once again😊 Happy to learn
The underlying heat-adjustment effect works like this: --------- "GREENHOUSE EFFECT", TRYING TO WARM IF THE QUANTITY INCREASES - The "greenhouse effect" in Earth's troposphere operates like this: Some of the "LWR" aka "infrared" radiation heading up gets absorbed into cloud above instead of going to space so that's the "heat trapping" effect of a cloud. The top portion of the cloud radiates up some of the LWR radiation that's manufactured inside the cloud but it's less amount than the LWR that was absorbed into the bottom of the cloud because the cloud top is colder than below the cloud and colder things radiate less than warmer things. That is PRECISELY the "greenhouse effect" in Earth's troposphere. It's the "greenhouse effect" of liquid "water" and solid "ice" in that example. You can see that "greenhouse effect" of liquid "water" and solid "ice" for all the various places on Earth from CERES satellite instrument at ruclips.net/video/kE1VBCt8GLc/видео.html at 7:50. It's the pink one labelled "Longwave....26.2 w / m**2" so cloud globally has a "greenhouse effect" of 26.2 w / m**2. - Solids in the troposphere have the exact same effect as the "cloud greenhouse effect" above for the exact same reason. - Infrared-active gases in the troposphere (H2O gas, CO2, CH4, N2O, O3, CFCs) have the exact same effect as the "cloud greenhouse effect" above for the exact same reason. Non infrared-active gases in the troposphere (N2, O2, Ar) have no "greenhouse effect". The "greenhouse effect" really is that simple, and it's utterly 100% certain. --------- SUNSHINE REFLECTION EFFECT, TRYING TO COOL IF THE QUANTITY INCREASES - Clouds (liquid "water" and solid "ice") also absorb & reflect some sunlight and the "reflect" part has an attempt-to-cool effect, which has nothing whatsoever to do with the "greenhouse effect". You can see that "sunlight reflection attempt-to-cool effect" of liquid "water" and solid "ice" for all the various places on Earth from CERES satellite instrument at ruclips.net/video/kE1VBCt8GLc/видео.html at 7:50. It's the blue one labelled "Shortwave....-47.3 w / m**2" so cloud globally has a sunshine reflection effect of 47.3 w / m**2. - Solids in the troposphere also absorb & reflect some sunlight and the "reflect" part has an attempt-to-cool effect, which has nothing whatsoever to do with the "greenhouse effect". - Infrared-active gases in the troposphere (H2O gas, CO2, CH4, N2O, O3, CFCs) do not absorb or reflect any sunlight (minor note: except a tiny portion in the high-frequency ultraviolet where O2 & O3 has absorbed most of it already in the stratosphere above the troposphere). --------- NET EFFECT OF THE 2 ENTIRELY-DIFFERENT EFFECTS DESCRIBED ABOVE - The net result of the 2 entirely-different "cloud" effects is that clouds have a net cooling effect of 21.1 w / m**2 as seen in the blue-hues pictorial at left on screen at either of my 2 GooglesTubes links above. - The net result for solids in the troposphere is a net cooling effect because the change in this effect by humans is the "global dimming" atmospheric aerosols air pollution effect and that's a cooling effect (separate from its cloud change effect). - The net result for infrared-active gases in the troposphere (H2O gas, CO2, CH4, N2O, O3, CFCs) is a warming effect because their 2nd effect above is negligible, essentially zero.
Good, but failes to explain that UV/Light convert into IRs, when bounced off light surfaces, or are absorbed by dark ones, unless they are Photosynthesising surfaces (like leaves) or Solar Photovoltaics. This is an important explanation to include
Good Channel Good video and good content thank you for this wide wealth of information and also this was very helpful to me because I have a test as well about greenhouse gases and properties of it how it works and the climate change and different things about that but thank you.
The explanation at 8:20 to 8:45 is essentially incorrect. When the vibrating molecule hits another molecule it kicks the molecules faster (heats them) and the vibration is gone so no photon is emitted to surface or anywhere. However, those molecules are hitting other molecules 1,700,000,000 times / second and that impact sometimes vibrates it and it sometimes emits a photon then and sometimes downwards, so that sends energy to surface sometimes. Obviously, the faster the air molecules go (i.e. the warmer) the more collisions so the more photons are made by GHGs. So really it's the full energy from surface of radiation (80%), evaporation latent heat (17%) & warm air parcels rising (3.4%) that warms the atmosphere (plus Sun absorbed in air-clouds-dust adds ~16% to that 103%) and then the atmosphere radiates back to surface depending on the temperature all that energy got it to. Increase a "greenhouse gas (GHG)" and the immediate result is that a little bit more gets radiated back to surface and a little bit less gets radiated to space (so overall the same amount is being radiated out until its temperature rises).
In this video, I try to put the greenhouse effect into perspective, please add this to your learning from this video: ruclips.net/video/kMqnHypf5gI/видео.html
If quartz glass is used which lets longwave radiation pass through, instead of ordinary glass experiments show the temperature of the greenhouse is the same. Your video contradicts this experimental outcome. Please explain.
Exactly. This explaination is wrong. Just like the simplified "how does airplanes fly" using Brnoullis equation and distance of travel. This bugs me because it messes up the way this is comunicated. Greenhouses overwhelmingly work by limiting convection.😄
@@erikkaareson6493 "Science is so simple" (but only for simpletons) How did we ever allow politicians to control the education of our most precious resource - our children? That's the real mystery that needs to be explained.
Thanks for trying to explain the greenhouse effect but some of your information is incorrect and much of it is incomplete to the point where you have really not explained the mechanism of the greenhouse effect. In particular your 1:1 correspondence of how a greenhouse works and how the greenhouse effect works is entirely wrong. The analogy is a stretch, the earth does not warm the way a greenhouse does. There are some superficial similarities, that is all. It ain't hard, you ought to do some reading before making a video like this.
You have raised a good point. The Earth’s atmosphere is not a greenhouse whichever way you look at it. The best that popular literature can do is to use the words greenhouse “effect” so that it appears that the so-called greenhouse gases making up about 1% of air are to blame for anything to do with global warming and climate change. Those much maligned gases are purely acting as a thermostat allowing life to exist as we know it.
Joel Weiner Yep, there's actually 1 heat-related aspect of a greenhouse that's EXACTLY the same as the "Greenhouse Effect" for Earth and 2 heat-related aspects of a greenhouse that have no similarity at all to the "Greenhouse Effect" for Earth (gravity causes them). A greenhouse's enclosure (glass & structure) at a cold time is colder on its outer surface than its inner surface so the outer surface is radiating less away than the inner surface is radiating back inside and that's the same as Earth's troposphere which gets cooler with altitude just like the glass pane gets cooler moving through it from inside to outside. That's what causes Earth's "Greenhouse Effect". A greenhouse enclosure also stops its air mixing with outside and limits the conduction. For Earth the mixing with outside is stopped by gravity and conduction is stopped by there's practically no matter in space to conduct it to (plus gravity is preventing Earth's air from spreading through the solar system and conducting heat).
@Joel Weiner Colder parcels of matter radiate less power than warmer ones and Earth's troposphere gets Colder with altitude so the higher up it is raised the average quasi-surface of molecules that radiate from Earth to space the less gets radiated to space, because it's radiating to space from a colder parcel. The mechanism (I correctly described it) is shit simple and obvious but working out HOW MUCH CHANGE is made by HOW MANY MORE OR FEWER MOLECULES oh boy that's an entirely different story and that's why the U.S. Air Force Kirtland Base engaged a team of physicists from Spectral Services Inc. in 1987 and didn't engage me to produce their MODTRAN, LOTRAN, HITRAN algorithm & code and code that the U.S. Air Force has patented and made available under license for a fee.
1. get warmer /more co2 = more green areas = nature etc. = happy. 2. sea surface is too big = never rises some meters. 3. cities, etc. are, not build at sea level and direct at sea. 4. area over cities, is x times, bigger and higher = cool down all and any -heat, and every night. -- 5. tv, etc. -news, politics, ngo-s, foundations, many youtubes, etc., could also say more co2 is good, and 6. co2 -part, in air, worldwide = only 0.03 % . 7. most people worldwide not think, co2 = dangerous. so, work together is better. :) -- 6.2 green house / roof made of co2 = bigger holes than a swiss-cheese, whole day-heat can always pass it. many, statements and texts, of 1000s of climate experts, are not and never a proof, of climate danger is true. -- 6.3 ice, on mountains and at north pole, = many degree celcius under 0, when ice "starts" to melt. 1-2 degree is it warmer ( maybe ). = think for yourself instead of to trust tv, etc. . not worry about ice bears. 6.4 ipcc / i.-g. panel on climate change = pro politics /take money, for or for what not ? some public votes per year, are commonly used ? -- -- 8. truth = more and bigger, cities, is not bad, for humans, animals, and for nature with climate. 8.2 even 7-8 billions have space in world, is a government number / statistic, can believe it ? so 8.3 resources are not going out ? never disappear anyway. -- 9.. same with corona virus is dangerous, most not think so, because of, no science-proof, pcr and antiBody -tests, never proof, any virus is dangerous. -- 9.2 high number, 100 + millions infected ( with? ), for ? almost all, who are tested, are not sick, now, before and later. and who is sick, has 1 or more, diseases.takes months + to make one sick. -- 9.3 most old people, not want, other restrict its life. but tv, "act" as religions = keep to repeat, to restrict life. blackmail people by, get vaccinated or have a lockdown = hate happiness ? if yes why ? evil rules ? no, or ? -- 10. national - assembly . net . germany : ddb news . org ( in, deutschland treff ). use, article 1, civil rights, ohchr, self determination right = you .. millions humans, stand over politicians, what they agreed to, always and world-wide ) = can establish a new system, with "all science-truths" are used, and fairness for all. most not voted for, the whole current government. who makes laws /bans, take you in prison, etc. . -- 10.2 is over, for those few, who decideD. is fully over when fear is away, in some millions per country. :) all called names, are pointless now ( crazy, right-wing, extremist, etc. ) we are more, stronger because have love, what always wins againt fake news and datas. have a good day.
I think I have explored this channel very late, but the one who comes late, comes fantastically...
Learned a lot how to explain full of information. Gratitude.
It's incorrect though.
Thank you so much sir
Very good channel.. very good explanation 😊
Some of the confusions resolved..
Please explain more like evolution of atmosphere ,earth , other planets, moon , universe etc
Also about solar wind
Thank you once again😊
Happy to learn
Best ever explanation I have ever Heard on Green House.. ❤️❤️
Wow, thank you!
It's incorrect. These hundreds of incorrect videos everywhere are very misleading.
Very good. Thank you.
Our pleasure!
I had a project and this helped a lot thx
The underlying heat-adjustment effect works like this:
---------
"GREENHOUSE EFFECT", TRYING TO WARM IF THE QUANTITY INCREASES
- The "greenhouse effect" in Earth's troposphere operates like this: Some of the "LWR" aka "infrared" radiation heading up gets absorbed into cloud above instead of going to space so that's the "heat trapping" effect of a cloud. The top portion of the cloud radiates up some of the LWR radiation that's manufactured inside the cloud but it's less amount than the LWR that was absorbed into the bottom of the cloud because the cloud top is colder than below the cloud and colder things radiate less than warmer things. That is PRECISELY the "greenhouse effect" in Earth's troposphere. It's the "greenhouse effect" of liquid "water" and solid "ice" in that example. You can see that "greenhouse effect" of liquid "water" and solid "ice" for all the various places on Earth from CERES satellite instrument at ruclips.net/video/kE1VBCt8GLc/видео.html at 7:50. It's the pink one labelled "Longwave....26.2 w / m**2" so cloud globally has a "greenhouse effect" of 26.2 w / m**2.
- Solids in the troposphere have the exact same effect as the "cloud greenhouse effect" above for the exact same reason.
- Infrared-active gases in the troposphere (H2O gas, CO2, CH4, N2O, O3, CFCs) have the exact same effect as the "cloud greenhouse effect" above for the exact same reason. Non infrared-active gases in the troposphere (N2, O2, Ar) have no "greenhouse effect". The "greenhouse effect" really is that simple, and it's utterly 100% certain.
---------
SUNSHINE REFLECTION EFFECT, TRYING TO COOL IF THE QUANTITY INCREASES
- Clouds (liquid "water" and solid "ice") also absorb & reflect some sunlight and the "reflect" part has an attempt-to-cool effect, which has nothing whatsoever to do with the "greenhouse effect". You can see that "sunlight reflection attempt-to-cool effect" of liquid "water" and solid "ice" for all the various places on Earth from CERES satellite instrument at ruclips.net/video/kE1VBCt8GLc/видео.html at 7:50. It's the blue one labelled "Shortwave....-47.3 w / m**2" so cloud globally has a sunshine reflection effect of 47.3 w / m**2.
- Solids in the troposphere also absorb & reflect some sunlight and the "reflect" part has an attempt-to-cool effect, which has nothing whatsoever to do with the "greenhouse effect".
- Infrared-active gases in the troposphere (H2O gas, CO2, CH4, N2O, O3, CFCs) do not absorb or reflect any sunlight (minor note: except a tiny portion in the high-frequency ultraviolet where O2 & O3 has absorbed most of it already in the stratosphere above the troposphere).
---------
NET EFFECT OF THE 2 ENTIRELY-DIFFERENT EFFECTS DESCRIBED ABOVE
- The net result of the 2 entirely-different "cloud" effects is that clouds have a net cooling effect of 21.1 w / m**2 as seen in the blue-hues pictorial at left on screen at either of my 2 GooglesTubes links above.
- The net result for solids in the troposphere is a net cooling effect because the change in this effect by humans is the "global dimming" atmospheric aerosols air pollution effect and that's a cooling effect (separate from its cloud change effect).
- The net result for infrared-active gases in the troposphere (H2O gas, CO2, CH4, N2O, O3, CFCs) is a warming effect because their 2nd effect above is negligible, essentially zero.
Very informative!
Good, but failes to explain that UV/Light convert into IRs, when bounced off light surfaces, or are absorbed by dark ones, unless they are Photosynthesising surfaces (like leaves) or Solar Photovoltaics.
This is an important explanation to include
Keep the good work going on 💪👍
Good Channel Good video and good content thank you for this wide wealth of information and also this was very helpful to me because I have a test as well about greenhouse gases and properties of it how it works and the climate change and different things about that but thank you.
Awesome
The explanation at 8:20 to 8:45 is essentially incorrect. When the vibrating molecule hits another molecule it kicks the molecules faster (heats them) and the vibration is gone so no photon is emitted to surface or anywhere. However, those molecules are hitting other molecules 1,700,000,000 times / second and that impact sometimes vibrates it and it sometimes emits a photon then and sometimes downwards, so that sends energy to surface sometimes. Obviously, the faster the air molecules go (i.e. the warmer) the more collisions so the more photons are made by GHGs. So really it's the full energy from surface of radiation (80%), evaporation latent heat (17%) & warm air parcels rising (3.4%) that warms the atmosphere (plus Sun absorbed in air-clouds-dust adds ~16% to that 103%) and then the atmosphere radiates back to surface depending on the temperature all that energy got it to. Increase a "greenhouse gas (GHG)" and the immediate result is that a little bit more gets radiated back to surface and a little bit less gets radiated to space (so overall the same amount is being radiated out until its temperature rises).
Good work sir keep it going on
Thank you, I will
It was good👍
In this video, I try to put the greenhouse effect into perspective, please add this to your learning from this video: ruclips.net/video/kMqnHypf5gI/видео.html
If quartz glass is used which lets longwave radiation pass through, instead of ordinary glass experiments show the temperature of the greenhouse is the same. Your video contradicts this experimental outcome. Please explain.
Exactly. This explaination is wrong.
Just like the simplified "how does airplanes fly" using Brnoullis equation and distance of travel.
This bugs me because it messes up the way this is comunicated.
Greenhouses overwhelmingly work by limiting convection.😄
@@erikkaareson6493 "Science is so simple" (but only for simpletons)
How did we ever allow politicians to control the education of our most precious resource - our children?
That's the real mystery that needs to be explained.
shady moma teaches he preaches one unit ANC family &balanced diet are bounded by hell fragments differentiated into bands where did you get this gel
can you send the ppt link , please
Play at speed 1.5x save alot of time
Detection gases space environment green policy
Thanks for trying to explain the greenhouse effect but some of your information is incorrect and much of it is incomplete to the point where you have really not explained the mechanism of the greenhouse effect. In particular your 1:1 correspondence of how a greenhouse works and how the greenhouse effect works is entirely wrong. The analogy is a stretch, the earth does not warm the way a greenhouse does. There are some superficial similarities, that is all. It ain't hard, you ought to do some reading before making a video like this.
You have raised a good point. The Earth’s atmosphere is not a greenhouse whichever way you look at it. The best that popular literature can do is to use the words greenhouse “effect” so that it appears that the so-called greenhouse gases making up about 1% of air are to blame for anything to do with global warming and climate change. Those much maligned gases are purely acting as a thermostat allowing life to exist as we know it.
@@davidyeates8381 So then what’s causing global warming and climate change?
Joel Weiner Yep, there's actually 1 heat-related aspect of a greenhouse that's EXACTLY the same as the "Greenhouse Effect" for Earth and 2 heat-related aspects of a greenhouse that have no similarity at all to the "Greenhouse Effect" for Earth (gravity causes them). A greenhouse's enclosure (glass & structure) at a cold time is colder on its outer surface than its inner surface so the outer surface is radiating less away than the inner surface is radiating back inside and that's the same as Earth's troposphere which gets cooler with altitude just like the glass pane gets cooler moving through it from inside to outside. That's what causes Earth's "Greenhouse Effect". A greenhouse enclosure also stops its air mixing with outside and limits the conduction. For Earth the mixing with outside is stopped by gravity and conduction is stopped by there's practically no matter in space to conduct it to (plus gravity is preventing Earth's air from spreading through the solar system and conducting heat).
@Joel Weiner Colder parcels of matter radiate less power than warmer ones and Earth's troposphere gets Colder with altitude so the higher up it is raised the average quasi-surface of molecules that radiate from Earth to space the less gets radiated to space, because it's radiating to space from a colder parcel. The mechanism (I correctly described it) is shit simple and obvious but working out HOW MUCH CHANGE is made by HOW MANY MORE OR FEWER MOLECULES oh boy that's an entirely different story and that's why the U.S. Air Force Kirtland Base engaged a team of physicists from Spectral Services Inc. in 1987 and didn't engage me to produce their MODTRAN, LOTRAN, HITRAN algorithm & code and code that the U.S. Air Force has patented and made available under license for a fee.
al mawakeb?
Detected
EXPLICIT
google send them some force sensitive electric material which don't respond in accordance to stimuli whose failure? oohweehaha
This is NOT how an actual greenhouse works!
Neither is it how so-called "greenhouse effect" in Earth's troposphere works. Described incorrectly in video.
1. get warmer /more co2 = more green areas = nature etc.
= happy. 2. sea surface is too big = never rises some meters.
3. cities, etc. are, not build at sea level and direct at sea.
4. area over cities, is x times, bigger and higher = cool down
all and any -heat, and every night.
--
5. tv, etc. -news, politics, ngo-s, foundations,
many youtubes, etc., could also say more co2 is good, and
6. co2 -part, in air, worldwide = only 0.03 % .
7. most people worldwide not think, co2 = dangerous.
so, work together is better. :)
--
6.2 green house / roof made of co2 = bigger holes
than a swiss-cheese, whole day-heat can always pass it.
many, statements and texts, of 1000s of climate experts,
are not and never a proof, of climate danger is true.
--
6.3 ice, on mountains and at north pole, = many
degree celcius under 0, when ice "starts" to melt.
1-2 degree is it warmer ( maybe ). = think for yourself
instead of to trust tv, etc. . not worry about ice bears.
6.4 ipcc / i.-g. panel on climate change =
pro politics /take money, for or for what not ?
some public votes per year, are commonly used ?
--
--
8. truth = more and bigger, cities, is not bad,
for humans, animals, and for nature with climate.
8.2 even 7-8 billions have space in world, is a
government number / statistic, can believe it ? so
8.3 resources are not going out ? never disappear anyway.
--
9.. same with corona virus is dangerous,
most not think so, because of, no science-proof,
pcr and antiBody -tests, never proof, any virus is dangerous.
--
9.2 high number, 100 + millions infected ( with? ), for ?
almost all, who are tested, are not sick, now, before and later.
and who is sick, has 1 or more, diseases.takes months + to make one sick.
--
9.3 most old people, not want, other restrict its life.
but tv, "act" as religions = keep to repeat, to restrict life.
blackmail people by, get vaccinated or have a lockdown =
hate happiness ? if yes why ? evil rules ? no, or ?
--
10. national - assembly . net . germany : ddb news . org
( in, deutschland treff ). use, article 1, civil rights, ohchr,
self determination right = you .. millions humans, stand over
politicians, what they agreed to, always and world-wide )
= can establish a new system,
with "all science-truths" are used, and fairness for all.
most not voted for, the whole current government.
who makes laws /bans, take you in prison, etc. .
--
10.2 is over, for those few, who decideD. is fully over
when fear is away, in some millions per country. :)
all called names, are pointless now ( crazy, right-wing,
extremist, etc. ) we are more, stronger because have love,
what always wins againt fake news and datas. have a good day.
Hsi